Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 23

Del Castillo Ponencias

2010
Spouses Bernales v. Heirs of Sambaan 163271 Division
People v. Noque 175319 Division
People v. Estrada 178318 Division
Delos Reyes v. Judge Cruz RTJ-08-2152 Division
PNB v. DKS International 179161 Division
Buada v. Cement Center, Inc 180374 Division
Cacao v. People 180870 Division
Dumaguete Cathedral Credit v. CIR 182722 Division
Soriano v. People, BSP 162336 Division
Vidar v. People 177361 Division
People v. Escoton 183577 Division
Sano Jr. v. COMELEC 182221 En Banc
Spouses Genato v. Viola 169706 Division
Allied Banking v. CIR 175097 Division
Areno v. Skycable PCC 180302 Division
Palali v. Awisan 158385 Division
City of Iloilo v. Judge Contreras-Besana 168967 Division
Dangan-Corral v. COMELEC 190156 En Banc
Doromal v. Biron 181809 En Banc
People v. Suan 184546 Division
Tiger Construction v. Abay 164141 Division
Gubat v. NAPOCOR 167415 Division
CIR v. SM Prime Holdings 183505 Division
Parents-Teachers Association of St. Mathew Christian Academy v. Metrobank 176518 Division
People v. Martinez 158627 Division
LNS International Manpower v. Padua 179792 Division
People v. Villarino 185012 Division
Spouses Certeza v. Philippine Savings Bank 190078 Division
Aliviado v. Procter & Gamble Phils. 160506 Division
CIR v. Far East Bank & Trust Company 173854 Division
Reno Foods v. Nagkakaisang Lakas ng Manggagawa 164016 Division
Titan Construction Corp. v. David 169548 Division
Lhuillier v. British Airways 171092 Division
Diega v. CA 173510 En Banc
Plaza v. Atty. Amamio P-08-2559 Division
People v. Bustamante 172357 Division
People v. Morales 172873 Division
People v. Napalit 181247 Division
De Guzman v. Gonzales III 158104 Division
Ansaldo v. Ramirez 159381 Division
Rovira v. Heirs of Deleste 160825 Division
Quidet v. People 170289 Division
Ang Ladlad v. COMELEC 190582 En Banc
Regional Agrarian Reform v. CA 165155 Division
TFS Inc v. CIR 166829 Division
Seguritan v. People 172896 Division
Basay v. Hacienda Consolacion 175532 Division
People v. Asis 179935 Division
Pantoja v. SCA Hygiene 163554 Division
Atty. Ferrer v. Spouses Diaz 165300 Division
Associated Anglo-American Tobacco Corp v. CA 167237 Division
Go v. Chavez 182341 Division
Vinuya v. Romulo (the plagiarism case) 162230 En Banc
Heirs of Pacres v. Heirs of Ygona 174719 Division
Evangelista v. People 163267 Division
People v. Amper 172708 Division
CIR v. Kudos Metal Corporation 178087 Division
Bustillo v. People 160718 Division
Ferrer v. Carganillo 170956 Division
Delos Reyes v. Ramnani 169135 Division
Masangkay v. People 164443 Division
Southeastern Shipping v. Navarra 167678 Division
People v. Baron 185209 Division
Victorias Milling Co v. CA 168062 Division
Lao v. Special Plans, Inc. 164791 Division
Angeles City v. Angeles City Electric Corporation 166134 Division
Asian Construction and Development v. Cathay Pacific 167942 Division
People v. Berdadero 179710 Division
Urieta v. Spouses Alfaro 164402 Division
Antolin v. Domondon 165036 Division
Adriano v. Tanco 168164 Division
Hebron v. Loyola 168960 Division
Disini v. Sandiganbayan 175730 Division
Rebellion v. People 175700 Division
Municipality of Tiwi v. Betito 171873 Division
Spouses Valenzuela v. Spouses Mano 172611 Division
Spouses Montecalvo v. Heirs of Primero 165168 Division
Lambert Pawnbrokers v. Binamira 170464 Division
Bautista v. Civil Service Commission 185215 En Banc
Mew Puerto Commercial v. Lopez and Gavan 169999 Division
Atty. Montano v. Atty. Verceles 168583 Division
Pasco and Pasco v. Heirs of de Guzman 165554 Division
Adrian Wilson International v. TMX Philippines 162608 Division
Fundialan v. Spouses Andres 166236 Division
Sonic Steel Industries v. CA 165976 Division
UST v. Sanchez 165569 Division
Heirs of Medrano v. de Vera 165770 Division
People v. Beduya 175315 Division
