Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 8

CETO QUICK LOOK:

Personal Experiences with the Combined Action Program in


Vietnam
March 17, 2004

Introduction. The Center for Emerging perspectives, and recollection of events that
Threats and Opportunities (CETO) occurred while he served as part of the
conducted a professional military education Combined Action Program in Vietnam.
discussion on March 5, 2004 concerning the Others who served in the same program,
Combined Action Program (CAP) in whether or not at the same time or location,
Vietnam.1 The guest speaker was Mr. Ed most likely will have had different
Matricardi, currently an attorney in Northern experiences and perspectives and have
Virginia, who was a U.S. Marine corporal different recollections today.
and served as a CAP squad leader in
Vietnam during 1967. Mr. Al Paddock, Any comments, questions, or
Ph.D., an historian and retired U.S. Army recommendations concerning this paper are
Special Forces colonel who served three welcome and should be submitted to
tours in Vietnam also participated in the CETO.2
session, as did the CETO staff.
History of CAP. In Vietnam, the Marine
For over two hours, Mr. Matricardi Corps instituted the CAP as a tactic for
led a riveting, frank discussion that covered defense in-depth. Platoons and squads were
much of his experiences and the lessons he assigned to villages and hamlets where
learned during the eight months he served in Marines and local militia forces were
the CAP. Although much of what was involved in counterinsurgency and
discussed was peculiar to Mr. Matricardi’s pacification efforts. The CAP was
personal experiences in Vietnam, some of it established in 1965 and ended in 1971. At
certainly will have direct application to its height, it had 114 units, each consisting
current and future operations in Iraq, of approximately 14 Marines, one Navy
Afghanistan, Haiti, and elsewhere. corpsman and 20 Popular Force (PF) militia
members. Its two-fold purpose was to
Highlights of the Combined Action establish an armed, aggressive military
Program addressed in this paper are presence to provide physical security in
provided for general information purposes villages, many of which were in densely
and are based on both the written notes and populated areas around the U.S. bases, and
oral comments by Mr. Matricardi. win the trust and cooperation of the people
through civic action projects.
One consideration that should be
taken into account when reading this report Types of CAPs. There were two types of
is that for the most part it is based on Mr. CAPs in Vietnam, stationary and roving.
Matricardi’s personal experiences, Stationary CAPs were permanently assigned
to a specific village. Roving CAPs rotated
1
every night into a different hamlet or
CETO is a think tank dedicated to developing new
ideas for the U.S. Marine Corps. CETO operates as a
2
division of the Expeditionary Force Development CETO, 3087 Roan Avenue, Building 3087-C,
Center, Marine Corps Combat Development Quantico, VA 22134, Phone 703 784-0452/50, Fax
Command. 703 784-0436, www.ceto.quantico.usmc.mil.

