Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
WEARABLE DIALYSIS
DEVICE
Report No: 006/2016
MaHTAS
Medical Development Division
Ministry of Health, Malaysia
Prepared by:
Maria Jaafar
B. Pharm (Hons), M. Med. Sc. (Pharm. Tech.)
Pharmacist/Principal Assistant Director
Health Technology Assessment Section (MaHTAS)
Medical Development Division
Ministry of Health Malaysia
Reviewed by:
1|Page
PD, Automated Wearable Artificial
Kidney or AWAK, and Mobilysis) (Table
1 at Appendix 1).8-10
WEARABLE HAEMODIALYSIS
DEVICE
2|Page
Figure 3 (Appendix 2) showed how wetness sensors were applied to both
WAK works. The patient’s blood is the arterial and venous access
drawn and flow through a double lumen connections to detect any leakage in the
catheter (red) and circulate through the system. The pulsatile blood pump also
blood channel of the WAK pump (grey) had a self-limited capacity to generate
into the dialyser. The reservoir (white) negative pressure for suction from the
containing heparin, is used to arterial side of the vascular access
anticoagulate the blood in the catheter which may results in termination of the
by using battery-operated micro pump. blood pump if any disconnection on the
The blood then, returns to the venous arterial side occurred. The blood pump
side of the double lumen catheter (blue) also stops if any venous resistance
to the patient. During the process, the exist.16-17
clean dialysate (green) enters the
dialyser. The dialysate is infused with a
solution containing potassium, calcium, WEARABLE PERITONEAL DIALYSIS
and magnesium from another reservoir DEVICE
(black) by using a pump. The dialysate
in the dialyser flow countercurrently to a) Vicenza Wearable Artificial Kidney
the blood and exits (yellow) into the for Peritoneal Dialysis (ViWAK PD):
dialysate channel. After that, another
Vicenza Wearable Artificial Kidney for
pump removes a predetermined amount
Peritoneal Dialysis developed by AWAK
of the spent dialysate (yellow) into a
Technologies is a miniaturised system
collection bag. Next, the rest of the
for continuos-flow PD with capacity to
dialysate flow through a series of
regenerate spent dialysate. It weight just
sorbent (yellow) which consists of
about two pounds (~1 kg), small in size,
canisters that contained urease,
battery-operated and able to provide
zirconium phosphate, hydrous zirconium
effective recirculation of PD solution at a
oxide, and activated carbon. At the
rate of 20 ml/min for more than 12
same time, a solution containing sodium
hours. This system is meant to be an
bicarbonate from a reservoir (purple) is
alternative for continuous ambulatory
pumped and infused into the dialysate.
peritoneal dialysis (CAPD) and
Lastly, the clean dialysate then returns
automated peritoneal dialysis (APD) to
back to the dialyser (green) for the next
reduce the time consumption, the steps
process.15
of procedure and amount of solution
For safety reason, the WAK is equipped required to perform PD. The system is
with three sensors. Blood flow will based on a combination of a long
automatically stop once the sensor overnight dwell exchange and a
detected bubbles in the blood circuit. continuos-flow PD during the day
Another sensor is to stop the performed with a special catheter and a
ultrafiltration pump if the patients’ blood special minicycler which utilised a
flow stopped for any reason. Special
3|Page
mixture of sorbents to regenerate the equilibration is obtained in the remaining
PD solution.8,18,19 indwelling solution. Glucose is optionally
added to the peritoneal cavity to achieve
The ViWAK PD system consists of:8,18 ultrafiltration if needed through a line
A double lumen peritoneal connected to a small reservoir which is
catheter located on the belt. Patient may activate
A dialysate outflow line this function via handheld computer.
After 2 hours, the fluid is drained and 2
A miniaturised rotary pump
litre of icodextrin exchange is performed
A circuit for dialysate
overnight to achieve further
regeneration featuring a
ultrafiltration. The clearance is further
waterproof container with four
increased by the 2 litre exchange and
cartridges in parallel with a
the overnight exchange.
mixture of activated carbon and
polystyrenic resins The system operates 24 hr/day and
A filter for deaeration and provides creatinine and β2 microglobulin
microbiological safety clearance in the range of 15-16
A dialysate inflow line litres/day, corresponding to a weekly
A handheld computer as a clearance of 100-110 litres. The number
remote control of exchanges reduced when compared
to CAPD and uses less fluid than in
APD. Figure 5 showed the schematic
diagram of the ViWAK.18
4|Page
b) Automated Wearable Artificial back into the peritoneal cavity (Figure
kidney (AWAK):20,21 6).