Metropolitan Bank and Trust v. Reynado and Adrandea 164538 Division
Nagkakaisang Lakas ng Manggagawa sa Keihin v. Keihin Philippines Corporation 171115 Division
People v. Alfonso 182094 Division
Salun-at Marquez v. Espejo 168387 Division
CIR v. Smart Communication Inc 179045-46 Division
Bug-atan v. People 175195 Division
People v. Villanueva 181829 Division
Crisostomo v. People 171526 Division
St. Mary's Academy of Dipolog City v. Palacio 164913 Division
Medline Management v. Roslinda 168715 Division
Land Bank of the Philippines v. Livioco 170685 Division
San Miguel Corporation v. Puzon 167567 Division
Shimizu Philippines Contractors v. Callanta 165923 Division
Lamsis v. Semon Dong-E 173021 Division
Spouses Pudadera v. Magallanes 170073 Division
Cebu Metro Pharmacy v. Euro-Med Laboratories 164757 Division
Calibre Traders v. Bayer Philippines 161431 Division
People v. Gonzaga 184952 Division
J.R.A Philippines v. CIR 177127 Division
CIR v. Aichi Forging Company of Asia 184823 Division
People v. Lucero 179044 Division
People v. Pojo 183709 Division
People v. Barcela 179948 Division
Lacosn v. MJ Lacson Development Company 168840 Division
PLDT v. Honrado 189366 Division
Toledo v. Hyden 172139 Division
Equitable PCI Bank v. Dompor 163293 & 163297 Division
People v. Nachor 177779 En Banc
Corpuz v. del Rosario 149261 Division
Palomata v. Colmenares 174251 Division

2011
Belle Corporation v. CIR 181298 Division
Luzon Development Bank v. Enriquez 168646 Division
Silicon Philippines v. CIR 172378 Division
Padre v. Badillo 165423 Division
Real v. Sangu Philippines 168757 Division
Padre v. Badillo, Cabales 165423 Division
Barangay Dasmarinas v. Creative Play Corner School 169942 Division
Islriz Trading v. Capada 168501 Division
Go v. Sunbanun 168240 Division
Lopez v. People 172203 Division
Franco v. People 171328 Division
Exodus International v. Biscocho 166109 Division
Legend International v. Kilusang Manggagawa ng Legenda 169754 Division
Harpoon Marines Services v. Francisco 167751 Division
Central Luzon Drug v. CIR 181371 Division
Heirs of Ochoa v. G&S Transport Corporation 170071 Division
Spouses Edralin v. Philippine Veterans Bank 168523 Division
Asia United Bank v. Goodland Company 191388 Division
Benancillo v. Judge Amila RTJ-08-2149 Division
Samahang Manggagawa sa Charter Chemical v. Charter Chemical 169717 Division
People v. Sandiganbayan and Barcenas 174504 Division
Sanden Aircon v. Rosales 169260 Division
Sea Lion Fishing Corporation v. People 172678 Division
BPI v. Coquia 167518 Division
Social Security Commission and SSS v. Favila 170195 Division
Imelda Pantollano v. Korphil Shipmanagement 169575 Division
Juliajvo-Llave v. Republic 169766 Division
Asian Terminals Inc. v. Malayan Insurance 171406 Division
Jerusalem v. Keppel Monte Bank 169564 Division
Santos v. NSO 171129 Division
People v. Olesco 174861 Division
People v. Relanes 175831 En Banc
Minoza v. Lopez 170914 Division
Airline Pilots Association v. PAL 168382 Division
Aliviado v. Procter & Gamble 160506 Division
Spouses del Rosario v. Gerry Roxas Foundation 170575 Division
Rodriguez v. Salvador 171972 Division
People v. Asetre 175834 Division
Espiritu v. Tankiansee 164153 Division
Alano v. Planter's Development Bank 171628 Division
Umale v. ASB Realty Corporation 181126 Division
Santos v. Litton Mills 170646 Division
HDMF v. Spouses See 170292 Division
University Plans v. Solano 170416 Division
People v. Dumadag 176740 Division
Calubaquib v. Republic 170658 Division
Barroga v. Data Center College 174158 Division
Palada v. Solidbank Corporation 172227 Division
Estate of Maninang v. CA 167284 Division
PNB v. F.F. Cruz and Co., Inc. 173259 Division
Montemayor v. Millora 168251 Division
Mapili v. Philippine Rabbit Bus Lines 172506 Division
Prudential Bank v. CIR 180390 Division
Union Bank v. Juniat 171569 Division
PNB v. Jumamoy 169901 Division
Abellana v. People 174654 Division
Atiko Trans v. Prudential Guarantee 167545 Division
Basbas v. Sayson 172660 Division
Villarin v. People 175289 Division
Catacutan v. People 175991 Division
Aurelio v. People 174980 Division
Rom v. Roxas & Company, Inc. 169331 Division
Swift Foods, Inc. v. Spouses Mateo 170486 Division
Duarte v. Duran 173038 Division
BPI Employees Union Metro Manila v. BPI 178699 Division
Cruz v. Judge Gingoyon 170404 Division
People v. Yanson 179195 Division
People v. Sales 177218 Division
Continental Cement v. Asea Brown 171660 Division
Valenzona v. Fair Shipping Corporation 176884 Division
Ho Wai Pang v. People 176229 Division
GSIS v. Besitan 178901 Division
Col. Dela Merced v. GSIS 167140 Division
People v. Concillado 181204 Division
Spouses Hipolito v. Cinco 174143 Division
Mahinay v. Judge Gako, Jr. 165338 Division
Polsotin v. De Guia Enterprises 172624 Division
Julian v. DBP 174193 Division
Sy v. Fairland Knitcraft Co. 182915 Division
People v. Agacer 177751 Division

2012
Pigcaulan v. Security and Credit Investigation 173648 Division
People v. Mamaruncas 179497 Division
Orix Metro Leasing v. Minors 174089 Division
Manila Electric Company v. Beltran 173774 Division
Oliveros v. Bersamin, San Miguel Corporation 173531 Division
Spouses Guidangen v. Wooden 174445 Division
Julie's Bakeshop v. Arnaiz 173882 Division
Jakosalem v. Barangan 175025 Division
People v. Cabrillas 175980 Division
Baltazar v. Laxa 174489 Division
Pacific Ace Finance v. Yanagisawa 175303 Division
Ison v. Galvez, Jr. 173951 Division
Estores v. Spouses Supangan 175139 Division
People v. Tanchanco 177761 Division
Du v. Jayoma 175042 Division
PNB v. Spouses Chee Cheah 170865 Division
Del Carmen v. Bacoy 173870 Division
Equitable Banking Corporation v. Special Steel Products 175350 Division
Rondina v. People 179059 Division
Dabon vda. De Mendez v. CA 174937 Division
People v. Biglete 182920 Division
Lim v. Mindanao Wines & Liquor Galleria 175851 Division
Judge Dalmacio-Joaquin v. Dela Cruz P-06-2241 En Banc
Rayel v. Philippine Luen Thai Holdings 174893 Division
Heirs of Gayares v. Pacific Asia Overseas 178477 Division
Heirs of Ochoa v. G&S Transport 170071 Division
Rodica v. Atty. Lazaro 9259 Division
Goldloop Properties v. GSIS 171076 Division
Heirs of Isip, Sr. v. Quintos 172008 Division
Fajardo v. Office of the Ombudsman 173268 Division
Lim v. Kou Co Ping 175256 Division
Jarl Construction v. Atencio 175969 Division
People v. Banig 177137 Division
Spouses Fortaleza v. Spouses Lapitan 178288 Division
Fort Bonifacio Development Corporation v. CIR 173425 En Banc
Misamis Oriental II v. Cagalawan 175170 Division
People v. Fundales, Jr. 184606 Division
Solidbank Union v. Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company 153799 Division
People v. Venturina 183097 Division
Perla v. Baring and Perla 172471 Division
Auza, Jr. v. MOL Philippines, Inc 175481 Division
Magtoto v. CA and Dela Cruz 175792 Division
Communities Cagayan, Inc. v. Spouses Nanol 176791 Division
V.C. Ponce Company v. Municipality of Paraque 178431 Division
Ladano v. Neri 178622 Division
People v. Soria 179031 Division
Chung, Jr. v. Mondragon 179754 Division
Mananquil v. Moico 180076 Division
People v. Ending 183827 Division
People v. Robelo 184181 Division
People v. Aneslag 185386 Division
Villondo v. Quijano 173606 Division
Sy v. Autobus Transport Systems, Inc. 176898 Division
Ching v. Bantolo 177086 Division
Marquez v. People 181138 Division

2013
Anderson v. Ho 172590 Division
People v. Agacer 177751 Division
Diona v. Balangue 173559 Division
People v. Espiritu 180919 Division
Aguirre II v. FQB+ 7, Inc. 170770 Division
Orpiano v. Spouses Tomas 178611 Division
The Manila Insurance Company v. Spouses Amurao 179628 Division
Fort Bonifacio Development Corporation v. CIR 173425 En Banc
National Power Corporation v. Spouses Zabala and Baylon 173520 Division
Republic v. AFP Retirement and Separation Benefits System 180463 Division
Republic v. Heirs of Bautista and Malabnan 181218 Division
People v. Cabungan 189355 Division
Spouses Castro v. Palenzuela 184698 Division
Diego v. Diego and Diego 179965 Division
DOH v. Phil Pharmawealth, Inc 182358 Division
Rodica v. Atty. Lazaro 9259 Division
Almuete v. People 179611 En Banc
People v. Fernandez 188841 Division
Robern Development Corporation v. People's Landless Association 173622 Division
The Orchard Golf and Country Club v. Francisco 178125 Division
Tangga-an v. Philippine Transmarine Carriers 180636 Division
Spouses Cacayorin v. Armed Forces and Police Mutual Benefit Association, Inc. 171298 Division
Dalangin v. Perez 178758 Division
Heirs of Gallardo v. Soliman 178952 Division
People v. Nocum 179041 Division
Garcia v. Vda. De Caparas 180843 Division
Boardwalk Business Ventures, Inc. v. Villareal 181182 Division
PO2 Gabriel v. Sheriff Ramos P-06-2256 Division
Moldex Realty v. Saberon 176289 Division
Spouses Tumibay v. Spouses Lopez 171692 Division
Mitsubishi Motors Philippines Salaried Employees Union v. Mitsubishi Motors Philippines Corporation 175773 Division
Orais v. Dr. Almirante 181195 Division
Maslag v. Monzon and Registry of Deeds of Benguet 174908 Division
Tanenggee v. People 179448 Division
Spouses Hing v. Choachuy, Sr. 179736 Division
Coderias v. Estate of Chioco 180476 Division
People v. Collado 185719 Division
People v. Jalbonian 180281 Division
Lim v. DBP 177050 Division
Jose v. Suarez 176111 Division
Spouses Bonrostro v. Spouses Luna 172346 Division
People v. Ramos and Ramos 190340 Division
Heirs of Miranda, Sr. v. Miranda 179638 Division
Zuellig Pharma Corporation v. Sibal 173587 Division
Canedo v. Kampilan Security and Detective Agency, Inc. 179326 Division
Manila Bankers Life Insurance v. Aban 175666 Division
Aguilar v. O'Pallick 182280 Division
Ining (Deceased) v. Vega 174727 Division
Ang v. San Joaquin, Jr. and Fernandez 185549 Division
PNB v. Arcobillas 179648 Division
Spouses Sabitsana, Jr. v. Muertegui 181359 Division
Cabrera v. Francisco 172293 Division
Venzon v. Rural Bank of Buenavista (Agusan del Norte), Inc. 178031 Division
People v. Suansing 189822 Division
Colegio del Santisimo Rosario v. Rojo 170388 Division
Asia Brewery, Inc. v. TPMA 171594 Division
People v. SPO1 Alawig 187731 Division
Spouses Aldover v. CA 167174 Division
Singian, Jr. v. Sandiganbayan (3rd Division) 190511 Division
People v. de Jesus 190622 Division
People v. Cial 191362 Division
Republic v. Saavedra Batuigas 183110 Division
De Leon and De Leon v. BPI 184565 Division
Judge Rodriguez-Manahan v. Atty. Flores 8954 Division
People v. Zulieta aka "Bogarts" 192183 Division
Agadan v. Atty. Kilaan 9385 Division
Digital Telecommunications Philippines v. Cantos 180200 Division
Cabatuan v. Atty. Venida 10043 Division
Spouses Warriner v. Atty. Dublin 5239 Division
People v. Guillen 191756 Division
Hadji Abdul v. Sandiganbayan and People 184496 Division
Manila Memorial Park v. Secretary of DPWH 175356 En Banc
People v. Montevirgen 189840 Division
Felipe v. Atty. Macapagal 4549 Division
Locsin II v. Mekeni Food Corporation 192105 Division
Araullo v. Office of the Ombudsman 194169 Division

2014
Spouses Vilbar v. Opinion 176043 Division
Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company v. Rosales and Yo 183204 Division
Lim v. Equitable PCI Bank 183918 Division
Alpha Ship Management v. Calo 192034 Division
LBP v. Onate 192371 Division
Manlar Rice Mill v. Deyto 191189 Division
Grand Asian Shipping Lines v. Galvez 178184 Division
People v. Crisostomo 196435 Division
People v. Manigo 194612 Division
Garza v. Coca-Cola Bottlers 180972 Division
People v. Gunda 195525 Division
Bignay Ex-IM Philippines v. Union Bank 171590 Division
People v. Salvador 190621 Division
Spouses Afulugencia v. Metropolitan Bank and Trust Co. 185145 Division
Thenamaris Philippines, Inc. v. CA and Mendigorin 191215 Division
PhilTranco Service v. PhilTranco Workers Union 180962 Division
Bucton v. Rural Bank of El Salvador, Inc. 179625 Division
People v. Soria 179031 Division
Balasbas v. Monayao 190524 Division
Demaala v. Sandiganbayan and Ombudsman 173523 Division
One Network Rural Bank v. Baric 193684 Division
Fil-Pride Shipping Company v. Balasta 193047 Division
Spouses Dela Cruz v. Spouses Capco 176055 Division
People v. Bis 191360 Division
Wesleyan University v. Wesleyan University Faculty and Staff Association 181806 Division
Spouses Santos v. Alcazar 183034 Division
People v. Obogne 199740 Division
People v. Aplat and Danglay 191727 Division
Castillo v. Prudential Life Plans 196142 Division
Macedonio v. Ramo 193516 Division
People v. Santiago 196970 Division
Heirs of Bihag v. Heirs of Bathan 181949 Division
People v. San Gaspar 180496 Division
People v. Abaigar 199442 Division
People v. Lalog 196753 Division
People v. Lujeco 198059 Division
Nahas, doing Business under the name and style Personnel Employment and Technical Recruitment Agency v. Olarte 169247 Division
Jacinto v. Gumaru 191906 Division
People v. Solano 199871 Division
Espineli v. People 179535 Division
Alilin v. Petron Corporation 177592 Division
Bumagat v. Arribay 194818 Division
SR Metals, Inc. v. Reyes, in his capacity as Secretary of DENR 179669 Division
Spouses Sombilon v. Atty. Garay and PNB 179914 Division
Libcap Marketing Corporation v. Baquial 192011 Division
Gipa v. Souther Luzon Institute 177425 Division
Amecos Innovations v. Lopez 178055 Division
Jose v. Novida 177374 Division
Spouses Silos v. PNB 181045 Division
Candelaria and Basit v. RTC Branch 42 173861 Division
Pro-Guard Security Services v. Tormil Realty and Development 176341 Division
PLDT v. Ocampo 163999 Division
Ico v. Systems Technology Institute 185100 Division
Aloysius Dait Lumauig v. People 166680 Division
Republic v. Namboku Peak, Inc 169745 Division
Spouses Velasco v. Waterfields Industries 177484 Division
People v. Sumilhig 178115 Division
Silverio, Sr. v. Silverio, Jr. 186589 Division
People v. Bunagan 196786 Division
People v. Zapata 197046 Division
Angeles, doing business under the name and style of Las Marias Grill and Restaurant v. Bucad 196246 Division
Royale Homes Marketing v. Alcantara 195190 Division
Spouses Dela Cruz-Tabino v. Tabino 196219 Division
People v. Go, Dela Rosa, and Necomedes 191015 Division
People v. Marcelo 181541 Division
Heirs of Manguardia v. Heirs of Valles 177616 Division
DAR, represented by Pangandaman v. Galle 171836 Division
NPC v. Samar 197329 Division
Meyr Enterprises v. Cordero 197336 Division
De la Paz v. L&J Development Company 183360 Division
NPC v. Tarcelo and Heirs of Santos 198139 Division
Angeles v. CA, OIC Martin 178733 Division
Spouses Rosete v. Briones 176121 Division
People v. Torres 189850 Division
Subic Bay Legend v. Fernandez 193426 Division
Heirs of Julao v. Spouses De Jesus 176020 Division
Viray v. Atty. Sanicas 7337 Division
Monsanto v. Lim and De Guzman 178911 Division
Robinson's Bank Corporation v. Gaerlan 195283 Division
Interorient Maritime v. Creer III 181921 Division
People v. Baturi 189812 Division
Magsaysay Mitsui OSK Marine, Inc. v. Bengson 198528 Division
Sun Life Canada (Philippines) v. Sandra Kit and the Estate of the Deceased Norberto Tan Kit 183272 Division
Residents of Lower Atab & Techers' Village v. Sta. Monica Industrial 198878 Division
Palileo and De La Cruz v. Planters Development Bank 193650 Division
Daging v. Atty. Davis 9395 Division
People v. Cabrera 190175 Division
Goodyear Philippines, Inc. v. Angus 185449 Division
Cosmos Bottling Corporation v. Commission En Banc of the SEC 199028 Division
Peak Ventures Corporation v. Heirs of Villareal 184618 Division
People v. Sato 190863 Division
People v. Araza y Sagun 190623 Division
People v. Amora y Viscarra 190322 Division
GSIS v. Calumpiano 196102 Division
People v. Brita 191260 Division
Mackay v. Spouses Caswell 183872 Division
BIR v. CA and Spouses Manly 197590 Division
People v. Dela Cruz y Sebastian 193670 Division
People v. Gandawali and Pagalad 193385 Division
People v. Prodenciado 192232 Division
People v. Delfin 190349 Division

2015
People v. Opiana 200797 Division
People v. Dilla y Paular 200333 Division
Spouses Gatuslao v. Yanson 191540 Division
Ofilada v. Spouses Andal 192270 Division
Aguilar v. Siasat 200169 Division
First Optima Realty Corporation v. Securitron Security Services 199648 Division
De Guzman v. Filinvest Development Corporation 191710 Division
People v. Butial 192785 Division
Paje v. Casino 207257 En Banc
People v. Dimacuha, Jr. 191060 Division
People v. Nepomuceno 194999 Division
People v. Colentava 190348 Division
People v. Nielles 200308 Division
People v. Gabuya 195245 Division
People v. Diaz y Roxas 197818 Division
People v. Reyes y Santos 194606 Division
People v. Basilio y Hernandez 195774 Division
People v. Perondo 193855 Division
People v. Bio 195850 Division
Andres v. Atty. Nambi 7158 Division
People v. Cunanan 198024 Division
Republic v. Huang Te Fu 200983 Division
Adolfo v. Adolfo 201427 Division
Tionco y Ortega v. People 192284 Division
FAJ Construction & Development Corporation v. Saulog 200759 Division
Republic v. Spouses Benigno 205492 Division
Banguis-Tambuyat v. Balcom-Tambuyat 202805 Division
Republic v. Daclan 197115 Division
Davao Import Distributors v. Atty. Landero 5116 Division
Roque v. People 193169 Division
Republic v. Pasicolan 198543 Division
People v. Mateo and Lapiz 198012 Division
People v. Villar 202708 Division
Litex Glass and Aluminum Supply v. Sanchez 198465 Division
Heirs of the Late Delfin Dela Cruz v. Philippine Transmarine Carriers, Inc. 196357 Division
Caoile v. Atty. Macaraeg 720 Division
People v. Wahiman 200942 En Banc
CE Casecnan Water and Energy Company v. Province of Nueva Ecija 196278 Division
Spouses Mercado v. LBP 196707 Division
Catipon, Jr. v. Japson 191787 Division
Serrano Mahilum v. Spouses Ilano 197923 Division
Daraga Press, Inc. v. COA and DepEd-ARMM 201042 En Banc
Petron Corporation v. Caberte 182255 Division
Beduya v. Ace Promotion and Marketing Corporation 195513 Division
DOHLE-Philman Manning Agency v. Heirs of Gazzingan 199568 Division
Malabunga, Jr. v. Cathay Pacific Steel Corporation 198515 Division
People v. Britanico and Britanico 201836 Division
Olarte v. People 197731 Division
Republic v. Dayaoen 200773 Division
CIR v. La Tondena Distillers 175188 Division
OCA v. Guan P-07-2293 Division
U-BIX Corporation v. Hollero 199660 Division
Centennial Transmarine v. Quiambao 198096 Division
Chua v. People 196853 Division
Jose Yulo Agricultural Corporation v. Spouses Davis 197709 Division
Romero and Domingo v. Singson 200969 Division
Salabao v. Atty. Villaruel, Jr. 8084 Division
OCA v. Abarentos CA-12-26-P Division
Marina Port Services v. American Home Assurance 201822 Division
Laurel v. Vardeleon 202967 Division
Maravilla v. Rios 196875 Division
Marsman & Company v. Ligo 198643 Division
Philippine Ports Authority v. Coalition of PPA Officers and Employees 203142 Division
Andres, Andres and Francisco v. Sta. Lucia Realty & Development Inc. 201405 Division
SSS v. Ubana 200114 Division
Arnado v. COMELEC 210164 En Banc
Republic v. Principalia Management and Personnel Consultants, Inc. 198426 Division
Movertrade Corporation v. COA and DPWH 204835 En Banc
Philippine Transmarine Carriers v. Aligway 201793 Division
INC Shipmanagement Inc v. Camporedondo 199931 Division
Republic v. Rev. Cortez, Sr. 197472 Division
Grace Marine Shipping Corporation v. Alarcon 201536 Division
