Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Tidal discharge and area-averaged current speed were mcasurcd over complete tidal
cycles at the ehtrancc to a salt marsh drainage system near Wachaprcaguc, Virginia. A
pronounced asymmetry in curves of discharge and current speed through time was observed
which can be simulated by a model incorporating scmidiurnal tides and “overtides” in
conjunction with marsh and chamlel storage relationships. As a persistent feature in marsh
channel flow relationships, the asymmetry, along with an apparent diffcrencc in flood and
ebb maxima, may have a systematic, long telm influence on the net transport of suspended
matter entering and leaving natural marshes,
This paper presents the results of a se- The significance of tidal current asym-
ries of detailed flow measurement made at metrics in relation to the transport of sus-
the entrance to a small tidal marsh channel pended matter was emphasized by Postma
and describes a marked asymmetry or dis- (1961, 1967) and Groen (1967) in the course
tortion in the curves of discharge and cur- of their work in the Dutch Wadden Sea.
rent speed, found to be typical of this type Speaking primarily of the tidal flat and
of system. The asymmetry observed rcp- channel complex in the western part of
rcscnts a significant departure from the the Wadden Sea, Postma illustrated a pro-
nearly sinusoidal curves found in many nounced current asymmetry for flow con-
other tidal waterways, common examples fined during part of each cycle to a tidal
of which are illustrated in tidal current pre- channel and extending the remainder of
diction tables, For a simple sine curve, cx- the time over a tidal flat. In this instance,
treme values occur midway between the the current maxima were shifted toward the
zero or slack water crossings. For the sys- time of low water slack, just opposite to
tem in question, flood. and ebb extrcma the shift mentioned above for marsh chan-
typically occur at between 1 and 2 hr nels. Groen later presented a theoretical
before and after the time of high water model incorporating the asymmetry ob-
slack ( slack before ebb) ,’ or some 4 to 5 served by Postma to show how a residual
hr away from low water slack (slack be- (nontidal) transport of suspended sediment
fore flood) in a normal cycle of slightly could occur in a channel experiencing no
more than 12-hr duration. There arc other net transport of water over a complete
examples (Myrick tind Leopold 1963; Pes- tidal cycIe. The direction of the residual
trong 1965) but I am not aware that the predicted by the model was landward, or
cause of the distortion has ever been satis- toward the inner reaches of the Wadden
factorily cxplaincd. I offer an explanation Sea as had long been inferred (Postma
here with the aid of a model simulating 1954; Van Straatcn and Kuenen 1957).
marsh channel hydraulics, or more prop- In other areas such as the east coast of
erly, marsh and channel conveyance-storage the United States, the question of residual
relationships. sediment transport in a variety of tidal
-- waterways remains problematic (Meade
1 Contribution No. 630 Virginia Institute of Ma- 1969, 1974; Oostdam 1971; Boon 1974).
rinc Science. Few field studies have been made that in-
’ This work was partly supported by the RANN corporate adequate temporal and spatial
program of the National Science Foundation with measures of suspended sediment concen-
initial support from NSF doctoral dissertation grant
CA 28545. This paper contains portions of a Ph.D. tration and current velocity, the principal
thesis submitted to the College of William and variables in the transport equation. Added
Mary, Williamsburg, Virginia, to this is the uncertainty of seasonal ef-
LIMNOLOGY AND OCEANOGRAPHY 71 JANUARY l97.5, V. 20( 1)
72 Boon
Fig. 2. Little Fool Creek during the initial Fig. 3. Little Fool Creek during maximum
stage of marsh flooding (MLW + 1.00 m). flood stage (MLW + 1.25 m).
surface arca plotted against tidal height As input to equation 3, I measured free
for a marsh drainage system. Strahler surface areas matched to tidal stage in the
( 1952), however, had previously system- creek system shown in Fig, 1. Low altitude
atized hypsometric relationships for a vari- aerial photographs were taken near the vcr-
ety of terrestrial drainage basins, using a tical using black and white infrared film
mathematical expression (35-mm Kodak high speed infrared) dur-
d-x a a ing various stages of a spring tide. Water
ZJ= ----Xx
x d-n 1
where d and a are constants representing
)
areas appear black and the resolution of
their margins is enhanced in positives made
from this film. Three measured baselines,
maximum and minimum area, x and q previously marked on the ground, were
represent area and relative height, and X used to determine scale in the photographs
is an exponential constant. Strahler dem- an d assess distortion effects. Tidal heights
onstrated that most drainage configurations were obtained during the overflights by a
could be described by this formula which recording tide gauge installed at the mouth
gencratcs a large family of curves depend- of the creek. To verify location and height
ing on one’s choice of x and the factor r of true water margins at specific times, scv-
= a/cl, a constant controlling the degree of era1 control points at the apparent margins
curvature. in the photographs were field identified
In the present case, it is necessary to and connected by levels to the tide gauge
modify Strahlcr’s formula since he dealt datum (mean low water). The agreement
with basin areas above a given elevation between true and apparent margins was
whereas the present problem requires that good in comparison to the resolution per-
portion of the total drainage area below mitted by the photographs. Finally, areas
a given height to match that of the water’s were measured with a planimeter, appro-
free surface. The resulting expression is priately scaled, and matched with the cor-
responding height of tide.
