Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Received 08.04.2001
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to investigate the relationship between methylene blue value, initial soil
suction and the swell percentage of expansive soil samples. In this study, commercially processed kaolinite
and bentonite mineral clays were mixed in preselected proportions to obtain soil samples possessing a
wide range of plasticities and different swell percentages. The methylene blue adsorption tests, suction
measurements using a thermocouple psychrometer technique and standard free swell tests in oedometer
cells (ASTM D4546-90) were conducted on samples of kaolinite-bentonite mixtures. The results indicated a
linear relationship between methylene blue value and swell percent and also between initial soil suction (Log)
and swell percent. The experimental relationship which directly relates the methylene blue value and initial
soil suction to the swell percent is established, the reliability of the swell percent prediction method based
on methylene blue value and initial soil suction (Log10 ) data is evaluated, and the coefficient of correlation
(R2 ) of this relationship is 0.992.
Key words: Expansive soil, Methylene blue value, Psychrometer, Swell percent, Soil suction
521
ÇOKÇA
can be defined as the free energy of soil water with Methylene blue adsorption test method (see
respect to that of a pool of pure water located outside Figure 1)
the soil at the same elevation. In other words, the
free energy difference is the work done to draw the The basic relationship in MBA analyses of clays in
pure water into the soil by countering the friction re- materials is that a ground powder is titrated with
sisting the flow of water and expanding the lattice of methylene blue dye, and a spot tested on filter pa-
soil. Two components of total suction, namely, “ma- per until the spot of material absorbs no more dye
trix” τm and “osmotic” τs suctions, are recognised. as evidenced by a lighter blue ring around the darker
Matrix suction reflects the forces emanating from the blue ring of the spot tested.
solid matrix of the soil for the retention of water. It After investigation, the following procedure was
includes the effect of the particle surface (adsorp- found to be the most convenient means of performing
tive) forces and the capillary tensile forces related the test. About 30 g of soil (dry equivalent) is mixed
to spatial pore-size distribution in the soil. Osmotic (speed of mixer is 700 rpm) with 200 mL of distilled
suction represents the effect of dissolved substances water. Once the mixture is homogeneous, a known
in retaining soil water and results from the differ- amount of methylene blue at a concentration of 10
ence in solute concentrations at different points in g/L is added to the soil suspension from a burette.
the soil water (Edil and Motan, 1984). In soils con- The soil water-methylene blue mixture is than agi-
taining very low salt concentrations in pore water, tated (at 400 rpm throughout the test). After each
psychrometric readings are essentially indicative of addition of methylene blue to the soil suspension, a
the matrix suction (Edil and Motan, 1984). Volume drop of the slurry is placed on a filter paper with a
changes in expansive soils are generally caused by glass rod for visual examination.
moisture variations that cause changes in the matrix Initially, a faint blue spot of solids is observed
suction stress state variable τm = (ua - uw ). surrounded by a transparent ring of clear liquid that
Recently psychrometers, which measure total soon evaporates. As titration proceeds, the colour
suction, have received increased usage in measuring of the inner spot becomes progressively darker blue
the suction of soil in the laboratory. as the clay adsorbs more dye, but the boundary of
The purpose of this study was to investigate the blue spot remains clearly marked and distinct.
the relationship between the methylene blue value Eventually, the end point is reached when the out-
(MBV), initial soil suction and the swell percent of line boundary of the inner blue spot breaks down into
expansive soil samples. For this reason, all the other a diffuse light blue-green halo, radiating outwards.
factors were eliminated or kept constant throughout At the first appearance of the blue-green halo,
the test program. titration is stopped and the drop test on filter pa-
per repeated five times. If the halo persists, the end
point has been reached; if not, titration is continued.
Methylene Blue Adsorption Test
Note the burette reading at this point and deduct
Adsorption of methylene blue by clay miner- the initial reading from it to give the volume of the
als methylene blue solution injected into the soil solu-
tion, Vcc (when learning the test, it is worthwhile to
Methylene blue is a large polar organic molecule carry the additions of methylene blue solution sev-
which is adsorbed onto the negatively charged sur- eral steps beyond the end point to compare MBA
faces of clay minerals. The amount of methylene before and after the end point).
blue adsorbed by a given mass of clay depends on For 100 g of fine soil, the MBV of the soil is given
the relative concentration of negatively charged sites by the following equation:
on the clay particle surfaces, and on the surface area
of the clay per unit mass.
Because methylene blue molecules are prefer- [Vcc (mL).10(g).100(g)]
MBV (g/100g) = (1)
entially adsorbed onto the negatively charged site [1000(mL).f 0 (g)]
which might otherwise attract cations, titration with
methylene blue can also be considered to give a rel- where
ative measure of the cation exchange capacity of a Vcc = volume of the methylene blue solution in-
clay soil (Cokca and Birand, 1993). jected into the soil solution, mL
522
ÇOKÇA
START
5 cm3
Methylene Blue
Negative
Methylene Blue Positive 5 times
End of
Adsorption Test Test
2 cm3
Methylene Blue
Negative
Methylene Blue
Adsorption Test
Positive
5 times
End of Test
humid zone
Methylene Blue
fixed
523
ÇOKÇA
tus manufactured by Wescor Inc. (Wescor type HR- τ = 2.3636 E25 - 1.7188
33T Dew point Microvoltmeter) of the United States R2 = 1
(it is accurate in the range of pF 3.2-4.8) was used. 10 —
—
5
foam, a medicine dropper and NaCl solutions with 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
different molalities of 0.3, 0.55 and 0.7 were used. E25
Calibration NaCl solutions with molalities of Figure 2. Calibration line for No. 36670 psychrometer.
0.3, 0.55 and 0.7 and having water potentials of -
13.68, -25.1 and -32.10 bars respectively were used Test Procedure From each clay mixture four
to calibrate the psychrometers. The psychrometer disc-shaped specimens having a diameter of 36 mm
measurements on sodium chloride solutions reflect and height of 15 mm were prepared at a dry density
the osmotic (and the total) suction equivalent of of 1.64 Mg/m3 and a water content of 10%, using
the solution. Four jars were filled with NaCl solu- static compaction. After preparing four compacted
tions of the same molality and then the jars were samples, one of them was left at the initial water con-
closed with the rubber stoppers with psychrome- tent level. The remaining three samples were wetted
ter wires passing through. Finally, plastic mud was with varying amounts of water for varying lengths
used to seal the openings between the psychrometer of time to establish a range of water content con-
wire and rubber stopper in order to prevent air en- ditions. After this gradual wetting process, all four
trance. These jars were placed in a thick cardboard specimens were left to swell in the desiccator for 2 to
box filled with plastic foam in order to minimize the 3 days to attain equilibrium water contents.
temperature variation of the sample container. After Then all four specimens were waxed. A hole was
two or three hours, the psychrometer voltage output drilled on the waxed, covered sample so that the ce-
readings stabilized. Thus the vapor equilibrium was ramic shield of psychrometer could be placed in the
reached. After reaching equilibrium, the psychrome- hole to measure the final equilibrium soil suction val-
ter voltage output and temperature readings were ues. The sides of the psychrometer were isolated by
taken. The psychrometer voltage outputs ET (in plastic modelling clay to prevent any water content
microvolts) were converted to the equivalent output change. These four samples were placed in jars and
at the calibration temperature of 25◦ C, E25 , using the jars were closed with the rubber stoppers which
Equation (2). had been affixed to the psychrometer wire. The jars
The psychrometer output E25 is then plotted were placed in a cardboard box filled with plastic
against water potentials (i.e. suction), and this pro- foam packing material for better heat insulation and
cedure is repeated for the remaining two molalities to left to reach equilibrium. Usually it took 24 hours
obtain the calibration line for the specific psychrom- to reach equilibrium. Psychrometer voltage outputs
eter (Figure 2). A typical example of a calibration and temperature readings are taken.
524
ÇOKÇA
This procedure was repeated at least three times B = slope of soil suction versus water content
a day until the successive readings stabilise, meaning curve
that vapor pressure equilibrium is reached. w = water content
Data Reduction and Interpretation The
psychrometer output (microvolt) at the measured
temperature is converted to an equivalent output us- Experimental Works
ing Equation (2). The psychrometer output is then
converted to soil suction using the calibration line for Material
the specific psychrometer. The data is then plotted The chemical compositions of kaolinite and bentonite
versus water content on a semi-log plot to establish are given in Table 1. Commercially processed kaoli-
the log soil suction versus water content relationship nite and bentonite mineral clays were mixed in pres-
(Figure 3), which is linear and has the form elected proportions to obtain clays possessing a wide
100 —
-
range of plasticities. The kaolinite and bentonite
-
-
- mixtures are shown in Table 2. The hydrometer tests
-
- were performed to find the proportion of clay in the
Pl = 22 %
-
Pl = 28 % soil mixtures. Particle size distribution curves show
Suction (100 kPa)
- Pl = 51 %
Pl = 72 % that as the bentonite content of the samples increase
Pl = 89 %
10 —
- Pl = 111 %
from 0 to 50%, the percentage finer than 0.002 mm
- Pl = 129 %
-
- Pl = 154 %
-
Pl = 177 %
-
Pl = 202 %
- Pl = 225 % Table 1. Results of chemical analysis.
-
1
Chemical Composition Kaolinite Bentonite
—
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 (%)
Water Content (%) MgO 0.04 0.45
Figure 3. Relationship between the suction and water Al2 O3 33.01 18.54
content. SiO2 49.65 59.75
CaO 0.35 3.07
Logτ = A − B ∗ w (4) Fe2 O3 1.84 3.63
SO3 0.18 0.13
where τ = soil suction without surcharge pressure K2 O 1.90 0.99
A = y-intercept of soil suction versus water con- Na2 O 0.11 2.25
tent curve, i.e. the soil suction value (logarithmic TiO2 1.48 0.65
scale) at zero moisture content. Loss on Ignition 11.10 9.87
SL PL LL
m
100% K
95%K + 5% Be
90%K + 10% Be
85%K + 15% Be
80%K + 20% Be
75%K + 25% Be
70%K + 30% Be
65%K + 35% Be
60%K + 40% Be
55%K + 45% Be
50%K + 50% Be
525
ÇOKÇA
Table 2. Soil properties, methylene blue values, A, B values, initial soil suction, measured and estimated swell percent.
∗
K: Kaolinite, Be: Bentonite
∗∗
Unified Soil Classification System
in the samples increase from 47.5% to 57.5% (Table percentage increases, the methylene blue value in-
2). Soil properties are given in Table 2. The initial creases (Table 2).
water content of the specimens is 10% (wi = 10%).
The final water contents of the specimens (at the end
of swell percent test) and the consistency limits are Soil suction tests
shown in Figure 4.
A linear relationship is assumed between log soil suc-
tion and water content (Figure 3), which has the
Methylene blue tests
form: Log10 τ = A – B . w
Methylene blue tests were performed as described be- Table 2 summarises the intercept A, which is the
fore. Temperature changes cause structural changes soil suction value (logarithmic scale) at zero mois-
in the clay and methylene blue capacity; therefore, ture content, slope B of log soil suction versus water
all the tests were performed under the same temper- content behaviour. The intercept A and slope B of
ature conditions. Before performing the methylene log soil suction versus water content behaviour de-
blue test, soil specimens were dried in the oven for crease with increasing PI. The steep slope (large B)
24 hours (oven temperature was around 100◦C) and for a soil sample is indicative of a relatively low swell
methylene blue tests were performed at room tem- capability (e.g. sample with PI = 22%), while the
perature (i.e. 20-24◦C). flat slope (small B) for a soil sample is indicative of
Hills and Pettifer (1985) state that the particle a relatively large swell capability (e.g. sample with
size of the test sample affects the methylene blue PI = 225%).
test results; to get rid of this effect and to maintain Soil suction tests using thermocouple psychrome-
uniformity of the test results, all the samples were ters were performed to obtain the soil suction versus
sieved through a No. 40 sieve (400 µm) before per- water content relationship. The soil suction value
forming the methylene blue test. corresponding to initial water content (wi = 10%)
After using Equation 1 the methylene blue val- was read from the log soil suction versus water con-
ues of the samples were found. As the bentonite tent relationship.
526
ÇOKÇA
—
0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
height of the ring was 6.0 cm. All the laboratory
Clay Activity
free swell tests were laterally confined. As the sam-
ple swells the deflections of the dial gauge is recorded. Figure 5. Relationship between the clay activity and
At some point the sample has no further tendency to swell percent.
swell and the maximum deflection recorded is used
for the calculation of the free swell. The percent of 180 —
120 —
—
0
ing percentages of bentonite generally follow a stan- 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
dard ‘S’ shape. Swell percent increases as plasticity MBV (g/100 g)
index increases. It was observed that for the mix-
Figure 6. Relationship between the methylene blue value
tures, the increases in swell with log time is slow ini-
and swell percent.
tially, increase steeply, and then reaches an asymp-
totic value. The time required to reach an asymp- The results indicated a strong relationship be-
totic value varies considerably, depending upon the tween initial soil suction (Log10 ) and swell percent
percentage of bentonite clay. For the lowest percent-
(Figure 7).
age of bentonite, swell stops in 2000 minutes and to
stop the swell for the highest percentage of bentonite
more than 35,000 minutes is needed. As the plastic- 180 —
Test Results 30 —
0
—
527
ÇOKÇA
The regression analysis made on the MBV-initial (Log10 ) data is evaluated, the coefficient of correla-
soil suction-swell percent (oedometer test) data has tion (R2 ) of this relationship is 0.992.
revealed the following correlation (Figure 8):
Acknowledgements
180 —
160 —
Swell = -121.8 + 12.17 MBV -27.66 log10 (Suction)
The author wishes to acknowledge the contributions
Swell Percent (Measured)
140 —
R2 = 0.992
by Prof. Dr. Altay Birand and Prof. Dr. Orhan
120 — Erol. The author also acknowledges the assistance
MBV in g/100g of the technical staff in the Geotechnical Engineer-
100 — Suction in kN/m2
Swell in percent
ing Laboratory of the Civil Engineering Department
80 — at the Middle East Technical University.
60 —
40 —
Nomenclature
20 —
A y-intercept of soil suction versus water content
—
—
0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 curve, i.e. the soil suction value (logarithmic
swell percent (Estimated)
scale) at zero moisture content
Figure 8. Relationship between the estimated and mea- B slope of the soil suction versus water content
sured swell percent. curve
Be bentonite
Swell (%) = − 121.807 + (12.1696 ∗ MBV) E25 the equivalent output at the calibration tem-
(6) perature of 25◦C
+ [27.6579 * Log10 (initial soil suction)]
ET the psychrometer voltage output, at T ◦ C (in
As seen in Figure 8, there is a strong relationship microvolts)
0
between MBV, initial soil suction and the swell per- f dry weight of the specimen used, g, i.e., the
cent. As the initial soil suction and MBV increases, specimen weight corrected for the moisture
swell percent also increases for the given initial dry loss at 105◦C for 24 h
density and water content. H initial height of the specimen
∆H change in initial height (H) of the specimen
Conclusions K kaolinite
LL liquid limit (%)
In this study, the relationship between MBV, initial m final water content (%)
soil suction and the swell percent of expansive soil MBV methylene blue value
samples was investigated. MBA methylene blue adsorption
The swell percent predicted by Equation (6) is PI plasticity index (%)
compared with the direct measurements from the oe- PL plastic limit (%)
dometer free swell test, as shown in Table 2. The re- SL shrinkage limit (%)
gression analysis made on the MBV-initial soil suc- T temperature in ◦ C
tion - swell percent (oedometer test) data has re- τ total suction
vealed the following correlation: τm matrix suction
τs osmotic suction
Swell (%) = -121.807 + (12.1696 * MBV) + [27.6579 ua pore air pressure
* Log10 (initial soil suction)] uw pore water pressure
Vcc volume of the methylene blue solution injected
The reliability of swell percent prediction method into the soil solution, mL
based on methylene blue value and initial soil suction w water content (%)
528
ÇOKÇA
References
ASTM, Standard Test Method for One-Dimensional sure of Soil Expansivity”, Geo2000 Conference (on
Swell or Settlement Percent of Cohesive Soils, An- CD), Australia, 2000.
nual Book of ASTM Standards, D4546-90, 04.08, Hang, P.T. and Brindley, G.W., “Methylene Blue
853-859, 1993. Absorption by Clay Minerals. Determination of Sur-
Cokca, E. and Birand, A., “Determination of Cation face Areas and Cation Exchange Capacities (Clay-
Exchange Capacity of Clayey Soils by the Methy- Organic Studies XVIII)“, Clays and Clay Minerals,
lene Blue Test”, Geotechnical Testing Journal, 18, 203-212, 1970.
GTJODJ, 16, 4, 518-524, 1993. Hills, J.F. and Pettifer, G.S., “ The Clay Mineral
Edil, T.B., Motan, S.E. and Toha, F.X., “Mechani- Content of Various Rock Types Compared with the
cal Behaviour and Testing Methods of Unsaturated Methylene Blue Value”, J. of Chemical Technology
Soils”, American Society of Testing and Materials, Biotechnol. Chem.-Tech., 35A, 168-180, 1985.
Special Technical Publication, 114-129, 1981. Nevins, M.J. and Weintritt, D.J., “Determination of
Edil, T.B. and Motan, S.E. “Laboratory Evaluation Cation Exchange Capacity by Methylene Blue Ad-
of Soil Suction Components”, Geotechnical Testing sorption”, Ceramic Bulletin, 46, 6, 587-592, 1967.
Journal, ASTM, 7, 4, 173-181, 1984. Snethen, D.R. “Characterization of Expansive Soils
Fityus, S., Smith, D.W. “The Influence of Fab- Using Soil Suction Data”, 4th International Confer-
ric and Mineralogy on the Expansivity of an Aus- ence on Expansive Soils, 54-75, 1980.
tralian Residual Clay”, Unsaturated Soils for Asia, Wray, W.K. “The Principle of Soil Suction and
Rahardjo and Toll (eds), 657-662, 2000. its Geotechnical Engineering Applications”, Fifth
Fityus, S., Smith, D.W. and Jennar, A.M., “Surface International Conference on Expansive Soils, Ade-
Area Using Methylene Blue Adsorption as a Mea- laide, South Australia, 114-118, 1984.
529