Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
I
N AN EPISODE OF
searches the streets of Harlem to find out what people think of
Tiger Woods.1 When he asks three Asian storekeepers if they
consider Woods Asian, one replies, ‘‘Not even this much,’’ pressing two
of his fingers together to show no space. This comic scene and the jokes
that surround Wood’s self-proclaimed identity reveal a cultural con-
tradiction that I explore in this essay, namely the simultaneous ac-
ceptance and rejection of blackness within a biracial discourse in
American popular culture. Though Wood’s self-identification may not
fit neatly into the black/white mixed-race identity explored in this
project, he still falls into a black/white dichotomy prevalent in the
United States. The Asian storekeepers agree with Rock’s tongue-in-
cheek suggestion that Tiger Woods is as black as James Brown, op-
posing sentiments like ‘‘The dude’s more Asian than he is anything
else’’ on an Asian-American college Internet magazine (‘‘Wang and
Woods’’). Woods cannot escape blackness (a stereotypical fried-chicken-
and-collard-green-eating blackness according to Fuzzy Zoeller), and yet
he also represents a multicultural posterboy, one whose blackness pales
next to his much-celebrated multi-otherness.2
Through advertising, interviews, and publicity, biracial celebrities
encode a distinct connection to blackness despite their projected (and
sometimes preferred) self-identification. Drawing from Richard Dyer’s
Stars, I read biracial celebrities Halle Berry, Vin Diesel, and Mariah
Carey by analyzing autobiographical representations, celebrity
statuses, public reception, and the publicity surrounding each of the
217
218 Sika Alaine Dagbovie
bordering ‘‘black and white,’’ ‘‘hope and despair, good and bad, sane
and insane; the positive and negative divided by two, multiplied by
sex’’ (11). In the sci-fi comic-book-turned-movie X-Men, Berry’s
character again occupies an ‘‘in-between’’ space. Lynne D. Johnson
asserts that Berry’s role as Storm in X-Men did not surprise, given her
mixed racial background: ‘‘Though not a tragic mulatto in the classic
sense of the myth, being mixed in both the racial and genetic mu-
tation sense of the word, Storm is representative of this idea.’’ In
2004, Berry played another mutant woman, Catwoman, first made
famous by biracial actress Eartha Kitt in a 1960s television show. Like
Berry’s other films, Catwoman capitalizes on Berry’s reputation as
exotic, liminal, and hypersexual.6
Berry’s casting as Leticia Musgrove in Monster’s Ball prompted di-
verse reviews from moviegoers and critics. The reaction from the black
community was mixed, mostly due to Berry’s casting as a stereotypical
black woman in a film that ‘‘unfolds like something that was written
by Simon Legree, the slave owner in Uncle Tom’s Cabin. Just hours after
they meet, the black woman lustfully seduces the startled white man’’
(Wickham 15A).7 While many reviews mention the clichés in Mon-
ster’s Ball, most fail to mention the stereotypical image of black
women.8 Actress Angela Bassett declined the role, she claims, because
‘‘I wasn’t going to be a prostitute on film. . . . I couldn’t do that
because it’s such a stereotype about black women and sexuality’’
(Samuels 54). Bassett does not mention the stereotypes of mixed-race
women implicit in Berry’s portrayal of Leticia, a woman who wants
Hank to ‘‘heal’’ her through sex. Here the movie recycles nineteenth-
century images of black and mixed-race women as oversexual.9 More
specifically, the movie encourages the myth of mixed-race women ‘‘as
lewd and lascivious as the men are idle, sensual, and dishonest’’
(Mencke 102). Though the film does not specifically label Leticia
mixed race, her characterization urges such readings. Symbolically, the
movie recalls the history of miscegenation yet, more specifically, the
movie reinforces general perceptions of Halle Berry as biracial. One
reviewer sarcastically claims that the film suggests blacks and whites
will get along only when ‘‘black women are already half white, already
measure up to the white beauty standard,’’ like Halle Berry (‘‘Monster
Balls’’). Berry’s role in Monster’s Ball speaks to Berry’s own tragic
mulatto image, and her image never strays far from the ‘‘biracial’’
characters she plays.
Mixed-Race Superstars 223
I didn’t see a black woman who looked, well, black. Am I the only
one to have noticed? Halle Berry—who let’s face it, is half-white—
made a lachrymose, Oscar-winning thing about being a woman of
colour, and yet the reality is that she looks no more like a person of
colour than I do. Is it just me, or do most of the black women cast in
Hollywood films, with their straight hair, thin lips and cappuccino-
coloured skins, look just a little bit white? (Kerr 44)
Boiler Room (2000), Pitch Black (2000), and The Chronicles of Riddick
(2004). While critics have charged Diesel with passing, others applaud
his savvy marketing skills. Diesel admits, ‘‘Being multicultural has
gone from the Achilles’ heel of my career to my strength.’’ He describes
the world as a ‘‘big melting pot,’’ deducing that ‘‘people are ready for a
hero who is more ambiguous’’ (Thrupkaew).
XXX’s advertising refers to its main character, Xander Cage, as ‘‘a
new breed of secret agent,’’ a seemingly intentional though oblique
reference to Diesel’s mixed-race background and his emergence in a
genre once dominated by now outdated white action stars like Arnold
Schwarzenegger, Sylvester Stallone, and Bruce Willis (White). Similar
descriptions follow Diesel, naming him a new ‘‘multicultural hero’’
(Mora) and the ‘‘first truly All-American action hero’’ (White). Director
Rob Cohen (XXX and The Fast and the Furious) maintains, ‘‘It has
taken America a long time to acknowledge the new face of America . . .
and to some degree, Vinny is that new face’’ (Kirkland). Such descrip-
tions recall Time’s 1993 special issue cover, ‘‘The New Face of America,’’
featuring a future mixed race, computer-made American woman. Su-
zanne Bost argues that Time’s female creation ‘‘charms . . . and yet she is
taboo, bloodless, impure’’ (Mulattas and Mestizas 1). Lauren Berlant
suggests that ‘‘new faces’’ like the Time cover respond to ‘‘problems of
immigration, multiculturalism, sexuality, gender, and trans(national)
identity that haunt the U.S.’’ (398). What does it mean that this new
representative (noncomputerized) face is a man, a ‘‘He-man’’ no less?
Diesel’s image, in part created through his movie roles, represents
America’s assimilation and capitalist impulses. In other words, his
image encourages the idea that race is a commodity that people can
trade, buy, or sell, virtually ‘‘e-racing’’ national histories of racializ-
ation. Henry Giroux writes, ‘‘National identity in the service of a
common culture recognizes cultural differences only to flatten them
out in the conservative discourse of assimilation and the liberal appeal
to tolerance’’ (182). The suggestion that Diesel stands for ‘‘everyman’’
attempts to create a national identity that eliminates difference. San-
tiago Pozo, CEO of Arenas Entertainment, tells Time, ‘‘In the past,
John Wayne and Jimmy Stewart were the face of America. . . . Today
it’s The Rock or Vin Diesel’’ (Tesoriero 61). Such a comparison suggests
that biracial celebrities like The Rock or Diesel evoke a ‘‘multiracial
sameness,’’ a sugar pill oxymoron that ends up surreptitiously re-
centering white normative American identity.
228 Sika Alaine Dagbovie
publications ran articles such as ‘‘Mariah Carey Tells Why She Looks
White but Sings Black’’ and ‘‘Mariah Carey: Not Another White Girl
Trying to Sing Black,’’ seemingly attempting to assure black audiences
that Carey was not trying to pass or disregard her black ancestry. How-
ever, Carey’s later physical transformation suggests an effort to depart
visually from ‘‘black’’ and to reflect white standards of beauty.
