Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Agostinho PDF
Agostinho PDF
)A6(7;B;6(CDDE(;B;7=F9;B 409
!"#$%!&$ #'"($%)%!%)*+,!-.$%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
,$/$%+/%0)"1/)"$%*'2'"$
RESUMO
T( :1':'-H'4( 3'( :1)-)3H)( H)UH'4( )U:'1( $,O"I$-( 1)V)UW)-( $( 1)-:)+H'( !$(
)!"#$%&'( :1':'-H$( :'1( D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'4( H)3!'( )I( 5+-H$( $( M'1I$%&'( !'(
S'I)I(1)Y"+-+H$!'(:),'(#1+-H+$3+-I'4('(S'I)I(-$3H+.#$!'6(E$(:1':'-H$(
!)()!"#$%&'($O'-H+3+$3$4(Y")(M'+(#'3#)0+!$(#'I'("I$(,'3O$()()U$"-H+5$(
#$I+3S$!$( !)( :"1+.#$%&'( I'1$,( )( !)( )U)1#+H$%&'( +3H),)#H"$,4( )--)( +!)$,(
-)( #'3#1)H+A$5$( Z( I)!+!$( Y")( '( [S'I)I( )UH)1+'1\4( I$H)1+$,4( I"HP5),( )(
I'1H$,(#)!+$()-:$%'(:$1$('([S'I)I(+3H)1+'1\4()-:+1+H"$,(+I"HP5),()(+I'1H$,6(
]'3H1$!+H'1+$I)3H)4()I0'1$(M'--)()!"#$H+5'4()--)(:1'#)--'(3&'()1$(!+1+O+!'(
:),'-(S'I)3-4(I$-(:),'(:1K:1+'(G)"-4(:'1(I)+'(!$(C,"I+3$%&'6( I('"H1'-(
H)1I'-4( :$1$( D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'4( G)"-( )1$( '( ^3+#'( I)-H1)Q( '-( :1'M)--'1)-(
3$!$()3-+3$5$I4(-'I)3H)(+3-H+O$5$I('-($,"3'-($(0"-#$1('(#'3S)#+I)3H'6(
--)(I'!),'()!"#$H+5'4(-)O"3!'('()3H)3!+I)3H'($O'-H+3+$3'4(!)-H+3$5$=
-)(ZY"),)-(Y")('"-$5$I()(Y")(3&'(H+3S$I(I)!'(!)(:1'#"1$1($(M),+#+!$!)(
:,)3$4(:'--+0+,+H$!$("3+#$I)3H)(:'1(G)"-6
!8 #5!,#
]"11)3H( 1)-)$1#S( #'I:1+-)-( 1)V)#H+'3-( '3( )!"#$H+'3( :1':'-)!( 0_( DH6(
Augustine on the formation of the type of person foregrounded by
]S1+-H+$3+H_4('1(1$HS)14(HS)(-$3#H+.)!(S"I$3(0)+3O6(X"O"-H+3)`-(:1':'-$,4(
#'3#)+5)!( $-( $( ,'3O( $3!( )US$"-H+5)( ?'"13)_( 'M( I'1$,( :"1+.#$H+'3( $3!(
+3H),,)#H"$,()U)1#+-)-4(!)$,-(a+HS(HS)(-"0-H+H"H+'3('M(HS)(['"H)1(I$3\(a+HS(
*
(G'"H'1()I(J+-HK1+$()(D'#+)!$!)(:),$(/E DL()(:1'M)--'1(!$(/3+5)1-+!$!)( -H$!"$,(
!)(N$1+3OP6( =I$+,Q(??:I),'RS'HI$+,6#'I
410 !"#$%&'()(*+,'-'.$(/0)1,23!+$4(56(784(36(894(:6(8;<=8>84(?",6@!)A6(7;B;6(CDDE(;B;7=F9;B
S+-( I$H)1+$,+H_4( I"H$0+,+H_( $3!( I'1H$,+H_4( 0_( HS)( [+33)1( I$3\( M)$H"1+3O(
-:+1+H"$,4(+II"H$0,)($3!(+II'1H$,(#S$1$#H)1+-H+#-6(X,HS'"OS($3()!"#$H+'3$,(
:1'#)--4(HS)(H1$3-M'1I$H+'3(+-(:$1$!'U+#$,,_($!I+3+-H)1)!(3'H(0_(HS)(S"I$3(
0)+3O(0"H(0_(b'!(HS1'"OS(C,,"I+3$H+'36(X##'1!+3O(H'(X"O"-H+3)4(b'!(+-(HS)(
Sole Teacher and teachers do not teach but merely instigate their students to
seek knowledge. Augustine’s educational model is proper to daring people
aS'($1)(3'H($M1$+!(H'(-))c(M",,(S$::+3)--(aS+#S(+-("3+Y"),_(O+5)3(0_(b'!6(
)I( Y")( )--)-( $-:)#H'-( 1):1)-)3H$5$I( '0-HP#",'-( :$1$( 1)$,+A$%&'( !'( -)"(
+!)$,4(+I:",-+'3$5$I=3'()I(-)"(#$I+3S$1($H'1I)3H$!'6((
f( I$3+Y")n-I'( #'3.1I'"( -"$-( H)3!m3#+$-( :$1$( 0"-#$1( '( [I$"(
#$I+3S'\4($Y"),)(Y")(,)5$5$($'-(:1$A)1)-(-)U"$+-6(G):'+-(!'(1'I:+I)3H'(
sua preocupação foi recorrente nesse assunto.
X'( #)H+#+-I'( ),)( !)5)( $( H)3!m3#+$( !)( !)-#'3.$1( !)( H'!'(
#'3S)#+I)3H'( 1)-:$,!$!'( 3'-( -)3H+!'-( )( 3$( I$Hd1+$4( ?P( Y")4( :$1$( ),)4( $(
concretização da verdadeira fé seria resultado apenas de uma convicção
+3H)1+'14(!)-5+3#",$!$(!)(H'!$()(Y"$,Y")1()U:)1+m3#+$()UH)1+'16
f( 3)':,$H'3+-I'( M'+( '( Y")( I$+-( +3V")3#+'"( '( -)"( :)3-$14(
:'--+0+,+H$3!'=,S)("I$(#'-I','O+$4("I$(5+-&'(!)("3+5)1-'4(:'1(I)+'(!$(
Y"$,( ),)( H)5)( #'3!+%W)-( :$1$( )-H$0),)#)1( $( 1),$%&'( )3H1)( '( )-:+1+H"$,4( '(
)H)13'4('(I$H)1+$,()('(H)I:'1$,6(
A verdade na sua condição de imaterial poderia ser encontrada nas
M'1I$-4(3$-(+!)+$-()()-H$-4(:'1(-"$(5)A4()-H$5$I()I(G)"-(hbCj D4(7;;;l6(
f( #'3S)#+I)3H'( !$( 5)1!$!)4( -)O"3!'( D$3H'( XO'-H+3S'4( :$--$5$( :),'(
#'3S)#+I)3H'(!)(G)"-4(I)-I'(Y")(+3!+1)H$I)3H)6(
$%,$",)'#$%*)%)*+,!-.$
f(#'3#)+H'(!)()!"#$%&'()I(D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'()5+!)3#+$4(3"I(:1+I)+1'(
I'I)3H'4($(+3V"m3#+$(!'(:)3-$I)3H'(#,P--+#'6( ,)($(!).3+"4(3'-(I',!)-(!)(
L,$H&'4(#'I'("I$(,'3O$()()U$"-H+5$(#$I+3S$!$(!)(:"1+.#$%&'(I'1$,()(!)(
)U)1#+H$%&'(+3H),)#H"$,4(:'1(I)+'(!$(Y"$,('(!+-#n:",'(+$(:1'O1)--+5$I)3H)(-)(
+!)3H+.#$3!'(#'I($(-$0)!'1+$4($(0'3!$!)4($(0),)A$()($(M),+#+!$!)(-":1)I$-4(
!+5+3$-4(M'3H)(!)(H'!'('(i)I(hp GfEGfq(jXDLXjXD4B<<gl6(E'()3H$3H'4(
)--$( #'3Y"+-H$( :1)--":"3S$( !+.#",!$!)-( $( -)1( )3M1)3H$!$-( )4( #'3M'1I)(
$.1I'"(3'(Tratado sobre a ordem, era difícil e raro
-)O"+1()(:)1#)0)1($('1!)I(!$-(#'+-$-(r666s4()($+3!$(I$+-(5)1()()U:,+#$1(
$('1!)I(!'("3+5)1-'4(Y")(O"+$()(O'5)13$('(I"3!'(r666s6(X#1)-#)3H)=
-)($(+-H'('(M$H'(!)(Y")4()I0'1$($,O"dI('(:'--$(M$A)14(3&'(#'3-)O")(
)3#'3H1$1("I('"5+3H)(Y")4(Y")1(:),'(Id1+H'(!)(-"$(5+!$4(Y")1(:'1(#)1H$(
-+H"$%&'(!)(#'3S)#+I)3H'-4(-)?$(!+O3'(!)(#'+-$-(H&'(!+5+3$-()('0-#"1$-(
hXbfDkCEJf4(7;;94(C4(BQB4(:6(Bt<l6
!"#$%&'()(*+,'-'.$(/0)1,23!+$4(56(784(36(894(:6(8;<=8>84(?",6@!)A6(7;B;6(CDDE(;B;7=F9;B 413
