Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Reduction to absurdity:
This is a fundamental logical loop. In fact it didn’t prove much. The basic thing
we demonstrated is that we use logic.
Reduction to infinity
When we try to demonstrate a truth we use syllogisms until we find a
contradiction:
Reduction to infinity
We can repeat this process until we find a proposition wrong. Then the whole
syllogism collapses. But if our first argument is quite strong (or just axiomatic)
then it could hold true for ever. In this case we assume that we are satisfied with
an adequate number of repetitions that support our primary argument more and
more…
Infinite regress
This is what we call an infinite regress. If P0 is our first proposition then it is true
if P1 is true, and P1 is true if P2 is true, and so on:
Pn+1 = Pn + I
If the first proposition P0 stands as ‘truth’ (like the sentence ‘logic is true’), then
we will never end with a contradiction nor with an affirmation.
Aristotle therefore believed that we can simply prove a theory by its axioms. Still
the problem remains: How can we find the originative source of a logical
argument?
Open Closed
Causal and infinite Acausal and spontaneous
Truths are demonstrable Truths are axiomatic
Effects need a cause to Effects are their own causes
explain them and vice versa
Time is an important Time is fundamentally an
property of nature illusion
God is an eternal question God is an internal question
Chance is explained with Chance is explained with
probabilities ‘meaningful’ coincidences
Classical determinism Quantum non-locality
Big Bang Model Steady State Universe
Infinity of infinities…