The curvature factor, r, in equation 3
results immediately once estimates of A,,i,,
and A,,,, are in hand. The exponent x
where 72’= dimensionless tidal height and comes through trial and error curve fitting
Auax T Anin are the extreme free surface to the remaining data, plotted in dimen-
areas produced by the tide in a given sionless form as A’ and 7%‘. In my experi-
drainage basin. The dimensionless height ence estimation of the limiting values of
is defined as height and area is reasonably straightfor-
ward because the convergence to these end
points is fairly well defined for any given
marsh basin. In contrast, the so-called
considering hlllill, h,,,, to be the limiting bankfull stage, important in terrestrial
heights corresponding to the fret surface stream hydraulics (Leopold and Maddock
extremes. For convenicncc in determining 1953; Wolman and Miller 1960), is not
area as a function of height, equation 2 clearly defined in a marsh. A limitation
can be rewritten as imposed by equations 2 and 3 is that Anlill
must not be zero.
A,= r(l-G) Figure 4 contains the data from my study
. G=(l-h’)l’“, (3)
r+G(l-r)’ (with A,,, = 80,200 m2, 72,,,,,= 1.20 m, Alnil)
Tidal discharge in a salt mursh 75
Table 1. A comparison of total discharge values (m”) derived by the hypsometric model and by
flow measurements at the entrance to Little Fool Creek, Phase: F-flood; E-ebb; R-residual. Tidal
datum is MLW.
TIME (hours) +
Fig. 5. Simulated tidal discharge curves for three different vahm of mean tidal amplit~ldc, II, at
entrance to Little Fool Creek, showing inflnencc of “overticlcs.”
20 DEC 1972 c
80
70 0- FLOOD
60 t A- EBB
/
IO
I
///’ , I
3
1
4
1 1-I
5 6 789
2
I 1 21 JAN 1973
Qmax ( m3/ set) -
( 1963) demonstrated that discharge and (Boon 1973, 1974) indicated a prcdomi-
current speed at a station are related by nantly seaward net transport of suspended
a simple power law of the form u = 7cQnL sediment in the system shown in Fig. 1.
where 7cand m are dimensionless constants. However, other processes besides the flow
An interesting footnote to their work re- asymmetry were found to be at work which
sults if one considers only the peak values caused both the direction and the magni-
in each cycle. tude of the residual to vary seasonally.
In Fig. 7, measured maximum discharge Among these were water temperature,
values ( qXnRX)are plotted against maximum which showed a positive association with
current speeds ( urnax), the latter computed seasonal suspended sediment levels, and an
as spatially weighted averages from eight annual cycle in monthly mean sea level
current meters operating simultaneously in due to a steric effect (Pattullo et al.
the flow section. Adopting the power law 1955)) which produces seasonal variations
convention, good correlation results be- in the volume of water flooding the marsh.
tween ulnas and ulllas values for a number Less information exists on transient effects,
of tides having varying combinations of such as the creation of horizontal gradients
range and mean water level; however, the of suspcndcd sediment between bay and
slopes of the fitted curves for flood and ebb marsh by the action of wind waves.
ensembles arc significantly different. Fig- Future studies in tidal marshes by gc-
urc 7 suggests that there is an additional ologists and biologists may require esti-
effect, perhaps a friction related one, that mates of transport of suspended solids in
accounts for the more rapid increase in dissolved and particulate, organic and in-
U IllRS with increasing ql,,n, in the cast of organic form, An understanding of the
ebb flows. Similarly, if all tides over a temporal and spatial relationships in tidally
year were to be considered, the mean levels induced flows is highly germane to this
of q,,lns and ~~~~~~ apparently would both be work. However, the determination of time-
grcatcr for ebb flows, although more data varying tidal discharge by means of an
are needed to confirm this interpretation. arca-height model, rather than by direct
flow measurements, is not recommcndcd
Dkcussion for the calculation of net transport. The
net movement of suspended matter in
Tidal discharge asymmetries occur in
marsh channels has been the subject of lit-
tidal marsh creeks as a consequence of
tle basic research to date, particularly inso-
drainage basin morphology and storage
far as flow measurements are concerned.
