Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
In partial fulfillment
MARKSEV
K31
Submitted by:
Jimenez, Trina
Tan, Camille
Submitted to:
April 8, 2014
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. Executive Summary 3
V. Competitive Analysis 11
XIII. 8Ps 26
XVII. References 38
XVIII. Appendices 40
2
I. Executive Summary
Being 22 years in the business, the founders who developed the company had a
goal to give the public better and convenient low-cost lodging facilities. Having
numerous branches around the metro and in some provinces it is an advantage for
Hotel Sogo to be well-known nationally. Hotel Sogo is a major player in the Philippine
Motel Industry. Despite this, it is still behind its major competitor Victoria Court and
although both motels have the stigma of being highly sexual in a mostly conservative
country why does Hotel Sogo lag far behind? This paper seeks to answer that question
and more as well as give recommendations as to what should Hotel Sogo do to find a
The paper serves as a tool to further improve the marketability of Hotel Sogo by
knowing the industry and the usage, attitude and image of the brand. In this paper,
analysis regarding the company background, internal and external factors and, industry
analysis are integrated to form objectives and strategies to enhance the image of Hotel
Sogo. The paper presents series of results from the data they gathered from individuals
who live in and outside of Metro Manila and aged 18-25. The 32 respondents are
randomly selected but still fall under the category. The study is conducted from January-
3
III. Industry Analysis
History of Motels
The history of motels can be traced back to early 20th century America
people could travel much longer distances in their cars. Lodging was difficult to come by
in the more rural areas of the United States and so motels were created to satisfy this
growing need. The first motel was the Milestone Mo-Tel of San Luis Obispo and the
word was created by the combining of the terms Motorist and Hotel. After World War 2
the motel franchises and chains became much more popular (Cluskey, n.d.). This is
attributed to post-war prosperity as well as the demand for predictability in the quality of
motels.
In the Philippines the Motel Industry began post-World War 2 (Baking, 2010).
They weren't places for illicit affairs during that period but instead acted as places where
American soldiers could lodge. In the article the first authentic motel in the Philippines
was said to be established in Pasay. In the 1950s however, many American soldiers
returned to the United States and hotels began to be built in Manila. This forced the
motels to change their strategies and many began offering short time rates (rates of 1-3
hours). This is attributed in the article as due to the rise of bars and nightclubs in Manila.
it was during this period that they became known for illicit sexual affairs. Following the
rape of a woman in a motel the motels were then associated with crime as well. It was
4
only in the 1970s and 80s that motels tried to save their image. Many motels changed
their names to names such as Victoria Court,Capri and Bermuda. They remodeled their
According to the National Statistics Office of the Philippines the country had
around 1,475 lodging establishments in 2009, 89.3% of which were hotels and motels.
thereto for a fee and an establishment primarily located along the highway with
individual or common parking space at which motorists may obtain lodging and in some
instances meals, respectively. 19.7% of that percentage being found in the NCR which
has the largest share. Western and Central Visayas tie for second place at 12.7% and
CALABARZON follows at 9.5%. Besides having the highest share in terms of total
establishments, hotels and motels also have the highest share in terms of employees at
97.1% with males outnumbering females. NCR likewise also leads in this category by
holding 31.7% of all the employees. The hotel and motel industry is a multibillion peso
industry which generated 40.8 billion pesos in 2009, 13.1 billion of which come from
tourists. Motels are busiest in the month of February and November (NSCB, 2012) this
is suspected to be because of Valentine’s Day and Chinese New Year for the case of
February and All Saint’s Day and All Souls’ Day for the case of November.
5
Moreover, the boost in reported consumer spending in recent statistics offers
opportunities for motel industry players. This boost is indicative of an increase in the
industry players today face barriers to growth as a result of increased costs. Expansions
are put on hold due to difficulty landing vacant real estate lots for new motel buildings,
high electricity costs, and relatively high wages. Las also mentioned that the number of
Recently, the BIR has begun clamping down on the hotel and motel industry
(Remo, 2014) as they suspect large amounts of unpaid tax are hidden by these
establishments. This suspicion is due partly from motel Mariposa declaring a largest tax
due than the luxury hotel Ascott Makati. The BIR acknowledges that this will be a
Love Motels
adulterous spouses can have discreet sexual encounters.” Las of Hotel Sogo claims
that these types of hotels cater to the short-term market or the “sachet” market where
specific primary needs are satisfied, stating that "People have basic needs in their lives:
6
physical need, belongingness and accomplishment....They have to eat, wear clothes
However, the growth of love motels in the Philippines has also contributed to the
further degradation of the reputation of motels in the industry. According to Ian King,
General Manager of Victoria Court, “The normal connotation for a hotel is that it’s dark,
(Lowe, 2013). This long-standing reputation has made it difficult for players to change
Hotel Sogo was established in 1992 by two people who can only be described in
their official website as one hotel professional and one commercial developer and
"AAA" licensed contractor. The partners endeavoured to "satisfy the public's need for
better and more convenient low-cost lodging facilities." The hotel is Japanese-themed
and Teamwork. The chain also claims to merge these Japanese principles with the
The company envisions to lead and to dominate the lodging industry in the
profitably throughout the country, exceeding the expectations and earning the loyalty of
7
guests through excellent accommodations and superior service." It's core values are
[Ability], and Galang [Respect]. In fact, much of the attributes and values the company
stands for are actually embedded into its logo. Its namesake "Sogo" is a Japanese word
meaning unity and teamwork, brotherhood, cooperation and harmony. Also, their official
website explains: "the Sogo Lady gesture of the Sogo fan covering the mouth
symbolizes courtesy and service without question; the intertwined or interlacing letters
of the word Sogo symbolizes unity and teamwork; the sticks of the fan symbolizes the
people of Hotel Sogo and the paper that binds the fan together symbolizes the union in
a common vision of the Sogo family to dominate the walk-up hotel industry."
and 8 branches in provincial areas. A good number of branches are strategically located
near MRT and LRT stations so as to provide convenience to customers and potential
Davao.
The hotel essentially caters to the 20 to 40 age group in which 60% to 65% are
single, while 30% to 35% are married. About 70% to 80% of the guests are Filipino, but
according to CEO, Edmundo Las, the number of Koreans and Japanese guests is
growing.
8
It was reported that 70% of their market book rooms for less than 12 hours, while
12% to 15% stay for 12 hours and 10% stay 24 hours. The hotel's busiest times are
generally between 3 pm and 11 pm, with the highest number of guests in their Pasay,
Cubao, Caloocan, Guadalupe branches (Lowe, 2013). The company also states a 30%
normal increase in volume of guests during Valentine's season which warrants longer
shifts and no days off for the employees. December is the company's busiest month
being that it is a month-long holiday celebration and there exists an influx of Christmas
bonuses.
Hotel Sogo has an official website that contains information about the
establishment. This information includes its history, branches, food and beverages,
career opportunities, and training academy. It also offers a chat-room facility and a
survey function for customer inquiries and feedback although these are not yet working
as of this paper.
The hotel is very present on social media channels such as Facebook and
Twitter with over 17,000 likes and 2,000 followers, respectively, as of March 2014. The
campaigns that have created buzz amongst netizens all over the country.
Hotel Sogo is also present on the world’s largest travel website, Tripadvisor.com.
It rates a mere 26 percent out of an overall 100 percent, and ranks 33 out of 55 Manila
Bed & Breakfast or Inns on the website. Although it was often praised for its affordability
and proximity, a majority of its comments and reviews were negative. Some of these
9
negative comments include dirty rooms, thin walls that would allow one to hear
neighboring customers, poor-quality mattresses and pillows, slow and untrained staff
The hotel is also available on Agoda.com, one of the fastest-growing online hotel
platforms worldwide. On the website, however, the pages on bookings and reviews are
V. Competitive Analysis
Competition
Executive in Motorcycle
10
Rooms.
The cheapest price costs P565 the Zen rpom costs P369
and the highest price is P1225 and the suite costs P4,400.
the competitor.
rooms.
11
VI. TOWS Analysis
THREATS OPPORTUNITIES
4. Technological proficiency
WEAKNESSES STRENGTHS
THREATS:
1. Unwholesome image
In the modern days, people have this bad perception of motels and so most of the
Costs involving purchasing land constructing buildings are increasing. Moreover, these
12
3. Rebranding of competitors
Key industry players are beginning to direct their efforts towards trying to reshape and
OPPORTUNITIES:
which causes the purchasing power of the Filipinos to increase. Thus, people have the
Based on the 2012 Household Survey on Domestic Visitors, an estimated 25.7 million
Filipinos who are 15 years old and above had traveled to any place within the country
4. Technological proficiency
More Filipinos are become more technologically adept and familiar with the Internet and
Internet advertising.
13
5. Younger domestic travelers
According to a survey conducted by NSCB, out of the 25.7 million domestic travelers in
2012, 27.9 percent were in the age group 15 to 24, while 25.8 percent were in the age
group 25 to 34. The two age groups combined made up more than half or 53.7 percent
of the total domestic travelers.
WEAKNESSES:
1. Inconsistent offerings
The rates and number of rooms differ among Hotel Sogo branches, as well as the
A number of complaints were made about the unknowledgable and improperly trained
staff. Notably, the front desk employees, bell boys, and the cleaning staff.
Much was said about the quality of the structural features, equipment, and amenities
that the hotel offers. Notably, the thinness of the walls, the uncomfortable mattresses
and pillows, the low lighting concepts, and the unsatisfying food.
Hotel Sogo’s website is lacking in information such as that of room rates and available
rooms. Moreover, it has no reservation facility, nor is there any contact details available
14
for any of the branches. Also, there appears to be no consistency or direction as to the
Hotel Sogo reports a relatively low average number of guests during non-peak season
STRENGTHS:
Hotel Sogo is very present on social media channels such as Facebook and Twitter with
- A majority of Hotel Sogo’s branches are located near bus terminals and train stations.
3. Affordability
- Hotel Sogo has and is known for its cheap and affordable room rates.
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
15
public transportation 3. Low-quality structural
amenities
4. Cluttered, unfocused
online efforts
peak seasons
1. Increase in consumer
Responsibility
+ O5)
16
official website. (W4 + O1 +
O4 + O5)
4. Invest in quality
structural features,
(W3 + O1)
1. Unwholesome image
+ T3)
17
VIII. Porter’s Five Forces
The competitive pressure stemming from the threat of new entrants is low. Entry
barriers in the motel industry are very high since opening motels entail large capital
investments and high operations and utilities costs. Also, slow cost recovery rates may
not be attractive to potential entrants. Moreover, big time players such as Hotel Sogo
and Victoria Court have a very firm hold on the market. It should be mentioned however
that there are multiple micro level lodging facilities in Metro Manila however they are not
large enough to pose a threat to the industry giants Hotel Sogo and Victoria Court.
2. Threat of Substitutes
Substitutes like hotels provide the motel industry with the most competition,
claiming 21.1% of the total income generated from lodging establishments (NSCB,
2012). Hotels provide customers with the same or even better quality service and
amenities. Hostels and dormitories are also a big threat to the motel industry, which, in
spite of their shared living quarters concept, provide low rates while satisfying short term
The pressure stemming from the bargaining power of buyers in the motel
industry is relatively high. Most drive-in motels rely on the affordability of their lodging
18
4. Bargaining Power of Suppliers
The bargaining power of suppliers in the motel industry is high due to the short
supply of available land and particularly prime real estate to build and expand on. This
gives the landowners more leverage in terms of setting prices. However, suppliers of
construction materials do not much have leverage because their offerings are relatively
Key industry players in the motel industry have been very active in terms of
coming up with new ways to improve their market standing and business performance,
increasing competition among them. Both Hotel Sogo and Victoria Court have been
been very aggressive in releasing advertisements and promotional materials about their
special promos and their themed-rooms. Victoria Court has even endeavoured to
extend their target market by advertising their themed rooms as venues for parties and
19
IX. Fishbone Diagram
Information
Although the rates of Hotel Sogo are shown on the website they are difficult to
find and they only show the rates for 12 hours and 24 hours for weekday and weekend
rates. Pictures of the rooms of only the Malate branch are shown while all the others
have stale images of the branch most of the time with poor lighting and occasionally
Procedures
The inconsistent prices also reflect the inconsistent services of Hotel Sogo.
Filipinos seem to be more tolerant of the low and inconsistent quality of services
20
compared to foreigners. Walk-in clients are the most common as you cannot reserve at
Hotel Sogo.
Backstage Personnel
Sanitation is horrible in Hotel Sogo, with the time between room turnovers not
Frontstage Personnel
towards them and in some extreme cases indifferent to illegal activities going on in their
branches.
The rooms are not maintained well and several customers of Hotel Sogo
complain of the lack of hot water and noisy air conditioning units. This clearly shows the
need for Hotel Sogo to allocate a greater amount of their budget to maintenance and
purchasing of new equipment. The televisions also provide pornographic channels and
this helps promote the idea of Hotel Sogo being a place where socially-unacceptable
The mattresses in Hotel Sogo are said to resemble “Thick Plastic” and the bed
sheets quite thin and provide no warmth. The food is grossly unappealing and this
21
causes customers to feel as though they had been misled by Hotel Sogo’s food
advertisements.
Other Customers
Most of the problems stem from patrons of Hotel Sogo who carry out illegal
activities. Prostitution, pimping and rape stories help tarnish the brand image of Hotel
Sogo. As long as these activities still continue Hotel Sogo will have a very difficult time
Other Causes
Although the locations of the branches are in prime real estate, such as near
major avenues and close to bus and train terminals, this also leads to other problems as
well. The pollution due to the heavy traffic that passes through these areas makes the
maintenance of cleanliness extremely difficult. The fact that it is highly accessible also
means that unscrupulous characters can use it for their socially-unacceptable activities.
Worst of all however is that high exposure to these harsh conditions jade the frontstage
and backstage personnel to their existence and hence make them far less hospitable
ages of 18-25.
22
2. Improve brand preference by 25% through better standardization of services
1. Have the largest market share of the motel industry in the Metro Manila area of
2. Have the Greatest Brand Recognition in the Greater Manila Area among people aged
18-25.
Demographics
Although Hotel Sogo caters specifically to Filipinos within the age range of 20-40
we would like to specifically target the age range of 18-25 of the social class lower and
upper C. The primary reason being they are young and impressionable enough to
change their views on Hotel Sogo. The older generation may hold onto the negative
stereotypes of the brand too much and hence spending time and money to change their
23
Psychographics
These would most likely be college students and would mostly function on a
student budget. They probably commute home from school or rent small condos near
their universities or terminals or train stations. Since they operate on student budgets
and starting salaries, they should be very price sensitive and would most likely only stay
in Hotel Sogo in groups, as splitting the bill would make it much more affordable.
Most of our respondents use the internet more than the television. On average
they spend 5.6 hours daily on the internet and only 1.83 hours on the television. They
spend 2.12 hours on the road everyday and this would explain why billboards are one of
the most common ways they are informed of Hotel Sogo. This may also explain why
most of them see it in the morning as it may be a staple of their daily drive/commute to
Behavior
them with a mean rating of 4.63, slightly above privacy which is rated at 4.6. Security
follows at 4.5 and given Hotel Sogo’s reputation as a place where illegal activities take
place this may be one of the most challenging but rewarding characteristics to change.
Food is one of the lowest rated characteristics at 3.57 and shows that motels are places
that this target market would prefer to sleep in rather than to eat in.
24
XII. Target Person
Profile
recently landed his first job as a management trainee and is excited to be making his
own income for the first time in his life. He loves to travel, and along with his closest
friends, have set out to explore the different travel spots in the Philippines. A self-
proclaimed adventurer, he gets a thrill out of visiting new places. He is always on top of
planning out of town trips and often keeps tabs on Piso Fares and discounts in hotel
lodging online.
XIII. The 8 Ps
Existing:
1. Product Elements
There are three main types of rooms in Hotel Sogo: Taxi Rooms, Garage Rooms,
and Motorcycle Rooms. The names of the rooms are dependent on the form of
transportation you took going there. Taxi rooms have three classes: Regular, Deluxe,
and the Regency. Garage rooms also have three types: Regular, Deluxe, and the Mega
Suite. Lastly, Motorcycle rooms only have two classes, namely, the Deluxe and the
Executive. Each room comes with a bed, television, bathroom and toiletries. They also
offer food such as Pancit Canton Spring Rolls, Grilled Pork Belly and Grilled Beef with
Red Curry Sauce. The person delivering the food up to the customers room is given
25
enough change to accommodate any amount of payment, and if the change is not given
The Prices in Hotel Sogo widely vary from branch to branch, although all seem
uniform in charging more for weekend stays than weekend stays. In the website the
only prices listed are those for 12 hours and those for 24 hours however the prices of
each kind of room is mostly given. Appendix C contains the price list of the Mabini,
Hotel Sogo has 22 branches within Metro Manila and 9 branches in the provincial
areas. Of the 22 branches in Metro Manila, 11 are located near avenues and 6 are
located along Epifanio de Los Santos avenue which is a major bloodline in Metro
Manila. They are open 24 hours and they maintain an official website, Facebook page
and Twitter page. They are also present on travel website, TripAdvisor, and hotel
platform website, Agoda. Our survey finds that Accessibility is rated the highest among
Hotel Sogo’s characteristics with a mean score of 5.14 with the highest possible score
being 7.
Sogo promotes mostly on flyers, banners and occasionally billboards. They also
promote heavily on taxis, pedicabs and other forms of public transportation. They also
26
5. Productivity and Quality
The Hotel Sogo website has a chat room function for inquiries and a survey
facility that isn’t functioning. In the rooms proper, text feedback instructions are posted
6. Process
Hotel Sogo is easily accessible as its branches are located close to public
transportation like trains and are alongside jeepney and taxi routes. Locating the check-
in desk was difficult, however, getting a room was pretty quick. A card key is issued a
few minutes after request and one is directed towards the room almost immediately
after. For checking out one only needs to go back to the counter and inform the
7. Physical Evidence
The motel issues a written invoice as proof of stay. However, in our experience,
the check-in staff neglected to give us the invoice at first and we were forced to ask for
it.
8. People
Security guards are positioned at the gates of each entrance of the motel. They
direct vehicles where to park within the complex. The receptionists were not very
friendly, accommodating and willing in terms of providing information about the motel.
The check-in ladies seemed disoriented and unsure about the check-in process and
27
especially about the receipt process. Customers seemed mostly from the upper and
Proposed:
1. Product Elements
packages will be established in partnership with local tourist attractions or sites. This will
the motels will help lessen the negative feedback from customers and improve their
28
7. Additional windows
9. Air deodorants
an increase in price is proposed in order to cover costs. This move is reinforced by the
quality. Moreover, prices will be collated and posted for the convenience of customers.
Website Improvement
pleasing and user-friendly. A reservation facility will also be established wherein all of
the motel’s room descriptions, images and rates will be collated to be viewed by website
visitors. Links to various online travel guides will be available as well as available
more investment.(Appendix B)
Sogo’s features that cater to the needs and wants of domestic travelers who visit tourist
29
spots closely located to specific Hotel Sogo branches. These advertisements will be
placed in strategic locations in both urban and rural areas of the Philippines, as well as
To further the cleaning up of the image of the hotel, Hotel Sogo will diversify its
The marketing team of the hotel will spearhead an attempt to increase brand
recognition and awareness, as well as communicate its attempt at a new image to the
target consumers by contracting travel bloggers and online critics to come to Hotel Sogo
and blog about their experiences. These bloggers will also throw contests and the like
More than the online feedback and inquiry facilities and text feedback
instructions, a suggestion box will be put up at the check-in counter and a hotline will be
established for the purpose of customer care and feedback. The survey section of the
30
6. Process
website. This will provide even faster check-ins and efficient querying. Also, brochures
(Appendix B) of room types with corresponding images and rates should be made
7. Physical Evidence
8. People
The lack of courtesy and knowledge of the staff is concerning and should be
dealt with accordingly. Hotel Sogo will invest in hospitality and service seminars and
31
XIV. Flower of Service
Existing:
32
Proposed:
33
XV. Investment Plan
Budget
34
XVI. Estimates of Profitability
35
XVI. References
Albert, J. (2012). Single Pinoys and Pinays: Are you ready to Mingle?. Retrieved on
February 24, 2014 from
http://www.nscb.gov.ph/beyondthenumbers/2013/02082013_jrga_marital.asp
Cluskey, J. (n.d.). History of the Motel. Retrieved on March 30, 2014 from
http://www.jimmccluskey.com/history-of-the-motel/
Hotel Sogo. (n.d.). About Us. Retrieved on February 24, 2014 from
http://hotelsogo.com/aboutus.html
Lowe, A. (2013, February). The Economics of Love Motels. Retried on February 24,
2014 from
http://www.rappler.com/business/21746-the-economics-of-sexy-love-motels
National Statistics Office. (2012, January). Final Results Tourism Establishments in the
Philippines (STEP) Accomodation. Retrieved on February 24, 2014 from
http://www.census.gov.ph/old/data/sectordata/sr12665tx.html
Remo, M. (2014, February). No TINs, No Taxes: BIR goes after motels. Retrieved on
February 24, 2014 from
http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/579345/no-tins-no-taxes-bir-goes-after-motels
Trip Adviser (n.d.). Hotel Sogo. Retrieved February 24, 2014 from
http://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g298452-d1627943-Reviews-Hotel_Sogo-
Pasay_Metro_Manila_Luzon.html
Urban Dictionary. (n.d.). Urban Dictionary. Retrieved February 24, 2014 from
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Love%20Motel
Villegas, D. (2011, February). Philippine Love Motels. Retrieved February 24, 2014 from
http://dennisvillegas.blogspot.com/2011/02/philippine-love-motels.html
36
XVII. Appendices
37
Have you ever tried going to these motels you mentioned?
Which one have you visited recently? Which ones have you seen in ads?
38
How did you see them? When did you see them?
Accessibility Hospitality
39
Security Food
Cleanliness Privacy
Price
40
Rate the characteristics of Hotel Sogo:
Accessibility Hospitality
Security Food
Cleanliness Privacy
41
Price
42
APPENDIX B - Creative Executions
43
44
Sogo Adventure Billboard
45
Sogo Website
46
Sogo Brochure
47
APPENDIX C - Price List
APPENDIX - Branches
48
49
APPENDIX E - UAI Questionnaire
50
51
52