Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
_________________________________________________________________________________________
Dear Assessor,
The model for assessment below is intended to aid the assessment process and not limit it. You
are perfectly free to add additional comments if these do not fit into one of the boxes. The aim is
to provide useful comments and helpful direction to the author if the article is deemed to be
publishable but in need of revision, or to provide an explanation if it is to be rejected.
Once you have carried out your assessment, please return it to the Editor-in-Chief, Professor
James Mandrell, at:
mandrell@brandeis.edu
Instructions: you are asked to fill in the boxes below, with a tick where appropriate. If you are
unsure of the options available, you may leave a box blank, but please indicate at the end your
reasons for doing so, in the final box, which is for your overall comments. Please note that your
comments and recommendations, suitably anonymised, will be passed on, to the author.
HOW WOULD YOU RATE THE ORIGINALITY AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE MANUSCRIPT?
ORIGINALITY:
Very high High Medium Low
X
SIGNIFICANCE:
Very high High Medium Low
X
YES NO
If necessary I am prepared to review a new version of the manuscript X
DATE OF ASSESSMENT
11/14/18