University of San Carlos — Department of Civil!

Engineering
CHE 521G FORM-1A-Undergraduate Research Paper Rating

Research Paper Title:

Student Author(s):

Corresponding Authors(s):
Reviewer: Signature:
Designation: ❑Chair ❑Member
Date of Paper Defense:
Term and Academic Year: 2nd Semester 2017 — 2018

Instructions to the Reviewer

1. Please accomplish CE 521G FORM-1A after having read and assessed the research proposal using the rubric.

2. Note that a proposal can only be approved if all specific dimensions indicated in the rubric are graded 2.0 or better.
Thus, if you have assigned a grade of 3.0 (Partially Meets Expectations) or 4.0 (Does Not Meet Expectations) to a
particular dimension, you must specify in clear terms the improvements that the proponents must do in order that the grade
can be raised to 2.0 or better. Kindly fill out CE 521G FORM-2A-Reviewer's Comments the details of the points needing
to be addressed.

Grade
Aspects and Dimensions First First Second
Submission Revision Revision
ASPECT 1. ACADEMIC INTEGRITY (40%)
Data Collection &Processing
Writing Integrity
ASPECT 1 Average
ASPECT 2. QUALITY OF RESEARCH PAPER CONTENT (40%)
Introduction
Literature Review & Background
Methods & Findings
Discussion &Conclusions
ASPECT 2 Average
ASPECT 3. QUALITY OF OVERALL DOCUMENT DESIGN (20%)
Abstract
Style & Mechanics
Formatting & Visuals
ASPECT 3 Average
OVERALL GRADE =
(Aspect 1 Average x 0.40) + (Aspect 2 Average x 0.20) + (Aspect 3 Average x 0.20)
Assessed/Reviewed (Signature)
Date Reviewed

Dna/a 1 of 1