Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
BRSM
QMSMDD ISO 13485 (2003)
Assessment Report/Checklist
Form 009
CLIENT‐ORGANIZATION (NAME): Teb Tajhiz Gharn
PHYSICAL LOCATION(s): No. 449 , Floor 3 , Tower Bahar Street , sourth
Bahar , Enghelab Ave. , Tehran , Iran.
Stage II Audit Date(s): 16 & 17 Apr.2016
Stage I Audit Date(s): 28 Feb 2016
NAICS (or NACE) CODE MD0105, MD0204
Assessment objectives: Attesting requirements of QMS MDD systems
have been met in client’s management system
ASSESSMENT TEAM INFORMATION
Assessment Team Leader, ATL Mojtaba Ramezani
Assessor 2 Marjan Azadmanesh
TE Fatemeh Montajebi
Assessor 4
Assessor 5
Assessor 6
Note: Adjusting the language within this form to the type of activity and nature of the organization is acceptable.
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
We pursuit to assure that client‐organization adheres to the protection of communities and consumers. This is to
1 follow the intent to the substitution of the word “identify” to the word “determine” as part of the importance to
the processes being capable of achieving desired outputs (including consumer’s well‐being).
OBL of lenses includes : Foldable Hydrophilic ,Foldable Hydrophilic A+,
2 Scope of activities Foldable Hydrophobic , Foldable Hydrophobic A+ , PMMA AC and PC ,
IRIS Retractors , Capsular tension Ring , injector & Cartridge
MOH requirements about OBL products and technical
Legal status supervisor are responsible for meet and monitoring of
3 these legal.
Obligatory applicable standard which
IMED regulations
organization has to follow
4 Quality Management System
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Does the organization establish, document, implement,
maintain and continually improve a Quality
Management System (QMS) with due consideration
given to identification of processes needed for the
QMS and their application throughout the system;
Processes are: storage, purchasing, packing, control of
determination of sequence and interaction of these non -conform product , training , contract review ,
4.1 processes, determination of criteria and methods
required to ensure effective operation and control of
corrective and preventive action.
these processes; availability of resources and Acceptance criteria are defined in M-3-01-00.
information required to support the operation and
monitoring of processes; measurement, monitoring and
analysis of the processes; implementation of action to
achieve planned results and continual improvement
‐If any, are the outsourced processes are defined?
DOCUMENTATION REQUIREMENTS
Is there a documented quality policy and documented
quality objectives and are they appropriate? The Quality Manual (QM) was observed. All required
Is there a documented quality manual and are there
documented procedures required by the standards?? standards clauses have been mentioned.
Are required records for planning, acting and controlling They have developed quality policy (QP) by determining main
4.2 processes efficiently available? targets
Are the documents are created for every type of
medical device including qms requirements and product Quality Objectives (QO) have been determined according to
specifications? (4.2.3) If these documents are applicable the main targets of quality policy.
to manufacturing processes, are montage and service
defined?
QUALITY MANUAL
Does the Quality Manual include, scope of QMS and
details of exclusion? Quality manual: M-0-01.
4.2.2 Are documented procedures reference to mandatory
procedures;
Is description of interaction of the processes included in
the QMS?
CONTROL OF DOCUMENTS
Are mandatory procedures documented?
Are control conditions pertaining to mandatory
documents proper?
Are review, update and re‐approval situations and
changes and current review situations for documents Control of documents and records: A-1-03-00.
traceable? Responsibilities for approve and issued is determined in
Are the relevant documents usable, readable and
4.2.3 recognizable at concerned usage points? this procedure. Method for control of approved and non
Are outsourced documents defined? approved and reviewed documents is determined in this
Are distribution of documents controlled, outdated
documents prevented from being used and appropriate
procedure
definition method applied in case of being stored for
any purpose?
Are these subjects clear in the relevant procedure?
