Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Rocket RSI
A solid propellant for your
rocket science trading 8
The V-Trade
Part 3: Fibonacci projections
and daily pivots 14
Support &
Resistance IN FX
Identifying strong levels 24
INTERVIEW
Building trading systems
with Cesar Alvarez 34
TRADING CHECKLIST
What should it include? 60
MAY 2018
Daily technical commentary
by expert analysts to help you
make smarter investing decisions
From daily blogs to live web shows, StockCharts.com hosts free
current market analysis and educational commentary from some
of the industry’s most distinguished technical analysts.
and more!
StockCharts.com
© StockCharts.com,Inc. All Rights Reserved. Information provided by StockCharts.com is not investment advice. You are responsible for your own investment decisions.
How much is your
broker charging you?
US Margin Loan Commission Rates
Rates Comparison Comparison
Options1 Base
$300K Equity Trades
per contract
no base cost
Interactive Brokers2 2.58%3 $2.50
$0.67 per contract4
$6.95 base
E-Trade 8.00% $6.95
+ $0.75 per contract
$4.95 base
Fidelity 7.07% $4.95
+ $0.65 per contract
$4.95 base
Schwab 7.07% $4.95
+ $0.65 per contract
$6.95 base
TD Ameritrade 7.75% $6.95
+ $0.75 per contract
Each firm’s information reflects the standard trading costs obtained from the respective firm’s
websites as of 3/5/18. Pricing and offers subject to change without notice.
FEATURE ARTICLE
8 RocketRSI—A Solid TIPS 29 Futures For You
Propellant For Your by Carley Garner
Rocket Science Trading Here’s how the futures market
by John F. Ehlers really works. 42 Retail ETFs Are A Mixed Bag
by Leslie N. Masonson
Wouldn’t it be great to know that
there’s a strong chance a cyclic 30 The Four Market Dimensions Interested in learning more about
reversal will take place? How many by Mark Rivest using exchange traded funds (ETFs)
indicators can identify this event? in your trading?
Improve your trading by combining
The RSI is a favorite indicator the dimensions of price, time,
among technical analysts. Make it momentum, and sentiment. 60 Get More Value Using
a tad bit more flexible and it may A Trading Checklist
help you find those high-probability
INTERVIEW by Thomas Bulkowski
reversal points.
What is a trading plan or checklist
34 Building Trading Systems and how can it help?
14 The V-Trade, Part 3: With Cesar Alvarez
Technical Analysis— by Jayanthi Gopalakrishnan
Fibonacci Projections And With a bachelor of science in
Daily Pivots electrical engineering and computer DEPARTMENTS
by Sylvain Vervoort science, and a master of science in 6 Opening Position
In this third part of a multipart computer science, it’s no surprise 7 Letters To S&C
series, we look at passive support that Cesar Alvarez found an affinity
for developing trading systems. He 41 Trade News & Products
& resistance with Fibonacci 46 Traders’ Tips
projections and daily pivots. has been at the forefront of stock
market research and has developed 57 Advertisers’ Index
a number of trading systems based 57 Editorial Resource Index
22 Explore Your Options on his findings. He’s got strategies
by Jay Kaeppel for daytrading, swing trading, 58 Futures Liquidity
Got a question about options? long-term trading … you name 59 Classified Advertising
it, he’s likely got it. Alvarez has 59 Traders’ Resource
also coauthored several books on
24 Trading Support & Resistance systems trading. We spoke with
Levels In FX him to find out more about what
by Solomon Chuama goes into the different types of
The forex markets typically move trading systems he develops.
in a zigzag fashion, and that
makes entry and exit decisions 38 Moving Average Hammer
challenging. Here we look at a few Pivots
tried and true methods to identify
strong support & resistance levels by Ken Calhoun
in the forex markets. Combine a Japanese hammer
candle with a moving average line
to confirm a pivot and generate a
trading signal.
Copyright © 2018 Technical Analysis, Inc. All rights reserved. Information in this publication must not be stored or reproduced in any form without written permission from the publisher. Technical Analysis
of Stocks & Commodities™ (ISSN 0738-3355) is published monthly with a Bonus Issue in March for $89.99 per year by Technical Analysis, Inc., 4757 California Ave. S.W., Seattle, WA 98116-4499. Periodicals
postage paid at Seattle, WA and at additional mailing offices. Postmaster: Send address changes to Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities™ 4757 California Ave. S.W., Seattle, WA 98116-4499 U.S.A.
Printed in the U.S.A.
CVL
Today’s G/L -$10 -0.12% 220.00
S 16.85 220.00
16.80 Total G/L -$10 0.12% 210.00
210.00
TB 15.80
180.00
170.00
CLOSED POSITION 170.00
160.00
$
160.00
15.80 YTD G/L $2,735 3.60% 150.00
150.00
140.00
140.00
Volume 6,228,654 14.80
Volume 6,228,654
14.30
Positions News Research Options
†
Sell orders are subject to an activity assessment fee (from $0.01 to $0.03 per $1,000 of principal). Trades are limited to online domestic equities and
options and must be used within two years. Options trades are limited to 20 contracts per trade. Offer valid for new and existing Fidelity customers
opening or adding net new assets to an eligible Fidelity IRA or brokerage account. Accounts receiving $100,000 or more will receive 500 free trades.
Account balance of $100,000 must be maintained for at least nine months; otherwise, normal commission schedule rates may be retroactively applied to
any free trade executions. See Fidelity.com/ATP500free for further details. Fidelity reserves the right to modify these terms and conditions or terminate
this offer at any time. Other terms and conditions, or eligibility criteria may apply.
Active Trader Pro® is automatically made available to customers trading 36 times or more in a rolling 12-month period. If you do not meet the eligibility
criteria, please contact Active Trader Services at 800-564-0211 to request access.
Screens are for illustrative purposes only.
Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC, Member NYSE, SIPC. © 2017 FMR LLC. All rights reserved. 736003.6.0
May 2018 • Volume 36, Number 6
Opening Position
The Traders’ MagazineTM
T
EDITORIAL
editor@traders.com he tail end of March 2018 reminded
Editor in Chief Jack K. Hutson us just how vulnerable the markets
Editor Jayanthi Gopalakrishnan can be. When the markets rise as much and
Production Manager Karen E. Wasserman
as quickly as they did from 2016 to 2018,
Art Director Christine Morrison
any negative news could make that market
quickly reverse direction. We saw how
Graphic Designer Wayne Shaw
Webmaster Han J. Kim
Contributing Editors John Ehlers,
the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA)
Anthony W. Warren, Ph.D. dropped over 1,400 points in two days. Of
Contributing Writers Thomas Bulkowski, Martin Pring, course, the drop was attributed to a few
Barbara Star, Markos Katsanos
different events that unfolded at around the
same time—the revelation of an apparent
OFFICE OF THE Publisher lack of protection of customer privacy by Facebook, the Trump administration’s
Publisher Jack K. Hutson
Industrial Engineer Jason K. Hutson
decision to levy tariffs on a number of Chinese imports, and the Federal Reserve’s
Project Engineer Sean M. Moore decision to likely raise interest rates a few more times within the next year. It
could have even been a combination of these events that caused the markets to
Advertising Sales react the way they did.
4757 California Ave. S.W.
Seattle, WA 98116-4499 Whenever there are fundamental issues that impact the market, there is a strong
likelihood they will weigh on sentiment. And sentiment, as we know well, can
206 938-0570 Fax 206 938-1307
advert@traders.com
send the markets moving quickly in one
Circulation direction. The shifts in market direction Whenever there are
Subscription & Order Service 1 800 832-4642
can cause volatility to rise, which is
1 206 938-0570 Fax 1 206 938-1307
circ@traders.com
welcomed by short-term traders—it gets fundamental issues that
Subscription Manager Sean M. Moore
the markets moving. Although volatility impact the market, there
is good for the markets, traders need to is a strong likelihood they
Website
http://www.traders.com know when to enter and exit their trades, will weigh on sentiment.
Staff members may be emailed through the Internet especially when things are moving fast.
L
using first initial plus last name plus @traders.com
et’s unravel some of what took place in the markets after Facebook (FB)
privacy issues were at stake. FB is one of the most widely followed
Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal
use, or the internal or personal use of specific clients, is grant-
ed by Technical Analysis, Inc. for users registered with the stocks and has a large weighting in the major indexes. After the news emerged,
Copyright Clearance Center (CCC) Transactional Reporting
Service, provided that the base fee of $1.00 per copy, plus its shares entered bear market territory. Pull up a daily chart of FB and overlay
50¢ per page is paid directly to CCC, 222 Rosewood Drive,
Danvers, MA 01923. Online: http://www.copyright.com. For
the 200-day moving average and you’ll see that at the end of March 2018, FB
those organiz ations that have been granted a photocopy shares were well below the moving average. Other widely held stocks, AMZN,
NFLX, GOOGL, AAPL, and NVDA, also saw their shares fall, although they
license by CCC, a separate system of payment has been
arranged. The fee code for users of the Transactional
Reporting Service is: 0738-3355/2018 $1.00 + 0.50. may not have been as hard hit as FB. All these stocks have a large impact on the
Subscriptions: USA: one year (13 issues) $89.99;
Magazines shipped outside the US require additional major indexes and as a result, the broader markets all fell, sending investors into
postage as follows: Canada, US$15 per year; Europe,
US$25.50 per year; all other countries US$39 per year.
panic mode. The 200-day moving average acted as a strong support for the S&P
Single copies of most past issues from the current year are 500 index, the 180-day moving average acted as support for the DJIA, and the
150-day average was a strong support level for the Nasdaq 100.
available prepaid at $8 per copy. Prior years are available
in book format (without ads) or digitally from www.traders.
com. USA funds only. Washington state residents add This goes to show that volatility and correlation can go hand in hand. And when
sales tax for their locale. VISA, MasterCard, AmEx, and
Discover accepted. Subscription orders: 1 800 832-4642 the markets have been as overvalued as they have been going into 2018, then you
or 1 206 938-0570.
Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities™,
can expect these types of market shocks. It all goes back to the basics—develop
The Traders’ Magazine™, is prepared from information well-thought-out trading systems and incorporate realistic risk management
strategies before you place any trades.
believed to be reliable but not guaranteed by us without
further verification, and does not purport to be complete.
Miami Downtown Richard Cavalleri/Shutterstock
Opinions expressed are subject to revision without noti- Here’s to good trading!
fication. We are not offering to buy or sell securities or
commodities discussed. Technical Analysis Inc., one or
more of its officers, and authors may have a position in
the securities discussed herein.
The names of products and services presented in this
magazine are used only in an editorial fashion, and to the
benefit of the trademark owner, with no intention of infring- Jayanthi Gopalakrishnan,
Editor
ing on trademark rights.
The editors of S&C invite readers to submit their opinions and information on subjects
relating to technical analysis and this magazine. This column is our means of communi- Winner
cation with our readers. Is there something you would like to know more (or less) about?
Tell us about it. Without a source of new ideas and subjects coming from our readers, this 16 years
magazine would not exist. in a row!
Email your correspondence to Editor@Traders.com or address your correspondence
to: Editor, Stocks & Commodities, 4757 California Ave. SW, Seattle, WA 98116-4499. All
letters become the property of Technical Analysis, Inc. Letter-writers must include their full
name and address for verification. Letters may be edited for length or clarity. The opinions
Build powerful
expressed in this column do not necessarily represent those of the magazine.—Editor trading systems in
MINUTES
TRADING VOLATILITY limits the peak of the VIX move on the
without coding
Editor, chart, as you stated. By allocating to a
I was reading the article VIX buying strategy when the equal-
by Andrew Sachais in weight S&P 500 index breaks down,
the March 2018 S&C, as is defined in the article, the trader is ®
J.
Welles Wilder’s original description of the Using a little algebra to put everything on the right-
relative strength index (RSI) in his 1978 hand side of the equation over a common denominator,
book New Concepts In Technical Trading the indicator equation becomes:
Systems specified a calculation length of
14 days. That requirement started me on a 40-year RSI = CU / (CU + CD)
quest to find the correct length of data for the compu-
tation of indicators and trading strategy rules. Many In this formulation, RSI has a value of zero if the
technicians have addressed the RSI and described its accumulation of CU is zero and has a value of 1 if the
applications. In this article I will derive a formulation accumulation of CD is zero. If you reduce the price
that has more flexibility and ease of interpretation. I movement to its primitive as a sine wave, then it is
will also extrapolate the algorithm to accurately address easy to see that this RSI has only CU going from the
a statistical approach to technical analysis. valley to the peak and only has CD going from peak to
valley. This RSI traces out the shape of the sine wave
Start with the RSI between these two limits. However, a sine wave swings
Here is the original definition of the RSI indicator: between -1 and +1 rather than between 0 and + 1. We
can cause the RSI to also have the same swing limits
RSI = 100 - 100 / (1 + RS) as the sine wave if we multiply the equation above by
2 and then subtract 1 from the product as:
where RS = Average gain of up periods
during the specified timeframe / Average RSI = 2*CU / (CU + CD) – 1
loss of down periods during the specified
timeframe Again, using a little algebra to put the right-hand
side of the equation over a common denominator, the
My first observation is that the factor of 100 is equation evolves to:
irrelevant. Second, the averages are not required
because we are taking the ratio of closes up (CU) to MyRSI = (CU – CD) / (CU + CD)
INGA POSLITUR
by John F. Ehlers
May 2018 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities • 9
full swing between -1 and +1. Smoothing the
output waveform averages the output that,
itself, can never exceed +1 or -1. Therefore,
the smoothed signal seldom makes the full
swing. This difference of achieving full
swing is important when we examine the
statistical nature of the indicator.
The EasyLanguage code shown in the
sidebar “My RSI Indicator EasyLanguage
Code” uses my SuperSmoother filter for
smoothing. I have separated the choice of
tradestation
SINCE
THESE RESULTS ARE BASED ON SIMULATED OR HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE RESULTS THAT HAVE CERTAIN INHERENT LIMITATIONS. UNLIKE THE RESULTS SHOWN IN AN ACTUAL PERFORMANCE RECORD, THESE RE-
SULTS DO NOT REPRESENT ACTUAL TRADING. ALSO, BECAUSE THESE TRADES HAVE NOT ACTUALLY BEEN EXECUTED, THESE RESULTS MAY HAVE UNDER-OR OVER-COMPENSATED FOR THE IMPACT, IF ANY, OF CERTAIN
MARKET FACTORS, SUCH AS LACK OF LIQUIDITY. SIMULATED OR HYPOTHETICAL TRADING PROGRAMS IN GENERAL ARE ALSO SUBJECT TO THE FACT THAT THEY ARE DESIGNED WITH THE BENEFIT OF HINDSIGHT. NO REP-
RESENTATION IS BEING MADE THAT ANY ACCOUNT WILL OR IS LIKELY TO ACHIEVE PROFITS OR LOSSES SIMILAR TO THESE BEING SHOWN. THE TESTIMONIAL MAY NOT BE REPRESENTATIVE OF THE EXPERIENCE OF OTHER
CLIENTS AND THE TESTIMONIAL IS NO GUARANTEE OF FUTURE PERFORMANCE OR SUCCESS. TECHNICAL ANALYSIS OF STOCKS & COMMODITIES LOGO AND AWARD ARE TRADEMARKS OF TECHNICAL ANALYSIS, INC.
Making it flexible
Although this article revisits a solid, favorite Stocks & Commodities Contributing Editor John Ehlers is
indicator to technical traders, several new for- a pioneer in the use of cycles and DSP technical analysis. He
mulations have been introduced that increase is president of MESA Software and cofounder of StockSpotter.
the interpretation of and the usability of the com. MESASoftware.com offers the MESA Phasor and MESA
good ol’ RSI. These are: intraday futures strategies.
• The RSI can be computed by using simple accumulations
of closes up and closes down rather than averages. The code given in this article is available in the Article Code section
of our website, Traders.com.
• The correct data length to use in the computation of the
RSI is half the dominant cycle period. See our Traders’ Tips section beginning on page 46 for commentary
• An equation has been derived using dilation and transla- and implementation of John Ehlers’ technique in various technical
tion that displays the RSI as swinging between -1 and +1. analysis programs. Accompanying program code can be found in the
This is a natural display of an oscillator-type indicator Traders’ Tips area at Traders.com.
for swing trading.
• Smoothing can be introduced either before or after the
Further reading
Ehlers, John [2013]. Cycle Analytics For Traders, Wiley.
RSI computation. Placement of the smoothing alters the
Wilder, J. Welles [1978]. New Concepts In Technical Trading
RSI waveshape because of the nonlinear operation of
Systems.
the RSI process. Smoothing before computing the RSI
‡TradeStation
is preferred.
‡See Editorial Resource Index
• Using the half dominant cycle period momentum rather †See Traders’ Glossary for definition
than prices alone establishes a zero mean.
• Applying the Fisher transform creates statistically sig-
nificant spikes that indicate cyclic turning points with
precision.
Futures trading is speculative and is not suitable for all investors. Futures accounts are not protected by SIPC. Futures trading services provided by
TD Ameritrade Futures & Forex LLC. Trading privileges subject to review and approval. Not all clients will qualify. This is not an offer or solicitation in
any jurisdiction where we are not authorized to do business. TD Ameritrade, Inc., member FINRA/SIPC. © 2017 TD Ameritrade.
Pivotal Concerns
The V-Trade
Part 3: Technical Analysis—Fibonacci Projections And Daily Pivots
In this third part of a multipart series, we look at passive Hindu-Arabic numerals. Liber Abaci also presented a problem
support & resistance with Fibonacci projections and daily involving the growth of a hypothetical population of rabbits,
pivots. based on idealized assumptions. The solution was a number
sequence that became known as Fibonacci numbers.
T
by Sylvain Vervoort The number sequence was known to Indian mathematicians
as early as the sixth century, but it was Fibonacci’s Liber
he objective of this series on the V-Trade is to ex- Abaci that introduced it to the West. Fibonacci numbers have
plain the techniques I apply to make manual and the following sequence: 1, 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, 21, 34, 55, 89, 144,
automatic buy & sell decisions, or a combination 233, and so on. Each number is the sum of the two previous
of both. Last month in part 2, I discussed passive numbers. The higher up in the sequence, two consecutive
support & resistance levels. I will continue that numbers divided by each other approach the so-called golden
discussion of technical analysis here with a focus on Fibonacci ratio (approximately 1:1.618, or 0.618:1).
projections and daily pivots. I will also include an indicator
ART: OPTURADESIGN/SHUTTERSTOCK
metatrader
and target price resistance levels at 161.8% and
261.8%.
Figure 1 shows how price reacts around these FIGURE 1: FIBONACCI RETRACEMENT AND TARGET LEVELS. Here you see how price reacts
Fibonacci retracement and destination levels. At 3 around these Fibonacci retracement and destination levels.
and 4, price retraces to the 38.2% price level. The
up move after these support levels finds resistance
at the 100% level, of course also a passive price
resistance level from the previous top at 2. When
price breaks the 100% level, it moves up to 5, the
161.8% Fibonacci level. Here, there is some resis-
tance and after a smaller pullback, price moves up
to 6 with a retrace back to point 7, a support from
previous top 5 and close to the 161.8% Fibonacci
support. Finally, price moves up and reaches the
top at point 8 at the 261.8% Fibonacci level.
You may use any turning points, shorter and
longer term, to create Fibonacci projections.
Fibonacci levels are an important tool to predict
support and target price levels.
Often, and based on the idea that resistance be-
comes support and vice versa, you can successfully
use price retraces for the creation of Fibonacci
projections. Let me show some examples.
Figure 2: FIBONACCI UP TARGET LEVELS. From the last low point, you can determine the
Fibonacci projection levels.
Fibonacci up target levels
In Figure 2, price has been in a down move until
14:45 on October 13. There is good reason to
believe this may be the end of the current down
move. After two to three bars you could assume
there is an upward turning point. You do not
have to wait for a turning point in the up move
to create a Fibonacci up projection. It is okay to
use the last wave down to make this projection.
In Figure 2, this is the red colored projection, 0 is
the last low point, and 100 the high point of the
last move down.
The 161.8% projection is at passive resistance
of price tops in the previous down move. The
261.8% target is reached and forms support for the
first pullback in the uptrend. Finally, price moves
up to the 423.6% target. So from the beginning FIGURE 3: FIBONACCI RETRACEMENT AND DOWN TARGET LEVELS. Here you see how all
of the up reversal, we know where price may go projected targets were reached with a couple of retracements on the way down.
? On? Your?Next
have to determine a point at which they
will consider cutting a loss or adjusting
the trade in some manner.
So here is a simple rule of thumb: You
?
?Investment
?
do not want to get stopped out by market
“noise.” If selling a bull put credit spread,
?
there should be an obvious support level
?? ??
above the price of the underlying secu-
??? ?
rity. If selling a bull put credit spread
there should be an obvious support
level below the price of the underlying
?
security. Your “uncle” point for the trade
you are considering should be beyond
the obvious support or resistance level
that appears on the price chart. Why?
? ?
Because any drop to the obvious support
?ANALYZE? ?ANY
level (or rise to the obvious resistance
level) that does not break out beyond
that point is nothing more than “noise.”
In fact, it could even serve to strengthen
the support (or resistance) level if price
retests and then holds above support (or
below resistance).
Consider the hypothetical bull put
credit spread that appears in Figure 1,
STOCK FREE!
which involves:
T
Concept of support & resistance
ART: VECTOR STUDIO/SHUTTERSTOCK
echnical analysis or chart analysis is the study of The forex market moves in a zigzag pattern. When the market
historical price movement to determine where price moves up, reaches a high point, and pulls back, that high is
will go. As you look at the chart you identify trends called resistance. The lowest point it reached before continuing
and patterns that will give you trading opportuni- its upward movement is called support (Figure 1).
ties. At the beginning of each trading week, most Resistance is the price level (ceiling) where selling is
forex traders first identify the market’s direction, strong to interrupt or reverse an uptrend. It also implies that
24 • May 2018 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities
Forex Focus
Resistance
Resistance
A forex trader should first
Resistance
identify trend direction and
Support
then choose to buy at support
in an uptrend and sell at a
resistance in a downtrend.
Support
FIGURE 2: KEY MARKET LEVELS. Here you see six psychological levels with 0.70000 price level as the most powerful support level.
FIGURE 3: FIBONACCI RETRACEMENT LEVELS IN A DOWNTREND. Price movement held a key market level at the 50.00 Fibonacci level, which is a vital resistance
level.
FIGURE 4: FIBONACCI RETRACEMENT LEVELS IN AN UPTREND. Traders can go long at the 38.2 Fibonacci levels, which is a vital support level that AUDUSD
held.
Futures, foreign currency and options trading contains substantial risk and is not for every investor. Only
risk capital should be used for trading and only those with sufficient risk capital should consider trading.
at the key levels, it may mean that level will hold. You candlestick for all long positions and at the high
should consider placing a short order at the resistance of the previous candlestick for all short positions.
or a long order at the support levels. Your take-profit can be set relative to the stop-loss
• In a trending market, you can trade support & resistance or you can trail-stop your profits.
levels as the market makes new highs and lows; this will
result in “swing points” in the market. In an uptrend,
Who drives the market?
On Sundays as the market opens, I have
a recent swing high will act as support, whereas in a
made it a point to identify these key zones of
downtrend, a recent swing low will act as resistance.
the market before trading begins because I
As usual, you take a long position at the support level
believe history always repeats itself. Support
while you short at the resistance level.
& resistance levels are the fundamentals
• Similarly, in a ranging market, you can trade support & of technical analysis. In technical trading,
resistance if the market is not choppy, as long as there always base your analysis results on higher
is a good distance between support & resistance levels timeframes rather than on lower ones. Higher timeframe
and trading currency crosses, that is, those not paired analysis tends to be more significant than the highs and lows
with the USD. In a range-bound market you can use of the lower timeframe. These levels represent the levels where
the relative strength index (RSI) oscillator to determine traders who are trading live drive the market when the market
when the market is oversold or overbought. You can do retests these levels.
this in the following ways:
Solomon Chuama has been working in the financial industry
{{
First, when the market is overbought, do not im-
for 16 years. He is a training seminar organizer and instructor
mediately take a short position, since you don’t
who tries to pass along to students his passion and knowledge
know whether price will continue to rally. Instead,
of forex trading.
take a short position as soon as the RSI falls below
the 70 level. This will give you a high-probability
Further reading
trade. When the market is oversold, take a long
Chuama, Solomon [2018]. “A Range-Bound Strategy,” Tech-
position if RSI crosses upward of the 30 level.
nical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities, Volume 36:
{{
Second, waiting for the market to make a false April.
break of a trading range. In any trading range
there will be at least one false breakout. A false
breakout is when price breaks beyond the estab-
lished range and moves back to the range. Initiate
a short position if price moves into and closes in
the resistance zone; initiate a long position if price
closes in the support zone.
{{
Finally, a stop-loss is set at the low of the previous
FIGURE 5: PURE PRICE ACTION. On the four-hour chart of CHFJPY you will find resistance zones forming at a price of 114.900. The market turns at a psychological
price level of 114.900. Price tested the resistance level three times and reversed each time. At the extreme low, the market tested support twice.
Daytrading Emini S&P Options for a short position, a trader could buy a (the price paid to purchase the option)
(Part 1 of 2) weekly put option instead. Similarly, a without giving up lasting power as an
Now that the CME offers Monday, buy signal can be met with the purchase opportunity cost. Specifically, emini
Wednesday, and Friday weekly options, of a weekly call option. Preferably, the S&P 500 futures traders often manage
is daytrading emini S&P 500 options a options used for daytrading should expire their risk per trade using stop-loss orders.
viable strategy? in roughly two to three days. However, stop-loss orders are highly
A few years ago, the idea of daytrad- The trader can choose the level of ag- prone to premature election, leaving trad-
ing options in the emini S&P was more gression and risk aversion by choosing ers to watch the market run away in the
of a pipe dream than a reality. Traders an appropriate strike price. For instance, anticipated direction without them.
wishing to do so were forced to trade a trader wishing to trade conservatively In addition, the use of stop-loss orders
options with monthly expirations (the would purchase an out-of-the-money generally leads to nearly guaranteed
third Friday of each month) or end-of- (OTM) option for little premium, but a small trading losses, as opposed to pro-
month options, which expire on the last more aggressive trader might be will- tecting capital while leaving potential
trading day of the month. Aside from ing to pay a higher price for an at-the- for gains. In short, stop orders tend to
the week prior to expiration, option day- money (ATM) option (this means the do more harm than good because they
traders would have been forced to buy strike price is identical, or similar, to often lock in losses at the worst time.
calls and puts with relatively substantial The use of long option trades, on the
time to expiration. This translated into other hand, translates into positions that
high premiums (high option prices), less Slower-moving option are always “in it to win it.” Of course, it
responsive option prices to the underly- positions in which the is possible to buy a weekly option and
ing futures price, and thus overall higher maximum loss is known see the premium quickly erode to noth-
risks and lower rewards. ing; yet even a nearly worthless option
Now that the CME offers options
are far less likely to keeps the trader in the game and things
expiring on every other day of the week trigger the emotional can change quickly. Losing long option
(Monday, Wednesday, and Friday), option meltdown that outright positions can always get better, but a
daytraders can focus their speculation on futures trading might. futures trade stopped out at a loss can
hours, not days or weeks. Further, it is never improve.
possible to profit from accurate intraday Another primary benefit of using
speculation in the ES in increments of a the current underlying futures price). long weekly options as opposed to long
few points of futures market movement, Obviously, options with strike prices or short futures contracts is the mental
not dozens of points. In short, options that are either ATM or near-the-money stability that comes with low and limited
traders can now utilize long puts and will be more responsive to changes in risk. Slower-moving option positions in
long calls to wager on short-term day the futures price; thus, not only are these which the maximum loss is known are
trades or swing trades. options more expensive to purchase, they far less likely to trigger the emotional
Except for scalping, futures traders also come with more risk than an OTM meltdown that outright futures trading
wishing to make the move to options as strike–priced option would. might. Thus, it is a highly conceivable
a means of mitigating risk and account If you find yourself wondering why notion that daytrading options promotes
balance volatility can do so without a trader would use options, which are rational decision-making by mitigating
changing their overall game plan. In less efficient than futures, to speculate emotional mayhem.
other words, the same technical indica- on intraday price moves, the answer is Some other benefits of this style of
tors and timeframes can be used for simple: to mitigate risk while maintain- daytrading are a lack of margin concern.
option daytrading as is used for futures ing leverage. More importantly, risk of a
daytrading. If a daytrading strategy calls long option is limited to a defined amount Continued on page 56
May 2018 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities • 29
Expand Your Horizon
T
by Mark Rivest with any pattern methodology.
Shortly after developing the wave theory that now bears his
raders often find themselves stuck in a world of two name, R.N. Elliott was introduced to the concept of Fibonacci
or sometimes only one dimension. They could be numbers and ratios. Fibonacci ratios can be used to discover
CHALKBOARD: FREDERIC MULLER/BULL, BEAR: GENE BLIELE/SEASONS: ANDREII SPY_K/
utilizing the dimensions of price and momentum market turning points by way of retracements or projections.
NAUTILUS SHELL:LORNA ROBERTS/SHUTTERSTOCK/COLLAGE: CHRISTINE MORRISON
while ignoring factors from the dimensions of Some of the main Fibonacci ratios are 0.236, 0.382, 0.50, 0.618,
time and sentiment. The reality is markets operate 1.00, 1.382 and 1.618. The ratios can be used on any time scale
simultaneously in all four dimensions and each from a one-minute chart to a chart spanning several decades.
must be analyzed to maximize profits. Fibonacci ratios are like magnets/resistors. They draw market
prices to them and then repel prices away. The most common
Price dimension retracement/projection ratio is 1.00, which represents equality.
All traders, regardless of which market they are trading, use Traders who use intraday charts are probably familiar with this
price dimension. Sadly, many traders focus only on price, giv- phenomenon. A bottom is made, prices rise, then fall back to
ing them a myopic view of the total picture. Price dimension the bottom, and then rally again. The decline is equal to the
encompasses two broad areas—chart pattern and support/ rally, a ratio of 1/1. The next most common ratio retracement/
resistance. The tools to discover support/resistance are Fibo- projection is 0.618, which is called the golden ratio.
nacci analysis, moving averages, and trendlines. Please refer to the daily S&P 500 (SPX) chart (2011–2013)
Two types of chart patterns are Elliott waves and standard in Figure 1. From 2011 to 2013 there were three instances
technical patterns such as head & shoulders. Whatever pattern when price retraced to the 0.618 Fibonacci level. The first,
30 • May 2018 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities
TRADING TECHNIQUES
stockcharts.com
oversold zone of 0–15% at each of the Fibonacci
turning points.
Time dimension FIGURE 1: PRICE DIMENSION. From 2011 to 2013 there were three instances when price retraced
to the 0.618 Fibonacci level. Although price did not hit the exact levels, it came pretty close to the
There are several methodologies used to study the target levels.
time dimension. Nearly every market has a broad
seasonal pattern. For example, crude oil is usually
bullish from February to May. Another technique
measures periodic market bottoms. This method
can be used on any time scale from intraday to
decades. For example, you could discover the
existence of a market bottom every four weeks.
Unfortunately, there’s usually wide leeway between
cycles, and eventually, at some point, a cycle fades
away. Some studies have found astronomical events
such as full/new moons and solar/lunar eclipses
can sometimes coincide with market turns.
A fascinating way to find market turns is Fi-
bonacci time analysis. R.N. Elliott discovered
that markets can have moves measured by the
Fibonacci sequence. The sequence is 1, 1, 2, 3,
5, 8, 13, 21, 34, 55, 89, 144, 233, to infinity. For
example, he found that the 1929 to 1932 bear
market was 34 months and the 1932 to 1937 was FIGURE 2: TIME DIMENSION. In mid-2016, the SPX had an incredible web of Fibonacci time
five years. The method can be used on any time sequence turns. The best part about using the Fibonacci time sequence method is accuracy. If
scale from minutes to decades and can be applied you forecast a bottom in 21 trading days and the market is still declining on the 22nd trading day,
to any market. There’s also another technique us- the forecast is invalid.
ing Fibonacci time ratios. In this article, I’ll focus
on the Fibonacci time sequence. trading days to the January 20th bottom also targeted August
Please see the daily SPX chart (12/24/15 to 9/30/16) shown 15! As spectacular as it was, there was more evidence from
in Figure 2. In mid-2016, the SPX had an incredible web of the price dimension that strongly suggested a top.
Fibonacci time sequence turns. If you add 21 trading days Using a Fibonacci ratio projection of the rally from Febru-
from the SPX top on April 20, the target is May 19, which ary 11, 2016 to June 8, 2016 was 310.45 SPX points, when
was an SPX bottom. If you add 13 trading days to the May multiplied by 0.618 equals 191.86. Adding 191.86 to the June
19th bottom, the target is June 8 as an SPX top. If you add 13 27th bottom at 1991.68 targets SPX 2183.54. The actual top
trading days to the June 8th top, it targets June 27, which was on August 15 was 2193.81.
an SPX bottom. I forecasted this turn in my June 24, 2016 Even more evidence of a potential SPX peak came from the
article at Traders.com, “The Brexit Factor.” momentum dimension. There was a RSI bearish divergence
The next turn was the most spectacular of all, as it involved on August 15 versus the reading made on July 22. The mid-
not one but two Fibonacci time sequences. Adding 34 trading August peak was followed by a correction that lasted until
days from June 27 targeted August 15. In addition, adding 144 early November.
May 2018 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities • 31
ish divergences. For the MACD the histogram portion of this
oscillator is particularly good at signaling divergences. MACD
Stochastics is usually the line crossovers give confirmation of a turn, sometimes shortly
most sensitive oscillator and after the bottom/top.
can frequently give the first One other tool from the price dimension that can be used
to discover turns are large breaks of the Bollinger Bands.
signs of approaching tops/ Keep in mind that this technique must be used in conjunc-
bottoms. tion with momentum oscillators. Frequently large breaks of
the upper/lower band could come in the middle of a strong
move up or down.
The best part about using the Fibonacci time sequence Sentiment dimension
method is accuracy. There is no leeway or fudge factor. The The sentiment dimension becomes a factor at intermediate
market must turn on a Fibonacci sequence number. If you and major market turns. Sentiment extremes usually indicate
forecast a bottom in 21 trading days and the market is still a market is ripe for a turn. However, R. Earl Hadady noted
declining on the 22nd trading day, the forecast is invalid. in his classic book “Contrary Opinion” that effective signals
can be made on sentiment divergences.
Momentum dimension Sentiment tools come in three forms; sentiment surveys,
Perhaps the first method to determine a market’s momentum anecdotal evidence, and put/call ratios.
comes from the Dow Theory developed in the early 20th cen- Sentiment surveys come from companies such as Market
tury. An examination of the Dow Jones Industrial Average Vane Corporation that compile their bullish consensus num-
and what was then called the Dow Jones Railroad Average, ber by tracking the buy and sell recommendations of leading
now called the Dow Jones Transportation Average,
revealed a top/bottom could be forming when the
two diverged. The same concept can be applied
to other markets and stock indexes.
In the precious metals market, a divergence
between gold and silver could indicate a coming
market turn. The same technique can be used with
crude oil and heating oil. With stocks, the major
U.S. stock indexes could be compared to stock in-
dexes of other nations. Focusing just on U.S. stocks,
divergences can be found between the main stock
market indexes and various market sectors.
Another way to determine momentum comes
from what are sometimes referred to as internal
indicators. The daily 52-week list of stocks mak-
ing new highs/lows can be of tremendous help to
discovering a potential stock market top/bottom.
A third methodology to measure market mo-
mentum comes in the form of oscillators. Three
of the most widely used are stochastic, MACD,
and RSI.
On the daily chart of SPX from 3/2/2015 to
3/1/2016 in Figure 3, the first piece of evidence
comes from the price dimension, with two of the
downside breaks in momentum oscillators in the
neutral zone indicating potentially more downside
action. The break in January 2016 had the oscilla-
tors near or at oversold levels, hinting the decline
could be finished relatively quickly.
Stochastics is usually the most sensitive oscil-
lator and can frequently give the first signs of ap- FIGURE 3: MOMENTUM DIMENSION. Three of the most widely used oscillators to measure
market momentum are stochastic, MACD, and RSI. The first piece of evidence comes from the price
proaching tops/bottoms. It will occasionally have dimension, with two of the downside breaks in momentum oscillators in the neutral zone indicating
bullish/bearish divergences. The RSI and MACD potentially more downside action. The break in January 2016 had the oscillators near or at oversold
give their best signals of a turn with bullish/bear- levels, hinting the decline could be finished relatively quickly.
32 • May 2018 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities
market advisers and commodity
trading advisers. High percentage
readings indicate a market near-
ing a peak and low percentage
readings hint at approaching
market bottoms.
Anecdotal evidence can come
from various media sources,
especially non-financial media.
If you hear or see news about
a market after an extended up
or down multi month move and
from a media source that usu-
ally doesn’t comment about that
FIGURE 4: SENTIMENT DIMENSION. Put/call ratios can be effective in discovering turns in sentiment. Here you see the
market, a significant turn could be best signals come from sentiment divergences in the CBOE weekly put/call ratio.
approaching. Be aware that this
type of evidence is not precise
in catching a turn, and it must be used in conjunction with As of this writing, the SPX rallied 58% in nearly two years.
other sentiment tools. All markets are giant puzzles, and you cannot solve the
Put/call ratios can be effective in discovering a turn within puzzle unless you have all of the pieces. Studying the four
a few trading days and sometimes on the day of the turn. On market dimensions could greatly increase your chances of
the CBOE weekly put/call ratio chart in Figure 4, you will finding those pieces.
see that the best signals come from sentiment divergences.
Note the bullish divergence at the August and October 2011 Mark Rivest is an independent investment advisor, trader,
US stock market bottoms. Even more significant was the and writer. He has written articles for Technical Analysis
double bullish divergence made at the double bottom for US of Stocks & Commodities, Traders.com Advantage, and
stocks in early 2016. When the final bottom came in Febru- Finance Magnates. He may be reached at markrivest@
ary 2016 there was relatively little money being allocated to gmail.com.
puts. Another interesting aspect on the chart was the increase
in put buying from early January 2015 to July 2015. During Further reading
this period the SPX went up. Perhaps some big money players Frost, A.J., and Robert Prechter [1985]. Elliott Wave Principle,
were loading up with put protection. New Classics Library.
Prechter, Robert Jr. [2003]. Beautiful Pictures, New Classics
Look beyond price Library.
Whatever market you trade, it’s imperative that you think Hadady, R. Earl [1983] Contrary Opinion, Key Books.
outside the one-dimension box. No trading system is perfect, Rivest Mark [2015]. “The Golden Section,” Traders.com
and losses will always occur, but they will occur far less and Advantage, www.traders.com, June 8.
in smaller amounts in relation to your market knowledge. If [2015] “Battle Line,” Traders.com Advantage, July
you are trading exclusively in the price dimension, learn as 17.
much as you can about the dimensions of time, momentum, and [2016] “Bullish Divergences Abound,” Traders.com
sentiment. This article is merely the tip of an iceberg. There’s Advantage, February 25.
a lot more information you can download into your brain. [2016]. “The Brexit Factor,” Traders.com Advantage,
Sometimes the signals from the four dimensions will be June 24.
weak or moderate. Occasionally, once or twice a year, power- [2016] “S&P 500 Near a Ceiling,” Traders.com Ad-
ful signals will emanate from all four dimensions. The SPX vantage, August 17.
bottom in February 2016 was one of those times. ‡www.stockcharts.com
• Momentum: Three oscillators with bullish diver-
gences.
• Sentiment: Double bullish divergence from put/call
ratio.
• Time: Seasonally bullish for US stocks February–
May.
• Price: Large break below the lower Bollinger Band.
Signals of this magnitude usually trigger multi-month moves.
May 2018 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities • 33
INTERVIEW
a couple of his classes. He eventually pushed me toward getting excited about types to understand which of the two
hired me to do some projects and that the stock market. camps you’re more likely to fall into.
led to me becoming director of research I’ve always viewed the stock market as I do have some breakout strategies I
for his company. I spent nine years there an interesting puzzle to try to solve, and trade, but they’re more difficult for me to
learning about quantitative research. even to this day, I still view it that way. trade than my mean-reversion strategies.
34 • May 2018 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities
Chart
Scan
Learn
Award-Winning Charting Professional Commentary
Trusted by thousands of online analysts, From daily blogs to weekly webinar shows,
StockCharts.com makes it easy to create StockCharts.com hosts free current market
high-quality technical charts with just a analysis and educational commentary from
few clicks. No software to install, just an some of the industry’s leading technical
internet connection and the browser of your analysts. Learn from the best to boost your
choice. Watch your charts automatically technical skills and financial prowess.
update in real-time and access them
on-the-go from any web-enabled device.
Customizable Scanning
Pring Murphy Hill
Fully customized to your technical
parameters, our world-class scan engine
allows you to instantly find the stocks that
meet your specific criteria. Plus, our technical
alerts notify you of key moves to help you
Swenlin Bowley Schnell
stay ahead of the curve.
and more!
Confirming A Pivot
Moving Average
Hammer Pivots
Combine a Japanese hammer candle with a moving average long swing trading entries.
line to confirm a pivot and generate a trading signal. You can see this pattern illustrated in the chart of BLDRS
Emerging Markets 50 ADR Index Fund (ADRE) in Figure 1.
O
by Ken Calhoun The low of the hammer is just above the 200-period simple
moving average (SMA) line. An entry following this ham-
ne of my favorite swing trading pivot patterns is mer continued up for two points. An alternative version of
to combine a classic hammer candlestick with a this pattern occurs when the hammer body is resting on the
major moving average support line. By combining a 200-period SMA line, after which you can enter if price
Japanese hammer candle with a Western technical continues upwards.
moving average line, you can capitalize on trading
technical signals generated by both approaches. Step-by-step action plan
As usual, the smartest technical trading approach is one in Here’s how you can start using hammers at 200-period SMA
which you use at least two signals to confirm an entry, which lines to confirm pivots when swing trading:
this month’s strategy provides. When using this technique, it
is easiest to see the signal using a 90-day daily candlestick Step 1: Look for charts in which a hammer occurs follow-
chart. You can use this pattern to initiate new long positions ing a downtrend that is resting on a 200 SMA line, as seen
on the day following the hammer, or to cover shorts. in Figure 1.
Swing Trading Pivot Signals Step 2: Set your buy stop order to enter $0.50 above the
A common problem when trading pivots is to erroneously high of the hammer (in this example, that would be $43.50
trade a weak bounce that does not continue upward much + $0.50 = $44). You do not enter on the day the hammer is
after entering a long position. That is why my primary trading being formed, but rather on a day following the hammer (up
style is to trade breakouts in preexisting uptrends. However, to three days after the hammer is seen).
when you see a hammer appear slightly above or at a major
moving average line, this particular pivot often works out for Step 3: Your exit target is the prior high on a 90-day candle
chart; in this example, that would
be $49.
Figure 1: Swing Trading Pivots with 200-period Simple Moving Average. A pivot long signal was Western trading world by my long-
generated after the hammer confirmed support at a major moving average line. time colleague Steve Nison.
38 • May 2018 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities
TRADING ON MOMENTUM
inTerview I use AmiBroker to run scans every at a time helps to smooth your overall
Continued from page 37 night. I have a semi-automated system equity curve. You also don’t know when
that runs on AmiBroker and identifies one of your strategies is going to break,
to be in. So it’s good to have a plan to the trades I will be getting out of, the and this way you don’t have all your
understand what to do if something like trades I should be in, and the trades I’ll money on that one strategy if it breaks.
that happens. be getting into the next day. AmiBroker Trading conceptually different strate-
Here’s an example of something that is a powerful product. I always suggest it gies helps to smooth your equity curve
happened to me recently. Most of my to people if they’re looking for a back- and keep it less volatile. That’s why I love
trades are automatically—or nearly testing platform. trading on the short side. It’s psychologi-
automatically—placed every night, and cally difficult for most traders but it does
for some reason, a couple of my trades What do you mostly trade? present opportunities.
did not get executed. The trade never hap- I mostly trade US stocks. I focus on I would encourage traders who are
pened or the order never got placed. the Russell 3000 stocks. The rest would starting out to try just two strategies.
So I had to go through the exercise of be exchange traded funds (ETFs). When you find your first strategy, trade
what my plan is when I’m not in a trade only half your capital using that strategy.
that I’m supposed to be in. For trades Do you have multiple strategies that you Keep the other half in cash. Maybe you
that I miss, my plan says to get into them use concurrently in your portfolio? can figure out a second strategy that’s
as soon as possible with a market order Yes, I think it’s important to trade mul- not highly correlated to your first one.
during market hours. This is not the time tiple strategies. For example, I am trading And if you can come up with four or five
to play daytrader. That’s my general rule. an S&P 100 mean-reversion strategy, a strategies, that’s a good number.
But these types of mistakes are out of Russell 3000 mean-reversion strategy, a I know people who trade 20, 30, 40, or
your control and you need to know what Russell 3000 breakout strategy, a Russell 100 strategies, but you need to have quite
you’re going to do. Trying to make it up 3000 short mean-reversion strategy, an a bit of money to be trading that many
on the fly is usually when you’ll make ETF short strategy, ETF mean-reversion strategies. For the average person, trading
a bad decision or do something wrong. strategy, a trend-following ETF strategy, three to four strategies is reasonable.
That was my personal experience and and a trend-following volatility strategy.
also from watching a couple of other I think I’m trading about eight strategies Thank you for speaking with us.
traders who tried to make it up on the right now.
fly. They usually ended up making a bad Further reading
situation even worse. Why is it important to trade multiple Alvarez Quant Trading, http://alvar-
strategies? ezquanttrading.com/blog
So preparing for any situation reduces Part of it depends on your capital or
the possibility of making erratic how much time you’ve got. You never
decisions. How do you pick stocks know when one strategy is not going to
to trade? work well. So having multiple strategies
May 2018 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities • 39
Continued from page 7 changes, for example, from questions arise. Thank you for taking
rank 4 to rank 1 (and if it’s the the time to read my article, and wishing
ETF is below the moving average (and fourth-best momentum strategy you all the best.
sell, presumably, using the rule opposite being pursued), sell.
A (see above), 2) You buy and sell on b. MA position change: If price Editor: Thomas Bulkowski is a Contrib-
crossovers. That is, buy when the prior is below its MA, it’s a signal uting Writer to Stocks & Commodities
quarter is below the MA and this quarter to sell. and the author of several books on tech-
is above the MA, and sell on the transi- nical analysis and pattern recognition.
4. As for the results for Figure 3, thank
tion from above to below, or 3) Test the Readers will find his article “Get More
you for your suggestion. I have the
reverse—buy on a crossover from above Value Using A Trading Checklist” in
data and will organize it and send
to below and sell on the cross from below this issue.
you the results as they become
to above.
available.
Finally, on page 25, upper-left column, ARTICLE CODE AT TRADERS.COM
5. As far as “moving average strate-
you write for Figure 3 that “The results Editor,
gies” versus “momentum strate-
show that using a simple moving average I have not logged in to Traders.com for
gies,” here, I specifically meant
as a filter can potentially reduce volatility a while but have the need to do so now.
momentum strategies. Figure 3
and MaxDD for most of the momentum Where would I locate the NinjaTrader
contains the fourth-ranked momen-
strategies” [my italics]. However, Figure code downloads, which are mentioned
tum strategy specifically in order to
3 pertains to only one momentum strat- in some of the articles?
illustrate how performing a moving
egy (rank4). Perhaps you meant “moving Ken
average filter could refine results and
average strategies” instead of “momen-
lower volatility. Figure 4 illustrates
tum strategies.” Please clarify. Article code is located in one of two
how a moving average filter overall
Let me finish by writing that I enjoyed places:
reduces volatility with regard to
your article and analysis. Thanks for
an average of all nine momentum 1. The Article Code section of our
sharing. I hope to read more from you
strategies, hence arriving at the ob- Subscribers’ Area:
in the future.
servation you have pointed out. This http://technical.traders.com/sub/
Tom Bulkowski
has also been corroborated in the codeYearList.asp
data calculation when I compared 2. The Traders’ Tips section of each
Author Marisa Yang replies:
performance before and after MA for issue, most easily accessed from the
Thank you for your questions regarding
each momentum strategy; I have not back-issue archive here:
my article. My answers to each question
included this data because it strays http://technical.traders.com/con-
follow, numbered 1 to 5.
from the focus of the article, which tent/backissuearchive.asp
1. Concerning MaxDD, you have asked is momentum strategies.
If you are looking for a particular code
a really good question here; thank
I hope my clarifications leave you set and cannot find it, please let us know
you for giving me the opportunity
with more answers than questions! and we will help you locate it.
to clarify. In Figure 1 in my article,
However, please let me know if more
theoretically, we should take the
lowest closing price of each quarter
to calculate MaxDD. However, for
simplification of computation, we
took the lowest annual return or
sum of consecutive loss of returns
to calculate MaxDD. Sneak preview... Coming soon!
2. Regarding Figure 3, it stems from
data unavailability. Since the
earliest available data starts from A Technical Method For Rating Stocks & resistance, this time with price trend, trend
December 1998, strictly speaking, by Markos Katsanos channels, Andrews pitchfork, and applying a
Is it possible to create a stock-rating system stop-loss.
the first MA10 data should be March
using multiple indicators or other technical
2001. Thus, for quarters in 2000, I Five Big Dan Zanger Money-Making
criteria? If so, how does it compare with
took advantage of the available data analyst ratings? Patterns
in the calculations. by Matt Blackman
3. Regarding a sell rule: You sell the The V-Trade, Part 4 Chart patterns and volume—that’s all well-
position if BOTH of the following by Sylvain Vervoort known stock trader Dan Zanger uses. Here
conditions are satisfied: In this fourth part of a multi-part series, we are five chart patterns he uses to recognize
continue the discussion of passive support potential home runs.
a. Ranking change: If the ranking
40 • May 2018 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities
BollingerBands.com adds Weekly
Market Timing Reports
BollingerBands.com now offers a
weekly collection of market timing
charts in addition to its free educational
materials, articles, and videos about us-
ing Bollinger Bands. The market timing
charts provide a pictorial view of market
action intended to be helpful for market Bookmap
timing. The Market Timing Report was
initially only available to subscribers of
Harmonic Pattern Collection It connects to Nasdaq Totalview full
The Bollinger Bands Letter, but market have been added, and the PRZ has been market depth data via Devexperts.
timing charts are now available to all updated to include more relevant zone The ability to compare current and
site visitors, while commentary for lines as well as terminal bar identifica- historical liquidity in the market became
the charts is provided with a Bollinger tion. Two new patterns (Gartley 886 and available with the support of historical
Bands Letter subscription. There are Deep Crab) have been added as well as market depth data for any instrument
currently 21 charts in the package with several new supporting indicators such as subscription. Devexperts provides a
more to come. The charts are divided HSI Arrows, RSI Bamm, Amplified RSI, dxFeed orderbook charting service for
into several sections based on various Pi Phi Bands, and Volume Spike. Bookmap, specially designed to mini-
major indexes. The Harmonic Pattern Collection is mize bandwidth requirements for heavy
The Market Timing Report is pub- endorsed by Scott Carney of Harmon- FOD data delivery used for visualization.
lished weekly. Also included are clas- icTrader.com, who will use it for live Connectivity to the GDAX exchange
sic market-timing indicators such as trading and for creating educational enables the trading of digital currencies
the advance-decline line, the high-low webinars and videos. such as bitcoin and Etherium.
index, and several volatility indicators. The licensing options for Harmonic www.bookmap.com, bookmap.dxfeed.com
A usage guide that explains the charts Pattern Collection have been expanded
is provided. so the user has a choice of three product STOCKCHARTS’ CHARTCON
John Bollinger developed Bollinger tiers. A 30-day trial is available. & StockCharts TV
Bands in the early 1980s. Traders use www.sr-analyst.com, StockCharts.com announced its online
the bands to help assess expected price www.sr-analyst.com/page_hpc.html streaming live conference, ChartCon
action in the markets. Bollinger Bands 2018, to take place August 10–11, 2018.
are offered on most financial charting Bookmap Version 7 Trading The theme is “Reducing Risk in Un-
software and websites. Platform charted Waters.” The conference will
Bookmap, a visualization and trading offer two days of investing education
platform for US equities, futures, and from experts, and commentary from
digital currencies, and Devexperts, de- leading chartists. The cost of registration
velopers of retail and institutional trading is $299. A limited number of seats will
platforms and providers of cloud-based be available for in-person attendees, with
financial data infrastructure, announced the option to also make a reservation for
the release of Bookmap version 7 trad-
ing platform. Continued on page 56
Bookmap’s data visualization offers
depth-of-market transparency. The
www.BollingerBands.com platform’s heatmap allows traders to
monitor the auction, and to observe
Harmonic Pattern Collection and interpret the evolution of the order
Divergence Software, Inc. has released book, the market microstructure, and
a major update to Harmonic Pattern the volume traded. Users can execute
Collection. Harmonic Pattern Collec- trades directly from a chart, and can trade
tion works with all securities and all futures, stocks, and digital currencies
bar intervals available in eSignal. The simultaneously. In addition, Bookmap
new version is faster, more efficient, and includes advanced order flow analytics,
finds more tradable patterns than prior indicators, and automated strategies.
versions. The pattern engine has been Bookmap version 7 seeks to offer
completely reworked as has the watch- the user a unique way to visualize the
list/scanner interface. Targets and stops dynamic in the order book on the fly.
As
in 2017. In 2017, more than 50 store chains filed for Chapter 11
by Leslie N. Masonson bankruptcy protection including Toys “R” Us, The Limited,
Sports Authority, Wet Seal, Radio Shack, Payless Shoes, Gander
investors and shoppers, we’re familiar Mountain, and Gymboree, among others. Unfortunately, 2018
with the world of retailing. Of course, may be another record year for store closings.
department stores, specialty retailers, The major impetus to the demise of the retail store has been
ART: VESTORPIXELSTAR/SHUTTERSTOCK
and malls were the rage in the 1970s to the change in consumer tastes for different merchandise, avail-
early 2000s. In those earlier years, names ability of multiple methods of delivering the goods, and the
like Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company, F.W. Woolworth demise of foot traffic in decaying malls. This decline was in no
Company, Montgomery Ward, Bradlees, Caldor, Inc., and small part due to the phenomenal success of Internet shopping
Jamesway were familiar stores in the Northeast that are no with mighty Amazon.com Inc. (AMZN) taking center stage
longer around. Currently, a few retail stores are still competing along with other well-run online retailers. Surviving retailers
but the question is how long they will last as brick-and-mortar need to make sure that their Internet presence is substantial
42 • May 2018 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities
WHY TRADE ETFS?
off-loaded to third-party retailers who resell the goods. US companies. VanEck Vectors Retail ETF RTH
For investors and traders looking to put some money to work Its top three Direxion Daily Retail Bull 3X Shares RETL
in the retail space investing in ETFs rather than individual holdings were PowerShares Dynamic Retail PMR
equities, their choices are limited to a handful of diverse BBY (5.95% First Trust NASDAQ Retail ETF FTXD
retail ETFs. Retail is considered a subset of the consumer of assets), KR
Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF XLY
discretionary (a.k.a. consumer cyclicals) sector. This sector (5.70 %) a n d
FIGURE 1: RETAIL ETFs. The ETFs reviewed in this
focuses on industries such as retailing, automobiles, apparel, COST (5.09%). article are listed here with their tickers. Note that RETL
leisure, restaurants, and media. Typical companies include This ETF has is a 3X leverage bull.
AMZN, Walt Disney (DIS), Home Depot (HD), and Comcast the lowest XTF
(CMCSA). rating of 0.7 (10 is the highest) of the group, which is based
The other consumer sector is called consumer staples or on a number of components explained on the xtf.com website.
noncyclicals. This sector encompasses companies that develop It also had the third-highest expense ratio of 0.63%, and the
and produce consumer goods and services, including food, next-to-lowest AUM at $11 million with minimal daily trad-
drugs, beverages, and tobacco products. Typical compa- ing volume of 2,054 shares. PMR, a custom-weighted ETF,
nies include Procter & Gamble, Coca-Cola, Philip Morris, had the second-worst performance over three and five years,
Walmart, Costco Wholesale, CVS Health Corporation, and of -3.17% and 50.6%, respectively. PMR uses an enhanced
Colgate-Palmolive. strategy that evaluates price and earnings momentum, quality,
Using xtf.com, I researched retail ETFs and compared their management action, and value.
key characteristics. I found a great many differences in the Overall, this ETF has not accumulated a large asset base,
ETF composition (top holdings), focus, performance, yield, which is surprising as it was the first one in its category, and
trading volume, and AUM. I reviewed six ETFs (Figure 1) its performance has also been lacking. The large-cap focus
and compared them against the well-known XLY (Consumer or their custom weighting may be the reasons for the less
Discretionary Select Sector SPDR fund). None of these ETFs than stellar performance.
exactly matches XLY in composition, but that is the closest
I could come to a similar universe. XLY is 99.6% correlated SPDR S&P Retail ETF (XRT)
to other similar sector funds such as Vanguard’s Consumer XRT’s inception was mid-2006. This equally weighted ETF
Discretionary ETF (VCR), and 98.1% correlated to Fidelity’s garnered $541 million in AUM, which is the highest among
MSCI Consumer Discretionary ETF (FDIS). the six retail ETFs evaluated. XRT is composed of 88%
As Figure 2 indicates, XLY was introduced in 1998, as consumer cyclicals, and 12% consumer noncyclicals. And
one of the original nine SPDR Select funds. And its market the two largest categories of stocks were specialty retail-
cap of $13 billion makes it the behemoth of the consumer ing, which accounted for 55% of its assets, and Internet and
discretionary space. Its top three holdings are AMZN direct marketing, accounting for 19%. The two largest-cap
(19.54%), HD (7.36%), and CMCSA (6.26%). Almost 88% of components were 30% small-cap and 29% micro-cap, with
its holdings are large-cap names with 27% in the Internet and 99% US companies. Its top three holdings were SFLY (1.91%
direct marketing space, and 17% in specialty retailers. XLY of assets), OSTK (1.75%), and NFLX (1.74%).
has the lowest expense ratio at 0.14%
compared to the six ETFs reviewed, Category XRT IBUY RTH PMR RETL FTXD XLY
and the highest xtf.com rating of the XTF Rating 9.5 5.9 9.3 0.7 2.9 2.4 9.8
group at 9.8.
Expense Ratio 0.35% 0.65% 0.35% 0.63% 1.05% 0.60% 0.14%
PowerShares Dynamic Retail Market Cap $541M $216M $75M $11M $30M $1M $13B
(PMR) Avg. Daily Volume 5,324,264 65,529 14,213 2,054 79,899 1,079 5,169,295
The first retail ETF introduced was Annual Yield 1.48% 1.46% 1.09% 0.01% 1.58% 1.13%
PowerShares Dynamic Retail (PMR), Inception Date 06/19/2006 04/20/2016 12/20/2011 10/26/2005 07/14/2010 09/21/2016 12/16/1998
not XRT, which most investors would Avg. # of Components 89 40 26 30 60 49 84
have guessed. This ETF is composed of
51% consumer cyclicals and 36% con- Investment Metric rank 82% 76% 95% 34% 96% 92% 89%
sumer noncyclicals. And the two larg- Performance - 1 Year 6.12% 55.95% 25.10% 7.19% 2.89% 14.11% 0.26%
est categories of stocks were specialty Performance - 3 Years -1.50% 36.52% -3.17% 24.69% 22.94%
retailing, which accounted for 36% of its Performance - 5 Years 45.21% 127.02% 50.06% 290.68% 122.10%
assets, and hypermarkets accounting for FIGURE 2: COMPARISON OF RETAIL ETFs. These ETFs vary widely in their focus, number of holdings, per-
12%. The two largest-cap components formance data, and xtf.com rating.
best used for trades comprising minutes, hours, or a day or amount. EMTY has AUM of $14.28 million with a 0.65%
two, at most. expense ratio.
Interestingly, its performance over one year and three years, ProShares Long Online/Short Stores ETF (CLIX) provides a
2.89% and 22.69%, respectively, were weak and reasonable 100% long position in online and non-store channel companies,
compared to the nonleveraged ETFs; however, the five-year along with a 50% short position on physical store retailers. CLIX
performance of 291% was significantly better than any of the has AUM of $14.72 million with a 0.65% expense ratio.
other ETFs, including XLY by a factor of 2.3 to 1. However,
the volatility over that period was quite high, resulting in a Conclusion
roller-coaster ride. Its Sharpe ratio was 50.57% over three Buying retail ETFs provides an opportunity to make a bet on
years. This compares to 13.63% for XLY and 18.61% for XRT. a subsector of consumer discretionary companies. Retail stock
Figure 3 illustrates its performance since inception and wild performance going forward will be rocky as the landscape is
swings since 2015. changing quickly, and there will be a handful of winners and
Overall, investors/traders should not be holding this ETF many more losers. After reviewing the critical evaluation fac-
for years, as its performance can deteriorate very quickly in tors covered here, I have concluded that for most investors, the
a down-trending market due to the price reset. This ETF is plain-vanilla XLY sector fund is the ETF of choice. Moreover,
most suited for short-term traders, not investors. If you are XLY has a 22.66% position in AMZN with a 9.8 xtf.com rating
considering trading this ETF, then make sure to read the and significant AUM and trading volume. Other ETFs with
detailed information on the Direxion website, especially the more than 15% in AMZN include RTH, IYC, CNDF, FDIS and
explanation of compounding and daily reset, so you don’t get VCR. Check them out on xtf.com or if any are of interest.
involved in something you may not fully understand. For more speculative investors, RTH also has a concentrated
portfolio (25 issues) with a high stake in AMZN, but better
Figure 4 provides a comparison of the price performance performance than XLY over the three time periods reviewed.
of the four oldest retail ETFs (XLY, XRT, PMR, and RTH) For millennials and more aggressive investors with interest in
for the earliest common period of December 21, 2011 through the Internet, IBUY can be considered a big bet in the online
February 22, 2018. The chart clearly shows the exceptional retail area, which may turn out to be a tremendous opportunity
outperformance of XLY (195.21%) and RTH (186.61%) by a to cash in on the growth in Internet commerce. However, expect
factor of at least two. Although RETL (triple-leveraged) was a wild ride, especially if a bear market or major correction
not shown on this chart (because there was insufficient vertical occurs. That means that an exit strategy is needed to prevent
space), its performance during this same period was 670.23%, big losses. Whatever you decide to do, please make sure you
more than three times that of the two best performers. Of can afford the risk involved, understand exactly what you are
course, RETL exhibited huge volatility, as it was up by over investing in, and have a specific plan for exiting if the market
920% in early 2017, then dropped to only 400% in August heads south. Always check the website of the issuers of any
2018, then rising 890% by January 2018. It’s certainly not an ETF you are considering and obtain as much information as
ETF for other than the most aggressive traders. possible to make an objective decision.
//Create half dominant cycle Momentum F METASTOCK: MAY 2018 TRADERS’ TIPS CODE
Mom = Close - Close[RSILength - 1] ; John Ehlers’ article in this issue, “RocketRSI—A Solid Propel-
//SuperSmoother Filter
lant For Your Rocket Science Trading,” presents two varia-
Filt = c1 * ( Mom + Mom[1] ) tions on the standard RSI calculation. Here are the MetaStock
/ 2 + c2 * Filt[1] + c3 * Filt[2] ; formulas for these indicators:
//Accumulate "Closes Up" and "Closes Down"
MYRSI:
CU = 0 ;
CD = 0 ;
sml:= 8; {smooth length}
for count = 0 to RSILength -1
rsil:= 10; {RSI length}
begin
if Filt[count] - Filt[count + 1] > 0 then
{super smoother}
CU = CU + Filt[count] - Filt[count + 1] ;
a1:= Exp(-1.414 * 3.14159 / sml);
if Filt[count] - Filt[count + 1] < 0 then
b1:= 2*a1 * Cos(1.414*180 / sml);
CD = CD + Filt[count + 1] - Filt[count] ;
c2:= b1;
end ;
c3:= -a1 * a1;
c1:= 1 - c2 - c3;
if CU + CD <> 0 then
filt:= c1 * (C + Ref(C, -1))/2 + c2*PREV + c3*Ref(PREV,-1);
MyRSI = ( CU - CD ) / ( CU + CD ) ;
{RSI}
//Limit RocketRSI output to
change:= ROC(filt, 1, $);
//+/- 3 Standard Deviations
CU:= Sum(If(change > 0, change, 0), rsil);
iF MyRSI > .999 then
CD:= Sum(If(change < 0, Abs(change), 0), rsil);
MyRSI = .999 ;
denom:= If(CU+CD = 0, -1, CU+CD);
if MyRSI < -.999 then
If(denom=-1, 0, (CU-CD)/denom)
MyRSI = -.999 ;
—Eric Lippert
eSignal, an Interactive Data company
800 779-6555, www.eSignal.com
—William Golson
MetaStock Technical Support
www.metastock.com
Figure 3: WEALTH-LAB. This shows some typical long entries following spikes
below -2 standard deviations on a daily chart of Apple (AAPL).
F eSIGNAL: MAY 2018 TRADERS’ TIPS CODE
For this month’s Traders’ Tip, we’ve provided the study Rock-
etRSI.efs based on the article by John Ehlers in this issue,
“RocketRSI—A Solid Propellant For Your Rocket Science
Trading.” The study is designed to assist you in identifying
cyclic reversal points.
The study contains formula parameters that may be con-
figured through the edit chart window (right-click on the
chart and select “edit chart”). A sample chart is shown in
Figure 2.
To discuss this study or download a complete copy of the
Figure 4: WEALTH-LAB. Increasing the bars to hold parameter had the most vis-
formula code, please visit the members community section ible effect on the system’s net profit.
Figure 6: AMIBROKER. Here is a daily chart of the SPY (upper pane) with the
RocketRSI (lower pane), replicating a chart from Ehlers’ article in this issue. After moving the code given in the article to your pre-
ferred compiler and creating a DLL, you can insert the re-
Filt = IIR( Mom, 0.5 * c1, c2, 0.5 * c1, c3 ); sulting indicator as follows:
// Accumulate "Closes Up" and "Closes Down" 1. Select new indicator from the insert menu.
Diff = Ref( Filt, -1 ) - Filt;
2. Choose the External Program & Library Calls category.
Up = Max( Diff, 0 ); 3. Select the appropriate external DLL call indicator.
Dn = Max( -Diff, 0 ); 4. Set up the parameters to match your DLL.
CU = Sum( Up, RSILength ); 5. Select the finished button.
CD = Sum( Dn, RSILength );
Users of NeuroShell Trader can go to the Stocks & Com-
MyRSI = ( CU - CD ) / ( CU + CD );
modities section of the NeuroShell Trader free technical
MyRSI = Ref( MyRSI, - RSILength + 1 ); support website to download a copy of this or any previous
Traders’ Tips.
// Limit RocketRSI output to +/- 3 Standard Deviations
A sample chart is shown in Figure 7.
MyRSI = Min( 0.999, MyRSI ); —Marge Sherald, Ward Systems Group, Inc.
MyRSI = Max( -0.999, MyRSI ); 301 662-7950, sales@wardsystems.com
www.neuroshell.com
// Apply Fisher Transform to establish Gaussian Probability
Distribution
RocketRSI = .5 * Log( ( 1 + MyRSI ) / ( 1 - MyRSI ) );
'SmoothLength = 8
'RSILength = 10
If CurrentBar - 1 Then
a1 = Exp(-1.414*3.14159 / (SmoothLength))
b1 = 2*a1*Cos(DegToRad(1.414*180 / (SmoothLength)))
c2 = b1
c3 = -a1*a1
c1 = 1 - c2 - c3
End If
Filt = c1*(Close + Close[1]) / 2 + c2*Filt[1] + c3*Filt[2]
CU = 0 Figure 10: quantacula. Here, the RocketRSI model is applied to Intel Corpora-
CD = 0 tion historical data.
For count = 0 To RSILength -1
If Filt[count] - Filt[count + 1] > 0 Then
CU = CU + Filt[count] - Filt[count + 1]
End If
If Filt[count] - Filt[count + 1] < 0 Then
CD = CD + Filt[count + 1] - Filt[count] F Quantacula Studio: MAY 2018 TRADERS’ TIPS CODE
End If
Next We added John Ehlers’ RocketRSI indicator (described in
If CU + CD <> 0 Then his article in this issue, “RocketRSI—A Solid Propellant For
myRSI = (CU - CD) / (CU + CD) Your Rocket Science Trading”) to our free TASC Extensions
End If
If myRSI > 0.999 Then myRSI = 0.999 package for Quantacula that you can obtain by clicking our
If myRSI < -0.999 Then myRSI = -0.999 marketplace link at www.quantacula.com.
RocketRSI = 0.5*Log((1+myRSI) / (1 - myRSI)) Once the extension is installed, you will see the RocketRSI
End Function
'--------------------------------------------------------------- among the other indicators adapted from previous Traders’
Sub Ehlers_RocketRSI_IND(SmoothLength, RSILength) Tips the next time you launch Quantacula Studio.
Dim MyRSI You can now use RocketRSI anywhere in the product that
MyRSI = RocketRSI(SmoothLength,RSILength)
plot1(MyRSI) accepts an indicator input, for example, the building block
plot2(0) model builder. We built a simple model by dragging and
End Sub dropping the following building blocks:
'----------------------------------------------------------------
Figure 11: NINJATRADER. Here, the RocketRSI and MyRSI indicators are shown
on a daily SPY chart. FIGURE 12: TRADE NAVIGATOR. This shows the RocketRSI indicator on LULU.
T
rading liquidity is often over- very high volumes. The greatest number three-year period. Thus, all numbers in
looked as a key technical of dots indicates the greatest activity; this column have an equal dollar value.
measurement in the analysis futures with one or no dots show little Columns indicating percent margin
and selection of commodity activity and are therefore less desirable and effective percent margin provide
futures. The following explains how to for speculators. a helpful comparison for traders who
read the futures liquidity chart pub- Courtesy of CBOT wish to place their margin money ef-
lished by Technical Analysis of Stocks ficiently. The effective percent margin
& Commodities every month. is determined by dividing the margin
value ($) by the three-year price range of
Commodity futures contract dollar value, and then multiply-
The futures liquidity chart shown be- ing by one hundred.
low is intended to rank publicly traded
futures contracts in order of liquidity. Stocks
Relative contract liquidity is indicated Trading liquidity has a significant ef-
by the number of dots on the right-hand fect on the change in price of a secu-
side of the chart. rity. Theoretically, trading activity can
This liquidity ranking is produced by serve as a proxy for trading liquidity
multiplying contract point value times All futures listed are weighted equally and equals the total volume for a given
the maximum conceivable price motion under “contracts to trade for equal dol- period expressed as a percentage of the
(based on the past three years’ historical lar profit.” This is done by multiplying total number of shares outstanding. This
data) times the contract’s open interest contract value times the maximum pos- value can be thought of as the turnover
times a factor (usually 1 to 4) for low or sible change in price observed in the last rate of a firm’s shares outstanding.
Jurik Research
TRADERS'
RESOURCE
TOP 10 VIEWED ADVISORY SERVICES
The information in Traders’ Resource is the most accurate at the time of posting and is subject to change. Because the vendors posting to Traders’ Resource are responsible for their own listing, Technical Analysis, Inc. declines any and all liability
for any representations made by the businesses and individuals listed. Nor can Technical Analysis, Inc. endorse any business or individual listed on Traders’ Resource. Technical Analysis, Inc. makes no warranties, express or implied, as to the
accuracy and reliability of claims herein. You agree to release Technical Analysis, Inc., together with its respective employees, agents, officers, directors and shareholders, from any and all liability and obligations whatsoever in connection with or
arising from your use of Traders’ Resource. If at any time you are not happy with the information posted to Traders’ Resource or object to any material within Traders’ Resource, your sole remedy is to cease using it. This list is updated frequently.
If you are aware of a business that should be listed, please email us at Editor@Traders.com.
T
by Thomas Bulkowski Then he rented a tiller to chew up weeds, work nutrients into
the soil, and shred my cable.
here are 10 types of people in the world: those who Yes, it ticked me off. I lost my Internet connection while I
understand binary and those who don’t. So goes the waited over a day for the phone company to drape a temporary
joke. In the trading world, there are two types of cable across three properties.
traders: those of us who use trading plans and those What did my neighbor say about all of this? That it wasn’t
who wonder why they can’t make money trading. his fault. And he’s a preacher, too. I expected honesty from
Perhaps that is an unfair assessment, and it’s not accurate him, not excuses. He said it was the phone company’s fault
anyway. But let’s talk about trading plans or checklists and because they didn’t bury the line deep enough. Since the line
how they can help you make money. You do want to make location was marked, that excuse didn’t work.
money, don’t you? Imagine that I was daytrading a short-side position at the
ART: IBREAKSTOCK/SHUTTERSTOCK
A trading plan is a document that outlines contingency plans time. The downed connection would have caused me a bundle
for each trade. Let me give you an example. My neighbor of stress and perhaps a chunk of money.
wanted to put down sod on his front lawn. I spoke to him about Think this is an isolated incident? It’s not. I heard of it hap-
this when he started and warned of a fiber optic telephone pening to a prominent money manager. A good trading plan
cable from my house that ran through his lawn to a junction should address these kind of situations.
box down the street.
60 • May 2018 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities
charting
Trading checklist
A good trading plan covers all contingencies of what might
happen during a trade. I approach my trading differently. I use A good trading plan covers all
a checklist. I programmed my computer to spit out a template
that I fill in. Yes, I will want to cover all contingencies so I’m contingencies of what might
not sucking my thumb while watching a trade go south. I’ll happen during a trade.
know what action to take if automated tools (such as stop-loss
orders) are not in place.
I have found the following items useful over my nearly 40
years of terrorizing the markets.
If other stocks in the same industry are struggling, and
• What are the market conditions? I use the S&P 500
I plan to sell a weak stock, I’ve noticed that some tend to
index and check the close-to-close price change over the
peak about six weeks before the earnings report (midway
prior one, two, and six months. A simple up or down
through the quarter). I haven’t tested this theory to see if
reading tells me what the various length trends are. Once
it’s really true, so be cautious using the information.
you have enough trades, you can sort the three spread-
sheet columns and determine what market conditions • What is happening on the longer time scale? Most of
work best for your trading style. my trades use the daily charts. So I’ll switch to the weekly
For example, if all three periods are down, are you or even the monthly chart to check the stock. Where is
making a bottom-fishing trade with the expectation support and resistance? That will help me determine
that the market trend will change, or do you like losing when to sell at a target, or buy more if it gets cheap. If
money? the stock tumbles, it will help me gauge how big the loss
could get. That’s important to know ahead of the event,
• What are the industry conditions? I want to know
when you’re not under pressure of a falling stock.
how other stocks in the same industry are doing, so I
always check as many as I can find. How many stocks • Did the stock recently dead-cat bounce? A dead-cat
are trending up or falling? Does it look like their trends bounce occurs when the stock drops at least 15% in one
will continue or have they reached pronounced support session, often dropping between 25% and 40%. The stock
or resistance? will bottom in a few days before bouncing up and then
For the industry trend, I count the number of stocks collapsing again. The stock will eventually bottom 15%
higher or lower over the last one, two, and six months. The to 30% below the pre-bounce low.
results suggest how strong the trend is and improves my Here’s the kicker. A second dead-cat bounce will
confidence that the trend will continue. If you compare occur 26% of the time within three months of the first
the percentage your trades make over the three periods one, and 38% of the time within six months. My rule is
and compare that to the percentage made using market to avoid buying a stock showing a dead-cat bounce for
conditions, you’ll be able to tell if industry or market at least six months unless I can justify it (and then only
conditions are more important to your wallet or purse. taking a tiny position).
Once you know the answer, wait for those same condi-
• Log the trade details. Date, time executed, time scale
tions to appear the next time and trade like crazy.
used (one- or five-minute scale, daily chart, and so on).
• Is the stock trending? I look for support and resistance For daytraders, you may find that trading in the morning
levels. I check the price trend over the prior one, two, gives better results than the afternoon (or the reverse),
and six months (using the same close-to-close price which is why having this information is valuable. Are
change benchmark). Again, sort performance by the you a better trader using the one-, two-, or five-minute
three periods to determine what conditions work best scales?
for your trading style. Longer-term traders may find that using market-on-
open or close orders gives better fills than trying to
• When is the next earnings announcement? I refrain
daytrade the entry or exit.
from buying a stock within three weeks of the an-
You will also want to log and track these two de-
nouncement. That means I’m on the sidelines during
tails:
any earnings announcements or pre-announcements.
Experience taught me this lesson. {{ Trade type. Is this a daytrade, a swing trade, posi-
Yes, I’ll keep a long-term holding during an earnings tion trade, or buy & hold investment? Sort your
announcement. It doesn’t make much sense to sell just spreadsheet trades by this field and see where you
because company earnings may or may not disappoint are most profitable. You will discover where your
that quarter. If it disappoints, I may use the dip to add strengths are and where you need to spend more
more to a position in a quality stock, because I know time developing your skills. You may find that the
most stocks will eventually recover. fewer trades you place, the more you make. That is,
May 2018 • Technical Analysis of Stocks & Commodities • 61
do you make more money daytrading or investing performance, or highlight that you need to improve
(buy & hold), or something in between? your stock-picking.
You may wish to track the hold time, too. If the • Buy reason. I’ll write a paragraph outlining my reasons
stock doesn’t move within x days/weeks/months, for the trade and what I think the stock will do after I buy.
then look for a better opportunity. You may wish to For longer-term holdings, I’ll jot down how frequently
jot down when the stock peaked during the trade (by insiders are buying or selling the stock, what analysts
looking back, after the trade ends). That informa- think of the company and industry trends, as well as
tion will allow you to determine the optimum hold some fundamental factors, like capital expenditures
time. After making enough trades, you may see a (cap-ex: decreasing is best for year-ahead performance),
trend you can capitalize on. Paired with market, debt level (some is good, too much is bad), and payout
industry, and stock trends already discussed, you ratio (for utility stocks to cover the dividend).
may be able to tell when a trade will work and how
long it’ll likely take before it peaks.
{{ Position size. Are you over-sizing the trade and Closing position
getting nervous about it? That happened to me with By building a spreadsheet contain-
a short-sale daytrade on Intel (INTC). After the ing many of the items discussed in
market closed, I planned the next day’s trade and this article, you can use it to help
decided to short 2,000 shares. Later that night, I tune your performance and make
became nervous. Something was bugging me about the big bucks. Then maybe, just
it. So I cut the size back to 1,000 shares and traded maybe, you can retire from your
it the next day. Turned out I lost money on the trade, day job as I did at 36.
so it was good that I cut my position size.
My computer tells me the correct position size, Stocks & Commodities Contributing Writer Thomas
so I don’t have to crunch the numbers myself. It Bulkowski (who may be reached via email at tbul@hotmail.
scales the trade according to my portfolio size, com) is a private investor and trader with almost 40 years of
market and stock volatility. You can perform the market experience and considered by many to be a leading
same function with a spreadsheet. Just plug in the expert on chart patterns. He is the author of several books
formula that works best for you. including Chart Patterns: After The Buy; Getting Started In
Chart Patterns; and the Evolution Of A Trader trilogy. His
• Scaling in and out. Will you add more shares to the trade? website and blog, www.thepatternsite.com, have more than
Will you sell portions of it? At what price or under what 700 articles of free information dedicated to price pattern
conditions will you take action? I know a daytrader who research.
sells a portion of his shares as soon as the first trade of
the day becomes profitable. Why? Because it helps his Further reading
mental outlook for the remainder of the day. I wonder Bulkowski, Thomas [2016]. Chart Patterns: After The Buy,
what happens if his first trade is a loss. Hmm. Wiley.
• Stop-loss price and target. For short-term trades, you’ll [2005]. Encyclopedia Of Chart Patterns, 2d. ed.,
want to know when to get out both if the trade performs Wiley.
as expected (exit price) and if it doesn’t (stop-loss price). [2014]. Getting Started In Chart Patterns, 2d. ed.,
It’s okay to use a mental stop for daytrades when the Wiley.
action is too quick to place a formal stop-loss order
with your broker. Just be sure to adhere to the mental
stop price.
You should know the stop-loss price and target exit
for all daytrades before placing them.
For longer-term trades, concentrate on where price is
likely to stall at overhead resistance or find underlying
support. If the trade moves in the adverse direction, how
far will it move? To put it another way, at what price will
the market be saying you have made a mistake?
• Relative strength. Is the price performance of the stock
climbing at a rate faster than the general market? I use
that tool to help beat the annual market performance
with my stock picks. Pruning your holdings after a pe-
riodic review (monthly? quarterly? yearly?) can boost
2 years............ 149
• Complete access to WorkingMoney.com $ 99
The information you need to invest smartly and successfully.
3 years............ 199
• Access to Traders.com Advantage $ 99
Insights, tips and techniques that can help you trade smarter.
5 years..........
$
29999
That’s around $5 a month!