1
CAP in Vietnam

remained in a rice paddy, always staying on Because of the permanent location of


the move. stationary CAPs and the continuous day-to-
day interaction Marines had with the locals,
Stationary CAPs personal friendships developed between
them. The nature of the stationary CAP
Each stationary CAP established a enhanced the ability of Marines to assimilate
permanent location for its command post. It with the local community and individuals, to
patrolled and performed all of its missions create dual missions, and to share
from a central, unmoving location. responsibility to complete the needed tasks
Because of their fixed nature, the command and missions.
post and patrols attached to stationary CAP
sites were more vulnerable to planned, In stationary caps, big bunkers were
coordinated attacks by various means. built for CAP personnel protection.
However, they were not used because the
Location of a stationary CAP site Marines saw them as lighting rods, highly
was dependant on the level of local support, visible symbols that frequently were the
needs, and makeup of the area. To be target of enemy attacks. When their villages
successful, the CAP teams needed to be or hamlets were attacked, CAP Marines
widely dispersed and intertwined among used slit trenches as fighting positions in
local inhabitants and structures. Fire teams lieu of big bunkers.
were spread widely throughout villages and
hamlets. In Mr. Matricardi’s village there
usually were 12 people assigned to a CAP
Defensive wire and munitions squad, with two squads in the CAP unit.
encompassed the entire hamlet, not only the Vietnamese Popular Forces (PFs)
U.S. Marines. Segregation of CAP Marines were the CAP Marines’ counterparts. The
in a separate compound or location, away PFs were villagers who acted as a militia to
from locals, was avoided as it made the protect their homes and families. They were
Marines an easy target for mortars and equipped with World War II vintage
rockets. CAP Marines occupied local weapons. Marines often exchanged their
dwellings and buildings, paying rent, rather weapons with them and dressed like them,
than constructing their own living quarters. taking off their U.S. uniforms, helmets,
sunglasses, etc. in order to be less obtrusive
Based on the surrounding area and
local populace, stationary CAPs presented Roving CAPs
an easier target to the enemy than roving
CAPs. This liability was offset by the unit’s Roving CAPs rotated every night
ability to fortify and establish permanent into a different hamlet or remained in a rice
defensive perimeters and check-points more paddy. Constant relocation reduced the
substantial than those established by roving probability of attack and infiltration,
CAPs. Stationary CAPs were also better provided a broader physical area of
able to build relationships that provided influence on the people and enhanced
them with intelligence on enemy actions and intelligence gathering.
intentions.
Roving CAPs were best suited for
deployment in urban areas with high

2
CAP in Vietnam

population densities as well as in less identified by pre-insertion intelligence.


densely populated rural areas that posed Consideration was also made to include
problems. people in a CAP squad with a variety of
skills such as carpentry, plumbing,
Roving CAP teams were not as electrical, etc. However, the primary need
capable of establishing the same level of was that each member have the killer
rapport and closeness with the local instinct.
population as were stationary CAPs.
However, teaming-up with Vietnamese CAPs learned how to communicate
Popular Forces allowed roving CAPs to with the villagers as part of their shared
afford protection to outlying areas with learning experience. Linguists were not
much greater effect than stationary CAPs. needed or used.

Daytime reconnaissance patrols The Marine CAP force continuously


would generally establish a new command gathered and refined intelligence and
post each day or would remain in the field as identified additional needs and objectives to
a nighttime ambush. Nighttime defensive be met. When a clear picture was achieved,
measures were installed and removed as a civic action team was assigned and
needed. brought in to fulfill the specific programs or
objectives identified under the security
Daytime checkpoints and patrols umbrella afforded by the Marines and their
were planned to be random and without PF counterparts. An understanding of the
pattern so as to reduce the possibility of needs of the people was continually refined
enemy anticipation of the CAP’s location. as intelligence was gathered on the ground
CAP Reaction Squads after insertion.

CAP reaction squads would leave the Civic action teams were mobile for
village or hamlet to help the squad that had easy deployment and reassignment,
been ambushed. They would conduct oftentimes conducting multiple assignments
reconnaissance by fire as they rushed to the in different locations at the same time.
ambush site. By the time they arrived, the
ambush usually was over, and they helped Marine fire teams likewise were
carry bodies and wounded back to the camp. readily reassigned as needed. It was
critically important that once a close
Mutual / Dual Missions relationship with a local group was
established, it be maintained for as long as
Coordination between local military, possible.
police, and civil authorities was essential.
Additionally, every effort was made to All day-to-day missions and
identify needs of the people prior to activities, such as combat patrols, defensive
insertion; this impacted missions, team perimeter watch, civic action programs,
composition, and logistical support. medical treatment, educational programs,
and the like, were planned with the advice
Fire teams were selected by and consent of the local authorities and
matching the specialties of the men with the conducted in a joint operational capacity.
initial objectives to be accomplished, as

3
CAP in Vietnam

Patrols, ambushes, and - After they first arrived, CAP


reconnaissance were conduced on a joint members were afraid they might be
basis with local forces, with Marines on killed because they did not know
point, radio, and drag. Standing watch what was going on, what rules to
normally was a dual responsibility, with follow, or which tactics, techniques,
Marines in vital roles. There was no way to and procedures to implement.
be sure of the loyalty or the courage of the
PFs. - After they had been there for a
while, CAP members were not as
Operational Control and Personnel Issues concerned with danger. They felt
they had a job to do and just wanted
CAP teams needed to have a high to accomplish it.
degree of autonomy. They especially did
not need officials from higher headquarters - Short-timer shakes affected
to visit them periodically and assign everyone. Keeping short-time
unrealistic missions and requirements. calendars was bad because it
reinforced the focus on leaving
Additionally, an autonomous- versus performing the mission.
appearing organization allowed the
operational control of operations and the It would have been preferable to
administration of civil needs to be presented rotate small two to three-man teams in and
as a local endeavor rather than American out of the CAP, on an unscheduled basis, as
manipulation. opposed to using individual replacements or
CAPs were not treated like regular conducting full unit rotations on set
line units in terms of uniform, appearance, schedules. It was important to build team
or adherence to standard operating homogeneity while maintaining experience
procedures. In the area of logistics, and familiarity with the village.
however, despite their low consumption
rates and limited need for support they Living in a hostile environment for
needed to have their logistics requirements an extended period of time created its own
given priority in order for them to be psychological problems. With the passage
effective. This often did not happen and led of time, under constant stress, and the
to innovation in supply procurement expectation of returning stateside,
methods on the part of CAP members and perceptions and attitudes of individuals
cooperating Special Forces and supply changed for the worst. This change was
personnel. obvious to fellow Marines, and more
importantly, it was obvious to the locals.
CAP members went through three
psychological stages during their time in the To maintain a stable, positive impact
village. It would have been advantageous to on the local civilians, it was important that
both the individuals and the program if they they remain unaffected by the varying
had received training prior to assignment attitudes of the Marines. This was
that would allow them to anticipate and especially important when the civilians
understand the changes they and their team affected were the PF members that worked
would go through. hand-in-hand with the Marines.

4
CAP in Vietnam

Bonds of Friendship and Trust. To be Buying local foodstuffs and eating


effective in achieving unit goals, the CAP with the locals helped establish strong
unit needed to be able to identify the needs trusting relationships. Conveying the
of the people, regardless of how they felt understanding that the Marines were just
personally about these needs. normal young Americans who were sent
there to live with and help them was easier
The means, tools, and equipment to to accomplish over a bowl of soup and rice.
effect the desired change needed to be
available for use in short order. Medicine, It was imperative to get to know the
educational materials, environmental needs, people. By keeping ears and eyes open,
candy and business assistance were CAP team members became cognizant of
commonly used. such things as:

Understanding the needs and fears of - Strange people moving around


the people was paramount to understanding the village
how to motivate them toward acceptance of - A local school needing chalk
a CAP unit. and blackboards
- Wells running dry
To be successful, CAP Marines had - Families needing help in the
to be considered locals by the locals. The rice paddy because they were
local populace had to believe that the sole shorthanded
mission of a CAP unit was to improve their
security and quality of life. Knowing what the villagers needed
Local villagers loved, feared, and without being told was important. Waiting
hated the CAPs. CAP Marines would do to be asked for help only served to reduce
simple things to obtain the local people’s their self esteem and to sow resentment
trust and cooperation, such as protecting towards the CAP. Marines strove to identify
homes, calling for a medical evacuation the people’s needs and satiate them, even
helicopter to evacuate seriously injured without the people’s knowledge that it was
children, or throwing hand grenades or other being done.
explosives into rivers to kill fish for the
locals to eat. While in the village, CAP members
did not have much contact with the outside
After the M-16, a smile and a world. They didn’t know what was going
handshake were the CAP members’ most on either in America or in Vietnam. The
important weapons. CAP members attended only thing they were aware of was the
and participated in events such as weddings, village and what was going on in and around
funerals (even of people killed by the CAP), it. News was obtained on the local level,
birth celebrations, and other events that were and intelligence, both true and misleading,
important to the villagers. It was important came in buckets.
to demonstrate an interest in their way of
life. When CAP members attended these The feeling of safety felt by the
events, they carried only concealed weapons locals because of the security afforded by
in order to fit in better. the CAPs cannot be overstated. The CAP
teams worked to make sure the village
people never felt the need to contemplate the

