Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
in India
Vikas kujur
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
DLF was the leading real estate player in India, and its visionary chairman, Mr. K.P.
Singh, had played a large role in this. In April 2008, he was conferred an Honorary
Degree of Doctorate in Science by the prestigious G.B. Pant University of Agriculture
& Technology, in recognition of his 'invaluable contribution in the field of Business
Administration.'
Describing his vision, Mr. K. P. Singh said in his acceptance speech, 'In my own
humble way, it has been my endeavour to pioneer a movement to make Housing and
Urban Development the new Sunrise Sector of our economy.'
'I am acutely aware that although my company DLF is today regarded as the largest
real estate developer in the world and has a pan-Indian presence with over 50 million
square feet under construction, India needs not one DLF, but hundreds of companies
like DLF to meet the rising aspirations of the people for better living standards, better
homes and better all round infrastructure.'
Mr. Singh further said, 'the ground reality is that due to neglect of this crucial sector
in the past, our urban infrastructure is today crumbling and our urban centers are
unable to cope with the burgeoning population. Everything is in short supply, whether
you talk of housing, power supply, roads or sanitation. This has led to the degradation
of the human condition in our cities and towns, where fifty per cent of the population
are slum dwellers, lacking even basic hygiene facilities and slum children, the citizens
of tomorrow, are growing up in an environment where character building has no
place.’
On the occasion, Dr. A. P. Sharma, Vice-Chancellor, G.B. Pant University said that Mr.
K. P. Singh has made 'historic and lasting contributions to the building of modern
India through his pioneering role as a real estate developer and corporate leader with
a vision to transform the urban landscape of the country'. Mr.K.P. Singh also set 'new
standards in the housing and urban development scenario' emerging as the 'driving
force'
2
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
The size of the Indian real estate sector is estimated to be over US$12 billion. The contribution of
the housing sector to India's GDP is a meagre 1% against 3-6% of developing countries. If the
economy grows at the rate of 10%, the housing sector has the capacity to grow at 14% and
generate 3.2 million new jobs over the next 10 years.
In the last 3 years, the construction activity in the real estate sector has been buoyant, after going
through a recession between 1995 and 1999. High growth in the economy, growing contribution of
the services sector, changing demographic profile (increasing proportion of young and working
population, increasing disposable incomes and urbanisation), rising demand from the technology
sector and favourable government policies are expected to drive the demand for real estate in India.
The housing boom is expected to continue, despite a marginal firming up of the interest rate on
housing loans.
Key Characteristics
The Indian real estate sector has traditionally been dominated by a number of small regional or
local players with low levels of expertise. The sector has seen limited inflow of institutional capital
and has used high net-worth individual (HNI) and other informal sources of financing as the major
source of capital, leading to low levels of transparency. This is rapidly changing as the sector is
witnessing far higher growth rates and significantly improved quality expectations as India gets
better integrated with the global economy. Some of the key characteristics of the Indian real estate
sector are:
a) Highly fragmented market dominated by regional players - Rapid growth in the last decade has
seen the emergence of larger players that have differentiated themselves through superior
execution and branding. Further, these players are now able to capitalize on their early mover
advantage with high market share, but remain confined to local or regional markets. While these
3
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
larger players are now initiating efforts to develop a broader geographic presence, their home
markets continue to generate majority of their profitability.
b) Local know-how critical success factor in the development phase - One of the key reasons for
emergence of local developers is the critical importance of local knowledge and relationships in
ensuring successful and timely development of real estate projects. Property is a state subject in
India and the rules and regulations that affect, among other things, approval processes and
transaction costs vary from state to state.
c) High transaction costs -The sector has traditionally been burdened with high transaction costs as
a result of stamp duty on transfers of title to property that varies state by state. Though efforts are
being made at the state level to reduce the stamp duties, they continue to be as high as 11 % in
certain states.
