Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
THE OUTLOOK
INTELLIGENCE FOR THE INDIVIDUAL INVESTOR
While the cloud of trade weighs on the industries of specialty and multiline retail
market, the U.S. consumer is doing A-OK. shouldn’t be ignored. They may not
Consumer confidence is near a 17-year high, contribute significantly to the Retail index,
unemployment is at an 18-year low, wages but as individual stocks they have been a
are moving higher (even if slowly) and bright spot in a sea of volatility.
spending has ensued. Retail sales increased Several of the traditional retailers have
0.8% in May, from April, which was the fastest jumped 20% or more in 2018. Macy’s (M 39
rate of growth since November. In response, ***) has been the comeback kid of the group,
retail stocks have been rewarded. The S&P advancing 54.3% year-to-date. Kohl’s (KSS 77
500 Retail index advanced 9% from the end ***) is 38.9% higher, Tiffany’s (TIF 135 ***) is
of March to the end of May and has continued 30.9% higher, Advanced Auto Parts (AAP 140
***) is up 38.7% and Foot Locker (FL 57 ***)
to move higher in June at an elevated pace.
is up 19.5%. If you want to expand outside of
On a year-to-date basis, the Retail index is
the S&P 500 Retail index, Abercrombie &
30.7% higher, well ahead of the 3.5% increase
Fitch (ANF 28 ***) and Dillard’s (DDS 98 ***)
for the S&P 500.
are 25-55% higher on the year.
Of course, Amazon and Netflix account for
In general, retail stocks started the year
more than 80% of the 30.7% Retail index
flying high, and reacted well to strong fourth-
increase. TripAdvisor (TRIP 57 **) and
quarter earnings. Consumers ramped up
Booking Holdings (BKNG 2,122 ***) are not
holiday spending in anticipation of tax reform
What’s Inside your typical retailers, but their 71.6% and
benefits and retail sales soared. Then, the
Intelligencer 2 23.1% advances year-to-date account for
consumer pulled-back on spending in the
Fund Strategies 3 about 5% of the gain in the retail index.
first quarter, which is not unusual, but the
That being said, big moves by some
Sub-Industry Outlook 4
traditional retailers suggest the sub- (Continued on page 8)
Focus Stock of the Week 5
Master List Portfolio 6 RECOMMENDED RETAILERS
Top 10 Model Portfolio 7 Y/Y EPS Y/Y SALES
12-MONTH GROWTH (%) GROWTH (%) PRICE SHORT FWD P/E
Observatory 8 RECENT TARGET PERF INTEREST MULTIPLE
COMPANY NAME / TICKER STARS PRICE ($) PRICE ($) 2018E 2017 2018E 2017 YTD (%) (%) (X)
Amazon / AMZN 4 1,730 1,800 197 -11.1 33.5 30.8 48.3 1.2 138.8
Follow our experts on Twitter:
Dollar General / DG 4 99 122 33.9 3.2 8.4 6.8 4.8 1.8 16.2
@cfraresearch Dollar Tree / DLTR 4 86 105 13.6 33.2 3.0 7.4 -18.7 2.4 15.6
@StovallCFRA Home Depot / HD 4 200 227 27.8 16.7 7.0 6.7 5.1 0.8 21.0
@ToddCFRA LKQ Corporation / LKQ 4 32 35 20.4 4.4 21.8 13.4 -19.3 1.8 14.4
@LBellCFRA
Netflix / NFLX 4 415 465 129.8 201.6 37.7 32.4 111.0 4.7 145.1
@KesslerCFRA
@GlickmanCFRA Tractor Supply / TSCO 4 78 85 24.4 1.6 6.5 7.0 1.2 6.1 18.7
Sources: CFRA, powered by data from S&P Global. All growth, short interest, price performance and multiple data as of June 19.
2 THE OUTLOOK JUNE 25, 2018 CFRAOutlook.com
for Tractor Supply (TSCO 78 ****) by $10 to $85, a forward P/E of 18.9X against our Copyright © 2018 CFRA. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part prohibited except by
newly-initiated 2019 EPS estimate of $4.49. With 2018 now about halfway over, permission. Because of the possibility of human or
mechanical error by CFRA and its data sources, CFRA
we think it’s appropriate to push our valuation out to base it on '19 EPS. This does not guarantee the accuracy, adequacy, or
multiple is slightly above the peer median, reflecting likely faster-than-peer completeness of any information and is not
responsible for any errors or omissions or for the
revenue and EPS growth. It is also in the middle of TSCO's ten-year P/E range. We results obtained from the use of such information.
are encouraged by the progress TSCO is making in leveraging its existing store
base, expanding e-commerce and emphasizing its omni-channel offering as nearly 70% of total online orders are now being
fulfilled at company stores. We are also encouraged by stronger-than-expected Q1 same-store-sales growth of 3.7%.
CHANGING OF THE DOW: Walgreens Boots Alliance (WBA 68 ****) will replace General Electric (GE 13 ***) in the Dow Jones
Industrial Average, effective prior to the open of trading on Tuesday, June 26, 2018. “General Electric was an original member
of the DJIA in 1896 and a member continuously since 1907,” says David Blitzer, Managing Director and Chairman of the index
committee at S&P Dow Jones Indices. “Since then the U.S. economy has changed: consumer, finance, health care and
technology companies are more prominent today and the relative importance of industrial companies is less. Walgreens is a
national retail drug store chain offering prescription and non-prescription drugs, related health services and general goods.
With its addition, the DJIA will be more representative of the consumer and health care sectors of the U.S. economy. This
change to the DJIA will make the index a better measure of the economy and the stock market.”
SUPREME COURT TAX RULING: By a split 5-to-4 decision, the U.S. Supreme Court rules that states can collect sales taxes from
online retailers. After some related controversies over the past several years, the highly anticipated ruling is only mildly
surprising to us, setting another precedent that effectively overturned the court's prior ruling in 1992 that barred states from
collecting such taxes. On face value, the ruling might raise the specter of potential negative implications for Amazon (AMZN
1,730 ****), which recently accounted for about 44% of the U.S. e-commerce market and an even more dominant 70% of
overall e-commerce growth. Still, we see a relatively limited exposure for AMZN, which already collects a sizable amount of
sales taxes across many states where it qualifies as taxable due to its sufficiently large physical presence. Thus, AMZN is
unlikely to cede a meaningful portion of its market share to traditional retailers as a result of the ruling, in our view.
EVALUATION SYMBOLS Hold—Total return is expected to closely approximate S&P Global Market Intelligence’s Quality Rank
the total return of a relevant benchmark over the
STARS Rankings coming 12 months, with shares generally rising in S&P Global Market Intelligence’s appraisals of the growth and
price on an absolute basis. stability of earnings and dividends over the past 10 years for STARS
CFRA’s evaluation of the 12-month potential of stocks is indicated and other companies are indicated by Quality Rankings:
by STARS:
Sell—Total return is expected to underperform the
total return of a relevant benchmark over the coming A+ Highest B+ Average C Lowest
12 months, and the share price is not anticipated to A High B Below Avg. D In reorganization
Strong Buy—Total return is expected to outperform show a gain. A- Above Avg. B- Lower NR Not Ranked
the total return of a relevant benchmark by a wide
margin over the coming 12 months, with shares
Strong Sell—Total return is expected to underperform Quality Rankings are not intended to predict stock price movements.
the total return of a relevant benchmark by a wide
rising in price on an absolute basis. margin over the coming 12 months, with shares
Buy—Total return is expected to outperform the total falling in price on an absolute basis.
return of a relevant benchmark over the coming NR Not Ranked
12 months, with shares rising in price on an
absolute basis.
CFRAOutlook.com THE OUTLOOK JUNE 25, 2018 3
FUND
STRATEGIES
With a favorable ruling from U.S. the floodgates of M&A activity in the deals that closed in 2017.”
