Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
A novel perspective to bitumen refineries life cycle assessment and processes emissions
Saeed Morsali
Gazi University, Faculty of Applied Science, Department of Environmental Science, Ankara, Turkey
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: This study provides an introduction and a novel view of the impacts of oil refineries industry on human health,
Received 16 February 2017 ecosystem quality and resources. The scope and issues for dealing with these challenges are rather wide and com-
Received in revised form 27 July 2017 plex because the Oil refineries are complex facilities. Several processes, such as distillation, vacuum distillation, or
Accepted 7 August 2017
steam reforming are required to produce a large variety of oil products such as gasoline, light fuel oil or bitumen.
Available online xxxx
The goals, perspectives and expectation for the environmental practice and control have changed dramatically
Keywords:
over the last couple of decades. Hence the required approach has to be multidisciplinary, based on established
Bitumen refinery LCA scientific concepts and sound engineering principles. The environmental impacts of oil refineries are assessed
Bitumen refineries emissions using the technique of life cycle assessment (LCA). In this paper, only the material production phase of the bitu-
Damage assessment of bitumen refineries men LCA is considered. To improve the quality of the LCA, a regionalized life cycle inventory (LCI) database for the
Environmental loads of bitumen LCA Oil refineries and commercial LCI databases are used to validate and model unit processes with an LCA software.
© 2017 Published by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Ecological Society of China.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.chnaes.2017.08.005
1872-2032/© 2017 Published by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Ecological Society of China.
Please cite this article as: S. Morsali, A novel perspective to bitumen refineries life cycle assessment and processes emissions, Acta Ecologica Sinica
(2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.chnaes.2017.08.005
2 S. Morsali / Acta Ecologica Sinica xxx (2017) xxx–xxx
Additionally, the study comes from the United States and uses time se- waste and their further treatment are distinguished. The environmental
ries data that is from 1998 to 2008 respectively [8]. Another study that impacts modeled include energy consumption and greenhouse gas
follows the same energy input rubric is the study by Wang [9] “Alloca- (GHG) emissions from oil refineries.
tion of Energy Use in Petroleum Refineries to Petroleum Products” There are various LCA methodologies that can be applied. They have
that analyzes energy usage. The Wang study uses the same model as different impact categories they cover, moreover they use different
the Venkatesh study but it classifies the emissions by process which is methods to evaluation these impacts, various kind of indicators selec-
more clear, besides in this study the used data are from 1996 and tion, and in their geographical focus. In this paper we used Eco-indicator
1999 within the geographical boundaries of the US which are sort of 99 which includes 3 main impact categories;
old data. These studies are only focused on the CO2 emissions and are Human health: under this category, we include the number and du-
based solely on energy inputs, these studies neglect all other emissions. ration of diseases and life years lost due to premature death from envi-
They offer a small glimpse of how different fuel types produce different ronmental causes. The effects we include are climate change, ozone
emissions but are not inclusive of all processes within a refinery. These layer depletion. Carcinogenic effects, respiratory effects and ionizing
studies do not go into detail on petroleum processing, transportation (nuclear) radiation.
process, raw material extraction and waste flow over the bitumen Ecosystem quality: under this category, we include the effect on spe-
lifecycle. In this study, the analysis leads to product specific allocation cies diversity, especially for vascular plants and lower organisms. The ef-
factors for energy, airborne and waterborne pollutants. Furthermore fects we include are Ecotoxicity, acidification, eutrophication and land-
working material consumption, additive requirements, production use.
waste, and infrastructure, the most important emissions and processes Resources: under this category, we include the surplus energy need-
are given by their impacts values. ed in the future to extract lower quality mineral and fossil resources.
The depletion of agricultural and bulk resources as sand and gravel is
2. Methods and inventory analysis considered under land use.
The purpose of this paper is to analyze petroleum refining and its im- 2.2. System boundaries
pacts on the environment. Many factors contribute to the consumption
patterns of bitumen including price, government legislation, infrastruc- The model describes the production of oil products for energetic and
ture, technology among others. Production can be just as affected by partly non-energetic uses and the production of thermal energy and
those factors but also by others such as labor strife, dwindling petro- electricity in Switzerland and Western Europe. The inventory tables
leum reserves, worldwide market price, profitability, seasonal demand for oil products include oil field exploration, crude oil production,
and much more [8]. long-distance transportation, oil refining, regional distribution and the
use of oil products in domestic and industrial boilers, in power plants
2.1. LCA methodology and in spark ignition engines (of trucks, personal cars, excavator, loco-
motives, and ships).
As mentioned LCA is a system for collating and determining the en- This study covers the bitumen production chain, starting from raw
vironmental loads of a product, service or a process through its full life material extraction and ending with a bitumen product ready for deliv-
cycle, from cradle to grave. In international standardization, ISO 14040 ery to a customer. The process is divided into four stages: crude oil ex-
series promote LCA as a technique to better understand and address traction, transport, production, and storage. A schematic description of
the possible environmental impacts associated with products (includ- the system boundary is given in Fig. 2.
ing services) [10]. ISO 14040 defines the principles and framework of
LCA, and ISO 14044 gives more detailed requirements and guidelines 2.3. Inventory data
[10].
SimaPro is the most widely used LCA software. It has unique features Inventory data for this study is taken from commercial Simapro 7.1
such as parameterized modeling and interactive results analysis. It uses program database and the oil fuel chain, in particular, is divided into
many LCA methods as well as databases to modeling a product based on the following process steps:
real experiments from Europe and USA. In this novel, we used a com-
mercial version of SimaPro 7.1 to validate the results. Unlike the men- • Oil field exploration: Include emissions caused by drilling activities,
tioned studies in this paper, all airborne, waterborne and emissions to barite and bentonite consumption and the emissions of oily drilling
the soil were listed based on the procedures. Database for emission fac- fluids into the sea (emission data for North Sea exploration is used).
tors for the Swiss and for the average Western European refinery are • Crude oil production: The variation in drilling efforts and energy con-
used. Airborne emissions comprise CO, CO2, SO2, NOX, particulate mat- sumption per barrel oil extracted from different regions is modeled.
ter, hydrocarbons (specified), acids and heavy metals (specified). Wa- • Long distance transportation: Distance is used according to the specif-
terborne pollutants comprise hydrocarbons (specified), and inorganic ic supply situation of Switzerland and Western Europe.
substances (sulfates, phosphates and nitrate). Different production • Oil refining
Please cite this article as: S. Morsali, A novel perspective to bitumen refineries life cycle assessment and processes emissions, Acta Ecologica Sinica
(2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.chnaes.2017.08.005
S. Morsali / Acta Ecologica Sinica xxx (2017) xxx–xxx 3
• Regional distribution: Regional distribution includes storage in large Fig. 3 shows the weighting analysis result for three main impact cat-
stock and the supply to the costumer. The requirements and emis- egories, as it is clear the resources impact category has the highest value.
sions during the regional distribution are considered. The infrastruc- It means in the bitumen refinery LCA resources category is the critical
ture and the energy consumption for the movement of goods, category. For the overall analysis which includes all subcategories
production waste and hydrocarbon emissions are included. Fig. 4 was given.
• Fuel oil boilers: Three different sizes of boilers are considered, namely Fig. 4 represents all subcategories weighting analysis with Pt unit,
10KW, 100KW and 1 MW and also manufacturing of boilers including according to this figure, in bitumen life cycle, fossil fuels, respiratory or-
tank room and the chimney is considered. ganics and climate change have the highest impact value.
2.4.1. Resources
2.4. Weighting Analysis of 1-ton bitumen production Mankind will always extract the best resources first, leaving the
lower quality resources for future extraction. The damage of resources
Eco-indicator 99 allows comparing the impact categories since they will be experienced by future generations, as they will have to use
have different units. This means that the impact category is divided by more effort to extract remaining resources. This extra effort is expressed
the reference. A commonly used reference is the average yearly envi- as “surplus energy”.
ronmental load in a country or continent, divided by the number of in- As the Fig. 3 shows the highest impact category is the resources cat-
habitants. However, the reference may be chosen freely. We could also egory. Throughout the bitumen cradle to grave period any fossil fuel
choose the environmental load of lighting a 60 W bulb for 1 h, 100 km of consumption would be considered in this category since the bitumen
transport by car or 1 l of milk [8×]. This can be useful to communicate directly related to oil production it is reasonable that fossil fuels catego-
the results to non LCA experts, as you benchmark your own LCA against ry will have the highest impacts among all subcategories. Estimating all
something everybody can imagine. Simapro uses Pt unit to show these the processes which involve fossil fuels usage required more detailed
impacts. The Pt unit used in eco indicator method defined as a dimen- study which is quite impossible to discuss in this study, however, for
sionless value. The value of 1 Pt means one thousandth of the yearly en- the resources category Table 1 have been listed. This table shows the
vironmental load of one average European inhabitant. priority of the process which has significant environmental loads.
