Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
STEAM SYSTEMS
STRATEGY
ENERGY
EFFICIENCY
EARNINGS
3E STRATEGY
TSI
MI
Y
RG
N
RA
E
E
Neither the European Commission, nor any person acting on behalf of the
commission, nor NOVEM, ETSU, ERI, nor any of the information
sources is responsible for the use of the information contained in this
publication.
3E STRATEGY
HOW TO SAVE
ENERGY AND MONEY
IN STEAM
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The Energy Research Institute would like to acknowledge the following for their contribution
in the production of the guide:
Energy Technology Support Unite (ETSU), UK, for permission to use information
from the ‘’Energy Efficiency Best Parctice’’ series of handbooks.
Energy Conservation Branch, Department of Energy, Mines and Resources, Canada,
for permission to use information from the ‘’Energy Management’’ series of manuals.
TLV Co, Ltd, for permission to use figures from their set of handbooks on steam.
Wilma Walden for graphic design work (walden@grm.co.za).
Doug Geddes of South African Breweries for the cover colour photography.
Guide Book Essentials
QUICK 'CHECK-LIST' FOR SAVING
ENERGY AND MONEY IN STEAM SYSTEMS
This list is a selected summary of energy and cost savings opportunities outlined in the text. Many more
are detailed in the body of the booklet. These are intended to be a quick 'checklist'.
3E STRATEGY
Table of contents
UNITS ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................2
1. INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................................................................................3
1.1 Sensible heat and latent heat ....................................................................................................................................................4
1.1.1 Example of the effects of increasing surface area .........................................................................................6
2. BLOWDOWN ............................................................................................................................................................................................7
2.1 Methods of blowdown ..................................................................................................................................................................7
2.2 How much do you blowdown? ...............................................................................................................................................9
2.3 What does it cost? ...........................................................................................................................................................................9
APPENDIX 1:
STEAM TABLE................................................................................................................................................................................................37
APPENDIX 2:
EFFECTS OF INSULATION THICKNESS ON HEAT LOSS FROM PIPES ...............................................................39
APPENDIX 3:
GLOSSARY ......................................................................................................................................................................................................40
3E STRATEGY
UNITS
TEMPERATURE:
0
The units here are degrees centigrade or Celsius. Written C. At
0 0
atmospheric pressure, water freezes at 0 C and boils at 100 C.
PRESSURE:
The units here are bars. Standard atmospheric pressure is 1.013 bars. One
bar is 100 kilopascal (KPa). Bars absolute are measured from complete
vacuum. Bars gauge (barg) are measured from atmospheric pressure. So 0
bar gauge is the same as 1.013 bar absolute.
ENERGY:
The energy content of steam is called enthalpy. The units here are joules (J)
or more usually kilojoules (KJ). Specific enthalpy refers to energy per unit
mass, and here the units are kilojoules per kilogram (KJ/Kg). One calorie is
4.186 J. One British thermal unit (BTU) is 1055J.
2
1. INTRODUCTION
Steam is used for heating and process work as it is steam traps are blowing steam and that boiler
an ideal carrier of heat. Its three main advantages operators blow down the boiler on the basis of
as a heat transfer medium are as follows: previous practice. Possibly, or even probably,
the equipment using the steam is not giving
It transfers heat at constant tempera-
optimum performance because it contains air, or
ture. This is extremely useful when
is waterlogged due to faulty steam trapping. The
dealing with heat sensitive materials.
production rate then falls.
The temperature of steam is dependent
upon the steam pressure. This results in
In giving up its heat the steam condenses, but still
a simple method of temperature control.
retains some of the energy originally put into it by
It is compact in terms of heat content per
burning fuel in the boiler. This energy can be
unit volume. This means heat can he
recovered and put to good use.
conveyed in simple piping systems.
Often it is not noticed that a 'wisp' of steam is The main area for making savings at the point of
leaking from a joint, that insulation is missing, that generation is by the control of flue gas losses.
3
This is discussed in the booklet "Saving Energy it, sensible and latent heat.
and Money in Boilers and Furnaces". Another
important quantifiable loss is blowdown loss. When heat is added to a kilogram of water, its
With steam utilization, the losses are split temperature rises by 4.19°C for each kJ of heat
between heat losses in the system (leaks, etc) added 1°C for each kilocalorie). This rise in
and heat loss by inefficient use at the place where temperature can be detected by the senses and
it is needed. is called sensibleheat (4l9 kJ/kg of heat is
0 0
required to convert water from 0 C to l00 C).
Finally, there is a discussion on heat recovery
techniques which explores methods of utilising At normal atmospheric pressure any further
0
the heat left in steam once it has given up its latent addition of heat to water at l00 C will not
heat. increase the temperature, but will cause some
of the water to boil into steam. In order to
change all the water into steam, 2.257 kJ/kg (537
1.1 SENSIBLE HEAT AND calorie/kg) of heat would have to be added.
LATENT HEAT The additional heat cannot be felt by the senses
as a rise in temperature and is called the latent
Before getting into the energy saving opportuni- heat of vaporisation. Thus a total of 2,676 kJ/kg
ties, it will be useful to understand how steam is of heat is required to turn water at 0ºC into
raised and the two types of heat associated with steam.
3000
2800 4
2600 Total heat of steam
2400
2200
2000 3
Enthalphy kJ/kg
Figure 1: Properties of steam (figure used with permission from TLV Co Ltd)
4
If water is subjected to pressure greater than Steam which does not increase in temperature
one atmosphere it will not boil at 100ºC (212º when heat is added is known as saturated steam.
F) but at a higher temperature. This tempera- It is a mixture of water and steam. Steam that
ture is related to the steam pressure and, as can does increase in temperature when heat is added
be seen from Figure 1, the lower the steam is known as superheated steam. It is pure steam
pressure the higher the proportion of latent with no water. Wet steam contains water
heat per unit weight of steam. This physical fact droplets. Dry steam does not contain water
has an important bearing on fuel economy. droplets.
It can be seen from Figures 1 and 2 that the higher Superheated steam is used in power stations
the steam pressure, the higher the steam tem- where high steam temperatures give a better
perature. This relationship can be used to thermal efficiency (more kilowatt-hours of
achieve a temperature required by a process, electricity per unit of fuel consumed). Process
critical in some cases, by matching it with the steam, used for heating in factories, woodyards,
correct steam pressure. For greater accuracy, hospitals and so on, is nearly always saturated
these relationships are normally given in the form steam. This booklet deals almost entirely with
of steam tables which are in Appendix 1. So if saturated steam and unless stated otherwise the
pressure is reduced to give greater economy it term "steam" means "saturated steam".
must be ensured that productivity is not upset by
the lower temperature. Many processes employing steam as the heating
Steam
Atmospheric pressure 7 bar
100°C 170°C
170°C
100°C
0°C 0°C
5
medium only make use of latent heat. Therefore, pressure of 2.4 bar simply by increasing the
it is necessary to optimise the availability of latent heating surface by 25%. If for instance a room
heat and the driving force, by good steam contains four lengths of heating pipe then the
pressure control. Additionally, the heat in the total heating surface will be increased by 25% if
condensate rises with steam pressure, and so the an extra length of pipe is added. By doing this, a
higher the steam pressure used for a process the saving of 4% is made. Further reduction in
greater the need to recover heat from the pressure to 0.34 bar and an increase in the
condensate in order to maintain high levels of heating surface of 75% would result in a saving of
efficiency. 7%.
It is shown in Figure 1 that the latent heat of This principle should be borne in mind when
steam decreases as the pressure rises. This designing heating systems, such as fitting heating
means that the higher the steam pressure, the coils in hot water tanks and installing heat pipes
smaller the amount of latent heat (usable heat) for air heating.
which will be available per kilogram of steam.
Therefore, at higher pressures more kilograms of There are two points to be considered:
steam are needed to supply a given quantity of
latent heat. As the boiler operating pressure is
reduced the specific volume of steam
Thus, from the point of view of steam economy, increases rapidly as the operating
the lower the steam pressure, the lower the pressure falls below 7 bar. The rapid rise
steam consumption for a given amount of heat. in the specific volume of steam promotes
It is also true, however. that the lower the steam carry-over of liquid water, which is not a
pressure, the lower the temperature and good heat conductor.
therefore the lower the rate of heat flow from a It is not possible to increase the heating
given surface area. This difficulty can sometimes surface in all kinds of steam plant and
be overcome by increasing the amount of equipment.
heating surface.
6
2. BLOWDOWN
Blowdown is a necessary operation for boiler of energy. Proper control is most important.
plant in order to maintain correct water condi-
tions. The water fed into the boiler contains When this has been achieved the recovery of
dissolved materials and as the water is evapo- heat from the blowdown should be examined to
rated into steam these are left to concentrate in see whether it is economical to do so. On
the boiler either in a dissolved or suspended average about 50% of the heat may be recover-
state. able.
7
traditional method utilised with shell
boilers.
35
30
25
Boiler pressure
20
15
10
0
10 20 30 40 50 70 100 200
8
2.2 HOW MUCH DO may be used for estimating the flowrate
when the valve is open - and from the
YOU BLOWDOWN?
figure obtained, an equivalent continu-
The following provides a simple checklist for ous blowdown flowrate may be calcu-
estimating the quantity of blowdown from a lated. Again, this will be related to the
boiler, if not already known: average generation rate.
1. If the TDS level of the boiler feedwater NOTE: The blowdown flowrate given in Figure 5
(mixture of condensate return and is in kg/second , not kg/hour as is commonly used
make-up) can be obtained, the required for boiler generating rates.
percentage of blowdown may be
calculated.
2. For existing plants, the present 2.3 WHAT DOES
blowdown method may consist of IT COST?
blowing down, say, 1 inch from the gauge
glass at regular intervals. This may be To buy water, treat it, pump it into a boiler, heat it
converted to a volume by estimating the to boiling point and then throw it away may be
water surface area of the boiler (width x necessary to satisfy the requirements of steam
length), and multiplying this by the quality. Unless it is properly controlled, how-
frequency of blowdown, to give an ever, it can be very wasteful of energy and
equivalent continuous blowdown money. It should also be remembered that
flowrate. Remember that this will be constant quality of water should not be taken for
related to the present average steam granted and intermittent blowdow practices may
generation rate. fail to cope with such a difficulty. The costs of
3 Alternatively, the existing blowdown blowdown are seldom obvious, because they are
method may consist of opening the hidden in the overall boilerhouse costs, in water
bottom blowdown valve for a given time and its treatment costs and in fuel costs.
at certain intervals. For the standard full-
bore valve the flowrate is controlled by
the length and bore of the blowdown
line, and the boiler pressure. Figure 5
9
3. STEAM UTILISATION
10
small quantity of high pressure steam is required but the steam lines means selecting a pipe diameter
where large quantities of low pressure steam are which gives the minimum acceptable pressure drop
used, the possibility of separating the two should be between the boiler and the user.
considered. A high pressure steam generator
dedicated to the high pressure steam using For many years designers and engineers used
equipment could be a more energy efficient option. simple ‘rule of thumb’ methods to determine the
pipe sizes for a particular application. These criteria
IN SUMMARY: were evaluated from actual situations and generally
still hold good.
HIGH PRESSURE
Leakage and Flash Steam Losses
To begin the process of determining required pipe
LOW PRESSURE size, it is usual to assume a velocity of flow. For
Large Surface Heat Losses saturated steam from a boiler, 20 - 30 m/s is
accepted general practice for short pipe runs. For
major lengths of distribution pipework, pressure
3.2 PIPE SIZING drop becomes the major consideration and
velocities may be slightly less. With dry steam,
Once the necessary system pressure has been velocities of 40 metres/sec can be contemplated -
determined, the pipes must be correctly sized. If the but remember that many steam meters suffer wear
pipe is too small, insufficient steam at a high enough and tear under such conditions. There is also a risk
pressure will get through to the process. Too large a of noise from pipes. Table 1 lists the mass flow of
pipe simply means that surface heat losses are steam in pipes for common saturated steam
increased or more insulation is required. Either way pressures and a pressure drop of 0.25 bar/100
the overall system efficiency drops. Proper sizing of metres.
11
3.2.1. IN SUMMARY the actual pipeline length for each distinct section of
pipework. At this point. rationalisation of existing
UNDERSIZED PIPES layouts to remove all unnecessary tees and elbows
Higher Pressure Requirement • Higher Leakage Losses should be considered. Long swept bends are
preferable to elbows; valves can be selected for
OVERSIZED PIPES minimum pressure drop.
Higher Surface Losses • Increased Capital Costs
If a 30 metre length of 100 mm pipe contains bends
and valves as shown in Figure 6, this represents an
3.2.2 OTHER PRESSURE LOSSES additional equivalent length of 69.6 metres and
hence a tripling of pressure drop over the straight
length (see Table 3).
When the steam route changes in direction or
the steam flow is disturbed, steam suffers a
drop in pressure. Thus the number of bends
and valves affects the pressure drop along 3.3 PIPE DRAINAGE
a given length of pipe. It is most convenient to
express this pressure drop through various fittings The fact that steam is produced from water which is
in terms of ‘equivalent straight length of pipe’ relatively cheap and plentiful is a definite advantage.
(see Table 2).
Table 2: Resistance of standard pipe fittings measured as equivalent pipe length (metres)
Pipe size Standard Standard Tee (flow Gate valve Globe valve
(mm) elbow (90º) Bend (90º) through branch) (open) (open)
12
The fact that, as steam cools it reverts to water, is General guidelines for the effective draining of
not. Condensate in a steam line is at least a nuisance condensate and layout of steam lines are given
but can be potentially disastrous. At the very least below.
condensate lying in the bottom of a pipe effectively
reduces that pipe’s cross-sectional area so requiring The steam mains should be laid with a
increased velocities and causing a higher pressure falling slope in the direction of steam flow
drop. In the worst case, the condensate layer of not less than 125 mm for every 30
becomes deep enough to be picked up by the metres of pipe length. This ensures that the
steam and forced as a bullet or plug down the pipe. condensate always flows to where the
These high velocity slugs have difficulty passing next drain point is sited.
round bends and through fittings. In extreme cases Drain points should be provided at
this water hammer can lead to sudden failure of the intervals of 30-45 metres along the steam
pipe or of fittings such as valves. main. The actual distances will vary,
depending on how often a branch pipe
If the condensate is carried forward into occurs and how often there is a change in
the process machines there is again the possibility of the level or direction of the steam main. In
damage. Wet steam builds up a thick film on heat a straight run of pipe carrying dry steam,
transfer surfaces reducing the effectiveness of the drain points and steam traps should be 45
process machines. It also leads to excessive metres apart. Installing them at more
erosion and wear on the pipework and frequent intervals may seem to be making
fittings of the machine, increasing maintenance the system safer but the penalty is the
costs. The excess condensate has to be removed increased possibility of failure and steam
by the existing steam traps, possibly overloading venting. If the steam produced by a boiler
them and leading to early failure. plant is very wet the drain points and trap
sets must be at more frequent intervals.
Good steam pipework layout ensures that there is Condensate will always collect where
provision for removing condensate from the there is a low point in the system, so a drain
distribution system before it can cause a problem. point is required at each of these. At any
For this provision to be effective the pipes must be bend there is an increased likelihood of
installed so that the condensate flows towards entrained condensate droplets being
these drain points. deposited on the walls of the pipe, this is
Table 3: Calculation of equivalent pipe length for example pipe run shown in Figure 6
13
especially true where a steam main rises. A
drain point is therefore required.
A sump should be provided at a drain point
in the main steam lines. The simplest
method is to use an equal ‘T’ connection,
the bottom limb forming the sump - (see
Figure 7). Figure 7a: Incorrect drainage of steam main
The choice of steam trap is important for (source: ETSU)
14
3.3.1 IN SUMMARY product. Often it is possible (and it always pays) to
clean the surface regularly. Two further films, air and
POOR DRAlNAGE Ù Water Hammer Ù water, have to be removed as rapidly and
Increased Maintenance Ù Poor Heat Transfer Ù completely as possible otherwise heat transfer and
Energy Waste process output efficiencies are reduced.
o o
121 C (250 F)
Metal heating surface
film
Water film
Condensate
99oC (210oF)
15
opportunity to mix with the steam. In the majority The practical effect of air and water films on process
of process plants where the cross-section of the output is shown in Figure 13. Steam at
steam space is relatively small, the general approximately 1 bar (15 psi) pressure is being used
behaviour of the steam when it initially passes into a to provide a process temperature of 99ºC. By
system is to push pockets of air ahead of itself, so reducing the thickness of both of these films it is
that the air is collected at some point remote from possible to either decrease the steam pressure for
the steam inlet to the system. the same process temperature, or increase the
process temperature for the same steam pressure.
Figure 14 shows this behaviour, where once the
steam is turned on it pushes and compresses the air As a result the system cannot warm up quickly and
into a remote place where it will form a cold spot uniformly, and in many cases the cold shot can
within the system. The water film is between 60 and cause distortion. The air will not necessarily remain
70 times more resistant to heat transfer than iron or at this spot - the flow of steam into the system may
steel, and 500 to 600 times more resistant than be turbulent and will agitate some of the air which
copper. has collected at the remote point.
The effect of the air film is even more drastic and is, An air / steam mixture is therefore created which is
in fact, more than 1 500 times more resistant to undesirable, since it lowers the effective
heat transfer than iron or steel, and no less than 13 temperature of the steam. In addition, the steam
000 times more resistant than copper. A film of air component of this mixture will give up its latent
of 0.025mm (1/1000 in) thickness has a resistance heat through the wall of the system heating surface.
to heat transfer equivalent to a wall of copper 330 As it condenses it will liberate the air component of
mm (13 in) thick. the mixture, depositing it to add to the existing
resistant films already in place.
16
possible to lay down any hard and fast rules about
where to position air vents. The final position must
be decided for each particular item of plant, based
on some knowledge of the shape of the steam
space and the position of the steam inlet relative to
the condensate outlet. Indeed, the choice of trap
type and its ability to handle air may also be
involved. Two examples are given which
demonstrate the need for careful consideration of
this matter.
Figure 11: Balanced pressure air vent
(source: ETSU) Figure 12 shows two pieces of plant, identical in
shape and size. In both plants condensate is drained
from the bottom. In plant A the steam inlet is also at
steam space will be fully occupied with steam,
the bottom, so when the steam is turned on it will
reducing the time taken for the system to warm up
push the air ahead of it to the remote point which is
to production temperature.
at the top of the steam space. The best position for
the air vent is, therefore, at the top of the steam
Since the air and steam are at different
space so that the steam trap would be required to
temperatures, a simple thermostatic air vent can be
pass little, if any, air. In plant B, however, the steam
used. It is advantageous, whenever possible, to use
will push the air downwards. Here provision must
a thermostatic air vent which combines high
be made for getting rid of the air, either by fitting an
capacity with the ability to stay open until steam
air vent or, more usually, by fitting a steam trap
temperature is almost reached, regardless of steam
which has high air venting capacity, such as a float
pressure variations. This is a characteristic of air
and thermostatic type.
vents which operate on the balanced pressure
principle. A typical example is shown in Figure 11.
Air vents with balanced pressure elements have
another advantage. An air/steam mixture has a
lower temperature than steam alone at the same
pressure, and this difference can be sensed by these
elements: therefore, whilst they will close in the
presence of steam, they will allow an unwanted
air/steam mixture to be discharged.
17
3.5 STEAM TRAPPING non-condensable gases can get into the system
either by being dissolved in the feedwater or as a
result of the breakdown of chemicals in the
feedwater.
3.5.1 THE PURPOSE OF
STEAM TRAPS
3.5.2 CLASSIFICATION OF
The expression ‘steam trap’ has already been used a
STEAM TRAPS
number of times in this Guide. A steam trap is a
device that fulfils three important functions: to
There are many types of steam traps in use today,
remove condensate (water), to remove air and to
not all of which can perform well the functions
retain steam. It removes the condensate formed
previously outlined. Before the principal types of
either within the steam pipework or within the
traps available are examined in detail, it will aid in
process equipment. It must be able to do this at
understanding of their operation if they are
least as quickly as the condensate is formed or the
classified by their main categories.
system will become waterlogged. In the case of the
steam pipework this would lead to water hammer
There are three main categories:
and the risk of damage to pipework and fittings. In
process equipment waterlogging means that the
1. Mechanical.
steam cannot get in to heat up whatever requires
2. Thermostatic.
heating, therefore the process stops or at least
3. Thermodynamic.
slows down significantly.
18
temperature. When the temperature has dropped operation are employed, though each mode is
to a specified value below the steam temperature, working on the same basic principle within its
the thermostatic trap will open to release the category.
condensate.
19
3.5.3 SUMMARY OF STEAM TRAP
CHARACTERISTICS
20
TYPE ADVANTAGES DISADVANTAGES APPLICATIONS
Inverted Bucket Reasonably rugged Vents air slowly. For draining steam
construction. Can be damaged by mains.
Withstands a fair freezing. Small items of
degree of water Will lose the water process plant
hammer. seal and blow steam operating under fairly
if there is a rapid steady conditions.
drop in pressure.
Wastes steam on
light loads.
Is not recommended
for use on superheat.
Thermodynamic Simple Cannot be used on Draining all classes
Compact rugged very low inlet of steam mains,
construction. pressures. especially where
Withstands water Cannot operate on high pressure or
hammer, freezing back pressures superheat exists.
and superheat. greater than 80% of Small items of
Some have special inlet pressure. process plant where
bimetal vent to vent Unless air vent is vibration or
air on start-up. fitted, it will air bind. movement exists.
High capacities per Without air-jacket the Steam tracing.
size of trap. trap will cycle rapidly
Operates over wide in adverse ambient
pressure range conditions e.g. rain
without a change of or snow.
orifice.
Unaffected by
vibration.
21
up to 100 mm (4”) pipe size and a dirt pocket left in an economic measure, does not turn out to be a
the bottom of the pipe. Never take the connection major disadvantage for the efficiency of the process.
to the trap from the bottom of the pocket, but Just such a case occurs when attempts are made to
always partly up the side. (Drain points for mains group several items of steam plant to one steam
larger than 100 mm (4”) should normally be not less trap. Take for example the steam heater illustrated
than 2 to 3 pipe sizes smaller, with the minimum in Figure 13. This is made up of a number of
being 100 mm (4”). Figure 14 shows a correct drain sections.
point.
The Heater Battery A receives the cold air first and
accounts for approximately 60% of the total heat
3.5.5 GROUP TRAPPING output of the air heater. The rate of condensation
within Section A is therefore very great. However,
Naturally no one wants to spend more money than by the time the air reaches Section C it is very warm
necessary when installing steam equipment, but and there is little steam condensed. Steam
care must also be taken that what is perceived to be therefore enters the outlet pipework of Section C
and reaches the trap, causing it to close. It has, in
simple terms, short circuited Section A and B.
CORRECT
Figure 14: Correct drain point. Venuss Figure 15: Group trapping
(figure used with permission from TLV Co Ltd) (figure used with permission from TLV Co Ltd)
22
3.5.6 CHECKING THE problem, it will not distinguish the particular
PERFORMANCE OF defective trap.
STEAM TRAPS
23
The trap will then discharge open-ended and Condensate and flash steam immediately
performance can be assessed as described above. downstream of the trap orifice can sound the same
as condensate and live steam at the orifice. Both
The drawback with this solution is that the trap is sounds are affected by mass flow and pressure.
relieved of back pressure. This will alter the
effective setting of bi-metallic traps, and if high A defective trap under light load conditions gives a
enough, will render impulse or thermodynamic lower signal than a correctly functioning trap under
traps inoperative. The test is therefore not full load conditions. However, a ‘scan’ across the
entirely conclusive and the results must be base of a trap can produce an astonishing spread of
considered accordingly. different signals. Other problems arise due to
interference from the sound of adjacent traps
Sight glasses transmitted through the pipework. Ultrasonic leak
detectors can be effective with some traps,
An alternative is to observe the discharge through a although they may need careful tuning to match, or
sight glass - a window fitted on the downstream suit, trap conditions.
side of a trap. This method is generally effective in
the case of traps having a blast discharge since the Electrical conductivity
on/off characteristic is clear.
A recent device, which utilises the electrical
Temperature measurement conductivity of condensate, involves fitting a sensor
chamber containing an inverted weir on the
Although temperature-sensitive crayons and the upstream side of the steam trap.
latest pyrometers have been used, these methods
are of limited use. However, they will detect a trap When the steam trap is working normally,
causing serious waterlogging. condensate flows under the inverted weir which
has a small hole at the top to equalise the pressure
The temperature of the condensate and flash on each side. The presence of condensate is
steam on the downstream side of a correctly detected by a sensor on the upstream side. The
working trap is normally around 100ºC. However, completeness of the electrical circuit is checked by
since the temperature is controlled by the line plugging a lead from the sensor into a portable
pressure, the condensate and live steam on the indicator; a visual signal (green or red) indicates
downstream side of a defective trap will have whether the trap is working correctly or not. If the
the same temperature. In this situation, trap fails in the open position, then a relatively large
temperature measurement gives no guide to trap volume of steam will flow towards the trap. This
performance. depresses the water level on the upstream side of
the weir and exposes the sensor. The electrical
Noise circuit is broken and the portable indicator signals
that the trap has failed.
While thermodynamic traps have a distinctive and
regular ‘click’, which can be detected by an This method has the advantage that a positive signal
untrained ear, many traps have no distinctive signal. is provided, which can be interpreted without the
24
need for experience or personal judgement. Use of include the renewal of any suspect parts. This
suitable wiring allows the test point to be installed avoids spending time and materials cleaning and
remotely from the sensor chamber. This can be reinstating partially-fatigued parts, such as bellows,
useful in the case of the traps located at high level or only to produce a trap that will require checking and
in ducts which would otherwise be inaccessible. be prone to fatigue.
Various versions of this equipment are also able to
identify traps that have gone cold due to a faulty Generally it is only the internal moving parts which
trap, a blocked strainer or a closed valve upstream. will wear, as the body of the trap usually lasts as long
as the plant to which it is fitted. It is therefore
Indirect method advantageous to be able to renew the internals of a
steam trap from time to time. The value of this
Steam metering provides a ‘standard’ figure when measure depends greatly on the ease with which
everything is operating correctly. A significant rise in new parts can be fitted and the reliability of the
steam consumption therefore indicates that the refurbished trap. The elements of most
traps are beginning to pass steam. However, steam thermostatic traps can generally be changed by
metering usually applies to a relatively large removing a screwed-in seat.
machine or area, making it difficult to determine
which particular traps are giving trouble. Replacement is simple and the remade trap reliable.
Nevertheless, it is a useful prompt that individual However, if the joint between the trap body and
traps should be checked. the seat (the weakest point) has been allowed to
blow steam, remaking will be impossible.
25
3.6 STEAM LEAKS main is assumed to be live for 4,500 hours each
year, then the annual cost of steam leakage can be
Steam leaks cause a surprisingly large amount of calculated.
energy to be wasted.
Visible steam leaks give employees the impression
that site management does not care about energy
STEAM LEAKS CHECKLIST efficiency. In the same way as leaving lights switched
on steam leaks do not motivate staff to save energy.
• Monitor safety valves and boiler crown
valves for passing steam. Monitoring the
The main difficulty associated with rectifying steam
vent pipes for excess temperature
leaks is operational, as access to cold lines rarely
serves as a quick check.
occurs at convenient times.
• Give high priority to repairing steam
leaks.
• Costs can soon mount up with only a few Techniques involving the pressure injection of fast-
leaking valve glands. setting resins into leaking flanges are available. Valve
• Operate a documented system for selection also plays a part: a bellow design can
reporting and rectifying steam leaks. justifiably be used for critical valves in certain
process areas. This type of valve, which
incorporates a double seal, allows on-line removal
Table 4 shows the approximate annual cost of of the main gland, if necessary, without affecting
losses of 7 barg steam through holes of various operations.
diameters. Because it is difficult to relate a leaking
flange gasket to a hole size, another commonly
referenced measure is the visible plume length of a 3.7 INSULATION
steam leak. Table 4 shows the expected plume
length for each hole diameter, based on 7 barg dry Insulating unlagged sections of pipework and fittings
saturated steam. Ambient conditions, including is one of the simplest and most cost-effective ways
background lighting, all serve to make this a very of increasing the energy efficiency of a heat
approximate measure. Nevertheless, it is a useful distribution system. The payback period is typically
one. If a steam cost of 5c/kg is applied and the steam less than a year.
26
heat loss is 1.5 kW/metre.
INSULATION CHECKLIST
• Check insulation thickness regularly The overall heat loss is 150 kW.
and. as fuel prices increase, calculate
whether extra thickness is justifiable. \ The amount of steam actually supplied from
• Check for waterlogging as this reduces the boiler house = 1 500 + 150 =1 650 kW
insulation values.
Final end-user efficiency = 1.500 x 76% = 69.1%
• Check for loose fitting sections of 1.650
insulation as these allow air to circulate
The revised energy cost = 5 = 7.24 c/kWh
between the insulation and the pipes. 0.691
• Cover hot liquid surfaces with either a lid
or a blanket of plastic balls. Measure the
INSULATED PIPEWORK
surface temperature of all warm
surfaces regularly. As a rough guide, all If the pipe were insulated with 100 mm of mineral
insulated pipes, insulated surfaces, bare fibre, the heat loss would be reduced from 1,500
surfaces of tanks, etc. inside buildings W/metre to 60 W/metre.
should be well below 60°C.
• Insulate steam supply pipes to unit The overall heat loss is 6 kW for 100 metres.
heaters, etc. left uninsulated on the
grounds that the heat loss contributes to \ The amount of steam actually supplied from
space heating. Without insulation, the boiler house = 1 506 kW
overheating can occur in mild weather.
Heat losses at high level can also Final end-user efficiency = 1500 x 76% = 75.7%
accentuate temperature gradients 1506
within a building. The revised energy cost = 8 = 6.61clkWh
0.757
Insulation has reduced pipework heat losses to
3.7.1 COMPARATIVE ENERGY negligible amounts.
COSTS OF UNINSULATED
Improving or installing thermal insulation is one of
AND INSULATED PIPEWORK
the simplest and most cost-effective ways of
In this example, fuel costs are 5c/kWh, which was achieving savings in a heat distribution system.
about average for South Africa in 1998 although it Improvements can generally be made without
can vary widely from region to region, especially interrupting operations.
with coal. The boiler efficiency is taken as 76%.
27
available to enable a durable and effective • ambient temperature:
installation to be made. The following factors • cost of insulation material; and
should be considered when selecting an insulation • required payback period.
material:
For a given return on investment, the lowest
• cost of both insulation material and combined cost of insulation and heat loss is
installation; required. The heat loss graph given in Appendix 2
• resistance to physical damage; shows the heat losses for pipes with a surface
temperature of 1500C and 100 mm (4 inch)
• condensation;
nominal bore with different thicknesses of
• maximum temperature capacity;
insulation.
• fire properties; and The cost of the heat loss over the selected
• ease of maintenance, i.e. removability/ evaluation period, can then be compared with the
replaceability. installation cost of different thicknesses of
insulation. Installation costs should be obtained
With most pipework pre-formed mineral wool from an insulation supplier or contractor. Such
with aluminium cladding performs well. Flanges calculations demonstrate the substantial cost of
should be either boxed in or given flexible covers. leaving pipes completely uninsulated and the
significant savings achieved by only 25 - 50 mm of
Uninsulated pipes in an occupied area should never insulation.
be justified on the grounds that they may contribute
to space heating. Space heating should always be
controlled: a circulation pipe is not controlled 3.7.4 INSULATING VALVES AND
particularly if it is running continuously to serve
FLANGES
process needs from the same circuit. Space heaters
are designed to direct heat to an area through
All the flanges and valves should be included when
radiation or directed convection currents. A hot
calculating heat loss from total lengths of
pipe at high level and next to a wall loses much
more heat through the roof than an possibly be
directed down to floor level.
• cost of fuel/heat:
• annual operating hours: Figure 17: Heat loss through unlagged
• pipework temperature and diameters: flanges (figure used with permission from TLV Co Ltd)
28
uninsulated pipework. In terms of heat loss, a flange content put in by the fuel - around 20%. It is
is equivalent to 0.5 metre of pipe, while a valve may wasteful to throw this away so either an alternative
be equivalent to 1 metre of pipe. Insulating a pipe use for it must be found in another process or it
reduces the heat loss by approximately a factor of must be retained within the steam system.
ten. Thus an uninsulated flange is equivalent to a five Condensate that has not been in direct contact
metre length of insulated pipe and an uninsulated with the process is chemically pure and therefore
valve is equivalent to ten metres of insulated pipe. needs little water treatment apart from pH
Although the pipework distribution system may adjustment. Both water treatment costs and
have excellent insulation on the pipes themselves. blowdown losses can therefore be reduced.
all the flanges and valves may have been be left bare.
Completing the insulation with flange and valve The savings achieved by returning the condensate
covers could halve distribution heat losses. Heat can be calculated as shown below.
loss through unlagged flanges is shown in Figure 15.
Insulation is one of the best ways of preventing leaks Step 1: Estimate the condensate quantity
because it reduces temperature differentials and returned per hour together with
the stresses associated with them. Any leaks will still temperature levels.
become apparent very quickly.
Step 2: Compute the quantity of heat
A modified approach is required for both flange and recovered
valve insulation. While it is generally a simple task to
remove standard mineral fibre insulation with its Q = W x 4.2 x (Th – Ta) kJ/hr
aluminium pop-riveted cladding. It is often time- where W = the quantity of condensate
consuming to refit it properly. The additional flowing/hour (kg/hr)
expense of flexible and tailored valve covers with Th = the temperature of the hot
quick-release fasteners for insulating pipe fittings is condensate (ºC)
worthwhile as they are much more likely to be Ta = the temperature of the make-
replaced. When employing contractors, their up water (ºC)
written terms of reference should include a
requirement to replace insulation after working. Step 3: Quantify the savings
29
to the condensate recovery system than to the expense of buying and maintaining heat recovery
steam system. All too often condensate is not equipment. In those exceptions where the
returned to the boiler house and is discharged to quantities are significant and where there is a use for
drain. Investment in condensate recovery systems process hot water, a simple heat exchanger can be
including pipes, valves, transfer pumping equipment used to avoid wasting the energy involved. It must
and insulation has, on many occasions, been shown be remembered, however, that the heat exchanger
to produce quick returns. will also suffer from fouling by the contaminated
condensate, but regular cleaning should be simpler
to arrange in this situation.
3.8.1.1 EXCEPTIONS
The one rule that must apply, and which overrides
There are some exceptions usually associated with all considerations of energy conservation, is that
large-scale sites where the capital cost of installing wherever there is any doubt as to the purity of the
and operating condensate collection is prohibitive. condensate it must not be returned directly to the
One such exception usually occurs where there is a boiler feedwater.
relatively small load a long way from the boiler
house. Another exception is where the length of
pipe run, even when well insulated, is so long that 3.8.1.2 IN SUMMARY
there would be no useful heat content left in the
condensate at the boiler house. In some cases, THROW CONDENSATE AWAY -
however, it may still be economic to return cold THROW MONEY AWAY
condensate over long distances because of the high
cost of raw water and feedwater treatment.
30
Table 7: Condensate/Flash Steam Capacity in Relation to Pipe Size
The proportion involved is normally small in weight recover it at a lower pressure and to use it
but occupies a relatively large volume, and an elsewhere within the process. The alternative is to
understanding of this form of two-phase flow is install a closed pressurised condensate return
required when determining the correct pipe size. system. Such systems are, however. expensive to
Fortunately, years of practical experience have install because every piece of equipment must be
produced a rule of thumb that all condensate able to withstand the high pressures involved.
pipework should be sized for water flow under Furthermore, many components within such a
start-up conditions. Under these conditions steam system form pressure vessels and so are subject to
condenses rapidly and the consumption will be at insurance inspection.
least twice that of normal operation. Experience
has shown that pipes sized in this way will be In summary:
adequate to carry the mixed flash steam and
condensate under operating conditions. UNDERSIZED PIPES
• Wasted Energy In Pumping
Table 5 gives the maximum capacity of pipes in OVERSIZED PIPES
common practice. This is based on a pressure drop • Higher Surface Heat Losses
of 0.8 mbar per metre run of pipe.
31
It is rarely possible to gravity feed condensate back Steam traps
Condensate Vent
to the boiler feed tank. It is conventional to install
condensate receivers at low level, thereby Float
Electrical circuit
minimising the back pressure on the steam traps,
and then to pump the condensate back to the Condensate return
boiler house. Either electric pumps, as shown in Receiver
Figure 18, or an automatic pumping trap, as shown
in Figure 19, can be used. Whichever is selected, it Pump
must be able to cope with condensate that is near
Figure 18: Electric condensate return pump
its boiling point. All condensate collecting vessels (figure used with permission from TLV Co Ltd)
should be properly vented because they are not Vent pipe
manufactured as pressure vessels and cannot
withstand full steam pressure when a steam trap Condensate return
from steam traps
fails.
Vented
Lifting Condensate receiver
If the differential pressure across the trap is allowed 5.5 bar (80 psi) 0.7 bar (10 psi)
Back pressure
to fall too low it will not operate, especially under
Figure 20: Lifting of condensate
start-up conditions, and this will result in (figure used with permission from TLV Co Ltd)
32
Table 8: Suction Head Required for Various feedwater inlet to the boiler. Table 6 shows the
Feedwater Temperatures minimum height differences required for various
feedwater temperatures.
Temperature (ºC) Suction Head (m)
86 1.5
90 2.1
95 3.5 3.8.3 CONDENSATE INSULATION
100 5.2
It is not uncommon to find that, whereas steam
pipework is insulated, condensate pipework is not.
Although condensate lines are at a lower
waterlogging. Another instance where this quite temperature, the main object of a condensate
often occurs is where thermostatic control of a recovery system is to recover the heat, so all
process vessel such as a jacketed-pan is required. If condensate pipework should be insulated.
this is achieved by throttling the steam supply the
steam pressure falls too low to operate the trap. Table 7 shows the loss from bare pipes. Under
average conditions, insulation will reduce this loss
Feed Pump Problems by about 7%.
Improving the amount of condensate returned to The boiler feed tank into which the condensate is
the boiler house may lead to other problems. The finally delivered should be adequately insulated and
feed tank temperature will now be high and this fitted with either:
may result in problems of cavitation and vapour
locking at the boiler feed pump. To overcome - a lid containing a vent to atmosphere;
these problems the pump must have sufficient net
positive suction head: this, in simple terms, can be - a floating blanket of hollow plastic balls on the
expressed as the height of the feed tank above the surface of the water. These prevent heat loss from
Theoretical heat emission from a single horizontal bare steel pipe free
exposed in ambient air at temperatures between 10ºC and 20ºC.W/m
Temperature Pipe size
difference
ºC 15mm 20mm 25mm 32mm 40mm 50mm 65mm 80mm 100mm
55 59 70 88 110 118 150 180 210 260
60 66 78 98 120 130 170 200 230 290
70 80 95 120 160 160 200 240 280 350
80 96 110 140 170 190 240 290 330 410
90 110 130 160 200 230 270 330 380 480
100 130 150 190 230 260 320 390 450 550
33
Plain lid loss Open top still air (1-1,2m/s 3-4 fps)
Loss 47,500w (162,000 Btu/hr
In general, the standard methods of condensate
3.977w Increased 21/2 times
by a 16 Km/hr recovery make no real use of the heat in the flash
breeze
steam which is available at the steam traps. The
correct way to use the flash steam, and at the same
Bare tank
Lagged Tank 1,8 x 1,8 x 0,9m loss time to get over many of the difficulties of
tank loss with 0,76m of water at 96°C 8,110w
645w ambient temperature 21°C condensate which is too hot to handle, is to fit a flash
vessel either in the common condensate return
system or after the traps on big high pressure steam-
50mm 5 tons of coal 61 tons of coal using units. The flash given off from this can be taken
2,5 tons of fuel oil 34 tons of fuel oil
Lagging
or 125 GL of gas or 1,500 GL of gas to a low pressure system or unit. Figure 24 shows a
Figure 21: Effect of insulation of Condensate Tank simple layout.
(figure used with permission from TLV Co Ltd)
34
Figure 22: kg of flash steam per kg of condensate
(figure used with permission from TLV Co Ltd)
Flash steam
Relief valve
Pressure guage
Condensate and
flash steam
Steam trap
Strainer Condensate
water level, the flash may be condensed and the The flash steam is lead away through C and
temperature of the feed will be raised. This will only the residual condensate from B is led away through
happen, however, if there is a considerable the steam trap D, which should preferably be of the
percentage of cold make-up. float type with continuous discharge. The flash
35
vessel should be fitted with a pressure relief valve to Reducing valve
prevent excess pressure build up should the
demand for low pressure steam drop below the Bay1 Bay2 Bay3 Bay4 Bay5
HP HP HP HP HP
rate of flash formation. Ideally, the flash vessel
should be fitted in a situation where there is a
Flash vessel
continuous demand for all the flash available. LP Condensate return
Maximum heat recovery is best obtained by
keeping the system pipework to a minimum, thus
avoiding unnecessary heat losses. Figure 24: Method of using flash steam
in a heating system
(figure used with permission from TLV Co Ltd)
For this reason a number of small, self contained
recovery units around the plant are generally better flash heat recovery, where the flash steam can be
than one major unit. The flash vessel and all used advantageously in the initial design of the
interconnecting pipework should be insulated. system. If the building to be heated consists of five
bays, then four hays can be served with high
pressure (HP) steam from which flash steam is
3.9.2 EXAMPLES OF FLASH recovered to serve the fifth bay with low pressure
STEAM HEAT RECOVERY (LP) steam, as shown in Figure 24. In this way the
capital cost is kept reasonably low with the
There are good and obvious reasons for advantage of getting the full latent heat out of the
introducing flash recovery into existing plant, but it system.
is much better to incorporate it as part of the
original design.
36
APPENDIX 1: STEAM TABLE
37
Specific Enthalpy Specific
Volume
Pressure Temperature Water Evaporation Steam Steam
(bar) (ºC) (kJ/kg) (kJ/kg) (kJ/kg) (m3/kg)
2.60 140.00 589.2 2144.7 2733.9 0.509
2.80 141.92 597.4 2139.0 2736.4 0.483
3.00 143.75 605.3 2133.4 2738.7 0.461
3.20 145.46 612.9 2128.1 2741.0 0.440
3.40 147.20 620.0 2122.9 2742.9 0.422
3.60 148.84 627.1 2117.8 2744.9 0.405
3.80 150.44 634.0 2112.9 2746.9 0.389
4.00 151.96 640.7 2108.1 2748.8 0.374
4.50 155.55 656.3 2096.7 2753.0 0.342
5.00 158.92 670.9 2086.0 2756.9 0.315
5.50 162.08 684.6 2075.7 2760.3 0.292
6.00 165.04 697.5 2066.0 2763.5 0.272
7.00 170.50 721.4 2047.7 2769.1 0.240
7.50 173.02 732.5 2039.2 2771.7 0.227
8.00 175.43 743.1 2030.9 2774.0 0.215
8.50 177.75 753.3 2022.9 2776.2 0.204
9.00 179.97 763.0 2015.1 2778.1 0.194
9.50 182.10 772.5 2007.5 2780.0 0.185
10.00 184.13 781.6 2000.1 2781.7 0.177
10.50 186.05 790.1 1993.0 2783.3 0.171
11.00 188.02 798.8 1986.0 2784.8 0.163
11.50 189.82 807.1 1979.1 2786.3 0.157
12.00 191.68 915.1 1972.5 2787.6 0.151
12.50 193.43 822.9 1965.4 2788.8 0.148
13.00 195.10 830.4 1959.6 2790.0 0.141
13.50 196.62 837.9 1953.2 2791.1 0.136
14.00 198.35 845.1 1974.1 2792.2 0.132
38
APPENDIX 2: EFFECTS OF INSULATION THICKNESS
ON HEAT LOSS FROM PIPES
The effects of varying insulation thicknesses on the amount of heat lost from different diameter
o
pipes with a surface temperature of 150 C are shown below.
4000
2000
600 800 1000
Heat loss
25
400
100 88 75 63 50 38
200
40 50 60 70 80 90 100
INSULATION THICKNESS (mm)
30
20
10 W/m
500
450
400
350
300
250
200
15
150
125
100
80
65
50
40
32
25
20
10
Heat loss for pipes with a surface temperature of 150oC with varying insulation thicknesses
39
APPENDIX 3: GLOSSARY
Blowdown High pressure water at the steam saturation temperature. Released from a steam
boiler to control sludge and total dissolved solids.
Boiling Point The temperature at which water boils to form steam. This temperature increases as
the pressure is increased.
Cavitation Local boiling at pump inlets caused by pressure reduction. Resulting bubbles reduce
pump efficiency cause noise and damage the pump.
Check Valves Non-return valves inserted into lines to prevent reverse flow.
Condensate The liquid which is formed as steam condenses. Ideally pure water.
CrownValve The valve at the steam outlet of a boiler. (Historically on the top or “crown” of the
boiler).
Demineralisation Removal of inorganic contaminants found in water.
Dryness Fraction A measure of how much water is entrained in the steam. Most boilers can achieve a
Dryness fraction of 0.98 (i.e. 2% entrained water droplets), but typically operate at
0.96 to 0.97.
Flash Steam The steam produced when the pressure of hot condensate is reduced.
Heat Content The enthalpy of a system. Given by H = U + PV where U is the internal energy.
P is the pressure and V is the volume of the system.
Latent Heat Heat that changes the state of a substance with no accompanying temperature rise.
When water is changed into steam, the heat is also known as the Enthalpy of
Evaporation.
Sensible Heat Heat that increases the temperature of the water or steam with no change of state.
SpecificVolume The volume (m3) occupied by 1 kg of steam at a given pressure. This of Steam
volume decreases as the pressure rises.
Steam Separators Devices used to remove entrained water droplets from wet steam.
or Dryers
SteamTraps Mechanical devices used to remove condensate (as it is formed) from pipes or plant.
40
Superheated Steam Steam to which sensible heat has been added to increase its temperature to above its
boiling point.
Thermal Fluids Generally mineral oils with high heat capacities that can be used as alternatives to
steam or hot water for process heating in the range 200 - 4000C.
Thermal-siphon The natural circulation that occurs in a system due to changes in Effect density as the
water is heated on one side of a pipe circuit.
Water Hammer The result of condensate being pushed, by steam pressure, down pipes as solid slugs.
Waterlogging The effect that occurs when the condensate that is formed cannot be removed
quickly enough and the pipe or vessel fills up with water, preventing steam from
entering.
SOURCES OF
41
FURTHER
INFORMATION
“Energy Management News” is a free newsletter issued by the ERI, which contains
information on the latest developments in energy efficiency in Southern Africa and
details of forthcoming energy efficiency events.
42