-H$()U'1H$%&'($O'-H+$3+$3$()1$($,)3H$!'1$4(1)-:'3!+$($'-($3-)+'-(
!'( S'I)I( +3-)O"1'4( H)I)1'-'( )( !)-'1+)3H$!'( !'( -)"( H)I:'6(X.3$,4( -"$(
:PH1+$( H)11)3$4( p'I$4( '( #)3H1'( !'( I"3!'( #+5+,+A$!'4( -"#"I0+$( $'( H)11'1(
0P10$1'(hNfp D]JCECq(Efp jjC4(7;;;l6
G)--$(:)1-:)#H+5$4($()!"#$%&'(M'+(#'3#)0+!$4($3H)-(!)(H"!'4(#'I'(
1)-:'-H$(Z(-+H"$%&'(!)(#'3V+H'4($'(!1$I$(+3H)1+'1(5+5+!'(:),'(S'I)I()(Y")(
-)()U:1)--$5$(3"I()-H$!'(!)(+3Y"+)H$%&'(!'(#'1$%&'((cor inquietum)4(#"?$(
origem era o contraste e a desproporção existente entre a altura e a grandeza
!'('0?)H+5'(Y")(-)(:)1-)O"+$6( I(H'I(!)(,$I)3H'4($.1I$5$(XO'-H+3S'()I(
suas !"#$%%&'%Q([r666s(:'1Y")(3'-(#1+$-H)-(:$1$(eK-()('(3'--'(#'1$%&'(5+5)(
+3Y"+)H'4()3Y"$3H'(3&'(1):'"-$()I(eK-\(hXbfDkCEJf4(B<9;Q(CQ(B4B4(:6(<l6
-H$(:1)#$1+)!$!)(!$(#'3!+%&'(S"I$3$4(-)O"3!'(D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'4(
H'13$5$('(S'I)I(+3#$:$A(!)(#S)O$1($(G)"-(:),'-(:1K:1+'-(1)#"1-'-4('"(-)?$4(
'(S'I)I(H+3S$(O1$3!)-()($,H$-($-:+1$%W)-4(:'1dI(-"$(#'3!+%&'(:$1$(1)$,+AP=
,$-()1$()UH1)I$I)3H)(,+I+H$!$6(T('(Y")(),)($.1I$()I(H'I(!)(S"I+,!$!)(3$-(
mesmas !"#$%%&'%Q([f(S'I)I4(M1$OI)3H'A+3S'(!$(#1+$%&'4(Y")1(,'"5$1=
e'-q('(S'I)I(Y")(:"0,+#$($(-"$(I'1H$,+!$!)4($11$-H$3!'('(H)-H)I"3S'(!'(
-)"(:)#$!'(r666s\hXbfDkCEJf4(B<9;4(CQ(B4B4(:6(<l6
X()-H$(1)$,+!$!)4(!)(Y")('(S'I)I(d(#'3-#+)3H)(:),$(Md4($O1)O$=-)(
'"H1$(Y")(:'!)(-)1(!)-#'0)1H$(:),$(1$A&'6(E)--)(#$-'4('(S'I)I(#)1H+.#$=-)(
!'-(-)"-(,+I+H)-(Y"$3!'(5',H$(-)"-(',S$1)-(:$1$($-(#'+-$-(Y")('(#)1#$I4('"(
-)?$4(:$1$($('01$(!$(#1+$%&'(hp GfEGfqjXDLXjXD4(B<<gl6(x")-H+'3$=-)(
'($"H'1Q([L'1("I(,$!'()U+-H)I4(:'+-(:1'5mI(!)(eK-q(:'1('"H1'(3&'()U+-H)I4(
:'+-( 3&'( -&'( $Y"+,'( Y")( eK-( -'+-6( f1$( -K( )U+-H)( 5)1!$!)+1$I)3H)( '( Y")(
:)1I$3)#)(+I"HP5),\(hXbfDkCEJf4(B<9;4(eCC4(BB4(:6(BBg=BB9l6
L'1()--)-(I'H+5'-('(S'I)I(d4(+35$1+$5),I)3H)4(+3#$:$A(!)(1)$,+A$1(
-'A+3S'()(:,)3$I)3H)($(:1PH+#$(M'1I$H+5$4(I)-I'(Y")('(!)-)?)()(3)#)--+H)4(
5+3#",$3!'( $( +--'( -"$( M),+#+!$!)6( E'-( D',+,KY"+'-4( $( #'I:1))3-&'( !$(
#'3!+%&'(!)(I+-)1$0+,+!$!)(!'(S'I)I(,)5'"(D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'($(-)(,$I)3H$14(
)I(:1+I)+1$(:)--'$4(!$(-)O"+3H)(I$3)+1$Q([L'1Y")(.#'($+3!$(0$,$3%$3!'(
#'I'("I(+3M),+A()(-'"(-):$1$!'(:'1("I(I+-)1P5),(H'1I)3H'w(yP(I'-H1)+(
Y")(3&'($I'(3)3S"I$('"H1$(#'+-$4(+-H'(d4($Y"+,'(Y")(3&'(-)($I$(:'1(-+4(
3&'(-)($I$6(N$-($I'(-'I)3H)($(-$0)!'1+$(:'1(-+(I)-I$\(hXbfDkCEJf4(
B<<94(CQ(B>4774(:6(88l6
]'3H1$!+H'1+$I)3H)4( ),)( #'3-+!)1$5$( $,)3H$!'1( '( M$H'( !)( Y")( 3$(
I)-I$(+3!+Om3#+$((1$!+#$5$($(O1$3!)A$(S"I$3$4(?P(Y")($($,I$()1$(I"HP5),6(
]'3M'1I)( #'3#,"+"( )I( X( k1+3!$!)Q( [f( Y")( $( $,I$( #)1H$I)3H)( 3&'( :W)(
)I(!^5+!$(d($(-"$(:1K:1+$(+3M),+#+!$!)()('(M$H'(!)(!)-)?$1(-)1(M),+A6(j'O'4(
o fundamento de sua esperança é a sua natureza mutável. Se não fosse
!"#$%&'()(*+,'-'.$(/0)1,23!+$4(56(784(36(894(:6(8;<=8>84(?",6@!)A6(7;B;6(CDDE(;B;7=F9;B 417
I"HP5),4(3&'(:'!)1+$(:$--$1(!$(M),+#+!$!)(:$1$($(!)-5)3H"1$4(#'I'(H$I0dI(
!$(!)-5)3H"1$(:$1$($(M),+#+!$!)\(hXbfDkCEJf4(7;;t4(vCeQ(Bt=7B4(:6(8F9l6
X( +3-$H+-M$%&'( 3$H"1$,( !'( S'I)I( #'3-+O'( '( ,)5$1+$( $( 0"-#$14( I$-(
3)I(-)I:1)4('(I),S'1$I)3H'(:)--'$,4($(1)$,+A$%&'(!$(#$I+3S$!$()!"#$H+5$6(
C-H'4(#'I'(?P(I)3#+'3$!'4(3&'(-)1+$(M)+H'(-)I(O1$3!)-()(!+Mn#)+-('0-HP#",'-6(
X(:1+I)+1$($1I$!+,S$()1$('(!)-5+'(!'(:1'?)H'(!$(M),+#+!$!)(:,)3$4('(Y")4()I(
O1$3!)(I)!+!$4()U:,+#$5$($(+3#$:$#+!$!)(!'(S'I)I(:$1$(1)$,+A$1()--)(0)I(
I$+'16(G)($#'1!'(#'I('(:'-+#+'3$I)3H'(!'($"H'1()I(X(k1+3!$!)4(d(:1K:1+'(!'(
S'I)I(0"-#$1($(M),+#+!$!)4(I$-(+--'(3&'(d(-".#+)3H)(:$1$($(1)$,+A$%&'(!)--)(
'0?)H+5'(-":)1+'14(?P(Y")(3)I(H'!'-(-&'(!'H$!'-(!)([Md(:$1$(#S)O$1(Z(M),+#+!$!)(
:),$(:"1+.#$%&'(!'(#'1$%&'\(hXbfDkCEJf4(7;;t4(vCCCQ(7;=7t4(:6(8>>l6
]'I( )-H$( $--)1H+5$4( D$3H'( XO'-H+3S'( 1'I:)"( #'I( $( H1$!+%&'(
#,P--+#$4($0$3!'3$3!'($(+!)+$(!)(Y")($(.,'-'.$(-)1+$(M'3H)(!$(M),+#+!$!)()(
deslocando essa possibilidade para instância divina. Em contraposição ao
G)"-(!'-(.,K-'M'-(#'3#)0+!'(#'I'(:,)3$I)3H)(H1$3-#)3!)3H)4(!)(M'1I$(
$( +3#$:$#+H$1( '( S'I)I( !)( $H+3O+=,'4( '( G)"-( !)( D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'( -)( M$A(
:1)-)3H)( )( :)--'$,4( $( :'3H'( !)( ,)5$1( '( #'1$%&'( !'( S'I)I( Z( +3Y"+)H"!)4(
$($,I)?$1($1!)3H)I)3H)($(:$A()($(M),+#+!$!)(Y")($:)3$-( ,)(:'--+0+,+H$1+$(
hNfp D]JCECq( Efp jjC4( 7;;;l6( D'I)3H)( :'1( I)+'( !)--$( 1),$%&'( -)(
:1'!"A+1+$( $( M),+#+!$!)( )( -)( $,O'( I)1)#+$( '( Y"$,+.#$H+5'( !)( !'I( !+5+3'(
#)1H$I)3H)()1$($(5+!$(M),+A6(X--+I4('(S'I)I(!)5)1+$(-)(#'3M'1I$1(#'I('(
Y")('0H+3S$(:),'(-)"()-M'1%'(:)--'$,4(I'H+5'(:),'(Y"$,(#'3-+!)1$5$(Y")($(
5+!$(M),+A(3$(H)11$()(-)(M$A+$(H$I0dI(:'--n5),(:),$()-:)1$3%$6(X()-H)(1)-:)+H'4(
