Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 6

[Downloaded free from http://www.jscisociety.com on Saturday, November 24, 2018, IP: 202.67.46.

239]

Original Article

Glaucoma awareness and knowledge in


a tertiary care hospital in a tier‑2 city in
South India
Mridula Prabhu,
Shankargouda H. Patil,
Abstract
Pravin Chandra R. Kangokar1 Background: Awareness of glaucoma is low in spite of being the second leading cause of
Departments of Ophthalmology, preventable blindness in the world. Aim: To study the awareness and knowledge levels
1
Community Medicine, S D M College of of glaucoma in a tertiary eye care hospital in a tier‑2 city. Materials and Methods: This
Medical Sciences and Hospital, Sattur, is a hospital‑based crosssectional study. A total of 704 patients attending ophthalmology
Dharwad, Karnataka, India outpatient department of Sri Dharmasthala Manjunatheshwara College of Medical
Sciences and Hospital (SDM) Dharwad, aged 40 years and above were administered a
questionnaire after a written informed consent to assess their awareness and knowledge
levels of glaucoma. Subjects “having heard of glaucoma” even before they were recruited
for the study were defined as “aware”, and subjects having some understanding of the eye
disease were defined as “knowledgeable”. Results: Out of 704 subjects recruited for the
study, only 34 (4.8%) subjects were aware of glaucoma and 22 (3.1%) had some knowledge of
glaucoma. Determinants of glaucoma awareness were higher levels of education, diabetes,
Address for correspondence:
or glaucoma and family history of glaucoma. Conclusion: Awareness and knowledge of
Dr. Mridula Prabhu,
Department of Ophthalmology, S D M
glaucoma was very low among the subjects. The findings of the study stress the need for
College of Medical Sciences and Hospital, health awareness for effective prevention of blindness due to glaucoma.
Sattur, Dharwad, Karnataka, India. Key words: Awareness, glaucoma, hospital‑based study, knowledge, south India
E‑mail: mridulaprabhu@rediffmail.com

INTRODUCTION There are numerous avenues to improve the prevention


of blindness from glaucoma, but improved early
Blindness is a concern world over. It affects a person detection offers the most potential. Social perceptions
socio‑economically, and the government’s spending of health have changed globally; there is an impetus to
toward health.[1] This is more so in a developing country move toward good health by using resources efficiently
like India. Glaucoma is the second leading cause of for preventive measures.[5]
visual loss in the world. The prevalence of glaucoma
worldwide is 67 million and 6.6 million people are There are various factors which influence awareness
blind due to glaucoma.[2] Blindness due to glaucoma is like level of education, family history, publicity by
irreversible but preventable. In India, glaucoma is the
media, and information distribution by government
third most common cause of blindness with a prevalence
agencies and non‑governmental organizations (NGO).
of 5.8% among the blind, next to cataract and uncorrected
refractive errors.[3] Nearly half of the blind people are The reason for undertaking this study is that previous
unaware of their condition.[4] studies done in India were mainly concentrated in
tier‑1 cities or at the rural level. [5‑7] We conducted
this study at SDM College of Medical Sciences and
Access this article online
Hospital which is a tertiary hospital situated in tier‑2
Quick Response Code
Website: city namely Dharwad, Karnataka state, India. Tier‑2
www.jscisociety.com cities are more in India and they consist of a mixture
of both urban and rural population. Hence, this
DOI: study was aimed at understanding the awareness
10.4103/0974-5009.109674 and knowledge about glaucoma in a tertiary eye care
hospital in a tier‑2 city.
Journal of the Scientific Society, Vol 40 / Issue 1 / January-April 2013 3
[Downloaded free from http://www.jscisociety.com on Saturday, November 24, 2018, IP: 202.67.46.239]

Prabhu, et al.: Glaucoma awareness and knowledge in a tier 2 city

MATERIALS AND METHODS Analysis was performed using the statistical software
IBM SPSS Statistics version 20 © copyright IBM
A sample size of 704 was calculated based on 13.3% Corporation 2010, New York 10589, USA. The Chi‑square
prevalence of glaucoma awareness in the population test and Fisher exact probability test were used to
above 40 years with an alpha error of 5% and a precision look for significant associations in awareness and
level of 10%. [5] The subjects were defined as every knowledge about glaucoma with other studied variables.
third patient above 40  years attending ophthalmology A probability (P) value less than 0.05 was considered
outpatient department of SDM medical college on statistically significant.
Tuesday, Thursday, and Saturday which happened to be
the outpatient days allotted to the investigator. We started RESULTS
on Jan 3, 2012 and stopped on June 30, 2012. Patients aged
less than 40 years and patients’ attenders were excluded. The questionnaire was administered to a total of 704
subjects and the answers were analyzed. (Response rate
Written informed consent was obtained from all subjects 100%). Among the subjects, 375 (53.3%) were males and
and the study was performed in accordance with the 329 (46.7%) were females. The mean age of the subjects
tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki. The Institutional was 54 ± 11 years. The minimum age was 40 years and
ethical committee clearance was taken from SDM College the maximum age was 90 years. The proportion of subjects
of Medical Sciences and Hospital. in each age cohort from 40 to 70 years was uniform. The
rural:urban ratio was 48.7:51.3 and the majority religion
Demographic details and literacy levels of all subjects were was Hindu (92.9%). Among the subjects, 153 (21.7%)
obtained. A brief structured open‑ended questionnaire were illiterates and 180 (25.6%) were college educated.
was designed to record information about the subject’s 175 (24.9%) subjects were diabetic, 12 (1.7%) had glaucoma,
awareness and knowledge about glaucoma [Annexure and 5 (0.7%) subjects had family history of glaucoma.
1]. The questionnaire was initially developed in English
and all the questions were translated into the two Table 1 shows frequency distribution of awareness
and knowledge of glaucoma among subjects. Out
most common languages Kannada and Hindi if the
of 704 subjects, only 34 (4.8%) subjects had heard of
subjects could not follow English. The questionnaire
was interviewer administered. The questionnaire was
administered prior to the history taking and examination Table 1: Frequency distribution of awareness and
procedures carried out for glaucoma. Details on the knowledge of glaucoma among subjects
Variables Total n=704
knowledge about glaucoma were obtained only for
Awareness Yes (%)
subjects who were aware of glaucoma.
Have you ever heard of the eye condition 34 (4.8)
glaucoma
Awareness and knowledge about glaucoma Not aware of glaucoma 670 (95.1)
Definition Knowledge
Subjects “having heard of glaucoma” even before being Risk factors for glaucoma
recruited for the study were defined as aware and One factor
patients who were having some understanding of the eye Obesity 3 (0.43)
disease were defined as knowledgeable. Knowledge was Increased IOP 14 (1.99)
graded as good, fair, and poor by two ophthalmologists Steroids 3 (0.43)
independently based on the subjects’ collective responses Chronic smoking+alcohol using 6 (0.85)
to questions on glaucoma. Family history of glaucoma 11 (1.56)
Diabetes 15 (2.13)
Two factors
Subjects were considered to have good knowledge, if they
IOP and steroids 2 (0.28)
were able to identify the risk factors for glaucoma such as
IOP and family history 7 (0.99)
increased intraocular pressure, family history, steroid use,
Steroids and family history 3 (0.43)
and able to meaningfully describe the condition along Three factors
with identifying treatment options. Fair knowledge was IOP, steroids and family history 2 (0.28)
considered if at least two of the risk factors were identified Risk factors not known 15 (2.13)
and a description of at least one treatment option was Meaningful description of glaucoma
correctly provided. Subjects were considered to have poor Increased IOP, eye pressure 14 (1.99)
knowledge, if they were not able to identify more than Loss of side vision 9 (1.28)
a single/no risk factor or treatment option for glaucoma. IOP=Intraocular pressure

4 Journal of the Scientific Society, Vol 40 / Issue 1 / January-April 2013


[Downloaded free from http://www.jscisociety.com on Saturday, November 24, 2018, IP: 202.67.46.239]

Prabhu, et al.: Glaucoma awareness and knowledge in a tier 2 city

glaucoma (awareness  =  4.8%). In the latter group, 12 Friend or glaucoma person in 4 (0.57%) subjects.
had only heard about glaucoma but had no further 7 (0.99%) subjects thought that visual loss due to glaucoma
knowledge of glaucoma. Among the 22 (3.1%) subjects was permanent, 4 (0.57%) thought it was reversible, and
who had knowledge, 12 had poor knowledge, 5 had fair the remaining 23 (3.27%) subjects did not know whether
knowledge, and remaining 5 had good knowledge. Only visual loss due to glaucoma was permanent or reversible.
18 subjects knew that glaucoma was treatable.
Table 4 shows the subjects knowledge level on treatment
Table 2 shows determinants of awareness of glaucoma. options for glaucoma.
There was no association between awareness and gender,
age group, residence, religion. The awareness was Table 5 compares the current and past studies on
significantly related to the educational status, diabetics, awareness and knowledge.
glaucoma patients, and subjects with family history of
glaucoma. DISCUSSION
Table 3 shows awareness comparison across genders Glaucoma is one of the leading causes of irreversible
with education level. There was no significant difference blindness in developing nations. It is one of the major
in awareness across genders. causes of ocular morbidity that needs urgent attention.[8] As
the population of elderly group is increasing the incidence
The source of information for awareness of glaucoma was of glaucoma is bound to increase. To our knowledge this
A doctor in 16 (2.27%) subjects is the first tertiary care hospital‑based study in a tier‑2
Mass media in 14 (1.99%) subjects city conducted to know the awareness about glaucoma in

Table 2: Determinants of awareness of glaucoma


Variable Rate Aware Not aware Odds ratio and P by (Chi‑square/
in % n=34 n=670 95% CI Fisher exact test)
Gender 0.17 NS
Male 5.87 22 353 1
Female 3.65 12 317 0.61 (0.30-1.25)
Age group 0.47 NS
40‑49 3.74 7 180 1
50‑59 6.09 12 185 1.67 (0.64‑4.33)
60‑69 6.03 12 187 1.65 (0.64‑4.29)
70‑79 1.98 2 99 0.52  (0.10−2.55)
>80 5.0 1 19 1.35  (0.16−11.60)
Residence 0.11 NS
Rural 3.50 12 331 1
Urban 6.09 22 339 1.79 (0.87-3.68)
Religion 0.36 NS
Hindu 4.59 30 624 1
Muslim 7.14 3 39 1.60 (0.47‑5.47)
Christian 20 1 4 5.2 (0.56‑47.96)
Others 0 3
Literacy <0.00 Significant
Illiterate 0.65 1 152 1
Primary 0.74 1 134 1.93  (0.07−18.31)
Secondary 4.24 10 226 6.73 (0.85‑53.08)
College 12.2 22 158 21.16  (2.81−158.97)
Diabetic status 0.02 Significant
Non‑diabetic 3.7 20 509 1
Diabetic 8% 14 161 2.21 (1.09‑4.48)
Glaucoma status <0.00 Significant
Non‑glaucoma patient 3.6 25 667 1
Glaucoma patient 75 9 3 80.04 (20.41-313.83)
Family history of glaucoma <0.00 Significant
No 4.15 29 670 1
Yes 100 5 0 infinity

Journal of the Scientific Society, Vol 40 / Issue 1 / January-April 2013 5


[Downloaded free from http://www.jscisociety.com on Saturday, November 24, 2018, IP: 202.67.46.239]

Prabhu, et al.: Glaucoma awareness and knowledge in a tier 2 city

India. There are two such studies reported from Ethiopia 3.1% which was less compared to urban Chennai and
and Singapore in tertiary hospitals.[9,10] Hong Kong studies.[5,12]

In our study, 4.8% (34/704) of people were aware In our study, awareness with respect to gender, age,
of glaucoma, which appears to be lower than that residence, and religion is not significant; this was consistent
found in urban Chennai (13.3%), while higher than with studies done elsewhere.[9] But when we compared the
that found in rural (0.33%) southern India and urban awareness with respect to literacy rate, out of 34 people
Hyderabad (2.4%).[5‑7] It is noteworthy that these Indian except 1, all had basic primary education. Among the
studies were population‑based epidemiologic surveys educated, the awareness increased exponentially [Table 2].
on either rural or urban population, and different age It was more significant in people educated above college
group criteria were used in two of these studies; hence, a level. This shows that higher the education level, they are
direct comparison may not be applicable. The awareness more likely to be aware of glaucoma which was similarly
level was very low compared to reports from developed noted in other studies.[5‑7,9‑14] Another point in our study
nations but higher compared to developing nations like is that there was no significant gender difference in terms
Nepal (2.4%) and Ethiopia (2.4%).[9,11] Knowledge was of numbers who were educated till secondary level in
the aware group. But there was a tendency toward low
Table 3: Awareness comparison across genders (n=34) awareness in women in college level educated people
Education level Males Females Total though statistically not significant  (P  =  0.08) [Table 3].
Up to secondary level 6 6 12 This point again stresses that female education needs to
College level 16 6 22 be given more importance in India. In the present study,
Total 22 12 34 12 (1.7%) persons were having glaucoma, but among
Chi square=2.89, DF=1, P Yates=0.089 these, 9 people were aware of glaucoma and 3 people
were unaware of their glaucoma status and all the 3 were
Table 4: Frequency distribution of treatment procedures illiterates. This point highlights the above literacy factor.
for glaucoma among subjects
Variables: Therapies for treating glaucoma Total n=704 Diabetic patients were more aware of glaucoma. This
Yes (%)
is probably because there are an estimated 50.8 million
Is glaucoma treatable? 18 (2.56)
diabetics in India.[15] At some point of time, these people
Awae of only a single therapyre of only a
single therapy
visit doctor where the treating doctor might have given
Eye drops 11 (1.56) education regarding ocular problems in diabetes. This
Surgery 9 (1.28) also supports our study report that doctors were the main
Laser treatment 6 (0.85) source of information in 16 (2.27%) patients regarding
Aware of two therapies awareness of glaucoma, which was followed by media
Eye drops and surgery 4 (0.57) 14  (1.99%), and family history 4  (0.57%). This differs
Eye drops and laser 4 (0.57) from other studies that the media in rural area and the
Surgery and laser 1 (0.14) family/friend in urban area were the main sources of
Aware of more than two therapies awareness in previous studies.[6,7] Those with family
Eye drops, surgery and laser 2 (0.28) history of glaucoma and glaucoma patients themselves
Treatment not known 11 (1.56) were more aware similar to other studies.[5,10,13] Family
Can’t say/No Answer 5 (0.71) history of glaucoma certainly plays a significant role in

Table 5: Glaucoma awareness and knowledge levels across the globe


Author Year Country Study population Awareness of Knowledge of
Glaucoma % Glaucoma %
Present study 2012 India Tertiary eye hospital patients‑Adults 40 years and above 4.8 3.1
Sathyamangalam et al. 2004 India Urban population–Adults above 40 years 13.30 8.70
Dandona et al. 2001 India Urban population–Above 15 yrs 2.30 2.0
Krishnaiah et al. 2005 India Rural population: Above 15 yrs 0.27 Not reported
Thapa et al. 2011 Nepal Community‑aged 40 years and above 2.4 Not reported
Tenkir et al. 2011 Ethiopia Community aged 40 years and above 2.4 Not reported
Saw et al. 2003 Singapore Tertiary eye hospital patients‑Adults 35 yrs and above 23 Not reported
Lau et al. 2002 Hong Kong Community‑Adults above 40 years 78.40 10.20
Gasch et al. 2000 United States General eye service patients–All Ages 72 Not reported
Livingston et al. 1995 Australia Community–Adults above 40 yrs 79 19

6 Journal of the Scientific Society, Vol 40 / Issue 1 / January-April 2013


[Downloaded free from http://www.jscisociety.com on Saturday, November 24, 2018, IP: 202.67.46.239]

Prabhu, et al.: Glaucoma awareness and knowledge in a tier 2 city

creating awareness. There were five aware subjects with REFERENCES


family history even though four were non‑glaucoma
subjects. Even though doctors and family history create 1. Shamanna BR, Dandona L, Rao GN. Economic burden of blindness in
India. Indian J Ophthalmol 1998;46:169‑72.
good awareness, it reaches a limited group of people
2. Quigley HA. Number of people with glaucoma worldwide. Br J Ophthalmol
only. Hence, we believe that media can play a bigger role 1996;80:389‑93.
in creating awareness as it is cost effective and reaches the 3. Thomas R, Paul P, Rao GN, Muliyil JP, Mathai A. Present status of eye care
masses, as telecast reaches every corner of the country. in India. Surv Ophthalmol 2005;50:85‑101.
4. Tielsch JM, Sommer A, Katz J, Royall RM, Quigley HA, Javitt J. Racial
variations in the prevalence of primary open angle glaucoma. The Baltimore
LIMITATIONS OF OUR STUDY Eye Survey. JAMA 1991;266:369‑74.
5. Sathyamangalam RV, Paul PG, Ronnie G, Baskaran M, Hemamalini A,
It was a hospital‑based study and not community based. Madan RV, et al. Determinants of glaucoma awareness and knowledge in
The community‑based studies may yield much lower urban Chennai. Indian J Ophthalmol 2009;57:355‑60.
6. Dandona R, Dandona L, John RK, McCarty CA, Rao GN. Awareness of
awareness and knowledge proportions as the public
eye diseases in an urban population in southern India. Bull World Health
have much less contact with the patients. Organ 2001;79:96‑102.
7. Krishnaiah S, Kovai V, Srinivas M, Shamanna BR, Rao GN, Thomas R.
Though there are many eye camps conducted by Awareness of glaucoma in the rural population of southern India. Indian
government for comprehensive eye care, the public J Ophthalmol 2005;53:205‑8.
8. Thomas R, Korah S, Padma P. Glaucoma an emerging cause for preventable
awareness of potentially blinding condition like blindness. Indian J Commun Health 1997;3:52‑63.
glaucoma remains low. Effective health education may 9. Tenkir A, Solomon B, Deribew A. Glaucoma awareness among people
influence individuals to undergo screening for eye attending ophthalmic outreach services in southwestern Ethiopia. BMC
diseases. This may lead to early detection of glaucoma Ophthalmol 2010;10:17.
10. Saw SM, Gazzard G, Friedman D, Foster PJ, Devereux JG, Wong ML, et al.
and prevention of blindness. Educating the public on Awareness of glaucoma and health beliefs of patients suffering primary
the consequences of delayed treatment of glaucoma acute angle closure. Br J Ophthalmol 2003;87:446‑9.
will be an important factor in promotion of preventive 11. Thapa SS, Berg RV, Khanal S, Paudyal I, Pandey P, Maharjan N, et al.
ophthalmic care. It is understood that health education Prevalence of visual impairment, cataract surgery and awareness of cataract
and glaucoma in Bhaktapur district of Nepal: The Bhaktapur Glaucoma
sessions have to be conducted in a language which the Study. BMC Ophthalmol 2011;11:2.
target individual understands. 12. Lau JT, Lee V, Fan D, Lau M, Michon J. Knowledge about cataract, glaucoma,
and age related macular degeneration in the Hong Kong Chinese population.
Br J Ophthalmol 2002;86:1080‑4.
CONCLUSION 13. Gasch AT, Wang P, Pasquale LR. Determinants of glaucoma awareness in
a general eye clinic. Ophthalmology 2000;107:303‑8.
Awareness and knowledge of glaucoma is low. An efficient 14. Livingston PM, McCarty CA, Taylor HR. Knowledge, attitudes, and self care
Information, Education and Communication (IEC) practices associated with age related eye disease in Australia. Br J Ophthalmol
strategy needs to be designed to increase the awareness 1998;82:780‑5.
15. Ramachandran A, Das AK, Joshi SR, Yajnik CS, Shah S, Kumar KM. Current
and knowledge levels of glaucoma and thus reduces
status of diabetes in India and need for novel therapeutic agents. Suppl JAPI
blindness due to glaucoma. 2010;58:7‑9.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT How to cite this article: Prabhu M, Patil SH, Kangokar PR.
Glaucoma awareness and knowledge in a tertiary care hospital in
We would like to acknowledge and thank Dr. Praveen Bagalkot a tier-2 city in South India. J Sci Soc 2013;40:3-8.
for all the support and help in completing this study Source of Support: Nil. Conflict of Interest: None declared.

Annexure 1: Questionnaire
Name
Age
Sex  Male  Female
Address  Rural  Urban
Religion  Hindu  Christian  Muslim
Literacy  Illiterate
 Primary (1-5 years of education)
 Secondary (5-10 years of education)
 College (10+2 to degree or more)

(Contd...)

Journal of the Scientific Society, Vol 40 / Issue 1 / January-April 2013 7


[Downloaded free from http://www.jscisociety.com on Saturday, November 24, 2018, IP: 202.67.46.239]

Prabhu, et al.: Glaucoma awareness and knowledge in a tier 2 city

Annexure 1: Questionnaire (Contd....)


Mother tongue  Kannada  Hindi  English Others
Diabetic status  Non-diabetic  Diabetic
Glaucoma status  Non- glaucoma  Glaucoma
Family h/o glaucoma  yes  No

Awareness of glaucoma
Have you ever heard of the eye condition glaucoma  Yes  No  Can’t say
Source of awareness  TV  Newspapers  Radio  Magazines
 Friends  Glaucoma person  Doctor

Knowledge about glaucoma


1. Tick the possible risk factors for glaucoma
 Obesity  Increased IOP
 Steroids  Chronic smoking and alcohol intake
 Family h/o of glaucoma  Diabetes
 None of the above  Can’t say
2. Description of glaucoma- record all mentioned symptoms
 Increased IOP, eye pressure
 Loss of side vision
3. Is visual loss  Permanent  Reversible  Can’t say
4. Is glaucoma treatable  Yes  No  Can’t say
5. What are the therapies for treating glaucoma that are currently available. Tick the appropriate choices
 Medicines – eye drops
 Surgery
 Laser treatment
 No treatment available
 Can’t say

New features on the journal’s website

Optimized content for mobile and hand-held devices


HTML pages have been optimized of mobile and other hand-held devices (such as iPad, Kindle, iPod) for faster browsing speed.
Click on [Mobile Full text]  from Table of Contents page.
This is simple HTML version for faster download on mobiles (if viewed on desktop, it will be automatically redirected to full HTML version)
E-Pub for hand-held devices
EPUB is an open e-book standard recommended by The International Digital Publishing Forum which is designed for reflowable content i.e. the
text display can be optimized for a particular display device.
Click on [EPub] from Table of Contents page.
There are various e-Pub readers such as for Windows: Digital Editions, OS X: Calibre/Bookworm, iPhone/iPod Touch/iPad: Stanza, and Linux:
Calibre/Bookworm.
E-Book for desktop
One can also see the entire issue as printed here in a ‘flip book’ version on desktops.
Links are available from Current Issue as well as Archives pages.
Click on View as eBook

8 Journal of the Scientific Society, Vol 40 / Issue 1 / January-April 2013

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi