Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
By
M. LAKSHMAN
M. V. Sc.,
DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY
(IN THE FACULTY OF VETERINARY SCIENCE)
AUGUST, 2011
i
CERTIFICATE
high standard to warrant its presentation to the examination. I also certify that the
thesis or part thereof has not been previously submitted by him for a degree of any
University.
Major Advisor
Date:
Place: Hyderabad (Dr. Y. ANJANEYULU)
Associate Professor
Department of Veterinary Pathology
College of Veterinary Science
Rajendranagar, Hyderabad-30.
ii
CERTIFICATE
(Dr. Y. ANJANEYULU)
Chairman of the Advisory Committee
iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
It gives me immense pleasure to express my deep sense of reverence and gratitude to my
major advisor Dr. Y. Anjaneyulu, Associate Professor, Department of Veterinary Pathology,
College of Veterinary Science, Rajendranagar, Hyderabad, for his profound interest, valuable
guidance, concrete suggestions, constant encouragement and constrictive criticism in planning
and presentation of the investigation reported in this thesis.
I express my heartfelt gratitude and deep sense of reverence to member of my advisory
committee Dr. Ch. Srilatha, Professor and University Head, Department of Veterinary
Pathology, College of Veterinary Science, Tirupati for her inspiring and affectionate guidance,
unending benevolence and constant encouragement during my research.
I humbly place on record my heartfelt thanks to Dr. T. S. Chandrasekhar Rao, Associate
Dean, College of Veterinary Science, Tirupati, for his clear and concrete ideas at basic stage of
research.
I shall remain grateful to Dr. D. Srinivasulu, Professor and University Head,
Department of Veterinary Science, College of Veterinary Science, Tirupati, for his cordiality and
the help which is green in remembrance during my Ph.D. studies.
I am extremely thankful to Dr. M.R. Reedy, Principal Scientist and his team PDP,
Rajendranagar, Hyderabad, for their involvement and able guidance to carry out molecular
studies in their laboratory.
I express my sincere thanks to the Head Department of Pathology and staff of the
laboratory, SVIMS, Tirupati, for extension of their help to carry out Immunohistochemistry
work in their laboratory.
I am immensely thankful to Dr. Ch. Ramakrishna, Scientist, NRCM, Changicherla,
Hyderabad, for his co-operation to carry out histopathological studies in his laboratory.
I am very grateful to Dr. A. Anand Kumar, Associate Professor& Head and
Dr. M. Maduri, Associate Professor, Department of Pathology, College of veterinary Science,
Rajendranagar, Hyderabad for their support.
I humbly place my sincere gratitude to the staff of RUSKA Labs, College of Veterinary
Science, Rajendranagar, Hyderabad for their involvement to carry out the experiment of my
Ph.D. Research Project.
I am grateful to Dr. Krishna Kumar, Reader Loyola Degree College, Secundrabad and
Dr. P. Anand Kumar, Associate Professor and Head Department of Microbiology, NTR College
iv
of Veterinary Science Gannavaram, for their appropriate guidance in research and preparation
thesis manuscript.
I shall be ever thankful to Dr. S.T. Viroji Rao and Dr. Chinni Pritham, for their help to
carry out their statistical analysis of my research work.
I am extremely thankful to Dr. K. Sujatha, Dr. Shashidar Babu, and Dr. K. Sathish
Assistant Professors, Department Pathology, College of Veterinary Science, Tirupati, for their
co-operation during my course of study.
I take it is privilege to express my heartfelt thanks and gratitude to my beloved kids
Mekela Bharath, Rachana, and Yashvanth for their love and affection constant inspection
great tolerance at the inconvenience and co-operation extended during my Doctoral programme.
Rhetoric is not enough to express my gratitude and regards from my inner core of the
heart to my beloved wife late Smt. M. Malathi and my mother late Smt. M. Venkatamma for
their whole hearted co-operation, constant encouragement, unstinted patience, caring love &
affection and cheerfulness during my course work and I lost them before completion of my
research, hence I am dedicating this basic scientific material to committed scientific community
in the honor of my wife and mother. Which enable me to acquire the present qualification,
further I express my happiness and sincere thanks to my father M. Anjaiah for his constant
approach and taking care of kids during my research project and analysis of the data, in his
absence it would have not been possible to shape the thesis work.
I express my deep sense of reverence to my beloved friend whose cardial love, affection
and constant encouragement helped me to complete my Doctoral programme and brace the
difficult situations.
I am happy to express my sincere gratitude to Mr. M. Karimullah Technician,
Department of Pathology, for his help and co-operation.
I express my love and worm regards to my brothers, sisters, in-laws and relatives whose
affection and encouragement helped me in completion of present investigation.
I take this opportunity to convey my thanks to Mr. Srikanth palavai, for his help in
preparation of quality images in befitting manner.
I thank the Sri Venkateswara Veterinary University for extending financial support
that enabled me to complete my research work.
(M.LAKSHMAN)
v
DECLARATION
the result of original research work carried done by me. I also declare that the
LIST OF CONTENTS
vi
Chapt.
Title Page No.
No.
I INTRODUCTION 1-4
vii
Prevention of TD by addition of CuSo4 hepato protective
2.14 35-36
agents and toxin binder
III MATERIALS AND METHODS 37-49
3.3 Haematology 39
viii
3.10.3 cDNA synthesis (for one reaction) 46
IV RESULTS 50-122
ix
4.6 Biochemical parameters 63
4.8 Morphometry 71
4.9.1 VEGF 75
4.9.2 VEGFR1 75
4.9.3 Bcl-2 75 & 78
4.9.4 MMP-2 78
4.9.5 MMP-3 78
x
4.10.2 Gross pathology of liver and kidney 79 & 81
4.11 Histopathology 81
Histopathology of tibial bones growth plate cartilage
4.11.1 81-88
(TGPC) employed H&E
Histopathology of tibial bones growth plate cartilage
4.11.2 88 & 95
(TGPC) employed Koneff’s satin
4.11.3 Histopathology of liver 95 & 97
V DISCUSSION 128-148
xi
5.4.1 Total erythrocyte count (TEC) 129-130
xii
5.12 Ultra structural pathology 143
Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) of tibial growth
5.12.1 143 -145
plate cartilage
5.12.2 Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) of liver 145 -146
VI SUMMAERY 149-152
xiii
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
Fig.1
Fig.4
Fig.5
Apparently healthy birds
Fig.6
Fig.9
Fig.10
Fig.7 Birds on sternal recumbency, sitting on hock joints and back ward
stretching of legs
xiv
Fig.12 Birds sitting on hock joints and mild back ward stretching of legs
xv
Fig.1 Graph showing glucose (g/dl)
Fig.1 C
Graph showing T values of VEGF gene expression
xvi
Fig.2 Graph showing CT values of VEFGR1 gene expression
Fig.3 C
Graph showing T values of Bcl-2 gene expression
Fig.1 C
Graph showing T values of MMP2 gene expression
Fig.1 Abnormal shortening and bending of tibial bones of group II,VII and
XII in comparison with other groups- 1st week
Fig.5 Abnormal size, shape and color of liver and kidney of group
II,III,VII,VIII,IX,XI and XII in comparison with other groups -1st
week
Fig.6 Abnormal size, shape and color of liver and kidney of group
II,III,VII,VIII,IX,XI and XII in comparison with other groups -5th
week
Fig.1 Group I: Section showing dilated blood vessel with blood. Note the
chondrocytes arrangement in rows with centrally placed nuclei.
H&E:50µm
Fig.2 Group III: Section showing few chondrocytes with swollen nucleus
and pyknotic nuclei in some. Also note many empty chondrocytes
that are oval shaped. H&E:50µm
xvii
Fig.3 Group IV: Section showing dilated blood vessel with blood. Note the
arrangement of chondrocytes in clusters which are small with
pyknotic nuclei. H&E:100µm
Fig.5 Group VIII: Section showing numerous blood vessels which are
empty. Clusters of tightly packed chondrocytes are seen with dense
nuclei. H&E:200µm
Fig.6 Group X: Section showing dilated blood vessel with blood. Clusters
of chondrocytes are seen with swollen and varied stages of nucleus.
H&E:50µm
Fig.2 Group III: Section showing swollen distorted chondrocytes that are
arranged in helter shelter manner. Also observe majority of
chondrocytes which are empty and few with pyknotic nuclei.
H&E:50µm
Fig.3 Group IV: Section showing dilated vessel with congestion. Few
chondrocytes distorted and distributed in helter shelter manner while
few are oval with pyknotic nuclei and few are empty. H&E:50µm
Fig.2 Group III: Section showing swollen empty oval shaped chondrocytes
xviii
and few chondrocytes are seen with pyknotic nuclei. H&E:25µm
Fig.4 Group V: Section showing large dilated vessel filled with blood.
Chondrocytes are seen in clusters having distorted eosinophilic
nucleus. H&E: 50µm
Fig.5 Group VIII: Section showing numerous emerging and dilated blood
vessels. Note the arrangement of chondrocytes in rows with dark and
pyknotic nuclei. Few cells are with eosinophilic nuclei while few are
empty. H&E: 100μm
Fig.6 Group IX: Section showing numerous emerging vessels with blood.
Note the swollen, distorted chondrocytes distributed in helter shelter
manner. Few cells are oval with pyknotic nuclei, chromatolysis, and
faint matrix. Other cells are empty. H&E: 100μm
xix
23 Photomicrographs of histopathological changes of cartilage in birds of 91
different experimental groups - 3rd week
Fig.3 Group III: Section showing few swollen chondrocytes with pyknotic
nuclei. Majority of the chondrocytes are in clusters and empty, they
are in clusters. Also note the large dilated blood vessel. H&E:50µm
Fig.9 Group IX: Section showing chondrocytes are arranged in rows and
clusters. Few cells showing pyknotic nucleus with karyorrhexis.
Also note few empty chondrocytes. H&E: 50μm
Fig.10 Group X: Section showing greatly dilated vessel filled with blood
with uniform chondrocytes on either side of the vessel. H&E:
50μm
xx
and shape. H&E: 50μm
Fig.6 Group VI: Section showing large number of swollen and empty
chondrocytes. Few cells are with large nucleus.H&E:50µm
Fig.10 Group X: Section showing few empty chondrocytes and few with
nucleus. H&E:50µm
xxi
27 Photomicrographs of histopathological changes (Koneff’s stain) of 96
cartilage in birds of different experimental groups
Fig.4 Group VIII: Section showing large oval empty chondrocytes, with
pyknotic nuclei and abundant matrix. Koneff’s stain:25µm
Fig.4 Group VIII: Section showing dilated vessel and bile duct hyperplasia.
H&E:50µm
Fig.2 Group IV: Section showing mild dilation and congestion of CV, loss
of architecture of hepatic cords with focal areas of dilated sinusoids.
H&E:50µm
xxii
Fig.3 Group V: Section showing marked dilation of CV with desquamation
of endothelium. Marked dilation of sinusoidal spaces. H&E:50µm
Fig.1 Group III: Section showing mild congestion of CV, and few
hepatocytes with degenerative changes. Marked dilation of sinusoidal
spaces is also seen H&E 25µm
Fig.2 Group IV: Section showing marked dilation of sinusoidal spaces and
few hepatocytes with mild fatty change. H&E 50µm
Fig.2 Group IV: Section showing marked dilation of tubules with shrunken
glomeruli. H&E:50µm
Fig.4 Group VIII: Section showing hyper cellular glomeruli with very mild
dilation of tubules. H&E:50µm
Fig.5 Group X: Section showing large focal round cell aggregates and
hyaline casts in the tubules with marked intertubular dilation.
H&E:25µm
Fig.1 Group III: Section showing moderate dilation of tubules. Note the
shrunken glomeruli and also marked dilation and congestion of blood
vessel. H&E:50µm
xxiii
Fig.2 Group V: Section showing few tubules with cystic dilation and
shrunken glomeruli. H&E:50µm
Fig.3 Group X: Section showing focal round cell aggregates and dilated
tubules with hyaline casts. H&E:50µm
Fig.2 Group III: Section showing large chondrocytes without nucleus and
few cells with pyknotic nucleus. Note increased staining intensity
(brown colour) is the indication for apaptosis IHC:50µm
xxiv
of endothelium. IHC:200µm
Fig.2 Group III: Section showing dilated vessels with intense staining
reaction of endothelium. IHC:25µm
Fig.3 Group IV: Section showing vessels with intense staining reaction of
endothelium. IHC:100µm
Fig.5 Group VIII: Section showing vessels with intense staining reaction of
endothelium. IHC:25µm
Fig.6 Group X: Section showing vessel with very mild staining reaction of
endothelium. IHC:25µm
Fig.1 Group I: Section showing normal Nucleus with RER and abundant
matrix. Urenyl acetate and lead citrate: 15120 x
Fig.3 Group IV: Section showing round nucleus with eccentrically placed
nucleolus, distorted RER, shrunken mitochondria and vesicular
cytoplasm. Urenyl acetate and lead citrate: 11340 x
Fig.5 Group VIII: Section showing pyknotic nuclei, dilated and distorted
RER, shrunken mitochondria, electron dense granules in the
cytoplasm. Urenyl acetate and lead citrate: 13320 x
Fig.6 Group X: Section showing round nucleus, with faint nucleolus mild
dilated RER with oval shaped dense mitochondria. Urenyl acetate
and lead citrate: 9450 x
xxv
Fig.2 Group III: Section showing condensed nucleus shrunken
chondrocytes, with completely altered mitochondria, dilated inter
cellular junction, vesicular cytoplasm. Urenyl acetate and lead
citrate: 7560 x
Fig.3 Group IV: Section showing altered nucleus note the disrupted RER
and vacuolated mitochondria, vesicular cytoplasm. Urenyl acetate
and lead citrate: 15120 x
Fig.1 Group I: Section showing round nucleus with other cell organelle and
clear RER and mitochondria. Urenyl acetate and lead citrate: 5670 x
Fig.3 Group IV: Section showing swollen nucleus, with loose inter cellular
junction, margination of chromatin and disintegration of nucleolus.
Note the vesicular cytoplasm. Urenyl acetate and lead citrate:15120 x
Fig.5 Group VIII: Section showing elongated nucleus, with dilated nuclear
membranes. Note altered mitochondria and large vesicular
cytoplasm. Urenyl acetate and lead citrate: 15120 x
xxvi
39 Transmission electron micrographs showing ultrastructural changes of 114
liver in birds of different experimental groups - 5th day
Fig.5 Group VIII: Section showing shrunken cells with pyknotic nucleus
and scanty chromatin margination. Note complete loss of cellular
architecture and cytoplasmic vaccuolation Urenyl acetate and lead
citrate: 7560 x
Fig.1 Group I: Section showing inter cellular junction, dilated vessels and
round nucleus. Urenyl acetate and lead citrate: 66150x
xxvii
Urenyl acetate and lead citrate: 15120 x
Fig.3 Group IV: Section showing mild to moderately swollen nucleus with
mild margination of chromatin. Observe the electron dense flocculent
material in cytoplasm. Urenyl acetate and lead citrate: 13230 x
Fig.3 Group IV: Section showing hemorrhagic dilated interstium. Note the
shrunken and distorted tubule with necrotic epithelial cells. Urenyl
acetate and lead citrate: 1890 x
Fig.4 Group VIII: Section showing shrunken epithelial cells with numerous
electron dense fat bodies, pyknotic nucleus and margination of
chromatin. Observe the vacuolated cytoplasm. Urenyl acetate and
xxviii
lead citrate: 6615 x
Fig.5 Group X: Section showing distorted and necrotic epithelial cells with
pyknotic nuclei and condensed nucleolus. Note the loose inter
cellular junction and swollen mitochondria. Urenyl acetate and
lead citrate: 4725 x
Fig.2 Group III: Section showing narrowed lumen with swollen epithelial
cells, nucleus with disrupted chromatin. Note the condensed
mitochondria. Urenyl acetate and lead citrate: 7560 x
Fig.3 Group IV: Section showing dilated lumen with intact epithelial cells.
Urenyl acetate and lead citrate: 3780 x
Fig.4 Group V: Section showing distorted epithelial cells with varied size
and shape of nucleus. Observe the condensed mitochondria, brush
boarder and loose inter cellular junction. Urenyl acetate and lead
citrate: 4725 x
Fig.5 Group VIII: Section showing distorted epithelial cells with varied
size and shape of nucleus. Observe the condensed mitochondria.
Note the brush boarder with loose inter cellular junction. Urenyl
acetate and lead citrate: 3780 x
Fig.2 Group III: Section showing narrowed lumen with swollen epithelial
cells. Observe the disrupted chromatin and condensed mitochondria.
Urenyl acetate and lead citrate: 4725 x
Fig.3 Group IV: Section showing narrowed lumen with intact epithelial
cells and note cytoplasmic vaccuolation. Urenyl acetate and lead
citrate: 3780 x
Fig.4 Group VIII: Section showing distorted epithelial cells with swollen
nucleus and margination of chromatin. Note the elongated
mitochondria. Urenyl acetate and lead citrate: 13230 x
xxix
Fig.5 Group X: Section showing distorted epithelial cells with altered
nucleus and mitochondria. Observe the loss of brush boarder and
dilated lumen filled with blood. Urenyl acetate and lead citrate:
3780 x
Fig.2 Group III: Specimen showing necrotic area and completely altered
Haversian system
Fig.2 Group III: Specimen showing dilated blood vessels and necrotic
parenchyma
Fig.3 Group IV: Specimen showing severe dilation of blood vessels altered
parenchyma
Fig.5 Group VIII: Specimen showing severe dilation of blood vessel and
necrosis of parenchyma
xxx
Fig.2 Group III: Specimen showing swollen tubules with completely
closed lumen and hemorrhages
Fig.3 VEGFR1
49 Amplification plots for different genes (VEGF, VEGFR1, Bcl-2, MMP2 126
and MMP3
50 Dissociation curve for different genes (VEGF, VEGFR1, Bcl-2, MMP2 127
and MMP3
xxxi
LIST OF TABLES
Mean values of albumin (g/dl), globulin (g/dl) and A/G ratio (g/dl) in
10 64
birds of different experimental groups
xxxii
Mean values of AST, ALT, and GGT (IU/ml) in birds of different
11 65
experimental groups
Mean values of albumin (g/dl), globulin (g/dl) and A/G ratio (g/dl) in
22 Annex
birds of different experimental groups – ANOVA showed in Annexure -I
xxxiii
Mean CT values of gene expression of different genes (MMP2 and
28 Annex
MMP3) in experimental birds – ANOVA showed in Annexure -I
Gross tibial growth plate cartilage lesions during 5th, 10th and 15th day
29 79
of experiment
Gross tibial growth plate cartilage lesions during 1st, 3rd, and 5th week
30 79
of experiment
Histopathological lesions in TMTD treated birds during 1st, 3rd, and 5th
32 88
week of age
xxxiv
Name of the student : M. LAKSHMAN
Title of the thesis : “Molecular and ultrastructural pathology of Thiram
(TMTD - Tetra methyl thiuram disulfide) induced
tibial dyschondroplasia (TD) in broilers”
Degree to which it is : Doctor of Philosophy
submitted
Faculty : Veterinary Science
Department : Department of Veterinary Pathology
Major adviser : DR.Y.ANJANEYULU
Associate Professor
Department of Pathology
College of Veterinary Science
Rajendranagar, Hyderabad-500 030.
University : Sri Venkateswara Veterinary University Tirupati –
517502
Year of submission : June, 2011
ABSTRACT
xxxv
revealed that TMTD exhibited a partial suppressive action on erythrpoiesis,
leucopoiesis and Hb synthesis in addition to causation of severe TD lesions.
Serum biochemistry showed significantly (P≤ 0.01) lower values of glucose
(IV, VII and IX), cholesterol (II, III and X), total protein and A/G ratio (III, IV, IX
and XI) during the experimental period. The lower values of AST and ALT were
recorded in groups II, IV, VI, VII, IX and X. The GGT and ALP values were lower
in groups V, IX, XI, XII and IV, V and XII respectively. Lower calcium levels were
observed in groups II, VIII and XII. Overall the ameliorative agents did not show
significant effect on haemato-biochemical parameters.
The regulation of different TD specific genes was studied in this experiment.
Significantly (P≤ 0.01) lower CT values of VEGF, VEGFR1 and Bcl-2 were recorded
in groups III, VIII and X. Lower CT values of MMP2 was observed in group V, VIII
and X, where as MMP3 it was observed in groups IV, VIII and X during 5th ,10th
and 15th day of experiment. Up and down regulation of respective genes are playing
a vital role in causation and repair of TD lesion.
Tibial bone, liver and kidney weights, length and diameter of tibial bones
were calculated. They revealed highly significant lower values in TMTD treated
birds when compared with other groups.
The graded lesions (+, ++ and +++) of longitudinally sectioned tibial growth
plate cartilage showed higher score at its widest point in TMTD treated samples over
other groups.
The changes like shrinkage, congestion of liver and kidneys were moderate
to sever in group II and III, mild in group VII, VIII, X and XII and mild enlargement
of the organs were observed in group IV, V and VI than group I.
The TGPC revealed marked changes in hypertrophic zone than the other
zones. Based on severity the lesions were classified as mild (+), moderate (++) and
severe (+++). Mild lesions were characterized by slight thickening of proliferating
zone, transitional zone, and hypertrophic zone and were characterized by pyknotic
nucleoli, disintegrating nucleolus and empty clusters of chondrocytes. The moderate
lesions were summarized as pyknotic, chromatolytic, degenerating nucleus and the
chondrocytes are ovoid without nucleus with more of eosinophilic matrix. Severe
lesions were characterized by grater thickening of proliferating zone, grater thinning
of hyaline zone, absence of chromatin material and empty clefts like chondrocytes
are grouped in clusters.
These graded lesions were prominent in group II, III, XII and followed by
group VII, X, VIII, IX and XI during 5th,10th and 15th day and 1st, 3rd and 5th week of
experimental period.
The sections also revealed pyknotic nuclei, empty (in few), oval and large
disorganized clusters of chondrocytes in group III. Proliferating blood vessels,
reorganization of chondrocytes with dark dens centrally placed nucleus with few
empty cells were observed in group IV, where as group V showed dilated vessels
and clusters of chondrocytes are in rows as that of normal. Group VIII sections
showed large oval empty chondrocytes, with more of matrix, few with pyknotic
nuclei. The sections of group X were large oval chondrocytes with nucleus, more of
matrix and cells are in the form of clusters than rows.
Liver and kidney samples from all the groups were studied. Severe dilation
of CV, mild dilatation of sinusoids, mild to moderate fatty change, hydropic
degeneration of perivascular area and shrunken hepatocytes, with thickened wall of
the blood vessels and karyorrhexic and pyknotic nuclei observed in group III
samples. Dilation of sinusoids, moderate congestion of CV, moderate fatty change
xxxvi
and focal aggregates of MNC’s were observed in groups III, VIII and X samples.
Mild to moderate lesions were revealed in group IV and V.
The kidney sections of group III showed moderate to severe lesions like
intertubular dilatation, shrunken glomeruli. Group IV sections showed grater
dilatation of tubules, shrunken glomeruli, hyaline casts and mild degeneration of
tubular epithelium. Mild to moderate intertubular haemorrhages, focal areas of
cystic dilatation, shrunken glomeruli, degenerating tubular epithelium were observed
in group V. Group VIII sections revealed moderate cystic dilatation of tubules,
degenerating tubular epithelium. Focal aggregates of mononuclear cells, focal areas
of hyaline casts, greater intertubular dilatation was observed in group X samples.
The changes were mild in early age and pronounced as the treatment advanced.
Immunohistochemistry of TGPC was studied in groups I, III, IV, V, VIII and
X for detection of specific anti apoptotic (Bcl-2) antigen which was detected in the
chondrocytes of groups III, VIII and X with varied stages of intensive reaction of
antigen. Group I, IV and V were revealed without reaction.
Expression of VEGF was done for detection of endothelial cellular changes
of blood vessels by using monoclonal antibodies against VEGF antigen. Increased
intensity of reaction was found in group III and IV and mild staining reaction was
also observed in groups V, VIII and X.
The TGPC, liver and kidney samples from different groups (I, III, IV, V,
VIII and X) during 5th, 10th and 15th day were used for transmission and scanning
electron microscopy (TEM and SEM).
The TEM lesions in hypertrophic zone of TGPC were characterized by
dilatation and vesiculation of rough endoplasmic reticulum (RER), enlargement of
para-nuclear space, and swollen mitochondria with electron-dense flocculent
material, loss of matrix and dilatation of Golgi saccules and nuclear chromatin
margination which is indicative of apoptosis was observed in group III and VIII. In
few sections o group III increased the lucency of cytoplasm of necrotic chondrocytes
were also found. Group IV and V the changes were consisted of a well developed
ribbon shaped RER with dilated regions in the vicinity of Golgi complex and
secondary vacuoles. Group X revealed round nucleus, with faint nucleolus mild
dilated RER, dense mitochondria was observed. Chondrocytes of 15th day revealed
large lipid inclusions, vesiculated and disarranged stacks of rough ER along with
apoptotic cells which had cytoplasmic crescentric cap like structures of condensed
chromatin is indicative of apoptosis and early cell death.
The TEM of liver sections of group II and III revealed moderate to severe
changes like margination of chromatin, disrupted nucleolus, and swollen
mitochondria with loss of matrix, cytoplasmic vaccuolation was observed. Mild to
moderate changes were also observed in group IV and V. Group VIII samples
revealed shrunken hepatocytes with pyknotic nucleus and scanty chromatin
margination, complete loss of cellular architecture, cytoplasmic vaccuolation
distorted nuclear membrane and loss of other organelle.
The kidney samples of group II and III revealed moderate to severe lesions
like swelling of nucleus, margination of chromatin, condensed and vacuolated
mitochondria, and narrow tubular lumen. Group IV and V showed mild to moderate
changes with the presence of brush boarder appearance in PCT. Samples of group
VIII revealed shrunken tubules with electron dense numerous fat bodies, pyknotic
nucleus, margination of chromatin, cytoplasmic vacuoles and vacuolated
mitochondria. Group X samples showed distorted and necrotic epithelial cells with
xxxvii
pyknotic nuclei, condensed nucleolus, loose inter cellular junction, swollen
mitochondria, loss of brush boarder and narrowed tubular lumen.
The SEM lesions of tibial bone growth plate cartilage of group III revealed
necrotic areas of cartialginous structures and complete loss of haversion sysytem
group IV sample showed a moderate alteration of haversion system and also the
haemorrhges were observed. Group V cartialge sample showed a narrowed
haversion system but appeared to be normal. The VIII and X group samples revealed
completely altered haversion system with moderate haemorrhges were observed.
The liver samples of group III revealed moderate to severe dilatation of CV
with perivesicular space and necrotic parenchyma. Thin slices of group IV samples
showed severe dilatation of blood vessels altered hepatic parenchyma, in group V
revealed an altered parenchyma, congestion and haemorrhages.The samples of
group VIII exhibited severe dilataion of blood vessels and necrosis of hepatic
parenchyma. Group X slices were revealed a mild dilataion of vessels and altered
hepatic architexure.
The kidney samples of group III revealed moderate swelling of tubules with
completely closed lumen and haemorrhages, the group IV showed an intertubular
dilatation, a mild swelling tubules and narrowed tubular lumen. Severe
haemorrhages and narrowed tubules were observed in group V. Group VIII samples
were showed a moderately swollen tubules with complete closure of tubular lumen,
a mild intertubular dilatation was seen among group X samples.
On perusal of literature limited information is available about TMTD
induced TD pathogenesis at molecular, ultrastructural level and ameliorative agents.
The present proved that the TMTD is a potential fungicide to induce TD at 60 ppm
and 100 ppm and an attempt was made with different ameliorative agents to counter
act the TMTD effect. The ameliorative agents which were used in this experiment
did not repair TD lesion completely, up and down regulation of TD specific genes,
apoptotic and other sub-cellular changes like RER dilation, changes in the
mitochondrial structure and nucleus, specific antigen reaction in
immunohistochemistry and graded histopathological lesions of TD affected
chondrocytes were moderate to severe in groups II and III, mild to moderate in
groups IV, VIII and X and mild in other groups comparatively control.
Preliminary attempt has been made to study the cellular and sub cellular
changes in liver and kidney due to its vital role in detoxification and excretion of
metabolites and toxic substances. The changes were pronounced in TMTD treated
groups followed by CuSo4 and other ameliorative groups. Thiram caused damage to
the liver and kidney. The body weight gains and FCR was excellent in LivOrdain,
CuSo4 and US CuraTox groups over TMTD treated groups.
The result of this study high lighted the importance of further investigation in
this area to minimize the economic losses due to TD in broilers.
xxxviii
CHAPTER - I
INTRODUCTION
Live stock play an important role in the economics of most tropical countries
where majority of house holds in rural areas are associated with livestock production
(Edwards, 2004).The demand for live stock products grows continuously in the
foreseeable future, contributing for economic growth of the nation. But recent events
suggest that the predicted economic gain is not being realized due to various disease
alleviate rural poverty and address the food security issues is being plagued by
shifting agriculture systems. The agrarian revolution has triggered invention and
usage of various crop, grain and seed protectants like systemic fungicides,
pesticides, fertilizers and insecticides which are posing challenges to the livestock
and feed industry. In the next 20 years there will be increased demand for livestock
2004).
Andhra Pradesh (AP) being the leader in poultry meat and egg production
contributing upto 30% and 15% export to other states of India respectively. Poultry
Rs. 29,000 crores to National Gross Domestic Product (GDP). Andhra Pradesh is
alone. The public and the private sectors have worked together to achieve this
most progressive and innovative among the agricultural / livestock industries of the
country with tremendous potential for employment due to large scale involvement of
xxxix
man power (Jyoti Palod, 2005). In the changing scenario, exposure of animals and
birds to insecticides / pesticide toxicity even for a short duration induces a state of
Beisel, 1996 and Hassig et al., 1996). Earlier studies (Kalita, 2004) dwelt only on
(Germeloc et al., 2004, Krishna Kumar and Rajender 2010, and Krishna Kumar
2011).
The pesticides and fungicides used in the grain crop cultivation are numerous
class, and the chemical name is Tetra Methyl Thiuram Disulfide (TMTD). The
common names in different parts of the globe are thiram (USA), thiuram (Japan),
and TMTD (USSR), TMT and TMTDS. Trade names include AAtack, Arasan,
Tiuramyl, Tirampa, TMTC, Trametan, Tuads and Tulisan (Hayes and Laws, 1990
The TMTD is a fungicide used in prevention of crop damage in the field and
general use pesticide by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). TMTD
xl
is used as a seed protectant, and also to protect the fruits, vegetables, ornamental and
turf crops from a variety of fungal diseases. It is also used as animal repellent to
protect fruit trees and ornamentals from damage by rabbits, rodents and deer. TMTD
can also be used in the treatment of human scabies, as a sun screen and as a
bactericide applied directly to the skin or incorporated into soaps (Hayes and Laws,
1990). TMTD is available in the form of dust, flowable, wettable powder (WP),
water dispersible granules and water suspension formulations and in mixtures with
Chemical (NOEC) are rarely found in literature (Cynthia Rider and Gerald Le Blanc,
2005). Hayes and Laws (1990) studied the NOEC for thiram at 100 ppm (4.9
pollutants (Fairbrother et al., 2004 and Kacmar et al., 1999). Similarly, information
meager in India (Lakshman, 2004 and Subapriya et al., 2007a, b & c).
Pesticides are also implicated in the large scale decline of wild life species
(TD) in broiler birds leading to weight losses and leg deformities (Rath et al., 2007,
and Tian et al., 2009). The TD is a cartilage abnormality which occurred in the
xli
assumed unusual posture with a tendency to squat, which eventually led to lameness
Siller, 1970; Siller and Duff, 1970 and Riddell et al., 1971, Lakshman et al., 2002
disease rather than on pathogenesis and molecular and ultra structural changes.
OBJECTIVES OF STUDY
1) To induce TD in broiler chicken by feeding them with graded levels of
thiram and to observe the development of Tibial Dyschondroplasia (TD)
and to evaluate the performance of birds.
xlii
CHAPTER - II
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
of the most effective seed protectants and for grain storage, both in the form of
powder as well as slurry. The popular name of TMTD is thiram and trade names
1994).
As per the WHO the common name is Thiram, the identity can be made by
thiuram disulfide and the Chemical Abstract Service (CAS) can made as
Tetramethyl thioperoxy dicarbonic diamide and the CAS registration number is 137-
26-8, the molecular formula is C6H12N2S4 the molecular weight is 240.4 and the
) in rats (male and female) 560 mg/kg bwt, rat (male and female) 630 mg/kg bwt (as
xliii
a 20% suspension in propylene glycol) in mouse it is 1350 mg/kg bwt, in rabbit it is
incorporated in broiler starter ration from day one to eight weeks of age (graded
levels of 30, 60, 120 and 240 ppm) caused TD and noticed leg abnormalities as
Comb White Leg Horn (SCWLH) chicks when fed with dietary TMTD at 30mg/kg
incidence of 40% TD in four week old birds. Veltmann and Linton (1986) observed
mg/kg diet over a period of 6-weeks and reported a significantly higher incidence
and severity of TD in layer chicks. They recorded the highest incidence of 69% in 6
dietary addition of thiuram, disulfiram and trace element mixture. He conducted two
such as Al, Ba, Br, Cr, F, Fe, I, Li, Mn, Mo, Ni, Si, Sn, Sr, V and Zn. The incidence
and severity of TD was lower in chicks fed on diet containing trace elements
whereas it was significantly higher in chicks fed with thiuram or disulfiram diet. In a
xliv
effect on TD. Lastly in the fourth experiment addition of thiuram or disulfiram to the
diet had lowered the absorption of calcium from the gastrointestinal tract but did not
find out the effect of TMTD at the rate 30 ppm in inducing TD and the ameliorative
effect of CuSo4 at the rate 200 ppm. They found a positive effect of CuSo4 against
Rath et al., (2004 & 2005) studied the mechanism of thiram induced TD in
chickens at 100 ppm level and stated that severe TD lesion developed in 90 % of the
birds in two days due to the suppression of chondrocyte maturation related gene
expression. In another study Rath et al., (2007) evaluated the efficacy of vitamin D3
or its metabolites on thiram induced (100 ppm and 50 ppm) TD in chickens and
concluded that vitamin D3 had not shown any useful effect. They further conducted
vascularization in TD by using thiram @ 100 ppm level for a period of 48 and 166
hours. They found an increase in the expression of VEGF gene by thiram at 48 hours
and continued beyond 166 hours. But they also found out a suppression of vascular
endothelial growth factor (VEGF) receptor gene and antiapaptotic (Bcl-2) gene at 48
hours post exposure to thiram. Down regulation of Bcl-2 receptor was observed even
at 166 hours, but not the case with VEGF receptor gene, statistically. They
concluded that failure of gene expression has resulted in the endothelial cell death
xlv
analysis and quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (QRT - PCR) in
chicken and turkey growth plate chondrocytes by using thiram as sensitive chemical.
All the MMPs diminished (P < 0.05) during this study and recovered later upon the
withdrawal of thiram. They concluded that MMP expression and growth plate
by incorporating thiram at 15, 30, and 60 ppm in the diet for four weeks from the
day of hatch and observed a reduction in weight gain, lameness, abnormal bending
of tibial bones, enlarged hock joints and sternal recumbency. Tibio tarsus exhibited a
white opaque and unmineralised cartilage plug with thinning of the growth plate and
Waibel et al., (1955) reported that during the summer of 1954, hens in
certain poultry farms of Minnesota suddenly laid soft shelled eggs. After thorough
investigation they found that ‘Arasan’ (TMTD) seed protectants were responsible
for egg production disturbances. They further studied the effect of dietary TMTD on
the growth rate of chicks and poults and observed retarded growth rate at 37.5 ppm
and leg weakness at 150 to 300 ppm levels. In another study Ackrson and Mussel
(1955) stated that Arasan was toxic for growing chicks with persistent depression in
Waibel et al., (1957) studied the effect of TMTD toxicity in chicks, poults
and goslings, and observed that chicks and goslings were very sensitive to the
dietary poisoning at 40 ppm and 150 ppm respectively. Turkey poults however
appeared to be more resistant at 200 ppm levels. At 20 ppm level the chicks were
xlvi
slightly heavier than the controls and at 125 ppm growth rate was half that of the
control group.
fed with 30, 60, 120 and 240 ppm of TMTD for eight weeks. Early clinical signs and
depression in growth was recorded on 5th day of feeding in groups fed with higher
doses i.e., 120 and 240 ppm whereas after 3 weeks of age it was seen in all groups.
insignificant at 30 ppm level of TMTD fed to chicks, but their histology revealed,
Tibial dyschondroplasia (TD). Veltmann and Linton (1986) studied the influence of
TD in Single Comb White Leghorn (SCWLH) chicks. They reported that body
weights at three weeks of age and bone ash at four and six weeks of age of chicks
fed either with 30 or 60 mg TMTD/kg were significantly lower than that of controls.
However the dietary TMTD significantly increased the incidence and severity of TD
in layer chicks with the highest incidence of 69% in 6 weeks old birds.
reduction in growth rate in broiler chicks fed with thiram at 37 ppm and a significant
changes.
al., (1994) showed a significantly higher body weight gain with mild doses of
Rao et al., 1996, both layers and broilers, revealed a significant reduction in their
body weight and complete cessation of egg production within three days of feeding
xlvii
Lakshman (2004a) mentioned that there was no significant effect on weight
gain in broilers at 30 ppm level of TMTD diet during first week of age, whereas at
8th week there was a significant reduction in weight along with weakness in legs. A
case of thiram contaminated leg abnormality in broilers in Andhra Pradesh (AP) was
which they gave emphasis on gene expression and endoplasmic reticulum (ER)
stress occurring in avascular transition zone of the growth plate leading to cartilage
abnormality.
study the dose and time relationship in feeding TMTD at 15, 30 and 60 ppm levels
for four weeks of age and observed that severe depression in body weight gain in all
eventually led to lameness and reluctancy in movement in five weeks old fowl. The
affected birds had retarded growth rate resulting in smaller than normal size. Most
the epiphysis and metaphysis were involved. The increase in size of tibial head was
xlviii
Riddell et al., (1971) reported widespread sub-clinical incidence of TD in
metaphyseal cartilage of tibio-tarsus stated that severely affected birds often had
Edwards (1985) investigated the effects of age versus diet, potassium levels,
TMTD and ionophores in the diet on the development of TD and observed that
(0.3%) corn-corngulten meal animal protein diet increased the incidence of TD. The
addition of thiuram to the diet caused an increase in TD. When thiuram was added to
the TD inducing diet it also caused a decrease in bone ash and in total and ultra
between the incidence and score of TD and bone ash of the ends and middles of the
tibiotarsus with the naked eye. Their study examined the incidence and severity of
TD in broilers under four different dietary regimes and compared the efficacy of
reduced levels of calcium relative to phosphorus with adequate (diet-1) and high
(diet-2) levels of vitamin D3 supplementation; a very low calcium diet (diet-3) and a
standard diet (diet-4) were also included. Gross examination suggested that TD was
present in 80 per cent, 79 per cent and 27 per cent of tibiotarsi from birds on diets 1,
xlix
2 and 4, respectively. However, histological examination indicated TD,
Orth and Cook (1994) in their review on avian TD stated that growth plate
cartilage resists vascularization due to which the growth rate of the birds slows down
and leads to economic losses. Thiram was found to be one of the causes for avian
TD.
occurs in many avian species. In their report, they emphasized on gene expressions
Leach and Nesheim (1965) and (1972) reported that tibio-tarsal and tarso-
inherited physiological defect, the expression of which was under dietary influence
and that which resulted in development of low and high incidence strains through
family selection. Further they opined that the high incidence of susceptible strain
which had changed the acid-base or cation-anion base. McCapes (1967) described
that the cartilage abnormality in chicken was very much similar to that of turkey
osteodystrophy.
l
Incidence of cartilage abnormality in broiler chickens was investigated by
four different strains wherein the affected birds showed lameness and characteristic
“plug” of metaphyseal cartilage distal to proximal epiphyseal ends of tibia and (or)
and observed that bilateral symmetrical lesions were restricted to proximal ends of
both tibio-tarsi and tarso- metatarsi of which the incidence and severity was
considerably greater in the former. Further, they mentioned that the fundamental
lesion was a persistent over grown cone of primitive diaphyseal cartilage which was
because of which cortical bone weakness and bending of the head of tibio-tarsus
occurred.
domestic meat type poultry of four weeks of age than in two weeks, wherein the
and collagen differed considerably from that of articular cartilage, but was similar to
li
that of growth plate of normal and TD effected birds of same age. No gross
Therefore, the authors suggested that abnormal cartilage formation was probably due
of growth plate vascular supply between two strains and observed that there was no
significantly higher in proximal plate than the distal plate in both strains.
Leach and Gay (1987) stated that abnormal cartilage development was
associated with chondrodystrophy, TD and rickets and opined that the former
condition resulted due to many nutrient deficiencies and was characterized by short,
thick bones and narrowed epiphyseal growth plate. An etiological experiment by Bai
and Cook (1994) to study TD like lesion in light-type chicks fed with cysteine
supplemented diets revealed large mass of abnormal opaque cartilage extending into
Rath et al., (1997) studied TD and reported that metabolic defect of the
growth plate resulted in retention of cartilage plug that failed to resorb and undergo
endochondral bone formation. They mentioned that this condition was common in
ossification and opined that this was a metabolic disorder of growth plate cartilage in
lii
fast-growing, meat type poultry and was characterized by retention of vascular
A detailed study on avian TD was carried out by Pines et al., (2005) who
stated that it was the most prevalent skeletal abnormality which caused huge
economic loss and posed as a major animal welfare problem. They described that
microarray technology, chicken genome project together with cell and organ culture
Clinical signs of TMTD toxicity were studied in chicks, poults and goslings
by Waibel et al., (1955 and 1957) and reported that the birds showed retardation of
growth, loss of weight and weakness in legs. This syndrome was characterized by
inability to stand, enlarged hocks, crooked and curled toes and in certain cases
perosis and spraddles. These symptoms occurred within a week at higher dosage
birds at five days age after feeding TMTD at 120 and 240 ppm levels. Later they
noticed enlarged hock joints, shortening and twisting of the tibio-metatarsal bones,
crooked toes and curled toes. All the affected birds stood on their hock joints
whereas some of the affected birds walked short steps and crossed their legs. The
liii
most striking feature was abnormal bowing and bending of femoro-tibio-tarsal
bones.
In another study Veltmann and Linton (1986) observed swelling and bowing
of femoral-tibial joint in birds fed with 100 mg/ kg TMTD diet, but not so when fed
they found thiram in four feed samples of starter ration. Chicks fed with this ration
examination revealed swollen hock joints with displacement of achilles tendon from
TD like bowing of tibio-tarsus in 18,250 male birds of three different broiler strains
reared under similar nutritional and managemental conditions. Leg problems were
Weidong Wu et al, (1990 and 1993) studied leg shape abnormality in TMTD
induced incidences of TD when fed with 37 and 75 ppm wherein they mentioned
movement in broilers at five weeks age when fed with TMTD diet at 30 ppm level
and in later age groups more than 90% of birds showed enlarged hock joints,
crooked and curled toes. They mentioned that most of the affected birds stood on
their hock joints where as some of them walked with short steps or wobbling gait
and stated that the most striking feature was the abnormal bowing and bending of
femoral-tibiotarsus.
liv
Rath et al., (2004) studied the comparative efficacy of different
tibio-tarsus, extended hind limbs, sterna recumbence, curled toes and straddles in
chicks that were fed with 15 – 60 ppm levels of TMTD for more than 21 days.
induced TD in birds fed with 200 ppm each of Cu and Zn for 1-17days recorded
remained within normal limits as reported by Rao et al., (1996). Rath et al., (2004)
in their study stated that there was a profound effect on several hematological values
of white blood cells, and hematocrit (p≤ 0.05) was indicative of thiram induced
levels.
lv
Coles (1986) and Mishra et al., (1998) reported hyper cholesterolemia in rats
exposed to thiram at 5, 10, 25 ppm for 180 and 360 days. Akin to their observations,
triglyceride and enzyme creatine kinase. Similarly Subapriya et al., (2007a) reported
insignificant values of serum proteins, albumin, globulin and albumin: globulin ratio
in thiram induced TD in broiler chickens fed with different levels of toxin (15, 30
Tanabe and Wilcox (1960) mentioned that serum alkaline phosphatase (SAP)
level was extremely high in young chicks and reached a low level in adult stage.
They inferred that these changes corresponded with growth rate and also due to
Rath et al., (1994 and 2004) observed SAP and aryl sulfate activity in severe
TD lesions in turkeys and in poultry fed with thiram (100 ppm) and reported that
both enzymes exhibited significantly lower activity (p<0.05). This indicated failure
They mentioned that SAP activity was significantly elevated whereas alanine amino
results in poultry which indicate negative effect of thiram on SAP but not so on ALT
lvi
Lakshman (2004) recorded marginally higher SAP activity in broilers fed
with 30 ppm thiram diet between 5 and 8 weeks of age and observed that as the age
advanced, SAP activity also increased. Rath et al., (2007) observed no substantial
(GGT), creatine kinase, and alkaline phosphatase (ALP) between different treatment
groups with vitD3 metabolites and 100 ppm and 50 ppm thiram. These observations
suggest that there is no much damaging effect on muscle, liver, or bone damaging
of SAP, ALT, AST and GGT in TD affected chickens stating that thiram had no
influence.
antioxidant capacity of liver in broilers. Thiram fed at 50 and 100 mg / kg diet which
content of liver and a decreased activity of super oxide dismutase (SOD) and
phosphorous ratio with relation to TD. The calcium: phosphorous varied from 0.8 to
1.8 in the 480 batch of cockerels. The lower Ca: P ratio (0.8) resulted in the increase
of TD upto 68 to 79%.
Rath et al., (1994 and 2004) mentioned that there was no difference in Ca
and P levels in turkeys with severe TD lesion and in poultry fed with thiram at the
rate 100 ppm and ruled out the possibility of imbalance in calcium and phosphorus
lvii
Lakshman (2004) observed significantly higher mean values of calcium (Ca)
in thiram fed broilers (30 ppm) with advancing age (5-8 weeks) and opined that such
process.
in the serum calcium level in the birds fed with 60 ppm thiram. There was no
significant variation in birds fed with lower levels (15 or 30 ppm) of thiram and
attributed that this fact could be due to thiram which at higher levels inhibited
eight weeks of age by feeding graded levels of TMTD at the rate 30, 60, 120 and
240 ppm respectively. The most striking feature was swelling and abnormal bowing
developed distally to epiphyseal plate. Similar report was also made by Lakshman et
Vargas et al., (1983) stated that in higher levels of TMTD (120 and 240
ppm) the lesion extended up to some distance down the shaft and graded the lesion
as mild, moderate and severe as per age (5 day to 3 weeks) and dose (ascending
levels).
Veltmann et al., (1985) studied TMTD (120 and 240 ppm) induced TD in
growing layers and reported that the condition was characterized by an abnormal
lviii
plug of non vascularized, unmineralised, white opaque cartilage in the proximal end
of the tibio-tarsus.
formation in tibio-tarsus in the broilers wherein they described that there was
Rao et al., (1996) recorded gross changes in different organs of layers fed
with TMTD at different levels of 79, 158, 236, and 315mg/kg diet wherein they
observed varying degrees of severe congestion in liver, kidney, lungs and brain
Lakshman et al., (2002) studied TMTD (at the rate 30 ppm) induced TD in
broilers and reported that the condition was characterized by an abnormal plug of
non vascularized, unmineralised, white opaque cartilage in the proximal end of the
5mm) and severe +++ (>5mm) and recorded gross changes in liver and kidney
such as mild enlargement, moderate congestion in both organs and pale focal areas
relative change in liver weights. In another study Rath et al., (2007) mentioned that
induced by them within 48 hrs of feeding thiram diet at the rate 100 ppm and was
lix
2.10 HISTOPATHOLOGY TD
2.10.1 TIBIAL BONE GROWTH PLATE CARTILAGE (TGPC)
Several authors described that the fundamental lesion in TD of fowl was a
and delayed or deficient blood vessel penetration which led to failure of proper
epiphyseo-metaphyseal region (Leach and Nesheim, 1965; Siller, 1970, Siller and
calcification and improper bone formation that interfered with the formation of
surrounding cortical bone, which was either absent or very thin and fragile.
vascular tunnels invading the zone of hypertrophy in proximal growth plate were
and 240 ppm) fed chickens (day old to 8 weeks of age) and classified the lesions as
mild, moderate, and severe. Moderate lesions consisted of small chondrocytes with
uniform eosinophylic cytoplasm and pyknotic nuclei. The cartilaginous matrix was
abundant and slightly basophilic. In severe cases the zone of proliferation was
thickened without any cellular abnormality, but was penetrated by fewer vessels that
The tip of the abnormal cartilage was surrounded by a thin and irregular layer of
spongy bone. Michael et al., (1992) also noted large “plugs” of cartilage attached to
lx
metaphyseal growth plate which had occluded blood vessels in the epiphysis and
proximal tibio-tarsal growth plates of 3 - 4 week old layer chicks fed with 30 mg /
kg of TMTD diet and found that it was un-mineralized with partly hypertrophic
cytoplasm.
Bai and Cook (1994) studied TD like lesion in fowl fed with cysteine and
normal growth plate. Rath et al., (1994) reported that TD lesion in turkeys had
hemorrhagic areas populated with large numbers of erythrocytes, often necrotic cells
and heterophils which was indicative of inflammation. The striking feature was the
Throp et al., (1991) reported that the proliferative zone in growth plate of 3
weeks old birds consisted of flattened chondrocytes whereas the transitional zone
transitional chondrocyte like cells, some of which had pyknotic nuclei and strong
eosinophylic cytoplasm.
broilers fed with TMTD diet and classified the lesions as mild, moderate and severe
with irregular blood vessel penetration from metaphysis. Moderate lesion consisted
of small spherical or oval chondrocytes with pyknotic nuclei and many vacuoles
lxi
were present in the slightly thick proliferating layer and zone of hypertrophic
(2004) in inducing TD in poultry. Affected areas of growth plates of chicks fed for
two days with thiram showed interesting differences in chondrocyte morphology and
characterized by nuclear shrinkage and empty lacunae during later times and also
involution of capillaries. Whereas chondrocytes did not differ much from those of
control in 15 day old birds fed with thiram. The authors opined that as the age had
lacunae.
Subapriya et al., (2007c) observed that the epiphyseal hyaline cartilage in earlier
groups was normal in both control and TMTD fed birds. Thinning of growth plate
thickening was associated with ovoid chondrocytes and eosinophylic matrix while
Walser et al., (1982) observed pale and enlarged kidneys in 80% of the
chicks that were affected with TD due to Fusareum roseum diet. They revealed
lxii
diffuse tubular nephrosis and occasional accumulation of urates in tubular lumen of
kidney. Dose dependent degenerative changes in the liver and kidney of layers were
reported by Rao et al., (1996) who studied the effect of thiram on the performance
Lakshman (2004) recorded mild hepatic changes in liver and mild hydropic
birds fed with different doses of thiram. At 15 ppm level venous and sinusoidal
changes, Kupffer cell hypertrophy, focal mononuclear cell collection, portal vein
whereas in 60 ppm group hepatic parenchyma showed diffuse micro vesicular fatty
degeneration and necrosis in sections of kidney of birds fed with at 30 and 60 ppm
thiram. These changes were also noticed in groups fed with 15 ppm level during
fourth week along with focal interstitial mononuclear cell infiltration in 30 ppm 60
growth plate cartilage of chicks was studied in two experiments by Lawler et al.,
lxiii
(1988) wherein Fusaroium equiseti was fed in intervals of 7 days up to 28 days and
phosphatase (AKP) and aryl sulfate (ASP) decreased in TD affected turkeys which
and observed for any differences between normal and TD cartilages. They opined
differences existed in patterns of both protein types between the two groups.
vascularization and noted that increased MMP-9 and enhanced vascularization were
associated with mechanical loading. Gay et al., (1985 and 2007) studied the
and demonstrated the presence of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), its
most cases immunostaining was intracellular except in the vicinity of blood vessels
where the matrix was also stained. Results suggested that the expression of these
four proteins was not a key factor in development of the avascular cartilage in
avian.
lxiv
Crucial role of matrix metalloproteinases (MMP) in growth plate
remodeling of extra cellular matrix (ECM) in TD lesion was studied by Simsa et al.,
from chicken and turkeys. They noticed that retinoic acid (RA) elevated MMP-2
activity in both species, but in chicken it only induced MMP-9 activity. In contrast
acetate (PMA) treatment. The authors specified that thiram reduced MMP-2 and
MMP regulation differed in the GP of these closely related avian species thus
ultrastructural studies of growth plate cartilage cells, liver and kidney in birds of
lxv
cartilaginous tissue adjacent to the epiphyseal growth plate in the tibiotarsus of
chickens. The proteoglycan and collagen content of this cartilaginous mass from
that of hyaline articular cartilage but was similar to that of epiphyseal growth plate
cartilage from normal birds of the same age or from birds with the abnormality. The
purified proteoglycan subunits extracted from the abnormal cartilage and from
to molecular weight and composition. Their findings indicated that the abnormal
development.
calcification of a rachitic model and in a normal growth plate of rats. They opined
that the matrix calcification begins at the level in the bottom of the growth plate
hypertrophic zone as the mitochondria at this level lose calcium. Calcification in the
Howlet et al., (1984) stated that the vascularity of the growth plate has an
important role in the pathogenesis of certain diseases of long bones as well as a vital
role in regulating their growth in length. Broiler chickens often suffer tibial
detail of the vascular supply of the normal proximal tibial growth plate, to provide a
lxvi
basis for studying possible vascular involvement in the pathogenesis of this form of
dyschondroplasia.
hypertrophic zone of the growth plate appeared normal but at EM level, cells of
depletion. They observed that the changes included dilatation and vesiculation of
shaped RER with dilated regions in the vicinity of Golgi complex and secondary
vacuoles.
in chicks was recorded by Haynes and Walser (1986) who conducted an experiment
on chicks that were divided into two groups of which one was treated twice daily
with TDP-1(a mycotoxin produced by Fusarium roseum) and the other was controls.
Treated birds were sacrificed in intervals of two days up to 14 days for evaluation of
lesions. The lesions were absent in initial six days, however some birds developed
mild lesions after 4 and 6 days of toxin diet. Beyond this period they observed
vacuoles, and peri-cellular matrix around chondrocytes was seen. In few cells
lxvii
mineral aggregates in interstitial septa and lipid vacuoles were observed of which
cartilage lesion of high and low incidence TD affected birds collected in intervals of
vesiculated and disarranged stacks of rough ER along with apoptotic cells which had
chicks revealed minimal level of apoptosis in affected cartilage. Their finding was
cells that outlived their normal life span. In the same experiment the authors
examined cells in TD growth plate by TEM and stated that nuclear membrane
bordering vascular channels showed evidence of cell death and apoptosis with
Christopher and Irving (2002) made a review over the fate of the terminally
chondrocytes apoptosis. They strongly suggest that the terminally differentiated cells
are deleted from the cartilage by apoptosis. Indeed, morphological, biochemical, and
end-labeling techniques confirm that death is through the apoptotic pathway. Since
the induction of apoptosis is spatially and temporally linked to the removal of the
cartilage matrix, this activity is associated with Ca2+, Pi, and arg-gly-asp {(peptide
lxviii
2.13 MOLECULAR PATHOLOGY OF TIBIAL DYSCHONDROPLASIA
(TD)
al., (1992) in variety of tissues including lymphoid and neuronal organs in adult
and embryonic stages. Recent studies indicated that Bcl-2 gene had the ability to
block apoptosis of hematopoietic cells. The authors described that this gene was
homologous to human Bcl-2 protein and consisted of two regions which surrounded
kidney, heart, ovary and brain. The primary transcript was spliced to encode a
25,687 delton (233 a.a protein). In adult birds expression of Bcl-2 gene was much
less in bursa Fabricius, whereas in the embryo it was extensively expressed. These
findings made the authors to conclude that homologue of human Bcl-2 gene existed
in chicken.
Knopov et al., (1995) conducted a study on gene expression and AKP activity
affected turkeys. They noted that osteopontin (OPN) and collagen type X were
Neufeld et al., (1999) studied the expression of VEGF gene and concluded
that its receptors were highly specific mitogen for vascular endothelial cells. As a
result five isoforms of this gene were generated by alternative splicing from a
single gene. Various forms of VEGF gene bind to two tyrosine kinase receptors
viz., VEGFR-1 (flt-1) and VEGFR-2 (KDR/flk-1) which were expressed almost
lxix
exclusively in endothelial cells. The authors explained that the expression of this
of TMTD for two days. The birds fed with 100 ppm toxin were monitored for
and 166 h after feeding. RT-PCR and capillary electrophoresis were used to
determine the expression of VEGF, its receptor VEGFR and anti apoptotic protein
Bcl-2 genes. Results showed maximal suppression of both genes at 48h where
Except for Bcl-2 this suppression was not evident at 166 h when the lesion was
visually discernible with chondrocyte death. Further analysis suggested that dead
cells in the lesion seemed to be related to early death of capillary endothelial cells
which expressed VEGFR through which VEGF transduced signals for angiogenesis.
Thiram initiated cell death was also evident in Bcl-2 gene suppression.
with 100 ppm thiram to a week old chicks for 48 h was observed by Rath et al.,
(2007) who recorded the expression of this genes for its receptors VEGFR1,
VEGFR2 and Bcl-2 in GP cartilage at 48h and 166 h respectively. RT-PCR and
relative to 18S gene as an internal strand. The authors found that there was an
lxx
elevated above the control level at 166 h. Suppression of genes encoding both VEGF
receptors and Bcl-2 was evident at 48 h in thiram-fed chickens when there was
distension of GP in thiram treated birds was seen at 166 h, the expression of VEGF
receptors was still lower. The authors opined that some early effects of thiram on GP
might have led to failure of genes encoding VEGF receptors and Bcl-2 thus resulting
hybridization analysis and QRT-PCR was studied in three groups of broilers. One
group was fed with thiram enriched diet, second recovery group fed with thiram diet
during first week of experiment followed by normal diet from second week and
lastly third group birds were control (Dan et al., 2009). According to them a model
was established for induction and recovery of TD and the results obtained showed
that even though MMP diminished in the TD lesion (p<0.05) the growth plate was
able to repair itself and reappear during the process of recovery from TD. They
finally suggested that the results strengthened the link between MMP expression and
growth-plate impairment.
vascularization and ossification of normal and impaired avian growth plate wherein
ossification which in turn was impaired in TD and rickets. Known family members
normal and impaired conditions. Expression of MMP-3, 9 and 13 was reduced in the
lxxi
lesion and was lined up parallel to expulsion of blood vessels which extended up to
the border of the lesion without penetrating it. In contrast MMP-2 had over
them was that racketic lesions were populated with proliferative chondrocytes and
hypertrophic markers, whereas TD lesions were filled with chondrocytes. As per the
chicks by using copper and other trace elements as a diet supplement was
investigated by Weidong Wu et al., (1990). They stated that copper sulphate diet
reduced the incidence and severity of this condition unlike zinc sulphate or
manganese sulphate. However, all the three trace elements prevented the adverse
effect of thiram on primary humoral immunity. The authors strongly suggested that
either thiram interfered with the metabolism of trace elements or the latter reduced
thiram toxicity. Based on these observations they concluded that the etiology of
effect of copper sulphate in broilers. They observed that epiphyseal growth plate
cartilage abnormality increased with advanced age in group I (Basal diet) and group
II (TMTD diet at the rate 30 ppm) birds with scores recorded between ++ (>2mm to
< 5mm) and +++ (> 5mm) respectively. However, in group III (TMTD at the rate 30
lxxii
ppm and CuSO4 at the rate 200 ppm) only one bird scored ++ where as rest of the
birds showed only + score which indicated that CuSO4 addition had an ameliorative
Since the available information on this aspect was very scanty, it has
prompted the present study as to how CuSO4, hepato protectants and toxin binders
Hence, this study may trigger new insights in to the molecular pathogenesis and
lxxiii
CHAPTER III
MATERIALS AND METHODS
In the present study, a total of four hundred and twenty (420) day-old male
broilers chicks of Cobb strain were procured from Venkateswara Hatcheries Pvt.
Ltd, Hyderabad. On arrival, all the birds were wing banded, individually weighed
and distributed into twelve groups of 35 chicks each. They were housed at Poultry
days). The experiment design adopted for the present study is shown in Table 1.
All the chicks were vaccinated against Marek’s Disease (MD) on the day of
hatch at hatchery and brought to the experimental shed where they were vaccinated
lxxiv
as per the standard protocol against Infectious Bronchitis (IB) on day one, F1 strain
Newcastle Disease (ND) on 5th day followed by La Sota strain booster dose on 21st
day and mild strain of infectious bursal disease (IBD) on 14th day and booster with
intermediate strain booster on 28th day. During 1st week vitamin A and B-complex
were added in drinking water along with water sanitizer. Birds had free access to
fresh feed and water ad libitum every day till the end of the experiment. Feed
composition (%) and its ingredients were formulated as per the National Research
The growing birds were observed thrice daily for clinical signs of TD and
mortality if any. Periodical weighing of birds and feed consumption was noted at
weekly intervals.
nearest gram with electronic weighing balance on day one and subsequently at
weekly intervals i.e., on 7th, 14th, 21st, 28th, and 35th days of experiment for studying
Weekly data on feed consumption and number of chicks for each week was
3.3 HAEMATOLOGY
lxxv
3.3.1 Collection of blood for haematological parameters
Six birds from each group (I to XII) were sacrificed at the end of 1st, 3rd, and
5th week of age, and 2 ml of blood from each bird was collected in anticoagulant
coated vaccutainers {(Potassium based Ethylene Di Amine Tetra Acetic Acid, K3-
EDTA tube, 13 mm x 75 mm, 2 ml (Rapid Diagnostic Pvt. Ltd., Delhi)} for whole
blood analysis. All the samples were estimated for total erythrocyte count (TEC),
viz. (i) mean corpuscular cell volume (MCV), (ii) mean corpuscular haemoglobin
leukocyte count (TLC) and differential leukocyte count (DLC). All the above
parameters were estimated with semi automatic blood cell counter (PE 6800- Procan
Pvt. Ltd., Delhi) and all results were tabulated for statistical analysis.
from the respective groups into clot promoting (Vit K- coated) vaccutainers (clot
These samples were allowed to clot for 3-4 hours, and centrifuged (Sigma 1-13-
bench top laboratory centrifuge, USA) at 20k rpm for 15 minutes and serum was
taken into eppendorf tubes and used for serum biochemistry and serum enzymes
diagnostics Pvt. Ltd., Delhi) by using Aspen biochemical kits (Rapid Diagnostics
lxxvi
Pvt. Ltd., Delhi) as per the manufacturer’s protocols and the results were statistically
analyzed.
The following serum biochemical profiles were analyzed at the end of 1st,
3rd, and 5th week. Total proteins (TP) and albumin (A) were estimated as per Dumas
method (Dumas et al., 1971), globulin (G) was calculated from TP and albumin.
Glucose (Glu) was estimated by glucose oxidase (GOD) method (Trinder, 1969) and
commercial reagent kits in semi auto analyzer (Star 21 plus - Aspen diagnostics Pvt.
Ltd., Delhi). All values were tabulated to check the significant difference.
and intervals as mentioned above. Aspartate amino transferase (AST), alanine amino
Chemistry (IFCC) method (Shaw et al., 1983) and serum calcium was estimated by
commercial reagent kits in semi auto analyzer and values were tabulated for
statistical analysis.
weigh the tibial bones, liver, and kidneys. The digital vernier callipers (Annapurna
Scientifics, Hyderabad) were used for measuring the length and width (at proximal
lxxvii
3.5.1 Weights of tibial bones, liver and kidneys (g)
Soon after the collection of blood the organs were dissected, cleaned from
extra attachments if any, particularly with tibial bones, liver and kidneys weights (g)
The tibial bones of respective groups (I to XII) were measured by using digital
Vernier callipers for its length (cm) and width (cm) at the proximal extremity of the
sacrificed birds from groups I, III, IV, V, VIII and X during 5th, 10th, and 15th day
and the tissue samples were collected for molecular pathology (quantitative real time
and immunohistochemistry.
changes in epiphyseal growth plate cartilage, if any and damage was assessed by
means of score at the width of widest point of the epiphyseal growth plate cartilage.
The epiphyseal growth plate cartilage with width > 3 mm was considered as
abnormal during 5th, 10th and 15th day and 1st, 3rd, and 5th week of age and the score
was shown in the table. In all birds the changes in liver and kidneys were also
recorded. The TD growth plate cartilage abnormality scoring was made, and the
lxxviii
+++ Severe (>3mm width at the widest point) lesion
The liver and kidney samples were collected and fixed in 10% neutral buffer
The tibial bones were also collected and longitudinally sectioned and gross
changes were recorded. One portion of each tibia was fixed in Zenker-formalin for
48 hours for Koneff’s stain and one portion used for routine Haemotoxylin and
The fixed tissues were processed and paraffin sections of 4-5 µ were made
Bone and growth plate cartilage were processed as described (Luna, 1968).
The fixed tissue samples were transferred into decalcifying solution, comprising of
the bones were completely decalcified. The end point of decalcification was
The slides were stained with Harris haemotoxylin for 10 minutes, which was
followed by washing in distilled water and staining with analine blue solution for
20-30 minutes. Both staining and differentiation was accomplished in the above
lxxix
solution and brought to the desired degree by checking under microscope from time
to time after rinsing the slide in distilled water. The sections were stained until the
structures of nuclei were clear, the freshly laid down bone was blue and the old bone
was red. Further, the sections were washed in distilled water followed by two
solution has been added for each 50 ml of alcohol. Sections were dehydrated,
Hyaline cartilage and pre-osseous substance stained blue. Bone stained bright
red or reddish brown. The matrix of vascular zone of epiphyseal disc and remnants
sections using the super sensitive polymer HRP (horse-radish peroxidase) - kit label
chromogen.
lxxx
The paraffin sections (2-3 μ) were mounted on APES (Amino Propyl
Triethoxy Silane) coated slides and incubated at 370 C overnight. Then deparafinised
(Gan, 1987; Gan, & William 1988) of pH 7.6. These sections were treated for
antigen retrieval by heat method using pressure cooker-till 3 whistles in tris EDTA
(pH 9.0). Surroundings were wiped and first reagent (Super Sensitive polymer of
HRP kit) was added to block the endogenous peroxidase for 15 minutes in 3%
H2O2.Sections were then washed in tris buffer, the surrounding of the sections were
wiped and the power block (secondary kit) for blocking of the unwanted antigenic
sites was added. Then incubated with primary antibody for 30 minutes at room
temperature in a moist chamber to prevent drying and washed three times with tris
buffer (5 minutes each). Later, incubated with enhancer for 30 minutes at room
each), secondary antibody was added and incubated for 30 minutes which was
subjected to buffer wash for 3 changes (5 minutes each). Development was done
chromogen) kept for 5 to 15 minutes and washed well in buffer. Then the sections
were washed thoroughly in running tap water for 10 minutes. The nucleus was
stained with Harris’s haemotoxylin for 15 seconds and checked for bluing under
microscope. After satisfactory observation, the sections were washed under tap
lxxxi
3.10 MOLECULAR PATHOLOGY OF TIBIAL DYSCHONDROPLASIA
(TD)
In control, higher dose of toxin group and CuSo4 and herbal ameliorated
groups (Groups I, III, IV, V, VIII and X) tissue samples were collected for RTPCR,
each group were used for material collection of tibial growth plate cartilage by
cervical disarticulation on 5th, 10th, and 15th day respectively. After sacrifice, the
birds were de-skinned and under strict aseptic precautions the growth plate cartilage
was collected and transferred on ice blocks for relative Quantitative Real Time PCR
processing.
The levels of selective gene expression associated with angiogenesis and cell
of Oligos-25nmol each of which procured from Genetix Biotech Asia Pvt. Ltd.,
(shown in the Table 2). The primer sequences adopted in this study were from Rath
lxxxii
3.10.2 RNA Isolation and Reverse Transcription (RT)
Proximal tibial growth plate cartilage pieces were aseptically collected from
different groups (I, III, IV, VI, VIII, and X) at different intervals and utilized for
RNA isolation. The sample material was made into small pieces in a sterile petridis
and digested for fifteen minutes in 1ml of trizol (Fermentas Life Sciences, Canada)
chloroform (Fermentas Life Sciences, Canada) was added to each sample and
shaken vigorously for ten minutes on orbital shaker (Neolab, Mumbai, India) at
Equipment Comp.) for 15 minutes at 13000 rpm at 40C. Upper aqueous phase was
transferred into other tubes and equal volume of isopropanol (Fermentas Life
Sciences, Canada ) was added to each tube and kept at -200C for 20 minutes (Deep
freezer - Blue Star, India) and then centrifuged at 13000 rpm for 10 minutes. The
supernatant part was decanted and the pellets were washed with 1ml of cold ethanol
rpm and then air dried after decanting. The pellets were dissolved in 30µL of RNA
storage buffer (Fermentas Life Sciences, Canada) to make required volume used for
cDNA synthesis.
1 µl of Oligo dT and 6µl of RNase free water (Fermentas Life Sciences, Canada).
Total of 12µl quantity was incubated at 700C for 5 minutes and snap cooled on ice.
Transcriptase) enzyme (Fermentas Life Sciences, Canada) was added to each tube
lxxxiii
and incubated in two steps at 420C for 60 minutes and at 700C for 10 minutes and
used for analysis by using conventional PCR (ESCO-Swift Maxi, USA) instrument.
One µL of cDNA was used for RT-PCR with a fluorescent dye SYBR Green
I (Absolute QPCR SYBR Green Mix; Fermentas Life Sciences) to monitor DNA
synthesis using specific primers. Beata (β) actin (Fermentas Life Sciences, Canada)
was used for normalizing control and the primers employed are listed in Table 3.
USA) using the following cycling protocol: a 950C denaturation step for 15 minutes
seconds) and 720C extension (30 seconds). Gene expression was normalized to the
house keeping gene 18S. The amplified PCR product was analyzed with Stratagene
Mx 3000PTM soft ware (Agilnet Technologies, USA). At the end of the RT-PCR a
melting curve was determined to verify the presence of a single amplicon (Reich et
al., 2008).
were collected from another six birds from respective groups (I, III, IV, VI, VIII,
and X) on 5th, 10th, and 15th day by cervical disarticulation. All birds were
deskinned, aseptically the growth plate cartilage were collected, washed with
phosphate buffer saline (PBS composition shown in Annexure I) and fixed in 2.5%
lxxxiv
3.11.1 Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) of tibial bone growth plate
cartilage (TGPC), liver and kidney
The growth plate cartilage from birds of these groups was used for electron
Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) were done for the samples. Soon after
cervical dislocation, the growth plates which were associated with TD lesion of
proximal tibia were quickly exposed. Thin slices of tissue (cartilage, liver, and
kidney) were dissected into 2.5% gluteraldehyde (S.D. fine chemicals, Mumbai) in
0.1M phosphate buffer (pH 7.3 stored at 40C), washed in buffer, post fixed in 1%
Mumbai) and embedded in Spurr’s (Spurr, 1969) resin (SPI-supplies, araldite 6005
night at 450C for complete polymerization of the tissue. Semi thin (1000 – 1500 nm
thickness) section were made with ultra microtome (Leica ultra cut UCT - GA- D/E-
100,Germany) for identification of the area and were stained with 1% toludine blue
microscope (Olympus - AX 70, USA) to locate exact area to be sectioned for TEM.
Then, ultra thin sections were made (500 -700 nm thickness) mounted on hexagonal
copper grids (SPI supplies, USA) allowed to air dry for over night and were stained
lead citrate (composition shown in Annexure I) as per Bozzala and Russels (1998)
protocol. All grids were dried at room temperature and observed under transmission
lxxxv
3.11.2 Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) of tibial bone growth plate
cartilage (TGPC), liver and kidney
Samples from the same birds were used for SEM. Thin slices of tissue
(cartilage, liver, and kidney) were dissected into 2.5% gluteraldehyde in 0.1M
phosphate buffer (pH 7.3 stored at 40C), washed in buffer, post fixed in 1% osmium
alcohol (Qualigens fine chemicals, Mumbai) and subjected for critical point drier
(CPD- Electron Microscopy Sciences, USA) and sputter coated (Auto fine coater
JEOL - JFC -1600, Japan) with gold palladium, observed under scanning electron
Cochran, 1994) by using SPSS soft ware. The quantitative gene expression for real
2 -∆∆C
time PCR was made by using T (delta delta threshold cycles) and by the
2008).
lxxxvi
CHAPTER - IV
RESULTS
with amelioration effect of copper sulfate, LivOrdain-FS (Herbal product, HP), and
The present research work was designed to study the effect of thiram on
experimental birds.
throughout the experimental period and were treated as positive controls with basal
diet (BD), copper sulphate (CuSo4) 200 ppm, LivOrdain-FS, and US Cura Tox-FS at
the rate 1g/kg diet respectively. The clinical signs noticed after 24 hours of feeding
of TMTD (60 ppm and 100 ppm) in group II and III which were treated as negative
controls. They exhibited clinical sings like huddling, not willing to move, less feed
and water intake. Subsequently, they showed hock sitting posture, unable to getup,
widening of legs and wings, twisting of toes, resting on sternum with backward
stretching of legs, wobbling gait and imbalance in standing (Plate 1, Fig. 1 - 9).
The above symptoms were also observed in groups VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, and
XII but to the lesser extent than group II and III birds which were depicted in plate 2
(Fig. 1-12).
50
lxxxvii
During the 2nd week mortality of 5 and 3 birds in group II and III, 3 birds in
other groups (VII, VIII, X and XII) was observed. During 3rd week, 2 birds from
group III, 3 birds from group VIII succumbed. These deaths were due to starvation
as the birds were unable to getup and take feed and water.
presented in Table 3 and the graph depicted in plate 3. Right from the end of first
week, there was a drop in body weight gain in respective groups. The lowest
cumulative mean value (621 g) was recorded in group III and the highest cumulative
mean value (1114 g) was observed in group V. These results were highly significant
and calculated FCR are shown in Table 4 and the graphically presented in plate 4.
The total feed consumption in different experimental groups during 1st to 5th week of
age, and also the cumulative means were highly significant (P≤ 0.01). At the end of
the experiment, the lowest cumulative mean value (2.94) was observed in group III
and the highest cumulative mean value (3.26) was recorded in group VIII.
leukocytes related parameters (TLC and DLC) are shown in Table 7 and 8 and
lxxxviii
During 1st week, the decrease in mean values (2.47, 2.85 and 2.87) were
recorded in groups II, X and III and groups I, VII, XI and XII recorded highly
significant (P ≤ 0.01) increase in these values (3.28, 3.32, 3.10 and 3.15). During 3rd
week, lower values (3.37) were recorded in groups II and III, and higher values
(3.55, 3.63 and 3.67) were observed in VII, IX and VI. The lowest value (3.35) was
also recorded in group I. By the end of experiment (5th week) lower values were
observed in group VIII and XI, significantly higher value (3.43) was recorded in
Significantly lower mean values of PCV were recorded in group III, VIII, IX
and X, and higher values were observed in group I and XI during the 1st week of
experiment. During 3rd week it was not significant, but at the end of experiment (5th
58
week) highly significant lower value (30.00) was recorded in group IV and higher
higher mean value (179.83) was observed in group III (100 ppm TMTD) during 1st
week of experiment. During 3rd week significantly lower values (128.83, 129.17 and
130.17) were observed in groups II, IV and V respectively and the higher value
lxxxix
(136.83) was recorded in group XII. By the end of experiment (5th week) the lower
value was recorded in group II and higher value was observed in group XI.
mean value (40.50) was recorded in group III during 1st week of experiment. During
3rd week, lower value was recorded in group XII and the higher value was observed
in group XI and I in which group XI was treated with ameliorative agent. By the end
(5th week) of the study, lower value (31.00) was observed in group I and higher
value was recorded in group VIII (100 ppm TMTD and 200 ppm CuSo4).
The MCHC was not significant during 1st week of experiment. However,
during the 3rd week the lowest value (27.67) was observed in group II (60 ppm
TMTD) and significantly higher value (30.83) was recorded in group IX. During 5th
week, lower mean value (21.83) was recorded in group I compared to treated
groups.
61
TLC was recorded in group XII (100 ppm TMTD and US CuraTox 1g/kg) and
increase in mean value (3579) was observed in group I. During 3rd week lower mean
value (1011) was recorded in group II (60 ppm TMTD) and higher value (2716) was
recorded in group I. At the end of the study, (5th week) lower value (2128) was
recorded in group XI and the higher value (3466) was observed in group I.
was recorded in group VIII and the increased mean value (39.17) was observed in
xc
group I during 1st week of experiment. During 3rd week, lower mean value (18.33)
was recorded in group IX and higher value was observed in group X. The
the highest mean value (79.50) was observed in groups VIII during 1st week of
group X and higher value (75.00) was observed in group II (60 ppm TMTD) during
2nd week of experiment. At the end of the experiment (5th week) the mean
significantly (P ≤ 0.01) higher value (3.17) was observed in group I. During 5th
and the highest value (5.67) was recorded in group II during 1st week of experiment
and it was not significant (P ≥ 0.05) during 3rd and 5th week of experiment.
albumin, globulin and A/G ratio) are tabulated in Table 9 and 10 and related graphs
group VII and higher (122.83) in group VIII. Significantly (P ≤ 0.01) lower value
xci
(97.67) was recorded in group IV and higher value (145.00) was observed in group I
during 3rd week of experiment. At the end of experiment (5th week) the lower mean
glucose value (177.17) was recoded in group IX and the higher values were
observed in groups II (60 ppm TMTD), VII (60 ppm TMTD and 200 ppm CuSo4)
higher value (164.16) was observed in group IX. At the end of experiment (5th day)
significantly lower value (117.50) was recorded in group X and higher values
were recorded in group III and IV, and the highest mean value (5.67) was observed
in group V during 1st week of experiment. During 3rd week, lower value (4.45) was
observed in group XI and the higher value (5.29) was observed in group X. At the
end of experiment (5th week) significantly (P ≤ 0.01) lower value (5.37) was
recorded in group IX and higher values were observed in groups I, VI and XI.
xcii
4.6.5 Serum globulin (G)
During 1st week of experiment, lowest mean value (1.37) of serum globulin
was recorded in group IV and the highest value (2.78) was observed in group V.
During 3rd week of experiment, significantly (P ≤ 0.01) lower value (1.10) was
recorded in group IX and higher value (2.13) was observed in group III (100
66
ppm TMTD). During 5th week, lowest value was recorded in (2.63) in group III and
highest value (4.33) was observed in group IV (200 ppm CuSo4).
4.6.6 Albumin: Globulin (A/ G) ratio
Significantly (P ≤ 0.01) lower mean value (0.33) of A/G ratio was recorded
in group III and the highest mean value (2.32) was recorded in group IV during 1st
week of experiment. During 3rd and 5th weeks, the A/G ratio was not significant
Serum enzymes parameters (AST, ALT, GGT, ALP and serum calcium are
depicted in Table 11 and 12 and relevant graphs are shown in plate 11 and 12 (Fig.
were observed in groups IV and VI, and elevated mean values (31.50 and 31.67)
were recorded in groups II and XI during 1st week of experiment. During 3rd week,
lower value (24.92) was observed in group IX and higher value (30.75) was recoded
in group IV. By the end of experiment (5th week), lower mean value (15.67) was
recorded in group II and higher values (31.33 and 31.50) were recorded in groups V
and XI.
xciii
Highly significant (P ≤ 0.01) decrease in mean value (14.50) of ALT was
observed in group VII and increased mean value (30.83) was observed in group VI
during 1st week of experiment. During 3rd week of experiment, lower mean value
67
(15.17) of ALT was observed in group IX and higher value (22.25) was recorded in
group IV. Significantly lower mean value (15.50) was recorded in group X and
higher mean value (31.00) was observed in group III (100 ppm TMTD) during 5th
week of experiment.
4.7.3 Gamma-Glutamyl transferase (GGT)
Highly significant (P ≤ 0.01) lower mean value (12.25) of GGT was recorded
in groups V and XII and higher values (20.25 and 20.33) were observed in groups
IX and X during 1st week of experiment. By 3rd week of experiment, the lower mean
value (11.58) was recorded in group XI and higher mean value (18.25) was observed
in group IV. At the end of experiment (5th week) the lower mean value (11.83) was
and the highest mean value (141) was observed in group VIII during 1st week of
study. During 3rd week group VIII recoded lower value (107.50) and higher value
(125.08) was recorded for group VI. By the end of experiment (5th week) the lowest
value (110.17) was recorded in group IV and the highest value (131.50) was
observed in group V.
xciv
3.33) were recorded in groups XII, VIII and II respectively, when compared to other
groups.
4.8 MORPHOMETRY
The mean values of tibial bones, liver and kidney are depicted in Table 13
and 14 and corresponding graphs are shown in plate 13 (Fig. 1, 2 & 3) and 14 (Fig. 1
and 2).
bone weight was recorded in group II and the higher value (3.37) was observed in
group IV. The lowest mean value (3.91) was observed in group III and highest
values (12.91 and 12.95) were recorded in groups V and I during 3rd week of
experiment. During 5th week, lower values (16.11 and 16.12) were recorded in
groups III and II respectively and higher values (28.30 and 28.51) were observed in
Significantly lower mean values (2.44, 2.56 and 2.70) of liver weights were
recorded in groups II, IX and VII and higher value was observed in group IV during
1st week of experiment. During 3rd week significantly (P ≤ 0.01) lower value (6.35)
was observed in group IX and higher values (21.85 and 22.43) were recorded in
group I and group IV. By the end of experiment (5th week), lowest mean value
(12.98) was recorded in group VIII while the highest value (42.57) was observed in
group V.
71
recorded in group II and higher mean value (1.22) was observed in group I. Highly
significant reduction in mean value (1.65) was recorded in group II while higher
xcv
values (6.40 and 6.52) were observed in groups I (control) and IV (200 ppm CuSo 4)
during 3rd week of experiment. By the end (5th week), highly significant decrease in
mean values (2.51 and 2.53) were recorded in groups II and III which were fed with
60 ppm and 100 ppm of TMTD and elevated mean value (8.81) was observed in
group I.
for group IX (60 ppm TMTD and 1g/kg LivOrdain-FS) and higher mean values
(4.63, 4.60 and 4.57) were recorded for groups I, II and III respectively.
Significantly decrease in mean values (5.15 and 5.22) were recorded for group II and
III respectively and increased value (7.42) was observed in group I during 3rd week
of experiment. By the end (5th week), lower mean value (7.38) was recorded in
2, MMP-2 and MMP-3 are shown in the Table 15 and 16. Consistent results were
obtained with the standardized test and the associated graphs are shown in plate 15
4.9.1 VEGF
xcvi
During 5th day of experiment, significantly (P ≤ 0.01) lower mean C
T value
(33.92) was observed in group III and the higher mean value (38.78) was recorded in
group X. By the 10th day of experiment significantly lower mean value (30.59) was
observed in group X and higher value (37.68) was recorded in group III. During 15th
day of experiment, lower value (29.16) was recorded in group VIII and higher value
4.9.2 VEGFR1
C
Significantly (P ≤ 0.01) decreased mean T value (20.47) of VEGFR1 was
observed in group III and higher value (22.29) was recorded in group V during 5th
day of experiment. During 10th day, lower value (18.10) was recorded in group VIII
and higher value (22.09) was observed in group I. By the 15th day of experiment,
significantly lower value (18.44) was recorded in group VIII and higher value
(21.85) was recorded in group III.
4.9.3 Bcl – 2
Significantly (P ≤ 0.01) lower mean CT value (19.73) of Bcl-2 was recorded
in group III and higher value (21.68) was observed in group X during 5th day of
experiment. During 10th day, significantly lower values (18.71 and 18.74) were
recorded for groups VIII and X respectively. By the 15th day of experiment, lowest
75
value (18.26) was recorded in group VIII and highest value (21.81) was observed in
group III.
4.9.4 MMP2
During 5th day of experiment highly significant (P ≤ 0.01) lower mean C
T
values (28.34) was recorded in group X and higher value (36.94) was observed in
group V. By the 10th day of experiment, lower value (26.28) was observed in group
X and higher value (32.250) was recorded in group IV. During 15th day, lowest
value (24.25) was observed in group VIII and highest value (29.10) was recorded in
group I.
4.9.5 MMP3
xcvii
Significantly (P ≤ 0.01) lower mean CT value (21.02) of MMP3 was recorded
in group IV and highest value (23.55) was observed in group V during 5th day of
experiment. During 10th day decreased mean values (19.42 and 19.46) were recorded
in groups VIII and X and increased value 23.66) was observed in group I. By the
15th day of experiment, significantly lower value (19.37) was observed in group VIII
growth plate cartilage (TGPC) as this was the focal and targeted organ in TMTD
induced TD in broilers. Gross pathological changes were noticed soon after 24 hours
of feeding the experimental diets. The significant gross changes of tibial bones were
observed in group II and III (length, weight, decreased diameter and slight bending
78
at proximal extremity) where as groups VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, and XII showed mild to
extremity, and mild increase in diameter of proximal extremity (Plate 17, Fig. 1- 4).
The birds of control group I, group IV (BD + CuSo4 200 ppm), group V (BD +
LivOrdian 1g/kg diet) and group VI (BD + US Cura Tox 1g/kg diet) did not reveal
any gross changes in the tibial bones. All the tibial bones were longitudinally
sectioned and the lesions of growth plate cartilage at its widest point was measured
and graded as mild (+), moderate (++) and severe (+++) lesions are shown in Table
Table 29: Gross tibial growth plate cartilage lesions during 5th, 10th and 15th
day (width at the widest point) of experiment.
xcviii
36 birds - 5th day 11 4 3
36 birds - 10th day 3 9 6
36 birds - 15th day 2 4 12
Total (108 birds) 16 17 21
Table 30: Gross tibial growth plate cartilage lesions during 1st, 3rd and 5th week
(width at the widest point) of experiment.
Number of birds + Mild ++ Moderate +++ Sever
and age (>1mm) (>1mm <3mm) (>3mm)
72 birds -1st week 13 11 48
rd
72 birds -3 week 9 18 45
72 birds -5th week 11 19 42
Total (216 birds) 33 48 135
Gross lesions observed in liver and kidney included shrinkage of liver and
kidneys which were more in group II and III. Where as in group VII, VIII, X and
XII showed mild shrinkage of liver and kidney. However, moderate enlargement
was noticed in group IV, V, VI than group I. Mild to moderate congestion of liver
79
and kidneys and oozing of bloody exudates from cut surface was also observed in
group II and III birds which is depicted in plate 17 (Fig. 5 and 6) where as other
4.11 HISTOPATHOLOGY
4.11.1 Histopathology of tibial bones growth plate cartilage (TGPC)
In general, the histopathological changes in TD induced tibial bone growth
plate cartilage showed remarkable changes in hypertrophic zone than the other zones
prehypertrophic zones irrespective of the age of the birds. In all the treated birds
tibial growth plate cartilage samples revealed marked changes like swollen, oval and
xcix
chromatin material. Some sections revealed eosinophilic nuclei and some showed
In all cases, the epiphyseal hyaline cartilage zone was of normal in thickness
group III cartilage sections in addition to the changes described above. Mild
thickening was also noticed in other groups (VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, and XII) and
irregular chondrocytes with clusters and abundant matrix was observed among the
The transitional zone was abnormally thickened with oval chondrocytes and
more of eosinophilic matrix in group II and group III and a slight variable change
were also recorded in other groups VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, and XII. Hypertrophic zone
was thickened and invaded by few blood vessels which appeared empty.
Eosinophilic matrix, pyknotic nuclei and empty capsules were seen. The bone
trabeculae appear to be normal but irregularly arranged. Defective cartilaginous
mass of cells and abrupt ossification, osteoblastic and osteoclastic activity and
transition of cartilage to bone tissue were seen in group II and III. The other groups
(VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, and XII) revealed mild to moderate changes where as groups I
and V were apparently normal. The sections of group VI revealed no significant
change but in group IV sections showed an irregular penetration of an emerging
capillaries (more in number) arising from diaphysis to metaphysis.
Mild changes similar to above sections were also observed in other groups
(VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, and XII). The sections of group IV, V, and VI did not show
any such changes Based on the above observations the lesions were classified as
c
mild (+), moderate (++) and severe (+++) as shown below in Table 31 (days) and
proliferating zone, transitional zone and hypertrophic zone with pyknotic nucleoli,
Moderate lesion (++): Moderate lesion was characterized by thin hyaline zone,
82
and empty cleft like chondrocytes grouped in clusters. The thickened hypertrophic
layer was invaded by few blood vessels which appeared empty. Eosinophilic matrix,
In general, there was dose dependent increase in the number of non nucleated
chondrocytes within the treatment groups when compared to the control group
without nucleus. The cartilage cell arrangement was completely disturbed. The
above lesions were recorded with slight variation between ++ to +++ as per the dose
variation is concerned (60 ppm, 100 ppm). There was no significant change in the
emerging capillaries. Over all in all groups the changes were very close as far as the
ci
not much variation was recorded. In CuSo4 fed groups (IV, VII and VIII) the
hyper trophic zones with centrally placed nuclei. Blood vessels were seen in all the
zones.
83
Six birds from each group (II, III, IV, V, VIII, and X) were sacrificed during the
days 5th, 10th, and 15th. A total of 90 tibial growth plate cartilage samples were used
histopathological changes in different groups (II) 18, (III) 18, (VIII) 10 and (X) 12,
where as in group IV one sample and in group V two samples revealed mild lesions.
Severe lesions were observed in group II and III which were fed with 60 ppm and
100 ppm of TMTD. Where as in ameliorative groups (VIII and X) mild lesions were
recorded (Plates 18, 19 and 20, Fig. 1- 6, Fig. 1-5 and Fig. 1- 4) during 5th, 10th and
Table 31: Histopathological lesions in TMTD treated birds during 5th, 10th and
15th day
Groups Severity of lesions Total
& No. of samples
+ ++ +++
II- 60 ppm TMTD 5 9 4 18
III-100 ppm TMTD 4 7 7 18
IV-200 ppm CuSO4 1 - - 1
V- LivOrdain-FS @ of 1g/kg diet 2 - - 2
VIII-100ppm TMTD + 200ppm CuSO4 3 4 3 10
X-100ppmTMTD + LivOrdain-FS @ of 1g/kgdiet 3 5 4 12
Total 16 25 18 59
cii
Similarly, six birds from each group (I to XII) were sacrificed during the 1 st,
3rd, and 5th weeks and a total of 216 tibial growth plate cartilage samples were also
collected and used for H&E staining out of which 92 samples revealed different
observed in group II and III, while moderate lesions (++) were noticed in groups V
and VI. The other groups recorded mild (+) changes. The histopathological lesions
observed in different groups during 1st, 3rd and 5th week of age depicted in
84
plate 21, 22 (Fig. 1-4) plate23, 24 (Fig. 1-6) and in plate 25, 26 (Fig. 1- 6) in
Table 32: Histopathological lesions in TMTD treated groups during 1st, 3rd, and
5th week of age.
Groups Severity of lesions Total
& No. of samples
+ ++ +++
I-BD (Basal diet) - - - -
II- 60 ppm TMTD 4 7 7 18
III-100 ppm TMTD 2 5 11 18
IV-200 ppm CuSO4 2 1 - 3
V- LivOrdain-FS @ of 1g/kg diet - - - -
VI- US CuraTox FS - - - -
VII-60 ppm TMTD +200ppm CuSO4 3 4 2 9
VIII-100 ppm TMTD + 200ppm CuSO4 2 3 2 7
IX-60 ppm TMTD + LivOrdain-FS @ of 1g/kg 4 3 - 7
diet
X-100 ppm TMTD + LivOrdain-FS @ of 1g/kg 4 5 - 9
diet
XI-60 ppm TMTD + US CuraTox-FS @ of 1g/kg 3 3 1 7
diet
XII-100ppm TMTD+ US CuraTox-FS @ of1g/kg 6 5 3 14
diet
Total 30 36 26 92
VIII, and X based on the pathognomonic lesions revealed during 5th, 10th, and 15th
ciii
days of H&E study. There was not much difference in the histological changes when
compared with routine H&E satin. The lesions observed in group III sections
included pyknotic nuclei in few chondrocytes, few was empty and oval and large
with few empty cells, where as group V sections revealed dilated vessels with blood
and chondrocytes were in rows and clusters with most of the cells having centrally
placed dense nuclei. Group VIII sections showed large oval empty chondrocytes
with more of matrix and pyknotic nuclei. The group X sections showed large oval
88
chondrocytes with nucleus, more of matrix and cells were in the form of clusters
Liver samples from all groups during days (5th, 10th, and 15th) and weeks (1st,
3rd, and 5th) were studied. The changes were observed in all groups during the above
period with dose difference (60 ppm and 100 ppm) which revealed similar changes
Sections from group III showed moderate to severe dilation of central vein
degeneration of perivascular area and shrunken hepatocytes. The wall of the blood
vessels was thickened with karyorrhexic and pyknotic nuclei. Sections of group IV
revealed moderate dilatation of CV, complete distortion of hepatic cords and focal
dilated sinusoids with focal areas of congestion and varied shape and size of the
civ
moderate to sever fatty change and focal areas of degenerating hepatocytes. In some
material. Few sections revealed mild sinusoidal congestion, fatty change and
MNC’s.
95
The above described lesions were focused in plate 28 (Fig. 1-5) during 5th day, in
plate 29 (Fig. 1-5) for the period of 10th day and in plate 30 (Fig. 1-3) for the period
day 1st, 3rd, and 5th week) were used for histopathological observations and there
were no variable changes with respect to the dose and interval. In group III, sections
optimum sized nucleus and the dilated area is filled with blood. On 15th day and in
cv
mononuclear cells, focal areas of hyaline casts, greater intertubular dilatation and
congestion. The changes were mild in early age and pronounced as the treatment
31(Fig. 1-5) for 5th day, in plate 32 (Fig. 1-4) for 10th day and in plate 33 (Fig. 1-4)
97
observe the apoptosis (Bcl-2) and endothelial growth factor (VEGF) reactions in
group I, III, IV, V, VIII and X during 5th,10th and 15th day of experiment.
expressed during the course of early cell death in which the nucleus is stained dark
with brown color indicate the presence of antigen. The antigen was detected in the
chondrocytes of group III with intensive reaction and large chondrocytes without
nucleus showing empty clefts like structures, where as in group IV intensely stained
the samples revealed pyknotic nuclei and chromatolysis without stining reaction of
antigen and few cells were empty but chondrocytes were arranged in cords and
clusters. Where as in group VIII, the intensity of reaction was increased and the
pyknotic nuclei number was more and most of the cells were empty with cleft like
dense intensily stained nucleus and emerging capillaries. All these changes were
cvi
predominently observed in pre hypertrophic and hypertrophic zones of growth plate
104
embedded section for detection of endothelial cellular changes of tibail bone growth
intensity of reaction was observed as brown color which indicated the extent damage
during the development of TD. Group I showed numerous vessels without staining
reaction of endothelium, on the contrary group III showed dilated vessels with
number was found to be increased with increased intensity of staining reaction, and
in groups V, VIII and X mild staining reaction of lining endothelium was observed
cvii
105
endoplasmic reticulum (RER), enlargement of para-nuclear space, swollen
the samples cytoplasmic vaccuolation was seen. Abundant ER dilated with large
was seen. In few cells, mineral aggregates in interstitial septa and lipid vacuoles
were observed of which the former increased the lucency of cytoplasm of necrotic
chondrocytes.
RER with dilated regions in the vicinity of Golgi complex and secondary vacuoles.
Some samples have round nucleus with eccentrically placed nucleolus, distorted
Group X revealed round nucleus, with faint nucleolus mild dilated RER with
and vesicular mitochondria along with elongated chondrocytes and round nucleus
cells which had similar cytoplasmic features and crescentric caps of condensed
chromatin.
108
cviii
The other findings were much more related with apoptosis, as a result of
which the tissue contained immature cells that outlived their normal life span. In
some samples of group III, VIII the nuclear membrane appeared crenated with
channels showed evidence of cell death and apoptosis with peripheral chromatin
condensation with loose inter cellular junctions. The above described TEM sub-
cellular changes were shown in plate 36 (Fig. 1-6) for 5th day, in plate 37 (Fig. 1-6)
during 10th day and in plate 38 (Fig. 1-6) for 15th day of experiment.
material disrupted nucleolus and swollen mitochondria with loss of matrix. Some
sections of 10th and 15th day showed perinuclear swelling, cytoplasmic vacuolation.
Few mitochondria were condensed and others were swollen with loss of matrix.
Some sections of 15th day revealed swollen nucleus, margination of chromatin and
nucleus, with margination of chromatin, large nucleolus and loss of other sub
cellular organelle. The electron dense granular material was also noticed throughout
field. The liver samples of 10th and 15th day of group IV showed moderately swollen
material.
Some sections in group V showed swollen nucleus with loss of outer margins
and complete loss of cell organelle, and electron dense chromatin blocks in the
nucleoplasma with a faint mitochondria and electron dense granularity throughout
109
field. Group VIII samples of different periods (5th, 10th, and 15th day) revealed
cix
complete loss of cellular architecture, cytoplasmic vaccuolation distorted nuclear
membrane and loss of other organelle. Fifth day samples of group VIII revealed
chromatin material and swollen mitochondria with scanty and faint matrix. During
15th day group VIII sample showed additional feature like loss of nucleolus and
nucleus with mild margination of chromatin and outer nuclear membrane with dark
faint blocks of chromatin, swollen and condensed mitochondria with scanty and
faint matrix with a prominent cytoplasmic vaccuolation was showed in plate 39, 40
cells, disrupted and marginated chromatin with narrow tubular lumen. In group IV, it
revealed dilated interstium filled with blood, shrunken and distorted tubule with
necrotic epithelial cells. Where as group V kidney samples revealed necrotic and
distorted tubular epithelial cells with electron dense granular material and faint
condensed mitochondria. The nucleus of tubular epithelial cells showed varied shape
and size, and few samples (10th and 15th day) revealed the brush border of proximal
113
Where as in group VIII the epithelial cells were shrunken with electron dense
vacuoles and vacuolated mitochondria were also observed. As the age advanced the
changes in group VIII revealed distorted epithelial cells with varied shape and size
cx
of nucleus, condensed mitochondria, brush border of PCT, loose inter cellular
junction and necrotic epithelial cells. Group X irrespective of age showed distorted
and necrotic epithelial cells with pyknotic nuclei and condensed nucleolus loose
inter cellular junction, swollen mitochondria and loss of brush border and narrowed
tubular lumen. In contrast to this the group I samples revealed intertubular junction
with intact epithelium with properly arranged sub cellular organelle. The
ultrastructural changes of kidney for different periods (5th, 10th and 15th day) of
few haemorrhges. Group V cartialge sample showed narrowed Haversion system but
appeared normal. The VIII and X group samples revealed completely altered
hepatic parenchyma. Group X slices revealed mild dilataion of vessels and altered
cxi
tubules and narrowed tubular lumen were noticed in group IV. Marked
haemorrhages and narrowed tubules were observed in group V. Group VIII samples
revealed a moderately swollen tubules with complete closure of tubular lumen. Mild
intertubular dilatation was seen in group X samples (Plate 47, Fig. 1-6).
The RT-PCR gel was run for the required experimental period and
synthesized gel pictures are depicted in plate 48 (Fig.1- 4) along with molecular
The RT-PCR product for the selective genes (VEGF, VEGFR1, Bcl-2,
and the amplification plots and dissociation curves and depicted in plate 49
122
cxii
CHAPTER - V
DISCUSSION
In the present study, TD was induced by TMTD (60 ppm and 100 ppm) and
an attempt was made to counter act the TD lesion with certain ameliorative agents
was studied. Thiram treated groups exhibited clinical signs like huddling,
disinclination to move and reduced intake of feed and water. Subsequently, they
showed hock sitting posture, unable to getup, spraddle legs, showering, lateral and
backward stretching of legs and wobbling gait were observed in few birds. Similar
observations were made by several research groups (Waible et al., 1955 and 1957;
Vargas et al., 1983; Veltmann and Linton 1986; Ramljak et al., 1988; Weidong Wu
et al., 1990 and 1993; Lakshman et al., 2002; Rath et al., 2004 and Subapriya et al.,
period. The above symptoms were also observed in ameliorative groups (VII, VIII,
IX, X, XI, and XII) to a lesser extent when compared to thiram (II and III) fed
chicks. However, the birds survived till the end of the experiment in comparison
with group II and III in which few fatalities were recorded. These observations are
partly supported by the results of Weidong Wu et al., (1990 and 1993) and
In the present experiment the cumulative body weight gains (621and 664 g)
were significantly (P < 0.01) lower in TMTD treated groups (II and III) over other
cxiii
This finding is in conformity with many research reports (Waible et al., 1955
and 1957; Ackerson and Mussehl 1955; Vargas et al., 1983; Veltmann and Linton
1986; Rao et al., 1996; Lakshman, 2004 and Subapriya et al., 2007b) of different
experiments carried out 60 ppm to 240 ppm of TMTD for a period of two days to
8weeks of age. Contrary to this Veltmann et al., (1985) and Weidong Wu et al.,
(1990 and 1993) Rath et al., (1994) Lakshman (2004) and Subapriya et al., (2007b)
reported insignificant difference in body weight gains at lower levels (15, 30 and 37
ppm) of TMTD.
Higher body weight gains (1105 and 1114 g) were recorded in the present
with findings of Weidong Wu et al., (1990) and Lakshman et al., (2002) who made a
first study on the role of CuSo4 (200 ppm) as an ameliorative agent against TD. The
significant finding of this experiment is that, the herbal product (LivOrdain) showed
fed groups and lower (2.18 and 2.41) in group IV (200 ppm CuSo 4) and V
Significantly (P≤0.01) lower means (2.47, 2.85 and 2.87) of TEC were
recorded in group II, X and III during 1st week of experiment. During 3rd and 5th
week lower means were observed in groups II, III, VIII and XI. These results
cxiv
observation is in accordance with opinion of Rath et al., (2004) who expressed mild
need to study more in this regard as the TEC plays a pivotal role by supplying O2 to
agent is used.
(P≤0.01) lower in group III (100 ppm TMTD), VIII (100 ppm TMTD + 200 ppm
CuSo4) and XI (60 ppm TMTD + UsCuraTox) and higher (9.72, 10.05 and 11.93) in
during 1st, 3rd and 5th week of experiment. The lower Hb values indicated that the
TMTD at higher level might be interfering with the metabolism and absorption of
Hb synthesizing elements in the body. The results indicated that CuSo4 (200ppm),
but not in combination with TMTD (60 ppm and 100 ppm). On the contrary,
previous reports (Weidong Wu et al., 1990 and Subapriya et al., 2007a) revealed
recorded in group III and X during 1st week. The results indicated that not only
TMTD (100 ppm) but also the CuSo4 is influenced the PCV. The role of
ameliorative agents during third week appears to be beneficial. The results of 1st and
5th week were contrary to the previous observations of Weidong Wu et al., (1990)
and Subapriya et al., (2007a) who opined that the hematocrit was insignificant.
However, in this study similar observations were drawn during 3rd week of
experiment.
cxv
5.4.4 ERYTHROCYTE INDICES
Significantly lower means were recorded in group II, IV, V, VIII, IX and
XII, during the entire experimental period. These results are similar to that of TEC,
Hb and PCV as the indices values are derived from the above parameters. Hence, it
can be inferred that the indices are in accordance with other erythrocytes parameters.
5.4.5 Total leukocytes count (TLC) and differential leucocytes count (DLC)
TLC values were significantly (P ≤ 0.01) lower in group XII during 1st week,
in group II during 3rd week and in group XI during 5th week. Among DLC
heterophils were significantly lower in group VIII and IX, lymphocytes were lower
in group I and X and eosinophils were lower in group VIII and III during 1st and 3rd
lymphocytes and sharp increase in heterophils and normal limits of TLC and other
Significantly (P≤0.01) lower glucose (IV, VII and IX), cholesterol (II, III and
X) and total protein and A/G (III, IV, IX and XI) were recorded during 1st, 3rd and
inducing and ameliorative agents action in relation with healthiness of liver in all
groups. The glucose was lower in CuSo4 control group, 60 ppm TMTD + CuSo4 and
liver which resulted in the lower body weight gains (VII and IX) but not in group
different groups. The lower cholesterol values in TMTD treated groups clearly
indicated the damage to the liver. However, group X also revealed lower value
indicating that LivOrdian did not protect the organ during this period of experiment.
TP and A/G ratio were lower in 100 ppm TMTD and CuSo4 treated groups,
cxvi
indicating the extent of liver damage. Similarly, in 60 ppm TMTD+LivOrdain and
60 ppm TMTD +UsCuraTox fed groups addition of ameliorative agents did not
protect the liver damage. Theses findings are in agreement with the earlier
observations made by Walser et al., (1982), Coles (1986) and Mishra et al., (1998)
who worked only with TMTD but not with the ameliorative agents. Contrary to
these Rath et al., (2004) and Subhapriya et al., (2007) recorded no significant
difference in TMTD treated groups. The lower values in different groups reflected
the compromising in weight gain due to improper protein synthesis, variation in A/G
ratio, cholesterol synthesis and its utilization which played a major role in growth
performance. In the present study, higher values of globulin and glucose in group V
could be due to the hepato stimulant action of LivOrdain fed at the rate of 1g/ kg
diet.
Significantly lower values (17.17 and 18.00) of AST were recorded in group
IV and VI during 1st week, in group II and X it was significantly lower during 3rd
and 5th week of experiment. Lower values (14.50, 15.17 and 15.50) of ALT was
observed in group VII, IX and X respectively during 1st, 3rd and 5th week of
experiment. GGT values were lower in group V, XI, IX and XII during the
experimental period. These results indicated the extent of damage to the liver due to
TMTD toxic action and chemical action of CuSo4 and UsCuraTox. Contrary to this
lower GGT was recorded in group V fed with herbal liver protectant during 1st week
The ALP was significantly low in group V, IV and VIII and the calcium was
low in group II, VIII and XII indicating the toxic action of TMTD and CuSo 4 at
cxvii
cellular and sub cellular level (Tanabe and Wilcox 1960; Rath et al., 1994 and 2004;
Significantly lower weights (31.22, 3.91, 16.11 and 16.12) of tibail bones,
liver (2.44, 2.70, 6.35and 12.98) and kidneys (1.22, 1.65, 2.51 and 2.53) were
observed in TMTD treated groups during 1st 3rd and 5th week of experiment.
Similarly, lower values of length (3.63, 4.63, 4.60, 4.57, 5.15, 5.22 and 7.38) and
diameter (0.21, 0.61 and 1.17) were recorded in TMTD fed birds. The results clearly
indicated that the TMTD has toxic effects on the development and growth of the
vital organs, which play a pivotal role in the body weight gains.
Out of the 12 groups of birds maintained, only 6 groups (I, III, IV, V, VIII,
X) were selected to study the level of expression of genes associated with the TD.
5.8.1 VEGF
The expression of VEGF gene was up regulated in thiram treated birds (III
group) at 5th day, but down regulated at 10th day and again up regulated at 15th day,
when compared to normal control birds (Group I). These findings are similar to
those of Rath et al., (2007), wherein increased expression of the VEGF gene was
reported up to 166 hours (7 days). In birds treated with both thiram and
cxviii
ameliorating agent copper sulphate (VIII group), the VEGF gene was up regulated at
5th day, 10th day and 15th day, when compared to copper sulphate controls (Group
IV). This up regulation of VEGF gene in group VIII was attributed mainly to the
action of thiram and not due to combined action of thiram and copper sulphate as
copper sulphate alone could not up regulate the VEGF gene expression on 5th and
10th day in copper sulphate controls (Group IV). In birds treated with both thiram
and LivOrdian (Group X) the VEGF gene was down regulated on 5th day and 15th
day, but not on 10th day, when compared to LivOrdian controls (Group V). It may be
surmised that LivOrdian possibly played role in down regulating the VEGF gene in
the group X. Since the objective of the study is to observe the regulation of the
for ameliorating agent were maintained for comparing the regulation of selected
5.8.2 VEGFR1
treated birds (Group III) at 5th day and 15th day, but it was slightly up regulated at
10day when compared to normal controls. However, Rath et al., (2007) reported that
the VEGFR1 gene expression was down regulated up to 166 hours. But reports are
not available about the regulation of VEGFR1 gene beyond 166 hours in thiram
treated birds. The VEGFR1 gene was up regulated at 5th day and 15th day in birds
treated with both thiram and ameliorating agent copper sulphate (VIII group). No
appreciable effect on VEGFR1 regulation was found at 10th day, when compared to
copper sulphate controls (Group IV). In birds treated with both thiram and
cxix
LivOrdain the VEGFR1 gene was up regulated on 5th day and 10th day, but not on
15th day when compared to LivOrdian controls. Therefore, it may be realized that
LivOrdian exerted its action in arresting the down regulation of VEGFR1 gene.
Although the ameliorative agents could modulate expression of VEGF and VEGFR1
genes in thiram treated birds, their effect varied at different days. Since this is a
preliminary work, further research work with increased sample size is required to
TD.
5.8.3 Bcl-2
birds (Group III) on 5th day and 10th day but remain unchanged at 15th day, when
compared to normal controls (Group I). This indicated that the cartilage plate cells in
thiram treated birds (5th and 10 day) were less prone to apoptosis up to 10th day
results are contrary to the findings of Rath et al., (2007) as it was reported that the
expression of VEGFR1 and Bcl-2 genes were down regulated in thiram treated
birds. In the present study, thiram was fed to birds of respective groups throughout
the experiment. Whereas Rath et al., (2007) studied the expression of selected genes
up to 48 hours in birds fed with thiram (in feed). In the present study, expression of
VEGF, VEGFR1 and Bcl-2 genes in tissue samples was studied at 5th day, 10th day
and 15th day, whereas Rath et al., (2007) studied the expression of these genes from
48 hours to 166 hours. As the thiram itself could not down regulate Bcl-2 gene
cxx
5.8.4 MMP 2
MMP-2 plays prominent role in the recovery phase of TD (Dan et al., 2009).
An increased CT value of MMP-2 gene in thiram fed birds (Group III) was observed
at 10th day indicating the decreased expression (down regulation) of MMP-2 gene.
This is in accordance with the findings of Hasky- Negev et al., (2008) and Dan et
al., (2009). However in the present study increased expression (up regulation) of
MMP-2 gene was observed at 5th day and 15th day in thiram fed birds. This may
attributed that at 5th day the TD might have not been fully set and at 15th day the
recovery phase might be in progress. Taking clue from the results it is observed that
the ameliorative agent copper sulphate countered the effect of thiram on MMP-2
gene expression at 10th and 15th day, which is indicated by the increased expression
C
of MMP-2 gene (decreased T values) in birds treated with both thiram and
ameliorating agent copper sulphate (Group VIII), when compared to thiram treated
birds (Group III). However such an effect was not observed in birds treated with
both thiram and LivOrdian (Group X). Therefore, it is opined that copper sulphate
5.8.5 MMP 3
The MMP-3 gene expression didn’t vary significantly in different groups at
5th day. However its expression was increased at 10th day in thiram treated birds
(Group III). This is contrary to the findings of Dan et al., (2009). Even both the
ameliorating agents further increased the expression of MMP-3 gene at 10th day, but
the expression levels were not consistent at 15th day. With this preliminary data it’s
is difficult to surmise the probable causes for increased levels of MMP-3 expression
cxxi
5.9 GROSS PATHOLOGY
Predominant changes were noticed in tibial bones, liver and kidneys of birds
in group II and III after 5th day of feeding of experimental diets. Group VII, VIII,
IX, X, XI, and XII samples also exhibited a mild to moderate changes during first
week of experiment. The birds of group I, group IV, group V and group VI did not
reveal any gross change in the tibial bones. The observations (not the ameliorative
effect) pertaining to tibail bones are in accordance with several authors (Vargas et
al., 1983; Veltmann et al., 1985 and 1986; Rao et al., 1996; Rath et al., 2004 and
2007 and Subapriya et al., 2007c). The above findings in relation with ameliorative
effect of CuSo4 are similar to findings of Weidong Wu et al., (1990 and1993) and
All the tibial bones were longitudinally sectioned and the lesions of growth
plate cartilage at its widest point was measured and graded as mild (+), moderate
(++), and sever (+++). Out of 108 birds sacrificed during 5th, 10th, and 15th day six
samples have revealed mild, 17 samples have shown moderate and 21 samples
revealed severe lesions. During 1st, 3rd and 5th week of age out of 216 samples, 33
revealed mild, 48 moderate and 135 revealed as severe lesions. The above
(2002).
5.10 HISTOPATHOLOGY
cxxii
disintegration of chromatin material of chondrocytes. Some sections revealed
columns and reduced vascularity of chondrocytes with abundant matrix. Most of the
chondrocytes were seen as clusters of empty cleft like structures. The transitional
zone was abnormally thickened with oval chondrocytes, more of eosinophilic matrix
in group II and III. Slight variable change was also recorded in other groups VII,
VIII, IX, X, XI, and XII. Whereas the hypertrophic zone was thickened and invaded
by a few blood vessels that appeared empty. The bone trabeculae appeared normal
tissue were seen in group II and III. Other groups (VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, and XII)
metaphysis.
changes in different groups (group II-18, group III-18, group VIII-10 and group X-
12. In group IV-1 sample and in group V-2 samples revealed mild lesions during 5th,
10th and 15th day. Severe lesions were observed in group II and III, which were fed
with 60 ppm and 100 ppm of TMTD, where as ameliorative groups (10 samples in
cxxiii
Sections of different groups during the 1st, 3rd, and 5th week were examined
changes. Severe lesions were observed in 18 samples each in group II and III, which
were fed with 60 ppm and 100 ppm of TMTD, respectively. Many reports (Leach
and Nesheim, 1965; Siller, 1970; Siller and Duff, 1970; Riddell et al., 1971; Riddell
et al., 1976; Bai and Cook 1994; Rath et al., 1994; Tselepis et al., 1996; Lakshman
et al., 2002; Pines et al., 2005 and Subapriya et al., 2007c) have described the
similar findings among immature chondrocytes and indicated that it could be due to
Histopathology of TGPC using Koneff’s satin was employed only in 10th day
samples of group I, III, IV, VIII, and X based on the pathognomonic lesions
revealed during 5th, 10th, and 15th days of H&E study. However no significant
pathological difference was observed when compared with routine H&E satin. The
lesions observed in group III sections were pyknotic nuclei in few chondrocytes.
While, few cells were empty and few were oval with large disorganized clusters.
chondrocytes with dark dense centrally placed nucleus with few empty cells, where
as group V sections revealed dilated vessels with blood and chondrocytes in rows
and clusters with most of the cells having centrally placed dense nuclei. Group VIII
sections showed large oval empty chondrocytes, with more of matrix and pyknotic
nuclei. Group X sections showed large oval chondrocytes with nucleus, more of
cxxiv
matrix and cells in the form of clusters than rows. Theses observations are in
Histopathology of liver sections for all groups (I-XII) on 5th, 10th, and 15th
day, and on 1st, 3rd, and 5th week was carried out. The sections of group III revealed
moderate to severe dilatation of central vein (CV), mild dilation of sinusoids, mild to
cords, focal areas of congestion and dilated sinusoids, varied shape and size of the
some sections a dark dense nucleus. The group VIII sections showed dilated vessels
fatty change and degeneration of hepatocytes with pyknotic nuclei. Group X liver
scanty and the previous observations made by Walser et al., (1982), Rao et al.,
(1996), Lakshman, (2004) and Subapriya et al., (2007c) are similar to the present
cxxv
5.10.3 Histopathology of Kidney
periods (5th, 10th, and 15th day; 1st, 3rd, and 5th week) were used for histopathological
observations and there were no variable changes in respect to the dose and period. In
group III, sections showed moderate to severe shrunken glomeruli with optimum
size nucleus and intertubular hemorrhage. On 15th day and in subsequent weeks
tubules, hyaline casts, shrunken glomeruli and mild dilatation of Bowman’s capsule.
and presence of hyaline casts. The changes were mild in early age and pronounced
as the treatment advanced. Present study observations are in agreement with the
findings of Walser et al., (1982), Rao et al., (1996) and Lakshman, (2004), who
against Bcl-2 antigen, which was expressed during the course of early cell death in
which the nucleus is stained dark and dense and with brown color indicating the
presence of antigen. The antigen was detected in the chondrocytes of group III with
cxxvi
intensive reaction, wherein large chondrocytes without nucleus showed empty cleft
like structures. Group IV revealed intensely stained dark dense nucleus in numerous
and chromatolysis of nucleus without staining reaction of antigen and few cells
were empty but chondrocytes were arranged in cords and clusters. In group VIII the
intensity of reaction was increased, the pyknotic nuclei number was more and most
of the cells were empty with cleft like structures. In group X the chondrocytes
appeared, have reorganised with dark dense intensily stained nucleus which was
centrally placed with emerging capillaries. All these changes were prodominently
ACP,AKP and ASP only. Lawler et al. (1988) has observed significant decrease in
the amnitude of ACP. Rath et al.,(1994) observed that the bitinilation enhanced
focus on Bcl-2 gene expression which palyes a significant role during the early death
observed as brown color which indicated the extent of damage during the
endothelium, on the contrary group III showed dilated vessels with increased
staining reaction of endothelium. In group IV, the capillary number increased with
intense staining reaction and in groups V, VIII and X mild staining reaction of lining
cxxvii
endothelium was observed. Gay et al.,(2007) studied the expression of VEGF in
localisation of VEGF. Tain et al., (2009) made an attempt to detect the differentailly
expressed genes (Col I and Hsp -90) in growth plate cartilage in relation with
present study could be the first report as far as the detection of Bcl-2 and VEGF
induced TD in broilers.
and mitochondria were very prominent. The ultrastructural changes of liver and
kidney were sequential and predominant. Perusal of literature revealed that research
reports are not available on sub cellular studies of liver and kidney in TMTD
induced TD in broiler chicks. Hence an attempt was made in the present study to
document the ultrastructural changes in the tibial bone cartilage, liver and kidney of
changes of hypertrophic zone in group III, VIII included the dilatation and
and dilatation of Golgi saccules. Few cells contained crescentric caps of condensed
cxxviii
apoptosis. Few cells showed karyorrhexic and pyknotic nuclei with an amorphous
was seen. In few cells, mineral aggregates in interstitial septa and lipid vacuoles
were also observed of which the former increased the lucency of cytoplasm of
necrotic chondrocytes.
RER with dilated regions in the vicinity of Golgi complex and secondary vacuoles.
Some samples had round nucleus with eccentrically placed nucleolus, distorted
Group X revealed round nucleus, faint nucleolus, mild dilated RER with oval
inclusions, vesiculated and disarranged stacks of RER along with apoptotic cells
In group III and VIII the findings were more related to apoptosis, in which
growth plate in the present experiment. These findings in accordance with the
findings of Lowther et al., (1974) and Brighton et al., (1978) who were focused on
cxxix
mitochondrial changes during early cell death in poultry and rats respectively.
by Howlet et al., (1984). Hargest et al., (1985) explained the early EM changes in
rapidly growing chickens and other animals affected by TD. The reports of Haynes
and Walser (1986), Ling et al., (1995), Ohyama et al., (1997) and Christopher and
apoptosis.
swollen mitochondria with loss of matrix. Some sections of 10th and 15th day
condensed mitochondria and in few cells swollen mitochondria with loss of matrix
were observed. Some sections of 15th day revealed swollen nucleus, with
showed swollen nucleus with margination of chromatin, large nucleolus and loss of
other sub cellular organelle. Electron dense granular material was also noticed
throughout the field. Moderately swollen mitochondria were also evident. The
sections of group V showed swollen nucleus with loss of outer margins and
complete loss of cell organelle and electron dense chromatin blocks in the
nucleoplasma was seen with a faint mitochondria and electron dense granularity
throughout the field. In group VIII samples of different periods (5th, 10th, and 15th
cxxx
distorted nuclear membrane and loss of other organelle were observed. On 5th day
scanty and faint matrix. On 15th day sections of group VIII revealed loss of
nucleolus and complete loss of other cytoplasmic organelle. The sections of group X
chromatin, swollen and condensed mitochondria with scanty and faint matrix and
The TEM of kidney sections of group III have showed the changes like
epithelial cells, disrupted and marginated chromatin with a narrow tubular lumen. In
group IV dilated interstium filled with blood, shrunken and distorted tubule with
necrotic epithelial cells was found, and the nucleus appeared normal. The sections of
group V revealed necrotic and distorted tubular epithelial cell with electron dense
granular material and condensed mitochondria. The nucleus showed varied shape
and size, and in few samples (10th and 15th day) it revealed the brush boarder of
proximal convoluted tubules (PCT). The cellular junction appeared to be loose. The
epithelial cells of group VIII were shrunken with electron dense numerous fat
vacuolated mitochondria. The lesions in group VIII revealed distorted epithelial cells
with varied shape and size of nucleus, condensed mitochondria, brush boarder of
PCT, loose inter cellular junction and necrotic epithelial cells towards the end of the
epithelial cells with pyknotic nuclei and condensed nucleolus loose inter cellular
cxxxi
junction, swollen mitochondria and loss of brush boarder and a narrowed tubular
lumen were noticed. In contrast to this the group I (normal controls) samples showed
tight intertubular junction with intact epithelial and properly arranged sub cellular
organelle.
The information on liver and kidney TEM changes was scanty, hence the
broilers.
growth plate cartilage of group III revealed necrotic areas of cartialginous structures
cartialge sample showed, only narrowing of the haversion system. The VIII and X
haemorrhges.
moderate to severe dilation of central vein (CV) with perivesicular space and
cxxxii
5.12.6 Scanning electron microscopy of liver
haemorrhages, the group IV showed mild swelling of tubules and narrowed tubular
group V. Group VIII samples showed moderately dilated tubules with complete
TD, they have a role in the surface pathomorphological changes of the concerned
organs.
economic status poultry industry. Hence, the present study has been under taken to
evaluate the factors responsible for TD lesion at molecular and ultrastructural level
with ameliorative agents. The present study indicated that Thiram has more
damaging effect on cartilage cells over other organs. VEGF and MMP2 are useful as
mitochondria, ER and nucleus in TMTD treated birds. LivOrdian was found to have
moderate ameliorative effect on VEGF and CuSo4 on MMP2. Future research should
ameliorative agents alone and in combination to over come this metabolic disorder
cxxxiii
CHAPTER – VI
SUMMARY
The present study was designed to find out the effect of TMTD in causation of TD
in broilers and amelioration effect of copper sulphate CuSo4, LivOrdian-FS and USCura
Tox-FS.
The experiment was designed with four hundred and twenty (420) day-old male
broilers chicks. All are wing banded, individually weighed and distributed into twelve (I -
XII) groups of 35 chicks each and reared in separate battery brooder pens under identical
managemental conditions throughout the experimental period (35 days) and daily observed
for clinical signs.
Group I served as control, group II and III were fed with 60 ppm and 100 ppm of
TMTD. Group IV, V and VI were fed with 200 ppm CuSo4, LivOrdain-FS and USCura
Tox-FS (1g/kg) Group VII and VIII were fed with 60 ppm and 100 ppm of TMTD and 200
ppm CuSo4 as an ameliorative agent, where as group IX and X were fed with 60 ppm and
100 ppm of TMTD and LivOrdain-FS. Group XI and XII were fed with USCura Tox-FS for
a period of 35 days.
Weekly weight gains were calculated and lowest cumulative mean value (621g) was
recorded in group III, similarly the FCR was analyzed and showed significantly (P≤ 0.01)
higher values in TMTD treated groups.
Six birds from group I, III, IV, V, VIII and X were sacrificed on 5th, 10th and 15th
day and TGPC paired samples were collected for selective gene expression ultrastructural
pathology and immunohistochemistry.
Further, six birds from each group were sacrificed during 1st, 3rd and 5th week of
age, blood samples, tibial bones, liver and kidney were collected from respective groups for
haemato-biochemical, histopathological and ultrastructural studies.
The results of haematological parameters showed significantly (P≤ 0.01) lower
values in TEC, Hb, PCV, TLC and DLC during 1st, 3rd and 5th week of experiment in groups
II, III, IV, VIII, XI, X and XII respectively. The results revealed that the TMTD exhibited
mild to moderate suppressive action on erythrpoiesis, leucopoiesis and Hb synthesis in
addition to causing severe TD lesion. The ameliorative agents have partially counteracted
the TMTD effect on erythrpoiesis, leucopoiesis and Hb synthesis.
Serum biochemical parameters showed significantly (P≤ 0.01) lower values in
glucose (IV, VIII and IX), cholesterol (II, III and X), total protein and A/G ratio (III, IV, IX
and XI) during the experimental period. AST and ALT values were also significantly (P≤
0.01) lower in groups II, IV, VI, VII, IX and X. The lower values of GGT and ALP were
cxxxiv
recorded in groups V, IX, XI, XII and IV, V and XII respectively. Lower values of serum
calcium were recorded in groups II, VIII and XII during the experimental period. The
significance in group IV could be due to toxic action of CuSo4 on liver and in group II and
III it might be due to toxic action of TMTD while in other groups might be due to graded
levels of TMTD and ameliorative agents.
C
The specific selective gene expression was studied and the mean T values of QRT-
C
PCR were statistically analyzed, the increased T values indicated decreased expression and
decreased C
T values indicated increased expression of the selective genes. Significantly (P≤
C
0.01) lower mean T values of VEGF, VEGFR1 and Bcl-2 genes were recorded in III, VIII
C
and X groups. Similarly lower mean T values of MMP2 was observed in X, V and VIII
groups and MMP3 gene lower values were recorded in group IV, VIII and X. These
observations indicated up and down regulation of selective gene expression in causation and
repair of TD lesion by using ameliorative agents.
The morphometry of tibial bone, liver and kidney weights, length and diameter of
tibial bones was done during the weekly sacrifices. Significantly (P≤ 0.01) lower mean
values were observed in group II, III, IV, VII, VIII and IX during 1st, 3rd and 45th week of
experiment. The results indicated that the TMTD has significantly influenced the
morphometry over ameliorative groups and control group. This could be due to age and
graded level of TMTD and the biological behavior of the experimental birds towards
ameliorative agents.
The pronounced gross changes like decrease in length, weight, diameter, slight
bending at proximal extremity of tibial bones were observed in group II and III, where as
group VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, and XII showed mild to moderate changes. The birds of group I,
IV, V and VI did not reveal any changes. All the tibial bones were longitudinally sectioned
and the lesions of TGPC at its widest point was measured and graded as mild (+), moderate
(++) and severe (+++) lesions during respective days and weeks and highest score (++ and
+++) was recorded in TMTD fed groups. The gross changes like shrinkage, mild
enlargement, mild to moderate congestion of liver and kidney were prominent in group II
and III followed by other groups VII, VIII, X and XII.
Histopathological changes in TGPC showed remarkable changes in hypertrophic of
zone of TMTD treated birds like swollen, oval and misshapen, clusters of empty cleft like
chondrocytes. Some sections revealed pyknotic nuclei, karyorrhexis and disintegration of
chromatin material. Some revealed eosinophilic nuclei and some showed swollen nucleus.
All the lesions were as graded mild (+), moderate (++) and severe (+++).
Special stain (Koneff’s’) was employed in samples of group I, III, IV, VIII, and X
to observe the specific changes if any. The sections of group III revealed pyknotic nuclei,
oval and large disorganized clusters of chondrocytes. Group IV sections revealed
cxxxv
proliferating blood vessels, reorganization of chondrocytes where as in group V the
chondrocytes are in rows and clusters. Group VIII sections showed large oval empty
chondrocytes with more of matrix and pyknotic nuclei. The group X sections showed a large
oval chondrocytes with nucleus, more of matrix and cells are in the form of clusters than
rows.
Liver samples of group III showed moderate to severe dilatation of central vein
(CV), mild dilatation of sinusoids, mild to moderate fatty change, hydropic degeneration
karyorrhexic and pyknotic nuclei. Group IV sections revealed moderate dilatation of CV,
complete distortion of hepatic cords and focal dilated sinusoids with focal areas of
congestion. Group V sections showed mild to moderate congestion of CV, desquamation of
endothelium, moderate to severe dilatation of sinusoids, moderate to sever fatty change and
focal areas of degenerating hepatocytes. Group VIII sections revealed dilated vessels, mild
sinusoidal congestion, fatty change and degeneration of hepatocytes. Group X sections
showed moderate congestion of CV, dilatation and congestion of sinusoids, mild to
moderate fatty change, and focal aggregates of MNC’s.
Kidney sections of group III showed moderate to severe intertubular dilatation,
shrunken glomeruli, hyper cellularity of interstitium, moderate cystic dilatation of tubules,
mild to moderate hyaline casts, mild dilation of Bowmen’s capsule were observed. Group
IV and V sections were revealed greater dilatation of tubules, shrunken glomeruli, hyaline
casts, mild degeneration of tubular epithelium, mild to moderate intertubular haemorrhages
and focal areas of cystic dilatation. Group VIII sections revealed moderate cystic dilatation
of tubules and degeneration of epithelium. Group X samples showed large areas focal
aggregates of MNC’s, focal areas of hyaline casts and greater intertubular dilatation.
Immunohistochemistry was employed by using monoclonal antibodies against Bcl-2
and VEGF antigen. The Bcl-2 expression was showed as intensive reaction in group III
intensive reaction over group IV. Group V the samples have revealed the pyknotic and
chromatolysis of nucleus without staining reaction. Stainig intensity was increased in Group
VIII and most of the cells are empty cleft like structures, where as group X sections appears
to be reorganised with emerging capillaries.
The VEGF expression was done to detect the damage of endothelium of TGPC
blood vessels. The brown color reaction is the indication of extent of damage during the
development of TD lesion which was observed in group III and IV, Mild reaction was
observed in group V, VIII and X.
The ultrastructural changes (TEM) of group III and VIII samples revealed dilatation
and vesiculation of rough endoplasmic reticulum (RER), swollen mitochondria with loss of
matrix and dilatation of Golgi saccules and few cells showed apoptotic changes. In most of
the samples cytoplasmic vaccuolation was prominent. Group IV and V samples showed well
cxxxvi
developed ribbon shaped RER with dilated regions in the vicinity of Golgi complex and
secondary vacuoles. Group X revealed round nucleus, mild dilated RER, oval shaped dense
mitochondria, and few sections revealed shrunken chondrocytes with pyknotic nucleus,
condensed and vesicular mitochondria. Group III and VIII revealed crenated nuclear
membrane, condensation and margination of chromatin which is evidence apoptosis.
The liver sections of group II and III revealed margination of chromatin material,
disrupted nucleolus and swollen mitochondria with loss of matrix. Some sections revealed
perinuclear swelling, cytoplasmic vaccuolation and swollen mitochondria with loss of
matrix. Group IV sections showed swollen nucleus with margination of chromatin and loss
of other sub cellular organelle. Sections of group V showed swollen nucleus and complete
loss of cell organelle. Group VIII samples have shown shrunken hepatocytes with pyknotic
nucleus and scanty chromatin margination, complete loss of cellular architecture,
cytoplasmic vaccuolation distorted nuclear membrane and loss of other organelle. The
sections of group X showed loss intercellular junctions, cytoplasmic vaccuolation
condensed nucleus and mitochondria.
The kidney sections of group III revealed moderate swelling of nucleus, condensed
vacuolated mitochondria, disrupted and marginated chromatin with narrow tubular lumen.
Group IV sections showed dilated interstium, shrunken, distorted and necrotic epithelial
cells. Group V revealed necrotic epithelial cells with condensed mitochondria with brush
boarder of PCT. Group VIII sections showed numerous fat bodies, pyknotic nucleus and
margination of chromatin, cytoplasmic vacuoles and vacuolated mitochondria and loose
inter cellular junction. Group X showed distorted and necrotic epithelial cells with pyknotic
nuclei, condensed nucleolus, swollen mitochondria and loss of brush boarder, loose inter-
cellular junction and narrowed tubular lumen.
The SEM lesions of TGPC of group III revealed necrotic areas of cartialginous
structures and complete loss of Haversian system. Group IV sample showed moderate
alteration of Haversion system and haemorrhges. Group V sample showed a narrowed
Haversion system. Group VIII and X samples revealed complete altered Haversian system
with moderate haemorrhges.
The liver samples of group III revealed moderate to severe dilation of CV with
perivesicular space and necrtic parenchyma, group IV showed severe dilation of blood
vessels with altered hepatic parenchyma, group V revealed an altered parenchyma,
congestion and haemorrhages. Group VIII samples exhibited severe dialataion of blood
vessels and necrosis of hepatic parenchyma and group X slices were revealed a mild
dilataion of vessels and altered hepatic architexure.
The kidney samples of group III revealed moderate swelling of tubules with
completely closed lumen and haemorrhages. Group IV showed intertubular dilatation and
cxxxvii
mild swelling of tubules with narrow tubular lumen. Severe haemorrhages and narrowed
tubules were observed in group V. Group VIII samples showed moderately swollen tubules,
group X samples revealed mild intertubular dilatation.
cxxxviii
LITERATURE CITED
Ackerson, C. W. and Mussehl, F. E. 1955. Toxicity of treated seed corn in rations
for chicks. Poultry Science. 34 (3):728-729.
Bancraft, J. D., Cook, H. C., Stirling, R.W. and Turner, D. R. 1994. Manual of
histological and their diagnostic application. Churchill Livingstone
Edinburgh London, Madrid, Melbourne, New York and Tokyo.263-288.
Boone, L., Meyer, D., Cusick, P., Ennulat, D., Provencher, B.A., Everds, N.
Meador, V., Elliot, G., Honor, D., Bounous, D. and Jordan, H. 2005.
Selection and Interpretation of Clinical Pathology indicators of hepatic injury
in pre clinical studies. Veterinary Clinical Pathology. 34:182-216.
Dan, H., Simsa, S., Hisdai, A., Sela-Donenfeld, D. and Monsonego-Ornan, E. 2009.
Expression of matrix metalloproteinases during impairment and recovery of
the avian growth plate. Journal of Animal Science. 87 (11): 3544-3555.
cxxxix
Dennis, A. L., Robinson, H. C., Dolman, J. W. and Thomas, K. W. 1974. Cartilage
matrix components in chickens with tibial dyschondroplasia. Journal of
Nutrition. 104: 922-929.
Dumas, B. T., Watson, W. A. and Biggs, H. G. 1971. Albumin standards and the
measurement of serum albumin with bromocresol green. Clinical Chemistry
Acta. 31:87-96.
Edwards, H. M. Jr. 1987. Effect of Thiuram, Disulfiram and a trace element mixture
on the incidence of tibial dyschondroplasia in chickens. Journal of Nutrition.
117: 964-969.
Edwards, J. 2004. Animal Health: A break point in economic development. In: 11th
International Conference of Association of International Tropical Veterinary
Medicine and the 16th Veterinary Association of Malaysia Congress, pp 23-
25.
Eisaku, H., Susumu, O., Tomota, N., Yukaro, K., Yuji, O., Tacko, H., Yuzo, K.,
Dongchon, K., Yuchiro, C., Kiyiko, G. and Kenji, S. 2009. Development of
new measurement method for serum calcium with chlorophosphonazo-III.
Annual Clinical Biochemistry. 46: 296- 301.
FairBrother, A., Smits, J., and Grasman,K. 2004. Avian Immunotoxicology. Journal
of Toxicology and Environment Health (part B). 7:105-137.
Fallavena, L. L. B., Salle, L. T., Moraes, H. L. S., Krahl, M., Reali, E. H., Santos,
G. P., Countinho, A. and Franco, J. L. K. 1991. Locomotor problems in
broiler chickens of three commercial strains: I. Clinical aspects, occurrence
of tibial dyschondroplasia and bowing of tibiotarso : Arquivo-Brasilerio-de-
Medicina- Veterinaria-e-zooteua : 43 (4) : (Poultry Abstracts (1982) 018 –
02968).
cxl
Gay, C.V., Anderson, R. E. and Leach, R. M. 1985 Activities and distribution of
alkaline phosphatase and carbonic anhydrase in the tibial
dyschondroplastic lesion and associated growth plate of chicks. Avian
Diseases. 29: 812-882.
Germeloc, D. R., Nyska, A., Kashon, M., Kuper, C. F., Portier, C., Kommineni,
C., Johnson, K. A. and Luster, M. I. 2004. Extended Histopathology in
Immunotoxicity testing: International laboratory validation studies.
Toxicological Science. 78:107-110.
Hasky-Negev, M., Simsa, S., Tong, A., Genina, O. and Monsonego-Ornan, E. 2008.
Expression of matrix metalloproteinases during vascularization and
ossification of normal and impaired avian growth plate. Journal of Animal
Science. 86:1306-1315.
Hassig, A., Wen-Xil and Stampflik. 1996. Stress induced suppression of the CMI
on the neuro endocrine control of the immune system. Medical Hypothesis.
46:551-553.
Hayes, W.J. and E.R. Laws (ed.). 1990. Handbook of Pesticide Toxicology, Vol. 3,
Classes of Pesticides. Academic Press, Inc., NY.
Howlett, C. R., Dickson, M. and Sheridant, A. K. 1984. The fine structure of the
proximal growth plate of the avian tibia: vascular supply. Journal of
Anatomy. 139(1): 115-132.
Jyoti Palod. 2005. Scope and Challenges of Poultry Production in 21st Century.
Poultry Line. 5:25-31.
Kacmar, P., Pistl, J. and Mikula, I. 1999. Immuno Toxicology and Veterinary
Medicine. Acta Veterinary Brno. 68: 57-59.
cxli
Kenneth, J. L. and Schmittgen, T. D. 2001. Analysis of relative gene expression data
using Real-Time Quantitative PCR and 2-∆∆CT method. Methods. 25: 402-
408.
Knopov, V. R., Leach, M., Barak-Shalom, T., Hurwitz, S. and Pines, M. 1995.
Osteopontin gene expression and alkaline phosphatase activity in avian tibial
dyschondroplasia. Bone. 16:329-334.
Krishna Kumar, C.V.R. 2011. Green Chemistry for Animal Health, e-proceedings of
National Seminar on Pharmaceutical Chemistry: Held at Krishna University,
Machilipatnam, A.P. 30th -31st January.
Krishna Kumar, C.V.R. and Rajendar, K. 2010. Agro chemical pollution in poultry
industry-status evaluation, e-proceedings of International Conference on
Climate Change: Held at Osmania University, Hyderabad, A.P. 9th -11th
December.
Lakshman, M. 2004 a. Effect of tetramethyl thiuram disulfide on the growth rate and
leg weakness in broilers. Indian Veterinary Journal. 81: 1093-1096.
cxlii
Leach, R. M. Jr. and Monsonego-Orman, E. 2007. Invited reviews tibial
dyschondroplasia 40 years later. Poultry Science. 86: 2053-2058.
Li, J., Bi, D., Pan, S. and Zhang, Y. 2007. Effect of diet with thiram on liver
antioxidant capacity on dyschondroplasia in broilers. British Poultry Science.
48 (6): 724-728.
Meister, R.T. 1992. Farm Chemicals Handbook '92. Meister Publishing Company,
Willoughby, OH.
Michael, L., Barry, H., Thorp, C. Colin, C. W. 1992. Avian tibial dyschondroplasia
as a cause of bone deformity. Avian Pathology. 21: 275-285.
Nene, Y. L. and Thapliyal, P. N. 1982. Fugicides in plant disease control. 2nd edn.,
IBH Publishing Company, New Delhi: 70-89.
cxliii
Pines, M., Hasadi, A. and Monsonego-Oman, E. 2005. Tibial dyschondroplasia?
Tools, new insights and future prospects. World’s Poultry Science
Journal.61: 285- 297.
Ramljak, D., Bidjin, Z., Culjak, K., Hrlel, G., Shhic, M. and Cizel, J. A. 1988.
Toxicity of Tetramethyl thiuram disulfide as a possible cause of leg
weakness in broiler chickens. Poultry Abstract. 14 (4): 137.
Rao, N. A., Ramsubba Reddy, V., Rajashekara, R. and Srilatha, Ch. 1996. Thiram
poisoning in poultry-its alleviation. Poultry Punch.12 (12): 37-42.
Rath, N. C., Bayyari, G. R., Beasley, J. N., Huff, W. E. and Balog, J. M. 1994. Age
related changes in the incidence of tibial dyschondroplasia in Turkeys.
Poultry Science. 73:1254-1259.
Rath, N. C., Huff, W. E., Bayyari, G. R. and Balog, J. M. 1998. Cell death in Avian
tibial dyschondroplasia. Avian Diseases. 42: 72-79.
Rath, N. C., Huff, W. E., Balog, J. M. and Huff, G. R. 2004. Comparative efficacy
of different dithiocarbamates to induce tibial dyschondroplasia in poultry.
Poultry Science. 83: 266-274.
Rath, N. C., Richards, M. P., Huff, W. E., Huff, G .R. and Balog, J. M. 2005.
Changes in the tibial growth plates of chickens with thiram-induced
dyschondroplasia. Journal of Comparative Pathology. 133: 41-52.
Rath, N. C., Huff, W. E. and Huff, G. R. 2007. Thiram- induced changes in the
expression of genes relating to vascularization. Poultry Science. 86 (11):
2390-2395.
Rath, N. C., Kannan, L.. Pillai, P. B., Huff , W. E., Huff, G. R., Horst, R. L. and
Emmert, J. L. 2007. Evaluation of the efficacy of vitamin D3 or its
metabolites on thiram-induced tibial dyschondroplasia in chickens. Research
in Veterinary Science. 83: 244 - 250.
cxliv
Reich, A., Jaffe, N., Tong, A., Lavelin, I,. Genina, O., Pines, M. Sklan, D,
Nussinovitch A. and Monsonego-Ornan, E. 2008. Weight loading young
chicks inhibits bone elongation and promotes growth plate ossification and
vascularization. Journal of Applied Physiology. 98: 2381-2389.
Sakamoto, M. 1997. Nutrition and Host Defence. Biotherapy (Japan). 11: 492-511.
Snedecor, G.W. and Cochran. W. G.1994. In: Statistical methods 8th Edn. Iowa state
University press, Ames, Iowa, USA.
Spurr, A. R. 1969. A low viscosity epoxy resin embedding medium for electron
microscopy. Journal of Ultrastructural Research. 26: 31- 43.
Stav, S., Hasdai, A., Dan, H. and Monsonego Ornan, E. 2007. Differential regulation
of MMPs and matrix assembly in chicken and turkey growth-plate
chondrocytes. American Journal of Physiology Regulatory, Integrative and
Comparative Physiology. 292: 2216 - 2224.
cxlv
Subhapriya, S., Vairamuthu, S., Muralimanohar, B. and Balachandran, C. 2007a.
Clinicopathological Investigation on Thiram toxicosis in broiler chicken.
International Journal of Poultry Science. 6 (4): 242- 244.
Tanabe, Y. and Wilcox, F. H. 1960. Effect of age, sex, and line on serum alkaline
phosphatase of the chicken. Proceedings of Society of Experimental
Medicine. 103: 68-70.
Tian, W. X., Zhang, W. P., Li, J. K., Bi, D. R., Guo, D. Z ., Pan, S. Y., Zhang, Y. H.
and Qin, P. 2009. Identification of differentially expressed genes in the
growth plate of broiler chickens with thiram-induced tibial dyschondroplasia.
Avian Pathology. 38 (2) 161-166.
Tomlin, C. 1994. The Pesticide Manual, 10th Edn. Crop Protection Publication, pp
989-990.
Waible, P. E., Pomeroy, B. S. and Elton, J. L. 1955. Effect of Arasan - treated corn
on laying hens. Poultry Science. 121: 40-42.
cxlvi
Waibel, P. E., Elton, J. L., Pomeroy, B. S. and Howard, L .B. 1957. Toxicity of
Tetramethyl thiuram disulfide for chicks, poults and goslings. Poultry
Science. 36 (1): 697- 703.
Walser, M. M., Allen, N. K., Mirocha, C. J., Hanlon, G. F. and Newman, J. A. 1982.
Fusarium induced osteochondrosis (tibial dyschondroplasia) in chickens.
Veterinary Pathology. 19: 544 - 550.
Weidong Wu, M. S., Cook, M. E., Chu, Q. and Smalley, E.B. 1993. Tibial
dyschondroplasia of chickens induced by fusarochromanone, mycotoxins.
Avian Diseases. 37: 302-309.
Wrathall, A. E., Simmons, H. A., Bowles, D. J., and Jones, S. 2004. Biosecurity
strategies for conserving valuable live stock genetic resources. Journal of
Reproduction, Fertility and Development. 16:103-112.
cxlvii
ABBREVIATIONS
cxlviii
CPD - Critical point drier
Cr - Chromium
Cu - Copper
CuSo4 - Copper sulphate
CV - Central vein
DLC - Differential leukocyte count
DMTC - DiMethyldithiocarbomate
DNA - Deoxyribo nucleic acid
dNTP - Deoxy nucleoside triphos phate
DPX - Distyrene plasticizer xylines
EBDCs - ethylene bisdithiocarbamates
ECM - Extra cellular matrix
EDTA - Ethylene diamine tetra acetic acid
EM - Electron microscopy
EPA - Environmental protection agency
ER - Endoplasmic reticulum
F - Feledioum
FCR - Feed conversion ratio
Fe - Iron
FS - Feed supplement
G - Globulin
g - Grams
GDP - Gross domestic product
GGT - Gamma-glutamyl transferase
Glu - Glucose
GOD - Glucose oxidase
GP - Growth plates
GSH - Glutathione
GSH-Px - Glutathione peroxidase
guHCL - guanidine Hydrochloric acid
h - hour
H&E - Haemotoxylin and eosin
Hb - Haemoglobin concentration
cxlix
HP - Herbal product
H2O2 - Hydrogen peroxide
HRP - Horse-radish peroxidase
Hsp - Heat shock proteins
Hsp90 - Heat shock protein 90
I - Iodine
IB - Infectious bronchitis
IBD - Infectious bursal disease
IFCC - International federation of clinical chemistry
IUPAC - International union of pure and applied chemistry
JEOL - Japan electronics optical limited
Kg - Kilo gram
LC - Lead citrate
LD50 - Leathal dose -50
Li - Lithium
MCH Mean corpuscular haemoglobin
MCHC - Mean corpuscular haemoglobin concentration
MCV - Mean corpuscular cell volume
MD - Marek’s disease
MDA - Malondialdehyde
ml - Milli liter
MMP - Matrix metalloproteinases
mm - Milli meter
Mn - Manganese
MNC’s - Mono nuclear cells
Mo - Molybdenum
mRNA - messenger Ribonucleic acid
NBF - Neutral buffer formalin
ND - Newcastle disease
Ni - Nickel
NIOSH - National institute of safety and health
NOEC - No Observable Effect of Chemical
NRC - National research council
cl
oCPC - o-Creso phthalein complexone
OPN - Osteopontin
OsO4 - Osmium tetraoxide
P - Phosphorus
PBS - Phosphate buffered saline
PCT - Proximal convoluted tubules
PCV - Packed cell volume
PDTC - Pyrrolidine Dithiocarbomate
PES - Poultry experimental station
pH - Negative log of hydrogen ion concentration
PMA - Phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate
ppm - parts per million
QRT-PCR Quantitative real time polymerase chain reaction
RA Retinoic acid
RER - Rough endoplasmic reticulum
RGD - arg-gly-asp (peptide sequence)
RT - Reverse transcriptase
RT- PCR - real time polymerase chain reaction
RTECS - Registry of toxic effects of chemical substances
SAP - Serum alkaline phosphatase
SCWLH - Single comb white leg horn
SEM - Scanning electron microscope
Si - Silica
Sn - Tin
SOD - Super oxide dismutase
SPI - Structure probe inc
Sr - Strontium
TBS - Tris buffer saline
TCA - Tri chloroacetic acid
TD - Tibial dyschondroplasia
TEC - Total erythrocyte count
TEM - Transmission electron microscope
TGPC - Tibial bones growth plate cartilage
cli
TLC - Total leukocyte count
TMTD - Tetramethyl thiuram disulfide
TP - Total proteins
tris - Hydroxymethyl aminomethane (T.B.S) buffer saline
UA - Urenyl acetate
V - Vanadium
VEGF - Vascular endothelial growth factor
VEGFR1 - Vascular endothelial growth factor receptor
WP - Wettable powder
Zn - Zinc
clii