Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
1
Ph.D Candidate Strategic Management/Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology,
+254 721513989 P.O BOX 81651, 80100 Mombasa, KENYA
igithaiga10@gmail.com
1
School of Entrepreneurship, Leadership, Procurement and Management, Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and
Technology, Kenya,
+254 722 89 60 92, P.O.BOX 6200-00200, NAIROBI- KENYA
1
School of Entrepreneurship, Leadership, Procurement and Management, Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and
Technology, Kenya,
+254 59 09 65, P.O.BOX 6200-00200, NAIROBI- KENYA
The top management must be on the fore front of the implementation and practices. Other studies included
quality management process starting from the initial barriers to include:, Jaafreh (2013) top leadership
stages. According to Arshida and Agil (2012), commitment, (Kazemi, 2016; Karaman & Kale, 2012;
adoption of TQM for the first time is associated with Mirawati, Othman & Risyawati, 2015) poor
development of new organizational policy, new organization – supplier relationship: (Muma, Nyaoga,
procedures and new tools that must be learned and Matwere & Nyambega, 2014) poor communication
spearheaded by top management. However, other which ignores employees participation while Arshida
researchers stated that leadership not only applied as a and Agil (2012) in Ghana’s industries found weak
supporting factor for TQM implementation but also organizational planning and lack of critical resources
very effective in improving overall performance of for quality management in the organization.
such organization. Good top leadership facilitate
effective TQM implementation resulting to improved Muturi, Maranga and Getecha (2013) pointed out
overall organizational performance such as improved that the level of quality management practices
employees participation, better communication and implementations among Kenyan’s small and medium
better quality goods and services and improved manufacturing industries have been far below
competitive advantage in the market (Wani & Mehraj, expectations though they have undoubtedly provided
2014). some indications on the extent of achievements.
Kinuthia and Owuor (2013) in selected hospitals in
Oruma et al. (2014) research focused on top Nairobi Kenya revealed that total quality management
leadership commitment on TQM practice among practices were hampered by lack employee’s
contractors in Nakuru County and confirmed that the involvement and culture change which required top
commitment of top leadership has a significant management intervention. Despite great efforts and
influence on TQM practice in the construction huge resources invested in implementation of quality
industry. Patrick (2011) of quality management management systems in the state corporations, they
systems found out that as a result of good leadership have not fully realized the benefits of successful
and top management commitment in Egypt and South implementation of QMS.
Africa, most food processing companies have
embraced effective quality management systems such It was on the background of the above worrying trend,
as IS0 9001:2008 and this has enabled them to achieve contradicting reports that are exposing stiff
a competitive advantage in the global market hence competition to organizations whereby state
leading to increased organization performance. corporations are not spared, that this study sought to
However Kosgei (2014) observed that lack of examine the effects of strategic management practices
commitment by top management, inadequate training on implementation of quality management systems for
of staff and ineffective communication has been the state corporations to enhance their competitiveness.
major bottlenecks in implementing effective and
efficient quality management systems in Kenya.
1.2 Research Objectives
1.1 Statement of the Problem The general objective of this study was to establish
the effects of strategic leadership practices on
The aim of every organization is to achieve and implementation of quality management systems for
maintain a sustainable competitive edge as the issue of state corporations
quality has become of great importance especially with
the ever growing concerns and demands from various 1.3 Scope of the study
players in the market. This can only be possible if an
organization endeavours to invest in good management The study analyzed the effect of strategic leadership
practices. This would include in engagements strategic practices on implementation of quality management
operations. systems for state corporations. This was because
despite great efforts and huge resources invested in
Hadi and Adavi (2016) conducted a study in Iraq on implementation of quality management systems in the
the barriers in implementing TQM in organization, state corporations, they have not fully realized the
research findings revealed that most organizations benefits of successful implementation of quality
were experiencing lack of skillful workers in the management systems.
process of TQM implementation however Kheni and
Ackon (2015), identified lack of top management 2. Theoretical
understanding and commitment as a barriers to TQM
implementation while Arshida and Agil (2012)
The Crosby’s theory was founded by Philip Crosby
identified government regulations, slow systems and
who was a contemporary leader in total quality
bureaucracy as the main barriers to TQM management. Crosby emphasized that quality is neither
intangible nor immeasurable. It is a strategic This study used purposive sampling method. This is
imperative that can be quantified and put back to work because purposive sampling technique involves
to improve bottom line (Smith, 2014). He made selecting certain units or cases based on a specific
ideologies of TQM easier to a layman view by purpose rather than randomly (Teddlie & Fen Yu,
breaking down issues to an understandable way that 2007). The researcher therefore gathered information
organizations could adopt. He redefined quality to from employees at the managerial level or
mean conformity to standards set by the industry or departmental heads because they were able to provide
organization that must align with customer needs. the relevant information for this particular study.
Sadikoglu and Olcay (2014), findings on TQM Secondly, the adoption of the process for quality
practices study support Crosby’s sentiments on management system is assumed to be strategic in
customer needs. They found out that companies that nature and hence a managerial responsibility.
have implemented TQM practices first need to know
their customers’ requirements and expectation and then 3.4 Data Collection methods
focus on producing goods and services that serve their
customer’s needs in order to achieve a competitive
Primary data was collected using questionnaire
advantage over their competitors. In Quality strategy, which were administered to 97 managers from the 8
Crosby based on participatory management and state corporations who were the respondents of the
training/ professional attitude of employees with an study. To validate the primary data, secondary data
aim of targeting zero defects which is a important
was collected from institutional quarterly and annual
strategic management practice that would help an reports and policy documents related to the study
organization to effectively achieve its goals. Regarding through document analysis method.
the Costs of quality, Crosby claimed that if improved
quality total costs would eventually fall, which led to
his most famous claim that quality, is free 4. Research findings and Discussions
(Paraschivescu, 2013).
4.1 Strategic Leadership Practices for state
3. Research Methodology corporations result analysis
Table 1: KMO and Bartlett's Test for Strategic 9 Managers ensures good .927
Leadership Practices factors communication processes to facilitate
effective quality management
Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin Measure of 10 Organization management is .886
.902 committed to QMS development for
Sampling Adequacy.
Bartlett's Approx. Chi-Square 739.619 effectiveness
Test of Df 45
Sphericity Sig. .000 All the ten factors registered thresholds of above 0.40
and were thus considered for further statistical
analysis.
4.3 Factor Analysis for Strategic Leadership
Practices
4.4 Descriptive Statistics Results for Strategic
The ten items measuring the independent variable Leadership Practices
Strategic Leadership Practices were subjected to a
reliability test where a Cronbach’s Alpha value of The main objective was to evaluate the effects of
0.781 was obtained. Factor analysis was then carried Strategic Leadership Practices on implementation of
out on the ten items where the following results were quality management systems on State Corporations in
obtained as shown on Table 2. Hair et. al., (2010) Mombasa County. Results in Table 3 below indicates
highlighted that Factor Analysis was necessary in that top management is committed to build trusting
research to test for construct validity and highlight relationship to move employees to a desired direction
variability among observed variables and to also check as supported by 92.9% while 88.2% respondents
for any correlated variables in order to reduce agreed that managers ensures that employees are aware
redundancy in data. According to David et al. (2010), of the systems within your organization to enhance
the general rule of the thumb for acceptable factor guidance in the implementation of QMS Further 90.5%
loading is 0.40 or above. of the respondents agreed that managers ensure
effective and efficient utilization of resources to
Table 2: Thresholds of the Independent Variable
support quality management process while 92.7%
Strategic Leadership Practices Factors agreed that their organizations supports the practice of
empowering employees to enhance smooth
implementation of quality management systems.
Statements Factor Managers frequently participate in QMS activities
Loadings where review meetings were supported by 90.5% of
1 The top management is committed to .595 the respondents while 85.9% of the respondents agreed
build trusting relationship to move that managers in their organization exercise visionary
employees to a desired direction leadership roles in QMS process. The top management
2 The managers ensures that .790 ensures quality objectives are established was
employees are aware of the systems evidenced by 95.3% of the respondents while 90.6% of
within your organization to enhance the respondents pointed out that their organization are
guidance in the implementation of committed to ensure systems are in place for effective
QMS QMS implementation. Managers ensures good
3 Managers ensure effective and .630 communication processes to facilitate effective quality
efficient utilization of resources to management was supported by 85.8% response rate
support quality management process while 90.6% supported that organization management
4 Your organization supports the .783 is committed to QMS development for effectiveness.
practice of empowering employees to
enhance smooth implementation of
The findings are supported by Manoj (2014) study
quality management systems.
which concluded that leadership is the driving force
5 Managers frequently participate in .784
behind any successful organization and that to achieve
QMS activities especially review
quality control depends on the ability and attitude of
meetings
the top management. There is need therefore for
6 Managers in your organization .903
managers to understand the importance of effective
exercise visionary leadership roles in
leadership roles. Leader considers people as critical
QMS process.
factor for success and should take leading role as a
7 The top management ensures quality .886
challenge for the organizational benefits. Mishra and
objectives are established
Pandey (2013) argue that without better leadership
8 Your organization is committed to .838
people cannot imagine a great institution. Other
ensure systems are in place for
researchers maintain that leadership responsibility for
effective QMS implementation
the quality management systems is key and should
[9] Kheni, N.A., & Ackon, F. (2015). Impact of Total [15] Mugenda, O. M., & Mugenda A.G. (2003).
Quality Management Practices (TQMPs) on Research Methods, Quantitative and Qualitative
Construction Project Quality Performance in Approaches, Nairobi: Acts Press.
Developing Countries: Study of Construction [16] Muturi, P., Maranga, S. & Getecha, C. (2013).
Businesses in Ghana. International Journal of Quality Management Practices in the Kenyan
Management Science, 2(3), 35–51. Small and Medium Manufacturing Industries.
[10] Kombo, D, K., & Tromp L, A. (2006). Proposal International Journal of Scientific & Technology
on Thesis writing. An introduction. Nairobi: Research, 2(11).
Paullines Publications. [17] Nkechi, E, I. (2010). Quality Improvement in a
[11] Kosgei, J.M. (2014). Challenges Facing the Global Competitive Market place-Success Story
Implementation of Total Quality Management in from Nigeria. International Journal of Business
Secondary Schools: A Case of Eldoret East and Management, 5(1), 211-218.
District, Kenya, Global Journal of Human [18] rodho, J. A. (2005). Techniques of Writing
Resource Management, 3(1), 12-18. Research Proposals and Reports in Education and
[12] Kothari, C R. (2004). Research Methodology: Social Sciences. Nairobi: Kenezja Enterprises.
Methods and Techniques. New Delhi: New Age [19] Oruma, B. W., Mironga, J, M., & Muma, B. O,
International Publishers. (2014). Top Management Commitment Towards
[13] Manoj, K, M. (2014). Importance of Leadership in Implementation of Total Quality Management
Total Quality Management. 61-77. Retrieved (TQM) in Construction Companies in Nakuru
from: County-Kenya. International Journal of
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/2955319 Economics, Finance and Management Sciences,
27. 2(6), 332-338. doi: 10.11648/j.ijefm.20140206.15.
[14] Mishra, P. & Pandey, A. (2013). The Role of [20] Paraschivescu, A.O. (2013). Japanese Quality
Leadership in Implementing Total Quality Science and Culture, Economy Trans-
Management (TQM) in Higher Education: disciplinarity Cognition, Vol. 16(1), 2013.
European Academic Research Vol. 1 Retrieved Retrieved from
from: www.euacademic.org IMPACT FACTOR: http://www.ugb.ro/etc/etc2014no1/06_Paraschives
0.485 (GIF) DRJI VALUE: 5.9. cu__Caprioara.pdf.
[21] Smith J, L (2014). Philip Crosby’s Legacy.
Quality. 53(8), 18.