2.

11 Moral Relativism – Ethics in Law Enforcement 17/10/2018, 12)35 AM

Home Read Sign in

Search in book …

ETHICS IN LAW ENFORCEMENT

CONTENTS

Chapter 2: Ethical Systems

2.11 Moral Relativism

The principles of morality can be viewed as either relativist or absolutist (Souryal, 2011).
Moral relativism refers to the differences in morality from culture to culture. A moral
relativist’s perspective would state that what is moral in one culture may not be moral in
another culture, depending upon the culture. This is important for police officers to understand
in a pluralistic society in which many cultures and religions make up the community where the
police officer works. It is important for officers to appreciate that what may be immoral in a
traditional Canadian sense may not be moral to members of a culture traditionally found
outside of Canada. In realizing this, officers may be able to withhold judgment, or at the very
least empathize with the members from that community for what in the officer’s perspective
may be an immoral act.

https://opentextbc.ca/ethicsinlawenforcement/chapter/2-11-moral-relativism/ Page 1 of 4
2.11 Moral Relativism – Ethics in Law Enforcement 17/10/2018, 12)35 AM

Morality in policing is, in most cases, relativistic since police officers are prone to accept moral
standards that allow them to achieve goals within the police subculture, often at times contrary
to the morals within mainstream society (Catlin and Maupin, 2002). It is moral relativism that
enables police officers to accept lying to suspects in interviews in order to gain confessions, or
to witnesses to gain compliance. In this instance, an officer may believe that lying is not
morally permissible in certain circumstances, but is permissible in other situations. Another
example in which a moral relativist perspective may assist an officer is in understanding
circumstances surrounding physical punishment of children who misbehave. A culture may
maintain that physical puinishment is morally permissible, even though in Canada the same
punishment may be in violation of the Criminal Code. It is helpful for officers to understand
this while investigating these offences, so that they can build rapport and empathize with
suspects, and use moral relativity as a theme in interviews to alleviate the guilt the suspect may
feel.

Contrary to relativism, moral absolutism refers to the belief that morality is the same
throughout all cultures; that what is right in one culture is right in all cultures and what is
wrong in one culture is wrong in every culture. Here, the immoral act is always wrong, no
matter the culture, because there are universal rules governing morality. Police officers who are
absolutists would reject lying, relying instead on a deontological perspective in which the
consequences of the lie do not matter.

Moral relativism is a meta-ethical theory because it seeks to understand whether morality is the
same in different cultures. Proponents of moral relativism do not observe universal rules
governing moral conduct; rather, moral rules are contingent on at least one of:

Personality (McDonald, 2010)

Culture (McDonald, 2010)

Situations (Catlin and Maupin, 2010).

The difficulty with applying relativism to the police culture is that it does not take into account
the diversity of individuals that make up the police culture (Westmarland, 2008). One of the
initiatives of community policing is that police agencies now recruit from a wide range of
https://opentextbc.ca/ethicsinlawenforcement/chapter/2-11-moral-relativism/ Page 2 of 4
2.11 Moral Relativism – Ethics in Law Enforcement 17/10/2018, 12)35 AM

ethnic and cultural backgrounds (Barlow and Barlow, 2009; Kalunta-Crumpton, 2009). This
diversity within law enforcement is reflected by the wide array of attitudes that police have
toward various issues and the change that has occurred within policing (Newburn and Reiner,
2007). The ability of cultural norms to change is ever-present, and norms can and do change to
reflect the values of other cultures (Groarke, 2011). Ultimately, cultural relativism reflects the
notion that what is right is permissible in the culture the actor is within and that moral
principles are not universal (McDonald, 2010). Within the policing context, the moral
underpinnings of members of the police subculture are often in step with the morals of
mainstream society, but at times they are not.

LICENSE SHARE THIS BOOK

2.11 Moral Relativism by Steve

McCartney and Rick Parent is
licensed under a Creative Commons
Attribution 4.0 International License,
except where otherwise noted.

Powered by Pressbooks

https://opentextbc.ca/ethicsinlawenforcement/chapter/2-11-moral-relativism/ Page 3 of 4
2.11 Moral Relativism – Ethics in Law Enforcement 17/10/2018, 12)35 AM

Open Source | Open Textbooks | Open Book Publishing | Learn More

Previous (Chapter)

https://opentextbc.ca/ethicsinlawenforcement/chapter/2-11-moral-relativism/ Page 4 of 4