d) Enhanced role of mortgage financing -Over the last five years, a significant portion of new
acquisitions, particularly in the larger cities in India, has been financed through banks and financial
institutions. This has been aided by a sharp decline in interest rates and broad availability of
financing products, due to aggressive marketing and product development by financial institutions.
i) Support from the GOI for the repeal of the Urban Land Ceiling Act (introduced in 1976), with
nine state governments having already repealed the Act. The law was repealed by the Central
Government in 1999. However, land being a state subject, the law is still in force in some states
like Andhra Pradesh, Assam, Bihar, Maharashtra and West Bengal;
ii) Modifications in the Rent Control Act to provide greater protection to homeowners wishing to
rent out their properties;
v) FDI being permitted in the real estate sector, subject to certain conditions.
4
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
The trend towards greater organisation and transparency has contributed to the development and
organised investment in the real estate sector by domestic and international financial institutions
and has also resulted in greater availability of financing for real estate developers. Regulatory
changes permitting foreign investment are expected to increase investment further in the Indian
real estate sector. These trends have been reinforced by the substantial recent growth in the Indian
economy, which has stimulated demand for land and developed real estate. Additionally, the tax
and other benefits applicable to SEZs are expected to result in a new source of demand.
Strengths
Their primary competitive strengths are :
5
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
As of April 30, 2006, their land reserves under development aggregated 1,372 acres
representing approximately 102 million square feet of developed area or area
available for development. In respect of properties representing an aggregate of
approximately 228 million square feet in 64 locations across India, Cushman &
Wakefield has opined that the land value of these properties is between Rs. 772
billion and Rs. 853 billion and Jones Lang LaSalle has opined that the land value of
these properties, as achievable by DLF, is approximately Rs. 853 billion.
Scale of operations
Their size allows them to benefit from economies of scale. They are able to purchase
large plots of land from multiple sellers, thus enabling us to aggregate land at lower
prices. They enjoy greater credibility with sellers of land as well as buyers of
properties as a result of their reputation and their scale of operations. The large scale
of our developments within a business line creates demand for our other business
lines.
Strategic locations
Their projects are strategically located. Their luxury residential developments benefit
from desirable locations that appeal to higher income customers, while their
townships are developed with easy access to city centres. Their commercial
developments are located in areas that are attractive to our multinational clients,
particularly in the IT and ITES sectors.
A tradition of innovation
They were one of the first developers to anticipate the need for townships on the
outskirts of fast growing cities and are generally credited with the growth of Gurgaon.
We were one of the early developers to focus on theme-based projects such as The
Magnolias development in DLF City, which includes a golf course. They are one of the
few developers in India to provide commercial space with floor plates of over 100,000
square feet and were an early developer of large shopping malls with integrated
entertainment facilities.
They have an experienced, highly qualified and dedicated management team, many
of whom have over 20 years of experience in their respective fields. Because of their
6
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
established brand name and reputation for project execution, they have been able to
recruit high calibre management and employees. They provide their staff with
competitive compensation packages and a corporate environment that encourages
responsibility, autonomy and innovation.
Since 2006, DLF has successfully transformed and established its business model as a
unique proposition. At one hand it is adopting a development company, while on
other hand it is retaining few retail and commercial projects in its books for
continuous cash flows in forms of rental earnings. The company is focusing on
minimising business and financial risk through diversification & a range of de-risking
initiatives.
2. It is taking exposure across business, segments and geographies to mitigate any down-
cycles in the market.
3. DLF intends to sell most of its commercial properties and offices to improve cash flows
and sustain large scale land acquisition in the initial years. Most commercial properties (IT
Parks, SEZs) have tax benefits; hence there is no tax impact. It also intends to sell few
properties (commercial/residential) through sale of shares.
7
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
4. A separate asset company, i.e.DLF Asset Ltd.(DAL), to buy assets from the ‘development
company’ on an ar,’s length, transparent basis through ‘open bid’ process with conditions
like ,1) if the market price of the asset be less than the 10% cap, dlf can execise a put option
on DAL, causing it to compulsorily buy the asset, and 2) DLF shall have an option to sell
assets, to the external ‘third party’ customer as well.