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 2 of 15
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
5.5 Responsibility, Authority and Communication
RESPONSIBILITY AND AUTHORITY
Has top management identified responsibility and
Responsibilities of packing and labeling department
observed on F-3-1-00 such as: control of sterility, control
5.5.1
authority and been communicated within the
organization?
of primary packing, control of product cleaning and
Has top management defined responsibilities and
authorizations for CE marking? packing, control of warehouse bout correct situation , ….
MANAGEMENT REPRESENTATIVE
Has top management appointed a member as
Management Representative with responsibility and Head of trading dept. is management representative. He
5.5.2
authority to ensure that the processes of the QMS are
established, implemented and maintained; report to is aware about his responsibilities. He approved by MD
top management on the performance of the QMS, through Official letter 6 month ago.
including needs for improvement and promote
awareness of customer requirements?
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 3 of 15
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
REVIEW OUTPUT
Does output from management review include actions Review output are as equired such as:
5.6.3
related to improvement of the QMS and its processes,
improvement of product related to customer training course about sales department
requirements, actions and decisions relate to resource
needs? action for license from MOH for OBL products.
6 Resource Management
PROVISION OF RESOURCES
Does the organization have methods to determine and
6.1 provide resources needed to implement and improve
the processes of the QMS and address customer
satisfaction by meeting requirements?
6.2 Human Resources
Are personnel assigned with responsibilities that affect
product quality competent on the basis of applicable
Human resources, infrastructure provided for support of
6.2.1 education, training, skills, and experience?
Are trainings performed for achievement of Required processes.
Competence?
Needed qualifications for packing and labeling personal
are: awareness of products, statistic and packing process,
COMPETENCE, AWARENESS, AND TRAINING requirements of ISO 9001, ISO 13485.
Has the organization identified the experience,
qualifications, competencies and skills of the personnel Mr. Asghari’s training schedule is based on training
performing activities affecting safety and efficiency of
medical devices particularly being manufactured and
needs which has been prepared by Management
provided to customer? representative such as:
6.2.2
Is training provided by the organization to satisfy the
competency needs? Course teamwork on end September 2015, effectiveness
Does the organization ensure that its employees are of course has been measured, it was 50, corrective action
aware of the relevance and importance of their
activities and how they contribute to the achievement has been observed, and root cause was the instructor, so
of quality objectives? he has been considered as black list.
Are records of education, experience, training and
qualifications maintained? Course has been re-held on November 2015 and record
of effectiveness of course for Mr. Ashghari has been
observed on December 2015. His grade is 90 from 100.
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 4 of 15
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
INFRASTRUCTURE
Has manufacturing equipment been designed,
Equipment for labeling of product provided, labeling
constructed, properly established and placed for proper section was clean, labeling rail’s disinfecting repot on
operation, maintenance, adjustment and cleaning?
In case of applicability, has the organization ensured
Dec 2015 has been observed.
documentation of natural limits or permissible Activity for maintenance of this equipment has
tolerances in manufacturing process and measuring and
test equipment and availability of the same for determined.
6.3
operators?
Are documented processes available for maintenance,
Labeling personnel shall have cap and gloves, GMP
cleaning and control of all equipment used in requirement has been done which accepted by IMED too.
manufacturing process and control of work
environment? Mr. Asghari, packaging operator has been observed he
Are required adjustments and maintenance intervals had gloves and cap.
identified?
Is maintenance plan placed normally on or near the His health card has been observed which is valid before
equipment and easily reachable?
Is maintenance realized based on the relevant plan?
August 2016.
WORK ENVIRONMENT
Does the organization identify and manage required
work environment needed to achieve conformity of
product?
Are the following factors which could affect product
quality in the work environment identified?
‐ Process equipment,
‐ Work environment,
‐ Personnel in this work environment
Are qualified and quantified limit values of the work
environment identified for a desired quality of the work
environment?
Are pollution levels of microbial and solid particles
controlled during product manufacturing where sterile
product or pollution of solid particle which is stipulated
to be sterilized or could live or not live during its
manufacture or utilization is important?
