Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
This idea became my dilemma when I was given a new set of tasks and duties
after several years of service in the Operating Room (OR) of the biggest government
hospital in the province of Nueva Ecija, Dr. Paulino J. Garcia Memorial Research and
without any experience of being an understudy in this area, it was my serendipity that
2
paved the way to my successful supervisory journey, a middle level managerial position,
in the same area where I was working for years, in the Operating Room.
The start of my supervisory journey was never easy; it was rough, and it was my
serendipity, my destiny and fate, that smoothened the way. But before I would delve
deeply into my serendipitous experiences, let me state briefly that just recently while I
Nurse, primarily in charge of infection control, an assignment, I was not sure if I could
perform well and was reluctant to accept. But as a trained nurse, I accepted the
assignment and the challenge. And I tried to carry it on with my reflections of my past
organize my staff in the OR so that they could carry on smoothly with their tasks without
me. My schedule then was: in the morning I stayed outside the OR to do my surveillance
tasks, and in the afternoon I had to go back to the OR to wear my other hat - a task I did
the other areas of the hospital where I worked with, were similar. But later on, I
supplies needed for every procedure. It also required skills in communication and
coordination with the surgical health team to smoothen the traffic in OR scheduling.
and younger generations of nurse-supervisors is the main intent of this study hoping that
through this sharing, they will become more equipped in their journey towards
3
supervisorship; that they can easily cope with the challenges and difficulties they might
encounter as they continue with their supervisory journey especially in an area in the
This section contains the summaries of the related literature and studies that
provided support to this investigation. They were presented by themes or topics for ease
a product or providing a service. Then unexpectedly, the new supervisor is facing a whole
new range of responsibilities, many of which have little to do with technical expertise.
Sometimes they are intimidated by a wide range of policies and procedures. The
new supervisor is suddenly faced with a wide range of rules and regulations - each of
which the supervisor is responsible to carry out. The supervisor is in charge for signing
time cards, authorizing overtime, granting compensation time, dealing with performance
grievances, conforming to a complicated pay system, and many others depending on the
New supervisors rarely have enough time. Management activities are so hectic
and demanding. No matter how systematic the planning, managers rarely get to spend
goes on in their group. They don't want to encounter any surprises. So they spend more
time reading, thinking, planning, communicating with employees. New supervisors often
spend 60 hours a week on the job. Still, they don't feel they have enough time to do the
job right.
New supervisors often feel very alone. This is because the supervisor is
responsible to be an advocate for the organization and at the same time an advocate for
the employee. There are instances that the supervisor became stuck in the middle. For
example, if the organization implements an unpopular new policy, the supervisor is often
responsible to communicate and justify that new policy to the employee. In this case,
management expects the supervisor to present and support the new policy, and the
employee vents his or her frustration to the supervisor. However, if the supervisor wants
to promote the employee or present some other reward, he or she is representing the
New supervisors often feel overwhelmed, and stressed out. Since, they are
responsible, for the first time, for the activities of another employee, they must ensure the
employee knows his or her job, has the resources to do the job and does the job as
effectively as possible.
The stress and loneliness in the role of new supervisors can bring out the worst in
them. If they deal with stress by retreating, they retreat to their offices and close the door.
5
If they deal with frustration, they become angry and unreasonable with their employees.
If they are used to getting strong praise and high grades, they work harder and harder
ongoing coaching and support. They need someone whom they can confide in. Ideally,
they have a mentor in the organization who remembers what it's like to be a first-time
supervisor, someone who makes himself or herself available. If the experience of first-
time supervisor is successful, this is challenging, but fulfilling. The supervisor goes on to
of new supervisors; hence, this study is rare; this is an original piece of work dedicated to
beneficial events and experiences which occur in the dispense of my duties and
which are vital in honing my supervisory skills. Said experiences are the main focus of
this study.
Room of the biggest government hospital in the province of Nueva Ecija be described?
2. What learnings (themes) can be derived from the said experiences?
6
3. How may the Manual for beginning nurse-supervisors be designed based on the
PJGMRMC, for 15 years, rising from the ranks of nurses in the said hospital with OR
nursing as my specialty.
This autobiographical research was two years in the making, year 2015 to 2016.
The following persons and groups may in one way or another be benefited from
the study:
supervisors in their day-to-day activities making them at par with what is expected of
them.
Hospital administrators. The Manual for new nurse- supervisors may guide
nurse and hospital administrators in designing programs that may help unit managers in
experiences as a nurse-supervisor which are worth sharing to new and upcoming nurse-
supervisors. The benefit that others may gain from this sharing is my noble contribution -
Future researchers. It is hoped that through this study, they will be guided as to
Conceptual Framework
This study on the serendipity of supervisorship was made possible through deep
PJGMRMC (Input). As I reflected on them, I wrote them down as well to have a concrete
basis in my analysis and in the generation of themes or meanings (Process) upon which a
Manual for beginning nurse-supervisors (Output) was designed to guide them in their
Research Design
8
The researcher used the qualitative research design adopting some principles of
phenomenology and autobiographical research using life narrative.. This research design
is appropriate for this study which focused mainly on one of the most challenging
Those topics that are central to people’s lived experiences are best suited for
phenomenological research.
collecting different facts in various narrative contexts and also of participating in the
phenomenology using Colaizzi’s steps (cited by Bertram and Magnusen, 2008) which is
guided by the preposition that there are basic structures within each unique human
experience. Its goal is to gain a description of an experience from the participant’s point
content.
2. Extracting significant statements; statements related to my work experiences
(referring back and forth throughout the data to validate the themes); the
similar to the protocols earlier identified. These themes were validated many
statements including the formulated meanings and the cluster of themes were
years and another eight years as an OR Head Nurse in one of the most challenging areas
in the hospital, the Operating Room. I believed it was worth sharing for others to emulate
10
or for them to have bases for critical assessment of what I did or failed to do.
The longest time of my career was spent in the operating room where I worked as
a staff nurse for 13 years, then as a head or senior nurse for eight years, and then as an
comprised the highlight of my nursing career, and said experiences were made the center
of this investigation.
I became a staff nurse in the OR through the very kind endorsement of my then
immediate supervisor. I did not expect that I would become an OR nurse. In fact, I did not
know if it was an advantage for me. What I knew was that an OR nurse must be smart,
fast worker, composed when working under tension, and could render sound judgement
during emergencies.
which means that it could only admit and do limited OR cases but the challenge I had to
face was to make the schedule of surgical procedures done efficiently and effectively
familiarization with the different instruments and equipment. I assisted the health team in
handling OR patients and as months and years passed by, I attended and handled different
post-operative procedures.
My early journey in the OR was very stressful. I became disoriented in the set-up,
instruments and equipment. I was always in a hurry and in distress thinking how I could
11
cope up with a lot of things to learn. Besides, I had to deal with the different members of
the health team - the surgeon, the anaesthesiologist, the internist and pediatrician.
Being an OR nurse is not easy because of the full responsibility in dealing with
life; the success of the surgical procedures largely depends on the OR nurse, so as one of
the health team members, I made sure that everything was in good condition. I had to
abundance of supplies, the safety of patients and environment, and compliance with
procedures and became familiar with the different instruments, equipment and supplies
needed for every OR patient and procedure. The training which I went through was rigid
because of the nature of the tasks and functions I had to perform. But I was glad that
when I was assigned in the OR, I already had mastery of the basic nursing skills which I
gained through my previous exposure in some of the critical areas in the Hospital. This
previous exposure made me familiar with all the members of the health care team.
After 13 years of service as a staff nurse in the OR, I was lucky to be elevated to a
higher position, as senior OR nurse or head nurse. As a head nurse, besides rendering
bedside nursing care, I had to teach and orient new OR nurses, trainees and students.
welcomed the position unmindful of the added responsibilities I would be dealing with
such as handling subordinates, teaching, supervising and leading them while I still did a
handful of other tasks, and worst, serving as a model to them. I encountered conflict
stress/distress that I managed to deal with.. As a head nurse, I had to guard my emotions
12
because some of the patients had to go, and I had to learn to be strong and firm so that I
could explain very well to the patients’ families what had happened and why it happened
and what possibilities were explored. Here, my use of judgement was improved and my
After all the hard work and the struggles that I went through for many years, I was
because in this new job. My main concern was to take care of the concerns of others (my
staff nurses) who were placed under my care, no longer my concern to myself and how I
could render direct care to my patients to the best of my ability. In other words, I had to
learn some managerial and leadership skills such as planning, organizing, directing,
I was also able to manage a healthy and a happy family, a task I did not know I could do
became wider, unlike when I was a senior nurse or head nurse where I only dealt with my
Supervisor. I felt that my superior had just no choice for the position that I applied for and
which fortunately I got. I was challenged to apply for this position since I wanted to
prove that I was capable enough to handle such position. Aside from my professional
reports and records on census; consumption; and inventory of equipment, materials, and
accomplish all of them and be able to submit them the following day. This happened
because my previous supervisor left the area without any endorsement at all, no files and
no reports.
when they scolded me in the presence of my subordinates and trainees, and I cried and
felt depressed and so sad. Although I was emotionally disturbed at that time, I continued
my daily routine as new supervisor while adjusting and discovering little by little how it
was to be a supervisor. My struggles and difficulties did not stop me from doing the
also felt the rivalry of gaining the trust of my staff with my superior which later on
resulted to hardship in leading them. There were times when I felt helpless and isolated
thinking that even my co-supervisors were not near and close to me, but I remained
supervisor. Because of my desire to gain the trust of my subordinates, I just worked hard
and did my job as supervisor the best way I could. I tried to get along with them and
joined them outside our hospital work, little by little I began to gain their trust. I had
communication skills with the healthcare team and I learned to handle different cases
more confident and proficient, although, up to the conduct of this study, I still
14
and co-workers.
While I was in the OR, I also witnessed changes in nursing leadership in the
Hospital. I experienced being with three chief nurses and I learned a lot from each of
them.
profession, my love for my work and the enduring support and assistance of my husband
Theme 1: Passion for the profession and enduring family support are ingredients for
work survival.
below:
in spite of all the challenges that came my way. It was my passion for the
profession that kept me going - passion for serving others. It may be difficult at times, but
Vallerand, Salvy, Mageau, Elliot, Denis, Grouzet, and Blanchard (2007) defined
passion as a strong inclination towards an activity that an individual likes and considers
important, and invests considerable time and energy in it. Passion represents the energy
underlying such persistent involvement. Being passionate for an activity leads individuals
to dedicate themselves fully to their activity, thereby allowing them to persist, even in the
Passion for my work made me persevere, adapted to the work and became a
Aside from passion, I had a very strong family support, a support system that
enabled me to continuously move on and pursue higher level of work goals and not being
participate in further training and professional development. One study demonstrated that
support in the family domain positively affects behavior in the work domain, and the
ways individuals deal with conflicting demands from both domains (Adams, King, &
King, 1996; Van Daalen, Willemsen, & Sanders, 2006; Wayne, Randel, & Stevens, 2006
I could say that family support especially my spouse plays a vital role in my work
success. “My passion for my work and family support served as contributing
factors for me to stay in the hospital for a long period of time” leading to the
Much of what is known and understood has been learned through experience.
Whether time is spent in classrooms or having experiences out in the world, much of
OR nurse for 13 years and head nurse for eight years are long enough for me to observe
what my previous OR supervisors had been doing. These made the supervisory
office, and the very reason why I did not give-up in the midst of challenges and
difficulties. Such supervisory challenges could have been insurmountable had I not been
Experience is not just about learning new skills – it is about exploring ourselves as
individuals. As years passed by, I learned to cope with the challenges. In verbatim:
Competent - typified by the nurse who has been on the job in the same or similar
situations two or three years; begins to see his or her actions in terms of long-ranged
17
goals or plans; conscious and deliberate planning characteristic helps achieve efficiency
and organization; lacks the speed and flexibility of the proficient nurse.
each situation; operates from a deep understanding of the total situation; performance is
highly proficient.
There were times when they scolded me in the presence of my subordinates and
supervisor while adjusting and discovering little by little how it was to be a supervisor.
My struggles and difficulties did not stop me from doing my work. In verbatim: “There
were times when I felt helpless and isolated, but I remained composed and I demonstrated
my power as supervisor”.
public, that:
When the inevitable challenges do cross your path, do not allow yourself to
feel overwhelmed. Accept them and realize that they are integral part of the
learning process, needed to allow you to grow into the person you need to
be to attract the success you desire. Challenges are often the very catalysts,
which will reveal all the hidden possibilities, which you may have missed,
had you not encountered the challenge.
“If there is a will, there is a way”, this proverb teaches us that if we really are
determined to do something (whether easy or tough), we can do it. Sometimes the task
may be too difficult, however the strong “will power” will help us to confront all the
difficulties and will find many ways toward the ladder of success..
supervisors for survival. This is in addition to the supervisory tips that abound in
Conclusion
19
work, family support, fruitful experiences and the will to overcome challenges in the
profession.
Recommendation
I recommend that the Manual which I designed and proposed for new supervisors
be published even in local papers or website of the Graduate School to serve its intended
purpose.
REFERENCES
from:http://www.rela.ep.liu.se/issues/10.3384_rela.2000-
7426.201231/rela0051/rela0051.pdf
McNamara, C. (2017) Typical Experience of a First-Time
Supervisor
from: http://managementhelp.org/supervision/getting-
started.htm
Serendipity. (n.d). Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary
from:
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/serendipity
Smith, 2012 (cited by Lawlor, 2014).
Good Social Work Supervision
from :
http://www.disabilitygauteng.org/newsletters/2017%2004/
08_NEWSLETTER_APR17.htm
Vallerand,R.J.,Salvy, S.J., Mageau, G., Elliot, A.J.,
21