Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 57

Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New

DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,


Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

DETAILED ENGINEERING ASSESSMENT (DEA)


OF
EXISTING MEZZANINE FLOOR STEEL STRUCTURE OF BUILDING-01
AT 37, SOUTH SASTAPUR, UPAZILA ROAD, FATULLAH,
NARAYANGONJ-1420, BANGLADESH
(+23.638196N, +90.492288E)

NAME OF THE CLIENT:


ABLOOM DESIGN LTD.

Date of submission (Revised) : 25-07-2017

Name & Address of The Submitting Engineer:


Engr. Abdul Quddus
B.Sc. Engg(Civil, BUET),
DMINB/CE-0231
MIEB-21384

DESIGN & DEVELOPMENT SOLUTION


Road-#23, H-#337, Ground Floor
Mohakhali New DOHS
Dhaka-1206
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

TABLE OF CONTENT

Sl No Description
1.0 As-Built drawing
2.0 Load Applied on structure
3.0 Evidential Image of connections
4.0 Typical calculation considering gravity load
5.0 Proposed structural framing system
6.0 Software used for analyzing the structure
7.0 Input Data
7.1 Static Load case
7.2 Load combinations
8.0 Base Reaction
9.0 Design Report
10.0 Column adequacy check
11.0 Beam adequacy Check
12.0 Joint adequacy check
13.0 Conclusion & Recommendation
Signature Of the Engineer
Appendix
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

2.0 Load Applied on structure

Dead load: Self weight

Load Load: 40psf

Wind Load:

The calculation of wind load confirms the sub-clause 2.4, Chapter 2, Part-6 of BNBC.
The following equation has been used to calculate sustained wind pressure of the
structure.

Pz=CgCpCcCiCzVb2 [BNBC, 2.4.6.2,2.4.6.3 Page-6-33,6-34]


Wind load was applied in two orthogonal directions X and Y.
The following parameters are considered

1. Design wind speed =195 km/hr


2. Exposure Type =A
3. Importance factor, I = 1.0

Earth quake Load:

As per specifications of BNBC, Part-6, Chapter-2, section-2.5.51, Equivalent Static


Force Method can be applied to calculate the earth quake force of this structure.
Design Base Shear, V=ZICW/R (Ref. Sec2.5.6.1, Chapter-2, Part-6, BNBC)

Where,
1.0 Seismic Zone coefficient factor, Z=0.15 for Zone-02
(Ref.Table6.2.22 Sec2.5.6.1, Chap.-2, Part-6, BNBC)
2.0 Importance factor, I = 1.0
(Ref. Table 6.2.23 Sec2.5.6.1,Chap.-2,Part-6, BNBC)
3.0 Numerical Co-efficient, C=0.034 (for steel structure)
4.0 Response Modification factor, R=6 (Ordinary moment resisting frame)

Earth quake load was applied in two orthogonal directions X & Y.


Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

3.0 Evidential Image of connections

Type of connection: Member has been connected by welding.


Connection Details of mezzanine floor

01 02

03 04

05 06

4.0 Typical calculation considering gravity load:


Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Member size =200x100x6.5mm (I)


Capacity of column against compressive strength= 140kip
Capacity of column against buckling =42kip
Moment carrying capacity =30k-ft
Member size =200x50x5.5mm (Channel)
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Capacity of column against compressive strength= 42kip


Capacity of column against buckling =15kip
Moment carrying capacity =7k-ft
Load Calculation:
Self weight of slab=4.0/12*150=50psf
Additional load due to framing=10psf (Approximate)
Total dead load=60psf
Assume live load=A
Hence total factored load=1.4*60+1.7*A=84+1.7A
Check Channel section:
Due to moment:
WL2/8=7
W=7*8/62
So, W=1.55klf=1550plf
Or,( ((84+1.7A)*20.6)/6)*1.3=1550
Or, A=155psf
Check I-Section: (Beam-01)
Due to moment:
WL2/8=30
W=30*8/16.672
So, W=0.86klf=860plf
Or,( ((84+1.7A)*70)/16.67)*1.3=860
Or, A=43psf
40 psf load can be applied
Column Check:
Maximum effective area of a single column=62.5 sqft
Maximum Gravity Load on Each column is (84+1.7*38)*62.5=9.5kIP
This is less than the capacity of column
So maximum 38 psf live load can be applied on mezzanine floor.