:'3!)1'"4(#'I("I(I+-H'(!)(+1'3+$()(0)3)5',m3#+$4()I(X(k1+3!$!)Q
Y")1(3)--)(#$-'('(Y")(:'!)4(:'1Y")(3&'(:'!)('(Y")(Y")1z(E+-H'(#'3-+-H)(
H'!$( $( M),+#+!$!)( !'-( I'1H$+-( -'0)10'-4( 3&'( -)+( -)( !+O3'( !)( 1+-'( '"(
!)( #'I:$+U&'Q( O,'1+$1=-)( !)( 5+5)1( #'I'( !)-)?$I4( :'1Y")( -":'1H$I(
#'I( :$#+m3#+$( '( Y")( #)1H$I)3H)( 3&'( Y")1+$I( Y")( ,S)-( -"#)!)--)6
r666s(S'I)I(M),+A(o(H$,(#'I'(H'!'-(!)-)?$I'-(-)1(o(3&'(-)(:'!)(!+A)1(
#'I( 1$A&'( )( )I( 5)1!$!)Q( [f( Y")( Y")1)-( d( +I:'--n5),( !)( 1)$,+A$1\6(
D)($,O"dI(?P(d(M),+A4(H"!'('(Y")(!)-)?$(d(:'--n5),(:$1$(),)4(:'+-(3&'(
!)-)?'"($,O'(+I:'--n5),(!)(-)1(1)$,+A$!'(hXbfDkCEJf4(7;;t4(vCCCQ(
g=B;4(:6(889=8<<l6
418 !"#$%&'()(*+,'-'.$(/0)1,23!+$4(56(784(36(894(:6(8;<=8>84(?",6@!)A6(7;B;6(CDDE(;B;7=F9;B
!%'"#)5'$5'*!*)7%,$"*'-.$%3!5!%$%!35'/$5!/)"#$
)UH)1+'1)-4(Y")(H)3H$5$(#'3Y"+-H$1()(:1)-)15$1(:$1$(O$1$3H+1('(Y")()3H)3!+$(
:'1(-)O"1$3%$4(M),+#+!$!)()(:1$A)16( 1$($--+I(Y")(XO'-H+3S'()U:1)--$5$($(
M1$O+,+!$!)(S"I$3$(:$1$(#'3Y"+-H$1('(0)I(I$+'1()(!)-M1"H$1(!'-(0)3)Mn#+'-(
dele decorrentes.
X(-":)1$%&'(!)--$(M1$O+,+!$!)(:$--$5$(:),'(#",H+5'()(!+O3+.#$%&'(
!$($,I$4(:'1(M'1H$,)#m=,$()(-+H"P=,$()I("I$(1)$,+!$!)(-":)1+'1(Z()UH)1+'1q('(
1)-",H$!'(!)--$($%&'(#'3#)!+$=,S)($(#S$5)(!'($#)--'(Z(-"$(+!)3H+!$!)()($'(
I)-I'(H)I:'(,S)($01+$($-(:'1H$-(:$1$($(#'3Y"+-H$(!$(-"$(#+!$!$3+$(#),)-H)6(
D)O"3!'(D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'4()--)()1$('(I'H+5'()--)3#+$,(!$()3H1)O$4(
!'( V"+14( !'( !),)+H$1=-)( )I( G)"-4( $( 5)1!$!)( +3.3+H$4( '( 0)I( -":1)I'( )(
+I"HP5),6(X(:)1M)+%&'(I'1$,4($(M),+#+!$!)(o()4()I(!)#'11m3#+$4($(-$0)!'1+$(
#'I:,)H$(o()-H$5$I(+3H+I$I)3H)(1),$#+'3$!$-(Z($%&'(!)(#'3S)#)1()($I$1(
esse bem maior.
C--'4(3$(:)1-:)#H+5$($O'-H+3+$3$4()1$($(#'3!+%&'(!'(mU+H'(!'(#'I:,)U'(
$5$3%'(#'O3'-#+H+5'4(H$3H'(3'(Y")(!+A(1)-:)+H'(Z(0"-#$(!)('0?)H'-()UH)1+'1)-(
)($(1)V)U&'(-'01)(-+(I)-I'(#'I'($(:'--+0+,+!$!)(!)(",H1$:$--$1('(Y")(-)(
colocava entre a percepção de determinadas coisas por meio dos sentidos e o
)3H)3!+I)3H'(!$(Y"$,+!$!)(!$Y"+,'(Y")()1$(5)1!$!)+1'4($(!+I)3-&'(-":)1+'1(
!$($,I$Q($([I)3H)\('"(+3H),+Om3#+$4($(:$1H+1(!$(1$A&'4(:'1(-"$(5)A(,)5$5$(Z(-"$(
:1K:1+$(+!)3H+!$!)(hp GfEGfq(jXDLXjXD4(B<<gl6( -H$-(#'3!+%W)-()1$I(
preparadas pelo intelecto no exercício cognitivo e propiciavam ao homem
+!)3H+.#$1('(Y")(5+$4('"5+$4(,+$('"(:)3-$5$(:'1(I)+'(!$(5)1!$!)(+3H),+On5),4(
Y")(-)(,'#$,+A$5$(3$(:1K:1+$([I)3H)\(hE/E D4(B<g9l6
L'1( +--'4( D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'4( !)M)3!+$( $( 3)#)--+!$!)( !)( $--"I+1( $(
1$A&'()($(Md4(3&'(#'I'(M1)3H)-(':'-H$-4(I$-(#'I'(#',$0'1$!'1$-4(#'I'(!"$-(
5+$-( Y")( ,)5$5$I( $'( #'3S)#+I)3H'( !$( 5)1!$!)Q( $( $"H'1+!$!)( o(k)','O+$(
420 !"#$%&'()(*+,'-'.$(/0)1,23!+$4(56(784(36(894(:6(8;<=8>84(?",6@!)A6(7;B;6(CDDE(;B;7=F9;B
!%#5!" ,)"*<",'!%)%$%)",$"#5$%,$/%*)+
:),$()U#),m3#+$(!$($,I$(1$#+'3$,\(hXbfDkCEJf4(B<<B4(C4(77Q7;4(:6(<gl6
E$( )-H)+1$( !)--$-( 1)V)UW)-4( '"H1$( Y")-H&'4( :'1( -)( +I:'1(
#'3-H$3H)I)3H)($'(S'I)I4(!)5)1+$(-)1(#'3-+!)1$!$Q(5+5)1(-)O"3!'($(#$13)(
,)5$5$='( $( 1'I:)1( $( 1),$%&'( #'I( G)"-4( $'( :$--'( Y")( 5+5)1( -)O"3!'( '(
)-:n1+H'4(3$(O1$%$4(,)5$5$='(Z(-$3H+.#$%&'()(Z("3+&'(#'I(G)"-6( --$(-)O"3!$(
':%&'(#'3.1I$5$4(:$1$(D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'4($(1),$%&'(:1K!+O$()(M)#"3!$(#'I(
'(:1K:1+'(G)"-4(Y")(,S)(#'3#)!)1+$($(O1$%$(!)(:$1H+#+:$1(!$(-"$()H)13+!$!)(
hXiiXbEXEfq(eCDXji pbJC4( B<F<l6(X.3$,4( '( S'I)I( 3$-#)"( :$1$(
-)1(#+!$!&'(!'(#d"4()I(-)"(:1'?)H'(!).3+H+5'4()--$(#+!$!$3+$(#),)-H)(d(Y")(
!)5)1+$(-)1(0"-#$!$()(#'3Y"+-H$!$6( ,$()1$('(.I(^,H+I'(!)(-"$()U+-Hm3#+$6
Com essa dinâmica formativa a educação cristã agostiniana
#'3H+3S$($()U+Om3#+$(!)(!$1("I(:$--'(Z(M1)3H)(:$1$(-":)1$1('-('0-HP#",'-(
causadores do fracasso humano e as práticas dissonantes com a
H1$3-#)3!m3#+$4('"(-)?$4($-($%W)-(!+1)#+'3$!$-(Z('0H)3%&'(!$($"H'3'I+$4(
Z( 0"-#$4( 3'( :1K:1+'( +3!+5n!"'4( !)( "I$( #'3-+-Hm3#+$( !)-5+3#",$!$( !'(
:1'?)H'( -$3H+.#$!'16(k$+-( $11'?'-( )3H1$5$I( )I( #'3V+H'( #'I( '( :1'#)--'(
)!"#$H+5'4(#"?$(#'3!+%&'(:1+I)+1$()1$($($#)+H$%&'4(:'1(:$1H)(!'(S'I)I4(
!)( Y")( $( -"$( )-H$0+,+!$!)( +3H)1+'1( H+3S$( :'1( :1+3#n:+'( $( !)0+,+!$!)( )( $(
M1$O+,+!$!)4()('(^3+#'(1)#"1-'(!'(Y"$,(:'!)1+$(!+-:'1()1$($(H1$3-#)3!m3#+$(
hXbfDkCEJf4(B<9t4(B87Q>4(:6(tF;l6
f( #'3S)#+I)3H'( S"I$3'4( )I( D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'4( 3&'( !)5)1+$( -)1(
+I$3)3H)4(I$-(H1$3-#)3!)3H)4(Z(I)!+!$()I(Y")('(S'I)I(:1)#+-$5$(0"-#$1(
'([$,H'\(:$1$()3#'3H1$1('(-)"(D)3S'14(M'3H)(!)(H'!'('(0)I4(!)(H'!'('(-$0)1(
)(!)(H'!$($(M),+#+!$!)6(x"$,Y")1(!+-H$3#+$I)3H'(!)--$(1)$,+!$!)(-":)1+'1(
H1$1+$(#'I'(#'3-)Y"m3#+$-($(+3-$H+-M$%&'4('(#'3V+H'4($(+3M),+#+!$!)4(5+-H'(
