Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
FREEMASONS’ HALL
96 GEORGE STREET
EDINBURGH, EH2 3DH
January 2018
Before entering the Hall, Members must present their tickets of membership which are
not transferable under pain of forfeiture. They must be properly clothed and should
appear in their own regalia.
David M Begg
Grand Secretary
Grand Office-bearers, Members of Grand Committee and Grand Stewards are requested to wear Morning Dress.
BUSINESS
1. Presents – Reports of Proceedings of Sister Grand Lodges.
5. Minute of the Board of Benevolence and Masonic Homes. Pages 134 to 139 of the
Proceedings.
b) That Brother Douglas Trevor Philand being appointed Provincial Grand Master of
Argyll and The Isles effect from 14 June 2018. Page 160 of the Proceedings.
d) That there should be placed on record a cordial vote of thanks to the following
Brethren for their service to the Scottish Craft during their term of their
Commissions: Brother T. Wilson Aitken, Provincial Grand Master of Kilwinning,
Brother Kenneth R. Johnson, Provincial Grand Master of Argyll and The Isles and
Brother Joseph A.O. Ogunfuwa, District Grand Master of Nigeria. Page 161 of the
Proceedings.
7. That a Petition be granted to issue a Charter for a new Lodge in the District of Lebanon,
under the name of Lodge Al Nour, No. 1847 (Page 151 of the Proceedings)
8. That a Petition be granted to issue a Charter for a new Lodge in the Province of East
Lothian and Berwickshire, under the name of Lodge Kajaki, No. 1848.
9. Realignment of Provinces, effective from 31st March 2018.
i) That the Province of Roxburgh, Peebles and Selkirk Shires be renamed the Provincial
Grand Lodge of The Scottish Borders.
ii) That the Province of East Lothian and Berwickshire be renamed The Provincial
Grand Lodge of East Lothian.
iii) That Lodges Dunse No. 23, St Ebbe, No. 70, St Luke, No. 132, Lodge St John, No.
280, The Lodge of Ercildoune, No. 1119 and Lodge Whiteadder, No. 1245 currently
within the Province of East Lothian, be incorporated under the Province of The
Scottish Borders.
10. Collection for the benefit of Scottish Masonic Benevolent Fund and the Scottish
Masonic Homes Fund.
Held in Freemasons’ Hall, Edinburgh on Thursday, the 26th day of October 2017.
Grand Lodge was opened in full form and with solemn prayer.
In Memoriam
BROTHER LOVERAIN JAMES WATT BEATT
Past Provincial Grand Master of Forfarshire
Died on 14th July 2017
Brethren, it is with great sadness that I have to report the death of a highly respected and
well-loved Brethren of our Craft namely:
120 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2017 _ 2018 No. 3
Brother LOVERAIN JAMES WATT BEATT, Past Provincial Grand Master of Forfarshire,
who died on 14th July 2017.
Brother Loverain, was born on the 1st September 1927 at the fit o'the Toon in Arbroath.
One of 4 children he attended Ladyloan Primary School, then Arbroath High School. On
leaving school he served his apprenticeship as a butcher, a trade that would serve him
all his working life.
He was called up for National Service in 1946 and was stationed in an Army Camp near
Dover, promoted to Sergeant and always maintained they got the wrong man. He met
Jean at a local dance and married her in 1947, after completing his National Service they
returned to Arbroath.
Lovie as he was known returned to working as a butcher, and worked for various butchers
in Arbroath and Carnoustie finishing his working life at the age of 70.
A family man, Lovie and Jean were married for 64 years, and were Great, Great
Grandparents. Illness' took its toll in 1985 when he almost lost his life, but fought back
to good health.
When his wife Jean became ill, he nursed her for many years until she passed away in
2012.
A great passion for Golf, and as a keen golfer he was Captain of both Arbroath Golf Club,
and Arbroath Artisan Golf Club, having won the Provincial Golf competition on many
occasions.
Loverain James Watt Beatt was initiated into Lodge St Thomas of Aberbrothock, No. 40
on the 27th December 1945. He served as Master of Lodge St Thomas of Aberbrothock,
No. 40 from 1963-65, and was a Master who had his own way of doing things. He would
never stick for a word, he would just use another. He was the only Master who could start
at the 1st degree final charge go into the Fellow Craft charge, then the Master Masons,
and finish in the 1st and not many new he had done it. He received his Distinguished
Members Certificate from the Lodge in 1998 for his untiring efforts and received a 70
years diploma in January 2016. Loverain Beatt Past Master was a regular attender of his
Mother Lodge up until last Christmas.
In 1973 he was Commissioned as Substitute Provincial Grand Master of Forfarshire, and
served the Province of Forfarshire faithfully and well as Provincial Grand Master from
1987-92. Lovie change the way Provincial approached Freemasonry in Forfarshire when
he walked in to a Lodge if he didn't know you he soon did by introducing himself as "I'm
Lovie, what's your name".
Loverain Beatt was much loved and admired by all who knew him, work colleagues,
and Freemasons alike. He will be sadly missed by the Brethren of Lodge St Thomas of
Aberbrothock, No. 40, and the Provincial Grand Lodge of Forfarshire.
He was educated at Bathgate Public School and at Bathgate Academy. Following service
in the Royal Air Force during the Second World War he joined Bathgate Cooperative
Society as a Van Salesman for many years. He then became an Insurance Agent with the
Cooperative Insurance Society until he retired in 1986.
He was married to Mary in 1947 and they were blessed with two daughters, Margaret
and Wilma, five grandchildren and eight great grandchildren.
There were two major influences in 1949 that were to play an important part in his and
Mary’s life. He was Initiated in Lodge Torphichen Kilwinning, No. 13 on 19th April 1949
and thereafter Passed and Raised on 3rd May 1949 and 17th May 1949 respectively. In the
same year he was ordained as an Elder within Bathgate High Church and served in this
capacity for 61 years, until he had his first stroke.
Brother Thomson served as Master in his Mother Lodge from 1961 to 1962 and thereafter
he served the Lodge as Assistant Secretary from 1963 to 1964, as Secretary from 1964 to
1972 and in the Office of Chaplain for 50 plus years.
He was commissioned as Depute Provincial Grand Master of Linlithgowshire by Brother
Alexander Fraser, Provincial Grand Master, in 1982 and thereafter he was appointed
as Provincial Grand Master of Linlithgowshire in 1987, an office he served with great
dedication and commitment until 1992.
His service to Freemasonry within Lodge Torphichen Kilwinning, No. 13, within the
Province of Linlithgowshire and within many other related Orders was exemplary, was
greatly appreciated and applauded by everyone who worked with him during these
years.
In addition to his service as an Elder, Jim and his wife Mary were the Leaders within the
Church Youth Club for many years and there is no doubt that their service to the Youth
Club was greatly appreciated by many from within the Community of Bathgate.
Unfortunately, Mary fell and broke both arms. So, Jim became “Head Cook and Bottle
Washer”. This was the start of his culinary skills, cooking meals and baking pancakes,
scones and cakes and, if that was not enough, he tried his hand at making marmalade.
Clearly, he and Mary could only eat so many pancakes, scones and cakes and, this being
the case, he was soon selling his produce at the close of Lodge meetings for Lodge Funds.
This developed very quickly and as a major Fund- Raising Venture, prior to leaving
home for Lodge Meetings, he would fill the boot of his car with his produce and sell it to
Brethren at the conclusion of the meetings, the profit from which was donated to Lodge
Funds and many Charities including Children’s Hospice Association Scotland.
His health deteriorated to such an extent that he was moved into Meadowvale Nursing
Home where he was cared for until his death on 15th July 2017.
His funeral within Bathgate High Church and his burial at Boghead Cemetery in Bathgate
were well attended by many who had the privilege of sharing part of their life with him.
He will be sadly missed by his many friends. However, we can all remember Jim Thomson
as a very special person, a highly committed and devoted Freemason and a loyal friend
to many.
But above all, he will be missed by his wife Mary, his daughters Margaret and Wilma,
his grandchildren and his great grandchildren and to them we do extend our sincere
condolences and blessing
122 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2017 _ 2018 No. 3
Brother James Pender Thomson was highly respected in all walks of life and we mourn
his passing to the Grand Lodge above.
Brother ASPI KHURSHEDJI BYRAMJI, District Grand Master of India, who died on 28th
July 2017.
Brother Aspi started his working career with the New India Assurance Co. Ltd. in 1962
when he was employed as a Claims Inspector for Automobiles. He obtained a Surveyor’s
license in the same year and in a career spanning 35 years, he retired in 1997 as a
Divisional Manager who was in charge of the Regional Office in Mumbai and two branch
offices in Pune and Jamshedpur.
Having a heart leaning towards service to others, he was an Active Member of the Lions
Club of East Bombay District and a Past President of the Club.
Aspi K. Byramji, was initiated in Lodge Forman No. 1066 on 5th February, 1970. After
having served in various capacities in the Lodge, he was elected to serve as Master in
December 1974.
Lodge Forman honored him for his services to the Lodge and to Masonry by awarding
him a Distinguished Service Membership in April 2007. During his Masonic career, he
has held almost all the Active Offices in the District and was ultimately Commissioned as
Depute District Grand Master in 2001, and then Commissioned as District Grand Master
2007 and re-commissioned in 2012 for a further five years.
The Grand Lodge of Scotland conferred on him the rank of Hon. Senior Grand Warden
in 2012.
During his term of office as District Grand Master, he led the District with great distinction.
He was due to demit office as District Grand Master at this October communication.
Brother PETER IRVING STUART, Past Provincial Grand Master of Dumfriesshire, who
died on 4th September 2017.
Brother Irving was born on the 21st July 1925 and died peacefully in The Thomas Hope
Hospital, Langholm, on 4th September 2017 aged 92 years.
He attended school at Langholm Academy, leaving at 15. His first job was an apprenticeship
with a local grocer. When the Second World War started, he signed up for the Royal Navy
and saw service in the Arctic Convoys and later in Far East. On leaving the Royal Navy,
he took up employment at the Local Foundry and was casting various objects including
drain covers. He then moved to C.A.D. Longtown as a bomb disposal expert.
By this time Irving was married and our own War Office at home was a little apprehensive
about his work with bombs, so he left and started work in the textile industry where he
remained until his retirement.
Irving married Martha in 1952, and they had one son Michael. He was father-in-law to
Sharon, the grandfather of Mhairi and Callum and great grandfather of Ellie.
The Langholm Parish Church was very important to Irving, and he was an Elder of the
Church and was Beadle for approximately 40 years before retiring.
He had many interest and hobbies. In his youth he played Rugby, mainly on the wing.
26th October 2017 GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND 123
After that, he took up bowling, and also gardening where he won many trophies at the
local shows.
However his main joy outwith Masonry was singing. He sang in the local Church Choir,
for the local Operatic Society, at Burns Suppers and of course the Master’s Song at
Installations.
For many years he sang a solo at the annual Divine Service held by Lodge Eskdale
Kilwinning No. 107. In the local Operatic Society he played the lead tenor in many of the
productions. His email address was “kokolangholm”, which shows his affection for the
many lead comic roles he played in the G&S productions.
Irving joined Masonry in 1966 in Lodge Eskdale Kilwinning No. 107, being initiated on 6th
October 1966. He became RWM of Lodge Eskdale Kilwinning No. 107 in 1974.
He joined the Provincial Grand Lodge of Dumfriesshire in 1976 and never looked back.
Starting as a Provincial Grand Steward 1976 he rose to Provincial Grand Architect in 1989,
and then became Substitute Provincial Grand Master in 1990-95 and Deputy Provincial
Grand Master 1995-2000. Following this he was appointed Provincial Grand Master for
the period 2000-2005, being installed by the Grand Master Mason Brother Lord Burton.
Tragedy struck fourteen days after the Installation when his wife Martha died, but he
carried on and completed his Commission. He continued to support his successors until
he became too ill.
He also held high office in other orders, including being Depute Grand Superintendent
for the Provincial Grand Chapter of Dumfriesshire for 1998 to 2003.
He will be greatly missed, not only by the members of his Mother Lodge, but by the
whole of the Province of Dumfriesshire.
We also have present the Grand Master of South Carolina, Brother Michael Smith, the
Grand Master of Kansas Brother Brandon Cole Presley, and the Past Grand Master of
Massachusetts, Brother Donald Laliberte. I would also like to welcome Brother the Rev.
David Taylor who today is celebrating his 60th Wedding Anniversary”.
I also Installed Brother Errol Charles Alberga as District Grand Master of Jamaica; Brother
Rajendra Rabindranth Bagwat as District Grand Master in Trinidad and Tobago and
Grenada; Brother Brigadier Edwards Orin Collins as District Grand Master of Guyana.
The Minute of the meeting of Grand Committee held on 7th September 2016 was
approved.
The Grand Secretary intimated that following the death of the Depute Grand Master
of Renfrewshire West, the late Brother John Keith, a further ballot of Lodges had been
taken and all Lodges and the Provinces had recommended Brother Robert McIntyre,
Provincial Grand Secretary, be appointed as Provincial Grand Master. Accordingly,
Brother McIntyre was recommended for appointment, as from 1st February 2018. Grand
Secretary intimated that this proposal be put to Grand Lodge this afternoon.
The “2000 Club” Draw was made by the Grand Master Mason, the winners being:-
Grand Secretary intimated that the BBC were intending to produce a documentary
about the Grand Lodge of Scotland and how they hold an important place in the national
Psyche of Scotland. The program would cover from the history of the Craft in Scotland,
to the present day. Some filming work would be done at the Installation and Festival of
St. Andrew, although not in a tyled temple, and Brethren who do not wish to be filmed
may stand aside.
The Grand Master Mason thanked the Brethren for their confidence in him and said how
proud he was to represent Scottish Freemasonry all over the world.
The Grand Master Mason enquired whether the list of Office-bearers listed on pages 82
and 83 of the Proceedings were approved, and there after declared that the list of Office-
bearers and Stewards as listed on pages and of the Proceedings were elected to serve for
the Year 2017/18.
126 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2017 _ 2018 No. 3
FREEMASONS’ HALL
Over the years we have made continued improvements to the building and regrettably
for a building this size, and enjoying the protected status imposed upon us by Historic
Scotland we have a duty to keep the building in a first-class condition.
Recently we have been having some trouble with our sound system here in the Main
Hall and it has been for repair. The principle reason has been a case of too many sound
technicians, (or those who think they are sound technicians), fiddling with the pre-set
controls.
The fire door exits onto Rose Street Lane at the rear of the building, will soon be replaced,
which will improve security and comply with Fire, Health and Building Control regulations.
We will also be installing new bag racks on either side of the side doors of Grand Hall to
better enable the Brethren to store their coats and bags prior to the meetings, although
this will not be done until after the Installation Meeting.
This year we again rented out the building for during the Edinburgh Festival. There was
a new company renting the building with a slightly different programme and judging by
the queues along George Street, it seems to have been a great success. The additional
rental income we receive is most welcome but importantly the building is open to the
public which helps to reduce the mystery and suspicion that still surrounds our work. An
integral part of the success of the Festival Lets is Brother Clark Wilson, our Grand Tyler
and Hall-keeper, who is greatly respected by the production companies, and an ever-
present attendance during the shows to supervise our facility.
This year we have, and are, experiencing a significant increase number of visitors to
the museum and the building in general, from visiting Overseas Masons. We are very
fortunate to have a well-versed band of volunteer guides to assist in showing visitors the
building. The enthusiasm for their task is greatly appreciated, by all of us at Grand Lodge.
Our staff are trained to the highest possible standards and supplement this with online
courses, to bring themselves to exceed the requirements of the Care Commission. There
is little doubt that the Care Sector is becoming overburdened with rules and regulations
and whilst we will never detract from our self-imposed standards, we must recognise
that the residential care sector will always be difficult.
We have continued to support Prostate Scotland and to date have collected almost
£380,000 for this most deserving of Charities, - of note was the fantastic zip - wire across
the Clyde that collected a total of £120,000 in one afternoon, a magnificent effort. We
128 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2017 _ 2018 No. 3
have agreed to continue to support this charity until 2020. The Charity continually
advertises and gives credit to Grand Lodge for our assistance.
Over the last few years we have seen a significant drop in Brethren and their families
requesting benevolent assistance. We introduced a few years ago an Almoners Guide to
Benevolence, and this has been a very useful tool in defining when benevolent assistance
may be required. However, Society has to a large extent changed, and given the amount
of grants and levels of assistance now available externally, it may be necessary to
question whether our definition of Masonic Benevolence is still appropriate. The Charity
Commissioner has recently questioned our definition of Masonic Benevolence in that
if Masonic Benevolence means that the funds are only for the relief of Freemasons and
their families then this would be at odds with the definition of charitable purposes in
the 2005 Act. We have received legal advice that if Masonic Benevolence was meant
to cover general charitable relief then there would be no need to amend our bye-laws.
Essentially, the charity Commission will not allow us to build up substantial funds in our
Benevolent Funds, if they are not being used for charitable purposes. This is a complicated
area, which may require some basic changes to the manner in which we manage all our
benevolent activities.
OTHER MATTERS
The Administration Committee are presently reviewing the basic structure of Grand
Committee, as it is recognised that there are too many on that Committee to effectively
manage the Craft. Proposals have been received to effectively reduce the numbers on
that Committee. Proposals to change the Constitution and Laws will be required to be
drafted; however, as the decision has been made to incorporate all the necessary changes
in one ‘hit’ the necessary Notices of Motion will take some time to implement. One of the
principle reasons for changing the number in Grand Committee will be to assist in setting
up various working groups that can be drawn from ALL the membership, not just from the
present Grand Committee. In this connection I would request any Brother who has specific
skills, tasks or expertise - to register them with Grand Secretary who will be able to compile
a list of Brethren that we can call on to assist when forming specific working parties.
26th October 2017 GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND 129
COLLECTION FOR SCOTTISH MASONIC BENEVOLENT FUND, AND THE SCOTTISH HOMES
FUND
The collection raised £265.88
(ii) The Grand Secretary on behalf of the Brethren thanked the Grand Master
Mason for his chairmanship of the Communication. The Brethren responded
with acclamation.
Held in Freemasons’ Hall, Edinburgh on Thursday, the 30th day of November 2017.
Grand Lodge was opened in full form and with solemn prayer.
“I would like to welcome this afternoon Most Worshipful Brother Zahnd, Grand Master
of Switzerland heading a deputation from the Grand Lodge of Switzerland. We also have
considerable number of deputations from our overseas districts, which include the Far
East, Ghana, Gibraltar, India, Lebanon, a large deputation from the Middle East, and from
Sierra Leone and the Gambia, The Bahamas, Nigeria, Zambia, and Panama.
There are many other distinguished guests from around the world with us and I extend
to all present the sincere greetings of the Grand Lodge of Scotland and I very much hope
that we are all going to have a most enjoyable day.”
The Senior Grand Warden, Junior Grand Warden, Grand Director of Ceremonies, Senior
Grand Deacon, Junior Grand Deacon and Grand Sword-bearer retired to escort into Grand
Lodge, Most Worshipful Brother Tor Evenson, Sovereign Grand Master of the Norwegian
Order of Freemasons who was presented to and welcomed by Brother Archibald D Orr
Ewing, Bart., Installing Grand Master.
132 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2017 _ 2018 No. 3
Brother Archibald D Orr Ewing, Bart., Right Worshipful Installing Grand Master, said;-
"Brethren, at the Regular Communication held on 27th October 2016, Brother Charles
lain Robert Wolrige Gordon of Esslemont unanimously was elected Grand Master Mason
for the ensuing twelve months. I would now call on the Grand Master Mason's Escort
to retire from Grand Hall in order to escort the Grand Master Mason-elect into Grand
Lodge."
The Escort, consisting of the Grand Director of Ceremonies, Grand Chaplains, Grand
Deacons, Grand Jeweller, Grand Sword-bearer, Grand Standard-bearers, President and
Vice President of Grand Stewards and two Grand Stewards, retired accordingly.
During the Processional Entry of the Grand Master Mason-elect and his Escort into Grand
Lodge, the Brethren sang Psalm, 121, the Consecration Vessels being deposited. The
Grand Master Mason-elect was presented to the Installing Grand Master, who addressed
him according to ancient custom.
Having signified his assent to the Charges and Regulations, the Grand Master Mason
elect took the oath de ideli administraione officii, after which the Brethren sang the
Choral Blessing, "The Lord Bless Thee and Keep Thee". On being invested with the Chain
and Jewel of his Office, the Grand Master Mason was conducted to the Throne of Grand
Lodge by the Installing Grand Master, and thereafter the Grand Director of Ceremonies
proclaimed Brother Charles lain Robert Wolrige Gordon of Esslemont, Most Worshipful
Grand Master Mason in due form.
The Grand Master Mason then appointed Brother Ewan Rutherford, as Depute Grand
Master and Brother Hugh Clelland as Substitute Grand Master.
The Grand Office-bearers for the coming year were then installed by Brother Ewan
Rutherford, Depute Grand Master and Brother Hugh Clelland, Substitute Grand Master:-
After the singing of Psalm 24, verses 7 to 10, the Senior Grand Chaplain offered the
Prayer of Dedication.
“I now present to you the Emblem of Authority and I extend to you and to the Grand
Office-bearers every good wish for the forthcoming year."
Brother Charles lain Robert Wolrige Gordon of Esslemont, Most Worshipful Grand Master
Mason, replied as follows:-
"Right Worshipful Installing Grand Master, Brother Archibald D Orr Ewing, Bart., I would
like to thank you for again installing myself, and Brother Ewan Rutherford and Brother
Hugh Clelland for installing the Grand Lodge Office-bearers this afternoon”.
COLLECTION
The collection amounting to £1,027.50 was uplifted.
GRAND TREASURER – Brothers Douglas Blue, Lodge St Vigean, No. 101; David Russell,
Lodge Otago Kilwinning, No. 417; Norman David Millar, Lodge Granite Union, No. 480;
William Charles Waite, Lodge Kenmuir, No. 570; Thomas Forgan Menzies Trotter, Lodge
Firth of Clyde, No. 626; Hamish Keir, Lodge Seaforth, No. 854; Said Selim Hobeika, Lodge
Peace, No. 908; Bomi Shavak Billimoria, Lodge Forman, No. 1066;
GRAND ALMONER – Brothers Keith Aikenhead, Lodge St Mark, No. 1313; Christopher
Robert George Parcells, Lodge Clarendon Kilwinning, No. 1427; James Glancy MacLean,
Lodge Friendship, No. 1712;
SENIOR GRAND CHAPLAIN – Brothers Phillip Davies, Lodge Biggar Free Operative,
No. 167; Ian James Bain, Lodge Ugie, No. 939;
134 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2017 _ 2018 No. 3
SENIOR GRAND DEACON – Brothers William McIntyre Shields Semple, United Lodge
of Dunkeld, No. 14; Neil Johnston Stephen, Lodge St John Operative, No. 92; Stephen
Robert McConnachie, Lodge Royal Blue, No. 399; Stuart McCall, Lodge Burns St Mary,
No. 505; Brian William Hunter, Lodge Hilton St Andrew, No. 1220; David John Collings,
Lodge St Andrew, No. 1318; Yip Wing Kong, Lodge St Andrew, No. 1432; William Bell,
Lodge Cadder Freestone, No. 1584;
JUNIOR GRAND DEACON – Brothers James Slider Dorricott, Lodge Hamilton, No. 233;
Lindell Elon Nurse, Lodge Scotia, No. 340; Noshir Godrej Paghdiwalla, Lodge Rising Sun,
506; Christopher Hartley Moore, Lodge St John, No. 1072; John McIndoe, Lodge Bothwell
Brig, No. 1229; Stewart William Pollock, Lodge Far East Caledonian, No. 1274; John
Stuart Macleod, Tarbert, Tarbert Loch Fyne, No. 1306; Floyd Pemberton Taylor, Lodge
St Andrew, No. 1509; Jayraman Ramesh, Lodge Notwani, No. 1633; Anthony Ulysees
Bostwick, Lodge St Michael, No. 1634; Nicholas Colin Browne-Marke, Lodge The Earl of
Eglington and Winton; No. 1650;
GRAND ARCHITECT – Brothers Kenneth Kennedy Morrison, Greenock Kilwinning, No. 12;
James Barbour, St Mark’s Lodge at Glasgow, No. 102; John Syme, Lodge Paisley St Mirrins,
No. 129; Robert Victor Woodstock, Lodge Glenlyon, No. 346; Martin Gale Smillie, Burns
St Mary, No. 505; Lloyd George Barnett, Lodge St John, No. 623; George Edward Wilson,
Lodge Randolph, No. 776; George Bell, Lodge Paisley St James, No. 1116; Errol Lloyd
Wright, Lodge Clarendon Kilwinning, No. 1427;
GRAND JEWELLER – Brother George Findlay McGhee, The Union and Crown Lodge
Glasgow, No. 103;
GRAND BIBLE-BEARER – Brothers John Robb Paterson Shirran, Lodge St Machar, No.
319; Martin Selmar Willweber, Lodge Hiogo and Osaka, No.498; Dennis Allan, Lodge St
Mary’s, No. 1287; Foo Boon Fong, Lodge Pahang, No. 1589; Hubert George Bartholomew,
Lodge St Andrew, No. 1684;
ASSISTANT GRAND SECRETARY – Brothers Robert Easton, Lodge St John, No. 46;
John Hunter, The St Johns Operative Lodge, No. 347; Robert McIntyre, Lodge Firth of
Clyde, No. 626; Douglas Hamilton Buck, Lodge St Servanus, No. 771; William Gilmour,
Lodge St Clair of Balbeggie, No. 867; Donaldo Alejandro Branch W. Lodge Thistle, No.
1013; Heshan Peiris, Lodge Angoni, No. 1404; Leslie Swanson Mair, Lodge Loch Lomond,
No. 1483;
GRAND ORGANIST –Brother Gordon Thomas Kinniburgh, Lodge Bonhill and Alexandria
St Andrew’s Royal Arch, No. 321;
GRAND PIPER – Brother Colin Sidley, The Lodge of Fort William, No. 43; Devan Pillai,
Lodge Tullibardine in the East, No. 1118;
GRAND MARSHAL – Brothers Daniel Gordon Cuthbert, Lodge King Robert de Bruce, No.
304; Kersi Noshir Wadia, Lodge Rising Star of Western India, No. 342; Anil Christopher
Nair, Lodge St Andrew’s in the East, No. 343; William Sinclair, Lodge St Fergus, No. 466;
David Charles Horne Davidson, Lodge Golden Feather, No. 855; Ronald Miller, Lodge Kyle,
No. 1117; Chesley Jordon Saunders, Lodge St Andrew, No. 1139; William Boyd Vivian,
Lodge Hearts Content, No. 1275; Hughie Butt, Lodge Humber, No. 1475; James William
Smith, Lodge Tullibardine, No. 1484; Arne Luring, Lodge Unity, No. 1510; Pradip Kari,
Lodge Ruwenzori, No. 1652; Terence Fitzgerald, Lodge Herodom, No. 1768;
GRAND TYLER – Brother William Johnstone Beattie, The Hawick Lodge, No. 111;
The Grand Secretary reminded the Brethren who were attending the Festival of St
Andrew that buses were available, immediately outside Grand Lodge, for transportation
to and from the Edinburgh Corn Exchange.
Grand Lodge thereafter was closed in due form and with solemn prayer after which the
Brethren joined in singing the National Anthem.
The Brethren then proceeded to the Edinburgh Corn Exchange, Edinburgh for the
celebration of the Festival of Saint Andrew.
136 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2017 _ 2018 No. 3
14th December 2017 GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND 137
REPORT BY
BENEVOLENCE AND CARE COMMITTEE
be minimal, when the excess of the insurance policy had been taken into account, it had
not been worthwhile making a claim.
The Committee viewed a number of photographs and was pleased to note that the work
to repair a local secondary school in Fiji, which had been organized by Lodge Polynesia, No
562, was now nearing completion. The School had been damaged as a result of Cyclone
Winston and the Committee agreed that its repair was an excellent use of the grant of
£5,700 which had been awarded by Grand Lodge. A report and additional photographs
will be provided by the Lodge once the repair project has been completed.
After discussion, it was agreed that, for the health and safety of all, wall mounted
defibrillators would be installed in Freemasons' Hall. Brother Dr. Nicol had carried out
extensive investigation and the Committee was pleased to note that, after consultation
with the Chairman and Grand Almoner, suitable equipment had been purchased to
enable a wall mounted machine to be installed outside the Hallkeeper's office on the
ground floor and in the corridor outside the lower hall. It was considered that these may
also be beneficial in the Masonic Homes and the Homes and Charities Manager, whilst
noting the requirement to be mindful of the DNR instructions which are in place for
Residents, will seek guidance from the Care Inspectorate in this regard when the annual
inspections at the Homes are being carried out. The Homes and Charities Manager
confirmed that she will arrange for the supplier to provide training in the use of the
equipment in the New Year - presently there are a total of 11 persons who have agreed to
be trained comprising of Grand Lodge Staff, Supreme Council for Scotland Staff, Brother
Dr Nicol and individuals who are regularly in attendance at meetings etc. in the building.
Advice is awaited from the Royal Order of Scotland and the Supreme Grand Royal Arch
Chapter of Scotland, with whom Brother Dr Nicol has been in contact, as to whether they
would like to be represented at the training.
It was noted that repairs have commenced to 94A George Street (which is owned by the
Benevolent Fund of Grand Lodge) and will be completed by the end of November. These
will be paid for by the lessee of this part of the building in accordance with the terms of
the lease.
The Homes and Charities Manager gave an updated report on the former Day Centre
building at Bridge of Weir. It was confirmed that a protocol has been put in place
regarding the maintenance and upkeep of the building which is being followed by Staff
on site - this includes a detailed check being carried out by the handyman once per week
and a visual check of each room daily. The building remains part of the premises check
which is carried out monthly by the designated Health and Safety member of Staff on
site at the Home and cleaning Staff ensure that it is regularly cleaned. An appropriate
level of heating is being maintained in order to avoid damage to pipes etc. during the
winter months. In terms of the future use of the building, it was agreed that certain
activities, such as the provision of a lunch club or drop in centre for older people, could
be ruled out as a result of the rural location. Any care related facility, such as a respite
provision or an interim care provision, would require to be registered in accordance with
the current National Care Standards, which would result in modifications to the building
being required, however, advice will be sought from the Care Inspectorate in this regard -
the annual inspection is due shortly and guidance will be requested at that time. The sale
of the building and its grounds may be an option as is its rental. There is also a possibility
that it could be used to provide a holiday facility (without care) for Brethren and/or their
14th December 2017 GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND 139
dependents. A suggestion was also made in relation to using the building to provide a
creche - after investigation it can be confirmed that there are a number of local children's
nurseries which are registered with the care Inspectorate, many of which do not appear
to be at full capacity, so it is difficult to exactly establish what the likely demand would be.
In terms of the standards which are required to operate a children's nursery, it appears
that the building may be suitable but detailed advice would be needed should this be
considered to be a viable option.
It was noted that the mini bus has now been sold.
Two enquiries were made by the owners of properties bordering the land owned by
Grand Lodge at Dunblane regarding tree management. After consultation with, and
permission from, the Tree Officer at Stirling Council, appropriate tree pruning and
maintenance has been completed.
The Committee was delighted to note that a sum of approximately £389,000 had
now been donated to Prostate Scotland, by Scottish Freemasonry, since it became
Grand Lodge's nominated Charity in 2012. Further, it was reported that the decision to
recognise the positive and productive nature of Grand Lodge's partnership with Prostate
Scotland, and the joint benefits which have arisen therefrom, by extending the Charity's
status as Grand Lodge's nominated Charity until 2020, had received excellent feedback.
In considering the annual award it was agreed that a minimum of £10,000 be granted,
however, that there was scope to increase this amount in order to ensure that the total
donations reached £400,000. It was agreed that the Homes and Charities Manager
would liaise with the Chairman, Grand Almoner and Grand Secretary in this regard. It
was confirmed that the sum awarded would be presented to Prostate Scotland at the
Festival of Saint Andrew. The Autumn 2017 Prostate Scotland newsletter was tabled and
the Committee noted the article relating to the Charity's partnership with Grand Lodge.
The Homes and Charities Manager gave an updated report in relation to the discussions
between COSLA, the Scottish Government and Scottish Care (the umbrella body for
private and voluntary care providers in Scotland) regarding future commissioning
arrangements and the development of the 'Real Cost of Care Calculator' which have
been ongoing for some time. Whilst discussions are continuing and some progress has
been made, such progress is slower than anticipated. Presently, the situation remains
that those who require to have the cost of their care home fees subsidized by the state
continue to be under funded for the service being provided.
Brother David A. Reid gave an updated report in relation to the joint charitable venture
which is being arranged in conjunction with Poppy Scotland and the Widows Sons
Masonic Motorbikers in August 2018. An updated schedule for the event was tabled and
noted. Brother Reid confirmed that he had attended the meeting of provincial Grand
Masters and that the venture had been well received. It was reiterated that publicity, and
liaison with Police Scotland and Local Authorities, would be managed by Poppy Scotland
but that the content of any press releases would be jointly agreed. It was also reconfirmed
that the proposal to purchase and lay wreaths at the locations visited would be a matter
for the individual Provinces and Lodges concerned. The Committee agreed in principle to
a commemorative pin being commissioned for sale as a memento of the event and it was
noted that this would be produced by Poppy Scotland as the Charity had a designated
supplier for these items. It was further agreed that Brother Reid should continue to liaise
140 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2017 _ 2018 No. 3
with Provincial Grand Lodges, Poppy Scotland and the Homes and Charities Manager as
required and he confirmed that it was hoped to meet with Poppy Scotland shortly.
The Committee was pleased to note that 180 new members had joined the 2000 Club
and thanked all those who participated in this fund -raising venture for their involvement.
It was agreed to recommend to the Board that the following grant be awarded from the
General Relief Fund:
The sum of £2,000 to the Teapot Trust, towards the operation of the Charity, which
provides a national programme of art therapy and creative interventions in hospitals and
hospices, in order to enhance the wellbeing of chronically ill children, young people and
their families.
After discussion, it was agreed that it may be beneficial to adopt a more pro-active
stance in terms of awards to external Charities. It was agreed that each member of the
Committee would give consideration to this issue and would put forward the name of
a Charity, with an overview of the work which it does, which they felt to be worthy of
consideration for a grant at the next meeting. It was confirmed that any suggestions
would require to meet the criteria in relation to providing a service which is Scotland-
wide and being registered with the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator.
The Committee carried out its annual review of the Eligibility Scales for the calculation of
First-time and Annual Grants and agreed that no changes be made to the present figures.
The Homes and Charities Manager reported on issues relating to Standards, legislation
etc in relation to Grand Lodge benevolence and the operation of the Masonic Homes.
The Co-ordinators of the Friends of the Home Volunteer Groups reported as follows-
Sir James McKay House –
• The Summer outings have been greatly enjoyed and we are grateful once again
to the Brethren and ladies of the following Lodges - St John, No. 187, Peebles
Kilwinning, No. 24, St Baldred, No. 313, Torrie, No. 1141, and Blackridge, No. 1145.
• The Residents will make their annual visit to Lodge Liberton, No. 1201 shortly and
are very much looking forward to this.
• The Garden Fete next year will be held on Sunday, 5th August and will be organized
by the Province of Linlithgowshire.
• It was noted that the Provincial Grand Lodge of Linlithgowshire Almoners concert
will be held on 17th October 2018 and the Residents and Staff of the Home will
again be invited to attend what has become a traditional and much enjoyed event
in their calendar.
• The Christmas lunch will be held on Monday, 18th December. It is pleasing that
the usual entertainers will be present and there will also be pipers from Stewart's
Melville College to entertain the Residents and guests prior to the lunch.
• Brother Rev lain Ramsden reported that he is continuing to try and maintain the
provision of regular divine services at the Home although this is proving challenging.
• The Widows Sons are again visiting the Home for their very popular 'Santa Run'
which will take place on 2nd December.
14th December 2017 GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND 141
• The Committee was pleased to note that meetings of the Friends of the Home
Volunteer Group continue to be held involving representatives from the Provinces
of East Lothian and Berwickshire, Edinburgh, Fife and Kinross, Linlithgowshire and
Midlothian. Excellent suggestions have been made in regard to ways in which to
support the Residents and Staff going forward.
The Chairman reported, as follows, to the Committee relating to the review of the
Constitution and Laws -
Background -
It was agreed that a review of the Constitution and Laws would be carried out to identify
any alterations which required to be made to ensure that they remain fit for purpose.
Small groups of Brethren had been appointed to cover various sections of the Constitution
and Laws. In respect of the review of Laws relating to the Scottish Masonic Benevolent
Fund, the Scottish Masonic General Relief Fund and the Scottish Masonic Homes Fund,
those appointed were J.M. Marcus Humphrey of Dinnet, Thomas C. Smith and George
M. Preston.
Review Process -
An initial review meeting had taken place on 7th August at which J.M. Marcus Humphrey
of Dinnet and Thomas C. Smith were present together with Grand Secretary and the
Homes and Charities Manager. George M. Preston had been unable to attend on that
occasion.
Those present considered each of the following Laws on an individual basis -
• THE SCOTTISH MASONIC BENEVOLENT FUND LAWS 251-264
• THE SCOTTISH MASONIC GENERAL RELIEF FUND LAWS 265-271
• THE SCOTTISH MASONIC HOMES FUND LAWS 272-280
After discussion, certain alterations were made to certain of the abovementioned Laws
to reflect, for example -
• The criteria which is in place as per the Guidance for Almoners publication
• Current policy and practice
• Legislative considerations
• Requirements of external regulatory bodies such as the Office of the Scottish
Charity Regulator and the Care Inspectorate.
A further meeting took place on 4th October at which J.M. Marcus Humphrey of Dinnet,
Thomas C. Smith and George M. Preston were present were present together with
Grand Secretary and the Homes and Charities Manager. Representatives of Grand Lodge
Lawyers were also in attendance. Discussions at this meeting centered, in the main,
around the requirements of the Charities and Trustees Investment (Scotland) Act 2005
with specific reference to the small minority of Lodges (in particular) and Provinces which
are registered with the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator, many of which have
historical registration by virtue of their listing with the Inland Revenue and would not
meet current registration criteria as defined under the Charity Test within the 2005 Act.
This had potentially created issues including governance and the way in which Masonic
benevolence is defined.
The Committee discussed the report and expressed itself content with the general
changes which had been made to certain Laws.
In regard to the issues which had been discussed at the second meeting, the Committee
agreed that it did not consider that it would be appropriate to alter the definition of
14th December 2017 GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND 143
Masonic benevolence, particularly as registration with the Office of the Scottish Charity
Regulator applied to only a small number of Lodges and Provinces, with some already
having dealt with the issue by creating a separate Charity Fund. In terms of governance,
it was felt that a small adjustment could be made to Law 193 if required. The Committee
also was of the view that, although guidance had been issued by Grand Lodge, the
question of registration and deregistration with the Office of the Scottish Charity Regular
ought to be placed on the agenda for the next meeting of Provincial Grand Masters so
that this could be clarified.
In terms of Grand Lodge, it was agreed that there is compliance with all of the requirements
of the legislation and therefore there is no need to alter the present definition of Masonic
benevolence or make any other changes.
The Committee appreciated the letter of thanks which had been received in regard to
the donation from Grand Lodge to the recent fundraising event which had been held
in aid of the First Responders. The evening had included a Guest Lecture by Brother
Moises I. Gomez entitled 'Remembrance, My 9/11 Experience'. It was agreed that it
would perhaps be appropriate to arrange such a Guest Lecture at Grand Lodge and it
was requested that this be investigated.
It was noted that an intimation of interest in purchasing a portion of the land at Dunblane
had been received from the owner of Ault Wharrie, which has now been converted into
a large family house. Advice had been received that the reason for the purchase would
be to make the driveway to the property into a private access. Whilst no formal offer had
been received, the Committee, after discussion, was of the view that no further portions
of the land should be disposed of at this time. It was agreed, however, that should an
offer be received this ought appropriately to be placed before the Committee.
The membership of the Committee for the ensuing year was discussed and it was
confirmed that Grand Secretary would review this with the Chairman in due course.
It was reconfirmed that the next meeting would take place on Wednesday, 14th March
2018 and that the meeting thereafter would take place on Wednesday, 8th August 2018.
It was agreed that the November 2018 meeting would be held on Wednesday, 7th of
that month.
GRAND COMMITTEE
RATHBONES INVESTMENTS
Purchases Cost
04/08/17 2,500 HSBC Holdings Plc £19,044
08/08/17 7,662 Strix Group Plc 7,662
17/08/17 30,000 Pacific Industrial Logistics 34,500
07/09/17 1,000 Bunzl Plc 22,795
£84,001
Purchases Cost
04/08/17 500 HSBC Holdings Plc £3,828
07/08/17 5,000 Fidelity China Special Sits. 10,914
08/08/17 4,598 Strix Group Plc 4,598
11/08/17 30,000 Xpediator Plc 7,200
17/08/17 14,000 Pacific Industrial Logistics 16,100
07/09/17 600 Bunzl Plc 13,745
08/09/17 1,200 Templeton Emerg. Markets 9,069
06/10/17 3,125 Barclays Plc 6,050
£71,504
146 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2017 _ 2018 No. 3
Purchases Cost
18/08/17 730 Baillie Gifford & Co £10,014
21/08/17 16,650 Scottish Mortgage Inv. Trust £70,083
£80,097
INSTALLATION OF SHELVING
In order to facilitate the storage of Masonic cases during meetings, it has been agreed
to consider the provision of shelving in one or both of the cloakrooms. Following two
site meetings with the contractor and sub-contractor, a specification is being prepared
to provide a shelving system which will be designed specifically with the storage of cases
in mind. Separate quotations are awaited for each of the cloakroom areas in order that
the Committee can make an informed decision as to how to proceed. The shelving
will require to be secured to the tiled walls, however, as there is evidence of previous
fixings in both cloakrooms, it is not felt to be necessary to seek approval from the City of
Edinburgh Council building control department.
148 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2017 _ 2018 No. 3
Brother Thomas C. Smith confirmed to the Committee he had just received a quotation
this morning in the sum of £17,131 plus VAT and after some discussion the Committee
agreed to the quotation presented.
FIRE SAFETY
Following the approval given at the previous meeting, the replacement fire escape doors
are presently being manufactured and will be installed during December.
SOUND SYSTEM
Due to recent failures in relation to the operation of the sound system, a meeting was
arranged with the supplier/maintenance provider to establish the nature of the faults
in order that an operational protocol could be put in place to avoid similar issues in the
future. Discussions with the supplier confirmed that the operation of the system by
multiple users, and by users who had not been trained appropriately, can lead to system
failure. A report has been provided (please see below) relating to the reason for the
system failures and outlining what options are available to secure the system and limit
access to certain aspects of its operation by using specialist settings and altering the
present 'access all areas' arrangement. Costs will be provided for the supply of additional
ancillary equipment such as the head sets so that spares are available in the event of a
failure in these pieces of equipment - the cost of an additional two head microphones
would be £929.11. In addition, the supplier suggested that approved operators receive
appropriate training in the use of the system. Discussion also took place relating to the
existing system which is analogue and the merits of upgrading to a digital system in the
future - upgrading to a digital system primarily means changing the mixing console which
would be at a cost of £1,499 for the equipment, which would fit in the existing rack. It
was agreed that the content of the report will enable a course of action to be determined
and a suitable operational protocol to be put in place.
The Committee agreed to upgrade to a digital system at a cost £1,499 plus VAT and to
purchase two additional headsets at a cost of £929.11 plus VAT.
14th December 2017 GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND 149
TINTED TREATMENT TO THE WINDOWS IN THE LIBRARY, MUSEUM AND FOUR OFFICE/
STAFF AREAS
Following agreement at the previous meeting that a costing be obtained for window
tinting in the library and museum in order to protect items which are on display from
damage from sunlight and that the costing be extended to include south facing areas
which would benefit from a reduction in the excess heat which is generated during the
summer months, a site survey has been completed and a quotation obtained. For the
areas specified the cost of applying the treatment would be £2,848 plus VAT. A cost of
£275 plus VAT each has also been obtained for the Grand Committee room and the
Grand Master Mason's room as the treatment would assist in preserving/protecting the
paintings and the period wallpaper in those areas should the Committee consider that
this would be worthwhile. There are numerous treatment shades available and these
would be selected based on individual locations. The Committee agreed to the quotation
presented of £2,848 plus VAT.
future, the external Risk Assessor who deals with Grand Lodge premises will visit the
Cruise shop annually.
1 January 2018, Grand Lodge will no longer process any green Quarterly Returns and all
Lodges should be encouraged to report and pay for all new Initiates, Affiliates and Marks
using the Database system.
i. The Committee received an up dated report on the arrangements for the planned
Ladies Day to be held on the day of the Grand Lodge of Scotland Installation on
30 November 2017. Everything was either in place or just being finalised and the
cost of the tickets would be set at £30.
ii. Brother Kenneth D. Kennedy wished to draw to the attention of the Chairman
and member of Committee that on occasions the Minutes of the Administration
Committee were sometimes approved by Grand Committee before the Minute
has been circulated to the Members of the Administration Committee. The
Chairman was aware of the situation but he usually discussed the minutes with
Grand Secretary before they were submitted to Grand Committee, as time would
not allow a full draft to be submitted before the Grand Committee meeting.
iii. The Chairman confirmed that in relation to the present review of the Constitution
and Laws currently being carried out that there was no need or requirement to
change the definition of Masonic Benevolence, as defined in Law 192.
iv. Brother Bud Gauld enquired, with regard to the BBC filming at the Installation
meeting, whether the sign of Fidelity could be used when entering the Lodge, as
it was widely used during the televised Tercentenary celebrations by the UGLE.
It was agreed that sign could be used but no others whilst the cameras were
present.
Present - Brothers Thomas F. Jessop, Chairman, Samuel Peden, Andrew Mushet, John S.
Miller, Alistair D. McIntosh, James P. Livingstone, James Ellis.
Apologies were recorded from Brother Robert Cooper.
The Chairman indicated that Brother Simon J. Nieminski was intended to be the first
item on the Agenda to discuss next years Memorial Concert for the late Dennis Townhill,
however he has indicated he would not be available today.
Minutes
The minutes of the meeting held on 15th August 2017 were approved.
Christmas Concert
The Christmas Concert sales were progressing, at £10 per person. Grand Lodge flyers
would be put on all seats at the October meeting, and Grand Secretary intimated he
would be emailing all Lodges shortly. It was agreed that Grand Secretary would arrange
luncheon for approximately 80 people, with flowers for the conductor and whisky for the
deputy conductor.
Present - Brothers W. Ramsay McGhee, (Chairman), Hugh Bryson, James Jack, Charles
Iain Robert Wolrige Gordon of Esslemont.
Apologies were recorded from Brother Lord Elgin., Sir Archie Orr Ewing, and Alistair
Marshall.
MATTERS ARISING
Grand Secretary advised he had written to the Government regarding Water Rates and
received a non-committal response in return. The Chairman advised that there had been
strong representations about the Water Rates, and he believed the Government were
reviewing the scheme.
ii) Grand Secretary advised he had been in contact with the Grand Lodge of Panama
regarding entering into a treaty of Cooperation with them and the matter was
now almost complete. The Grand Secretary advised he had discussed the
provisions with our newly established Lodge in Panama with the Brethren of
Lodge St. John No.1843 who were present at the Festival of St. Andrew. It was
agreed that the Chairman and Grand Master Mason would sign the agreement
on behalf of Grand Lodge.
iii) The Chairman reported that he and the Grand Master Mason had met with the
Grand Master of New York, in Washington. The meeting was cordial however
differences remained regarding Lebanon. The Chairman reported that they were
very well received in Washington and the Grand Master Mason was one four
Grand Masters chosen to lay a memorial wreath at the tomb of the unknown
soldier in Arlington.
Scheme Benefits: Grand Lodge and the local Provincial Grand Lodge will support each
University Scheme Lodge to build a team of enthusiastic freemasons who will apply
themselves to improving the working of the Lodge to ensure it can attract a group of new
members, with a focus (but not exclusively so) of full-time students and staff in higher/
further education.
University Scheme Lodges enjoy several standing dispensations, any or all of which may
be invoked when considering a full-time student applicant:
• University Scheme Lodges will receive support from Grand Lodge and their own
Provincial Grand Lodge, as well as networking opportunities with other lodges
participating in the Scheme.
Requirements:
• A disciplined process for admitting those joining as full-time students (e.g.
inviting them to harmony a few times, asking for letters of reference on their
character).
• Formal mentoring programme to ensure candidates have an opportunity to
learn about freemasonry as they undertake their degrees
• Appoint an effective administrator who can communicate effectively using email,
social media etc.
• Maintain and submit to the Scheme, records of:
o Candidate essays submitted after their First Degree
o Mentoring reports
o Feedback forms when student members move away
• A suitable number of Regular Meetings to enable students to attend during term
time. Consideration should be given to ensure that Installation Meeting does not
clash with holiday or exam time.
• Affiliation of experienced masons to bolster Lodge Office-Bearers
• Streamline lodge meetings to improve the experience:
o Dispense with deputations in/ out
o Limit formal presentations
o Circulate minutes electronically prior to meetings
o Re-write ritual to avoid unnecessary repetition
• Formal Harmonies following meetings with toasts and replies
• Maintain ongoing contact with student members who move away once their
studies are complete
• Change the lodge name to include the '(University Lodge)' designation
Commitment:
• A target to admit a minimum of three full-time students and two others who are
admitted outwith the scheme dispensations.
• The core original members will support the changes to the bye-laws and methods
of working to ensure the lodge's success within the Scheme.
• A University Scheme Lodge is expected to keep a couple of progressive offices
(e.g. a Deacon and Warden role) available for enthusiastic student members
to be installed 'out of sequence'. Student members should be encouraged to
deliver floor ritual once they have become Master Masons.
• A typical student member will be expected to be initiated, passed and raised
within one year.
Scheme Benefits: A University Scheme Status Lodge will receive support from Grand
Lodge and their own Provincial Grand Lodge to assist in attracting full-time students, as
14th December 2017 GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND 157
University Scheme Status Lodges enjoy several standing dispensations, any or all of which
may be invoked when considering a full-time student applicant:
• Admit full-time students from the age of 18 without being a Lewis;
• Admit full-time students who have not been resident for three years within the
Lodge vicinity;
• Full-time student members will have a reduction of 50% of all Grand Lodge and
Lodge fees.
Requirements:
• A disciplined process for admitting those joining as full-time students (e.g.
inviting them to harmony a few times, asking for letters of reference on their
character).
• Formal mentoring programme to ensure candidates have an opportunity to
learn about freemasonry as they undertake their degrees
• Appoint an effective administrator who can communicate effectively using email,
social media etc.
• Maintain and submit to the Scheme, records of:
o Candidate essays submitted after their First Degree
o Mentoring reports
o Feedback forms when student members move away
• Ensure there are a suitable number of Regular Meetings that students will be
able to attend (i.e. at least 6 meetings are within student term time).
• Maintain ongoing contact with student members who move away once their
studies are complete
Commitment:
• A target to admit a minimum of two full-time students
• A University Scheme Status Lodge will appreciate that enthusiastic new student
members are to be encouraged, by considering them for a progressive office
which is 'out of sequence', but certainly encourage floor ritual once they become
Master Masons.
• A typical student member will be expected to be initiated, passed and raised
within one year.
• A University Scheme Status Lodge will appreciate that they need to develop
student members slightly differently as they will, typically, be active members
for only a short time.
158 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2017 _ 2018 No. 3
DISCIPLINARY COMMITTEE
5 September 2017
th
Present - Brothers David Wishart, Chairman; Hugh Clelland, Ronald W.A. Forbes, Robert
Little, Alexander B. M. McLachlan, Thomas Davidson, John Muirhead, George M. Preston,
James C. Peddie.
The Chairman welcomed the members of the Committee and thanked them for their
attendance.
Lodge St Michael’s Kilwinning, No. 63
The Committee reviewed correspondence relating to the case of Brother James Simons
Thomson of the above Lodge who had been sentenced to admonition by the Provincial
Grand Lodge of Dumfriesshire on the 10th July 2017. No appeal had been received.
After due deliberation the decision of the Committee was to confirm the sentence of
admonition.
Lodge Royal Arch, No. 198
The Committee reviewed correspondence relating to the case of Brother Dale Laurenson
Russell of the above Lodge who had been sentenced to suspension sine die with a
recommendation of expulsion from the Scottish Craft by the Provincial Grand Lodge of
Ayrshire on the 24th July 2017.
No appeal had been received. After due deliberation the decision of the Committee was
to confirm the sentence of suspension sine die with expulsion from the Scottish Craft.
Lodge Forfar and Kincardine No. 225
The Committee considered a report relating to Brother James David Reilly of the above
Lodge. Being satisfied that Brother Reilly had been convicted in a Court of Law and
sentenced to a term of imprisonment for a period of thirteen months, the Committee
found him guilty of conduct unbecoming a Freemason and imposed a sentence of
suspension sine die together with a recommendation of expulsion from the Scottish
Craft.
Lodge Panmure, No. 299
The Committee gave further consideration to the case of Brother David Maurice Murray
of the above Lodge who had been sentenced to suspension for a period of two years by
the Provincial Grand Lodge of Forfarshire on 24th April 2017.
Representations in terms of Law 243 had been received. After due deliberation the
decision of the Committee was to vary the sentence of suspension for a period of two
years to that of suspension sine die.
Lodge Ballingry, No. 1183
The Committee reviewed correspondence relating to the case of Brother Alexander
Robertson of the above Lodge who had been sentenced to admonition by the Provincial
Grand Lodge of Fife and Kinross on the 26th June 2017. No appeal had been received.
After due deliberation the decision of the Committee was to confirm the sentence of
admonition.
Lodge Balcarres, No. 1240
The Committee reviewed correspondence relating to the case of Brother Andrew Burns
of the above Lodge who had been sentenced to suspension for a period of three years
14th December 2017 GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND 159
by the Provincial Grand Lodge of Fife and Kinross on the 26th June 2017. No appeal had
been received.
After due deliberation the decision of the Committee was to confirm the sentence of
suspension for a period of three years.
The Chairman was warmly thanked for his Chairmanship of the meeting.
DISCIPLINARY COMMITTEE
26 October 2017
th
Present - Brothers David Wishart, Chairman; Hugh Clelland, Ronald W.A. Forbes, Robert
Little, Alexander B. M. McLachlan, Thomas Davidson, George M. Preston, James C.
Peddie.
The Chairman welcomed the members of the Committee and thanked them for their
attendance.
The Chairman was warmly thanked for his Chairmanship of the meeting.
160 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2017 _ 2018 No. 3
OVERSEAS
1. On 13th to 15th October Grand Secretary attended the European Grand Secretaries
Meeting in Lisbon.
2. On 29th October to 1st November the Grand Master Mason, accompanied by Brother
Marcus Humphrey of Dinnet, and Sir Archibald Orr Ewing, Past Grand Masters,
Brother W. Ramsay McGhee, Depute Grand Master, Brother William H. Gauld,
Grand Director of Ceremonies, and Grand Secretary attended the Tercentenary
celebrations of the United Grand Lodge of England, in London.
3. On 1st to 3rd of December the Grand Master Mason, accompanied by Grand
Secretary attended the Grand Lodge de Nationale de Francais, in Paris.
4. On 7th to 10th December the Grand Master Mason and Past Depute Grand Master,
Brother W. Ramsay McGhee attended the Grand Lodge of the District of Columbia,
in Washington.
14th December 2017 GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND 161
The following Brethren were elected as Grand Stewards for the following year:
MICHAEL W.L. DENNIS STUART M. MUIRHEAD
JAMES A. BINGHAM ROBERT W. STEWART
GEORGE T. STODDARD ANDREW G. G. MCFADDEN
WILLIAM S. RIDDICK THOMAS W. McCRONE
DONALD G. GRAHAM WILLIAM PETTIGREW
RONALD G. COOPER ALLAN T. LEISHAMAN
CAMERON A. GIBSON IAN STRACHAN
ROBERT B.B HENDERSON DAVID J. COLLINGS
ROBERT B. MATHEW JOHN E. LOTHIAN
IAIN D. McINTOSH BRUCE C. COATES
WILLIAM M. HUTCHISON JAMES McMILLAN
LENNARD A. HUGHSON JAMES M. MUIRHEAD
JAMES M. HARPER DEREK A.L. MACKAY
DOUGLAS R.H. NICOL MICHAEL MCADAMS
ROSS MENNIE MARTYN W. GREEN
LEWIS R. YOUNG WILLIAM C. CAMPBELL
ALEXANDER L. HAMILTON STEVEN G. HENRY
THOMAS I. BLACK DOUGLAS McGEE
ALEXANDER J. CRAIB RICHARD ANDERSON
ANDREW M. RAEBURN ANDREW REDDY
NORMAN COLBORNE ANDREW J. McIVOR
COLIN DAVIE WILLIAM INNES
CRAIG MACDONALD ROBERT CROWE
STANDING COMMITTEES
Grand Secretary reported that in accordance with accepted practice he had discussed
with the Grand Master Mason and the Chairmen of the Standing Committees, the
Committees for the following year and arising therefrom the Grand Master Mason made
the undernoted recommendations relating to the appointment of Standing Committees
which were approved by Grand Committee.
ADMINISTRATION
James Bell, Grand Treasurer, ex officio, (Chairman), Thomas C. Smith, William H. Gauld,
Ewan Rutherford, Kenneth D. Kennedy, Douglas W. Duncan, Michael Kinnaird, Alexander
Galbraith, Rev. Canon Joseph Morrow.
DISCIPLINARY
David Wishart, (Chairman), Hugh Clelland, Robert Little, Alexander B.M. McLachlan,
Ronald W.A. Forbes, Thomas Davidson, George M. Preston, James Peddie, John W.
Blackie.
DISCIPLINARY REVIEW
John F. Herrick, (Chairman), Maurice E. Wilson, W. Scott Sneddon, Alan Dickson, Douglas
Fergie, Michael Mulholland, Kenneth Johnson, John S. Brockie, Norman MacLeod.
i)
That Brother Thomas Wood be appointed as Provincial Grand Master of
Kilwinning with effect from 14th June 2018.
ii) That Brother Douglas Trevor Philand being appointed Provincial Grand Master of
Argyll and the Isles with effect from 14th June 2018.
iii) That Brother Dr. Olanrewanju Olumide be appointed District Grand Master of
Nigeria with effect from 14th June 2018.
VOTE OF THANKS
Brother Charles I.R. Wolrige Gordon of Esslemont, Grand Master Mason, requested that
there should be placed on record a cordial vote of thanks to the following Brethren for
their service to the Scottish Craft during their term of their Commissions:
Grand Secretary advised that the total amount collected in 2017 for the Prize
Draw was £28,737.00 compared with £30,839.00 in 2016.
Grand Secretary noted that the following had returned all their allocated tickets
unsold or had reported a nil return:
Lodges 320
Provincial Grand Masters 8
Grand Office-bearers 2
Grand Committee Members 8
ii) On behalf of Grand Committee, Grand Secretary thanked the Grand Master
Mason for his Chairmanship of the meeting and wished him and his family a
relaxing and peaceful Christmas and a prosperous and healthy New Year.
The Grand Master Mason reciprocated the Season’s Greetings and the Brethren
responded with acclamation.
164 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2017 _ 2018 No. 3
14th December 2017 GRAND LODGE OF SCOTLAND 165
166 PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2017 _ 2018 No. 3