Check edge supporting system:


I-Joist rest on an angle at edge which are connected with wall by 3-12mm dia bar
Maximum shear force at edge, V
Load on beam=(84+1.7*38)* maximum effective area/span length
=(149*78/15.33)=760plf
So sear force at edge=760*15.33/2=5.83kip
Shear resist by 3-12mm dia rod=0.3*40*3*0.175=6.30kip ; Hence ok

Present framing system is able to carry gravity load only but is unable to carry lateral load
earthquake & wind. So a few nos. of column & beam at specific locations is proposed to
resist lateral load.

6.0 Software used for analyze the structure:

ETABS 3D analysis is performed to check the structural adequacy.


Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

7.0 INPUT DATA

7.1 Static Load Case


Load Case Type
DEAD DEAD
LIVE LIVE
WINDX WIND
WINDY WIND
EQX QUQKE
EQY QUAKE

7.2 Load Combinations:


Combo Type Case Factor CaseType

WSD ADD DEAD 1 Static


WSD LIVE 1 Static
ACC1 ADD DEAD 1.2 Static
ACC1 LIVE 1.6 Static
ACC2 ADD DEAD 1.2 Static
ACC2 LIVE 0.5 Static
ACC2 WINDX 1.3 Static
ACC3 ADD DEAD 1.2 Static
ACC3 LIVE 0.5 Static
ACC3 WINDX -1.3 Static
ACC4 ADD DEAD 1.2 Static
ACC4 LIVE 0.5 Static
ACC4 WINDY 1.3 Static
ACC5 ADD DEAD 1.2 Static
ACC5 LIVE 0.5 Static
ACC5 WINDY -1.3 Static
ACC6 ADD DEAD 1.2 Static
ACC6 LIVE 0.5 Static
ACC6 QUAKEX 1.5 Static
ACC7 ADD DEAD 1.2 Static
ACC7 LIVE 0.5 Static
ACC7 QUAKEX -1.5 Static
ACC8 ADD DEAD 1.2 Static
ACC8 LIVE 0.5 Static
ACC8 QUAKEY 1.5 Static
ACC9 ADD DEAD 1.2 Static
ACC9 LIVE 0.5 Static
ACC9 QUAKEY -1.5 Static
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

8. 0 FOUNDATION ADEQUACY CHECK:

SOIL CAPACITY CALCULATION:


From soil test report, Bearing capacity of soil at 5’-0” level (Table-4)
Avg. allowable bearing capacity, Qall=(1.18+0.46+0.28+0.46+1.00)/5=0.676tsf (FOS=2.5)

Bearing capacity compliance (Existing condition)

Allowable Bearing Capacity of soil , qa=0.676tsf (FOS=2.5)


Service Area of
Current
Load footing
Point Footing ID. Remarks
(DL+LL)
sqft FOS
Kip
440 WSD 11.39 9 2.68 ADEQUATE
441 WSD 10.93 9 2.79 ADEQUATE
444 WSD 10.93 9 2.79 ADEQUATE
424 WSD 10.7 9 2.85 ADEQUATE
435 WSD 10.25 9 2.97 ADEQUATE
422 WSD 9.42 9 3.23 ADEQUATE
442 WSD 8.97 9 3.4 ADEQUATE
436 WSD 8.93 9 3.41 ADEQUATE
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

