MAF651 – SEMINAR IN MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING

RUBRIC FOR PROJECT REPORTs (10%)

MEMBERS’ NAME STUDENT’S NO. GROUP

1
2
3
4

CRITERIAS/ MARKS EXCELLENT GOOD SATISFACTORY POOR

MARKS
FORMAT Report is properly Report is properly Report is properly Report is not binding,
binding, with title page, binding. Missing one binding. Missing two no title page, no table
table of contents, of the format criteria. or more of the format of contents, no
paginating, introduction, criteria. paginating, no
contents, conclusion and appendix
appendix
10 10-8 7-6 6-5 >5
INTRODUCTION Provide clear overview Provide moderate Provide overview but Provide vague
of the topic using own overview of the topic, no definition of key introduction (which is
sentence (original),clear define some key concept, relevant not clear), irrelevant
definition of key concepts and terminology and not using own
concept, relevant terminology sentences, no
terminology definition of key
concept, no relevant
terminology
15 15-14 13-10 9-7 >7
CONTENT Provide proper Provide logic structure, Unclear structure, no Provide an
structure, readable, readable; less continuity among unstructured, not
comprehensive yet comprehensive (omit paragraphs comprehensive,
relevant discussion of few relevant issues of irrelevant discussion.
the content. the topic). Topics are not arranged
A smooth flow of accordingly. Not
thought (good original
arrangement of the
topics). Original
40 40-35 34-27 26-20 >20
CONCLUSION Provide critical Provide general Provide conclusion by No conclusion given
conclusion of the topic conclusion of the topic repeating the same
by giving own comment by giving general sentences from the
comment content with no
comment given
15 15-14 13-10 9-7 >7
APPLICATION TO Provide discussion by Provide insufficient Provide example of No examples of
INDUSTRY giving example of discussion of companies’ experience companies’ experience
companies’ experiences companies’ that apply SMA on SMA
that apply the SMA experiences that apply techniques but no
techniques the SMA techniques discussion given
10 10-8 7-6 6-5 >5
REFERENCES Use sufficient references Use reference Use insufficient Reference given from
which are relevant to the insufficient references reference which the textbook only
topics, reliable (from which comes from comes from unreliable
journals) with proper mixed sources (reliable sources and without
referencing style and unreliable) with proper referencing
proper referencing style
style
10 10-8 7-6 6-5 >5
TOTAL 100
FORMAT REPORT:
- Maximum 10 pages (2,000 words)
- Use font: Arial, size 11 or Times New Roman, size 12 and text is justified. Line spacing 1.5
- Attach the references used under Appendix (Submit the articles used for references in softcopy i.e. disc)
- Last day of submission: Week 14
 MAF651 – SEMINAR IN MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING
RUBRIC FOR SEMINAR PRESENTATION (10%)

MEMBERS’ NAME STUDENT’S NO. GROUP

1
2
3
4

CRITERIA MARKS EXCELLENT GOOD SATISFACTORY POOR

PRESENTATION Presenters have an Presenters miss one of Presenters miss two No eye contact- reading
eye contact and the criteria in the or more criteria in the from the slide/notes,
SKILLS
interact with the presentation skills. presentation skills soft voice or mumbling,
audience, speak with no intonation, locking
clear and loud voice, hands, no interaction
suitable intonation, with audience, Mixed
body language, languages
gestures, proficient
English
20 20-18 17-14 13-10 >10
EXPLANATION OF All presenters able to The presenters able to The presenters try to Unable to explain the
explain the issues, explain the issues, explain the issues issues clearly, do not
THE ISSUES
show a deep show a good although do not show understand the topic
understanding of the understanding of the understanding the and do not give
topic and able to give topic and give topic and do not give example
relevant example satisfactory example relevant example
40 40-35 34-27 26-20 >20
VISUAL AIDS AND The group uses Use more than 1 Use more than 1 Use only 1 visual aid,
various visual aids (eg. visual aids , attractive, visual aids, but do not small, not attractive and
CREATIVITY
Slides, colored paper, but no creativity in display creativity in do not display creativity
use white board, flash presentation presentation in presentation
cards), visible,
attractive, and exhibit
excellent creativity
20 20-18 17-14 13-10 >10
QUESTION AND The group able to Answer the question Answer the question Unable to answer
answer all question confidently and unconfidently, no question asked and
ANSWER
asked correctly, provide example but example provided and unable to give example
confidently and the answer is give incorrect answer
provide example incorrect
10 10-8 7-6 6-5 >5
TEAM WORK Show high degree of Show good degree of Show moderate No co-operation among
co-operation and co-operation and degree of co- members
unity in group (help unity in group operation and unity in
each other during the group
presentation and Q&A
session)
5 5 4-3 2 >2
APPEARANCE Dress professionally Dress according to the Dress according to the Dress unprofessionally
(wear formal attire, university’s dress university’s dress code (causally: wear jeans, t-
long sleeve shirt, tie, code, neat and shirt, fancy dress and
pants and shoes) neat presentable slipper)
and presentable
5 5 4-3 2 >2
TOTAL 100

- Time (including 10 minutes Q&A session): 60 minutes

- All group members must involve in the presentation
- If any member is absent, the presentation can not be postponed to other time
- All members must be accountable for the topic assigned & provide notes for all students