Despite publicly claiming a multiracial heritage, Carey admits that
her physical hints of blackness made her self-conscious. Recalling her
Butterfly (1997) album cover, Carey shares that she felt pressured to cover
up her face ‘‘because I had been told I looked horrible and too ethnic with
my face showing’’ (Grigoriadis 194). As Carey’s hair turns straighter and
blonder, she increasingly signifies ‘‘whiteness’’ while contradictorily
maintaining a position as ethnic ‘‘other’’ vis-à-vis her public assertions of
biracialism. Richard Dyer suggests that ‘‘blondeness is racially unam-
biguous’’ and ‘‘the ultimate sign of whiteness’’ (Heavenly Bodies 44, 43).
Carey represents a racial anomaly because her image simultaneously
projects different racial tropes. These competing discourses establish
Carey in a biracial narrative that depends upon her liminality.
Musically, Carey has moved from pop to hip-hop, in some ways a
symbolic shift from white to black. After Carey divorced then Sony
Music president Tommy Mottola, her music and image changed dras-
tically. Carey claims that her Butterfly album symbolizes her feelings of
personal and professional freedom impelled by her divorce. As she
explained it in 1997, ‘‘I feel more free to put more of myself into my
music’’ (Thigpen 113). With Butterfly, Carey has worked with more
hip-hop artists and producers to tap into her ‘‘broad demographic.’’ As
she observes, ‘‘I have an audience that’s urban and one that’s Middle
America.’’ She continues, ‘‘So I have to really be a little bit conscious of
the fact that it’s broad, and also it’s diverse in terms of the racial thing.
I am anyway, being a mixed person racially’’ (Ehrlich 338). On Rainbow
(1999), Carey collaborated with hip-hop artists and rappers including
Jay-Z, Usher, Da Brat, Missy Elliott, and Snoop Dogg. Carey’s earlier
albums Mariah Carey (1990), Emotions (1991), and Daydream (1995)
demonstrated her penchant for love ballads and cross-over pop songs,
save for Carey’s ‘‘Dreamlover’’ remix with Ol’ Dirty Bastard on Day-
dream. Earlier albums also feature Carey in her pre-blonde days, sug-
gesting that Carey’s physical transformation heightened after she
professionally embraced black culture. In a 2002 MTV interview Carey
revealed, ‘‘Most of my friends and most of the music I listen to and
230 Sika Alaine Dagbovie
hook may suggest Carey’s possible roles as phone sex operator or pros-
titute. Magazine photos of Carey (as in Vibe March 2003) (Ogunnaike)
are not just revealing, but border on soft porn. In one photo she wears a
trench coat, partly opened to reveal her naked body. Another frames
Carey lying on a couch, one hand on her breast, the other suggestively
positioned below her stomach. Still another shows Carey in an un-
zipped miniskirt and unzipped midriff top, suggestively looking
downwards at her skirt. While many pop stars like Christina Aguilera
and Britney Spears also wear skimpy and sexy clothing, Carey’s pro-
vocative style of dress is coupled with a publicized troubled multiracial
identity, making her sexuality fetishized and tragic. Tellingly, Carey
cites Marilyn Monroe, a star whose name virtually equaled sex in the
1950s and who began her career as a pin-up, as the person she most
admires.11 Not surprisingly, Barbara Walters symbolically likens the
two, calling Carey ‘‘a soldier’s pin-up girl come to life’’ while describ-
ing her Kosovo trip to visit US troops (Carey, ‘‘Surviving the Glare’’).
Carey’s semi-autobiographical box office failure, Glitter, confirms her
racialized sexuality despite its attempts to critique biracial clichés. In
one scene the music video director explains his idea for the main
character’s video: ‘‘She is not black, she is not white, she is exotic, OK?’’