445 WSD 8.85 9 3.44 ADEQUATE


421 WSD 8.47 9 3.6 ADEQUATE
483 WSD 8.13 9 3.75 ADEQUATE
418 WSD 7.95 9 3.83 ADEQUATE
426 WSD 7.89 9 3.86 ADEQUATE
446 WSD 7.61 9 4 ADEQUATE
447 WSD 7.22 9 4.22 ADEQUATE
428 WSD 6.98 9 4.36 ADEQUATE
419 WSD 6.82 9 4.47 ADEQUATE
427 WSD 6.7 9 4.55 ADEQUATE
434 WSD 6.25 9 4.87 ADEQUATE
438 WSD 5.43 9 5.61 ADEQUATE
420 WSD 5.35 9 5.69 ADEQUATE
439 WSD 5.3 9 5.74 ADEQUATE
437 WSD 5.28 9 5.77 ADEQUATE
448 WSD 4.66 9 6.53 ADEQUATE
433 WSD 3.67 9 8.29 ADEQUATE
443 WSD 3.63 9 8.39 ADEQUATE
432 WSD 3.53 9 8.62 ADEQUATE
429 WSD 2.69 9 11.31 ADEQUATE
425 WSD 2.43 9 12.52 ADEQUATE
431 WSD 1.76 9 17.29 ADEQUATE
423 WSD 1.28 9 23.77 ADEQUATE
430 WSD 0.8 9 38.03 ADEQUATE

Bearing capacity compliance (After Beam retrofitting)

Allowable Bearing Capacity of soil , qa=0.676tsf (FOS=2.5)


Area of
Service Load Current
footing
Point Footing ID. Remarks
(DL+LL) Kip sqft FOS

441 F1 10.95 9 2.78 ADEQUATE


444 F1 10.93 9 2.79 ADEQUATE
422 F1 9.39 9 3.24 ADEQUATE
426 F1 9.36 9 3.25 ADEQUATE
442 F1 8.97 9 3.4 ADEQUATE
436 F1 8.88 9 3.43 ADEQUATE
445 F1 8.85 9 3.44 ADEQUATE
421 F1 8.46 9 3.6 ADEQUATE
483 F1 8.14 9 3.74 ADEQUATE
446 F1 7.61 9 4 ADEQUATE
447 F1 7.21 9 4.22 ADEQUATE
440 F1 7.19 9 4.24 ADEQUATE
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

418 F1 7.04 9 4.33 ADEQUATE


428 F1 6.98 9 4.36 ADEQUATE
419 F1 6.71 9 4.54 ADEQUATE
427 F1 6.7 9 4.55 ADEQUATE
435 F1 6.65 9 4.58 ADEQUATE
547 F1 6.33 9 4.81 ADEQUATE
434 F1 6.25 9 4.87 ADEQUATE
448 F1 5.67 9 5.37 ADEQUATE
438 F1 5.43 9 5.61 ADEQUATE
420 F1 5.35 9 5.69 ADEQUATE
439 F1 5.3 9 5.74 ADEQUATE
437 F1 5.28 9 5.77 ADEQUATE
476 F1 5.12 9 5.95 ADEQUATE
424 F1 4.45 9 6.84 ADEQUATE
425 F1 4.07 9 7.48 ADEQUATE
433 F1 3.67 9 8.29 ADEQUATE
443 F1 3.63 9 8.39 ADEQUATE
432 F1 3.53 9 8.62 ADEQUATE
429 F1 2.69 9 11.31 ADEQUATE
431 F1 1.76 9 17.29 ADEQUATE
423 F1 1.28 9 23.77 ADEQUATE
430 F1 0.8 9 38.03 ADEQUATE

Comments: All footings are adequate.


Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

9.0 ETABS Output Data:

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 1

PROJECT INFORMATION

Company Name = DESIGN & DEVELOPMENT SOLUTION


Client Name = ABLOOM SWEATERS LTD
Project Name = MEZZANINE FLOOR

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 2

S T O R Y D A T A

STORY SIMILAR TO HEIGHT ELEVATION

STORY2 None 84.000 84.000


BASE None 0.000

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 3

S T A T I C L O A D C A S E S

STATIC CASE AUTO LAT SELF WT NOTIONAL NOTIONAL


CASE TYPE LOAD MULTIPLIER FACTOR DIRECTION

DEAD DEAD N/A 1.0000


LIVE LIVE N/A 0.0000
WINDX WIND UBC94 0.0000
WINDY WIND UBC94 0.0000
QUAKEX QUAKE UBC94 0.0000
QUAKEY QUAKE UBC94 0.0000

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 4

A U T O W I N D U B C 9 4
Case: WINDX

AUTO WIND INPUT DATA

Exposure From: Rigid diaphragm extents


Direction Angle = 0 degrees
Windward Cq = 1.0303
Leeward Cq = 0.00000000001

Top Story: STORY2


Bottom Story: BASE

No parapet is included

Basic Wind Speed, V = 121 mph


Exposure Type = B
Importance Factor, Iw = 1

AUTO WIND EXPOSURE WIDTH INFORMATION (Exposure widths are from diaphragm extents)

STORY DIAPHRAGM WIDTH X Y

STORY2 D1 396.840 561.720 198.420

AUTO WIND CALCULATION FORMULAS

P = wind pressure = SUM(Ce Cq qs Iw) -- Method 1

Ce, the combined height, exposure and gust factor coefficient, is from UBC94 Table 16-G

qs is the wind stagnation pressure at the standard height of 33 feet


qs = 0.00256 V^2 >= 10 psf

AUTO WIND CALCULATION RESULTS


Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

qs = 37.4810 psf

AUTO WIND STORY FORCES

STORY FX FY FZ MX MY MZ

STORY2 2.77 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.000 -549.862

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 5

A U T O W I N D U B C 9 4
Case: WINDY

AUTO WIND INPUT DATA

Exposure From: Rigid diaphragm extents


Direction Angle = 0 degrees
Windward Cq = 1.4323
Leeward Cq = 0.000000000001

Top Story: STORY2


Bottom Story: BASE

No parapet is included

Basic Wind Speed, V = 121 mph


Exposure Type = B
Importance Factor, Iw = 1

AUTO WIND EXPOSURE WIDTH INFORMATION (Exposure widths are from diaphragm extents)

STORY DIAPHRAGM WIDTH X Y

STORY2 D1 396.840 561.720 198.420

AUTO WIND CALCULATION FORMULAS

P = wind pressure = SUM(Ce Cq qs Iw) -- Method 1

Ce, the combined height, exposure and gust factor coefficient, is from UBC94 Table 16-G

qs is the wind stagnation pressure at the standard height of 33 feet


qs = 0.00256 V^2 >= 10 psf

AUTO WIND CALCULATION RESULTS

qs = 37.4810 psf

AUTO WIND STORY FORCES

STORY FX FY FZ MX MY MZ

STORY2 3.85 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.000 -764.406

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 6

A U T O S E I S M I C U B C 9 4
Case: QUAKEX

AUTO SEISMIC INPUT DATA

Direction: X
Typical Eccentricity = 5%
Eccentricity Overrides: No

Period Calculation: Program Calculated


Ct = 0.034 (in feet units)
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Top Story: STORY2


Bottom Story: BASE

Rw = 6
Z = 0.15
S = 1.5
I = 1
hn = 84.000 (Building Height)

AUTO SEISMIC CALCULATION FORMULAS

Ta = Ct (hn^(3/4))

If Z >= 0.35 (Zone 4) then: If Tetabs <= 1.30 Ta then T = Tetabs, else T = Ta
If Z < 0.35 (Zone 1, 2 or 3) then: If Tetabs <= 1.40 Ta then T = Tetabs, else T = Ta

V = Z I C W / Rw

C = (1.25 S) / (T^(2/3))
C <= 2.75
C >= 0.075 Rw, that is, C >= 0.4500

If T <= 0.7 sec, then Ft = 0


If T > 0.7 sec, then Ft = 0.07 T V <= 0.25 V

AUTO SEISMIC CALCULATION RESULTS

Ta = 0.1463 sec
T Used = 0.2048 sec
C Used = 2.7500
W Used = 244.98

V Used = 0.0688W = 16.84

Ft Used = 0.00

AUTO SEISMIC STORY FORCES

STORY FX FY FZ MX MY MZ

STORY2 16.84 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.000 -3053.196

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 7

A U T O S E I S M I C U B C 9 4
Case: QUAKEY

AUTO SEISMIC INPUT DATA

Direction: Y
Typical Eccentricity = 5%
Eccentricity Overrides: No

Period Calculation: Program Calculated


Ct = 0.034 (in feet units)

Top Story: STORY2


Bottom Story: BASE

Rw = 6
Z = 0.15
S = 1.5
I = 1
hn = 84.000 (Building Height)

AUTO SEISMIC CALCULATION FORMULAS

Ta = Ct (hn^(3/4))

If Z >= 0.35 (Zone 4) then: If Tetabs <= 1.30 Ta then T = Tetabs, else T = Ta
If Z < 0.35 (Zone 1, 2 or 3) then: If Tetabs <= 1.40 Ta then T = Tetabs, else T = Ta
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

V = Z I C W / Rw

C = (1.25 S) / (T^(2/3))
C <= 2.75
C >= 0.075 Rw, that is, C >= 0.4500

If T <= 0.7 sec, then Ft = 0


If T > 0.7 sec, then Ft = 0.07 T V <= 0.25 V

AUTO SEISMIC CALCULATION RESULTS

Ta = 0.1463 sec
T Used = 0.2048 sec
C Used = 2.7500
W Used = 244.98

V Used = 0.0688W = 16.84

Ft Used = 0.00

AUTO SEISMIC STORY FORCES

STORY FX FY FZ MX MY MZ

STORY2 0.00 16.84 0.00 0.000 0.000 9502.117

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 8

M A S S S O U R C E D A T A

MASS LATERAL LUMP MASS


FROM MASS ONLY AT STORIES

Loads No No

M A S S S O U R C E L O A D S

LOAD MULTIPLIER

DEAD 1.0000

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 9

D I A P H R A G M M A S S D A T A

STORY DIAPHRAGM MASS-X MASS-Y MMI X-M Y-M

STORY2 D1 0.000E+00 0.000E+00 0.000E+00 559.577 140.975

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 10

A S S E M B L E D P O I N T M A S S E S

STORY UX UY UZ RX RY RZ

STORY2 6.345E-01 6.345E-01 6.345E-01 0.000E+00 0.000E+00 0.000E+00


BASE 4.210E-03 4.210E-03 4.210E-03 0.000E+00 0.000E+00 0.000E+00
Totals 6.387E-01 6.387E-01 6.387E-01 0.000E+00 0.000E+00 0.000E+00

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 11

C E N T E R S O F C U M U L A T I V E M A S S & C E N T E R S O F R I G I D I T
Y

STORY DIAPHRAGM /----------CENTER OF MASS----------//--CENTER OF RIGIDITY--/


LEVEL NAME MASS ORDINATE-X ORDINATE-Y ORDINATE-X ORDINATE-Y

STORY2 D1 0.000E+00 0.000 0.000 583.714 166.964

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 12

MODAL INFORMATION
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Modal Analysis not done.

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 13

TOTAL REACTIVE FORCES (RECOVERED LOADS) AT ORIGIN

LOAD FX FY FZ MX MY MZ

DEAD 1.326E-13 8.315E-14 2.469E+02 4.493E+04 -1.393E+05 1.801E-11


LIVE 4.930E-14 3.252E-14 9.324E+01 1.698E+04 -5.280E+04 8.191E-12
WINDX -2.771E+00 5.102E-13 2.416E-19 -4.286E-11 -2.328E+02 5.499E+02
WINDY -3.852E+00 7.093E-13 -1.536E-20 -5.958E-11 -3.236E+02 7.644E+02
QUAKEX -1.684E+01 -6.021E-13 -2.817E-17 5.057E-11 -1.415E+03 3.053E+03
QUAKEY -8.021E-13 -1.684E+01 -9.114E-18 1.415E+03 -6.741E-11 -9.502E+03

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 14

S T O R Y F O R C E S

STORY LOAD P VX VY T MX
MY

STORY2 WINDX 2.229E-04 -9.113E-04 4.373E-05 2.220E-01 5.895E-03 -


2.459E-02
STORY2 WINDY 3.099E-04 -1.267E-03 6.079E-05 3.086E-01 8.195E-03 -
3.418E-02
STORY2 QUAKEX 8.492E-05 -1.022E-02 1.177E-04 1.706E+00 -1.400E-01 -
5.211E-01
STORY2 QUAKEY 4.285E-05 -1.469E-04 -1.039E-02 -3.486E+00 6.325E-01 -
2.183E-01

