5/11/2018 The Indian problem - World trade

World trade
The Indian problem

Opposition to a global trade deal risks hurting the very countries India claims it is trying
to protect

Print edition | Leaders Nov 23rd 2013

INDIA, home to a third of the world’s extremely poor people, takes pride in being a
champion of the poor. But words are one thing, deeds another. Right now, India
stands in the way of a deal that members of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) are
hoping to do in less than two weeks’ time—and its stubborn opposition could
deliver a serious blow to the poorest countries in the emerging world.

Negotiators meet on the Indonesian island of Bali in early December in a final

attempt to salvage the Doha round of world-trade talks. Since its start in 2001 Doha
has stumbled from impasse to impasse, then to a collapse in 2008. Revived talks
aimed for a slimmed-down deal. It would focus on “trade facilitation”: efforts to
ease trade through simplified customs rules, which almost everyone can support.

https://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21590478-opposition-global-trade-deal-risks-hurting-very-countries-india-claims-it-trying 1/4
5/11/2018 The Indian problem - World trade

But a fierce disagreement over agriculture is tangling up the talks and threatening a
breakdown in Bali. India is mostly to blame.

Get our daily newsletter

Upgrade your inbox and get our Daily Dispatch and Editor's Picks.

Email address Sign up now

Its objections are not exactly surprising.

Latest stories
Like many other developing economies,
“Cold War” is a faultless romantic epic
PROSPERO
India strengthened “food security” policies
in response to recent swings in food prices,
Why has Argentina called in the IMF?
THE ECONOMIST EXPLAINS stepping up subsidies to meet production
When did Donald Trump make it “crystal clear” goals. Those subsidies may soon grow large
the travel ban was not a Muslim ban?
DEMOCRACY IN AMERICA
enough to violate WTO rules. A club of
developing economies, led by India, is
See more
demanding a rule change. Rich countries
are reluctant to give ground.

Domestic politics is part of the problem. Manmohan Singh, India’s prime minister,
would like a deal. But his government faces a general election in the first half of
next year. The leader of his Congress party, Sonia Gandhi, is sure to resist efforts to
weaken the food-security law. India’s truculence is also rooted in its self-image as a
torch-bearer for the interests of the world’s poor.

In election season, politicians often object to sensible but unpopular reforms. Yet
such short-sightedness can prove costly. And in this case it is India and other
developing countries that will pay the highest price. The trade-facilitation
measures in the Bali package would add an estimated $68 billion a year to global
output, with much of the gain concentrated in poor countries. More important,
failure would destroy the credibility of the WTO, a body which boosts the
developing world’s bargaining power.

The WTO already has the look of a vestigial institution. Richer countries are
pushing forward with ambitious new regional deals—including a Trans-Pacific
Partnership and a Trans-Atlantic Trade and Investment Partnership—that exclude

https://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21590478-opposition-global-trade-deal-risks-hurting-very-countries-india-claims-it-trying 2/4
5/11/2018 The Indian problem - World trade

the biggest emerging markets. Still poorer economies in Africa and Latin America
rely on the WTO to get their voices heard.

Your own special dreams in Bali

India may consent to a temporary expedient: a “peace clause” that would waive
WTO rules for a few years. But that would be a shoddy compromise, yet another
sign that the global forum cannot deliver meaningful agreements. India should
instead bring its law within the trade body’s rules: a hard choice, but one likely to
pay dividends over time. Such a deal in Bali would enable the WTO’s new director-
general, Roberto Azevêdo from Brazil, to blaze an ambitious path for liberalisation.
A post-Bali agenda would almost certainly include a binding schedule for
elimination of rich-country farm subsidies—something the developing world has
long desired.

You’ve seen the news,

now discover the story
Get incisive analysis on the issues that
matter. Whether you read each issue cover to
cover, listen to the audio edition, or scan the
headlines on your phone, time with
The Economist is always well spent.

Enjoy 12 weeks’ access for £12

+ receive a free notebook

https://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21590478-opposition-global-trade-deal-risks-hurting-very-countries-india-claims-it-trying 3/4
5/11/2018 The Indian problem - World trade

https://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21590478-opposition-global-trade-deal-risks-hurting-very-countries-india-claims-it-trying 4/4