Has exclusion been applied during all manufacturing
processes for a controlled environment? As valid
ground of exclusion, is pollution reduced to known,
consistent and controlled level by an approved cleaning For labeling of finished products, no need special
method and packaging kept at this level through control
process?
environmental requirements. Labeling is doing in general
Have indicators been identified for a controlled situations and storage of products must be done in
environment which covers valid cleaning and packaging accordance with requirements on label. Control of
processes including the organizations holding a valid
6.4 cleaning process? warehouse environment situations is doing by head of
(Temperature, Humidity, Air Current, Filtration of Air, warehouse by thermometer and humidity meter in
Ionization of Air, Pressure differences, Lighting (along
with its spectral content and severity), Sound, Vibration, warehouse. The records show temperature between 18c
cleaning of Working surfaces and processes, Water to 25 c.
quality, number of persons in the work environment)
Have dressing conditions, cleaning conditions and Records kept in this dept.
health conditions for any person being in contact with
the product or the work environment including those
persons who enter the area sterilized prior to use or
temporarily or for a short period in terms of importance
microbiologic cleaning holds been identified?
Are personnel to work in special work conditions or a
controlled environment provided with special training
and/or supervision? In the event that any personnel
including temporary and trained personnel for
performance of special tasks in a controlled
environment are assigned for performance of the works
such as production, maintenance, cleaning or repair, are
such personnel supervised by an appropriately trained
person? Have the procedures for product introduction,
product polluted or being likely to be polluted, manual
working for working surfaces or personnel, cleaning or
removal of contamination in order to prevent cross
pollution of product, work environment or personnel?
Are the records indicating appropriateness for all
conditions kept?
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 5 of 15
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
7 Product Realization
PLANNING OF PRODUCT REALIZATION
Has the organization considered the scope of its own
quality management system in planning of product
realization?
Has the organization prepared required records for a
proof indicating that quality objectives and product
rules, processes established, documents and product‐
specific necessary resources, verification, validation,
tracking, measuring, inspection and product‐specific
test activities , realization processes and the product
meet the rules?
In the event that inspection and test are conducted by
Risk analysis instruction observed: B-3-01.
manufacturing personnel, do inspection and test Record of risk analysis form observed: B-3-10.
results, processes, organization’s procedures ensure
impartiality of inspection and test results? Hazard about labeling and packing identified
7.1 Risk management completely such as: no label of product specification
Has the organization prepared a procedure containing
all processes of product realization for risk management in pack, un correct expiry date (more than 3 years) ,
activities and realized the following?
Keeping the records
… and effects and causes of these failures
Preparation of Risk Management Plan determined completely.
Determination of Risk team and its Responsibilities
Determination of Intended Use of Device and Safety
Characteristics of Device
Definition of hazards
Risk Estimation for Hazards
Evaluation of Risks
Risk Control Measures
Definition of Residual Risks
Risk/Benefit Analysis
Preparation of Risk Management Report
DETERMINATION OF REQUIREMENTS RELATED TO THE
PRODUCT/SERVICE
Has the organization defined the requirements of
customer including the requirements for the activities
on delivery and after delivery?
Do these requirements include the following?:
‐ regulatory and legal requirements related to the
countries and territories where the product is supplied
to the market Orders from customer received and then must be
‐ anticipated utilization,
‐ Performance expectations, record in order form. Because of no license product
‐ Design factors from MOH , organization cannot sale and no
7.2.1 ‐ Delivery plans
‐Unclear customer expectations records of sale observed.
Does the organization record customer’s expectations
related to product/service in order to revise the same? As a Sample order form which was contain Delivery
In the event of any change in order or offer or both for
any reason whatsoever, are changes revised and an time, amount, product Code was observed.
agreement is reached on the changes as it is in original
order or offer?
In the event that changes are accepted, are all
personnel being affected by the changes within the
organization informed?
Are relevant documents affected by these changes
amended?
7.2 Customer‐Related Processes
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 6 of 15
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
7.3 Design and Development
DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT PLANNING
Have the stages of design and/or development been
identified?
Have review, verification and validation activities
appropriate to each design and/or development stage,
7.3.1 responsibilities and authorities been identified in design excluded
and development planning?
Are design and development planning updated when
planning output is appropriate and in the progress of
design and development?
DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT INPUTS
Are inputs related to product requirements identified
and relevant records maintained?
Do these inputs include functional and performance
7.3.2 requirements, applicable regulatory and legal Excluded
requirements, applicable information derived from
previous and similar designs a any other requirements
essential for design?
Have the inputs been reviewed in terms of adequacy?
DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT OUTPUTS
Are design and/or development outputs approved
before prior to release and in a manner that enables
verification against the design and/or development
inputs?
Do the design and/or development outputs meet the
7.3.3 design input requirements and Excluded
‐provide appropriate information for purchasing,
manufacture and service performance,
‐ contain or reference product acceptance criteria
‐ define the characteristics of the product that are
essential to its safe and proper use?
DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
Does the organization identify suitable stages for
systematic reviews of design and/or development?
7.3.4 Are the results of review and subsequent follow‐up Excluded
actions recorded in order to evaluate the ability to
fulfill requirements and identify problems and
propose corrective actions?
DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT VERIFICATION
7.3.5 Does the organization in planned arrangements ensure Excluded
that design output meets input criteria
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 7 of 15
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT VALIDATION
Is the design and/or development validation performed
in accordance with planned arrangements to confirm
that final product is capable of meeting the
requirements of intended use or application
7.3.6 requirements defined? Excluded
Is verification completed (if applicable) prior to delivery
or implementation of product? Ara relevant records
maintained?
Are results of review and required actions recorded?
CONTROL OF DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT CHANGES
Have design and development changes been identified
and recorded?
Have design and development changes been reviewed,
verified, validated and approved prior to
implementation?
7.3.7 Does the review of design and development changes Excluded
include evaluation of the effect of changes on
previously delivered product and the parts constituting
the product?
Are the results of review of changes and subsequent
follow‐up actions documented?
7.4 Purchasing
Purchasing Process; Has the organization prepared
documented process to ensure that purchased product
conforms to purchasing requirements?
Are criteria for selection of suppliers defined?
Are evaluation and reevaluation of suppliers have been
defined?
Has the organization defined tracking frequency of
supplier’s performance?
Does the organization have the proofs indicating that
supplier monitoring activities, outsourced processes are
Supplier’s evaluation checklist: B-3-02 observed.
controlled and the products or services conform to the Supplier (producer of lenses) evaluated about :
7.4.1
rules of the organization containing customer demands
and regulatory rules? credit of supplier , on-time delivery , quality of
Have the requirements of purchasing information
(containing the rules related to supplier records)
product , … score was : 88 and was acceptable
including outsourced processes been identified to score. (Acceptable range is more than 70).
ensure product and service quality?
Does the organization have the methodology to
communicate these requirements to the supplier?
Are purchasing contracts available?
Do the type and content of the control on supplier and
purchased product depend on the next product
realization of purchased product or final product?
Are purchasing records retained?
PURCHASING INFORMATION
Does purchasing information define the product to be
purchased?
Where appropriate, does purchasing information
include product approval, procedures, requirements for For purchasing of finished products from main
7.4.2
process and equipment, Personnel qualification and the
requirements of Quality Management System? producer, name and code of product announces to
How does organization ensure the adequacy of
specified requirements in the purchasing information
main producer.
prior to their release to the supplier?
Are records for the information related to purchased
product available?
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 8 of 15
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
VERIFICATION OF PURCHASED PRODUCT
Has the organization identified a method in order to
ensure that the product received conforms to the
specifications, is finished, holds appropriate identity
and is free from any damage?
After purchasing of finished product from main
Do the processes include the provisions in order to producer, these products verified according to
verify that incoming product is provided along with
packing instruction. Such as: serial 15322 qc record
7.4.3
support documentation (e.g. conformity certificates,
acceptance test reports)? has been observed regarding document review and
Has data been provided related to analysis of previous
acceptance inspection data, rejection history in the quantity on12/6/1394 August 2015.
plant or customer complaints, required inspection
quantity and necessity of reevaluation of supplier?
Has the organization identified the authorized person
for conformity approval of incoming material?
Are verification records retained?
7.5 Production and Service Provision
CONTROL OF PRODUCTION AND SERVICE PROVISION
7.5.1.1 General rules
Has the organization identified control requirements for
production and service process?
Is control quantity and control detail level
proportionate to criticality level of its process?
Has the characteristic qualities of product been
identified? When required, have documented
procedures, documented rules, work instructions and
reference materials reference materials and reference
measuring processes been made available?
Has appropriate equipment been selected in the
manner that enables process and product specifications
to be obtained? Packing of product instruction documented:
Have the documents for using appropriate equipment
been established?
labeling, insert of catalog and specification, packing.
Has it been verified that new and/or significantly Controls of products packed primary has defined
modified equipment meets purchasing/design
specifications and posses the ability to operate within according to risk analysis, such as : control of hazard
7.5.1 the limits defined and process operating limits? about un correct exp. Date of products and also
Have control devices been identified?
Has a document been prepared for using control information with packing for every product are
devices?
Have implementation and control requirements for
different from others . This controls during packing
labeling and packaging been identified? has defined completely in packing instruction Q-6-
Are the records obtained during manufacturing process
of any product lot and facilitating traceability and 01.
review of the manufacture of this lot retained?
Do the records include the following information?
‐ When applicable, quantity of raw materials,
components and intermediate products and lot
numbers of those materials,
‐ When applicable, start and completion dates of
different stages of manufacture including sterilization
records,
‐ Quantity of manufactured product,
‐ Signed results of all inspections and tests,
‐ Representation of production line used,
‐ Any deviation from manufacturing specifications.
7.5.1.2 Control of production and service‐Special rules
Control of product cleanliness and contamination
Has the organization identified product cleanliness
rules? Cleaning includes: sterilization of product be done
Have the materials and substances used during
manufacturing process been adequately defined and by main producer and this clause excluded.
labeled in order to prevent complexity and process Record of cleanness monitoring for 15/6/1394 has
7.5.1.2.1 faults?
Have certain medical devices been cleaned and/or been observed signed by Technical supervisor,
cleared of contamination so as to prevent employees
and other product from being exposed to any report of cleaning for same week has been observed
contamination with signed by manufacturing manager.
Have cleaning and implementation requirements been
documented?
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 9 of 15
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
Assembly activities
Have assembly activities and responsibility for medical
device been identified?
In the event that any medical device should be
assembled and mounted in the location where the user
is present, have guiding instructions been prepared by
7.5.1.2.2 the organization for accurate assembly, montage, tests excluded
and/or calibrations?
Has the organization provided the instructions which
allow assembler to confirm proper operation of the
device?
Are the results of assembly or commissioning tests
recorded?
Service activities
In the event that functionality of products needs service
or maintenance for proper utilization of products, have
documented requirements been established for service
activity?
Has the organization identified service responsibilities
between distributors and users?
Have service activities carried out by the organization or
a separate agency been planned?
Have the design and functionality of equipment or
devices with special purpose related to manual
operation and service after assembly been validated?
7.5.1.2.3 Are measuring and test equipment used for site service Excluded
and tests controlled?
Have instructions related to the lists of spare parts or
parts and for use in product service been prepared?
Has the infrastructure covering technical consultancy
and technical support, customer training and spare
parts or provision of parts been established?
Are service personnel trained?
Are specialized service personnel available?
Has the organization formed a system for receiving
customer demands so as to determine whether
customer complaints and rules are handled?
Are service records retained?
Special rules for sterile devices
Does the organization record process parameters Organization received sterilization records tracked
related to sterilization process and used for each
7.5.1.3 sterilization lot? for each production lot from producer .records of
Are sterilization records tracked for each production lot
related to medical devices?
Dec 2015 were observed.
7.5.2 VALIDATION OF PROCESSES FOR PRODUCTION AND SERVICE PROVISION
General rules
a)defined criteria for review and approval of the
process
b)approval of equipment and qualification of staff
involved
7.5.2.1 c) use of specific methods and procedures excluded
d)records requirements
e)revalidation
documented procedure for validation of
software/computer applications, and records of
validation
Special rules for sterile medical devices
Have sterilization processes been validated prior to
use?
