Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Studies
August 2018
Interdisciplinary
Studies
What is “interdisciplinary studies”?
Interdisciplinary Studies (IDS) is the integration of multiple disciplines of
study. Interdisciplinarity is “the capacity to integrate knowledge and
modes of thinking drawn from two or more disciplines to produce a
cognitive advancement… in ways that would have been unlikely
through a single disciplinary means” (Husni, 2016).
“Interdisciplinary learning brings together diverse disciplines in a
comprehensive manner, enabling students to extend their learning,
access higher-order thinking skills and develop meaningful
understandings of complex interactions amongst themselves, their
community, and the world around them” (Action on Curriculum, 2011).
“Consider the same example of time difference between New York and Beirut,
the learner is supposed to use the mathematical operation she/he built in math
class and the research process over the internet on any subject in the computer
class to the geography knowledge of longitudinal lines and their relation to time
settings. Each is considered as an activity from a different frame; the learner role is
to detect that this is the information she/he needs to integrate together to solve
the presented problem in the new situation.”
Why promote
Collaboration between
disciplines?
“Engaging in the processes
Collaboration between
essential for
disciplines provides
interdisciplinary work
benefits for the student,
require specific cognitive
namely life-long learning
abilities and dispositions,
habits and personal growth
including the ability to
by working collaboratively
embrace complexities,
with other students (Jones,
Interdisciplinary work appreciate different points
2009).
helps develop the of view and being open to
skills today’s new ways of
employers want and understanding the world.”
need, and fosters the (Everett, 2016).
development of skills
needed for good
citizenship. (Everett, Employers indicated
2016) that they would like
universities to place
more emphasis on
critical thinking, oral
From taking part in an and written
interdisciplinary project, “Students communication and
indicated an improvement in a applied knowledge.
number of different cognitive (Everett, 2016)
abilities, including perspective
taking, integration, problem-
solving, abstract thinking, holistic Interdisciplinary teaching “lessons
thinking, critical and creative support the students’ practical
thinking and reflective thinking.” knowledge by making them aware
(Everett, 2016) of other relevant perspectives and
situations of application in class
and providing them with authentic
lessons that again influence the
students’ commitment and interest
in the matter.” (Spintzyk et al.,
2016).
How can collaboration be
promoted
between disciplines?
“Leadership is important at the
college and university levels if
interdisciplinarity is to thrive.”
(Townsend et al., 2015, p 658).
Four faculty
After classroom
members from
visits, the four
different
teachers gather
disciplines visit
to discuss their
each other’s
observations.
classrooms.
Teaching squares
Teachers reflect
No criticism is on their own
given; the focus teaching and
of discussion is implement
gathering ideas. strategies that
benefit their
students.
(Haave, 2018)
In 2003, the human genome was revealed, it was the first time the world discovered that
there were 20, 000 genes in a genome. The graph above shows kinase protein/genes.
Kinases are interesting enzymes they have an important role in cells that turn certain key
pathways on and off. What is interesting is that Kinases are heavily mutated in many
cancers. Drug companies have been targeting certain kinases as therapeutical options.
Despite knowing about over 500 types of Kinases, scientific research only focuses on a
small number or 10 percent of these kinase genes/proteins. The reason why this happens
is because in order to receive funding, there needs to be preliminary ideas, which leads us
to the similar research. Due to globalization, researchers in different countries read the
same published articles and come up with similar follow up questions, which they then use
to apply for funding with, so everyone ends up prioritizing the “hot” areas of research
publications and ignoring a large portion of the Kinases.
interview
On the Importance of Collaboration
2) Would collaboration lead to more discoveries?
Yes, I believe that it would. For large scale efforts in research to succeed, there are a few
things that are needed. One of the most important factors is collaboration between disciplines
to avoid having talented researchers all duplicating their efforts. Also, interdisciplinary
collaboration could lead scientists to learn from a broad base of literature instead of reading
the exact same articles with the exact same findings that lead to similar follow up questions.
3) Do you believe the competitive nature of research hurts collaboration or collaborative inquiry
and what, if anything, can be done to change this?
There are many science laboratories here in Toronto that are too competitive which creates an
environment where each scientist is trying to discover something new in these “hot” areas of
publication. This happens when scientists all try to cover the same topic and do not try to
divide and conquer the kinases or work as a team. Also, we use the term getting “scooped” as
a term for when someone takes credit for your research, something that no one wants, so
collaborative inquiry is almost impossible across laboratories with the current structure we have
for funding and getting published.
I don’t believe there is anything that can be done about this, unless we change the peer-
review process and push for more open access publications. We could also assign a well-
funded task force that would be in charge of piloting new discoveries in science.
We wanted to Computers
Early Childhood Education
know if teachers
Earth Sciences
from different English
backgrounds ESL
experience IDS French
differently. Geography
German
Health Services
We asked. History
They Keyboarding
What subjects
DeLuca, Bolden, & Chan (2017) had similar findings in their research. When
they researched the most commonly experienced activities in collaborative
inquiry, they found co-planning was a relatively common activity, while co-
teaching was not (DeLuca et al., 2017, p 70). Our findings could be due to
scheduling conflicts, time, availability of larger learning spaces to
accommodate more than one class for co-teaching, and willingness of staff
to co-teach/let go of control.
Survey results
The Future of IDS
The majority of our survey respondents (40 of 45) rate
themselves as ‘very willing’ or ‘extremely willing’ to work with
other teachers in different subjects or disciplines than their
own, with only 1 respondent not likely to work with others. This
displays openness to integrating IDS and collaboration, if
teachers are provided with the resources necessary to
implement this method.
Moreover, 93.3% of the respondents believe it will be
extremely, very, or somewhat practical to use IDS techniques
in their work settings. 91.1% claim that they think IDS is
extremely or very useful for their students, with their current
knowledge of the method. These numbers keep us optimistic
of the future of IDS and collaboration.
Q
interdisciplinary learning who work with When my school made
as we counsel and look students and teachers interdisciplinary groups with
at each child and their on S.T.E.M. projects. math, English and social
needs. studies it was great because
we share (mostly) the same
students. But after awhile they
stopped because it was a
If I were to take the lead scheduling nightmare.
and go to the Describe your experiences
school/district and ask to with Interdisciplinary
start some interdisciplinary
learning as either a
work, I would have TONS I do see value in
of support. But it would be teacher or a learner. Do
?
this, although I have
teacher initiated, not top- you have any hesitations a hard time finding
down initiated. with this method? What enough time to
levels of support does your teach all of my
This was a “hot topic” and curriculum in a
school provide? Are there semester as it is!
highly practiced method of
teaching 20 years ago projects at your school that
when I first started teaching. are interdisciplinary?
I loved it!! Students really I think interdisciplinary
benefited from seeing how learning is the way of
topics are related and the future. With the vast
learning really applied to amount of information
life. Then the “test everyone and access to
Our district/school is 100%
and everything” era of information, it is more
supportive of *department*
education hit and teachers important than ever to
collaboration and learning.
were forced to concentrate make connections
It is the foundation of
only on their subject of between various
collaboration where we live.
discipline. Let’s get back on fields/subjects. As much
But we NEVER, EVER get far
track for doing what is best as the school
enough to do
for students. Let’s remember encourages this, there
interdisciplinary
that we teach kids not are no formal structure
collaboration. And that is
subjects in school. set up to make this
because of high turnover
rates. happen.
summary:
Teachers are willing and enthusiastic about interdisciplinary teaching.
The major roadblocks are time, structure, training, administrative support
and the willingness of other teachers to collaborate.
Planning Considerations (Drake, Reid & Kolohan)
Higher order
Aim to
incorporate
higher-order
Drake, Reid and Kolohan
thinking skills recommend that teachers
into the rich
Create performance
who wish to integrate
task curricula should ask
Analyze themselves these three
questions:
thinking skills
Apply What do we want the
students to know?
Understand
Factual knowledge
Conceptual knowledge
Procedural Knowledge
Remember
Metacognitive Knowledge
Consider starting
interdisciplinary
Choose a task that
collaboration on a rich
supports shared
assessment task for
big ideas.
students.
Brainstorm possible
activities using a For example, if
graphic organizer collaborating between
Math and Science,
Create a rich assessment consider focusing on the
task that acts as a shared big ideas of
culminating activity aligned cause and effect, or
with the Know-Do-Be and order, as opposed to
curriculum expectations. trying to connect
probability to
Organize daily instruction. organisms.
Checklist for a
rich performance assessment task (Drake, Reid & Kolohan)
Question:
In what ways can disciplines
collaborate?
ANSWER: Teachers from different disciplines
can create interdisciplinary projects
and share them to inspire other
teachers to do the same.
(you may continue your Community Needs Project from Career Education)*
STEP #1: PROPOSAL (Google Doc/Slides)
Project must address a Community Need
Must have an achievable goal for the allotted time (3 weeks)
Criteria:
Goal must include problem-solving, decision-making, and research
Must outline HOW you are going to accomplish your goal, WHY you are pursuing that goal, and
WHAT your service project entails
Each HOW, WHY, and WHAT require a minimum of ½ page paragraph supported by research
(12 size font, Times New Roman)
STEP #2: PROJECT ADVERTISEMENT
Promote your project using at least one of the following:
Commercial (live or recorded)
Website
Poster(s)/Print Ad
Create a project NAME, LOGO, and SLOGAN
Complete at least one promotional item with the technology/digital arts teacher using your name, logo,
and/or slogan, such as a:
Decal, sticker, magnet, business card, coaster, etc.
Criteria:
Must be informative, engaging, and persuasive
You will present your advertisement in class*
STEP #3: ACTION PLAN
Detail how you plan to carry out your project and achieve your goal A hand out will be provided in
which you must:
Breifly describe your project
What will you need? Supplies? How will you get what you need? (be specific) When
will your project take place?
Task Assignment: Who will do what? When? How long will/did it take?
Phone calls, announcements, site visit(s), getting supplies, etc.
Criteria:
Log and complete an action plan outline every week
“Our school does have embedded PLC time each week and
we are allowed to work with any teachers we choose, so we
naturally have a collaborative atmosphere should we choose
to take advantage of it. Unfortunately, not many think that
math is a subject that is easy to collaborate with, so we tend
to work within our own department.”
You will need the following resources to get started on this project:
Exercise Formulas and definitions (page 2)
Report outline (Page 3)
You will use this online template to start your own Excel tracking sheet:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1EIAhJQ0u8rdj5H1TeV9avMRhymA0ZdAZrz10ybiVGCk/edit#gid
=1251986310
For a guide on how to populate your worksheet, check out this video:
Feel free to download and change the formatting to suit your personal brand as a trainer. Replace the text
“Science group” in cell A1 with your own personal trainer company name (you can also create a logo if you wish).
Definitions and Formulas:
Body Mass Index (BMI) estimates human body fat based on the individual's weight and height. A BMI from 18.5
to 24.9 is considered normal.
BMI = 703*w/h2
w = weight (in pounds)
h = height (in inches)
Basal Metabolic Rate (BMR) is the daily amount of energy (in calories) expended at a specified activity level.
BMR (Men) = 6.23w + 12.7h ‐ 6.76a + 66
BMR (Women) = 4.338w + 4.698h ‐ 4.68a + 655
w = weight (in pounds)
h = height (in inches)
a = age (in years)
Calories Burned measures the amount of calories burned during an exercise. In order to lose 1 kg of body fat
(3500 kCal) per week you must expend 500 cal/day.
"METS” = metabolic equivalents of the exercise
w = weight (in pounds)
t = time (in minutes)"
At Rest BMR assumes no activity whatsoever, while Active BMR assumes the following levels of activity:
Sedentary, Light, Moderate, High, or Extreme.
Active BMR = Activity Factor x BMR
Activity Factor = a multiplier based on the individual exercise activity
Metabolic Equivalents (METS) are multiples of the resting metabolic rate due to exercise, where 1 MET = 3.5
cal/kg of body weight.
(Metabolic Equivalents) are multiples of the resting metabolic rate due to exercise, where 1 MET = 3.5 cal/kg of
body weight.
(Temertzoglou, 2008)
Report Outline:
Introduction:
Include your rationale for creating your type of exercise program
Include a testable hypothesis
Materials and Methods:
Explain how your workout will be completed and what type of equipment you will need
Results:
Include personal statistics of you and your clients (if you choose to test your workout program
on others) at the beginning and the end to compare
Maintain a weekly journal on your progress
Show completed work on your Excel tracking sheet. All formulas included
State whether your hypothesis was correct/incorrect
Discussion:
Describe your interpretations of the findings. For example, did you learn something new or
surprising, or could there be something wrong with how BMI is calculated based on what you
observed?
Conclusion:
Sum up your findings/observations
Describe in anything could be improved with your program or if additional research is required
References:
Cite any sources you used to conduct your research using APA style.
We decided to share the teaching component of this project on YouTube publicly, which would allow
other teachers to view it and create their own interdisciplinary project. Teachers could also follow the
links in the description part of the video to download any of the resources shown above.
“Mathletes” Project
Math + Physical Education + Technology
To get a better understanding of the Mathletes Projects,
watch the video below, or access via link:
https://youtu.be/cCVouPYVVIg
Simple Solutions
to Common Roadblocks
time
As identified by Aled Edwards in his interview
about the importance of collaboration is it
reduces the duplication of each individual’s
efforts. Invest them time in collaborating in
order to reap the time savings later.
structure
If venturing into Collaborative Inquiry
across disciplines for the first time, utilize
the Collaborative Inquiry: A Facilitator’s
Guide by Jennifer Donohoo. This guide
provides a step-by-step method to
structure your interdisciplinary steps
towards collaboration.
References
Action on Curriculum, Education Program Standards and Assessment, Sept. 2011, Alberta
Education.
DeLuca, C., Bolden, B., & Chan, J. (2017). Systemic professional learning through
collaborative inquiry: Examining teachers' perspectives. Teaching and Teacher Education,
67, 67-78.
Drake & Reid. (2010, September) Integrated Curriculum. Ontario Ministry of Education, The
Literacy and Numeracy Secretariat. Retrieved from
http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/eng/literacynumeracy/inspire/research/WW_Integrated_Curricul
um.pdf
Drake, Reid & Kolohan. Interweaving Curriculum and Classroom Assessment. Oxford
University Press, 2014. Print.
Edwards, A. (2011). Too Many Roads Not Taken. Nature, 163-165.
Edwards, A. (2015, March 9). Canadian biomedical science is outstanding…but also
redundant? Retrieved from Healthy Debate: http://healthydebate.ca/opinions/canadian-
biomedical-science-outstandingbut-also-redundant
Environmental School Project in Maple Ridge. (2017). Retrieved from http://es.sd42.ca/
Everett, M.C. (2016). Interdisciplinary Studies: A Site for Bridging the Skills Divide. The Journal of
Effective Teaching, 16(2), 20-31.
Haave, Neil. (2018, July 31). Teaching Squares Bring Cross-Disciplinary Perspectives. Retrieved
from https://www.facultyfocus.com/articles/faculty-development/teaching-squares-cross-
disciplinary-perspectives/
Husni, N.M. & El Rouadi, N. (2016). Interdisciplinary Curriculum Empowers Cognitive
Advancement to Solve Real Life Problems. Journal of Education and Learning, 5(4), 34-43.
Jones, C. (2009). Interdisciplinary Approach: Advantages, Disadvantages, and the Future
Benefits of Interdisciplinary Studies.
Spintzyk, K., Strehlke, F., Ohlberger, S., Gröben, B., & Wegner, C. (2016). An Empirical Study
Investigating Interdisciplinary Teaching of Biology and Physical Education. Science Educator,
25(1), 35-43.
Temertzoglou, T. (2008). Exercise Science: An Introduction to Health and Physical Education.
Toronto: Thompson Educational Publishing, Inc.
Townsend, T., Pisapia, J., Razzaq, J. (2015). Fostering interdisciplinary research in universities: a
case study of leadership, alignment and support. Studies in Higher Education, 40(4), 658-675.