Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Lecture Outline:
1. Introduction to Sampling Theory
2. The Regionalized Variable
3. Reserves vs Resources
Samples are what we base our entire analysis on. If our sampling is incorrect, if there is a bias, we
will introduce errors that can have very large economic implications. Remember the average
capital cost of a mine.
Sampling Stages
Each sampling exercise must establish the following: objective, population, data to collect,
precision needed, and measurement method.
Probability: Sample must be equiprobable, where each elements has the sample probability of
being selected
Range of Sampling
A few grams ( say from drill core) to several tonnes (from a bulk sample)
Either very little material or way too much material to work with.
The problem remains the same, how do you make sure that the sample is representative of the
whole
Consider the mineable grades for gold are potentially anything >0.1 oz/ ton, what is the
implication of improper sample preparation
Regionalized Variable:
1. A variable that is distributed in space in a structured manner such that some degree
of spatial correlation exists
2. Samples that are close together, are on average more similar than samples located
far apart
Example of regionalized variables: Grades, vein thickness, fracture density, metal accumulations
(grade X length).
• As the support increases (i.e. bigger sample), the variability of the sample’s grade
decreases. The effect is called smoothing.
Implication of Supports
• Samples of different size cannot be compares with one another without first being
normalized. This normalization process makes all samples of uniform support.
• Drill core samples cannot be directly compared with bulk samples or with chip
samples. Drill core of one sixe cannot be directly compared with that of another size.
They have different support!
Mineral Resources
Inferred resource:
• The part for which geological evidence and limited sampling can be used to
define:
• Quantity
• Grade or quality
• Assumed geologic grade and continuity
• Sampling from:
• Indicated resource:
– Confidence is “high” and allows estimate of:
• Quantity
• Grade/Quality
• Shape
• Physical characteristics
– Estimates then used for:
• Technical analysis
• Economic analysis
• Mine planning
– At this point, drill holes are closely spaced
• Measured resource:
• Quantity, quality, shape, and physical characteristics are well established
• More detailed look at technical and economic parameters
• Data supports production planning
• Project has economic viability
• Sampling and testing confirms BOTH geological and grade continuity
• Variations in estimates will not significantly alter economic viability
COMMERCIAL VALUE
• In mining, the percentage of valuable metal or material in the ore that is recovered first
by the mining method selected and later on by the processing and metallurgical
treatment
• It is a measure of mining or extraction efficiency
What is a Dilution?
• The contamination of ore with barren of low grade rock in mining operations resulting in
a lower grade than when originally sampled in place.
• Internal dilution is planned (a result of the mining method used or geology)
• External dilution is unplanned (a result of poor blasting control or poor ground
stability
Mineable Reserves
• Mineable reserves are very different from the geological or drill-inferred resource.
• In open pit deposits, reserves are set by the stripping ration or the cost of delivering the
ore from the pit
• In underground deposits reserves are affected by the minimum mining width, dilution
and the amount of ore tied up in pillars
Open Pit Mining Essentials: Stripping Ratios, Pit Limits & Cutoff Grade
Lecture outline:
1. Stripping Ratios
2. Pit Limits
3. Cut Off Grades
Stripping Ratios
• The stripping ratio (SR) refers to the amount of waste that must be removed for a given
quantity of ore in open pit mining.
• It is most commonly expressed as:
SR = Waste (tonnes)/ Ore (tonnes)
• A wide variety of other units are used as well. In coal we use:
SR = Overbuden (m3)/ Coal Thickness (tonnes)
Instantaneous Stripping ratio: the stripping ratio for a given push back
Overall stripping ratio: the stripping ratio for the total amount of material removed
Break-even stripping ratio: The instantaneous stripping ratio at the point where the cost of
stripping the waste exactly equals the value of the ore uncovered
Example:
Original Pit
The original pit on this section consists of 6 benches and has a depth of 150’. The area of ore A 0
is:
A0 = A1 = 200 * 100 + 50 * 150 = 27,500 ft2
The area of waste AW is:
AW = 2A2 = 100 * 100 = 10,000 ft2
Bench 7
Bench 8
Bench 9
Summary
• As can be seen by this simple example, with each cut, the same amount of ore (5,000 ft2)
must pay for an increasing amount of waste.
• The overall stripping ratio is less than the instantaneous value.
• There becomes a point where the value of the ore uncovered is just equal to the associated
costs with the slice.
• This would yield the maximum pit on this section. Assume that in this case the breakeven
stripping ratio is 1.625. Then the final pit would stop with the mining of bench 9.
• Through pit deepening, the walls of the pit are moved away or ‘pushed back’ from their
original positions
• The term ‘push-back’ is used to describe the process by which the pit is deepened by one
bench
Pit Limits
• The establishment of pit limits involves the development and superposition of a geometric
surface called a pit onto the mineral inventory
• The mineable material becomes that lying within the pit boundaries
• The size and shape of the pit depends upon economic factors and design/production
constraints.