5|Page
automated peritoneal dialysis
(APD). CAPD is a continuous,
machine free and done by holding
up plastic bag and cleansing fluid
to patients. Unfortunately,
peritonitis remains the major
complication of the PD technique in
spite of antibiotics creams applied
at the exit site. Furthermore,
patients have to spend time
performing their exchange three to
Figure 7: Mobilysis four exchanges per day with CAPD
or connect themselves to an
PATIENT GROUP AND automated overnight cycler or APD
(automated peritoneal dialysis)
INDICATION
which although transportable, still
The wearable dialysis device is meant requires a mains electrical supply
for patients who suffer from chronic and fresh dialysate, and they are
kidney disease requiring dialysis certainly not wearable.6,19
treatment.
Medications (to help with growth,
prevent bone density loss, and/or to
CURRENT PRACTICE treat anaemia)
The treatment of chronic renal failure
depends on the degree of kidney Diuretic therapy or medications (to
function which may include:5 increase urine output)
6|Page
EFFICACY pressure lower than 100 mmHg but one
patient had systolic blood pressure
a) WAK: lower than 120 mmHg. Individual Renal
A prospective, non-randomised, and Treatment Satisfaction Questionnaire
exploratory clinical trial (NCT02280005) (RTSQ) was used to assess the WAK
approved by FDA was conducted by treatment experience satisfaction
Gura V et al. involving seven subjects compared to conventional
where only five of them completed the haemodialysis treatment among the
24-hours treatment period.24 patients and the results showed that
satisfaction with WAK treatment was
The results showed the mean weighted- significantly higher (p<0.001) compared
average concentrations of blood urea to the conventional haemodialysis
nitrogen (BUN) during the 24 hours including satisfaction with treatment-
WAK treatment (17±5 mg/dL) were related side effects, convenience and
significantly lower compared to 48 hours flexibility of treatment, discomfort or pain
period before the WAK session where involved with treatment, and also
patients underwent conventional satisfaction with freedom during dialysis
haemodialysis treatment (39±18 mg/dL). treatment.24
The mean β2-microglobulin
concentrations was also significantly A pilot study was conducted by
lower during the WAK treatment (17±8 Armignacco P et al. in 2007 to analyse
mg/l) when compared to periods of the performance of WAK. The study
conventional haemodialysis (22±11 which was approved by the UK
mg/l). Conversely, the mean serum Medicines Health Regulation Authority
potassium (3.8±0.5 meq/l) and serum (MHRA) involved eight patients with
phosphate (3.1±0.5 mg/dl) concentration CKD who were treated with regular
were increased after 24 hours WAK haemodialysis three times a week.
treatment (3.9±0.4 meq/l and 3.9±0.8 Since the efficacy of WAK had not been
mg/dl respectively). The acid-base and established, the MHRA requested that
electrolyte homeostasis was found to be the treatment using WAK should not
maintained during the study without replace patients’ standard intermittent
patients’ dietary restriction and haemodialysis treatment. Thereby, fluid
phosphorus-binding medications intake. removal to achieve target postdialysis
Mean BUN, creatinine, phosphorus, and weight was not set as the objective of
β2-microglobulin clearance during the this study.7,16
trial were 17±10, 16±8, 15±9 and 5±4 Patients’ blood oxygen saturation and
ml/min which were close concordance of the cardiac cycle were monitored
blood-based and dialysate-based continuously. Patients’ weight before
measurements of solute clearance.24 and after treatment was recorded and
From the study, no patient was biochemical test was also done. 7,16
observed to experience systolic blood
7|Page
The MHRA has determined that SAFETY
between two and four patients, the WAK
treatment should be performed up to a) WAK:
four hours only. The treatment were The non-randomised study conducted
allowed to be extended up to eight by Gura et al. portrayed that the device
hours after the first phase completed performed well with no serious
and no major adverse events observed. complication as there were no evidence
The mean blood flow and dialysate flow of saturation with uraemic solute but the
during the treatment was 58.6 (11.7) trial was stopped after the seventh
ml/min and 47.1 (7.8) ml/min subject due to device-related technical
respectively and the results showed that problems such as excessive carbon
the device performed well in removing dioxide bubbles in the dialysate circuit.
