Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Desalination
H I G H L I G H T S
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: In this study, a hybrid solar-wind water distillation system (HSWWDS) is proposed and studied. The system con-
Received 11 January 2016 sists of a conventional single basin solar-still and a wind-water heater operating simultaneously. The advantage
Received in revised form 18 April 2016 of the proposed system is its ability to operate day and night and, therefore, it produces larger quantities of distill
Accepted 19 May 2016
water even in cloudy days with good winds. A simple model equations are constructed and simulated. Jordan's
Available online 27 May 2016
summer and winter climate conditions are considered to test the system and to estimate the monthly and annual
Keywords:
yields. Results have shown a significant increase in the distillation output especially at times when the wind en-
Hybrid Solar Wind Water-Desalination Renew- ergy is significant at summer nights. Furthermore, the effect of the size of the wind turbine on the performance of
able Wind-heat-generator the system has been studied and documented. The calculations showed that the yield can be three to four times
more than conventional solar distillers.
© 2016 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction Jordan is blessed with abundance of solar energy. The average daily
solar irradiation in Jordan ranges between 5.5–6.5 kWh/m2/day [8].
Renewable energy in the engineering sector has become very impor- Wind Atlas in Jordan indicates that large areas have average annual
tant and attractive. It is widely expected in the future that a large pro- wind speed between 6–6.5 m/s, and in some areas may exceed the av-
portion of energy used by the human race will derive from a variety of erage wind speed above 7 m/s at 10 m heights [8].
renewable sources. Renewable energy is used in many processes Several works have been carried out to use solar energy to produce
where thermal solar energy, wind energy, and geothermal energy distill water. Conventional or passive solar stills depend only on the
have been used in a large number of thermal systems such as air heat from the sun to produce water, they include different types such
heating, heated water, and water desalination [1–3]. as single effect, multi-effect, basin, double slope, and wick [9]. Solar stills
Jordan suffers from the lack of drinking water. On a per capita basis, are very simple systems for water distillation, which are driven by the
the lowest levels of water availability in the world are recorded by Jor- thermal energy collected from the sun. Brackish water is fed into a
dan [4]. Countries with per capita water production of less than basin, then it evaporates due to this thermal energy, finally, water
1000 m3/year are considered to be water-poor countries by most ex- vapor is condensed on the surface of the glass to be collected inside a
perts [5]. According to the world bank data [6], the renewable internal container [10]. The maximum efficiency of solar stills has reached 50%.
freshwater resources per capita in Jordan is 108 m3/year during the Stills with bad insulation caused a reduction of 14.5% in the still efficien-
years 2011–2015. This lists Jordan at only 20% of the water poverty cy. The increase in wind speed from 0–3.6 mph causes a 2% efficiency
levels [7]. loss in the still performance [11]. Even though, solar stills can provide
an effective solution in places that suffer from poor water quality
⁎ Corresponding author at: B.O. Box 3030, Irbid 21110, Jordan.
while having high solar intensities. Solar stills are cheap to manufacture
E-mail addresses: malnimr@just.edu.jo (M.A. Al-Nimr), kiwan@just.edu.jo and need less maintenance, but the main problem is the low water pro-
(S.M. Kiwan), mechsamer2011@yahoo.com (S. Talafha). duction rates [12]. Solar stills can be used in places with smaller needs
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.desal.2016.05.018
0011-9164/© 2016 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
34 M.A. Al-Nimr et al. / Desalination 395 (2016) 33–40
3. Mathematical modeling
Table 2
Data used in the current model simulation.
Ag
α ″g ¼ α 0g ð8Þ
Ab
α 0g ¼ α g 1−Rg ð9Þ
h3
H2 ¼ 0 ð10Þ
h3 þ hb Fig. 3. Weather data for 21st of December at the simulated site.