• With an increase in price, the pit would expand in size assuming all other factors remained
constant. The inverse is obvious!
• The pit at the end of mining is called the ‘final’ or ‘ultimate’ pit.
• In between the birth and death of an open-pit mine there are a series of ‘intermediate’ pits.
• Procedures for generating pit limits are based upon:
• Hand methods,
• Computer methods, and
• Computer assisted hand methods
• Within the pit are found materials of differing value. Economic criteria are applied to
assign destinations for these materials based on their value (i.e. mill, waste dump, leach
dump, stock pile etc.)
• Once the pit limits have been determined and rules established for classifying the in-pit
materials, then the ‘mineable’ ore reserves (tonnage and grade) can be calculated.
Example
Strip 1
Break- Even SR
The breakeven SR that is strictly applied at the wall is:
SR3 = BESR = 1.9 = (Net Revenue)/(Stripping Cost)
Since the net value of 1 unit of ore is _$1.90 and the cost for 1 unit of waste is $1.00, one can
mine 1.9 units of waste to recover 1 unit of ore.
The final pit limit is where the length of waste (LW) is just equal to 1.9 times the length of ore
(LO) as measured along the midline of the mined strip.
True if:
• Cost and revenues both expressed in terms of same units (e.g. volumes)
• Density of ore and waste are the same
3. The Cutoff Grade policy allows a mining company to fine tune their operation with
respect to a given financial objective
4. The Cutoff Grade dial also controls how much ore is available to the mill from a given
bench and how much of a final product to be produced in a given period
5. The overall influence of Cutoff Grade policy on the economics of an operation are
profound
• The cash costs related to mining, processing and refining along with the commodity
price determines the lower limit to cutoff in a given period
• If the financial objective of the company is to maximize undiscounted profits, the cutoff
grade should be lowered all the way down to process breakeven cutoff grade
• Processing every tonne of ore that pays for itself will maximize the undiscounted profits
for the operation
• If the financial objective of the company is to maximize the discounted profits that is Net
Present Value (NPV), the Cutoff Grade in a given period has to be adjusted upwards to
pay for the opportunity cost of mining lower grade ore now while the higher grades are
still available.
• The mining rate, processing rate, the ultimate rate of production for the commodity
being sold, and the production costs determine how far the cutoff grade has to be
adjusted upwards to maximize the NPV
• Defined as the break-even grade that equates cost of processing and refining to the value
of the block in terms of recovered metal and selling price
• Any administrative overhead expense that would stop if mining were stopped must be
included in the cost calculations
• They are established to satisfy the objective of maximizing the undiscounted profits from
a given mining operation.
• They are constant unless the commodity price and costs change during the life of mine,
AND
• They do not consider grade distribution and heterogeneity of the deposit
Grade-Tonnage Curves
Grade-tonnage curves are one of the more useful tools for summarizing mineral inventory
information.
Two curves are involved:
• One is a graph of the tonnage above cutoff grade vs. cutoff grade
• One is the average grade of tonnage above cutoff vs. cutoff grade
A third graph, quantity of metal vs. cutoff grade, can derived from the other two.
Grade and tonnage data are compiled with the following assumptions:
• The deposit is correctly classified (i.e. no mixed deposit types).
• The grade and tonnage represent the complete in situ resource (production + reserves).
• The data represent grade and tonnage from a single deposit or a group of small deposits
designated as a single deposit.
• The number of deposits that define a grade/tonnage curve are a reasonably complete
representation of the resource.
Grade-tonnage Curves
Sources of error:
• Mixed geological environments.
• Poorly known geology.
• Data recording errors.
• Mixed deposit/district data.
• Mixed mining methods.
• Incomplete production and resource estimates.
Lecture Outline
1. Economic Strategy
2. Pit Limit Design
3. Lerchs- Grossman
4. Floating Cone
Economic Strategy
High Complex
Uncertainty is unavoidable
Until recently we didn’t have the tools to crunch the mass of data
Key Elements
Successfully meet reasonable economic target in the short term
Incorporating flexibility to adapt to the changing, unpredictable economic and
physical realities over the LOM
Economic Strategy
• Before the design of a pit can be attempted we need to establish the economic
and engineering parameters
Economic:
• Profit generated during mining
• Net present value of the various mining sequences
• Rate of return on cash flow for the overall project
• Percentage of the mineral reserved recovered
Profit Example
Extraction Sequencing
Two extreme strategic views:
• The maximum rate of return strategy = high-grading
• The maximum economic reserve recovery strategy = subsidizing mining of
uneconomic material using profits from economic portions
Once we have decided on a final pit limit, we need to define an e xtraction sequence
Sequence is dictated by investing in plant and equipment along with the sequence of
revenue generation and will define the cash flow through time from which the Net
Present Value of the project is determined
• Design will vary with regard to slopes, pit economics and scheduling
parameters
• Before the pit is designed engineers must decide what parameter to design for
In establishing pit optimization and design, there are some things need to be
considered such as: Current future Markets (supply and demand) and designing for
Risk (Risk adverse versus risk neutral)
And For an economic design these aspects need to be undertaken: Simple cashflow
analysis, discounted cashflow analysis, projected accrual accounts, options pricing,
Monte Carlo analysis, discrete probability analysis, and counter point.
In general:
Pit optimization is numerical process that determines the size and shape of the
ultimate pit, which will maximize the value of the mine subject to pit slope constraints.
The process of identifying the pit outline (3D) that produces the maximum economic
value given a set of engineering and economic constraints tempered with risk
tolerance
Pit Optimization
The two most popular pit optimizing algorithms are: floating cone and Lerchs
grossman (widely acceptable as the better method)
Value Model
Floating Cone Methods use these 4 design criteria to determine the ultimate pit limit
The value of all ore within the ultimate pit limit must support the removal of of the
waste that is inside that limit
An ore block can only support the removal of the waste blocks that must be removed
in order to release it and cannot be used to offset the costs of blocks beside or below it
• Position an inverted cone, with the required slopes, on each block with a
positive value
• If the total value of all blocks in the cone is positive, “mine” those blocks
Lerchs-Grossman Algorithm
• The theory behind Lerchs Grosman is that each tonne of ore mined should pay
for its own removal
• Based on economic parameters
• Capital cost
• Operating cost
• Metal prices
• Exchange rates
• Optimization generates the optimum pit limit that produces the best cashflow
• The theory behind Lerchs Grosman is that each tonne of ore mined should pay
for its own removal
• Based on economic parameters
• Capital cost
• Operating cost
• Metal prices
• Exchange rates
• Optimization generates the optimum pit limit that produces the best cashflow
Lecture outline:
Orebody Evaluation Process
Modeling Complexity
By and Co-product significance
Interpolation
2. Geological Interpretation
3. Statistics/ Geostastics:
• Classical stats – histogram analysis, distribution types, statistical metrics, scatter lots,
variance analysis, correlograms, outlier analysis
• Geostatistics – variograms
4. Grade Interpolation
• Method to estimate the value (grade of a new point in space based on the existing
information.
• All interpolation techniques have assumptions that may or may not be valid
• Most (not all) interpolation techniques introduce so bias in the calculation
• Because of the strong correlation, one variable can be estimated by the other
• Additionally interesting in this example is the fact that the rejects/pulps of the assays
don’t differ greatly from the actual assays
• In this case Au would be the principal metal and Ag is seen as a function of Au
mineralization
Equivalent grades
• An equivalent grade is one that is a combination of two or more grade variables in an
arbitrary manner to produce a single variable for estimation purposes
• Example: a Au project with accessory Ag
• Equivalent grades are used to simplify the problem by using only one variable to
estimate
• Equivalent grades are nasty! They hide things and really shouldn't’t be used
• Metal prices fluctuate significantly so k may be no longer valid and another estimation
will have to be done.
• More serious is that recoveries are not taken into account for individual metals and can
vary significantly with grade
What is Interpolation?
• Process of creating a surface based on values at isolated sample points.
• Sample points are locations where we collect data on some phenomenon and record the
spatial coordinates
• We use mathematical estimation to “guess at” what the values are “in between” those
points
• Interpolation is used because field data are expensive to collect, and can’t be collected
everywhere
Sample Points
• Also known as “control points.”
• These are points where you or someone else has collected data (attributes) for a spatial
coordinate (point)
• Any number of attributes can be collected at that point
• e.g. lithologies, alteration, structural data
Interpolation Example
Elevation
• Elevation values tend to be highly spatially autocorrelated because elevation at
location (x,y) is generally a function of the surrounding locations
• Except is areas where terrain is very abrupt and precipitous, such as Patagonia,
or Yosemite
• In this case, elevation would not be autocorrelated at local (large) scale,
but still may be autocorrelated at regional (small scale)
Sampling
• Once again it all comes down to sampling…
• What we are sampling and the density of sampling
• The number of samples we want depends on statistical certainty which we want
• Our desired confidence level will determine the number of samples we need
• This is the trade-off between cost and statistical certainty
Scale Dependency
• If we have high sample density, we will capture local variation
• If we have low density of sample points, we will lose sensitivity of local variation and
capture only regional variation
• Let’s look at this in an orebody context…
• Tell me about a porphyry deposit vs. a vein type/
• IDW assumes that unknown value is influenced more by nearby than far away points,
but we can control how rapid that decay is. “Influence diminishes with distance.
Kringing Method
• Semivariograms measure the strength of statistical correlation as a function of distance;
they quantify spatial autocorrelation
• Because Kriging is based on the semivariogram, it is probabilistic, while IDW is
deterministic
• Kriging associates some probability with each prediction, hence it provides not just a
surface, but some measure of the accuracy of that surface
Stereographic Analysis
Planar failure
Wedge failure
Toppling Failure