This same theme follows representations of Carey’s public and private
life. In July 2001, Carey appeared on MTV’s Total Request Live (TRL)
pushing an ice-cream cart in a ‘‘Loverboy’’ (the name of Glitter’s first
single) T-shirt and heels. She proceeded to perform a pseudo strip tease,
taking off her T-shirt to reveal a hidden skimpy outfit. Entertainment
reporters and tabloids ridiculed Carey for her bizarre behavior and
incoherent ramblings to TRL host, Carson Daly. Accordingly, Ego Trip’s
Big Book of Racism! comically named Carey their number one ‘‘Tragic
Mulatto’’ for, among other things, ‘‘a propensity for ‘whorelike attire,’ a
nervous breakdown, a mocked and derided cinematic debut, and a
failed soundtrack’’ ( Jenkins 81). Such descriptions urge the question,
what role does Carey have in sexualizing her image? Carey reports
feeling ‘‘constantly amazed’’ regarding her portrayal as ‘‘very loose
morally and sexually,’’ an ironic statement considering that Carey in-
vites such readings in nearly all recent publicity photos and public
outings (‘‘Mariah Carey Discusses’’ 58). Though we can never know
how much agency stars exert over their image, Carey seems to per-
petuate wittingly an oversexual public persona. She represents a his-
torically comfortable vision of mixed race women. Carey poses little
232 Sika Alaine Dagbovie
threat to racial hierarchy because she fits a mold that showcases just
enough ‘‘blackness’’ to intrigue but not enough to appear definitive or
political.
NOTES
Works Cited
———. Heavenly Bodies: Film Stars and Society. New York: St. Martin’s
Press, 1986.
Ebert, Roger. Rev. of Monster’s Ball. Dir. Marc Forster. Chicago Sun-
Times 1 Feb. 2002. 1 Mar. 2004 hhttp://www.suntimes.com/ebert/
ebert_reviews/2002/02/020101/htmli.
Farley, Christopher John. Pop’s Princess Grows Up. Time 25 Sept.
1995: 75.
Felpenn, Lisa. Rev. of Monster’s Ball. Dir. Marc Forster. Sight and Sound
June 2002 sec. 12.6: 46.
Giroux, Henry A. ‘‘The Politics of National Identity and the Pedagogy
of Multiculturalism in the USA.’’ Multicultural States: Rethinking
Difference and Identity. Ed. David Bennett. London: Routledge,
1998. 178 – 94.
Glitter. Dir. Vondie Curtis-Hall. Twentieth Century Fox, 2001.
Grigoriadis, Veronica. ‘‘The Money Honey.’’ Allure Sept. 2001: 1901.
‘‘Halle Berry.’’ Road to the Red Carpet. Entertainment Television. 3 May
2003.
Haynes, Esther. ‘‘Am I Going to Be Happy or Not?’’ Jane Dec. 2003:
126 – 28.
Hill, James. ‘‘ ‘Outing’ Diesel.’’ Bet.com. 2 Aug. 2002. 4 Mar. 2004
hhttp://www.bet.com.articles/o,,c3gb3453-4121,00.htmli.
Hirschberg, Lynn. ‘‘The Beautiful and Damned.’’ New York Times
Magazine 23 Dec. 2001: 26.
Iverem, Esther. ‘‘A Monster Love.’’ Rev. of Monster’s Ball. Dir. Marc
Forster. 21 Feb. 2002. Seeing Black. 26 Feb. 2004 hhttp://www.
seeingblack.com/x022102/monstersball.shtmli.
Jenkins, Sacha, Elliott Wilson, Jefferson Mao Chairman, Gabriel
Alvarez, and Brent Rollins. Ego Trip’s Big Book of Racism! New
York: Regan Books, 2002.
Johnson, Lynne D. ‘‘Bearing the Black Female Body as Witness in
Sci-Fi.’’ 1 Dec. 2003. Pop Matters. 1 Mar. 2004 hhttp://www.
popmatters.com/columnsjohnson/031218.shtmli.
Jones, Lisa. ‘‘The Blacker the Berry.’’ Essence June 1994: 601.
