Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
*
1. Introducción
! " ! !
# ! "!!# ! # !$
!#" "!%" "!!#
&' "!!# ("("
# ! &"! ! "!!#)& &
!# ! *! "!!# !
# !!" " +$#&
,)&!# ! *! "!!#!
!# -
!%"!# !"
!# !! !!
!"%&.("
! "!$("!#
! !#!!# ("
(" !("
!"("'
!
/("!!!!0 "!!#
(" # !!" ("
" %%!%$("""
""1
(".! !# !2
"'!## ! "!!#
3 " !0("' "!!#("'# !2
& "4"("&("' "
!!#("' "!"" "
" !
$("("%""0%&
5&'"("("6("
(" "!# !
-
!"#
!" !"!.
"! "!!## !/(" ("
("6.*70
!8"7!#
# !"!
175
2. La lógica y sus presentaciones
3# !%
"
-
! !"6 ".
! & #!" -"! 9".
"!%# !! .!"&
# !("6." !!! .!# !
("! XIX!:;
!"& <# !.!=7!.
3 ! #!"!"! !
!<'!=("
%
">!3# !?&'
? #
" "*
! "("!&#!
6 7" ("" !"
<&.&=%"!
3("## ! @ .
("(" !"
3!#("%! "*""'!!!"("
!"&"!! @! !!-&!
'!& "!" !" ("
" 86A6&%&&
*%& *
"2+!".
",3
"# " &&!!! ("
!" !#*$ !A0<
!##!
!(" &# 8"
&=3
- ! # !% %
%" $ "% "
" %!&
!0# !#!# !
# !!!# !docens,"# !.!!# !
# !!# !utens, 5 # !0
la utensdocensD"6.* !("# ! !
("("%! )!" # !
(" !("!&2 %!%!&
/#0Analíticos # !docensRefutaciones sofísticas
Tópicos # !utens,!2#
!&'&
! "(" ' (" 7 " . "
! # !utens "'
.!! .!!docens-
!"#!.!#!&'
! "!# "!!""("
/("" &# !!" 0
176
-!! %!! 6#
# !!! %! 6#
! '2! "!!!"&
! 6#(" ! 6#
("" ! ! !
! E
177
&
!&!&'# ! !
!!' !"
K"# !&!"" !"
<7= # !5 !&
# !3 .
$" !"# " ! # !
# !!.!# !!# !"!
# !!# !!" !!!
!# &' # ! !.! 2
&' # !7 # !!
# ! ("!"'! 7.!
$("! " # !("%! "
"# ! / "# ! "!
!L)" !"#!! !
modus ponens # !&!"
41M
".&0!" !%
7N
2" 6! !"# !
"
#
!"#!"" " !
!.!! # !3" # !.
!"
!! % ("
!!
3# !docens""
" !*("
! ! a priori("'# !
!&& !6!%6 "
!!!
("("!%6
178
6+O!!,-!!%
97!"!!(""!!
("8&P%2%!8)& .
!"!!)"("% !!6
!!%!
"!#!("
&(" !$ !#"" "
6" " !%("!"!# !docens
$6 " !#&! "!!#!%6
# !-! ! -
!
"!!#!%6"
# !
sea la utens docens-" 0! &
"!% "!!#
6 !# !utens 6 !
#!"!%!! "!.!2
XIX!6 XX
#
*"("!
179
# !docens%! ! 7 !#!
! & %! !
# !.!"" -
#
# !!&#"!
" ! &# (""
&
"!#
"# !-"
"!#
!
!
!!" # !docens%"&# !7!("
!
#
!&!$%)
2!I:!%S! *F!""7
# !
E/(" &!"
# !"!
#
!"!%"
5&'
"!# ("("!%6&# !
docens!&".!"
# !utens3!
!D" "!%" # !(""
("(""# !
7"
#
!$("%&" 7#
""
#
!- !!%6
# !!" !"7!!
# !docens " "
D"6.%
!
# ! utens ! " &" !#
!&
180
" !#
."" " 2!*M!
# !
!*NQ&("
# !docens "
3!## !
#
% & "0"
"
!
!!%6-"!
%&!" "'! (""!# !utens"
*
!O
!8"*
"#!"! !%863"
86 !!!"
"%*
!0 '"*" !!' ("
& !6%&.8 !!
!& +D"' "
#
!
,2&&(".& !""!
*!"#." !""%
("!" !"" "
&
F&. " ("(""!!"#0# !
! * 62"
! %&
%"&8 " "2"
&*!"#%&. ("."
"!! !"("("
I !"#'(" %!"
(" @ .
#!"&"
" &"("
2#
.!! - ! . %
" *!&!& !" "
$" ! !
!"!" ! ""
! "!""!%
.0<-! !=<T" = ! "6!("
"-!("!# !utens!#!.
" &T8 !# !
docens"7"# !"("%"!
!" . 3 # ! utens " !
! !
&!! "
"!" !("" 8!"-
# !utens " docens" !"6
!! %!%%!" ! " #!
*! .!!" % &
%3 !"# !
! !"
"!%Tópicos '!&! <" =(""
181
"!# ) !* !
medieval de las obligationes" !!! !"# .
" !"!/!!"
*" 7!#! # !M!<%&
!%=("&! ("
!(" "& "!"("! ("!
0<%&!&%&!%=
!<$'
"%&=<$'
"= ("
!<$'
"!=!"&N
F("(" consequentiae
" !# !&
!!"
!("!"Tópicos, !"
# !utens. 2*0"<#!=" 0<("!
!&'=K" ("" "
"&"! "!! (" "
< !&!!&' &!=#!
!<(""&" &"&'
=<(" &' =1
"! !!*"< !&!="
!# ! #! < ! &!= & ! #!
< !&!=5" modus ponens
modus tollens!.7 M("
&' N!!"!
# !!
!"
/ !"&&'<# !=
< '!!= " ) !!0
182
demonstratioN02! * !
7!
!!# !
183
%!% (";% %!("7
("7!!=
-7!!!!
#
'!
!# !(""
! !! ." 4!1
XIVL- &6#" !&'
! (" !-
/& >"2 ;.MYN"!!!# 6#
<&.!=! !$'A80
- ! . " "(" !"
"!" "&) " K>
"!# '!! ("
!2 ;." # !! 3
.!! &! " !# ! "!
&!*0"8&
"! !#""8
&("
)& &!("& "("
! !783& "
8 ! !! !!" !
""6-8&
#
&'
@ 22 ;. "!0!" # !
!(" (" !"%&.("!
("'"66(" !") "(""
!
"%&.("! /#("
"
&.!"%&("
("!
!"3-!"$" "(";" !&
184
%(" !("!!
""!"!! R
O!" & !%67 !!!#
! Z% ) - MN A!%6
'!!"% *!&"-
!
("* !' ("0
*+"
F%& *""!" %!# !%
&"! !"" ! "
185
# 3
#
# ("
&!"!!"!"%!"
"6
racional&!"" -
!" # !" 6#" '!!
!# ! '!!!&"
(""!" 6#$("!7 !"#
. "
# !utens" "
""(". "!!# # !
docens ! !&
-!%6 # !" "&("%&.("
& "&("!
&0<!=
! <6&=!("%
!&# ! &!
"!"" # !!.!" !!#)
& # !!.!""<# !=RE$
("!%69!0 # !("
"<=# !%(""7"
#
!
)& !("
"" "!9!
! ("%%& 0"!9!# !utens
# !docens("6.""# !9!%!"
6
" "-!
"!!#%&. "(".%# ! "
"!
186
Notas
[$
!"! # I4$ T! 1
O )/ '/ 6!! 1
O)/4!! I !#2 :O/2"
!# !#
Cfr\T-/3-HMNEl desarrollo de la lógicaM P" "6N
5! ! 2 &' "!#
!
]# -!"
"! /# '!
!- "!#" # ! "!"'!!
!
!M "!!#&" N&'" ! "
"!#!& . &
<Q X44%&%!%". !
"! "'!" !.!!quiditas
ens$4""&!quiditas"&
# !!# " ! 'ens
" " *"
!!# != Cfr 2-A$I4/3 H \ <$%
%!% " =\A-5]/TTT/\P2& MN
/ 4!
5 6" 7// $& $&
O2L
3
AZI33QP!(" MN
7M
2>N:!)7:R
E
Cfr:-O$FZ5MENIntroducción a la lógica'7!OT/
3628("* ("" # !!.!!
"! !#M< !#=N
("% # !("& !"
# !!.! .Cfr2-^/
36MRNIntroducción a las lógicas no clásicas'7!OT/
L
Cfr2AI-)5>%MNIntroduction to Non-Classical Logic$& $
& O2-!" " !#" !&
# !!* .& # !!.!0
!!"("/: "
) !! !< "=modus tol-
lendo ponens "
2!!
" "!#
exclusiva M(" #" N ("0
!!"("" "!#7!"
" ponendo tollens
"
" "!#7!"" &
Cfr.2AI-)5>Una brevísima introducción a la lógica
Z!''7!0- Z!' '7!L!
Cfr>/A;I-)P3"MNLógica del tiempo PZ 86
2
!!"L E<3# ! !!
F M3)A GSN=
CfrP/TI\/)5"AASMNAn Introduction to ReasoningTG
187
QS!2"&% $3"%!7!(""
# !6.!.!!
!
CfrMRNFilosofía de la enseñanzaM 1 !2.N'7!1$-
E !0<-8"8!!
!UWV
'
(" !! 8(" ("!
(" " 8=
Cfr)I->-3FMNEducating Reason. Rationality, Critical Thinking and
EducationTGQSA" !!"
-7"" &<# !=("" 7 !
!
#
! % ! " -
! # ! docens
" " !
"# !"!"
! ! & &' (" " &
#
!
CfrF//$\)"MNPhilosophy of Logics$& $& O
2!T!" ("("
# !!"!
("(" utens docens
R
) " "!# ad hominem ! " "!
6"#
!"
-" !!!
6 "!%6"("'!
""
#
!
E
Cfr21/T;-A/MRNLógicaM P2'6:!N:"/-
$
CfrA-;ZT;HMN<-7!# "!#=La lámpara de
Diógenes8R*":'O /"# 2"&
L
Cfr $ZT)5/T5ITZ 1&. "/" A 3# MN Elementos de
89:9# ;5!/-
tación normativa'7!1O )3""6
%# !M& # ! ! #!N
@!".!# *" !
O&" "!!#& !!")2/;-2"4!
<Z& =\A-5]/TTT2& P\/M NMNThe Cam-
5 6" 7// $& 0 $& O
2R
Cfr)5O2-<5!0% &!("!
<\A-5]/TTT2& P\/ibidR3
"("!!&! # !
Cfr/>T/4/$$/)MN<=<9!":"/
O:/8;.- L
Ibidem
Cfr</&/!" A%!; "=MNAntiqui rethores la-
tini2-7
!2/" F "2RF "!!#0
Alcuino. Diálogo sobre arte retórica M/!"$ /(" .8
EN57
"!!# "!
188
!# P/ ) O /"#
]!!'7!
Cfr</&/!" A%!; "=op. citRR/!"!
("
"#!
R
Cfr<O "*=:-A5-33ZTI1>:" M N
MN9!"E -!! I&! 1
5$)I$
E
$ Metalogicon P" )&"McaN;/1ZT5-$
A8MN<$/"-86' ) XII=Revista Española
de Filosofía EspañolaEO ] 6R
CfrA/^/ibidem
L
Cfr 1-AA-A4! MN M 4! 1! N
4!2!;! / #
A/^/op. citR
>I3)ZT-MN9!M /2!)
$&N > !I4
Cfr/5-):MNLógica de los estoicosM ">!:#N
5!
R
>I3)ZT-op. citO. ! Z% )
-MN !>("<!!("$
2#/#$!#!! "=O("*!
!! -0<" !"
("!$!]#!/#!
! P$!! =CfrAZ55-A;/
- MLNEnsayos escogidos!!# F"&6'7!
)-2!$ " R
R
$ 4Z3/T5-)":"<1 '!!O&.!
Z% ) -= Revista Española de Filosofía Medieval E
O ] 6F" )4!MLEN! .
("<! ! !%"& " " !
A!!#0&
;!& 0&
189