Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
DONNABELLE
PEDRAJAS, et al.
GR. 192993; 11 August 2014, THIRD DIVISION, (Peralta, J.)
ISSUE:
RULING:
The Court states that a death of a seaman during the term of his
employment makes the employer liable to the former’s heirs for death
compensation benefits. However, this rule is not absolute. The employer may be
In the case at bar, although both the NBI and PNP stated that they cannot
rule out any indications of homicide, such opinions are inconclusive as evidence
because an opinion should not be construed as a judgment. Moreover, the Court
declares that it is more logical to rely on the findings and observations of the Italian
Medical Examiner because they were made after he personally and carefully
examined the place immediately after the incident. The medical examiner had the
luxury of investigating the crime scene. Since there is conclusive evidence presented
by Wallem Maritime Services that Hernani committed suicide, the latter’s heirs are
not entitled to any compensation or benefits.