Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
326
EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE
Evidence-Based Interventional Pain Medicine
according to Clinical Diagnoses
! Abstract: Painful shoulder complaints have a high inci- Key Words: evidence-based medicine, shoulder pain,
dence and prevalence. The etiology is not always clear. Clini- subacromial bursitis, acromioclavicular joint disorder,
cal history and the active and passive motion examination of glenohumeral joint, nervus suprascapularis, corticosteroid
the shoulder are the cornerstones of the diagnostic process. injection, pulsed radiofrequency
Three shoulder tests are important for the examination of
shoulder complaints: shoulder abduction, shoulder external
INTRODUCTION
rotation, and horizontal shoulder adduction. These tests can
guide the examiner to the correct diagnosis. Based on this This article on shoulder complaints is part of the series
diagnosis, in most cases, primarily a conservative treatment “Interventional practice guidelines based on clinical
with nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs possibly in com- diagnosis.” Recommendations formulated in this article
bination with manual and/or exercise therapy can be started. are based on “Grading strength of recommendations
When conservative treatment fails, injection with local anes- and quality of evidence in clinical guidelines” described
thetics and corticosteroids can be considered. In the case of
by Guyatt et al.1 and adapted by van Kleef et al.2 in the
frozen shoulder, a continuous cervical epidural infusion of
editorial accompanying the first article of this series
local anesthetic and small doses of opioids or a pulsed radio-
frequency treatment of the nervus suprascapularis can be (Table 1). The last literature update was performed in
considered. ! September 2009.
The incidence of shoulder complaints in daily general
Address correspondence and reprint requests to: Maarten van Kleef, practice is high. An estimate of 24 episodes for every
MD, PhD, FIPP, Maastricht University Medical Centre, Department of Anes- 1,000 patients in general practice has been calculated
thesiology and Pain Management, PO Box 5800, 6202 AZ Maastricht, The
Netherlands. E-mail: maarten.van.kleef@mumc.nl.
with a prevalence of 35 for every 1,000 patients per
DOI. 10.1111/j.1533-2500.2010.00389.x year, 60% of whom are women.3 Although 60% of the
patients with shoulder complaints recover after one
© 2010 World Institute of Pain, 1530-7085/10/$15.00
year, shoulder pain has a tendency to recur from time to
Pain Practice, Volume 10, Issue 4, 2010 318–326 time.3
Painful Shoulder • 319
1 A+ Effectiveness demonstrated in various RCTs of good quality. The benefits clearly outweigh risk and burdens
1 B+ One RCT or more RCTs with methodologic weaknesses, demonstrate effectiveness. The benefits clearly
outweigh risk and burdens Positive recommendation
2 B+ One or more RCTs with methodologic weaknesses, demonstrate effectiveness. Benefits closely balanced
with risk and burdens
2 B! Multiple RCTs, with methodologic weaknesses, yield contradictory results better or worse than the control
treatment. Benefits closely balanced with risk and burdens, or uncertainty in the estimates of benefits,
Considered, preferably
risk and burdens.
study-related
2 C+ Effectiveness only demonstrated in observational studies. Given that there is no conclusive evidence of the
effect, benefits closely balanced with risk and burdens
0 There is no literature or there are case reports available, but these are insufficient to suggest effectiveness
Only study-related
and/or safety. These treatments should only be applied in relation to studies.
2 C- Observational studies indicate no or too short-lived effectiveness. Given that there is no positive clinical
effect, risk and burdens outweigh the benefit
2 B- One or more RCTs with methodologic weaknesses, or large observational studies that do not indicate any
superiority to the control treatment. Given that there is no positive clinical effect, risk and burdens Negative recommendation
outweigh the benefit
2 A- RCT of a good quality which does not exhibit any clinical effect. Given that there is no positive clinical
effect, risk and burdens outweigh the benefit
It is not always clear why a patient develops shoulder pancoast tumor must be ruled out. The findings
complaints except when it is due to trauma. Pathologies from the shoulder examination are therefore of great
such as an aseptic inflammation of the synovial mem- importance.
branes of the glenohumeral joint, the acromioclavicular
and sternoclavicular joints, and inflammation of the I.B PHYSICAL EXAMINATION AND
outer soft tissue surrounding these joints can cause CATEGORIZATION OF SHOULDER PAIN
shoulder complaints. A systematic review establishes Three shoulder tests are important for the examination
that there is a relationship between artherosclerosis and of shoulder complaints: shoulder abduction, shoulder
shoulder pain.4 In addition, function disorders of the external rotation, and horizontal shoulder adduction.
cervical spinal column and the cervicothoracic transi- With these three tests it is possible to establish the most
tion play a role in the etiology of shoulder complaints. It important shoulder pathologies, which are usually
is therefore also of great importance to involve the cer- expressed as a brachialgia.
vical spinal column and cervicothoracic transition in the
examination of the shoulder function. Shoulder com- Normal Active and Passive Shoulder Abduction
plaints may be due to many causes and/or be part of an During the active and passive shoulder abduction, the
already existing ailment. examiner stands behind the patient, who is sitting.
When the right shoulder is being examined, the exam-
I. DIAGNOSIS iner fixates the patient’s body by placing his left (fixat-
ing) hand on the patient’s left shoulder keeping his left
I.A HISTORY thumb at the C7 level. This is to prevent the patient
In general, the symptom pattern is characterized by pain from lateral flexion toward the left during the abduction
that prevents the patient from sleeping on the affected of the right shoulder. With the examining (open) right
side. The localization and radiation pattern of the pain hand placed on the patient’s elbow, the active abduction
can provide an indication as to whether one is dealing of the arm is guided to the point where the patient stops
with a primary disease of the shoulder joint or with a because of pain, and if possible, passive shoulder abduc-
cause external to the shoulder joint. Other serious tion is further executed. The abduction is executed in
conditions such as pain in other joints, fever, malaise, the frontal plane as much as possible by keeping the
weight loss, dyspnea, and angina pectoris should be examiner’s (open) right hand somewhat to the ventral
ruled out: specifically for nontraumatic shoulder pain side of the patient’s elbow (Figure 1) to prevent ventral
that has an abnormal natural course. Above all, a translation of the arm during the abduction. Under
320 • huygen et al.
Table 3. Shoulder Complaints without Limited Range of Motion but with a Painful Course
Impingement - +++ - -
Subacromial bursitis - +++ - -
right shoulder (Figure 3). With the examining right hand Shoulder Complaints without Limited Range
placed on the patient’s right elbow, the active horizontal of Passive Motion but with a Painful
shoulder adduction is guided to the point where the Abduction Course
patient stops because of pain and, if possible, the passive Table 3 represents the shoulder complaints without
horizontal shoulder adduction is further executed. limited range of motion but with a painful arc in the
Because the etiology of the shoulder complaints is active as well as the passive shoulder abduction. In
usually unclear or even unknown, the findings from the addition, one or more structures in the subacromial
active and passive range of motion examination are used space can be affected. This is also called the impinge-
to classify the shoulder complaints.5 On the basis of the ment syndrome in orthopedics. Subacromial bursitis is a
active and passive abduction, external rotation and common clinical affection.
horizontal adduction of the shoulder, one can detect the
underlying cause of the shoulder complaints and catego-
Shoulder Complaints without Limited Range of
rize it in the following three groups:6
Passive Motion and without a Painful
• Shoulder complaints with limited range of Abduction Course
passive motion If the active and passive motion examination
• Shoulder complaints without limited range of of the shoulder reveals no disorder, the pain is usually
passive motion but with pain on shoulder abduc- caused by structures external to the shoulder or the
tion or retro-abduction shoulder pain can be part of a radiating pattern such
• Shoulder complaints without limited range of as brachialgia resulting from cervical radicular
passive motion and no painful abduction syndrome or a brachial plexus lesion. This also
trajectory includes neurological conditions such as Parsonage–
Turner syndrome (amyotrophic shoulder neuralgia)7
Shoulder Complaints with a Limited Range and the referred pain syndromes of the shoulder; the
of Passive Motion latter can have a visceral genesis. An exception is the
Table 2 shows the shoulder complaints with a limited unstable shoulder as in habitual shoulder dislocation.
range of motion. It does not include shoulder affections Table 4 provides an overview of the most common
that are considered to be the result of a systemic condi- shoulder complaints without limited range of passive
tion such as rheumatoid arthritis, for example. motion.
322 • huygen et al.
I.C ADDITIONAL TESTS cervical spinal column and cervicothoracic passage. The
Diagnostics and laboratory tests are not indicated local application of heat and cold has been insufficiently
during the initial phase of uncomplicated shoulder com- studied.3
plaints. Additional blood tests (C-reactive protein,
hemoglobin, erythrocyte sedimentation rates, rheuma-
II.B INTERVENTIONAL MANAGEMENT
toid factor) must be carried out in case of persisting
shoulder complaints if a systemic condition or other Depending on the conditions, a local injection with an
serious affection is suspected.8 Radiographs, ultrasound, anesthetic and corticosteroid is given to treat subacro-
and a magnetic resonance imaging examination are indi- mial bursitis, diseases of the acromioclavicular joint,
cated with prolonged persistence of shoulder com- adhesive capsulitis (frozen shoulder) and a rotator cuff
plaints. A bone scan is indicated when metastasis or disease.3 On the basis of a Cochrane review,10 there is
primary tumor is suspected. little evidence to either support or reject the efficacy of
corticosteroid injections.
Table 5. Evidence for Interventional Management of corner of the acromion is identified. The bursa subac-
Painful Shoulder Complaints romialis is injected exactly in the center. In case of
Technique Evaluation serious calcification in the bursa subacromialis, calcifi-
cation should be surgically removed. The most impor-
Corticosteroid injections 2B!
Continuous cervical epidural infusion 2C+ tant complication of injection is an infection. Small
PRF nervus suprascapularis 2C+ subcutaneous bleedings may result in a temporary
increase in pain after the injection.
PRF, pulsed radiofrequency.
N. suprascapularis
Clavicula
Branches of the
m. infraspinatus
Figure 4. Anatomy of the shoulder joint, landmarks for the pulsed radiofrequency treatment of the nervus suprascapularis.
The spina scapulae is palpated and demarcated Van den Hecke for coordination and suggestions regard-
from the cranial side. Across the middle of a line ing the article.
running from the acromion to the margo medialis
scapulae (medial scapular border), a line is drawn par- REFERENCES
allel to the cervical spinal column; the lateral angle is
then divided into two equal parts with a line and an X 1. Guyatt G, Gutterman D, Baumann MH, et al.
Grading strength of recommendations and quality of evidence
(the injection site) is drawn on this line 2.5 cm from
in clinical guidelines: report from an american college of chest
the angular point. An SMK 10/5 needle is inserted
physicians task force. Chest. 2006;129:174–181.
perpendicular to the skin in all directions until 2. van Kleef M, Mekhail N, van Zundert J. Evidence-
bone contact is made with the scapula in the based guidelines for interventional pain medicine according to
fossa supraspinata; this usually occurs at a depth of clinical diagnoses. Pain Pract. 2009;9:247–251.
5 to 6.5 cm. At the cranial border of the fossa 3. Winters D. NHG-standaard schouderklachten.
supraspinata, called the margo superior scapulae Huisarts Wet. 2008;51:555–565.
(superior scapular border), the incisura scapulae is 4. Viikari-Juntura E, Shiri R, Solovieva S, et al.
located (Figure 5). This is the injection site for the Risk factors of atherosclerosis and shoulder pain—is there
nervus suprascapularis. One should be careful not to an association? A systematic review. Eur J Pain. 2008;12:
insert the electrode too far ventrally; there is a small 412–426.
chance of rib contact or pneumothorax. The electrode 5. De Winter J, Sobel J. Diagnosis and Classification of
Shoulder Complaints. Amsterdam: Free University Amster-
is connected to the generator and with a motor stimu-
dam; 1999.
lation (2 Hz) of < 0.3 V twitches should be visible in
6. Groenier KH, Winters JC, van Schuur WH, De
the shoulder girdle. Subsequently, PRF treatment is Winter AF, Meyboom-De Jong B. A simple classification
executed with a frequency of 2 Hz, 20 ms and 45 V system was recommended for patients with restricted shoulder
lasting 4 minutes. There is usually immediate improve- or neck range of motion. J Clin Epidemiol. 2006;59:599–
ment with regard to movement and pain in most 607.
patients. In some cases, the treatment must be repeated 7. Hussey AJ, O’Brien CP, Regan PJ. Parsonage-Turner
after a few weeks. With injection techniques, one must syndrome-case report and literature review. Hand (N Y).
be aware of potential intravascular injection in the 2007;2:218–221.
arteria or vena suprascapularis. Pneumothorax is also 8. Mitchell C, Adebajo A, Hay E, Carr A. Shoulder
a described complication. pain: diagnosis and management in primary care. BMJ.
2005;331:1124–1128.
9. Bergman GJ, Winters JC, Groenier KH,
IV. SUMMARY et al. Manipulative therapy in addition to usual medical care
Clinical history and the active and passive motion for patients with shoulder dysfunction and pain: a random-
examination of the shoulder are the cornerstone of the ized, controlled trial. Ann Intern Med. 2004;141:432–
diagnostic process. 439.
When conservative treatment fails, injection with 10. Buchbinder R, Green S, Youd J. Corticosteroid injec-
local anesthetics and corticosteroids can be considered. tions for shoulder pain (review). The Cochrane Library.
2008;3:CD004016.
In case of a frozen shoulder or capsulitis, a continuous
11. Arroll B, Goodyear-Smith F. Corticosteroid injec-
cervical epidural infusion of local anesthetic and small
tions for painful shoulder: a meta-analysis. Br J Gen Pract.
doses of opioids or a PRF treatment of the nervus
2005;55:224–228.
suprascapularis can be considered, preferably as part of 12. Burbank KM, Stevenson JH, Czarnecki GR,
a study. Dorfman J. Chronic shoulder pain: part II. Treatment. Am
Fam Physician. 2008;77:493–497.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 13. Narouze SN, Govil H, Guirguis M, Mekhail NA.
Continuous cervical epidural analgesia for rehabilitation after
This review was initially based on practice guidelines shoulder surgery: a retrospective evaluation. Pain Physician.
written by Dutch and Flemish (Belgian) experts that are 2009;12:189–194.
assembled in a handbook for the Dutch-speaking pain 14. Shah RV, Racz GB. Pulsed mode radiofrequency
physicians. After translation, the article was updated lesioning of the suprascapular nerve for the treatment
and edited in cooperation with U.S./International pain of chronic shoulder pain. Pain Physician. 2003;6:503–
specialists. The authors thank José Geurts and Nicole 506.
326 • huygen et al.
15. Rohof OJJM. Radiofrequency treatment of periph- for treatment of whiplash-related cervical zygapophysial joint
eral nerves. Pain Pract. 2002;2:257–260. pain. Surg Neurol. 2008;70(suppl 1):50–55; discussion S1:55.
16. Rohof OJJM, Dongen VCPCv. Pulsed radiofre- 18. Keskinbora K, Aydinli I. [Long-term results of
quency of the suprascapular nervi in the treatment of chronic suprascapular pulsed radiofrequency in chronic shoulder
intractable shoulder pain. 2nd World Congress of Pain, Pain pain]. Agri. 2009;21:16–21.
Practice Edition. Edited by Raj PP. Istanbul, Blackwell Science, 19. Kane TP, Rogers P, Hazelgrove J, Wimsey S, Harper
2001, pp 114. GD. Pulsed radiofrequency applied to the suprascapular nerve
17. Liliang PC, Lu K, Hsieh CH, Kao CY, Wang KW, in painful cuff tear arthropathy. J Shoulder Elbow Surg.
Chen HJ. Pulsed radiofrequency of cervical medial branches 2008;17:436–440.