h1
H1 ¼ ð11Þ
h1 þ U 0cg−a
0
h3 hb
U 3b ¼ 0 ð18Þ
0 As h3 þ hb
hb ¼ U b 1 þ ð12Þ
Ab
The total heat transfer coefficient from water to glass can be obtain-
As
U 0cg−a ¼ U cg−a ð13Þ ed by the summation of all these three heat transfer coefficients:
Ab
h1 ¼ hcw þ hew þ hrw ð19Þ
Kg
h2
Lg
U cg−a ¼ ð14Þ
Kg The radiative heat transfer coefficient (hrw) is given by the following
þ h2
Lg expression:
h2 ¼ 5:8 þ 5V ð15Þ
hrw ¼ ε eff σ ðT w þ 273Þ2 þ ðT c þ 273Þ2 ðT w þ T c þ 546Þ ð20Þ
U ¼ U 12 þ U 3b ð16Þ
1 1
εeff ¼ þ −1 ð21Þ
h1 U 0cg−a εw εg
U 12 ¼ ð17Þ
h1 þ U 0cg−a
Fig. 4. Variation of glass and water temperatures for stand-alone still during 21st of June
Fig. 2. Weather data for 21st of June at the simulated site. with h3 = 612 W/m2 °C.
M.A. Al-Nimr et al. / Desalination 395 (2016) 33–40 37
Fig. 5. Variation of glass and water temperatures for the hybrid system during 21st of June,
Fig. 7. Variation of glass and water temperatures for the hybrid system during 21st of
with h3 = 612 W/m2 °C and At = 7 m2.
December with h3 = 496 and At = 7 m2.
Q : cw
P c ¼ eð25:317−T c þ273Þ Fc ¼ ð30Þ
5144
ð24Þ
Q :1
P w −P c
hew ¼ 16:27 10−3 hcw ð25Þ Q : ew
T w −T c Fe ¼ ð31Þ
Q :1
Q : cw ¼ hcw ðT w −T c Þ ð26Þ
Fig. 6. Variation of glass and water temperatures for stand-alone still during 21st of Fig 8. Time variation of water temperature and solar irradiation for conventional system
December with h3 = 496 W/m2 °C. during December 21st.
38 M.A. Al-Nimr et al. / Desalination 395 (2016) 33–40
Where PR/Atd is the rated power density of the selected wind turbine
and Vco = 25 m/s, Vin = 3 m/s and Vr = 11.5 m/s, are the cut-off, cut-in
and rated velocities, respectively. Eq. (35) is written in this form (i.e.,
function of rotor area) to simplify the analysis later while investigating
the effect of wind turbine power or rotor blade diameter on the yield of
the still. It should be noted that for the base case the rotor area At was
selected to be 7 m2 at which the wind turbine rated power is 1750 W.
This is comparable to the solar irradiation at turbine design speed.
The differential equation given by Eq. (3) is solved to obtain the var-
iation of the temperature of water and glass. Evaporation rate can be
calculated after knowing the temperatures, then distillate rate and effi-
Fig. 9. Variation of distillate water ratio of hybrid system to conventional system with ciencies can be calculated using:
power ratio.
∑hev ðT w −T c ÞΔt
η¼ ð36Þ
And ∑ðI þ P in ðV Þ=As ÞΔt
hev ðT w −T c Þ
_ ¼
m ð37Þ
Q: hfg
F r ¼ :rw ð32Þ
Q1
3.2. Simulation
The glass cover temperature is found by applying the steady state
energy equation as: The differential equation was solved numerically using multi-itera-
tion Huen's method:
h1 T w þ h2 T a 1
Tc ¼ ð33Þ T iþ1 i
w ¼ T w þ ðm1 þ m2 Þh ð38Þ
h1 þ h2 2
T iþ1 p
−T iw
m1 ¼ w
ð39Þ
U h
a¼ ð34Þ
Mw C w
T iþ2
w
p
−T iþ1
w
p
m2 ¼ ð40Þ
h
Fig. 4 shows the variation of the saline water and glass cover temper- 5. Conclusion
atures during the summer day for the conventional system. While Fig. 5
shows the variation of the saline water and glass cover temperatures In this study, a hybrid wind water distillation system is proposed and
during the summer day for the hybrid system. It is worth mentioning studied. The system is consisted of a single basin solar still and a wind
that the results obtained in this case are close to the experimental re- water heater. The advantages of this system are: increasing the distillate
sults reported by [24] for a similar system. They reported still efficiency output and the efficiency, and being operational in night and cloudy
of 20.2% and the distillate water production of 2.36 kg/day. times. A validated mathematical model is selected from literature and
Close inspection of Figs. 4 and 5 shows that the temperatures of the modified to describe the hybrid system. Simulation is carried out
brackish water and the glass covers for the hybrid system are higher under Jordanian summer and winter climates.
than for the stand alone system due to the energy introduced by the Results have shown an increase in distillation efficiency and distilla-
wind water heater. It is also noticed that for the hybrid system the tem- tion output. Result have also shown an increase in thermal lag of 20 min.
perature difference between the brackish water and the glass cover In addition, the relationship between the wind turbine radius and the
temperatures is slightly increased. This is due to the increase of the performance of the system has been shown, it has been shown that in-
water temperature associated with the wind water heater. It is also no- creasing the wind turbine radius increases the efficiency and the distil-
ticed that a temperature gradient is developed during the night due to lation output of the system.
the wind water heating, which causes the system to stay operational It should be noted that the results presented here are dependent on
at night. It is expected to have good yield during the night because the the climate conditions of the selected site. The system, as many renew-
outside temperature is low and then, the condensation process is faster able energy systems, is very sensitive to the assumed values of design
than the day. The daily yield for the hybrid system was calculated to be operating parameters such as wind machine size (diameter) and solar
5.1 kg/day. This means that the yield of the hybrid system 216% of the still. However, the proposed design itself is very flexible and the ratio
conventional system during this summer day. between the sizes of the two systems are left to the users. In locations
Figs. 6 and 7 show the time variation of the glass and water temper- with high wind speeds then the size of the wind machine may be small-
atures during 21st of December for the stand alone system and for the er to produce same amount of distilled water. On the other side if the lo-
hybrid system, respectively. The weather data shown in Fig. 3 are cation has high solar radiation the solar still may be smaller and so on.
used. The efficiency of the stand-alone still is calculated to be 11.34%, Finally, the authors would like to thank Mr. ME Dahdolan for his help
and the distillate rate is calculated to be 0.5296 kg/day. It is noticed in editing the manuscript.
that the temperatures of the brackish water and the glass covers for
the hybrid system are higher than for the stand alone system in the
same way during summer. It is also noticed that there is a noticeable in- References
crease in the temperature difference between the brackish water and
the glass cover temperatures, this due to the increase of the water tem- [1] M.A. Al-Nimr, M.K. Alkam, A modified tubeless solar collector partially filled with
porous substrate, Renew. Energy 13 (2) (February 1998) 165–173.
perature associated with the wind water heater. It is also noticed that a [2] V. Nelson, Wind Energy: Renewable Energy and the Environment, CRC Press, 2009.
temperature gradient is developed during the night due to the wind [3] J. Tabak, Solar and Geothermal Energy, first ed. Facts on File, New York, 2009.
water heating, which causes the system to stay operational at night [4] H. El-Naser, Management of Scarce Water Resources: A Middle Eastern Experience,
WITPRESS, 2009.
and at cloudy times. The efficiency of the system was calculated to be
[5] GTZ and NRA, National Water Master Plan. Rep. Agrar- und Hydrotechnik and BGR,
15.61%, and the daily yield was calculated to be 1.0871 kg/day. (Hannover, Frankfurt, Amman), 1977.
Fig. 8 shows the relationship between brackish water temperature [6] Wordbank database, http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/ER.H2O.INTR.PC, last
and the solar irradiance for the conventional distillation system. It is visted April 14, 2016.
[7] M.S. Mohsen, Water strategies and potential of desalination in Jordan, Desalination
shown that there is a thermal response of the brackish water when 203 (1–3) (February 2007) 27–46.
heated by the sun. The thermal lag (describes a body's thermal mass [8] Jordan Meteorological Department: Jordan Annual Climate Bulletin, JMD, Amman,
with respect to time, body with high thermal mass will have a large Jordan, 2007.
[9] H.E.S. Fath, Solar distillation: a promising alternative for water provision with free
thermal lag) between the maximum solar irradiance and the maximum energy, simple technology and a clean environment, Desalination 116 (1) (Septem-
water temperature is found to be 1 h and 40 min while it is found to be ber 1998) 45–56.
2 h for the hybrid system (not shown). [10] K. Vinoth Kumar, R. Kasturi Bai, Performance study on solar still with enhanced con-
densation, Desalination 230 (1–3) (September 2008) 51–61.
To investigate the effect of wind power introduced to the system on [11] A. Maalej, Solar still performance, Desalination 82 (1–3) (August 1991) 197–205.
the overall system performance, Fig. 9 has been produced. The rated [12] J.A. Duffie, W.A. Beckman, Solar Engineering of Thermal Processes, Wiley, New York,
power of the wind turbine is varied by changing the swept area of the 1991.
[13] S.P. Sukhatme, Solar Energy: Principle of Thermal Collection and Storage, Tata
turbine. It is then assumed that area is the only variable that affect the McGraw-Hill, New Delhi, 1987.
wind turbine output. Other variables such as power coefficient, cut-in, [14] H.S. Aybar, A review of desalination by solar still, in: L. Rizzuti, H.M. Ettouney, A.
rated and cut-out wind speeds are kept unchanged. Fig. 9 shows the re- Cipollina (Eds.), Solar Desalination for the 21st Century, Springer 2007,
pp. 207–214.
lationship between the ratio of power input to the system by wind and
[15] G.N. Tiwari, A.K. Tiwari, Solar Distillation Practice for Water Desalination Systems,
solar and the ratio of distillate water of the hybrid system to conven- Anshan, New Delhi, 2008.
tional system. As expected, the amount of distillate water increases [16] Y. Nakatake, H. Tanaka, A new maritime lifesaving distiller driven by wind, Desalina-
with increasing the power input ratio. However, this change of distillate tion 177 (1–3) (June 2005) 31–42.
[17] M.A. Eltawil, Z. Zhao, Wind turbine-inclined still collector integration with solar still
water is subjected to increase or decrease according to the wind distri- for brackish water desalination, Desalination 249 (2) (December 2009) 490–497.
bution. Nevertheless, for this location it is clear the distillate water for [18] N. Ninić, B. Klarin and I. Tolj, Offshore Hybrid Wind Power-Distillation Plant. Patent
the hybrid system can reach 4 times larger than that of conventional P20110545A, 2011.
[19] N. Ninić, B. Klarin, I. Tolj, Hybrid wind-power-distillation plant, Therm. Sci. 16 (1)
system. (2012) 251–261.
Finally, the yield of the water distillate was calculated for each [20] J.A. Carta, J. González, V. Subiela, The SDAWES project: an ambitious R&D prototype
month for conventional and the hybrid systems. The values are listed for wind-powered desalination, Desalination 161 (1) (February 2004) 33–48.
[21] A. Maurel, “Desalination by RO Using RE (Solar & Wind): Cadarache Center Experi-
based on daily average and plotted in Fig. 10. It is clear that for this ence,” in Proceedings of the New Technologies for the Use of RE Sources in Water
site the wind energy potential in spring and summer is high and, there- Distillation, 1991.
fore, the amount of water distillate for the hybrid system is higher than [22] M. Gökçek, Ö.B. Gökçek, Technical and economic evaluation of freshwater produc-
tion from a wind-powered small-scale seawater reverse osmosis system (WP-
that of the conventional system. On annual basis, the amount of water
SWRO), Desalination 381 (2016) 47–57.
produced by the hybrid system reached four times of those quantities [23] M.A. Al-Nimr, W.A.M. Al-Shohani, Design of a wind water heater, Appl. Mech. Mater.
produced by conventional system. 110-116 (2011) 4970–4976.
40 M.A. Al-Nimr et al. / Desalination 395 (2016) 33–40
[24] A.K. Tiwari, G.N. Tiwari, Annual performance analysis and thermal modelling of pas- [27] J. Fernandez, N. Chargoy, Multistage, indirectly heated solar still, Sol. Energy 44
sive solar still for different inclinations of condensing cover, Int. J. Energy Res. 31 (1990) 2–215.
(14) (2007) 1358–1382. [28] S. Mathew, Wind Energy Fundamentals: Resource Analysis and Economics, Spring-
[25] G.N. Tiwari, Solar Energy, Fundamentals, Design, Modelling and Applications, CRC er-Verlag, Berlin Heidelberg, 2006.
Press, New York, and Narosa Publishing House, New Delhi, India, 2003 280–281.
[26] A.K. Tiwari, G.N. Tiwari, Thermal modeling based on solar fraction and experimental
study of the annual and seasonal performance of a single slope passive solar still: the
effect of water depths, Desalination 207 (6) (2007) 184–204.