characteristics in conjunction with prevail-
ing tidal range and stage. In other parts Sectional flow measurements obtained with
of the marsh-lagoon complex, such as the precision current meters can be expected
drainage channels found on exposed mud to yield better accuracies than those which
flats, a different set of morphologic and the assumptions inherent in an area-height
tidal conditions can be expected. Postma’s model can support, and on which confi-
(1961) observation that tidal flat chamrels dencc in the present model indeed de-
demonstrate a flow asymmetry which is out pends. In other applications, such as the
of phase by half a tidal wavelength from hindcasting of total flood or ebb discharge
the asymmetry here described for marsh (tidal prism) and long term prism distribu-
chamrels does not, therefore, conflict with tions from continuous tide data. the arca-
my results. Moreover, the interesting thc- height model can be very useful.
ory by Groen (1967) showing how the
direction of residual suspended sediment fieferences
transport may depend on flow asymmetry
has added implications insofar as transport B0oN, J- I’* 1973. Sediment transport processes
in a salt marsh drainage system. Ph.D. thesis,
within marsh channels is conccrncd. Collcgc of William and Mary, Williamsburg,
Data collected and reported elsewhere Va. 226 p.
80 Boon
--. 1974. Optimized measurements of dis- draulic gcomctry of a small tidal estuary.
charge and suspended sediment transport in U.S. Geol. Surv. Prof. Pap. 422-13. 18 p.
a saIt marsh drainage system, in press. In OOSTDA~I, B. L. 1971. Suspended sediment
Symp. Int., “Relations scdimcntaircs entrc cs- transport in Delaware Bay. Ph.D. thesis,
tuaires et plateaux continentaux.” Inst. Gcol. Univ. Delaware, Newark, 316 p.
du Bassin d’Rquitaine, Bordeaux. PATTULLO, J., W. MUNK, R. REVELLE, AND E.
BYRNE, R. J., AND J. D. BOON. 1973. An inex- STIXONG. 1955. The seasonal oscillation in
pensive, fast response current speed indicator. sea level. J, M ar. Res. 14: 88-155.
Chesapeake Sci. 14: 217-219. PE~TRONC, R. 1965. The development of drain-
DOODSON, A. T., AND I-I. D. W~nuvnc. 1941. Ad- age patterns on tidal marshes. Stanford Univ.
miralty manual of tides. Admiralty Hydrogr. P&l. Geol. Sci., Tech. Rep. 10. 87 p.
Office, London. 270 p. l'OSl'h$A, I-1. 1954. Hydrography of the Dutch
CROEN, P. 1967. On the residual transport of Waddcn Sea. Arch. Neerl. Zool. 10: 405-
suspended matter by an alternating tidal cur- 511.
rent. Neth. J. Sea Res. 3: 564-574. -. 1961. Suspended matter and Secchi
HUTTON, R. E:. 1945. Erosional development of disc visibility in coastal waters. Ncth. J. Sea
streams and their drainage basins; hydrophys- Res. 1: 359-390.
ical approach to quantitative morphology. -. 1967. Sediment transport and scdimcn-
Gcol. Sot. Am. Bull. 56: 275-370. tation in the estuarine environment, p. 15%
JENKINS, G. M., AND D. G. Wn~rs. 179. In G. H. Lauff [ed.], Estuaries. Am.
1968. Spec-
tral analysis and its applications. Holden- Assoc. Adv. Sci. Publ. 83.
HAGOTZKIE, R. A., AND R. A. BRYSON. 1955. IIy-
Day.
drography of the Duplin River, Sapclo Island,
LIXWOLD, L. B., AND T. MADDOCK. 1953. The
Gcorgin. hll. Mar. Sci. Gulf Carib. 5: 297-
hydraulic geometry of stream channels and
314.
some physiographic implications. U.S. Geol.
STRAIILEI~, A. N. 1952. Hypsometric (area-alti-
Surv. Prof. Pap. 252. 57 p.
tude) analysis of erosional topography. Geol.
MEADE, R. II. 1969. Landward transport of bot- Sot. Am. Bull. 63: 1117-1142.
tom sediments in estuaries of the Atlantic VAN STIIAATEN, L. M. J. U., AND P. I-1. KUENEN.
Coastal Plain. J. Scdimcnt. Petrol. 39: 222- 1957. Accumulation of fine-graincd sedi-
234. ments in the Dutch Wadden Sea. Gcol. Mijn-
-. 1974. Net transport of sediment through bouw 19: 329-354.
the mouths of estuaries: seaward or land- WOLMAN, M. G., AND J. P. MILLER. 1960. Mag-
ward?, in press. In Symp. Int., “Relations nitude and frcqucncy of forces in geomorphic
scdimcntaires entrc cstuaircs et plateaux con- processes. J. Gcol. 68: 54-74.
tinentaux.” Inst. Gcol. du Bassin d’Aquitainc,
Uordcanx. Submitted: 29 March 1974
MYIIICK, R. M., AND L. B. LEOPOLD. 1963. IIY- Accepted: 10 October 1974