District Judge Richard Leon and media industry in the latter part of In addition, the total value of
AT&T’s subsequent acquisition of 2018 and beyond.” However, the global M&A transactions has
Time Warner on June 14, M&A has media industry has not been the increased year over year, with a
officially been brought into the only area of M&A activity so far this greater number of $5 billion-plus
spotlight once again. According to year. In fact, according to S&P Global transactions propelling growth in
CFRA Equity Analyst Tuna Amobi, Market Intelligence data, “fourteen first-quarter announced deal value.
CFA, CPA, “the compelling judicial U.S. equity issuance transactions of Global M&A is also expected to rise
precedent on the AT&T/Time Warner at least $1 billion closed in the first to a peak of $3.2 trillion in 2018,
ruling could foster a more favorable quarter 2018, putting the year on according to a report by Baker
regulatory backdrop that could open pace to exceed the 27 $1 billion-plus McKenzie and Oxford Economics.
As with many investment investment approach. Permian Basin, where CFRA Equity
strategies, to get exposure to the Here we look at two funds in the Analyst Stewart Glickman, CFA,
mergers and acquisitions trend M&A sphere: one ETF and one mutual believes there are even more
without going after individual deals, fund. consolidation opportunities.
investors can look to some fund The IQ Arbitrage ETF (MNA), by Westchester Capital’s The Merger
options. However, the long-short MainStay Investments, has Fund (MERFX) is a mutual fund that
strategy funds that offer this approximately 75% country allocation also has about 75% regional
exposure typically have higher fees, to the U.S. As of May 31, MNA’s five- exposure to the U.S. Year to date
less liquidity and greater risk year annualized total return was through June 15, MERFX had a
compared to most other funds. 3.88%, underperforming its trailing total return of 5.33% versus
CFRA does not rate long-short underlying index by 73 basis points the 2.33% alternative event-driven
strategy funds (i.e., taking long due to its 0.77% expense ratio. peer average. Included in its top-five
positions in stocks that are expected However, its largest holding (8.51%) holdings is Rockwell Collins (COL 134
to increase in value and short is CFRA Buy-rated Andeavor (ANDV ***), which is being acquired by
positions in stocks that are expected 135 ****), which has entered into a United Technologies (UTX 123 ****),
to decrease in value). However, we definitive merger agreement with bringing together two aerospace
still conduct research on their record, Marathon Petroleum (MPC 72 ****). giants. COL is also the second largest
underlying holdings, costs and ANDV is crucially positioned in the holding for MNA, at 8.26%.
IQ Merger Arbitrage ETF / MNA NR 31 11/16/2009 1.12 2.42 3.75 0.77 558.29
The Merger Fund / MERFX NR 17 10/14/1982 6.02 2.56 2.78 1.43 1,150.10
Source: CFRA, powered by data from S&P Global. *Average annualized.
4 THE OUTLOOK JUNE 25, 2018 CFRAOutlook.com
SUB-
INDUSTRY
OUTLOOK
FOCUS
STOCK
The focus stock for the week ended The 2018 outlook for trading from equities (57.7% of total
June 24 is Morgan Stanley, which looks promising, with strong trading revenue) compared to fixed
carries CFRA's highest investment income, currency, commodities
recommendation of 5-STARS, or Morgan Stanley has (FICC) revenue at 43.3% in Q1 2018.
Strong Buy. MS is a global financial We like that MS has downsized its
services firm that provides a
transformed its FICC trading platform in the last 18
comprehensive suite of products to corporate profile to a months, which may limit exposure
a diverse group of clients and more reliable, steady to large trading losses.
customers, including corporations, growth company. Asset Regulatory reform tied to Dodd-
governments, financial institutions and wealth management Frank Stress Tests or the Volcker
and individuals. Rule could be a plus for MS trading
A core strategy is growing its
units along with investor revenue, in our view. While it may
Global Wealth Management Group services contribute to be too early to tell on proposed
(GWMG) business. This unit high recurring revenue changes to the Volcker Rule issued
accounted for 39.5% of total net and anchor the firm’s on May 30 by the Federal Reserve
revenues in Q1 2018, lower than more cyclical investment Bank, we expect greater clarity on
past quarters in the mid-40% the activities tied to market making
range. Institutional Securities, with
banking and trading versus proprietary trading.