5. Mitigating financial & business risk by a range of initiatives, (refers A Risk Mitigating
High Growth Approach below)
1. Mitigating risk by continuing its diversification plan, i.e, multiple business across
geographies;
2. Mitigating funding risk in its existing and future businesses;
3. Minimising risk in existing business through optimal product segmentation &
continuous cash flows in terms of development and rental income;
4. Complementing existing & future businesses in case of mixed land use and
mitigating execution risk by having tie-ups with best in class global organisations;
5. De risking businesses through the virtuous cycle, asset monetisation & value
unlocking and sub vertical level fund launches;
6. More de risking by monetising retail and leisure businesses( raising funds by
launching retail and convention centre REITs);and
7. Intends to have a larger footprint in vertical or project level fund management to
be managed through its own AMC.
8
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
reserves in the last 1-2 years for fulfilling its growth agenda a until 2020 & beyond. The
company has kicked off four key strategic initiatives;
d) Diversify into other businesses & successfully complement them with existing business.
Horizon 1
Focus on building core business and land bank acquisition.
2006-08
• Achieve market leadership in core business using standard formats. Eg;
• Finalise partners and develop pilot properties for emerging business, eg; SEZ,
hotels
Horizon 2
2008-12
• Expand product line within core business, e.g
9
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
Horizon 3
Create huge upside beyond current business plan
2012-16
• Aggressively expand geographic spread in all the business
Incremental growth
In line with initiatives and stratergies formed by DLF, it is pretty much on the
path of following its three –phase strategy. Its current land reserves are sufficient to
last for its horizon 2 and 3. Its land reserves are widely spread across geographies
and is optimally segmented across different verticals, i.e, residential, commercial,
retail, plots. As seen from land concentration table , which is in line with DLF Horizon
1, top 10 cities account for almost 94% of land reserves. It is now present in all
regions of India and has been able to create a successful diversified portfolio with in
its existing business . i.e, optimally divided land reserves between residential,
commercial(including IT/IT SEZ) and retail. The company has also been able to draw
an effective line in between its sale and lease projects.
10
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
It has finalised partners for its ambitious hotel ventures and is on its way to roll out
4,000 hotel rooms by end -2010. It has acquired 51 hotel sites having a potential
development of ~ 9,000 rooms.It has received in-principle approvals for six of its SEZ
& has initiated the process for acquiring land. Land acquisition for its Manesar SEZ &
South Maharashtra SEZ has already begun.Despite having the largest development
plan in the country across segments and geographies,we expect DLF to continuously
bid for large projects( contiguous plots or large infrastructure projects), which will
further help DLF in mitigating the risk of any down-cycles in the market by
complementing its acquired projects with other verticals through mixed land use.
Execution
The project execution process commences with the obtaining of requisite regulatory
approvals, including environmental approvals, and the development of a project
concept based on the area’s marketability, target customers and potential return.
After a detailed review of the site parameters, they formalise an architectural brief
based of the project concept which is subsequently finalised with selected architects
and other external consultants. They closely monitor the development process,
construction quality, actual and estimated project costs and construction schedules.
11
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
They operate three separate sales and marketing departments, one for each of their
residential,
commercial and retail business lines. Their sales and marketing function is illustrated
in the chart (source: DLF IPO Red Herring prospectus)
Segmental snapshot
Residential business
• Aggressive launch of mid income housing projects in second half of Q3FY08
with primary focus on Chennai, Indore, and Kolkata.
• The New Town Heights in Rajarhat witnessed aggressive absorption; it was sold
out with in four days of its launch.
• New tools like one house per family and one year lock in period were used to
cut down speculative demand.
Commercial segment
• Aggressive growth in area under construction; it increased by 16% and 35%
over Q2FY08 and Q1FY08, respectively.
12
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
• Average lease rates have dropped over the past quarter by more than 30%,
primarily due to change in location.