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 15

STORY DRIFTS

STORY DIRECTION LOAD MAX DRIFT

STORY2 X WINDX 1/498694


STORY2 X WINDY 1/358727
STORY2 X QUAKEX 1/313227
STORY2 Y QUAKEY 1/173440

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 16

DISPLACEMENTS AT DIAPHRAGM CENTER OF MASS

STORY DIAPHRAGM LOAD UX UY RZ

STORY2 D1 WINDX 0.0000 0.0000 0.00000


BASE D1 WINDX 0.0000 0.0000 0.00000
STORY2 D1 WINDY 0.0000 0.0000 0.00000
BASE D1 WINDY 0.0000 0.0000 0.00000
STORY2 D1 QUAKEX 0.0002 0.0000 0.00000
BASE D1 QUAKEX 0.0000 0.0000 0.00000
STORY2 D1 QUAKEY 0.0000 0.0002 0.00000
BASE D1 QUAKEY 0.0000 0.0000 0.00000

ETABS v9.7.4 File:MEZZANINE FLOOR 15.05.2017 Units:Kip-in May 14, 2017 15:20 PAGE 17

STORY MAXIMUM AND AVERAGE LATERAL DISPLACEMENTS

STORY LOAD DIR MAXIMUM AVERAGE RATIO

STORY2 WINDX X 0.0002 0.0001 1.999


STORY2 WINDY X 0.0002 0.0001 1.999
STORY2 QUAKEX X 0.0003 0.0001 1.807
STORY2 QUAKEY Y 0.0005 0.0002 1.941
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

10.0 Column adequacy check:

Tensile strength of steel=36ksi

Column adequacy check(Existing condition)

Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio


STORY2 C4 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.486
STORY2 C9 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.443
STORY2 C11 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.212
STORY2 C14 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.155
STORY2 C16 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.205
STORY2 C18 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.847
STORY2 C19 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.591
STORY2 C20 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.538
STORY2 C21 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.242
STORY2 C22 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.801
STORY2 C23 I2-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.705
STORY2 C49 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.746
STORY2 C50 I2-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.871
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio


STORY2 C63 PIPE ACC1(C) 0.016
STORY2 C70 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.202
STORY2 C71 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.995
STORY2 C72 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.415
STORY2 C73 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.069
STORY2 C78 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.787
STORY2 C79 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.109
STORY2 C80 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.207
STORY2 C81 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.797
STORY2 C82 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.142
STORY2 C83 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.142
STORY2 C84 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.112
STORY2 C85 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.089
STORY2 C86 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.56
STORY2 C87 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.408
STORY2 C88 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.082
STORY2 C89 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.84
STORY2 C90 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.099
STORY2 C91 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.584
STORY2 C92 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.129
STORY2 C93 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.095

Column adequacy check(After proposing steel column)

Steel Columns - Stress Check Output - AISC-LRFD93


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
GB C1 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.607
GB C2 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.963
GB C3 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.108
GB C4 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.687
GB C5 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.789
GB C6 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.026
GB C7 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.345
GB C8 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.229
GB C9 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.263
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Steel Columns - Stress Check Output - AISC-LRFD93


Story ColLine SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
GB C10 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.211
GB C11 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.557
GB C12 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.202
GB C13 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.017
GB C14 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.169
GB C15 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.281
GB C16 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.276
GB C17 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.201
GB C18 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.207
GB C19 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.691
GB C20 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.146
GB C22 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.404
GB C23 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.085
GB C24 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.828
GB C25 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.774
GB C26 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.213
GB C27 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.862
GB C28 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.689
GB C29 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.589
GB C30 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.568
GB C31 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.095
GB C33 P1 ACC1(T) 0.023
GB C34 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.133
GB C35 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.552
GB C36 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.149
GB C37 I-SECTION ACC1(C) 0.387

Comments: For structural members adequacy several new steel columns has
been proposed.
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

11 Beam adequacy check:

Beam adequacy check:(Existing condition)


Steel Beams - Stress Check Output - AISC-LRFD93
Story BayID SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
GB B425 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.777
GB B426 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0
GB B427 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B428 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.001
GB B429 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.001
GB B430 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B432 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.039
GB B433 ANGLE ACC1(T) 0.344
GB B434 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.079
GB B435 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B436 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.001
GB B437 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.169
GB B438 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.194
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Steel Beams - Stress Check Output - AISC-LRFD93


Story BayID SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
GB B439 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.11
GB B440 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.213
GB B441 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.051
GB B443 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.09
GB B444 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.101
GB B445 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.319
GB B448 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.461
GB B449 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.522
GB B452 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.707
GB B453 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.054
GB B454 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B455 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B457 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.51
GB B458 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.221
GB B459 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.074
GB B460 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.169
GB B461 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.486
GB B464 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.086
GB B466 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.414
GB B469 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.013
GB B470 I-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.009
GB B472 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.004
GB B473 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.323
GB B474 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.154
GB B475 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B476 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B478 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.912
GB B479 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 1.073
GB B481 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.487
GB B484 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.051
GB B485 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.056
GB B486 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B487 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B488 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.031
GB B489 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.051
GB B490 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B491 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.001
GB B492 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B493 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.049
GB B494 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.136
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Steel Beams - Stress Check Output - AISC-LRFD93


Story BayID SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
GB B495 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.004
GB B497 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.004
GB B499 ANGLE ACC1(T) 0.691
GB B500 ANGLE ACC9(T) 0.033
GB B501 ANGLE ACC9(T) 0.031
GB B502 ANGLE ACC1(T) 0.283
GB B510 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.03
GB B512 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.004
GB B514 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.259
GB B524 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.006
GB B532 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B534 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.43
GB B536 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.433
GB B537 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 1.022
GB B539 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.719
GB B540 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.768
GB B541 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.135
GB B542 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.015
GB B546 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.52
GB B547 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.277
GB B548 ANGLE ACC9(T) 0.11
GB B550 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.689
GB B551 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.731
GB B552 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.023
GB B553 ANGLE ACC9(T) 0.03
GB B554 ANGLE ACC1(T) 0.698

Comments: For structural members adequacy several new steel floor beams has
been proposed.
A single floor beam is inadequate. Inadequate members are proposed to
strengthen.

Beam adequacy check:(After retrofitting condition)

Steel Beams - Stress Check Output - AISC-LRFD93


Story BayID SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
GB B425 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.745
GB B426 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0
GB B427 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.001
GB B428 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.001
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Steel Beams - Stress Check Output - AISC-LRFD93


Story BayID SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
GB B429 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.001
GB B430 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B432 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.039
GB B433 ANGLE ACC1(T) 0.345
GB B434 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.387
GB B435 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B436 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.001
GB B437 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.169
GB B438 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.194
GB B439 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.11
GB B440 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.213
GB B441 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.051
GB B443 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.09
GB B444 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.101
GB B445 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.314
GB B448 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.451
GB B449 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.534
GB B452 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.517
GB B453 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.054
GB B454 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B455 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B457 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.339
GB B458 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.221
GB B459 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.074
GB B460 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.169
GB B461 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.486
GB B464 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.086
GB B466 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.414
GB B469 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.013
GB B470 I-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.009
GB B472 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.004
GB B473 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.323
GB B474 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.154
GB B475 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B476 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B478 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.914
GB B479 RMB ACC1(T) 0.737
GB B481 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.335
GB B484 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.051
GB B485 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.056
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

Steel Beams - Stress Check Output - AISC-LRFD93


Story BayID SecID PMMCombo PMMRatio
GB B486 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B487 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B488 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.031
GB B489 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.051
GB B490 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B491 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.001
GB B492 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B493 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.049
GB B494 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.136
GB B495 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.004
GB B497 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.004
GB B499 ANGLE ACC1(C) 0.106
GB B499 ANGLE ACC1(T) 0.691
GB B500 ANGLE ACC9(T) 0.033
GB B501 ANGLE ACC9(T) 0.031
GB B502 ANGLE ACC1(T) 0.283
GB B510 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.03
GB B512 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.004
GB B514 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.258
GB B524 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.006
GB B532 C-SECTION ACC9(T) 0.002
GB B534 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.43
GB B536 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.415
GB B537 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 1.022
GB B539 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.113
GB B540 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.17
GB B541 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.135
GB B542 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.015
GB B546 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.521
GB B547 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.277
GB B548 ANGLE ACC9(T) 0.11
GB B550 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.093
GB B551 I-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.113
GB B552 C-SECTION ACC1(T) 0.027
GB B553 ANGLE ACC9(T) 0.03
GB B554 ANGLE ACC1(T) 0.698
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