Please cite this article as: S. Morsali, A novel perspective to bitumen refineries life cycle assessment and processes emissions, Acta Ecologica Sinica
(2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.chnaes.2017.08.005
4 S. Morsali / Acta Ecologica Sinica xxx (2017) xxx–xxx
Table 1 shows processes which effect on resources during bitumen Damage to human health expressed as the number of year life lost
lifecycle, the unit used for this table is MJ surplus which explained ear- and the number of years lived disabled. These are combined as Disability
lier. According to this table crude oil production has the highest value in Adjusted Life Years (DALYs), an index that is also used by the World
resources impact category. Bank and the WHO [4].
Table 2 listed most important processes which cause a different kind
2.4.2. Human health of disease, all these processes have the certain effect on human health
As it explained already human health impact category has different during bitumen lifecycle. Diesel in diesel generator onshore, Petroleum
kind of subcategories which all consider a various type of disease due gas flaring and Residual oil in the refinery are the most important pro-
to bitumen production and consumption uses. cesses in the human health category. During all these steps various sub-
stances release to the environment, Table 3 shows these substances.
• Carcinogens: Carcinogenic effects due to emissions of carcinogenic Table 3 shows most important emissions from bitumen lifecycle as-
substances to air, water and soil. sessment, Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) are a family of gases that can cause a
• Respiratory organics: Respiratory effects resulting from summer number of serious health effects. One form of NOx, nitrogen dioxide, is
smog, due to emissions of organic substances to air, causing respirato- unhealthy to breathe, especially for children, the elderly, asthmatics
ry effects. and people with the chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. NOx is
• Respiratory inorganics: Respiratory effects resulting from winter also a key component to the formation of ozone and photochemical ox-
smog caused by emissions of dust, sulfur and nitrogen oxides to air. idants. Breathing low levels of ozone, for example, can trigger asthma
• Climate change Damage: expressed in DALY/kg emission, resulting attacks and other problems for people with pre-existing respiratory
from an increase of diseases and death caused by climate change. problems [11]. These tiny particles cause effects on breathing and the
• Radiation Damage: expressed in DALY/kg emission, resulting from ra- respiratory system, damage to lung tissue, and even premature death.
dioactive radiation This gas releases from fossil fuels burning.
• Ozone layer Damage: expressed in DALY/kg emission, due to in-
creased UV radiation as a result of emission of ozone depleting sub- Table 2
stances to air Processes which effect human health during bitumen lifecycle.
Please cite this article as: S. Morsali, A novel perspective to bitumen refineries life cycle assessment and processes emissions, Acta Ecologica Sinica
(2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.chnaes.2017.08.005
S. Morsali / Acta Ecologica Sinica xxx (2017) xxx–xxx 5
Table 3 Table 5
Emissions from bitumen life cycle assessment cause diseases. Damage assessment of 1-ton bitumen production and substances which effect on ecosys-
tem quality.
No Substance Compartment Unit Bitumen
refinery No Substance Compartment Unit Bitumen refinery
Please cite this article as: S. Morsali, A novel perspective to bitumen refineries life cycle assessment and processes emissions, Acta Ecologica Sinica
(2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.chnaes.2017.08.005
6 S. Morsali / Acta Ecologica Sinica xxx (2017) xxx–xxx
[8] R. OBorn, From Ground to Gate: A Lifecycle Assessment of Petroleum Processing Ac- [10] H. Lehtinen, A. Saarentaus, J. Rouhiainen, M. Michael Pitts, A. Azapagic, A Review of
tivities in the United Kingdom, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, LCA Methods and Tools and Their Suitability for SMEs, 2011.
2012. [11] https://www.sei-international.org/gapforum/policy/effectshumanhealth.php.
[9] M. Wang, H. Lee, J. Molburg, Allocation of energy use in petroleum refineries to pe-
troleum products: implications for life-cycle energy use and emission inventory of
petroleum transportation fuels, Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 1 (9) (2003) 34–44.
Please cite this article as: S. Morsali, A novel perspective to bitumen refineries life cycle assessment and processes emissions, Acta Ecologica Sinica
(2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.chnaes.2017.08.005