5
CAP in Vietnam

possibility of being abandoned and left alone others. Efforts to win over children by
to face retribution. fulfilling their educational and medical
needs led to acceptance by the women, (their
A soft-handed approach in dealing mothers and sisters), which in turn made it
with the locals was essential. However, easier to obtain the confidence of the men
when force was used as a response to and the people in general, hence affording
violence, it was quick, aggressive and greater intelligence and cooperation.
overwhelming.
Many villagers, especially children,
The administration of medical were injured by unexploded ordnance while
treatment, entertainment, education, and doing simple things like working in their
environmental needs was made on the basis rice paddies or playing. Some of the
of their system and beliefs, not ours. explosives were placed there by the enemy
with the intent to blame the Marines. CAP
Assimilation of locals with the members must be mentally prepared for
Marines and Marines with the local extremes in human behavior.
populace was considered a priority. No
activity, attitude, or wearing of apparel that Positive Interactions with Adults
could be interpreted as an “in your face”
statement was allowed to occur. Understanding cultural differences is
essential. In Vietnam, physical contact
between men was a major issue.

Holding hands or placing one’s arms


Interactions with Children across the shoulders of another man was a
natural thing for the average Vietnamese
By winning over the kids, CAP male. It meant friendship and trust.
teams were able to win over their brothers Civilians and Popular Forces would walk the
and sisters, and eventually to get into the trails holding hands, or stand around arm-in-
homes and win over their parents. Children arm.
are by nature more accepting of strangers
and open to new ideas and suggestions. Since the average Marine would
rather be pinned down under hostile fire
A Marine unit is extremely imposing than hold hands with another man, physical
and intimidating. However, once the contact between U.S. Marines and
children understood that the Marines were Vietnamese men initially was extremely
honest and would protect them, they began uncomfortable. In time, the Marines
to invite Marines into their homes, where realized the contact was not sexual but
influence and exposure to the family greatly rather a sign of respect, trust, and an
expanded. expression of admiration.

Although intimate contact with the Having sexual contact with local
local females was considered taboo, it women was, of course, the best way to lose
should not be overlooked that once a Marine respect and enrage the local people. If a
earned the respect of a woman, as with a Marine inappropriately fraternized with a
child, the seeds were sown for acceptance by local woman, he was reassigned from the

6
CAP in Vietnam

CAP and gone the next day. The transfer Operating as an enabler to the people
was intended to reduce conflict with the to help them achieve their goals by bringing
people whom the CAP was serving and U.S. resources to the local level opened
depending on for support and intelligence. many lines of communication and
cooperation. The program kept a lot of
Furnishing security to families, Vietnamese non-combatants alive and
schools, and local open-air markets brought obtained intelligence critical to fighting the
the CAP closer to the people. However, war.
such large-scale support did not remove the
villager’s desire for individual gain from the Tactics, Techniques and Procedures. Mr.
CAPs actions. Care was taken to ensure that Matricardi was assigned to a stationary CAP
all the people benefited from the CAP’s which was responsible for a village and
presence. several small hamlets. There were only four
trails leading to his village. Initially, CAP
One of the most important things to patrols would go out after sunset and return
come out of the CAP was that it created between 0300 and dawn. These patrols
opportunities for the Vietnamese villagers to often were ambushed while returning to
teach the Marines. The program provided their base camps. In response, they varied
opportunities for both sides to trade ideas their schedules and returned after dawn.
and build relationships.
If a member of the CAP had a bad
Helping the locals to build adobe feeling or premonition about something, the
bricks out of mud and straw, working in the squad tried to follow that instinct, whether it
rice paddies on a water wheel, or simply meant adjusting a mission or doing
watching local children while their parents something differently.
worked the paddies, all brought the human
factor into play. CAP members would go into a
village, gather intelligence, and report on the
CAP team members were careful not needs of the village. It was important to
to look down on local lifestyles or compare demonstrate to the local people that the CAP
them to American lifestyles. Eating bugs could bring in the necessary resources to
when living with people who do so, earned improve security, get things fixed, and help
respect and helped span the cultural gap. improve the standard of living.
Different societies have their own quirks.
For example, when administering Fire discipline was very important to
medication or providing medical care to the the CAPs. They did not want to kill locals
locals, the Marines found that it was best to who might have been caught in the middle
make it hurt. Pills such as penicillin, of a firefight. They also did not want to
although offering identical relief, were not waste ammunition so as to ensure they had
deemed by the villagers as powerful as a enough when they really needed it.
painful inoculation, because taking a pill
didn’t hurt. CAP teams recognized that in CAPs did not like associating with
order to make the people feel better they regular line units. Regular line units acted
needed to do whatever it took, including and dressed much differently than the CAPs.
giving them a shot and making it hurt. These units were much more conventional in
their approach, used different tactics,

7
CAP in Vietnam

techniques and procedures, and were not as light of current operations in Afghanistan,
effective as the CAPs in dealing with the Iraq, Haiti, and the global war on terrorism.
local people. CAPs interacted with Army Marines returning to Iraq as part of
Special Forces who passed through their Operation Iraqi Freedom II or deploying
areas and with whom they shared many elsewhere, would be well served to learn
traits. from the general lessons of their
predecessors in Vietnam.
The soft-handed approach was the
name of the game with the CAP. However, Iraq in 2004 will pose a much
team members had to be able to react different environment than the one the
quickly and swiftly, to be ready to receive Marines experienced in the 2003 war and
fire and shoot back. the first months after Saddam’s regime was
removed from power. An emboldened
The CAP was like a neighborhood enemy has adapted to the tactics, techniques,
watch. Every night there would be and procedures of the coalition, is exploiting
incidents. Some nights no one got hurt. fear by embarking on a campaign of taking
Other nights a few people got hurt, and on foreign hostages, and continues to attack
others, some were killed. coalition military forces whenever it can, as
well as Iraqi governmental and police
CAPs would always take a corpsman officials, religious assemblies, civilians,
on nighttime patrols and ambushes. There non-governmental organization and
were two corpsmen assigned to Mr. humanitarian relief workers, and the
Matricardi’s CAP, who happened to be twin infrastructure. According to recent polls,
brothers. This caused morale problems many Iraqis have mixed feelings about the
toward the end of their assignment as they coalition. While they see it negatively as an
began to worry more about each other’s occupying power, they still want it to remain
safety than that of the team. and provide for their security. Further
complicating this environment is the limited
Stray dogs and water buffalo caused Shia’a uprising led by firebrand Islamic
problems for CAP patrols, as they would cleric Muqtada al-Sadr and the projected
bark and make noises, alerting local turn-over of sovereignty to the interim Iraqi
civilians and the enemy to their presence. governing council by July 1, 2004.
While the water buffalos were “hands off,”
the teams would kill any dogs they came The Marine Corps Combined Action
across on patrol. Program in Vietnam is a good example of
the kind of innovative thinking and action
Village chiefs and PFs did all of the that has guided the Corps throughout its
interrogations of captured personnel, a task history of involvement in small wars. The
the Marines normally did not perform. Marines of today are writing their own
chapter in that history. As in Vietnam, it
Marines would frisk search women will be written with the cooperation of the
suspected of carrying weapons or explosives local people and the blood and sacrifices of
when required. Marines and locals on the ground.

Conclusion. There is much value to the


study of the Vietnam era CAP, especially in

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi