Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
A Jungian Approach
Jennifer Birch, M.A.
The University of Alabama
The Alabama Counseling Association Journal, Volume 34, Number 2, Spring 2009
3 Using Drawings
creative process of art to improve and en- bate concerning the degree of direction a
hance the physical, mental, and emotional play therapist employs is also applicable
well-being of children. “The creative to art therapy and drawings. While some
process involved in artistic self-expres- counselors choose a directive role when
sion helps people to resolve conflicts and utilizing drawing techniques, others pre-
problems, develop interpersonal skills, fer to be non directive in their method.
manage behavior, reduce stress, increase Professionals find both directive and
self-esteem and self-awareness, and nondirective methods reach into the indi-
achieve insight” (American Art Therapy vidual‘s unconscious. Therefore, chil-
Association, 2006). dren’s art expressions within therapy are
viewed from diverse perspectives and in-
Drawings terests depending on the therapist. Draw-
Therapists use drawings as a means of ings are used not only as an assessment or
communication when working with chil- diagnostic tool, but counselors use draw-
dren. Drawings broaden the individual’s ings as a therapeutic intervention in coun-
experience of expression by allowing the seling (Malchiodi, 2003).
safe expression of feelings and attitudes
in ways that words cannot (Hagood, 2000; Jungian Drawing
Landreth, 1991; Oster & Gould, 1987). A Jung (1934) contended the goal of
white sheet of paper becomes a “safe counseling is “to make unconscious con-
place” for the child to express himself or tent accessible and so to bring it closer to
herself in a non-threatening manner, the patient’s understanding” (p.182). Ac-
(Allan, 1988). Drawing can “create inter- cording to Jung, in order for clients to
nal perceptions about self and the achieve meaning and wholeness, there
world”(Malchiodi, 2003, p. 155). These must be a balance between the uncon-
graphic representations “bring issues to scious and conscious. Rather than
the surface, thus accelerating the helping specific techniques, the counselor’s
professional’s ability to intervene and as- understanding of the “nature of the
sist troubled children” (Malchiodi, 2001, psyche, the meaning of play, and the goal
p. 21). of the therapy influence on the play
therapy process” is important in this
“Although child-centered play ther- theory (de Domenico, 1994, p. 453).
apy is the most widely employed play Jungian therapists encourage the individ-
therapy technique,” rooting itself in the ual to embrace uniqueness within his or
humanistic approach, many play thera- herself.
pists prefer techniques derived from
Jung’s Analytical Psychology (Peery, Play is a primary means to self-
2002, p. 408). The specific counseling realization (Jung, 1961). Lack of psycho-
styles of play therapy influence the coun- logical coping skills, family psy-
selor’s approach to drawing assessments. chopathology, trauma, and ways of
While child-centered play therapy is char- education, raising, and socializing chil-
acterized as being nondirective, Jungian dren promote ego disturbances. The
therapists offer varying degrees of direc- counseling role is to observe, attempt to
tion in the counseling session. This de- understand, integrate, and communicate
The Alabama Counseling Association Journal, Volume 34, Number 2, Spring 2009
Using Drawings 4
The Alabama Counseling Association Journal, Volume 34, Number 2, Spring 2009
5 Using Drawings
specific details in the drawing. A child bush had no protection of any kind from
that needs defenses may draw a fence sur- the coming storm. When asked about the
rounding the rosebush. A child that needs rosebush, Jamie replied. “The tornado
more security and stability in their life will blow it away. It doesn’t have any
may emphasize the roots and root struc- roots to hold it. It is too young. It was just
ture of the bush. A child who can both planted last year.”
draw the thorns and the full blooming
roses may have a better concept of reality Jamie had moved to a new school after
and have a more mature understanding of the death of her father. The mother had
taking the good in life with the less desir- to live with the grandparents. The grand-
able. The fullness of the blossoms and parents had very different ideas about
leaves on the bush indicate the fullness of parenting from Jamie’s parents. Both the
the child’s life, as the child perceives it. mother and Jamie discussed how the fam-
A child who draws a rose bush with only ily had been thrown into chaos by the un-
rose buds may be on the verge of great expected death of the father and the many
changes in their lives from the child’s per- changes that were taking place in their
spective. Of course, dead rosebushes, bro- family. Jamie had been referred to the
ken limbs, or other indications of a lack counselor because of what the mother
of vitality in the rosebush are indications considered to be unresolved grief and
of the child’s emotional state of depres- childhood depression.
sion, hopeless or despair. However, before
making any lasting interpretation, ask the As the counselor looks at the drawing
child what season of the year it is, as a and listens to the tone of Jamie’s voice,
rosebush in winter has no leaves or blos- she can hear the despair and grief the
soms. A child who is very literal or con- child is experiencing. As the rosebush is
crete can just be drawing what they have a metaphor for Jamie’s current situation,
seen at home in their own flower gardens the counselor talks to Jamie through this
(Allan, 1988). metaphor by asking these guiding ques-
tions: What does the Rosebush need to be
Other parts of the post-drawing inter- protected from the tornado? Who can
view include asking the child what the take care of the Rosebush and be sure that
weather is like for the rosebush, which it survives the storm? What will it take for
may give the counselor an indication of the Rosebush to bloom in the Spring?
how the child perceives the environment How do you think it will look next year or
as warm, cool, or cold. The following au- even five years from now?
thor fictionalized case excerpt will give an
example of a rosebush post-drawing in- Jungians often speak to the uncon-
terview by a child from an emotionally scious through the metaphor of the draw-
impoverished family situation: ings, directing the thought processes by
guiding questions. Unlike a more direc-
Jamie drew a bare rosebush devoid of tive approach, the Jungian therapist trusts
greenery or blossoms. A huge tornado the unconscious to make meaning of the
was drawn in the background approach- metaphor and does not explain it to the
ing the much smaller rosebush. The rose- child. To illustrate talking through the
The Alabama Counseling Association Journal, Volume 34, Number 2, Spring 2009
Using Drawings 6
metaphor, the counselor might respond to if that impression is the one that the child
Jamie by saying the rosebush looks like it intended to convey. According to Allen
is stronger than it looks and if the rose- and Bertoia (1992) the time spent reflect-
bush moves with the wind rather than tries ing in a picture journal can “set in motion
to resist the wind it will stay rooted. If the the inner drive of growth and develop-
rosebush does become uprooted, the gar- ment” (p. 30).
dener will come by to check on all the
bushes after the storm and will help the Conclusion
rosebush to be replanted. Drawings can provide a vehicle for
children to explore their external world
Journal Drawing and to discover their coping skills and
Another approach used by Allan and abilities. Through the use of drawings,
Bertoia (1992) is journal drawing or the children can communicate complex ideas
creation of picture journals. The child and messages that would otherwise be
draws a picture or a series of pictures impossible due to lack of vocabulary.
much like other journal entries are made. Through the concrete production of cre-
The child may choose to add written com- ative expressions, children can share their
ments to the pictures he or she has drawn. internal world of experience with the
The counselor does not ask the child to counselor in the external world of the
draw anything in particular. The child just counseling session. Presented in this arti-
draws what they feel like drawing for each cle are some launching points or drawing
entry. Usually the child brings the draw- experiences for the counselor interested in
ings into the counselor to review. The pursuing Jungian art expression as a tool
counselor guides the child through ques- in counseling sessions with children.
tions to reflect about feelings, meanings,
or experiences that are reflected in the pic- Author Notes:
tures. These questions may take the fol- Correspondence regarding this article
lowing format: Tell me what you were should be addressed to:
feeling when you drew this picture? What Karla D. Carmichael, Ph.D.
had happened just before this picture? Counselor Education
What is going to happen next? Tell me Box 870231
what you like about this picture? Tell me Tuscaloosa, Alabama 35487-0231
how you would change this picture? Give dr.k@consultant.com
me a moral or special title for this picture?
References
Several of the pictures may be Allan, J. (1988). Inscapes of the child’s
grouped together and the counselor may world: Jungian counseling in schools
ask the child to tell a story with a begin- and clinics. Dallas, TX: Spring Pub-
ning, middle and end for the story. If the lications.
pictures are very abstract, the counselor
may ask the child to tell label each color Allan, J., & Bertoia, J. (1992). Written
with a feeling word. Sometimes the coun- pathways to healing: Education and
selor may want to just share an impression Jungian child counseling. Dallas, TX:
that he or she gets from the picture and see Spring Publications, Inc.
The Alabama Counseling Association Journal, Volume 34, Number 2, Spring 2009
7 Using Drawings
The Alabama Counseling Association Journal, Volume 34, Number 2, Spring 2009