7.5.2.2 Have the standards used for validation of sterilization excluded
process been identified and implemented?
Have the requirements in the Article no. 7.5.2.1 been
met?
7.5.3 Identification and Traceability
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 10 of 15
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
Identification
Has the organization identified and documented the
product through appropriate methods during product Identifying and traceability procedure: P-1-02-00
7.5.3.1 realization?
How has the organization identified product situations documented.
in accordance with tracing and measuring
requirements?
In P-1-02-00, method of identifying and traceability
TRACEABILITY are Compatible to real lot no. batch No. on pack of
75.3.2.1 General
How is the product traced?
product. Such as: in pack of hydrophilic, lot no. has
7.5.3.2 Has any method been documented for traceability?
Does the organization ensure traceability of the medical
checked. Identifying of lot No. and batch No. done
device during typically production and storage process by main producer and this organization do not
up to expiration of ownership?
change these specifications. Such as: batch 012549
which has been bought for Mrs. Amiri Hospital toos.
Special rules related to active implantable medical
devices and implantable medical devices
Does the organization ensure traceability in inspection
and stock records for the changes of the personnel For all lenses has determined patient card for record
performing a work traceability of which belongs to an
7.5.3.2.2 introductory (e.g. serial number, data code, lot code,
of patient and surgeon name. On pack of these
party number) special to operation source, changes in
raw materials, changes in the works performed through
products recorded barcode for trace of product to
tools, new or different machine devices, changes of customer. Such as code 012549 which has been
process methods?
When applicable, are special personnel assigned to act
bought for Mrs. Amiri left eye in toos Hospital.
during processing medical device or each stage of
delivery traced?
Status Identification In warehouse observed products ready to sale and all
7.5.3.3 Organization has identified status of product with
respect to measurement and monitoring requirements of them have complete labeling.
CUSTOMER PROPERTY
Does the organization ensure identification, verification,
protection and safety of customer property provided
for product or in the manner that it creates product
while it is under the organization’s control or being
7.5.4 used? Excluded
Does the process ensure that occurrence of any
customer property that is lost, damaged or otherwise
found to be unsuitable for use are recorded and
reported to the customer?
PRESERVATION OF PRODUCT
Are methods and controls established to preserve
conformity of product during internal processing and
until delivery to intended destination?
Has the organization established documented processes
Storage , handling and keeping of product procedure has
or documented work instructions for control of the documented : F-1-03. Storage temperature has
product with limited shelf life or which requires special
determined : 18-25◦c. up to 5 pack must be put in shelf
7.5.5 storage?
Are such special storage requirements controlled and of warehouse. Size of packing for lenses determined in
recorded?
Does this preservation include definition, transport,
this procedure. Storage situation checked and all
packaging, storage and protection of the product and requirements has meet. Such as : storage temperature.
the parts constituting the product?
Is there a logo on product? Is it proper to its
instructions?
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 11 of 15
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
CONTROL OF MONITORING AND MEASURING DEVICES
Has the organization identified the measurements to be
made and the measuring and monitoring devices
required to ensure conformity of product to specified
requirement?
a) Be calibrated or verified at specified intervals, or
prior to use, against measurement standards traceable
to international or national measurement standards;
7.6 where no such standards exist, the basis used for excluded
calibration or verification s hall be recorded;
b) Be adjusted or re‐adjusted as necessary;
c) Be identified to enable the calibration status to be
determined;
d) Be safeguarded from adjustments that would
invalidate the measurement result;
e) Be protected from damage and deterioration during
handling, maintenance and storage.
8 Measurement, Analysis and Improvement
General
Does the organization plan to implement the
monitoring, measurement, analysis, and improvement
measurement, analysis and improvement processes are
processes required for conformity of the product and carried out through statistical techniques and
8.1
QMS and improvement of its efficiency?
Are measurement, analysis and improvement
applicable methods according to Statistic analysis
processes are carried out through statistical procedure
techniques and applicable methods?
8.2 Monitoring and Measuring
Customer satisfaction is handling by procedure: B-2-02.
Every 6 mounts.
8.2.1 CUSTOMER SATISFACTION Customer survey is done based on: function, safety,
Does the organization monitor the information related
to customer perception in order to understand whether reliability, quality, packing …
8.2.1 customer requirements are met or not?
Has the organization determined methodologies for
Because of no license product from MOH, organization
obtaining and using information on customer cannot sale and no customer survey collected. But
satisfaction and/or dissatisfaction? procedure is as requirement.
For sample and mock a form has been completed.
INTERNAL AUDIT
Has a documented procedure been established that
includes responsibilities and requirements,
Internal audit procedure: A-1-04-00.needed qualification
requirements for planning and conducting the audit, for audit team is determined in this procedure. Intervals
reporting the results, maintaining the records?
Are audits planned in the form of an audit program?
for internal audit are every 6 mounts. first internal audit
has held on Feb.2016. Planning of internal audit : A-3-
8.2.2
Does audit programme take importance and status of
the fields and processes to be audited including the 09-00 observed. all processes has audited. Questions and
results of previous audits?
Do selection of auditors and implementation of audit evidence of audit recorded in audit checklist A-3-06-00.
ensure objectivity and impartiality of the process?
Do auditors audit their works?
One non conformity observed in internal audit(about
Do follow‐up actions cover verification of the measures training effectiveness)
taken and reporting of verification results?
MONITORING AND MEASUREMENT OF PROCESSES
Processes has measured based on acceptance
Does the organization implement appropriate methods criteria. result of measuring observed according to
8.2.3
for monitoring QMS processes and where applicable,
for measurement such WMS processes? analysis of data procedure .sample :purchasing
When planned results are not achieved, is corrective
action taken for product conformity?
process that measured based on time purchasing and
result was 100%
8.2.4 MONITORING AND MEASUREMENT OF PRODUCT
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 12 of 15
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
General rules
Does the organization establish appropriate stages to
measure and monitor product characteristics?
Test and investigation procedure: Q-1-01-00.
Have verification methods been documented? Controls before and during of packing according to
Is this verification process realized in accordance with
the arrangements planned during appropriate stages of risk analysis such as: exp. Date , specification on
8.2.4.1 product realization process?
Are conformity evidences along with acceptance criteria
label and supplier qc report shall be done.
maintained? For lot: 012638s 20150056 , batch no.: 012638 .
Are the records approved by the authorized
person/persons in the process of product release?
Items must be controlled records observed on record
Are product release and distribution of service, planned Q-3-01-00.
regulations (Article 7.1) completed satisfactorily?
Special rules related to active implantable medical
devices and implantable medical devices
8.2.4.2 Does the organization record the identity of the excluded
personnel carrying out any inspection or test?
CONTROL OF NON‐CONFORMING PRODUCT
Does the organization have methodologies to ensure
that product that does not conform to requirements is
identified and controlled to prevent unintended use or
delivery?
Is there a documented procedure related to non‐
conforming product?
Does the organization take measures to remove non‐
conformity related to product?
When applicable, do the processes identify the methods Procedure for control of non conforming products
8.3
authorizing the non‐conformity’s use, release or
acceptance in agreement with customer? has documented but no records observed.
Are required measures taken to preclude the product’s
original intended use or application?
Responsibilities have determined.
Are records related to the nature of nonconformities
and the measures taken later maintained?
Is corrected nonconforming product subject to re‐
verification to demonstrate conformity to the
requirements?
Do the processes ensure that appropriate corrective
action is initiated when non‐conforming product is
detected after delivery or use has started?
DATA ANALYSIS
Does the organization collect, identify and analyze
appropriate data to demonstrate efficiency and
appropriateness of QMS and the fields where QMS’s
efficiency can be continuously improved?
Analysis of data for result of processes measuring
Has a documented procedure been prepared for these observed. Results were in acceptable range and no
8.4
analyses?
corrective and preventive action defined. Also
Do the characteristics and tendencies of the processes
and products including data analysis, customer analysis of supplier performance (main producer)
satisfaction, conformance to product requirements,
opportunities for corrective actions provide information observed and results were acceptable.
related to suppliers?
Have data types for data analysis been defined?
Are data analyses recorded?
8.5 Improvement
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 13 of 15
REFERENCE, AS
This Clause
APPLICABLE1
Has been
Reference Clause Observations Verified,
please Tick
mark √
CONTINUAL IMPROVEMENT
Has the organization identified required changes by
using quality policy, quality objectives, audit results,
analyses of data, corrective and preventive actions and
management review in order to ensure and sustain
ongoing conformity and efficiency of quality
management system and does the organization
implement such changes?
Has the organization established written procedures in
order that advisory warnings can be published and
implemented?
Are the records of all examinations related to customer
complaint maintained?
Have the complaints been evaluated within the scope of
the following points?: Instruction for customer complaints management
‐ whether the organization fails to comply with its own
specifications or not,
observed: B-2-03-00.
8.5.1 ‐ whether the organization has caused problems to
occur despite the fact that it has complied with its own
Recall procedure has documented.
specifications Corrective and preventive and improvement
In the event that the activities outside the organization
are identified through examination of the contribution
procedure: A-1-05-00.
of such activities to customer complaint, has the
relevant information been shared among responsible
organizations?
In the event that any customer complaint is not
followed up through a corrective and/or preventive
action, has the reason of this failure been confirmed
and recorded?
Has the organization established a documented
procedure for notifying adverse events and alertness
within the scope of after‐sale supervision activities?
Does the process comply with international guides?
(MEDDEV 2.12.1 – MEDDEV 2.12.2)
Are the notices for adverse events recorded
8.5.2. CORRECTIVE ACTION
Is there a documented procedure for Corrective and
Preventive Action?
Are corrective actions taken to eliminate causes of
nonconformities effective in preventing recurrences?
Does this procedure include the requirements of Records of corrective action observed. The effectiveness
8.5.2 reviewing non‐conformities (including customer
complaints), determining the causes of non‐conformity,
was checked.(records of internal Audit non-conformity,
evaluating the actions needed to ensure that related to training effectiveness were checked).
nonconformities do not recur, determining and
implementing the corrective action needed, and review
of the results of the action initiated?
Is adequacy of corrective‐preventive actions identified?
PREVENTIVE ACTION
Has the organization established a documented
procedure for preventive action with defined
requirements for identifying potential non‐conformities
8.5.3
and their causes; evaluating the need for action to
prevent occurrence; determining and implementing No records of preventive action observed.
preventive action needed; recording results of action
taken; reviewing preventive action taken.
What are the methods for identifying the adequacy of
corrective‐preventive actions?
FORM‐009_V4_QMS MDD Issued: July 9, 2003 Revised: March 2013 Page 14 of 15
By exception, we indicate the specific Strengths and weakness of the organization in light of the management system, as we perceive and seen through
processes in reference to requirements of the criteria being ascribed as these apply and relate to the assessment plan and planning of the assessment.
This aspect relates to Accreditation Body as it does to the protection of consumers in the client-organization’s role within their respective supply – chain.
Disclaimers: (1) herein, we reiterate that any suggestion or opinion that the assessment team expresses does not construe to be a contractual
requirement. (2) The degree of certainty in conclusions increases by the competence of the assessment team as well as the attestation within the
assessment protocol, values, mission and vision under which we operate for the protection of consumers, still remains a certain level of uncertainty.
Strength: Weakness
Management commitment Inventory control
action Request Type I Form-008 – as we indicate and that each of the RA addresses the basic four (4) questions
as seen in Form-008:N/A
action Request Type II Form-008 – as we indicate and that each of the AR addresses the basic four (4) questions
as seen in Form-008:
TTG‐08‐2016: No customer feedback observed, as Iran’s regulation, company can not sale before IMED certificate, so customer
feedback analysis is not possible
END of REPORT