12.0 Joint check:


Table: joint shear
Point Load FX FY

2 ENVELOP MAX 2.05 0.87


2 ENVELOP MIN -1.92 -1.00
24 ENVELOP MAX 2.38 0.90
24 ENVELOP MIN -1.90 -1.22
25 ENVELOP MAX 1.98 1.16
25 ENVELOP MIN -1.59 -1.49
26 ENVELOP MAX 0.82 0.27
26 ENVELOP MIN -0.68 -0.29
27 ENVELOP MAX 0.85 0.31
27 ENVELOP MIN -0.64 -0.40
29 ENVELOP MAX 1.03 0.35
29 ENVELOP MIN -0.94 -0.35
30 ENVELOP MAX 0.59 0.51
30 ENVELOP MIN -1.15 -1.11
32 ENVELOP MAX 0.95 0.36
32 ENVELOP MIN -0.96 -0.41
33 ENVELOP MAX 0.50 0.39
33 ENVELOP MIN -0.50 -0.37
45 ENVELOP MAX 1.64 4.45
45 ENVELOP MIN -1.65 -4.04
46 ENVELOP MAX 1.67 2.40
46 ENVELOP MIN -1.46 -2.24
53 ENVELOP MAX 1.56 1.39
53 ENVELOP MIN -1.40 -1.65
58 ENVELOP MAX 1.01 1.27
58 ENVELOP MIN -0.98 -1.34
59 ENVELOP MAX 0.44 0.44
59 ENVELOP MIN -0.39 -0.56
61 ENVELOP MAX 1.67 1.58
61 ENVELOP MIN -1.62 -1.58
63 ENVELOP MAX 0.52 0.88
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

63 ENVELOP MIN -0.65 -1.03


65 ENVELOP MAX 0.07 0.16
65 ENVELOP MIN -0.07 -0.15
66 ENVELOP MAX 0.26 0.13
66 ENVELOP MIN -0.17 -0.22
76 ENVELOP MAX 1.10 1.01
76 ENVELOP MIN -0.88 -0.84
77 ENVELOP MAX 0.74 0.83
77 ENVELOP MIN -0.79 -0.72
78 ENVELOP MAX 0.53 0.44
78 ENVELOP MIN -0.50 -0.79
79 ENVELOP MAX 0.62 1.20
79 ENVELOP MIN -0.99 -1.71
236 ENVELOP MAX 1.14 1.04
236 ENVELOP MIN -1.09 -1.12
672 ENVELOP MAX 0.41 0.23
672 ENVELOP MIN -0.42 -0.22
685 ENVELOP MAX 1.37 1.55
685 ENVELOP MIN -1.28 -1.65

Joint Check (Beam column):


Maximum shear, Fx=2.38kip
Thickness of welding, s=3/16in
Allowable shear in weld, Fv=0.3*40=12Kip
Assume length of weld=L
Then,
L*s*Fv=Fx
L*3/16*12=2.38
L=1.05in
But minimum welding length, L=4s=4*3/16=0.75in
So required welding length, Lr=1.05in
Provided length, Lp=(4+4)=8in; Hence ok

Edge joint (join in brick wall) check:

Maximum vertical shear, Fy=4.45Kip


3-12mm dia bar provided in edge support
So resisting force, Fr=0.3fy*3*As=0.3*40*3*0.175=6.3kip >4.45; Hence ok
Lane #23, House-B-160, Ground Floor, New
DOHS, Mohakhali, Dhaka-1212,
Mobile: +8801718612966,
E-mail: quddus_ce@yahoo.com

13.0 Conclusion & Recommendation:

The following observation has been found.

1. Present structural system is adequate to carry 40psf live load


2. To ensure structural adequacy due to lateral loading a few nos of column & beam is proposed
in specific locations. A floor beam is inadequate. Inadequate beams are proposed to
strengthen.
3. Foundation system adequate.

Thanking You

Md. Abdul Quddus


B.Sc Engg. (Civil, BUET)
MIEB-21384, DMINB/CE-0231
CEO & Structural Designer
DESIGN & DEVELOPMENT SOLUTION

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi