Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Submitted By:
Ms. Divya Ramesh
( Reg. No. 02XQCM6019 )
OCTOBER – 2004
DECLARATION
The findings of this study are based on the data collected by me and
have not formed the basis for the award of any other Degree/Diploma
of any other University or Institution.
This is to certify that Ms. Divya Ramesh, bearing register no. 02XQCM6019, a student
of M.P.Birla Institute of Management, Bangalore has succesfuly completed the Project
Work titled ‘Customer Value Management’ at ICICI Prudential Life Insurance Company
Ltd., Bangalore as a partial fulfilment of MBA program, during the months of May to
August 2004.
I hereby certify that the research work embodied in this dissertation entitled,
“Customer Value Management” at ICICI Prudential Life Insurance Company Ltd.,
Bangalore has been undertaken and completed by Ms.Divya Ramesh, bearing
Register Number 02XQCM6019 under my guidance and supervision.
I also certify that she has fulfilled all the requirements under the covenant
governing the submission of dissertation to the Bangalore University for the award
of MBA Degree.
I extend my gratitude to the staff of the Sales Department at ICICI Prudential Life
Insurance Company Ltd., Bangalore for their co-operation while carrying out this
project.
My grateful thanks are also due to Ms.Veena, Insurance Advisor with ICICI Prudential
Life Insurance Company Ltd., Bangalore and my parents for their incredible support.
Place : Bangalore
I Introduction
1. Conceptual Framework of CVM 3 –4
2. Problem Statement 5
3. Need & Significance of the Study 6 –7
4. Objectives of the Research 8
II Review of Literature
1. Purpose 9 –14
2. Conclusion 15
3. Methodology 16
4. Benefits from the Literature Review 16
III Research Methodology 17 -18
1. Scope of the Study
2. Type of Research
3. Data Collection
4. Sampling Technique
5. Sample Size
6. Sample Description
7. Instrumentation Technique
8. Tools used for Hypotheses testing
9. Limitations of the Study
IV Company Profile 19 - 26
CONTENTS
Annexure
1. Select Bibliography 56 - 57
2. Questionnaire 58 – 61
3. Research instrument used 62
4. Data incidental to research
• IEPA Attribute Model 63 – 65
• Product Comparison 66 – 71
• Task assigned by the company - Survey 72 - 79
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This project is done for ICICI Prudential Life Insurance Company Ltd. In today’s
environment the customers have become sovereign authorities. They constitute the focal
point for any business. The effectiveness of Customer Value Management helps a
business enterprise to create and sustain differentiating value, which has been focussed in
this study.
Customer Value Management represents the best practices used today by companies
worldwide to attain their visions of finding out what customers want and giving it to
them. Customer Value Management provides a rational set of technology; methods and
strategies to weave needs and wants of customers into key process designs and
management activities of a company.
Customer Value Management is a vehicle to understand what the customers want from
the Company and how it can go about aligning its business to deliver the same
consistently. Every Company has perspectives about Finance, Customers, Internal
Business & Growth. Customer Value Management deals with the ‘Customer
Perspective’ which along with the other perspectives are aligned with the strategic intent
and posture of the company.
The Customer Value Map will be designed to assess where the company’s service stands
against competitors on the relative quality versus price matrix.
This Study is based on certain objectives and the research on Customer Value
Management has been developed based on these objectives. The objectives are as
follows :
• To identify the route to provide superior delivered value to customers
• To unzip the direct link between customer value and the market share
• To determine whether the ‘Customer Value Map’ can assess the position of the
company’s service against its competitors on the relative quality – price matrix
1
The important findings of this study are :
The most important reasons for buying a Life Insurance Policy from ICICI Prudential
are brand name, wide varieties of policies to choose from and good servicing of
policies
The most important value added features in ICICI Prudential’s policies are wide
range of options within the same policy, multiple benefits packed in a single policy,
flexibility and good returns
The manifestations of value of ICICI Prudential in order of ranking are – maximum
risk cover, profitable mode of investment, tax rebate, multiple benefits, pre-
sales/during-sales/after-sales service and premium.
2
INTRODUCTION
Customer Value Management (CVM) represents the very best practices used by
companies worldwide to attain their visions of finding out what customers want and
giving it to them. It has become a leading approach to attract market share. It is a means,
by which a company can balance the demand for service and products with an
infrastructure that is customer centric, delivers increased productivity & benefits the
customer’s product line.
Customer Value Management is a way to build customer loyalty and improve value for
the company. It provides a way to understand customers’ values and then leverage that
knowledge to prevent customer dissatisfaction or to influence buyer behavior. It creates
an alignment between customer’s dyn amic vision of ideal value delivery and business
capability to deliver that value. The company should focus on specific capabilities and
infrastructure to deliver value and also reengineer business capabilities with a focus on
customer envisioned value.
Customer Value Management is a very powerful tool to make the company truly
customer oriented, attain top of the line growth and bottom line results. It is a formal,
systematic approach to compete and grow, based on delivering customer value. CVM is
also fast emerging as the ‘Ruling Currency’ to the growth of the company.
In implementing CVM, how a customer perceives the company and obtains value should
be identified and managed. If employed correctly it can help a business enterprise create
and sustain differentiating value. CVM helps a company in the following ways :
a) Develop and implement a business vision to become customer centered i.e. be
number one in the eyes of their customers
b) Implement strategy to differentiate and compete on service and value to customers,
not merely on products and price
c) Understand what drives customers’ loyalty and give it to them 3
The implementation of CVM begins with the company identifying the needs/wants of
their customers and building on specific capabilities and business practices to fulfill
these needs/wants. CVM is thus a top down approach.
4
PROBLEM STATEMENT
To meet the challenges faced in the Life Insurance Industry, ICICI Prudential Life
Insurance Company Ltd. has to gear up itself. Customer Value Management is a leading
approach to attract market share. It can emerge as the ‘ruling currency’ to the growth of
the company.
The emphasis is on how ICICI Prudential Life Insurance Company Ltd. can arrest the
value migration of their customers and capture new value of the customers by modifying
their business design.
Specifically, the problem statement is – “How can ICICI Prudential ensure customer
equity through an effective Customer Value Management Program?”. The study will
focus on the three aspects of Customer Value Management i.e.
a) Being customer centric
b) Delivering increased productivity
c) Benefits provided to the consumer’s product line
5
NEED AND SIGNIFICANCE OF STUDY
Virtually every company has a vision and a strategy to achieve it. But missing element
from all of these companies is the very presence of the word ‘Customer’. Incorporating
the word customer into the vision statement has been a fairly recent phenomenon. In
today’s environment the customers have become monarchs. They have taken on new
importance as the focal point for business. Today’s management philosophy is to find
out what the customers want and give it to them. This helps company to stay head of
competition.
There are key issues for major companies that need to be addressed. These can be
summarised as follows :
• Just having a clear vision and strategy to achieve that vision is not enough. Even
when a strategic vision is in place it might have little impact on the goals of the
company. Hence this strategic vision has to be tied to the customer’s expectations
from the company.
• To remain successful today, the theme for a business’s vision and strategy must
change from, “Where do we want to be in five years?” to “Where do our customers
want us to be, and how do we get there?”
• For every given customer desired outcome, the full value chain relating to how a
customer perceives and obtains value from the company must be identified and
managed having the customer as the focal point.
Customer Value Management helps address all the above issues. It helps to leverage
customer value to drive business performance. Organizations can successfully employ
customer value management system to know their customers precisely. They can also
know their competitors’ customers. Effective customer value management allows
organizations to assess which products and services meet customer’ needs and
appropriately define their value proposition relative to their competitors.
The need for the study stems from the fact that the Management at ICICI Prudential Life
Insurance Company Ltd. has to observe the effectiveness of Customer Value
Management. This study will help the company to understand as to how it can arrest
value migration, protect existing value of customers and capture new value by modifying
their business design.
The significance of the study is that the company would benefit by knowing how
effective the perspective of Customer Value Management presently is. The policyholders
and the employees of the company have been involved in this study to give the company
an in depth picture of the views of both of these two categories of people. The areas of
improvement (recommendations) will be highlighted in the study, which will immensely
benefit the company.
7
OBJECTIVES OF THE RESEARCH
Specifically the following objectives have been set for our research investigation :
• To identify the route to provide superior delivered value to customers
• To unzip the direct link between customer value and the market share
• To determine whether the ‘Customer Value Map’ can assess the position of the
company’s service against its competitors on the relative quality – price matrix
8
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1) Purpose
2) Methodology of review
3) Conclusion
4) Benefits
Purpose of the Review of Literature
• To identify the problem statement
• To understand the secondary data that has been gathered in the field of the study
• To attempt to make new findings on the problem statement without reinventing
what has already been done in this field of study
If CRM is the "pipes" of a system for two-way communication with customers, then
CVM is the human factor. Businesses that know what customers value, know how to
deliver this value better than the competition, and know when it's important to
communicate with customers so that they perceive the true value delivered achieve
competitive advantage, better business results and shareholder value. The challenge for
business is to turn this understanding into practical action that delivers measurable
results. The idea that business success comes from focusing on customers is not new, and
vision and mission statements are full of aspirational language about creating value for
customers. Yet some of the most metrics-driven companies would be hard pressed to
explain how they are measuring and managing customer value. There is now an
emerging art and science of customer value management that is proving its worth in
increased market share and shareholder value for the companies that practice it.
Companies that capture and use customer data with the same kind of discipline, passion
and understanding they give to operational and financial data are learning that this
business practice is well worth the time and money invested. By focusing on winning in
the customer market, they also win in attracting and retaining talented people and in the
financial market. Customer value management is about:
Choosing value: Asking customers in the target market what they value, finding out how
they rate the value that is delivered compared to the competition, and using this
understanding to focus priorities and then decide what value proposition to take to
market.
Delivering value: Making sure that the business processes are aligned with the value
proposition, and determining what business improvements will deliver the greatest value
to customers.
Communicating value: Educating the market on the value proposition and how the
company is focusing investment to deliver greater value than the competition.
Customer Value Management (CVM) helps leverage customer value to drive the
company’s business performance. Organizations successfully employing a customer
value management system know their customers. They also know their competitors’
customers. Effective customer value management allows organizations to assess which
products and services their customer’s demand and need, and appropriately define their
value proposition relative to their competitors. Focus Areas are :
CVM integrates a range of strategies that allow your organization to be more valuable to
your current and future customers:
10
• Identify major business processes and products/services valued highest by
customers.
• Present gaps between employee and customer value perceptions.
• Identify strategic market segments and competitive positioning of your
products/services.
CVM Plan Implementation
• Phase-in required organizational alignment changes.
• Conduct Customer Relationship Management (CRM) and CVM employee
training.
• Implement customer business process and product/service improvements.
• Launch customer marketing and communication program advancements.
• Implement CRM and CVM performance tracking systems.
Benefits of Customer Value Management are
• Know and understand your customers needs
• Increase customer loyalty
• Assess product and service lines to align with client needs
Source : John Renner, Vice President, Sabre’s Customer Value Management
solutions (25/6/2004)
3. The Second Deadly Sin of CVM - Ignoring the Customer Life Cycle
Customers rarely stand still – their preferences, behavior, lifestyle and buying habits
invariably change over time. And while marketing executives recognize the dynamic
nature of customer behavior and customer relationships, many miss the opportunity to
create new value because of organizational inertia that prevents many enterprises from
keeping pace with customers’ changing needs. Companies aren’t clear about what, when
and how of meeting customers evolving needs and preferences. This uncertainty and lack
of knowledge translates into lost revenues and missed opportunities to cement profitable,
long-term customer relationships. A customer-centric life insurance company should
deeply understand the needs of its highly focused segments and services them
accordingly. It doesn’t take a major effort to a chieve impressive results – adding two
columns to a customer file the first identifies the value of a customer, second identifies
the appropriate offer to present to that customer. This simple redesign makes it possible
to provide customer service reps with important details about a customer’s value and
preferences. Companies can garner 20 to 30 percent increases in terms of the percentage
of customers adding at least one additional product to their portfolios. They can increase
sales yield 10 to 20 percent by improving their ability to match product
recommendations to customers’ profiles. And by carefully targeting product
recommendations in response to incoming customer calls, sales rate improvements of 10
to 25 percent are not uncommon. The net profits from CVM can be reinvested into
additional incremental improvements, creating a cascade of successful results that ripple
throughout the organization.
Source : Kevin Grieve & Edgar Ortiz, DM Direct Newsletter, Sep 2003
CVM helps to understand how line of business, marketing, sales managers and
executives in the insurance business can:
• Improve customer retention
• Increase revenue
• Drive down cost in their businesses
Customer Value Management approach can be used for more accurate cost projection,
and to better measure actual value contribution by customers.
Customer Service - Products and prices in an Insurance industry can be easily duplicated.
Thus service becomes the only differentiator which will provide the competitive
advantage in the long run. Insurance companies should have a cell for customer
management, which caters to the customer needs and complaints. The Insurance agents
are the interface between the customer and the Insurance company. The agents should be
able to accomplish the following to improve service. 13
Companies that aspire to serve their customers both well and profitably need to be aware
of five major trends that will play a role in the evolution of CRM into CVM - rising
customer expectations, viewing customers as assets, improving customer intelligence
quotients, developing new organization models and increasing financial rigor. It is
important to have a customer value measurement system, which often succeeds the
customer satisfaction measurement system. The customer value measurement systems
need to cater to many dimensions of the relationship including those of competitor
analysis. Sharing the customer value measures with the customer forms an integral part
of a metrics based customer relationship management system.
14
CONCLUSIONS
All the above articles are related to Customer Value Management and also implications
of adopting CVM in the Life Insurance industry. It therefore, becomes important for us
to understand as to how a Life Insurance company can increase value for its customers,
protect the existing customers, avoid migration of customers and also to add new value
to customers by way of modifying the business design.
It will help to understand the intricate details of CVM in a Life Insurance industry
The role and importance of CVM in the services sector can also be understood
The implications of adopting CVM on the business, the expected value of customers and
the capability of the company to deliver the same can be examined
15
METHODOLOGY OF THE REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Review of the literature has been done with the help of the following sources :
Company Literature
Brochures
The Internet
ICICI Prudential – Quarterly Report
Publications
Articles on CVM
A text book on Customer Value Management
The review of literature has been very informative, as it has thrown light on the research
and articles that have been written on Customer Value Management.
Moreover it has helped in identifying the degree of research that has been done already
on this topic. It has helped our study, as it constituted the basis of secondary data for our
study.
16
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Type of Research
Our research is a formal study with some elements of exploration involved. This research
is also aimed at recognising the areas of improvement for ICICI Prudential Life
Insurance Company Ltd. in terms of their relationship with customers.
Data Collection
Data sources consisted of primary and secondary. Sources of primary data included the
policyholders of ICICI Prudential Life Insurance Company Ltd. and also its employees.
Sources of secondary data included the information provided by the organisation and
various text books, magazines, internet and company broucheres.
A structured questionnaire was developed and administered to generate the primary data.
Sampling Technique
Random Sampling
It is also called probability sampling or chance sampling. Under this sampling design
every item of the universe has an equal chance of inclusion in the sample. All choices are
independent of one another. It gives each possible sample combination an equal
probability of being chosen. We, therefore, adopted this technique in our study.
Sample Size
The composition of our sample consisted of policyholders of ICICI Prudential Life
Insurance Company Ltd., the employees and insurance advisors. The respondents whom
we have approached are 50 in number.
17
Sample Description
Age 20 – 30 30 - 40 40 - 50 50 - 60 Total
No. 25 9 3 13 50
The respondents are concentrated in the age groups between 20 – 30 years. There are
also respondents in the age groups of 50 – 60 years.
No. 35 15 50
Majority of the respondents are male (70%) and the remaining 30% of them are females.
Instrumentation Techniques
Structured Questionnaire : The primary data has been collected through structured
questionnaires, which were administered to the respondents.
18
COMPANY PROFILE
THE ICICI GROUP
The Industrial Credit and Investment Corporation of India Limited (ICICI) was
incorporated at the initiative of the World Bank in 1955, the Government of India and
representatives of Indian industry with the objective of creating a development financial
institution for providing project and corporate finance to Indian industry. It started off its
operations by providing finance for industrial development, and it has diversified into
housing finance, consumer finance, mutual funds and its latest venture Life Insurance.
Following the market oriented economic policy reform in the 1990s, ICICI moved away
from its traditional role into a new era of liberalized regulation and intense competition.
A series of initiatives were championed to keep up with keen competition in India’s
financial service sector, and access to international capital markets was crucial to the
success of the new mandate. Since inception, ICICI has grown from a development bank
to a financial conglomerate and has become one of the largest public financial
institutions in India. ICICI has thus far financed all the major sectors of the economy.
19
people have their own sets of needs at various stages of their lives. That's why they offer
a choice of solutions depending on whether you are a young individual planning for the
years ahead or an established professional planning for your retirement. The Company is
now operational in ten cities throughout the country.
ICICI Prudential Life Insurance company is a joint venture between ICICI, a premier
financial powerhouse and Prudential, a leading international financial services group
headquartered in the United Kingdom. ICICI and Prudential came together in 1993 to
form Prudential ICICI Asset Management Company, which has today emerged as one of
the largest private sector mutual fund company in India. The two companies bring
together the strongest financial service brands in Asia, known for their professionalism,
excellent quality of service and long - term commitment to consumers. Riding on the
success of this relationship, the two companies joined hands once more in 2000, to form
ICICI Prudential Life Insurance Company, with a commitment to provide leading-edge
life insurance solutions. This venture plans to take care of the insurance needs at various
stages of life. ICICI Prudential has been adjudged the Best Life Insurer by Outlook
Money. This is the only award that recognises the value delivered to customers in
addition to business performance.
ICICI Prudential's equity base stands at Rs. 6.75 billion with ICICI Bank having 74%
stake in the company and Prudential having 26%. The Company was granted Certificate
of Registration for carrying out Life Insurance business, by the IRDA on November 24,
2000. It commenced commercial operations on December 19, 2000, becoming one of the
first few private sector players to enter the liberalized arena. ICICI Prudential was
positioned as an enabler of protection relevant to the needs of the life stage. The
Company issued its first policy on December 12, 2000. In the year ended March 31,
2004, the company had issued over 430,000 policies. ICICI Prudential was amongst the
first to identify the emerging opportunity in the Pension segment and launched two
linked pension products- LifeTime Pension and LifeLink Pension, which have been well
received in the market. The company has a network of about 30,000 advisors as well as
12 bancassurance tie-ups. ICICI Prudential has one of the largest distribution networks
amongst private life insurers in India. Today the company is the #1 leading private life
insurer in the country. The company has a commitment to increase consumer knowledge
about Life Insurance. 20
HISTORY
ICICI Prudential was established in Dec 2000. Sine the brand ICICI is well known in the
country, they did not have to face that particular challenge. They wanted to build an
organisation with culture different from that of LIC. Life Insurance was positioned as a
high excitement and emotive product. The task at the time of set up was to establish the
ICICI brand, build awareness and give the brand a larger than life image by addressing
the issue of credibility and trust to invest funds with. Another big initiative that ICICI
Prudential launched was a quality initiative – Six Sigma. For promoting the company,
the theme was ‘cover every Indian with joy, hope, freedom, life’. Further, they chose
children from municipal schools who received endowment policies. These programs
were to deliver the brand promise. Today the company has set themselves metrics that is
best in class for various categories of players. In terms of service the company’s
benchmarks are the best retail financial services player in the world. The company is
hopeful of playing a major role in the expanding the life insurance market in this
country.
PRUDENTIAL ASIA
Prudential is the largest life insurance company in the United Kingdom. Asia has always
been an important region for Prudential and it has had a presence in Asia for over 75
years. It has over 45,000 staff agents and over 1 million customers. It has its operations
in 12 countries throughout Asia.
SERVICE
ICICI Prudential has recruited and trained over 18,000 insurance advisors to interface
with and advise customers and has the highest number amongst private life insurers on
the renowned Million-Dollar Round Table (MDRT). Further, it leverages its state-of-the-
art IT infrastructure to provide superior quality of service to customers. It has a
‘Customer First’ philosophy.
COMPETITORS
ICICI Prudential faces tough competition from Life Insurance Corporation of India
which is one of the oldest insurance company and also from other private insurers like
Birla Sunlife, Tata AIG, MetLife etc, HDFC Standard Life Insurance, ING Vysya etc.
22
LIFE INSURANCE SCORE CARD - (First year & single premium in 2003 – 04)
VARIOUS DEPARTMENTS
Sales & Distribution Department Operations Department
Bancassurance Risk Management
Group Assurance Department Front Desk
HR & Administration Department Training Department
The organisation structure is given on Page 26.
23
YEAR OF REVIEW 2003 – 2004
Life Insurance Market share Market share as Market share as %
company as % of % of no. of of lives under group
premium policies/schemes scheme
400000
350000
300000
250000
200000
150000
100000
50000
0
G
rk
a
l
ar
j
ia
ja
iv
AI
yo
nm
nt
Ba
Av
ew
de
ta
Sa
nz
Ta
ru
N
lia
IP
ax
AM
Al
IC
M
IC
PRODUCTS
ICICI Prudential Life Insurance offers a range of innovative, customer-centric products
that meet the needs of customers at every life stage. There are 13 policies to cater to
individuals, which can be enhanced with six riders so as to create a number of
combinations. Given the demographic and social conditions of India - like an aging
population, absence of a social security system and inflation - ICICI Prudential Life sees
immense potential in the growth of retirement products.
Solutions for individuals
Savings Solutions : SecurePlus, CashPlus, Save ‘n’ Protect, CashBak
Protection Solutions : LifeGuard
Child Solutions : SmartKid Child Plans, SmartKid
Market-Linked Solutions : LifeLink, LifeTime
Retirement Solutions : ForeverLife, SecurePlus Pension
Market-linked Retirement Products : LifeTime Pension, Lifelink Pension
Group Solutions
ICICI Prudential also offers group insurance solutions for companies seeking to enhance
benefits to their employees. The group plans are : Group Gratuity Plan, Group
Superannuation Plan, Group Term Plan
Products for the rural market
A basket of policies have been designed specifically for the rural market like Mitr,
Suraksha & Salaam Zindagi
Flexible Rider Options – Six different rider options to choose from 25
CEO & MD
Page 26
Chief IT
Zonal Mgr.
Zonal Operation Zonal HR Zonal
Mgr. Mgr. Mktg Mgr.
Branch /
Territory Mgr. Branch HR Branch
Branch O&U
Mgr. Mktg Mgr.
Mgr.
SM/ Assistant
SM HR Marketing
Team
Executives Executive
Leader
Advisors
DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION
• Statement of Hypotheses
• Testing of Hypotheses
• Inferences from the analysis
STATEMENT OF HYPOTHESES
The following three hypotheses which are appropriate to our study have been tested
1. Ho = There is not more than one route to provide superior delivered value to
customers
H1 = There is more than one route to provide superior delivered value to customers
2. Ho = There is no direct link between Customer Value and Market Share
H1 = There is a direct link between Customer Value and Market Share
3. Ho = Customer Value Mapping cannot assess where the company’s services stand
against competitors on the relative quality versus price matrix
H1 = Customer Value Mapping can assess where the company’s services stand
against competitors on the relative quality versus price matrix
27
I (a) Ideas/Meanings associated with the Life Insurance Policy of ICICI Prudential
80 No.
60
Percentage
40
20
0
Max Risk Cover
Tax Rebate
Total
Premium
Meanings/Ideas
Interpretation : The most important association of idea with Life Insurance policy of
ICICI Prudential is as a profitable mode of investment (52%). The other associations
with the company are in terms of the maximum risk cover, tax rebate and multiple
benefits provided by the policies. Presales, during-sales and after-sales service is also
another idea association given by the respondents.
I (b) Ranking the above manifestations of value as associated with the Life
Insurance policy of ICICI Prudential
40
35
Weighted 30
25
Average 20
Rank 15 10
5
0
Premium
Max
Tax
Rank (No. of
respondents)
Manifestations
of Value
Interpretation : We need to identify the most important value associated with Life
Insurance policy of ICICI Prudential. The most important values according to the
customers are providing maximum risk cover, profitable mode of investment, tax rebate
enjoyed by them, multiple benefits provided, pre-sales:during-sales:after-sales service
provided. Premium comes last in the order of ranking.
29
Hypothesis Testing I
Ho = There is not more than one route to provide superior delivered value to customers
H1 = There is more than one route to provide superior delivered value to customers
The statistical tool used to test this hypothesis is Chi-square test. This non-parametric
test is used keeping in mind the sample size. Chi-square = (Oij-Eij)²/Eij
Rank 38 34 29 28 7 5 141
Total 59 60 50 49 11 17 246
Chi-
-Eij)²/Eij where Oij is the observed frequency in the i,jth cell and Eij
is the expected frequency in the i,jth cell.
We calculate chi-square as : Expected (E) is calculated as (21+26+21+21+4+12)/6
E = 17.5
Degrees of freedom is (c-1)(r-1) = (2-1)(6-1) = 5
E O (O-E)2/E
17.5 21 0.70
17.5 26 4.12
17.5 21 0.70
17.5 21 0.70
17.5 4 10.41
17.5 12 1.72
Chi-Square 18.37
Inference : At 5% level of significance and 5 degrees of freedom the table value of chi-
square is 11.07 and calculated value is 18.37 which is higher than the table value. Hence
we reject the null hypothesis and conclude that there is more than one route to deliver
superior delivered value to customers, the most important route being to provide
maximum risk cover to customers.
30
II (a) Preference of companies to buy a Life Insurance Policy
50
45
40
35
30
Percentage 25
20
15
10
5
0
ICICI Other Pvt. Total
Prudential Companies Series1
Series2
Life Insurance companies
31
Note : The respondents have more than one reason for preferring a policy from ICICI
Prudential. Hence the total is not additive.
20
15
Percentage
10
Policies are
Most popular
Highly
Wide
Returns-
Series1
Series2
Reasons for preference
Interpretation : This helps to know the reasons for preferring policies of ICICI
Prudential. The most important reasons are the company’s well known brand name, wide
varieties of policies to choose from, good service provided to customers, good returns
and also highly affordable and flexible policies. Hence it can be inferred that this
company’s polici es are preferred due to its brand name and other value additions
provided by the company.
Interpretation : The respondents who prefer a Life Insurance policy from other private
Life Insurance companies do so depending on whether a suitable Life Insurance policy
product is offered by them and not because of the value provide by those companies.
32
Hypothesis Testing II
Considering the first two reasons with the highest percentage , we use the z-test as
follows :
p1 = 0.53 and p2 = 0.18 (sample proportions)
n1 = 58 and n2 = 58 (sample size)
P = n1p1 +n2p2 = 58 (0.53) +58 (0.18) = 0.355
n1 +n2 58 + 58
Q = 1 – P = 1-0.355 = 0.645
33
III (a) Quality of ICICI Prudential in terms of its value
Total
Low
Quality
Series2
Series1
Medium
High
0 20 40 60
No. of responses
Interpretation: This is to find out the quality of ICICI Prudential in terms of its value.
The quality of the company is found to be high with majority of the respondents i.e. 70%
and only 30% of them feel that the quality of the company in terms of its value is
medium. This shows that the quality of ICICI Prudential in terms of the value provided
to customers is high. This is also evident from the graph.
34
Price of policy of ICICI Pru
40
35
No. of responses
30
25
20 Series1
15 Series2
10
5
0
le
l
h
ta
ig
ab
Lo
To
H
rd
fo
Af
Price of policy
Interpretation : We need to identify the customer’s opinion about the price of premium
policies of ICICI Prudential. It is evident from the graph and the table that 84% of the
respondents stated that the policy is affordable while only a small percentage of them –
13% stated that the price is high. The price of the policy of ICICI Prudential seems to be
affordable.
35
Hypothesis Testing III
Ho = Customer Value Mapping cannot assess where the company’s services stand
against competitors on the relative quality versus price matrix
H1 = Customer Value Mapping can assess where the company’s services stand against
competitors on the relative quality versus price matrix
Customer Value Map
Higher 1.25
25
1.0
0
Lower 0.84
0.75
0.40 0.60 0.70 0.80
Lower Higher
X – axis : Relative Quality (in %)
Y – axis : Relative Price (in %)
Inference : This map helps us to assess where the company’s service stands against
competitors. The position of the ICICI Prudential is to the right and below the fair value
line. This is indicated by the black dot as shown above. Hence ICICI Prudential is in a
gain sharing position. Hence we reject the null hypothesis and conclude that Customer
Value Mapping can assess where the company’s services stands against competitors on
the relative quality versus price matrix.
36
INFERENCES
Table-1 Gender
Gender No. Percentage
Male 35 70%
Female 15 30%
Total 50 100%
It is inferred from the table that 70% of the respondents are male and 30% of them are
females.
Table-2 Age
Age No. Percentage
From 20 to 30 25 50%
From 30 to 40 9 18%
From 40 to 50 3 6%
From 50 to 60 13 26%
Total 50 100%
It is seen from the table that majority of the respondents 56% are from potential insurable
age bracket of 20 to 30 years.
This project is based on certain objectives and seeks to find out as to how many
respondents have a Life Insurance Policy at present. It is noted that 92% of them have a
policy and the rest of them indicate potential customers for the company.
Table-4 Name of Life Insurance company from which the policy is bought
Life Insurance Company No Percentage
ICICI Prudential 37 80%
LIC 9 20%
Total 46 100%
The data indicates that majority of the respondents who have a life insurance policy have
purchased it from ICICI Prudential –80%. A small percentage of them have purchased
the policy from Life Insurance Corporation of India.
The table indicates that ICICI Prudential’s ‘LifeTime’ and ‘Retirement Solutions’ are
most preferred among all types of policies followed by ‘SmartKid’ policy. Among
policies of Life Insurance Corporation of India ‘Endowment’ seems to be the most
preferred policy.
This indicates the satisfaction level of policyholders in terms of service provided by the
company. It is inferred that a high percentage of respondents – 63% have a high level of
satisfaction and 37% of them stated that the level of satisfaction for policy service is
medium.
The data shows that majority of the respondents – 76% stated that private life insurance
companies are more trustworthy. A small percentage of them did not agree with this.
This infers that a majority of the respondents have faith in private life insurance
companies and hence have purchased policies from them.
39
Table-9 Why private life insurance companies are not trustworthy?
Reasons No. Percentage
Relatively new in India compared to LIC 5 42%
Liable for a shakeup 3 25%
Risk involved - Govt. policies could 1 8%
change
Fear of closure 1 8%
Exit norms are not widely 1 8%
known
Very complicated procedures 1 8%
Total 12 100%
This table indicates the reasons for the customers not having faith in private life
insurance companies. 42% of the respondents stated that private life insurance
companies are relatively new in India compared to Life Insurance Corporation of India
and 25% of them felt that private companies do not have a strong financial foundation.
The other reasons are fear of closure, risk involved and complicated procedures followed
by them.
This table shows the customer’s view about the prices of policies of private life
insurance companies. 90% of the respondents stated that the price is affordable. Only a
small percentage of them felt that the price is high.
This table shows the awareness level of ICICI Prudential among respondents. Data
shows that all respondents –100% are aware of ICICI Prudential.
Table-14 If you are aware of the policies of ICICI Prudential and other private
companies, your preference would be :
Preference No. Percentage
ICICI Prudential 45 90%
Other Private Companies 5 10%
Total 50 100%
This table shows the preference of customers to buy a life insurance policy of a particular
company. It is inferred that 90% of the respondents prefer policies of ICICI Prudential
and only 10% of them prefer other private companies. This shows that ICICI Prudential
forms the most preferred company among the private players.
42
Table-16 Extra value added features in ICICI Prudential’s policies
Extra Features No. Percentage
Wide range of options within the same policy 14 28%
Multiple benefits packed in a single policy 13 26%
Don't Know 12 24%
Good returns provided 10 20%
Flexibility 10 20%
Liquidity 4 8%
Different riders/top ups are provided 3 6%
Low lock in period 2 4%
Switching between options allowed free once 2 4%
every year
Policy details - easy to understand in the brochure 1 2%
Total 71 -
Note : Each respondent finds more than one value added feature in the policy
This shows the value-added features in policies of ICICI Prudential. Wide range of
options –28%, multiple benefits-26% and flexibility and good returns (20% each) seem
to be the most important value-added features. About 24% of the respondents are unable
to identify extra value-added features provided by ICICI Prudential.
Table-17 Ideas associated with the Life Insurance policy of ICICI Prudential
Meanings No. Percentage
Profitable mode of investment 26 52%
Max risk cover 21 42%
Multiple benefits 21 42%
Tax rebate 21 42%
Pre/during/after sale services 12 24%
Premium 4 8%
Total 105 -
Note : Respondents have more than one meaning associated with ICICI Prudential
The most important idea associated with insurance policy of ICICI Prudential is
profitable mode of investment (52%). Maximum risk cover and tax rebate are the other
meanings associated. 24% of the respondents have the sales service as a meaning
associated with ICICI Prudential.
43
Table-18 Rank the above manifestations of value in the order of merit
Manifestations of Value Rank (No. of respondents)
Max Risk Cover 38
Profitable Mode of Investment 34
Tax Rebate 29
Multiple Benefits 28
Premium 5
Pre/During/After Sales Service 7
The table shows that the most important value associated with the life insurance policy
of ICICI Prudential is maximum risk cover. The other values in the order of merit are
profitable mode of investment, tax rebate, multiple benefits, pre/during/after sales service
and premium.
Note : The total is not additive as the respondents have more than one value associated
with ICICI Prudential
Table-19 What do you feel about the premium policy of ICICI Prudential?
Particulars No. Percentage
High 5 13%
Low 1 3%
Affordable 31 84%
Total 37 100%
Note : The total represents respondents who have an ICICI Prudential policy
This shows the customer’s opinion about the premium policy of ICICI Prudential. It
indicates that 84% of the respondents felt that the policy is affordable. Only 13% of them
felt that the premium rate of policy is high.
The table indicates the quality of ICICI Prudential in terms of its value. 70% of the
respondents have rated the quality of ICICI Prudential as ‘High’ in terms of its value.
30% of them have rated the company’s quality as ‘Medium’. However no respondent felt
that the quality of the company is ‘Low’.
44
Table-21 Satisfaction with ICICI Prudential in policy servicing
Satisfaction No. Percentage
Yes 37 100%
No Nil -
Total 37 100%
Note :The total represents respondents who have a policy from ICICI Prudential
This table shows the satisfaction of customers with ICICI Prudential in servicing of
policies. All respondents (100%) who have policies from ICICI Prudential have
expressed satisfaction with respect to servicing of their policies.
This shows the popularity of ICICI Prudential growing day after day. 98% of the
respondents agreed about the growing popularity of ICICI Prudential while only 2% of
them disagreed.
45
Table-24 Reasons for its popularity
Reasons No. Percentage
Marketing strategy/Sales tactics 14 28%
adopted
Aggressive promotion 11 22%
Wide network of agents 10 20%
Established brand name 10 20%
Service level is good 6 12%
Superior product features 5 10%
Policies provides various benefits 4 8%
Good returns on policies 2 4%
Understand customers better 1 2%
Total 63 -
Note : The respondents have more than one reason for its popularity
The reasons that are most important for the popularity of ICICI Prudential are – the
marketing strategies adopted, aggressive promotion, its wide network of advisors,
established brand name in the order of merit. The other reasons are quality of service,
superior product features and various other benefits provided by policies.
Table-25 Do you recommend heavy dose of personnel selling for ICICI Prudential?
Recommend No. Percentage
Yes 20 40%
No 30 60%
Total 50 100%
It is seen from the table that 60% of the respondents do not recommend a heavy dose of
personnel selling for ICICI Prudential while only 40% of them seem to be in favor of a
heavy dose of personnel selling.
The opinion of all the respondents (100%) about the image of ICICI Prudential is
positive. None of the respondents felt that the company’s image is negative.
A majority of the policyholders (68%) do not recommend a policyholders club for ICICI
Prudential. Only 32% of them feel the need for it. The current policyholders may favor a
club in the future.
49
Table-36 Future outlook visualised for ICICI Prudential
Future Outlook No. Percentage
Increase in growth & profitability 50 4%
Good future ahead 20 40%
Quite bright 16 32%
Will remain as the No. 1 Pvt. Life 6 12%
Insurance company
Fabulous 4 8%
Will emerge as a powerful brand 1 2%
Future is challenging 1 2%
Total 98 -
Note : The respondents have more than one opinion about the future outlook
40% of the respondents state that ICICI Prudential has a good future ahead. 32% of them
stated that the future of the company is quite bright, 12% of them hope that ICICI
Prudential will remain as the leading private life insurance company. The remaining
respondents opined that ICICI Prudential would emerge as a powerful brand. 2% of them
stated that the future is challenging.
50