ICT Marketing Services v. Sales 202090 Division
Magsaysay Maritime Corporation v. Mazaredo 201359 Division
Maersk-Filipinas v. Jaleco 201945 Division
Carique v. Philippine Scout Veterans Security and Investigation Agency 197484 Division
Saso v. 88 Aces Maritime Service 211638 Division
NEC System Integrated Construction v. Crisologo 201535 Division
Etom, Jr. v. Aroma Lodging House 192955 Division
Pinlac v. People 197458 Division
Mangubat v. Morga-Seva 202611 Division
New Filipino Maritime Agencies v. Datayan 202859 Division
Inutan v. Napar Contracting & Allied Services 195654 Division
United Alloy Philippines v. UCPB 179257 Division
People v. Lagangga 207633 Division
Island Overseas Transport Corporation v. Beja 203115 Division
Heirs of Latayan v. Tan 201652 Division
CIR v. Toledo Power Company 196415 Division
Zing v. Robles 197096 Division
Trinidad II v. Spouses Palad 203397 Division
Vicmar Development Corporation v. Elarcosa 202215 Division

2016
Balanay v. Judge White RTJ-16-2443 Division
Iladan v. La Suerte International Manpower Agency 203882 Division
People v. Ranche 198450 Division
Wallem Maritime Services v. Quillao 202885 Division
Endaya v. Villaos 202426 Division
Mendoza v. Officers of Manila Water Employees Union 201595 Division
Spouses Teano v. Municipality of Navotas 205814 Division
Republic v. Sarenogon, Jr. 199194 Division
Petron LPG Dealers Association v. Ang 199371 Division
Spouses Trayvilla v. Sejas and Paglinawan 204970 Division
Mathaeus v. Spouses Medequiso 196651 Division
People v. de la Cruz y Santos 207389 Division
Tabuk Multi-Purpose Cooperative v. Duclan 203005 Division
Poe v. COMELEC 221697 Separate Opinion (Dissenting)
People v. Constancio and Berry 206226 Division
Heirs of Salud v. Rural Bank of Salinas 202756 Division
Bacolor v. VL Makabali Memorial Hospital 204325 Division
Doehle-Philman Manning Agency v. Haro 206522 Division
The Insular Life Assurance Company v. Khu 195176 Division
Republic v. Heirs of Lim 195611 Division
Nicolas v. People 186107 Division
Commissioner of Customs v. Pilipinas Shell Petroleum 205002 Division
People v. Camposano 207659 Division
Bradford United Church of Christ v. Ando 195669 Division
Malangas v. Atty. Zaide 10675 En Banc
People v. Peralta and Ambas 208524 Division
Macalino v. Pis-an 204056 Division
People v. Britanico and Britanico 201836 Division
People v. Abenes 210878 Division
Valeroso and Legatona v. SkyCable Corporation 202015 Division
Santos v. Integrated Pharmaceutical Inc. 204620 Division
Capili v. PNB 204750 Division
Pamaran v. Bank of Commerce 205753 Division
Guntalilib v. Dela Cruz and Dela Cruz 200042 Division
Union Bank of the Philippines v. Philippine Rabbit Bus Lines 205951 Division
Guagua National Colleges v. Guagau National Colleges Faculty Labor Union 204693 Division
Forest Hills Golf and Country Club v. Fil-Estate Properties, Inc 206649 Division
Pascual v. People 204873 Division
Heirs of Guiambangan v. Municipality of Kalamansig 204899 Division
Petron Gasul LPG Dealers Association v. Lao 205010 Division
Celiz v. Cord Chemicals, Inc 200352 Division
Almeda v. Office of the Ombudsman (Mindanao) 204267 Division
PICOP Resources, Inc v. Social Security Commission 206936 Division
Nicolas v. Mariano 201070 Division
Campos, Jr. v. Atty. Estebal 10443 Division
Sonley v. Anchor Savings Bank 205623 Division
People v. Caga y Fabre 206878 Division
IBM Philippines v. Prime Systems Plus, Inc 203192 Division
People v. Buenamer y Mandane 206227 Division
People v. Bombasi y Vergara 211608 Division
Manigque-Stone v. Cattleya Land, Inc 195975 Division
Philippine Science High School - Cagayan Valley Campus v. Pirra Construction Enterprises 204423 Division
Naga Centrum v. Spouses Orzales 203576 Division
Fabie v. Atty. Real 10574 En Banc
GSIS v. Manalo 208979 Division
Leo's Restaurant and Bar Café v. Bensing 208535 Division