Y")('(01+,S'()UH)1+'14()I(-"$(-)!"%&'4($:)-$1(!)(-$H+-M$A)1(-":)1.#+$,I)3H)4(
3&'( :1))3#S)1+$( '( 5$A+'( +3H)1+'1( Y")( :$1H+#",$1+A$( $( )U+-Hm3#+$( S"I$3$(
Y"$3H'( $( M$,H$( !$( :1)-)3%$( ( -$3H+.#$!'1$( !'( -)"( D)3S'1( hp GfEGfq(
jXDLXjXD4(B<<gl6
I( M$#)( !+--'4( 3"I( )U)1#n#+'( 1)V)U+5'4( D$3H'( XO'-H+3S'( )I( X(
k1+3!$!)( :)1O"3H$5$=-)( '( :'1Y"m( !$( +I:'1H23#+$( !$( $,I$( -)( #'3S)#)1(
em toda a sua dimensão. Seu posicionamento em relação a esse
$"H'Y")-H+'3$I)3H'4(M1"H'(!)(-"$-(+3Y"+)H$%W)-4(M'+(:1)#+-'Q(),)(3&'(!)+U'"(
!^5+!$-()I(1),$%&'($'(-)"(:)3-$1()(Z(-"$(#1)3%$6
422 !"#$%&'()(*+,'-'.$(/0)1,23!+$4(56(784(36(894(:6(8;<=8>84(?",6@!)A6(7;B;6(CDDE(;B;7=F9;B
]'3M'1I)(#1)+'4(d(:$1$(),$(-)(:)3-$1()I(-+(I)-I$()(5+5)1(!)($#'1!'(
#'I(-"$(3$H"1)A$4('"(-)?$4(:$1$(Y")(-)(!)+U)(O'5)13$1(:'1($Y"),)($(Y")I(
!)5)()-H$1(-"?)+H$4()($#+I$(!$-(#'+-$-(Y")(!)5)(!'I+3$16(D'0($Y"),)(:'1(
Y")I(!)5)(-)1(!+1+O+!$()(-'01)($Y"+,'(Y")(),$(!)5)(!+1+O+16(N"+H$-(5)A)-4(
!)5+!'(Z(#'3#":+-#m3#+$(!)-1)O1$!$4($($,I$($O)(#'I'(Y")()-Y")#+!$(!)(
-+(I)-I$6(L'+-($($,I$(5m($,O"I$-(#'+-$-(+3H1+3-)#$I)3H)(0),$-(3"I$(
3$H"1)A$(-":)1+'14(Y")(d(G)"-6( (Y"$3!'(!)5)1+$()-H$1(:)1I$3)#)3!'(
3'(O'A'(!)--)(i)I4($'(Y")1)1($H1+0"n=,'($(-+(I)-I$(3&'(Y")1(M$A)1=-)(
-)I),S$3H)( $( G)"-4( #'I( '( $"Un,+'( !)( G)"-4( I$-( -)1( '( Y")( ),$( d( :'1(
-+(:1K:1+$4($M$-H$3!'=-)(! ,)()(1)-5$,$3!'6(*+1I$=-)(#$!$(5)A(I)3'-4(
:'1Y")( -)( +,"!)4( :)3-$3!'( -"0+1( #$!$( 5)A( I$+-( $,H'6( E&'( -)( 0$-H$(
$( -+( I)-I$4( )( 3)I( ,S)( 0$-H$( 0)I( $,O"I4( $'( -)( $M$-H$1( !$Y"),)( Y")(
"3+#$I)3H)(-)(0$-H$(hXbfDkCEJf4(7;;t4(v4(tQg4(:6(>B<=>7;l6
!%)*+,!-.$%,$/$%$85!%*'2'"!
(f(:1)--":'-H'(!)(Y")('(!+-#n:",'(H)3S$(#S)O$!'($("I(0'I(H)1I'(
Y"$3H'($'-('0?)H+5'-(M'1I$H+5'-(!$(+3H)1+'1+A$%&'()(!$(H1$3-#)3!m3#+$(o($(
H1$3-#)3!m3#+$(,)5$(Z(+3H)1+'1+A$%&'(o4(#'3-H+H"+("I$(-+H"$%&'(:1+5+,)O+$!$(
:$1$(-)()!"#$1(3'(-)3H+!'(:,)3'(!$(#'3#):%&'()!"#$H+5$(!)(D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'4(
'"(-)?$4('(!+-#n:",'()-H$1+$(:1):$1$!'(:$1$(H)1($#)--'(Z()H$:$(!)#+-+5$(!$(
-"$( :)!$O'O+$4( 3$( Y"$,4( :$1$( ),)( '( :1K:1+'( G)"-( $--"I+$( $( #'3!+%&'( !'(
O1$3!)(I)-H1)(Y")(+3-H1"n$()()!"#$5$4(Y")(+,"I+3$5$($(-"$(+3H),+Om3#+$()(
incandescia seu coração.
( I( X( 5)1!$!)+1$( 1),+O+&'4( 3"I$( )U:'-+%&'( Y"$-)( #),)01$H+5$4(
XO'-H+3S'(!)+U'"(#'3S)#)1()--$()H$:$()!"#$H+5$4($'(I)-I'(H)I:'()I(Y")(
$(1),$#+'3'"(Z-()H$:$-($3H)#)!)3H)-6
E&'(-$+$-(!)(H+4(I$-(5',H$(:$1$(!)3H1'(!)(H+(I)-I'4($(e)1!$!)(S$0+H$(
no coração do homem. E se não encontras senão a tua natureza sujeita
$(I"!$3%$-4(5$+($,dI(!)(H+(I)-I'6( I(H)(",H1$:$--$3!'4(:'1dI4(3&'(H)(
)-Y")%$-(Y")(H1$3-#)3!)-(H"$($,I$(Y")(1$#+'#+3$6(L'1H$3H'4(!+1+O)=-)($(
fonte da própria luz da razão.
X'3!)( :'!)( #S)O$14( #'I( )M)+H'4( H'!'( 0'I( :)3-$!'1( -)3&'( $Hd( Z(
e)1!$!)w(D)( $(5)1!$!)(3&'(d( $H+3O+!$(:),'(:1K:1+'(1$#+'#n3+'4(),$(d(
?"-H$I)3H)4($(.3$,+!$!)(!$(0"-#$(!'-(Y")(1$#+'#+3$I6
!"#$%&'()(*+,'-'.$(/0)1,23!+$4(56(784(36(894(:6(8;<=8>84(?",6@!)A6(7;B;6(CDDE(;B;7=F9;B 423
+-($(S$1I'3+$(Y")(3$!$(I$+-(:'!)1+$(",H1$:$--$16(J$1I'3+A$=H)(#'I(
),$6(]'3M)--$(Y")(H"(3&'(d-(+!m3H+#'4(Y")(H"(5+)-H)($(),$4(:1'#"1$3!'=$4(
3&'($(:)1#'11)1()-:$%'-4(I$-(:),'(!)-)?'(!)(H)"()-:n1+H'6(*'+(),)(Y")(H)(
M)A()3#'3H1P=,$4(3&'(#'I(M1"+%&'(#$13$,()(0$+U$4(I$-(#'I(-"I'(!),)+H)(
)-:+1+H"$,6(k"!'(:$1$(Y")('(S'I)I(+3H)1+'1(-)(S$1I'3+A)(#'I(XY"),)(
Y")(3),)(S$0+H$(hXbfDkCEJf4(7;;74(><Qg74(:6(<9=<<l6
(E)-H$( 1)V)U&'4( ),)( :W)( Z-( #,$1$-( $-( H1m-( )H$:$-( #'I:'3)3H)-( !$(
-"$( :1':'-H$( )!"#$H+5$4( )5+!)3#+$3!'( '( H1$%'( I$+-( )M)H+5'( !$( )!"#$%&'(
#1+-H&4('(-)"($O)3H)(:1+I)+1'4('"(-)?$4('(:1K:1+'(G)"-(-)I('(Y"$,(),$(3&'(
-)( 1)$,+A$1+$6( E)--)( :1'#)--'4( $'( S'I)I( )-H$5$( 1)-)15$!'( )I( "I( :$:),(
-)#"3!P1+'4( $Hd( I)-I'( ,+I+H$!'( )( -"0-+!+P1+'6( L'1( +--'4( :$1$( '( 3'--'(
:)3-$!'1('(-"#)--'()!"#$H+5'(:$--$5$(:),$($!'%&'4(:'1(:$1H)(!'(!+-#n:",'4(
!)("I$($H+H"!)(Y"$-)(!)($0'3!'3'4(!)()3H1)O$($(G)"-4(#'3M'1I)(-+3H)H+A'"(
3'-(D',+,KY"+'-Q([]1m(#'3-H$3H)I)3H)()I(G)"-()()3H1)O$=H)(+3H)+1$I)3H)(
$(),)(r666s(!)#,$1$=H)(!'(#,)I)3Hn--+I'()(O)3)1'-n--+I'(D)3S'14(!)(I'!'(
Y")(),)(3&'(#)--)(!)()1O")1=H)($Hd(),)()(3&'(:)1I+H$(Y")(3$!$(H)('#'11$\(
hXbfDkCEJf4(B<<94(C=ve4(7<4(:6(t>l6
G)--)( I'!'4( )I)1O)( "I$( !$-( Y")-HW)-( H)',KO+#$-( Y")( I$+-(
+3Y"+)H$1$I( )( :1'5'#$1$I( '( :)3-$1( $O'-H+3+$3'( )( Y")( :$1)#)( H)1( -+!'(
superada apenas pelos mistérios da Trindade. Esse ponto nuclear não
$:)3$-( !$( )!"#$%&'4( I$-( !$( 1),+O+&'( #1+-H&( )1$( '( :$:),( !$( O1$%$( !+5+3$(
3$(1)!)3%&'(!'(S'I)Iq('()-:$%'(1)-)15$!'(Z(,+0)1!$!)(3$(-"$(!+I)3-&'(
cooperadora nesse processo e cujas manifestações expressivas podiam ser
encontradas na educação e no magistério do homem.
L$1$('()3H)3!+I)3H'()@'"()U:,+#$%&'(!)--$-(Y")-HW)-4(D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'(
0"-#'"(1)-:$,!'()I($,O"I$-()U'1H$%W)-():+-H',$1)-(!)(L$",'(!)(k$1-'Q
b)3H+'-Q($--+I4(:'+-4($Y"),)(Y")(:,$3H$4(3$!$(dq($Y"),)(Y")(1)O$4(3$!$(
dq(I$-(+I:'1H$(-'I)3H)(G)"-(Y")(!P('(#1)-#+I)3H'(hB(]'1(>Qgl6(r666s
L),'(#'3H1$1+'4()3H)3!$I(Y")4(-)(-&'(.,S'-(!)(G)"-4(-&'(#'3!"A+!'-(
:),'( -:n1+H'(!)(G)"-(hpI(9QB8l4(!)(I'!'(Y")(M$%$I('(Y")(!)5)I(
M$A)1()4(!):'+-(!)(Hm=,'(M)+H'4($O1$!)%$I(ZY"),)(!)(Y")I(1)#)0)I($-(
M'1#$-6(D&'(I'5+!'-($($O+14(I$-(3)I(:'1(+--'(!)+U)I(!)(M$A)1($(-"$(
:$1H)6(T=,S)-(+3!+#$!'('(Y")(!)5)I(M$A)1()4(Y"$3!'(M$A)I(#'I'(!)5)I4(
'"(-)?$4(#'I($I'1()(O'-H'(:),$(?"-H+%$4($,)O1)I=-)(:'1(H)1(1)#)0+!'($(
-"$5+!$!)('"H'1O$!$(:),'(D)3S'14(:$1$(Y")(-"$(H)11$(:1'!"A+--)(-)"(
M1"H'(hDj(98QB>l6(x"$3!'4(:'1)I4(3&'($O)I4(-)?$(!)+U$3!'(H'H$,I)3H)(
!)( M$A)14( -)?$( M$A)3!'='( -)I( $I'14( !)5)I( '1$1( :$1$( 1)#)0)1( '( Y")(
$+3!$(3&'(HmI6(N$-4('(Y")(H)1&'()('(Y")(3&'(-)1P(1)#)0+!'w(f"('(Y")(
H)I4(Y")(3&'(H)3S$I(1)#)0+!'w(hB]'1(8Qgl(hXbfDkCEJf4(B<<<4(CC4(
>Q84(:6(9F=9gl6
(X(1+O'14('(Y")(O$3S'"(!)-H$Y")(3)--$(!+-#"--&'(M'+($(+!)+$(!)(Y")(
H'!'( :1'O1)--'( )!"#$H+5'4( Y")1( 3'( Y")( !+A( 1)-:)+H'( Z( M'1I$%&'( S"I$3$(
Y")1(3'(1)M)1)3H)(Z(M'1I$%&'(1),+O+'-$4(!)5)1+$(-)1()3H)3!+!'4()I(^,H+I$(
+3-H23#+$4( 3$( :)1-:)#H+5$( !$( $%&'( !+5+3$4( $( Y"$,4( !)( I$3)+1$-( !+5)1-$-(
+3V"n$(3'(!+-#n:",'4('1+)3H$5$(-"$-(:1PH+#$-()(-"$($:1)3!+A$O)I(:'1(I)+'(
da graça.
Nem mesmo a fé era um ato pessoal em seu sentido pleno: antes de
H"!'()1$("I(!'I(!+5+3'q($Hd(I)-I'($(5'3H$!)(!)(#1)1(!)5)1+$(-)1($H1+0"n!$(
$( )--$( O1$%$( hXbfDkCEJf4( B<<94( CC4( >8QF;4( :6( <;=<Bl6( L'1( +--'4( )1$( $(
:$1H+1(!$(Md(Y")(-)(#S)O$5$(Z(#'I:1))3-&'(!)(G)"-4('(Y")(3&'(-+O3+.#$(
Y")(M'--)($,O'(#)O'4(+11$#+'3$,4(I$-(-+I("I(+3-H1"I)3H'(Y")(:'--+0+,+H$5$(
$:1'U+I$1=-)( !)( G)"-( hNfp D]JCECq( Efp jjC4( 7;;;l6( U:1)--+5$4(
3)--)( -)3H+!'4( M'+( -"$( #'3#,"-&'( )I(X( k1+3!$!)( !)( Y")( [X( Md( 0"-#$4( '(
)3H)3!+I)3H'()3#'3H1$\(hXbfDkCEJf4(7;;t4(ve4(7Q74(:6(89Bl6
(f(Y")(.#$()5+!)3H)(d(Y")(H'!$($($%&'(!'(S'I)I()I(M$5'1(!)(-"$(
)!"#$%&'4( !+1)H$( '"( +3!+1)H$I)3H)4( )1$( I'H+5$!$( :'1( G)"-4( )I0'1$4( )I(
$,O"I$-(-+H"$%W)-4(!):)3!)--)("3+#$I)3H)(!'(S'I)I6(L'1()U)I:,'4(#$-'(
'(S'I)I(-)(3)O$--)($(1)#)0)1()--$(O1$%$4(),$(3&'('($H+3O+1+$4($'(#'3H1P1+'4(
-)($(!)-)?$--)(,+51)I)3H)()($(I)1)#)--)4()--$(5'3H$!)(-)1+$($5+5$!$(:),$(
ação divina e o bem seria concedido.
!"#$%&'()(*+,'-'.$(/0)1,23!+$4(56(784(36(894(:6(8;<=8>84(?",6@!)A6(7;B;6(CDDE(;B;7=F9;B 425
(]'I(+-H'4($(,+0)1!$!)()($(:$1H)(1)-)15$!$($'(S'I)I(3$()!"#$%&'(
:1':'-H$(:'1(D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'($!Y"+1)I(1),)5'4()I0'1$(-)(H1$H)(!)("I(:$:),(
1),$H+5'4(-)#"3!P1+'6(C--'(3&'(:'!)1+$(-)1(!+M)1)3H)4($.3$,()-H$-(!+I)3-W)-(
S"I$3$-( )-H$5$I( -"0I)H+!$-( Z( 5'3H$!)( )( Z( O1$%$( !+5+3$6( 3H1)H$3H'4(
D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'(3&'(!)+U'"(!^5+!$(!)(Y")4(:$1$($,#$3%$1()--)(0)I4(:$:),(
M"3!$I)3H$,(H+3S$($(5'3H$!)(,+51)()(5)1!$!)+1$(!'(S'I)I(hp GfEGfq(
jXDLXjXD4( B<<gl4( :'1Y")( G)"-( 3&'( #'3#)!+$( '( !'I( !$( Md( )( !$-( 0'$-(
'01$-(:$1$(Y")I(3&'(,"H$--)(+3#)--$3H)()(01$5$I)3H)(:$1$(I)1)#m=,$-6
(L$1$( )3M$H+A$1( )--$( Y")-H&'4( ),)( #'3#,"+"( )I( X( #'11)%&'( )( $(
O1$%$Q( [ +-( #'I'( $( ,+0)1!$!)( -)( S$1I'3+A$( #'I( $( O1$%$( !)( G)"-( )( 3&'(
$(#'3H1$1+$6(X(5'3H$!)(3&'('0HdI($(O1$%$(:),$(,+0)1!$!)4(I$-($(,+0)1!$!)(
:),$(O1$%$4()("I$(:)1)3+!$!)(!),)+HP5),()(M'1H$,)A$(+3-":)1P5),()I('1!)I(
$(:)1-)5)1$3%$\(hXbfDkCEJf4(B<<<4(9QBg4(:6(B;7l6
A ação humana livre tinha uma função importante a desempenhar
3'( M)3uI)3'( )!"#$H+5'( $O'-H+3+$3'Q( )I( ^,H+I$( +3-H23#+$4( #'3-+-H+$( )I(
$#)+H$14(-"0I)H)1=-)()(:'H)3#+$1($-(!+M)1)3H)-(I$3+M)-H$%W)-(!$(O1$%$()($Hd(
mesmo ocultar sua misteriosa presença no coração do homem.
(L'1H$3H'4(-)I($($3"m3#+$()($(#',$0'1$%&'(!'(S'I)I4('(:1'O1$I$(
-$3H+.#$!'1( :$1$( ),)( :1):$1$!'( :'1( G)"-( 3&'( #S$O$1+$( $'( 0'I( H)1I'6(
E)--$( #$I+3S$!$4( '( S'I)I( !)5)1+$( :$--$1( :'1( !'+-( I'I)3H'-( !+-H+3H'-(
:$1$(#'3Y"+-H$1($(1)3'5$%&'(:1K:1+$(!$(-$3H+.#$%&'6
(f( :1+I)+1'( I'I)3H'( H+3S$( ,"O$1( #'I( '( 0$H+-I'4( '01$( Y"$-)(
exclusivamente divina realizada com o perdão das faltas cometidas pelo
S'I)I(Y")(#S)O$--)(Z(#'35)1-&'6(E'(-)O"3!'(I'I)3H'4(-"$(1)$,+A$%&'(-)(
fazia por meio de um diálogo muito mais claro entre a liberdade humana e
$(O1$%$(-$3H+.#$!'1$(hXbfDkCEJf4(7;;t4(vCe4(BgQ7>4(:6(8g>l6
]'I('('0?)H+5'(!)()U:,+#$1($Hd(Y")(:'3H'()1$(:'--n5),($(:1)-)3%$(
':)1$H+5$(!$(O1$%$(3'(#'1$%&'()(3$([I)3H)\(!'(S'I)I4(D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'(
!)-)35',5)"( H'!$( "I$( H)'1+$( O3'-+',KO+#$( )( :)!$OKO+#$4( #"?'( 3^#,)'(
d( $( !'"H1+3$( !$( C,"I+3$%&'4( )I0'1$4( +I:'1H$( #'3-+!)1$14( -"$( k)'1+$( !$(
C,"I+3$%&'( ",H1$:$--)( $( #'3!+%&'( !)( "I( $1H+Mn#+'( .,'-K.#'6( ,$( 3&'( -)(
1)!"A+$(^3+#$()(M"3!$I)3H$,I)3H)($("I$(H)'1+$(!'(#'3S)#+I)3H'4(?P(Y")($(
grande preocupação do autor era compor uma imagem da ação da graça na
#'3-#+m3#+$(S"I$3$4(Y")(#$:H$5$('-(:,$3'-(!)(G)"-(:),$(+3H),+Om3#+$()(:),'(
$I'16(C--'(!)5)1+$('#'11)1(H$3H'(3$([I)3H)\(Y"$3H'(3$(5'3H$!)4(:$1$(Y")($(
426 !"#$%&'()(*+,'-'.$(/0)1,23!+$4(56(784(36(894(:6(8;<=8>84(?",6@!)A6(7;B;6(CDDE(;B;7=F9;B
,"A(!+5+3$4(:'1(I)+'(!)(]1+-H'4(:"!)--)('1+)3H$1('(S'I)I(Y")(-)(1)5)-H+"(
!$(Md6(X($,I$4()I(-"$(:$1H)()-:+1+H"$,4(#'3-H+H"+($(5)1!$!)+1$(+I$O)I(!)(
G)"-4( -)3!'( :'1H$!'1$( !$-( 5)1!$!)-( )H)13$-( :1).O"1$!$-( 'M)1H$!$-( :),$(
O1$%$( !+5+3$6( X'( )3H)3!)1( Y")( ?P( #'3S)#+$( 5+1H"$,I)3H)( $( $,I$4( 3)--)(
-)3H+!'4(-)(1)#'1!$(hi jjCEfkkf4(B<FFl6(X($,I$4()I(-"$(3$H"1)A$4()1$($(
grande responsável por promover evidências legítimas do seu contato com
G)"-6( ,$(1)V)H)4($()U)I:,'(!'()-:),S'4($(3$H"1)A$(!+5+3$(hbCj D4(7;;;l6
L'1(+--'4(XO'-H+3S'($#'3-),S'"(3'-(k1$H$!'-(-'01)('( 5$3Od,+'(!)(
D&'(y'&'Q([D)O"3!'('(I$)-H1'4(Y")(!+--+:$(3'--$-(H1)5$-(#'I(-"$(,"Aq('(
3'--'(5)1!$!)+1'(D',4(Y")(:)3)H1$(#'I(-)"-(1$+'-(3'--'-(#'1$%W)-q(3&'('(
-',(Y")($,I)?$I('-(',S'-(!$(#$13)4(I$-(-+I('(D',(Y")('-(',S'-(!'(#'1$%&'(
!)-)?$I( $1!)3H)I)3H)( Y")( -)( ,S)-( M$%$( 5+-n5),\( hXbfDkCEJf4( 7;;t4(
vCv4(B;4(:6(8>gl6(
E)--$(M'1I",$%&'(!'(S'I)I(+!)$,(#1+-H&'4()I(X(k1+3!$!)4(-"$(+!)+$(
M'+($:1)-)3H$!$(-)O"3!'('"H1$('1+)3H$%&'()($!Y"+1+"('"H1'(#'3H)^!'4(:,)3'(
!)($,)1H$()($Hd(I)-I'(!)($!5)1Hm3#+$Q([N$-(-)($,O"dI4(I)-I'($!5)1H+!'4(
3&'( #'3-)O")( !+-H+3O"+1( )--$-( 1)$,+!$!)-4( d( :'1Y")( )-HP( I)1O",S$!'(
em grande cegueira de coração e nas trevas da ignorância. Está assim
:1)#+-$3!'(!)($"Un,+'(!+5+3'(0)I(I$+-(:'!)1'-'(:$1$(#S)O$1(Z(5)1!$!)+1$(
-$0)!'1+$\(hXbfDkCEJf4(7;;tQ(vCe4(gQ<4(:6(8tBl6(
E)--)(-)"(I$O+-Hd1+'4(D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'(M'+(#$H)OK1+#'(#'I('(S'I)I(
Y")( -)( :1)H)3!+$( #1+-H&'4( #'I'( $:$1)#)( )I(X( O1$%$( !)( ]1+-H'( )( '( L)#$!'(
f1+O+3$,Q([j)+$I4(:'+-4()()3H)3!$I4(5)?$I()(#'3M)--)(Y")(G)"-4(3&'(:),$(,)+(
'"(:),$(!'"H1+3$(Y")(-'$I()UH)1+'1I)3H)4(I$-(:'1("I$(M'1%$(+3H)13$()('#",H$4(
$!I+1P5),()(+3)MP5),4(':)1$I(3'-(#'1$%W)-(S"I$3'-(3&'($:)3$-(1)5),$%W)-4(
I$-(H$I0dI($(0'$(5'3H$!)\(hXbfDkCEJf4(B<<94(C4(7t4(:6(7><l6(
G)--)(I'!'4(:'!)=-)(!+A)1(Y")($(#'3#):%&'(!)(C,"I+3$%&'(G+5+3$(
#'3-H+H"+"=-)( )I( I)HPM'1$( :)1M)+H$( !$( )!"#$%&'( #1+-H&4( 3$( I)!+!$( )I(
Y")()U:,+#$5$('-(+3H)1)--)-(#1+-H&'-()(3),)-(-)()3Y"$!1$5$(hp GfEGfq(
jXDLXjXD4( B<<gl6( L'1( )--)( I'H+5'4( )I( D)1IW)-4( D$3H'( XO'-H+3S'(
+3-+-H+$()I(-"$()U'1H$%&'Q([r666s(H'!'(3'--'()-M'1%'4(+1I&'-4(3)-H$(5+!$(SP(!)(
#'3-+-H+1()I(#"1$1('(',S'(!'(#'1$%&'(#'I(Y")(5m($(G)"-\(hXbfDkCEJf4(
B<9>4(99Qt4(:6(t8;l6
CI:'1H$( ,)I01$1( Y")( $( k)'1+$( !$( C,"I+3$%&'( G+5+3$( )-H1+0$=
-)4(Y")1(3'(-)"(-)3H+!'(I$+-()-H1+H'(Y")1(3'(-)"(-)3H+!'(I$+-($I:,'4(3'(
!"#$%&'()(*+,'-'.$(/0)1,23!+$4(56(784(36(894(:6(8;<=8>84(?",6@!)A6(7;B;6(CDDE(;B;7=F9;B 427
#'3S)#+I)3H'(1$#+'3$,4(#'I(0$-)(3'(M$H'(!)(Y")(D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'(-)(:1':u-(
$(1)V)H+1(-'01)("I(#'3S)#+I)3H'(O3'-+',KO+#'(:'-H",$3H)(!)(!'+-(#$I+3S'-(
!+M)1)3#+$!'-(:$1$(-)(#S)O$1(Z(1)$,+!$!)()(Z(5)1!$!)(hXbfDkCEJf4(B<9F4(
B7;Q74(:6(8g>l6
Dessa perspectiva a iluminação não pressupunha a passividade
!$( I)3H)( 3'( )U)1#n#+'( +3H),)#H+5'4( $( )U)I:,'( !)( "I$( H'H$,( #'3#)--&'(
do conhecimento por parte de Deus. A necessidade do ato intelectivo
)U:,+#$5$=-)(:),'(M$H'(!)(Y")($(+,"I+3$%&'(!+5+3$(3&'(,+Y"+!$5$($($%&'(!$(
5'3H$!)(S"I$3$4(3)I('()U)1#n#+'(!$(-"$(#'3!+%&'4(#'I'(#$"-$(-)O"3!$(
3)--)(:1'#)--'(hXbfDkCEJf4(B<t94(B7;Q7l6
C-H'(:'-H'4(!)5+$=-)(H)1()I(#'3H$('(#'3S)#+I)3H'(1)M)1)3H)($'-(-)1)-(
I$H)1+$+-4(:1)-)3H)-('"(+I$O+3$!'-4($#)--n5)+-($'(S'I)I(:),'-(-)3H+!'-()('(
1)M)1)3H)(Z-(+!)+$-(5+$0+,+A$!$-(:),$-(:$1H)-(I$+-(),)5$!$-(!$($,I$4([I)3H)\(
'"(+3H),+Om3#+$6(X:)-$1(!$-(!+M)1)3%$-(Y")(:$1H+#",$1+A$I()(-):$1$I()--$-(
I$3+M)-H$%W)-(!'(#'3S)#+I)3H'4()-H$-($--"I)I(5$,'1)-()(2I0+H'-(:1K:1+'-(
!)( $:,+#$%&'( hp GfEGfq( jXDLXjXD4( B<<gl4( #'3M'1I)( M'+( )U:,+#$!'(
)I(X(k1+3!$!)Q([j'3O)(!)(3K-4(H$I0dI4(!"5+!$1(!$(5)1!$!)(Y")(3'-(5)I(
:),'-( -)3H+!'-( #'1:'1$+-6( L'1( I)+'( !),)-4( $H)-H$I'-( $( )U+-Hm3#+$( !'( #d"(
)( !$( H)11$( )( !)( H"!'( '( I$+-( Y")( ),)-( #'3HmI4( 3$( I)!+!$( )I( Y")( $Y"),)(
Y")( 3'-( #1+'"( $( 3K-( )( $( ),)-4( Y"+-( Y")( !),)-( H+5d--)I'-( #'3S)#+I)3H'\(
hXbfDkCEJf4(7;;tQ(ve4(B7Q7B4(:6(tB7l6
Uma orientação nesse mesmo sentido também apareceu em A
#+!$!)(!)(G)"-Q([]1m(3'-(-)3H+!'-4(Y")(I$3+M)-H$I($-(1)$,+!$!)-()5+!)3H)-4(
)(!),)-(-)15)=-)($($,I$4(:'1(+3H)1Id!+'(!'(#'1:'4(:'+-(d(I$+-(I+-)1P5),('(
)3O$3'(!)(Y")I(:)3-$(Y")(3"3#$(-)(,S)-(!)5)(Md\(hXbfDkCEJf4(7;;>4(
B<4(veCCC4(:6(8;<l6
D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'( 3&'( 3)O$5$( $( 1)$,+!$!)( !'-( 0)3-( +3M)1+'1)-4( I$-(
#'3-+!)1$5$( Y")( 0$-H$5$( '"5+=,'-( hNXppf/4( B<tgl( :$1$( )3H)3!m=,'-( )(
"H+,+AP=,'-()I(M$5'1(!)("I(0)I(I$+'16(C--'(3&'(+I:,+#$5$(#'3-+!)1$1(Y")('(
#'3S)#+I)3H'(-)3-n5),(#$1)#+$(!)(5$,'14(I)-I'(Y")(-)"(I'H'1(M'--)I(#'+-$-(
!)( I)3'1( +I:'1H23#+$( Y"$3!'( #'I:$1$!$-( $'( #'3S)#+I)3H'( 1$#+'3$,6( L'1(
'"H1'(,$!'4()I(^,H+I$(+3-H23#+$4()--$-(I$3+M)-H$%W)-(!'(#'3S)#+I)3H'()1$I(
'1+O+3P1+$-(!)(G)"-4('(Y")(3&'($"H'1+A$5$()-Y")#)1(Y")($(+3H)15)3%&'@$%&'(
!+5+3$(M$A+$=-)(+I)!+$H$4(!+1)H$4()M)H+5$()()5+!)3H)(3$(:1'!"%&'(!$-(+!)+$-6(
N)-I'( $--+I4( :$1$( D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'4( 3&'( -)( :'!+$( 3)O$1( Y")( '(
428 !"#$%&'()(*+,'-'.$(/0)1,23!+$4(56(784(36(894(:6(8;<=8>84(?",6@!)A6(7;B;6(CDDE(;B;7=F9;B
#'3H+!$-(3$($,I$4(:'--+0+,+H$!$-(:),$(#'3H)I:,$%&'(+3H)1+'16(
f-( I)-H1)-4( 3$( 5)1!$!)4( 3$!$( )3-+3$5$I4( I$-( :1'5'#$5$I4(
)-H+I",$5$I( '-( !+-#n:",'-( $( 0"-#$1( '( #'3S)#+I)3H'4( '"( -)?$4( -)O"3!'(
)--$(H)-)4(:'1(I)+'(!$(M$,$(:1':1+$I)3H)(!+H$4('(!+-#n:",'(3$!$($:1)3!+$(
!'(I)-H1)4('"(I),S'14()-H)(3$!$()3-+3$5$($'(-)"(!+-#n:",'q(:'!+$(-'I)3H)(
+3#+HP=,'( $( 0"-#$14( )I( -)"( +3H)1+'14( $( 5)1!$!)( )H)13$( )( +I"HP5),4( '"( -)?$4(
!)-#'01+=,$(:'1(I)+'(!$(+3H)1+'1+A$%&'6(]$-'(M'--)(#1+$!$4(3&'(-)1+$()H)13$4(
I$-(H)I:'1$,()(I"HP5),q(!)('"H1$(M'1I$4(-)1+$("I(!)-#'01+I)3H'(1)$,+A$!'(
:),'-([',S'-(!$($,I$\6(
X( I+--&'( !'( I)-H1)( 3&'( )1$( "I$( H$1)M$( #1+$H+5$q( :),'( #'3H1P1+'4(
:'1(-)1("I(H1$!"H'1()(H1$3-I+--'1(!$(5)1!$!)(!+5+3$4(#$0+$=,S)(H1$!"A+1($(
:$,$51$(+3H)1+'1(o(Y")(d(-+O3'(!$(:$,$51$(!+5+3$(o()I("I(H+:'(!)(,+3O"$O)I(
Y")(M$#+,+H$--)($'-(-)3H+!'-(!'(!+-#n:",'(#$:H$1($(I)3-$O)I(-$O1$!$6
G$(:)1-:)#H+5$($O'-H+3+$3$(3)I(H'!'-()1$I(#$:$A)-(!)(:1'#)!)1(Z(
+3H)11'O$%&'(!$($,I$4(0)I(#'I'(!)(#'3-",H$1(-"$(,"A(+3H)1+'16(E)--)(#$-'4(
)1$( 3)#)--P1+'( $?"!P=,'-4( +3H)11'OP=,'-( hi jjCEfkkf4( B<FFl6(X--+I4( $(
#'3H)I:,$%&'(!$-(#'+-$-()(!'-('0?)H'-(-)(5+$0+,+A$5$(:'1(I)+'(!'([',S'(
!$( $,I$\6( XY"),)( Y")( +3H)11'O$5$( 3$!$( )3-+3$5$4( ?P( Y")( )--$( )1$( "I$(
faculdade do mestre interior.
L'1( I)+'( !$( :$,$51$4( '( I)-H1)( S"I$3'( )U:1)--$5$( $( 5)1!$!)(
)U+-H)3H)( 3'( )-:n1+H'( !'( !+-#n:",'4( Y")( :'!+$( )-#"H$1( )( )3H)3!)1( :'1Y")(
5+$(:),'([',S'(!$($,I$\4(M$A)3!'=-)(!+-#n:",'(!$(5)1!$!)6(XO'-H+3S'(3&'(
!)-#'3-+!)1$5$( $( :'--+0+,+!$!)( !)( '( I)-H1)4( $'( M$,$14( !)-#'3S)#)1( )( 3&'(
5)1(3'(+3H)1+'1(!$(-"$($,I$($(5)1!$!)(o(!+A+$('(Y")(3&'()1$(5)1!$!)+1'(:'1(
+O3'1$1($(5)1!$!)(o4(I$-($Y"),)(Y")('('"5+$(:'!+$(5)1(-)"(:1K:1+'(+3H)1+'1(
)(#'3S)#)1($(5)1!$!)6(L),$-(I)-I$-(:$,$51$-4('(:1+I)+1'()U:1)--$5$('(Y")(
-)(#'3-+!)1$5$(M$,-'()('(-)O"3!'(#'3H)I:,$5$('(5)1!$!)+1'4(:'1(I)+'(!'(
I)-H1)(+3H)1+'16(f-(!+--+I",$!'-()(I)3H+1'-'-(I'-H1$5$I4($'(M$,$14(Y")($-(
:$,$51$-(H$3H'()3-+3$5$I(Y"$3H'(:'!+$I()-#'3!)1($(5)1!$!)6(f(Y")(M$,$5$(
)U:1)--$5$('(Y")(:)3-$5$()('(Y")()-#"H$5$()3H)3!+$($(5)1!$!)q(:'1H$3H'4(
$-(:$,$51$-(3&'(-+O3+.#$5$I(:$1$('-(!'+-($(I)-I$(#'+-$(hXbfDkCEJf4(
B<9;04(vCC4(8;()(vCCC4(8>4(:6(>7;=>7Bl6
f($"Hm3H+#'(I)-H1)(3&'()1$('(Y")()U:,+#$5$()(-)()U:1)--$5$(:),$-(:$,$51$-4(
I$-(]1+-H'(Y")(S$0+H$5$(3'(:1K:1+'(S'I)I4('(Y"$,4(:'1(-"$(5)A4(#'3H)I:,$5$='(
:$1$(#S)O$1(Z(5)1!$!)(hXbfkCEJf4(B<9;04(vCe4(8t=8F4(:6>7>=>78l6
!"#$%&'()(*+,'-'.$(/0)1,23!+$4(56(784(36(894(:6(8;<=8>84(?",6@!)A6(7;B;6(CDDE(;B;7=F9;B 431
]'I(0$-)(3)--$(#'3#):%&'4($('#":$%&'(!'(+3H)1+'1(!'(S'I)I(:'1(G)"-(
favorecia sua ação no mundo.
