Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Notes
1. http://ricerca.repubblica.it/repubblica/archivio/repubblica/2012/02/16/se-la-feroce-religione-
del-denaro-divora.html
2. Cleveland A (1913) Indictments for adultery and incest before 1650. Law Quarterly Review
29: 57.
Reference
Golder B (2011) Foucault’s critical (yet ambivalent) affirmation: Three figures of rights. Social &
Legal Studies 20: 283–312.
DANIEL MCLOUGHLIN (ed), Agamben and Radical Politics. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University
Press, 2016, pp. 280, ISBN 978 1 4744 0263 7, £19.99 (pbk).
economic administration of life in Christian theology and the related ‘argument that
Marx secularised a Christian account of the Being of creatures as divine praxis’. Whyte
points out that Agamben’s argument turns out to be a limitation in the understanding of
contemporary ‘triumph of the economy’ (p. 73), since it misses the specificity of capi-
talist economic relations.
Agamben’s diagnosis of the contemporary economic administration of life is
further scrutinized in Chapter 5, ‘Liturgical Labor: Agamben on the Post-Fordist
Spectacle’, in which Daniel McLoughlin provides a reading of Agamben’s explora-
tion of Monastic Rules, showing how it forms a viable way for the understanding of
the ‘Post-Fordist spectacle’ (p. 92) of contemporary capitalism. The passage to the
post-Fordist era has been marked by the emergence of a renewed ‘immaterial’ form
of labour’, which ‘transforms the capitalist mode of production’ profoundly (p. 103).
The rise of immaterial production envelops the whole life of the subject; ‘living and
producing tend to become indistinguishable’ (p. 104) and every sphere of human life
and of human sociality becomes a ‘productive machine’. According to McLoughlin,
Agamben’s investigation on Monastic rule, offers a paradigmatic figure of the form
of life of post-Fordist capitalism. The life of the monk – according to the monastic
rule – is regulated in every aspect by norms of conduct; it consists in a ‘generalised
self-government’, which determines a ‘practice of manual and spiritual’ (p. 106)
work that covers – as in the case of immaterial labour – in its totality the monastic
life.
Justin Clemens’s Chapter 6, ‘An Alogical Space of Genetic Reintrication: Notes on an
Element of Giorgio Agamben’s Method’, explores the ‘genealogical interlacing of
apparently antithetical concepts’ (p. 117), which form a specific argumentative tech-
niques that Agamben adopted on many occasions. This operation consists in uncovering
the moment of ‘inseparation’ of what is practically and theoretically, separated (religion,
law, politics, economy and ultimately sovereignty and biopolitics), and is invested of a
specific significance. Interestingly, Clemens argues that this intellectual operation of
genealogical reintrication is properly an ‘act of radical politics’ (p. 135). Agamben’s
intellectual strategy explores new viable ways of scrutinizing the obscurity of our time,
providing the theoretical instruments for avoiding the repetition of the failure(s) of past
political actions.
The question of time in Agamben’s approach to political theology is central to
Nicholas Heron’s chapter titled ‘Zoē aiōniōs: Giorgio Agamben and the Critique of
Katechontic Time’. According to the Pauline conception, the Parousia, the end of time,
is delayed by the presence of ‘something’ (the katechon) that prevent the advent of the
Antichrist and the subsequent end of time operated by God himself. The presence of
‘secular politics’ and of the Church as an institution is possible only inside the moment of
this delay, with a particular orientation towards the end of history and the establishment
of the kingdom of God. However, Agamben sustains, ‘the Roman Church has closed its
eschatological window’ (Agamben, 2012), renouncing to its messianic vocation, becom-
ing – along with other temporal powers – a katechontic entity. In the eternal present of a
suspended eschatology, there is no space to think to another (messianic) time. Thus,
Heron claims that Agamben invites us to think an immanent ‘qualitative transformation’
120 Social & Legal Studies 27(1)
of the life we live, marked by ‘inoperativity’ and by the opening of the Sabbath rest in the
present (p. 158).
Chapter 8, Sergei Prozorov’s ‘Agamben, Badiou and Affirmative Biopolitics’, draws
a parallel examination of the congruencies and divergences between the two philoso-
phers. Prozorov advanced the thesis that despite the manifest differences of their thought,
as to style and arguments, there is a strong similarity between them: both are ‘working
through the possibility of an affirmative biopolitics’ (pp. 166–167). Agamben and
Badiou ‘have developed two versions of the same political logic that constitutes a
positive form of life out of the condition proper to the unqualified being’ (p. 184).
The volume, then, turns on Agamben’s crucial idea of form-of-life. This concept
conveys the image of a way of existence that has deposed its ties to the architecture
of sovereign power and the capitalist form of labour and production. A form-of-life is a
life for which the customs and habits – codified legally and socially – have lost their
binding character re-entering the sphere of potentiality. In Chapter 9, “Form-of-Life and
Antagonism: On Homo Sacer and Operaismo,” Jason E. Smith argues that Agamben
articulation of the idea of a form-of-life ‘through the mobilisation and displacement of
three key concepts’ that is general intellect, multitude and antagonism (p. 191) has been
influenced by the lessons of operaismo (a current of thought, which has informed the
action of militant groups between the end of 1960s and 1980s). The idea of a form-of-life
is further scrutinised by Steven DeCaroli’s ‘What is a Form-of-Life? Giorgio Agamben
and the Practice of Poverty’. This chapter locates the question of form-of-life in
Agamben speculation on monasticism rule. Through a close analysis of the Franciscan
highest poverty DeCaroli establishes how Agamben’s form-of-life consists in a form of
life ‘that remains aware of its way of living as a way of living’ (p. 217). A form-of-life is
a life that has gained the consciousness of its intimate contingent linkage to social and
juridical forms and, therefore, has the possibility to act differently with respect to its
actual configuration.
The possibility of thinking life outside the law and sovereign power is central to the
conclusive chapter of this volume, ‘Law and Life beyond Incorporation: Agamben,
Highest Poverty and the Papal Legal Revolution’. Here, Miguel Vatter retraces the lines
of Agamben’s enquiry in the Franciscans’ attempt to abdicate any kind of law and
property, focusing on the critique of ‘corporate personality’ as a political and legal form
of association. The idea of trust as an ‘unincorpo-rated body’ (p. 249), Vatter sustains
should be seen as a ‘dispositive’ offering a ‘materialist and juridical basis for an idea of
association that is alternative to that of the corporation’ (p. 253), designating the possi-
bility of the ‘common’ as a form of association that escapes the sovereign structure of
power.
Within the landscape of the critical literature on Agamben, this book represents a
unique and detailed investigation of his later works. Making sense of the articulation and
the complexity constituting Agamben’s theoretical enterprise is not an easy task. How-
ever, this work succeeds in disentangling, quite clearly, the main theoretical knots of his
account of economy and government. Overall, the efforts enclosed in Agamben and
Radical and Radical Politics, succeed in opening novel diagnostic perspectives to the
current dominion of economic governmental rationality. The dedicated focus of Agam-
ben’s alternative critique of economy is an opportunity to think a politic guided by a
Book Reviews 121
different ethic alien to the logic of sovereign power and the capital. This volume, thus, is
an engaging read for those who are interested in understanding and resisting the archi-
tecture of power that pervades the biopolitical era.
GIAN GIACOMO FUSCO
University of Kent, UK
References
Agamben G (2011) The Kingdom and the Glory for a Theological Genealogy of Economy and
Government. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Agamben G (2012) The Church and the Kingdom. Calcutta: Seagull Books.
Agamben G (2013) The Highest Poverty: Monastic Rules and Form-of-Life. Stanford: Stanford
University Press. Available at: http://ricerca.repubblica.it/repubblica/archivio/repubblica/
2012/02/16/se-la-feroce-religione-del-denaro-divora.html (accessed 13 February 2017).
DEBORAH L. RHODE, Adultery: Infidelity and the Law. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press,
2016, pp. 260, ISBN 978-0-674-65955 -1, £21.95 (hbk).