Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 1

The Chief Engineer (O&M) T&G,

LESCO Headquarters Lahore.


Subject: DEFENCE REPLY TO THE FINAL SHOWCAUSE UNDER RULE-5(IV) OF
PAKISTAN WAPDA EMPLOYEES E&D RULES-1978.

Respected Sir,

I hereby submit my defence reply to the final show cause notice issued to me by your good office under letter
no. HRD/HRM/CONFD:/E-3239, and I implore you to consider following points.

1) I have been served a show cause notice because according to you the protection relays installed at
Transformer T3 the 132KV Bhai Pheru Grid station did not operate, however, as I have mentioned in
my earlier defense reply, PROTECTION RELAYS(Over current/earth fault, differential, transformer
tap changer,oil winding) OF THE TRANSFORMER DID OPERATE, AS ENDORSED IN THE ENTRY IN THE
P&I REGISTER MADE ON THE DATE OF THE INCIDENT BY THE ADDITIONAL DEPUTY MANAGER P&I.
(COPY ATTACHED)
2) Relays installed on the lines need not operate because the level of the current did not reach the
certain threshold required for their working. Protection relays installed on the lines also did not
operate from the far end. It is pertinent to point out here that two different power houses feed the
grid. Had the fault current exceeded the level of threshold required for the relays to operate, the
circuit must have tripped from the far end as well. As it did not happen, it is certain that the current
did not exceed the required limit for the operation of the relays installed at the lines.
3) According to the eye witnesses of the incident, there was heavy sparking, after which fire erupted
out. I would like to point out that the incoming of the said transformer was not properly grounded by
the GSC staff after they had changed the incoming, and the heavy spark was the result of that. It was
due to the ungrounded incoming that fire erupted. The protection system of the transformer was
intact.

In the light of above mentioned points I request you to please exonerate me of all the charges leveled against
me.

It is further requested that I want to be heard in person as well.

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi