Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Author:
Pedro L Moro, MD, MPH
Section Editor:
Peter F Weller, MD, MACP
Deputy Editor:
Elinor L Baron, MD, DTMH
Contributor Disclosures
All topics are updated as new evidence becomes available and our peer review
process is complete.
Literature review current through: Apr 2018. | This topic last updated: Nov 21,
2017.
The clinical manifestations and diagnosis of cystic and alveolar echinococcal infection
will be reviewed here. The epidemiology, treatment, and prevention of echinococcosis
are discussed separately. (See "Epidemiology and control of
echinococcosis" and "Treatment of echinococcosis".)
The clinical presentation of E. granulosus infection depends upon the site of the cysts
and their size. Small and/or calcified cysts may remain asymptomatic indefinitely.
However, symptoms due to mass effect within organs, obstruction of blood or lymphatic
flow, or complications such as rupture or secondary bacterial infections can result.
Cysts typically increase in diameter at a rate of one to five centimeters per year.
However, cyst growth rates and time courses are highly variable [1,2]. Hydatid cysts
may be found in almost any site of the body, either from primary inoculation or via
secondary spread. The liver is affected in approximately two-thirds of patients, the
lungs in approximately 25 percent, and other organs including the brain, muscle,
kidneys, bone, heart, and pancreas in a small proportion of patients. Single-organ
involvement occurs in 85 to 90 percent of patients with E. granulosus infection, and
only one cyst is observed in more than 70 percent of cases (image 1).
E. granulosus cysts can rupture into the biliary tree and produce biliary colic,
obstructive jaundice, cholangitis, or pancreatitis. (See "Endoscopic diagnosis and
management of biliary parasitosis".)
Pressure or mass effects on the bile ducts, portal and hepatic veins, or on the inferior
vena cava can result in cholestasis, portal hypertension, venous obstruction, or the
Budd-Chiari syndrome. (See "Etiology of the Budd-Chiari syndrome".)
Liver cysts can also rupture into the peritoneum, causing peritonitis, or
transdiaphragmatically into the pleural space or bronchial tree, causing pulmonary
hydatidosis or a bronchial fistula. Secondary bacterial infection of the cysts can result in
liver abscesses. (See "Pyogenic liver abscess".)
Cysts can break or develop secondary bacterial infection. The presence of these
complications changes the clinical presentation, either by causing new symptoms or by
increasing the severity of existing symptoms. The principal complication is cyst rupture,
with spilling of cyst material containing fragments of larval tissue and protoscolices into
the bronchial tree or the pleural cavity. Bronchial tree involvement can lead to cough,
chest pain, hemoptysis, or emesis; pleural cavity involvement can cause
pneumothorax, pleural effusion, or empyema. Secondary bacterial infection of the cyst
can manifest as a pulmonary abscess with poorly defined margins [6-8].
Approximately 60 percent of pulmonary hydatid disease affects the right lung, and 50 to
60 percent of cases involve the lower lobes [9]. Multiple cysts are common.
Approximately 20 percent of patients with lung cysts also have liver cysts [10]. The
ratio of lung to liver involvement is higher in children than in adults [10].
Other organs — Involvement of organs outside of the liver or lung is unusual but can
lead to significant morbidity and mortality.
●Cysts in the kidney can cause hematuria or flank pain [15]. Immune complex-
mediated disease, glomerulonephritis leading to the nephrotic syndrome, and
secondary amyloidosis have also been described [16,17].
●Bone cysts are usually asymptomatic until a pathologic fracture develops; the
spine, pelvis, and long bones are most frequently affected [18].
Outcome — The outcome of infection varies with the stage of the disease. One study
reported on the long-term outcome of 33 patients with asymptomatic liver hydatid cysts
[1]. The natural history of infection was variable. Approximately 15 percent of patients
had undergone surgery 10 to 12 years after the initial diagnosis. Among patients who
did not undergo surgery, 75 percent remained asymptomatic; 57 percent did not have a
change in the size of the cyst by imaging.
Calcification usually requires 5 to 10 years to develop and occurs most commonly with
hepatic cysts but rarely with pulmonary or bone cysts. Total calcification of the cyst wall
suggests that the cyst may be nonviable.
Extrahepatic primary disease is very rare (1 percent of cases). Multiorgan disease was
described in 13 percent of cases in one series in which metacestodes involved the
lungs, spleen, or brain in addition to the liver [23]. Immunodeficiency, such as HIV or
transplantation, may accelerate the manifestations of alveolar echinococcosis [24].
If left untreated, more than 90 percent of patients will die within 10 years of the onset of
clinical symptoms, and virtually 100 percent will die by 15 years [25]. Since treatment
with albendazole has been introduced, the prognosis has improved considerably. Of
117 patients from France who underwent long-term follow-up, the actuarial survival rate
was 88 percent [26]. Life expectancy has improved, and patients undergoing radical
treatment have a better outcome now than 40 years ago. In Switzerland in 1970, the
life expectancy for an average 54-year-old patient with echinococcosis was estimated
to be reduced by 18 and 21 years for men and women, respectively; by 2005, life
expectancy was reduced by approximately 3.5 and 2.6 years for men and women,
respectively [26].
Plain radiography may demonstrate calcification within a cyst but cannot detect
uncalcified cysts so is not adequate for definitive diagnostic evaluation.
Shifting the patient's position during ultrasonography may demonstrate "hydatid sand,"
which consists predominantly of hooklets and scolexes from the protoscolices. Hydatid
disease is probable in the setting of hydatid sand, inner cyst wall infoldings, and
separation of the hydatid membrane from the wall of the cyst observed on ultrasound
[31].
Several other classification systems are based upon ultrasound appearance (image 2):
●The Gharbi classification divides cysts into five types [36]. Type I cysts consist of
pure fluid; type II have a fluid collection with a split wall; type III cysts contain
daughter cysts (with or without degenerated solid material); type IV have a
heterogeneous echo pattern; and type V have a calcified wall [36].
WHO categories CE1 and CE2 are active cysts. Type CE1 is unilocular, and type CE2
is multilocular with daughter cysts (figure 1). Class CE3 consists of cysts that are
thought to be degenerating (transitional group). There are two types of CE3: CE3a,
featuring the "water-lily" sign for floating membranes, and CE3b, which is
predominantly solid with daughter cysts. Establishing whether daughter cysts are
present is important for guiding treatment. In addition, nuclear magnetic resonance has
demonstrated that CE3a and CE3b have different metabolic characteristics [37].
Classes CE4 and CE5 are considered inactive. By ultrasonography, they are
echogenic with increasing degrees of calcification and are nearly always nonviable.
It is important to establish whether daughter cysts (cysts that have involuted from the
wall and reside within the larger cyst) are present and to distinguish them from brood
capsules, which are attached to the wall of the larger cyst. This distinction is important
for guiding treatment.
Lung cysts may be single or multiple, usually do not calcify, rarely lead to daughter cyst
formation, and may contain air if the cyst has ruptured.
Computed tomography — Many reports suggest that CT has higher overall sensitivity
than ultrasonography (95 to 100 percent) [29,30,38]. CT is the best mode for
determining the number, size, and anatomic location of the cysts and is better than
ultrasound for detection of extrahepatic cysts. CT may also be used for monitoring
lesions during therapy and to detect recurrences (image 1) [39].
Magnetic resonance imaging — MRI has no major advantage over CT for evaluation
of abdominal or pulmonary hydatid cysts, except in defining changes in the intra- and
extrahepatic venous system [42]. MRI may delineate the cyst capsule better than CT
and may be better at diagnosing complications, particularly for cysts with infection or
biliary communication. However, MRI is usually not required and, in most instances, is
not cost effective [43-45].
Both CT and MRI are useful in diagnosing echinococcal infection in other sites such as
in the brain [46].
Serologic and antigen assays — Serology is useful for primary diagnosis and for
follow-up after treatment [23,47,48]. Antibody detection is more sensitive than antigen
detection for diagnosis of E. granulosus [23].
●Complement fixation
●Indirect immunofluorescence
●Latex agglutination
●Radioimmunoassay (RIA)
●Immunoblot
The sensitivity and specificity of a number of the serologic tests have been compared
(table 2). ELISA appears to be the most sensitive and specific of the available assays
[49-54]:
●One study compared eight serologic tests among 131 patients with E.
granulosus infection [52]. IgG ELISA was the most sensitive (94 percent) and
specific (99 percent) for the majority of cyst locations.
●One report compared six different serologic tests for the diagnosis of cystic
hydatid disease among 243 patients with surgically confirmed infection [53]. The
two ELISA tests gave identical results, with a sensitivity of 89 percent for liver
cysts and 78 percent for lung cysts. In the 39 patients with false-negative results,
the use of immunoblotting only increased the yield by 8 percent; ELIEDA did not
identify any additional cases.
The methods most frequently employed for initial screening tests (using crude antigens
such as hydatid fluid or protoscolex extracts) are ELISA and IHA. Confirmatory tests
using specific antigens can then be performed, such as immunoelectrophoresis and
immunoblotting [51]. Additional tests using recombinant or purified species-specific
antigens may also be useful diagnosis [55].
Simple, heat-stable, inexpensive tests, such as hydatid antigen dot immunoassays, are
often used for field testing and population screening [56]. The dot-ELISA has a
reported sensitivity of 88 to 96 percent and a specificity of 90 to 98 percent [57-59].
Two major E. granulosus antigens utilized in serologic testing include antigen 5 and
antigen B:
●Antigen 5 is a major parasite antigen found on the inner aspect of the germinal
layer, brood capsule, and protoscolices. Only a few studies have assessed the
value of tests based on recombinant antigen 5, which has relatively low specificity,
although it is used quite extensively for diagnosis in clinical practice [51].
The sensitivity of these antigens in ELISA assays is 60 to 90 percent and the specificity
is usually approximately 90 percent [63]. The sensitivity in immunoblot and gel diffusion
assays is approximately 90 percent with a specificity of 97 to 100 percent [62,64]. One
study demonstrated that the immunoblot with the antigen B–rich fraction was positive in
92 percent of patients with E. granulosus but was also positive in 79 percent of patients
with E. multilocularis [65]. No cross-reactivity was observed with sera from patients with
other parasitic diseases, malignancies, or healthy controls.
Clinical factors — A negative serologic test generally does not rule out
echinococcosis. There is no consistent correlation between serologic results and the
number or size of cysts [49]. In general, liver cysts elicit an antibody response more
frequently than lung cysts. Overall, approximately 85 to 95 percent of liver cysts and 65
percent of lung cysts are associated with positive serology, although this varies with the
specific serologic test used and cyst activity [50]. Brain, eye, and splenic cysts often do
not produce detectable antibodies, whereas bone cysts frequently are associated with
positive serology. Serology is less likely to be positive with cysts at any site if the cysts
are intact, calcified, or nonviable.
The likelihood of false-negative results is variable depending on the site of the lesion
and the integrity and viability of the cyst. Antigen-antibody complexes that "mop up" all
antibodies may lead to false-negative reactions. The sensitivity of serologic assays is
often assessed in human patients whose cysts are not intact, leading to high rates of
positive serology [73]. The sensitivity of the same assays are much lower in human
cases detected as part of epidemiologic studies (eg, ultrasound surveys) [2,67]. False-
positive reactions are more likely in the presence of other helminth infections (such
as Taenia saginata, Taenia solium, and particularly neurocysticercosis), cancer, and
immune disorders.
Obstruction of the inferior vena cava or of the portal venous system may be evident,
which may be more easily appreciated on MRI. Lung, brain, and bone lesions may also
be detected.
Serology — Serologic tests are more reliable for diagnosis of E. multilocularis infection
than for E. granulosus infection; sensitivity and specificity rates are 95 to 100 percent
[80]. A specific E. multilocularis antigen such as the affinity purified Em2 antigen from
AE metacestodes is often used; the Em2-ELISA can discriminate between E.
granulosus and E. multilocularis in 95 percent of cases. Serology usually remains
positive indefinitely; following complete surgical resection, serology may normalize
within a few years [81]. The Em2-ELISA frequently becomes negative within four years
of surgery and becomes positive again in the setting of a recurrence [80,82,83]. An
Em2plus-ELISA assay uses additional species-specific antigens; it has sensitivity and
specificity of 97 and 99 percent, respectively, and is also useful for monitoring
recurrence following surgical resection [84-86]. These tests may not be readily
available and may be found only in specialized centers.
ELISA and immunoblot studies using Em 18, an 18-kD protoscolex antigen, are
sensitive and highly species specific [65,87-91]. The antigen is also useful for
differentiating between active and inactive infection and is useful for follow-up of
patients on treatment [86,87,92,93].
Clinical recurrence is frequently associated with rising serologic titers. IgG1 and IgG4
antibodies are the most sensitive isotypes for monitoring success of therapy [87].
●Simple benign cyst – Patients with symptomatic liver cyst may present with
abdominal discomfort, pain, or nausea. Liver cysts are distinguished
from Echinococcus by ultrasonography. (See "Diagnosis and management of
cystic lesions of the liver".)
●Cirrhosis – Patients with cirrhosis may have anorexia, weight loss, weakness,
and fatigue; patients with alveolar Echinococcus may have malaise, weight loss,
and right upper quadrant discomfort. The two are distinguished based on
radiographic imaging and laboratory data. (See "Cirrhosis in adults: Etiologies,
clinical manifestations, and diagnosis".)
SUMMARY