———. Bulletproof Diva: Tales of Race, Sex and Hair. New York:
Doubleday, 1994.
Kangaris, Charlie. ‘‘Halle Berry.’’ Senses of Cinema. 23 Nov./Dec.
2002. 1 Mar. 2004 hhttp://www.sensesofcinema.com/contents/02/
23/symposium1.html#berryi.
Kennedy, Dana. ‘‘Halle Berry, Bruised and Beautiful, Is on a Mission.’’
New York Times 10 Mar. 2002: 2A1.
Kerr, Philip. ‘‘A Shocking Cheek.’’ New Statesmen 17 June 2002: 44.
236 Sika Alaine Dagbovie
Kirkland, Bruce. ‘‘Word’s Out: Vin’s In.’’ Toronto Sun. 4 Aug. 2004.
4 Mar. 2004 hhttp://www.canoe.ca/JamMoviesArtistsD/diesel_vin.
htmli.
La Ferla, Ruth. ‘‘Generation E.A.: Ethnically Ambiguous.’’ New York
Times 28 Dec. 2003, sec. 9: 11.
‘‘Mariah Carey Discusses Her Sex Life, Race, Career.’’ Jet 31 May 2000:
56 – 60.
‘‘Mariah Carey: Shining Through the Rain.’’ Interview with John
Norris. MTV. 3 Dec. 2002.
‘‘Mariah Carey Talks to Biracial Teens.’’ Oprah. ABC. 27 Dec. 1999.
Transcript.
‘‘Mariah Carey Tells Why She Looks White but Sings Black.’’ Jet 3 Apr.
1991: 56 – 57.
Mencke, John G. Mulattoes and Race Mixture: American Attitudes and
Images, 1865 – 1918. Ann Arbor: Umi Research Press, 1979.
Morgan, Joan. ‘‘Free at Last.’’ Essence Apr. 2005: 118 – 24
‘‘Monster Balls.’’ Rev. of Monster’s Ball, dir. Marc Forster. Metaphilm.
29 Feb. 2004 hhttp://www.metaphilm.com/philms/monstersball.
htmli.
Mora, Renee Scolaro. Rev. of XXX, dir. Rob Cohen. Pop Matters 9 Aug.
2002. 16 Feb. 2004 hhttp://www.popmatters.com/film/reviews/x/
xxx.shtmli.
Mumford, Kevin J. Interzones: Black/White Sex Districts in Chicago and
New York in the Early Twentieth Century. New York: Columbia
University Press, 1997.
Normant, Lynn. ‘‘Mariah Carey: Not Another White Girl Trying to
Sing Black.’’ Ebony Mar. 1991: 54 – 58.
Ogunnaike, Lola. ‘‘Through the Fire.’’ Vibe Mar. 2003: 113 – 20.
Pappademas, Alex. ‘‘Over the ‘Rainbow’: A Tale of Two Mariahs.’’
Boston Phoenix. 22 Nov. 1999. 24 Mar. 2004 hhttp://weeklywire.
com/ww/11-22-99/boston_music_2.htmli.
Prince. ‘‘Controversy.’’ Controversy. Warner Bros., 1981.
Ritz, David. ‘‘Heart to Heart.’’ Essence Dec. 2002: 1281.
Root, Maria P. P. ‘‘From Shortcuts to Solutions.’’ Racially Mixed People
in America. Ed. Maria P. P. Root. Newbury Park: Sage, 1992.
342 – 47.
Schwarzbaun, Lisa. Rev. of Monster’s Ball. Entertainment Weekly 25 Jan.
2002. 2 Mar. 2004. EBSCO.
Samuels, Allison. ‘‘Angela’s Fire.’’ Newsweek 1 July 2002: 54.
Senello, Frank. Halle Berry: A Stormy Life. London: Virgin Books, 2003.
Stephens, Vincent. Rev. of Rainbow. Popular Music & Society Summer
2003, sec. 26.2: 234 – 35.
Mixed-Race Superstars 237