Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
A H Chowdhury
Professor, EEE, BUET
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Table of Contents
2
2
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
This also ensures more flexibility in selecting failure criteria and making
appropriate assumptions
3
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Two types of studies may require very different models and mathematical
approaches
4
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Redundancy in transmission system means ties between stations that are stronger
than would be warranted by normal loads, or links where none are required in basic
design
extra transmission capacity may be needed to avoid overloading under unusual operating
conditions
5
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Reliability and costs of installing additional components and operating the system
Since in an emergency there is not always enough time available for a cold start, some
reserve units are kept spinning to provide service immediately
6
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
– Selection of the level of modeling detail and analysis method, in order to be able to study
the correct phenomena
7
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Table of Contents
8
8
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Outage Definitions
U1 D1 U2 D2 U3 D3 U4 D4
Up
status
Failed
Time
In repairable systems, durations and effects of component and system failure states
are of particular interest
IEEE Committee Report, ‘Proposed Definitions of Terms for Reporting and Analyzing Outages of Electrical
Transmission and Distribution Facilities and Interruptions,’ IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and
Systems, Vol. 87, pp. 1318-1323, May 1968.
9
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Outage Definitions
10
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Outage Definitions
11
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Outage Definitions
Forced outage
An outage that results from emergency conditions directly associated with a
component, requiring that component be taken out of service immediately,
either automatically or as soon as switching operations can be performed, or an
outage caused by improper operation of equipment or human error
Scheduled outage
An outage that results when a component is deliberately taken out of service at a
selected time, usually for purposes of construction, preventive maintenance, or
repair
12
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Outage Definitions
13
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Outage Definitions
14
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Outage Definitions
15
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Outage Definitions
Forced interruption
An interruption caused by a forced outage
Scheduled interruption
An interruption caused by a scheduled outage.
16
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Outage Definitions
Temporary interruption
– has a duration limited to the period required to restore service by manual switching at
locations where an operator is not immediately available
– Such switching operations are typically completed within 1-2 hr
Sustained interruption
– Any interruption not classified as momentary or temporary
17
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Table of Contents
Outage definitions
18
18
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
19
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Assumptions in modeling
– These to a large extent establish the 'rules of the game‘
– Assumptions are made in such diverse areas as the representations of weather effects,
system load, planned maintenance, common-mode failures, and derated component states
– Assumptions are also required as to what effects, quantities or states can be neglected
Selection of the analytical method
– Based on number of considerations
• system structure and size
• component independence
• reparability
• failure and repair time distributions
• component failure modes
• effects of operating routines
• environmental effects etc.
20
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
21
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
22
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Table of Contents
Outage definitions
23
23
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
• The most common deterministic method for assessing power system reliability
is the N-1 criterion
– a considered reliable if it is able to withstand any prescribed outage situations or
contingencies within acceptable constraints
• Uncertainties
– Failures of components, plant, and systems occur randomly
– Uncertainties of new power generation projects,
– Uncertainties of future power demand and scope
– Uncertainties of regulatory constraints and external rules
24
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
• Deterministic approach does not recognize unequal probabilities of events that lead
to potential operating security limit violations
– can efficiently handle a numerous sets of possible alternatives, with different outcomes
and chances of occurrence, for which individual evaluations could be unfeasible
25
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
2. Situation Analysis
26
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
• Interaction Analysis
– Reveals cause and effect relationship
among user defined zones
– Zone interaction is defined by a zone
“cause” where outage is located and
a zone “affected” where violations
are experienced
• Situation Analysis
– Analyses events or situations that
have high probabilities or higher
impacts on system
– analysis results can be revealed in Probabilistic risk indices in
the impact/probability space impact/probability space
27
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
28
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
29
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
30
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
31
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
– Establish existing indices which serve as a guide for acceptable values in future reliability
assessments
32
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Table of Contents
Outage definitions
Construction of Reliability Model
Deterministic and probabilistic approaches
System hierarchical levels
Reliability cost and reliability worth
Data collection
33
33
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
System divided using its main functional zones which can be analyzed separately
– Generation systems
– Composite generation and transmission systems
– Distribution systems
34
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
35
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
36
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Main subsystems
Generating stations
– Each station or each unit in station analyzed separately
– Form input to both HL-I and HL-II assessments
Generating capacity
– Reliability of generating capacity evaluated by pooling all sources of generation and all
loads (i.e., HLI assessment studies)
Interconnected systems
– Generation of each system and tie lines between systems modeled, but network in each
system not considered
– Assessments are HLI studies
Composite generation/transmission
– Network limited to bulk transmission; integrated effect of generation and transmission
assessed (i.e., HLII studies)
37
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Distribution networks
– Reliability of distribution evaluated by considering ability of network fed from bulk supply
points in supplying load demands
– Analyzed separately rather than including them as complete systems in network reliability
evaluation
38
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Protection systems
– Reliability of protection systems analyzed separately
39
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Table of Contents
Outage definitions
Construction of Reliability Model
Deterministic and probabilistic approaches
40
40
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
41
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
To reduce frequency and duration of outages and to ameliorate their effect invest
either in design phase, operating phase, or both
Questions
– How much should be spent?
– Is it worth spending any money?
– Should reliability be increased, maintained at existing levels, or allowed to degrade?
– Who should decide— utility, a regulator, customer?
– On what basis should decision be made?
Underlying trend in all questions is the need to determine
– Worth of reliability in a power system
– Who should contribute to this worth
– Who should decide levels of reliability and investment required to achieve them
42
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Reliability, R
role in decision-making process ΔC
43
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Reliability, R
utility, customer, or society ΔC
44
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
45
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Table of Contents
Outage definitions
Construction of Reliability Model
Deterministic and probabilistic approaches
46
46
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Data Collection
47
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Data Collection
48
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Data Collection
Quality of data, and confidence that can be placed in it, dependent on accuracy
and completeness of compiled information
49
Power System Reliability Analysis - Preliminaries
Data Collection
– unit approach
Unit approach useful for assessing chronological changes in reliability of existing systems
50