Hotel segment
• Management has identified 51 hotel sites compared to 39 in the previous
quarter.
• The first Hilton Garden Inn is set to open in Saket (New Delhi) by end 2008.
• 4,000 hotel rooms expected to be operational by FY10 end with a long term
target of 25,000 hotel rooms in the next six-seven years.
• Acquisition of “Aman” gives a significant thrust to the hotels business unit, with
a strong international footprint.
SEZ business
• Five SEZs got notified, aggregating to 27 mn sq ft.
32 milestone: Executed collaboration agreement for 10.45 acres for new site at
Village Silokhera Gurgaon
13
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
They have a loyal customer base and encourage the participation of former buyers or
tenants in their new product launches. They employ various marketing approaches
depending on whether the project is residential, commercial or retail. These include
launch events, corporate presentations, web marketing, direct and indirect
marketing, as well as newspaper and outdoor advertising. Their marketing team sells
both directly to customers and through brokers. In their commercial and retail
business lines, they market space primarily through property consultants and by
using their relationships with existing tenants. Different marketing approaches are
used to target anchor commercial and retail tenants. They use approximately 120
brokerage firms to market their properties.
Mr. Rajiv Singh, Vice-Chairman, DLF Ltd, said, "We are sure that while WSP will bring
in its own strengths, we at DLF will set new benchmarks in the design and
construction industry."
In February 2006, DLF has entered into a joint venture with UK's leading construction
company, Laing O'Rourke Plc to form DLF Laing O’Rourke with an initial investment of
about Rs 500 crore. Both partners had contributed Rs. 250 crore each to the initial
corpus of the joint venture and it had also floated a dedicated fund with a corpus of
$1.5 billion for infrastructure projects. The joint venture company completed the most
prestigious projects of DLF like- IT Parks, The Mall of India, The Magnolias and many
of DLF's retail destinations. The joint venture company will help DLF group in
executing its infrastructure projects like harbors, tunnels, power plants, pipelines,
bridges and roads,
"The joint venture will help DLF become a major player in the country's construction
and infrastructure development programmes. It will tap potential across infrastructure
sector covering express highways, airports and hi-tech construction involving power
plants and mega projects," the DLF Universal Vice-Chairman, Mr. Rajiv Singh, said at
a conference”
14
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
On March 2007, DLF2 signed a 50:50 joint venture with Nakheel, a large property
developer from the UAE for two integrated townships in India with an initial
investment of $10 billion..The joint venture company will develop 40,000 acres at
Gurgaon and between Mumbai and Pune in Maharashtra. Construction of these two
projects is expected to start the same year only and the first phase of the
construction/development is targeted to complete in next three years. The cost of the
land is only 40% of the $10 billion investment. Approximately 70% of the land has
been acquired by DLF.
In November 2006, DLF signed a joint venture with Hilton Hotels Corporation. The
plan of the joint venture company is to develop and own 75 hotels and service
apartments throughout India over the next seven years and Hilton will invest up to
$143 million in the joint venture. 74% stake was held by DLF in the joint venture and
the rest will be held by the Hilton Hotel Corporation as a symbol of its commitment to
the joint venture. The first stage of the joint venture was to involve 20 hotels in key
locations like Kolkata, Chennai, Hyderabad, Bhubaneswar, Kochi, Delhi and
Chandigarh.
DLF made a partnership with IBM for a 10 year contract to transform and manage
DLF's IT Infrastructure. DLF tried to leverage IBM's Information Technology
infrastructure management solution to get high quality information that will be
efficiently managed in a cost-effective manner.
Rajeev Singh, Vice Chairman DLF thinks “As part of the partnership IBM and DLF will
also set up a Technology Innovation Council (TIC) with joint participation. The TIC will
focus on identifying and deploying new solutions for DLF and Indian Real estate
industry. Some of the solutions under consideration are advanced security
15
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
management solutions like Digital Video Surveillance, utilizing technology for land
acquisition process and other management systems. Some of the other focus areas
would include IT solutions for building management and intelligent buildings.”
DLF signed a joint venture with U.S. based Prudential Financial Inc. This agreement
allowed Prudential Financial Inc to expand its international investments business and
make a relevant mark of its official entry into the Indian mutual fund market. Under
the terms of the joint venture, DLF will own the 39 percent and Prudential Financial
Inc. will hold the majority stake in the joint venture with 61 percent interest. The
asset management joint venture is based in Mumbai and provides a wide range of
mutual fund and investment related products, including domestic and international
mutual funds to Indian retail and institutional clients
Competition
Even though many players are present in the real estate space in India, the top 5 of
them are as under:
• DLF Ltd.
• HDIL
• Omaxe Ltd.
• Parsavnath Developers
We analyse each of these competitors and there relative positions in the real estate
space in India.
HDIL
HDIL - Housing Development and Infrastructure Limited, is a listed real estate
development company with significant operations in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region.
HDIL's business focuses on Real Estate Development, including construction and
development of residential projects and, more recently, commercial and retail
projects, Slum Rehabilitation and Development, including clearing slum land and
rehousing slum dwellers, and Land Development, including development of
infrastructure on land which the company then sells to other property developers.
16
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
HDIL has an integrated in-house development team which covers all aspects of
property development from project identification and inception through construction
to completion and sale.
HDIL was the most profitable company out of the 5, with Operating profit margins as
high as 51.4% for a 3 year average, and Net Profit Margins as high as 43.75% for the
3 year average (refer Appendix >>>>___ for detailed comparison). Furhter, its 3 year
CAGR was a whopping 251%, which was also the best in the industry. Among the 5
players, It controlled 36, 50 and 62% of the market In terms of revenue in
proportionate distribution terms. (refer appendix for details)
Since its inception Sobha's reputation is built on rock solid values, benchmark quality
standards, uncompromising business ethos, focused customer centric approach,
robust engineering, in-house Research and development and transparency in all
spheres of conducting business. They also had a successful IPO in 2006 when the
issue was oversubscribed by 127 times. The company had completed 18.8 million
square feet of area as of September 2007, 42 completed residential/ commercial in
house projects, 36 ongoing projects and 104 contractual projects beginning with the
17
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
first residential project in Bangalore in 1997. The locations it was present in were
Bangalore, Karnataka, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh, Orissa, Tamil Nadu, Punjab, Harayana
and Maharashtra.
Its OPM and NPM for a 3 year average were 22.86% and 14.60% respectively. Its 3
year CAGR was also lower than competition at 60.62%.
Omaxe Ltd
The company was originally set up as Omaxe Builders Private limited in 1989,
promoted by Mr. Rohtas Goel , the founder, to undertake construction & contracting
business. The company further changed its constitution to a limited company known
as Omaxe Construction Ltd., in 1999. The name of the company has now changed to
Omaxe Ltd from 2006. The company began life as a civil construction and contracting
company, has successfully executed more than 120 prestigious Industrial,
Institutional, Commercial, Residential and Hospital construction projects. The
company entered the Real Estate Development business in 2001 and in now amongst
the large Real Estate Development companies in India. Mr. Rohtas Goel , a first
generation entrepreneur, a civil engineer by qualification and a visionary having more
than two decades of experience in Construction and Real Estate Development.
Omaxe received a number of awards from the industry, recognition of its continued
efforts towards achieving excellence and quality. The company became the first
Construction Company of northern India to receive an ISO 9001:2000 Certification.
The company is at present developing over 156 million sq ft of area across 31 towns
in 10 states in Northern , Central India and Southern India.
In terms of its financials, it still lacks behind its competitors as its OPM and NPM
average over 3 years was 19.33% and 10.72% respectively. Yet, it was a fast growing
company with a 3 year CAGR of 206.82% which was second only to HDIL.
Parsavnath
Parsvnath had a commitment to `building a better world’, which they tried to fulfil by
transforming barren tracts into landscaped green belts housing world class
commercial, residential and recreational properties. They believe in creating
architectural marvels using state-of-the-art technology and global architectural,
construction and business practices. They provided cost-effective and holistic
solutions for our customers while creating and adding value for our partners and
stakeholders. They had a pan-India presence in over 51 cities in 18 states, where they
built contemporary residential spaces, state-of-the-art office complexes, luxurious
18
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
shopping malls and hypermarkets, posh hotels, futuristic multiplexes, and ultra
modern IT Parks and special economic zones.
They were a relatively smaller player compared to the rest, and had only 10% of the
proportionate distribution based on revenues among the top 5 real estate players. Its
profit margins weren’t too encouraging either, with 3 yr NPM and OPM averages being
18.21% and 22.45%. Their growth rate (CAGR, 3 yr average) was a healthy 140%.
HR Strategy of DLF
The housing sector alone is likely to generate 40 lakh new jobs within ten years. The
prime reason for such a huge demand of personnel has been due to great demands for
residential and commercial real estate projects. Moreover, the sector offers attractive
opportunities to people with roles such as developers, architects, strategy and urban
planners, civil engineers, and contractors. It also offers a plethora of opportunities which
are not confined to profiles of contractors and builders only, but extend up to
professionals including people with marketing, law, finance, and advertising
backgrounds. Many property management companies also work tightly with the sector,
thereby, resulting into indirect generation of employment.
Coming to the trends of talent acquisition, most real estate firms are becoming
proactive in terms of hiring and are adopting latest talent acquisition and recruitment
trends like on-campus recruitments, e- recruitments using recruitment portals, executive
search and so on. To meet the demands for highly skilled professional, companies like
DLF are looking out for campus recruits from top business schools like IIMs. The job
options range from real estate appraisal to property managers, advisors, investment
bankers, entrepreneur, retail buyers and merchandisers, visual merchandisers, supply
chain distributors and logistics and warehouse managers.
19
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
The changing face of realty sector is posing great challenges for the companies in terms
of talent shortage and high attrition. To deal with such challenges becomes the sole
responsibility of the HR departments of the companies so as to keep pace with the
growth of the sector.
CSR Initiatives
"For DLF, Corporate Social Responsibility is not just an add on; rather our business and
social commitment are mutually reinforcing and neither will be sustainable without the
20
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
other. We have a continuing social responsibility towards the people of the area in which
we operate more so towards the less fortunate. It has been our constant endeavor to
create sustainable economies and transform stagnant lives into active partnerships
through synergized proactive handholding in areas of infrastructure, education, training,
health and environment. We have made a public commitment to carry on these trusted
relationships." – CEO Mr. K.P.Singh.
• Solved the sewer problem in Nathupur and Chakarpur villages by connecting them to the
DLF’s own sewer line system.
21
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
22
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
23
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
24
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
25
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
26
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
Liquidity: Due to strong cash flows, liquidity is not at all an issue in this case.
Leverage: This might be a cause for concern today but as the projects cash in, the
debt will be repaid by the company. This will decrease the financial risk for the
company; which might be considered a bit high today. But considering the
development sector in real estate, the debt-equity is usually high due to unknown and
large financial requirements.
27
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
28
DLF: Real Estate Leadership in India
Financial Comparison
Revenues 3- Year PBDIT 3-Year PAT 3-Year
Company Name
(Rs Cr.) CAGR(%) (Rs Cr.) CAGR (%) (Rs Cr.) CAGR (%)
DLF Ltd. 1,101.66 63.47 986.11 171.32 405.77 144.83
HDIL 2,379.87 137.43 1,758.22 251.89 1,410.51 251.86
Sobha Developers Ltd 1,422.51 50.83 365.36 61.21 228.30 60.62
Omaxe Ltd. 940.87 54.30 281.12 208.54 124.83 206.82
Parsvnath Developers 643.83 139.60 154.50 167.64 106.25 140.23
29