fluid with no cardiovascular adverse Two subjects needed lithium ion battery
event, no changes in ECG as well as replacement before the 24 hours
serum electrolytes and acid-base treatment completed and three subjects
balance. During the study, patients had required gas bubbles removal from the
no difficulty to sleep and no time taken circuit.24
to recover after completing the
treatment. 7,16 One subject was discontinued treatment
after four hours due to clotting of the
blood circuit. Another subject was
b) ViWAK PD discontinued treatment after 10 hours
due to pink discolouration of dialysate.24
A conceptual proposals for ViWAK PD
was put up but no clinical trials have There was no serious adverse events
been conducted.18,25 reported such as significant changes in
serum haptoglobin, lactate
dehydrogenase or haematocrit which
may indicate significant haemolysis. The
c) AWAK tolerability was good except two
A proof of concept test was done where subjects experienced mild muscle
ninety successful PD session ranging cramping, one subject experienced a
from 4 to 24 hours each were conducted brief episode of nausea, one had an
in 20 male patients using a single-lumen episode of diarrhea on the day following
catheter either by conventional in-and- treatment and one subject encountered
out or a tidal PD dialysate flow pattern. moderate malaise after discontinuation
One patient was maintained on this of the treatment. However, all seven
sorbent regeneration system for two subjects were able to ambulate while
months.20 receiving WAK treatment.24
8|Page
seven hours and four hours respectively According to a study conducted by
as both patients were not receiving Mushi L et al the cost of dialysis in
adequate anticoagulants at that time. Malaysia was estimated as RM 79.61 to
One patient encountered fistula needles RM 475.79 per HD treatment (mean
dislodgement and the built-in safety cost: RM169/HD) and RM 1,400 to RM
mechanism had stopped the blood 3,200/patient/month for CAPD treatment
pump during the incident. Patient was (mean cost: RM 2186/patient/month).27
temporarily disconnected but the needle
was quickly reinserted and the treatment ORGANIZATIONAL ISSUES
was continued smoothly. 7,16,17,26
Training on managing wearable dialysis
device should be provided to the
healthcare provider that will be involved
b) AWAK
in this device-based intervention as they
A sorbent-based assembly in AWAK may need to advise and guide patients
device which regenerates both the in performing their own dialysis at home
aqueous and the protein components or work place.
(AqC and PrC) of the spent dialysate is AWAK needs no purchase, construction
considered as a novel, autologous and maintenance of physical facilities
protein-containing dialysate. The AWAK and equipment and also expected to
has capacity to regenerate AqC which minimise professional personnel
have similar composition with involvement as patients may perform
commercially available peritoneal dialysis process themselves.20
dialysate, but contains bicarbonate
instead of lactate and has slightly higher POTENTIAL IMPACT
pH value (pH: 6.5-7.0) compared to
commercial dialysate (pH:5.0-5.5). For WAK is an innovative device that allow
regenerated PrC, it is recycled back into patients to have dialysis treatment
the peritoneal cavity to rehabilitate or anywhere 24 hours per day. Since the
eliminate protein loss (Table 6).20,21 function mimics the natural kidney, this
new device may have potential in
The regenerated dialysate that is providing patients with freedom to work
sterilised through the filter-sterilisation
and perform their daily activities while
before being infused into patients has
been tested and the results were dialysing.6,17
negative in culture and pyrogen free.20
Improvement in size and weight of
WAK prototype in the future will make
ESTIMATED COST this device more convenient for patients
The actual cost implication of wearable to wear it consistently. In terms of
dialysis device is not known yet. safety, there was no serious adverse
However, it was postulated this new events during the treatment reported in
device will reduce the overall cost.20 the published studies.
9|Page
A PD system using concept of recycles REFERENCES
dialysate, and less frequency of
exchanges, connections/ disconnections 1. National Kidney Foundation.
of catheter, and a continuous closed PD K/DOQI Clinical Practice Guidelines
system could potentially reduce the risk for Chronic Kidney Disease:
Evaluation, Classification and
of peritonitis. In combination with a
Stratification. 2002. Available from:
nighttime 7.5% icodextrin exchange, this https://www.kidney.org/sites/default/
system may provide patients daytime files/docs/ckd_evaluation_classificat
freedom from exchanges while ensuring ion_stratification.pdf. Accessed on 9
adequate ultrafiltration and the November 2016.
maintenance of electrolyte and acid-
base balance.6,19,20,25 2. Gura V, Rivara MB, Bieber S et al.
A wearable artificial kidney for
The ViWAK PD and AWAK also may patients with end-stage renal
have potential to reduce the cost of disease. JCI Insight. 2016:1(8).
dialysis fluid by fluid regeneration to 3. Thomas B, Wulf S, Bikbov B et al.
remove toxic products, and offer the Maintenance dialysis throughout the
major prospect of increasing the world in years 1990 and 2010.
efficiency of PD. However, the devices Journal of the American Society of
are still in early development stage and Nephrology. 2015:ASN-2014101017
not much been studied.18,20
4. Clinical Practice Guidelines:
In general, these wearable dialysis Management of Chronic Kidney
devices may possibly reduce the needs Disease in Adults. Ministry of
Health, Malaysia. June 2011.
for dialysis centre as well as minimise
Available from
the healthcare professional involvement http://www.moh.gov.my/attachments
as patients may perform the dialysis on /CPG%202014/Kidney01.pdf
their own. Besides, these devices also
relatively require less storage space for 5. BL Goh, LM Ong and YN Lim (Eds).
supplies. Moreover, not as kidney 22nd Report of the Malaysian
transplantation, patients do not need Dialysis and Transplant Registry
2014. The National Renal Registry,
anti-rejection treatment and medications
Malaysia Society of Nephrology.
to improve the side effects. All these Kuala Lumpur, 2015. Available
potentials are likely to benefit patients from: http://www.msn.org.my.
and society, however, further study and Accessed on 9 November 2016.
clinical trial need to be conducted to
prove the effectiveness and safety of the 6. Davenport A. Portable and wearable
dialysis devices for the treatment of
devices comprehensively.18,20
patients with end-stage kidney
failure: Wishful thinking or just over
the horizon?. Pediatric Nephrology.
2015;30(12):2053-2060.
10 | P a g e
7. Armignacco P, Lorenzin A, Neri M 14. Nephrology nursing and the
et al. Wearable devices for blood wearable artificial kidney. Available
purification: Principles, from
miniaturization, and technical http://www.nephrologynews.com/ne
challenges. In Seminars in dialysis phrology-nursing-and-the-wearable-
2015; 28(2):125-130. artificial-kidney/. Accessed on 9
September 2016
8. Shin SJ. Current status of
bioartificial kidney. Journal of 15. Gura V, Macy AS, Beizai M et al.
Biomedical Science and Technical breakthroughs in the
Engineering. 2014;2014. wearable artificial kidney (WAK).
Clinical Journal of the American
9. Armignacco P, Garzotto F, Neri M et Society of Nephrology.
al. WAK engineering evolution. 2009;4(9):1441-1448.
Blood purification. 2015;39(1-
3):110-114. 16. Davenport A, Gura V, Ronco C et
al. A wearable haemodialysis device
10. Ronco C, Davenport A, Gura V. The for patients with end-stage renal
future of the artificial kidney: moving failure: a pilot study. The Lancet.
towards wearable and miniaturized 2007;370(9604):2005-2010.
devices. Nefrología (Madrid).
2011;31:9-16. 17. Gura V, Ronco C, Nalesso F et al. A
wearable hemofilter for continuous
11. FDA approves trial for wearable ambulatory ultrafiltration. Kidney
artificial kidney. Available from international. 2008;73(4):497-502.
http://www.nephrologynews.com/fda
-approves-trial-for-wearable- 18. Ronco C, Fecondini L. The Vicenza
artificial-kidney/. Accessed on: 22 wearable artificial kidney for
peritoneal dialysis (ViWAK PD).
July 2016
Blood purification. 2007;25(4):383-
12. FAQ: Seattle Wearable Artificial 388.
Kidney safety trial. Answers to
common questions about the WAK 19. Davenport A. Portable or wearable
and its initial testing. Available from peritoneal devices–the next step
http://hsnewsbeat.uw.edu/story/faq- forward for peritoneal dialysis. Adv
seattle-wearable-artificial-kidney- Perit Dial. 2012;28:97-101.
safety-trial. Accessed on: 22 July
2016 20. Lee DB, Roberts M. A peritoneal-
based automated wearable artificial
13. Miniature Portable Dialysis Machine kidney. Clinical and experimental
on Fast Track for FDA Approval. nephrology. 2008;12(3):171-180.
Available from
http://www.industrytap.com/miniatur 21. Fissell WH, Roy S, Davenport A.
e-portable-dialysis-machine-fast- Achieving more frequent and longer
track-fda-approval/23979. Accessed dialysis for the majority: wearable
on 11 July 2016 dialysis and implantable artificial
11 | P a g e
kidney devices. Kidney
international. 2013;84(2):256-264.
12 | P a g e
Appendix 1
13 | P a g e
Appendix 2
14 | P a g e