strong trading, came in at 55.1%. areas. We look to return of capital as the
The remainder is Investment next major catalyst for MS, which is
Management (6.5%), for corporate equities reported in Q1 2018, while subject to the Fed stress tests to
and pension investors, as well as increased customer activity be released in late June. We are
Other (-1.1%). GWMG provides spurred higher trading in other confident MS will get approval of its
management services to clients areas. Compared to direct peers, plan and the consensus is
through a network of 15,712 global MS has one of the highest ratios of estimating a 24% dividend increase
representatives. The business total sales and trading revenue to in Q3 2018.
provides higher recurring fee total net revenue in Q1 2018, and Our 12-month target is $65,
revenue, low client turnover and the firm had a higher contribution applying a forward P/E of 13.8X our
available funds to realize 2018 EPS estimate and a price to
interest income. Morgan Stanley net tangible book value at 1.9X,
Morgan's Institutional both metrics at a premium to
Ticker: MS
Securities Group (ISG) includes direct peers. Our risk premium is
capital raising, financial Ranking: supported by strong execution and
advisory services, corporate consistency in performance, even
lending, financing and market- Recent Price: $50 with uncertainties regarding
making activities for equity and market volatility and customer
12-Month Target Price: $65
fixed-income securities. MS is activity.
well positioned to realize fee Market Capitalization ($B): 88.14 Risks to our recommendation
growth, often ranking #1 or #2 and target price include weaker
in M&A or equity underwriting. P/E Ratio: 10.6 client trading activity in equity and
We see market share gains with fixed income markets, a slower
Yield: 2.0%
many of the large European release of underwriting deals from
banks retrenching their Source: CFRA, powered by data from the investment bank's pipeline and
investment bank and trading S&P Global. geopolitical risks.
operations to home markets.
6 THE OUTLOOK JUNE 25, 2018 CFRAOutlook.com
Performance calculations for all model portfolios do not take into account capital gains taxes or brokerage commissions and fees. If the foregoing had been factored into the model
portfolio’s investment performance, it would have been lower. This performance calculation also does not take into account timing differences between the model portfolio selections and
purchases made based on those selection by actual investors. Over certain periods, the model portfolio incurred losses and over time the model portfolio is expected to continue to pose a
risk of negative investment returns. Because the model portfolio has a high turnover rate, it is best suited for tax-deferred accounts such as IRAs and is less suited for other accounts.
Investors should seek financial advice before investing based on the model portfolio. This model portfolio does not address the specific investment objectives, financial situation, and
particular needs of any person. Stocks in the model portfolio will not be suitable for all investors. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
The Observatory
Selected actions for June 15 to June 21
STARS 12-MONTH SPGMI’S
NEW OLD RANKING RECENT TARGET QUALITY FAIR VALUE
COMPANY NAME / SYMBOL STARS STARS DATE PRICE ($) PRICE ($) RANKING RANK
S&P GLOBAL™ is used under license. The owner of this trademark is S&P Global Inc. or its affiliate, which are not affiliated with CFRA Research or the author of this content.
The Observatory provides a selection of analytical actions — upgrades, downgrades, initiations — from CFRA Equity Research Services. Stocks featured in the Observatory are
selected by The Outlook according to factors including, but not limited to, newsworthiness, capitalization, and inclusion in a model portfolio published by The Outlook. For all STARS
changes in real time, go to CFRAOutlook.com. Please note that all investments carry risks. Investors should seek financial advice before investing.
All of the views expressed in this research report accurately reflect the research analysts’ personal views regarding any and all of the subject securities or issuers. No part of the
analysts’ compensation was, is, or will be, directly or indirectly, related to the specific recommendations or views expressed in this research report.