Greenstar Express, Inc. v. Universal Robina Corporation 205090 Division
Spouses Domingo v. Spouses Manzano 201883 Division
Hernandez v. Crossworld Marine Services 209098 Division
Interadent Zahntechnik Philippines v. Simbillo 207315 Division
Villamor v. Employees' Compensation Commission 204422 Division
Ruiz v. Dimailig 204280 Special En Banc
Federated LPG Dealers Association v. Del Rosario 202639 Division
Matudan v. Republic 203284 Division
Chua v. Atty. Jimenez 9880 Division
Manulife Philippines v. Ybanez 204736 Division
People v. Dr. Sobrepena, Sr. 204063 Division

2017
Garingan-Ferreras v. Umblas P-11-2989 En Banc
Valencia v. Classique Vinyl Products Corporation 206390 Division
Asian Institute of Management v. AIM Faculty Association 207971 Division
People v. Quita 212818 Division
Turks Shawarma Company v. Pajaron 207156 Division
People v. Tionloc 212193 Division
CIR v. St. Luke's Medical Center 203514 Division
Sta. Ana v. Manila Jockey Club 208459 Division
Spouses Pajares v. Remarkable Laundry and Dry Cleaning 212690 Division
People v. Ismael y Radang 208093 Division
PNB v. Chan 206037 Division
Brown v. Marswin Marketing Inc 206891 Division
People v. Gabriel y Gajardo 213390 Division
Almendras v. South Davao Development Corporation 198209 Division
Villamor and Bonaobra v. People 200396 Division
TSM Shipping Phils. V. Patino 210289 Division
People v. Gayoso y Arguelles 206590 Division
LBP v. Spouses Chu 192345 Division
People v. Sibbu 214757 Division
Bankard, Inc. v. Alarte 202573 Division
Asiatrust Development Bank v. CIR 201530 Division
Herma Shipyard, Inc. v. Oliveros 208936 Division
Dutch Movers, Inc. v. Lequin 210032 Division
Guyamin v. Flores 202189 Division
Siy v. Tomlin 205998 Division
DPWH v. Malaga 204906 Division
People v. Soriano y Narag 216063 Division
Republic v. Spouses Salvador 205428 Division
United Polyresins, Inc. v. Pinuela 209555 Division
Japos v. First Agrarian Reform Multi-purpose Cooperative 208000 Division
People v. Abellanosa 214340 Division
People v. Gamba y Nissorada 215332 Division
Spouses Estrada v. Philippine Rabbit Bus Lines 203902 Division
Barbosa and Barbosa v. People 207193 Division
People v. Napoles y Bajas 215200 Division
Lagman v. Medialdea 231658 En Banc
Abagatnan v. Spouses Clarito 211966 Division
Darines and Darines v. Quinones and Quitan 206468 Division
Palma v. Judge Omelio RTJ-10-2223 Division
Sta. Ana v. Atty. Cortes 6980 Division
Edison (Bataan) Cogeneration Corporation v. CIR 201665 Division
Cabiles v. Atty. Cedo 10245 Division
North Sea Marine Services Corporation v. Enriquez 201806 Division
Cathay Land v. Ayala Land, Inc. 210209 Division
Pen Development Corporation v. Martinez Leyba, Inc 211845 Division
People v. Padlan y Leones 214880 Division
Torres v. Aruego 201271 Division
Spouses Rosario v. Alvar 212731 Division
Re: Report on the Preliminary Results of the Spot Audit in the RTC, Branch 170, Malabon City 16-05-142-RTC En Banc
Coson v. People 218830 Division
People v. Panes y Magsanop 215730 Division
Career Philippines Shipmanagement v. Godinez 206826 Division
DAR v. Galle 171836 Division
Re: Anonymous Complaints against Judge Bandong RTJ-17-2597 Division
Meatworld International v. Hechanova 208053 Division
Lontoc-Cruz v. Santos Cruz 201988 Division
Cruz, Manahan, Jervoso v. People 206437 Division
Dela Cruz v. Domingo 210592 Division
Re: Judicial Audit Conducted in the RTC, Branch 20, Cagayan De Oro City 14-11-350-RTC En Banc
Regalado v. De La Rama vda. De La Pena 202448 Division
People v. Polangcus 216940 Division
People v. Dagsil y Caritero 218945 Division
People v. Norada and Seva 218958 Division
People v. Ejan y Bayato 212169 Division
Dillena v. Alcaraz 204045 Division
People v. Macud y Dimaampao 219175 Division
Expedition Construction Corporation v. Africa 228671 Division
Leonidas v. Vargas and Republic 201031 Division