--$( ,"H$( :),$( M'1I$%&'( S"I$3$4( 1),$#+'3$!$( Z( -"$( ,"H$( :),'(
#1+-H+$3+-I'4(1)V)H)('(-)"(Om3+'()-:)#",$H+5'()(5+-+'3P1+'(Y")4()-:)#+$,I)3H)(
3'()I0$H)(#'I('-(#+-IPH+#'-(!'3$H+-H$-4(H'I'"(!+I)3-W)-()($-:)#H'-(Y")(
:1)3"3#+$1$I($(C!$!)(Nd!+$6
G$(I)-I$(I$3)+1$4(3$(0$H$,S$(Y")(!)-)35',5)"(#'I'('-(:),$O+$3'-(
$0'1!'"($,O"I$-(:1'0,)IPH+#$-(Y")($()U)I:,'(!$(-$,5$%&'4(O1$%$4(,+51)=
$10nH1+'4(:1'5'#$1$I($-(!+-#"--W)-()M)15)-#)3H)-()($#$,'1$!$-(!'-(-d#",'-(
-)O"+3H)-6( L'1( )--)( I'H+5'4( $H1+0"+=-)( $( D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'( $( #'3!+%&'( !)(
1):1)-)3H$3H)(!)(!"$-(d:'#$-4(#"?'(-+O3+.#$H+5'(!+5+-'1(!)(PO"$-(M'+('($3'(
8B;4($3'(!'(-$Y")(!)(p'I$(:),'-(O'!'-6(
X'(-)(#'3-+!)1$1(Y")($(M'1I$%&'(#",H"1$,($O'-H+3+$3$(M'+($(!)("I(
#1+-H&'( !'( -d#",'( Ce4( H$I0dI( -)( M$A( 3)#)--P1+'( '0-)15$1( Y")( -"$-( '01$-(
)( #'3#):%W)-( H)',KO+#$-( )( .-+',KO+#$-( I$+-( +I:'1H$3H)-( !$( ^,H+I$( M$-)(
apontavam para os séculos seguintes.
L'!)=-)( +3M)1+1( Y")( $( H1$3-+%&'( S+-HK1+#$4( 1)-:'3-P5),( :),$(
instabilidade e pela dolorosa e sofrida conscientização da precariedade do
I"3!'4($(:'3H'(!)('(S'I)I()"1':)"(3&'(-)(#'3-+!)1$1('"(-)3H+1(#+!$!&'(
!$( 5),S$( '1!)I4( #"?'( !)-I'1'3$I)3H'( !)-#'1H+3$5$=-)( :$1$( H'!'-4( M'+(
-)3H+!$( )( '0-)15$!$( :'1( D$3H'( XO'-H+3S'( hNfp D]JCECq( Efp jjC4(
7;;;l4(#'3M'1I)(+3!+#$I(-"$-(1)V)UW)-6(
D"$( +3V"m3#+$( 3&'( -)( ,+I+H'"( $( )--)-( !'+-( :)1n'!'-( #'3V+H$3H)-4(
mas avançou pelos séculos posteriores modelando o comportamento dos
S'I)3-6(*'+(-":)1$!$4(:$1$($,O"3-()-H"!+'-'-4(-'I)3H)($'(,'3O'(!'(-d#",'(
vCCC4(#'I('(-"1O+I)3H'(!$-(O1$3!)-(:1'!"%W)-(+3H),)#H"$+-(!$()-#',P-H+#$6(
f( 5+O'1( !'( :)3-$I)3H'( $O'-H+3+$3'( M'+( 1)#":)1$!'( 3$( C!$!)( N'!)13$4(
Y"$3!'(:$--'"($('#":$1(,"O$1(!)(!)-H$Y")(3$-(!+-#"--W)-(!)-)3#$!)$!$-(
:),$( p)M'1I$( L1'H)-H$3H)4( Y")( '( H'I'"( #'I'( :'3H'( !)( 1)M)1m3#+$( :$1$(
-"$-(1)V)UW)-()($%W)-6(G)-H$Y")(H$I0dI(H)5)(3'(-d#",'(veCC4(:$,#'(!)(
G)-#$1H)-4( !'( 1$#+'3$,+-I'( )( !'( )I:+1+-I'( hbCj D4( 7;;;lQ( -"$-( '01$-(
M'1$I( )!+H$!$-( #"+!$!'-$I)3H)4( M'I)3H$3!'( 3'5$-( )( -+O3+.#$H+5$-(
discussões relacionadas ao pensar da modernidade.
X--+I4( D$3H'( XO'-H+3S'( H'13'"=-)( '( 1)M)1)3#+$,( !$( #1+-H$3!$!)4(
'( Y")( ,S)( 5$,)"( '( HnH",'( !)( [N)-H1)( !'( f#+!)3H)\6( L$1$( I"+H'-( !)( -)"-(
!"#$%&'()(*+,'-'.$(/0)1,23!+$4(56(784(36(894(:6(8;<=8>84(?",6@!)A6(7;B;6(CDDE(;B;7=F9;B 433
)-H"!+'-'-4(-"$(+I:'1H23#+$(-)(H'13$(H$3H'(I$+-()5+!)3H)(Y"$3H'4($:K-(-"$(
I'1H)4(#'I)%'"($('#'11)1($([$O'-H+3+A$%&'`(!'(f#+!)3H)6(D"$(+3V"m3#+$(d(
$,+(:)1#):Hn5),4(-)?$(:),$-(,)+H"1$-(Y")(-)(M$A(!)(-"$-('01$-4(!$-(!+-#"--W)-(
Y")($+3!$(:1'5'#$4(-)?$(:),'(M$H'(!)(-)1(+I+H$!'(hJXNNXE4(B<9;l6(XHd(
:'1( +--'4( ),)( [$:$1)#)( #'I'( '( :'1H$=5'A( !$( I$+-( #'3-H$3H)( )( $"H)3H+#$(
H1$!+%&'(#1+-H&\(hNXppf/4(B<tg4(:6(ttl6
D)O"3!'( '( I)-I'( J)31+( N$11'"4( 3+3O"dI( #'3H1+0"+"( H$3H'(
#'I'( D$3H'( XO'-H+3S'( :$1$( '( :1'O1)--'( !'( #'3S)#+I)3H'( !'( S'I)I4(
)-:)#+$,I)3H)( $( 1)-:)+H'( !'( Y")( )-H)( :'--"+( !)( I$+-( +3H)1+'14( !)( I$+-(
)--)3#+$,6( E)--$( !+1)%&'4( -'01)--$)I( -"$-( ]'3.--W)-4( 3$-( Y"$+-( I)1)#)(
:$1H+#",$1( !)-H$Y")( "I( !)( -)"-( H)UH'-( I$+-( )U:1)--+5'-( 3)--)( -)3H+!'Q(
[3$!$(I$+-(M$A+$(-)3&'(-"O$1('-(:)+H'-4(-$0'1)$1('(:1$A)1(r666s6( I(-)O"+!$(
#'I)#)+(H$I0dI($(1+1\(hXbfDkCEJf4(C4(F4gQ94(:6(B7=B>l6( --$(M1$-)(,$:+!$1(
aponta a precisão e a profundidade da dimensão psicológica de seu olhar na
volta ao passado: foi preciso o aparecimento de Freud e da psicanálise para
-)( #'I:1))3!)1( )( 5$,'1+A$1( '( #'3H)^!'( !)--$-( #'3-+!)1$%W)-( 3'( Y")( !+A(
1)-:)+H'(Z(5+!$(:1d=3$H$,4(Z(#'3!+%&'(:',+I'1M$(!$(#1+$3%$()(Z(:1'M"3!+!$!)(
de determinados traumatismos.
X(1+O'14('(Om3+'(-+3HdH+#'(!)(D$3H'(XO'-H+3S'(#'3H1+0"+"()M)H+5$I)3H)(
:$1$( S$1I'3+A$14( )I( "I( #'1:'( !'"H1+3P1+'4( '-( ),)I)3H'-( $--+I+,P5)+-( !$(
.,'-'.$( #,P--+#$( )( '-( M1$OI)3H'-( !'-( :$!1)-( #1+-H&'-( Y")( '( $3H)#)!)1$I6(
,)( ),$0'1'"( "I( 5$-H'( -+-H)I$( !)( I)H$Mn-+#$( #1+-H&4( #"?$( +3V"m3#+$4(
+3)O$5),I)3H)4(:)1!"1$($Hd(3'--'-(!+$-6
Referências