Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Others
August 23, 2018
INITIATING COVERAGE
Sector view:
Strutting the fashion street. We initiate coverage on Aditya Birla Fashion and Retail Price (`): 190
(ABFRL) with a BUY rating and a target price of `220 based on June 2020E EV/EBITDA
of 20X for Madura and EV/EBITDA of 17X for Pantaloons. Madura is a steady growth Target price (`): 220
and strong FCF generating business, while Pantaloons turnaround can provide a BSE-30: 38,286
strong margin kicker. We forecast healthy revenue/PBT CAGR of 16/124% over
FY2018-21 driving a reduction in leverage and improvement in return ratios.
Strong brands, multiple channels of retail and pan-India presence; initiate with BUY
ABFRL is India’s leading apparel company comprising Madura (lifestyle brands) and Pantaloons
(affordable fashion retailer). Madura owns some of the largest menswear brands in India such
as Peter England and Louis Philippe. Its strong brand pull, capital-efficient franchise model of
growth and strong cash-flow generation are key positives. We believe Pantaloons business is
on the cusp of a turnaround, with margins of the business improving to an all-time high of
9.6% in 1QFY19. SSSG revival, cost-cutting measures and stabilization of operations of
recently opened stores are set to drive an improvement in profitability.
ABFRL’s profitability was impacted by multiple macro events over FY2016-18 such as
demonetization and GST implementation, which impacted consumer spends and Madura’s
sales through distributors. Further, heavy discounting by e-commerce impacted SSSG
performance over FY2015-17. We believe macro risks have waned, and while competitive
intensity is high, ABFRL’s growth trajectory is set to improve as (1) Madura’s new casual and
event wear-focused range finds fresh demand and drives EBO expansion and (2) Pantaloons’
improved product assortment and steady expansion drive higher revenue growth.
We forecast healthy revenue, EBITDA and PBT CAGR of 16%, 30% and 124%, respectively
over FY2018-21 driven by steady SSSG performance of Madura and Pantaloons, improved
margin profile of Pantaloons and lower losses in other businesses (innerwear, fast fashion).
We expect Madura to remain a healthy FCF-generating company, with increased profitability
in other businesses driving a steady reduction in D/E to 0.9X in FY2020 from 1.6X in FY2018.
An economic downturn, or other factors, which may lead to reduced consumer spending, are
key risks for ABFRL. Increase in competitive intensity from other channels such as e-commerce, Garima Mishra
unavailability of requisite real estate for expansion and/or sharp increase in rentals, longer- garima.mishra@kotak.com
Mumbai: +91-22-4336-0862
than-expected turnaround of new businesses are other risks.
For Private Circulation Only. In the US, this document may only be distributed to QIBs (qualified institutional buyers) as defined under rule 144A of the Securities Act of 1933. This document is not for public distribution
and has been furnished to you solely for your information and may not be reproduced or redistributed to any other person. The manner of circulation and distribution of this document may be restricted by law or
regulation in certain countries, including the United States. Persons into whose possession this document may come are required to inform themselves of, and to observe, such restrictions.
Others Aditya Birla Fashion and Retail
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ABFRL: Strong brands and improving reach in a steady growth industry .................9
ABFRL: Decline in discretionary spending and higher competition are key risks .....24
ABFRL: Strong 16% revenue CAGR and 124% PBT CAGR over FY2018-21 .........26
The prices in this report are based on the market close of August 21, 2018.
FINANCIAL SNAPSHOT
Exhibit 1: ABFRL, consolidated estimates and valuation summary, March fiscal year-ends, 2016-21E
EBITDA
Net revenues EBITDA Net income EPS margin P/E EV/EBITDA RoCE RoE
(Rs mn) (Rs mn) (Rs mn) (Rs) (%) (X) (X) (%) (%)
2016 60,346 3,784 (1,098) (1.4) 6.3 (134) 43
2017 66,330 4,375 535 0.7 6.6 274 38 8 6
2018 71,814 4,683 1,178 1.5 6.5 125 35 9 11
2019E 83,508 6,753 1,774 2.3 8.1 83 24 10 15
2020E 97,052 8,526 2,822 3.7 8.8 52 19 13 20
2021E 111,538 10,261 4,331 5.6 9.2 34 15 16 24
xx
Exhibit 2: Consolidated income statement, balance sheet and cash flow, March fiscal year-ends, 2013-21E (Rs mn)
ABFRL comprises two businesses: lifestyle brands segment comprising Madura’s menswear
brands, luxury brands and fast fashion retail (Forever 21 and People), and Pantaloons which
is a large format value fashion retailer.
At 20X, our target multiple for Madura is broadly in line with peer average. Madura has a
strong brand proposition, extensive reach and healthy return ratios. Pantaloons deserves a
lower multiple than Madura as its model has taken some time to stabilize, and profitability,
while improving, is still below its peak potential.
The peers mentioned below are all in the branded apparel business, though their business
models are different: Page is the market leader in the branded innerwear space, Trent is a
large format store retailing only private labels, Arvind has other businesses besides branded
fashion, Future Lifestyle owns Central and Brand factory formats as well as brands, Shoppers
Stop is a department store with largely third-party brands, and Vmart is a retailer of
unbranded apparel.
Exhibit 3: Indian branded fashion retailers are trading at an average EV/EBITDA of 21X March 2020
Valuation comparables of Indian retailers, March fiscal year-ends
Market-cap EV/EBITDA EV/Sales P/E ROE (%) 2018-20 CAGR (%)
Company (US$ mn) 2018 2019 2020 2018 2019 2020 2018 2019 2020 2018 2019 2020 Revenue EBITDA PAT
Page 5,451 46 54 44 10 12 10 110 84 68 46 46 45 21 26 27
Trent 1,770 57 44 36 5 5 4 142 71 49 6 10 14 23 31 71
Arvind 1,507 14 12 10 1 1 1 34 25 18 9 11 13 14 22 37
Future Lifestyle 1,177 18 14 12 2 2 1 65 50 37 10 9 11 21 18 32
Shoppers Stop 701 22 18 14 1 1 1 20 49 36 44 10 13 10 25 (25)
Vmart 785 25 32 26 3 4 3 71 58 46 26 23 24 22 25 24
Kewal Kiran 264 17 15 13 4 na na 25 23 21 19 19 19 8 13 10
Average 28 26 21 3 4 3 61 51 39 19 17 19 16 23 19
Aditya Birla
Fashion & Retail
Madura Pantaloons
Its Madura business is the largest contributor to revenues and EBITDA, followed by
Pantaloons. ABFRL has seeded certain new businesses such as Forever 21, People and
innerwear retail, which are currently in the investment phase.
Exhibit 5: SSSG revival of Madura and margin increase in Pantaloons to drive profitability
Details of key assumptions, March fiscal year-ends
We forecast ABFRL to post revenue, EBITDA and net profit CAGR of 16%, 30% and 54%
over FY2018-21E. Like its peers, it is a key beneficiary of an increasing demand for branded
apparel and higher discretionary consumption spends. Its widespread reach and ownership
of multiple brands make it a key player in the branded apparel space.
Pantaloons. Pantaloons has been a drag on ABFRL’s profitability since its acquisition in
FY2013. However, the company’s recent measures to boost profitability are bearing fruit.
These include: (1) alignment of Pantaloon’s product pricing with value fashion peers in order
to cater to a wider consumer set, (2) expansion in Tier-III/IV cities where competition is
limited, (3) increased reliance on private labels with quick churn out of trendy apparel, and
(4) increased focus on cost controls, with measures such as rent and store area
rationalization, fixed cost controls, etc. Further, the company is looking to increase
advertising in both offline and online modes, as well as looking to create a dedicated online
portal for Pantaloons, as part of its omni-channel strategy, which we believe will enable a
wider reach. The impact of these measures is visible on the steadily improving margin profile
of Pantaloons over the past 3-4 quarters.
Other businesses. These comprise innerwear, fast fashion (Forever 21, People) and luxury
brands businesses. Among these, we believe the innerwear business has legs to grow, given
cross-sell opportunities in existing Van Heusen stores as well as Pantaloons stores. While this
category is competitive, ABFRL is investing in its distribution reach and product quality to
drive revenues. Fast fashion faces extreme competition from other retailers like Zara, H&M,
and hence we believe this format may take some more time to break even, and curtailment
of investments is a positive. Luxury brands is currently a small business and we believe future
expansion of the same will be measured.
We also note a change in management in the company—Ashish Dixit’s elevation to the role
of MD, as well as new business heads for both Madura and Pantaloons. We believe this has
brought about fresh strategies of reviving the omni-channel proposition as well as widening
the product portfolio for both Madura and Pantaloons.
Overall, we like ABFRL’s brands business for its steady growth potential, improving online
presence as well as strong cash generation. Pantaloons turnaround can drive a rapid
improvement in profitability as well as reduced leverage over time. Other businesses provide
an optionality, which we don’t factor in our valuations at the moment.
2020 2021
Lifestyle brands
EBITDA (Rs mn) 5,331 5,891
EV/EBITDA (X) 20 20
EV (Rs mn) 106,621 117,829
Pantaloons
EBITDA (Rs mn) 3,687 4,472
EV/EBITDA (X) 17 17
EV (Rs mn) 62,675 76,021
Other businesses
Revenues (Rs mn) 7,538 10,061
EV/revenues (X) 1.0 1.0
EV of other businesses 7,538 10,061
Total EV 176,834 203,910
Net debt (Rs mn) 14,510 10,597
June 2020 equity value (Rs mn) 170,071
Target price (Rs/sh) 220
We back-up our multiple based target price calculation with a DCF-based TP calculation, and
arrive at a fair value of `215, similar to our multiples-based TP of `220. Our DCF assumes (1)
revenue CAGR of 13% over FY2019-25 moderating to CAGR of 8% over FY2025-35, (2)
improvement in EBIT margin from 4.4% in FY2019 to 9.4% by FY2030, (3) WACC of 10.8%
and (4) terminal growth of 5%.
2018 2019E 2020E 2021E 2022E 2023E 2024E 2025E 2026E 2027E 2028E 2029E 2030E 2035E
Net Sales 71,814 83,508 97,052 111,538 127,021 143,944 161,353 178,464 197,391 217,929 240,169 264,078 289,047 408,237
Yoy growth (%) 8 16 16 15 14 13 12 11 11 10 10 10 9 5
EBIT 1,878 3,646 4,827 6,450 7,931 9,754 11,570 13,608 15,742 18,143 20,835 23,833 27,098 42,559
EBIT margin (%) 2.6 4.4 5.0 5.8 6.2 6.8 7.2 7.6 8.0 8.3 8.7 9.0 9.4 10.4
EBIT*(1-tax rate) 4,516 2,862 3,789 4,225 5,195 6,389 7,578 8,913 10,311 11,883 13,647 15,611 17,749 27,876
Depreciation/Amortisation 2,805 3,107 3,699 3,811 4,224 4,598 5,382 5,815 6,424 6,800 7,132 7,404 7,950 8,483
(Inc.)/Dec. in working capital 2,627 (1,171) (406) (435) (465) (508) (522) (513) (573) (622) (673) (724) (756) (639)
Capital expenditure (3,967) (2,998) (3,439) (3,795) (4,365) (4,830) (4,970) (5,296) (5,773) (6,367) (7,006) (7,651) (8,115) (7,391)
Free cash flows 5,982 1,800 3,643 3,806 4,589 5,649 7,468 8,919 10,389 11,695 13,100 14,641 16,828 28,329
Years discounted — 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 16
Discount factor — 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0
Discounted cash flow — 3,372 3,179 3,458 3,841 4,581 4,937 5,189 5,270 5,326 5,371 5,570 5,606
Organized apparel retailing in India is currently driven by exclusive brand outlets of leading
brands of Madura (Louis Philippe, Van Heusen, Peter England etc.), Raymond, Fabindia,
BIBA, AND, Zara and large format lifestyle stores such as Shoppers Stop, Lifestyle and
Pantaloons.
Exhibit 8: Apparel and accessories has the highest penetration of organized retail after consumer
electronics
Penetration of organized retail in various products category (%)
Source: Report on ‘Women’s Ethnic Wear Market in India’ by Technopak, Kotak Institutional Equities
Exhibit 9: Apparel and accessories was the second largest retail category in 2017
Category-wise size of total retail and organized retail, March fiscal year-end, 2017
Source: Report on ‘Women’s Ethnic Wear Market in India’ by Technopak, Kotak Institutional Equities estimates
Exhibit 10: Proportion of branded and organized apparel retail to increase over time
Size of branded and organized apparel retail, March fiscal year-ends (US$ bn)
Notes:
(a) Branded apparel signifies registered trademarks that are sold through both organized retail and trade
channels.
(b) Organized retail signifies formal retail channels of Exclusive Brand Outlets (EBOs), LFS, e-commerce, etc.
Apparel retailed through these organized retail point of sales is necessarily branded.
Source: Report on ‘Women’s Ethnic Wear Market in India’ by Technopak, Kotak Institutional Equities
Higher consumption in these cities augurs well for ABFRL, which has a wider presence than
competitors and intends to expand to newer cities. Its largest flagship brand Peter England is
present in 750+ cities, compared to 450+ cities for Raymond.
A case in point is China – which has a substantially larger apparel market size and also a
much higher penetration of e-commerce. However, we see that large Chinese brands are
still adding stores. Their commentary suggests that even though e-commerce as a
proportion of sales is increasing, they are still witnessing growth in their offline format.
Further, store additions are particularly helpful in situations of companies looking to either
revamp brands and/or plan brand extensions.
We believe apparel retailers will need to be present across both offline and online channels
of sales. With rising urban population and increasing purchasing power of non-metro cities,
we believe ABFRL can continue to grow its network of stores over the next few years.
Exhibit 12: Chinese branded apparel companies are still expanding physical stores
Revenue and store count of branded apparel Chinese companies, December calendar year-ends
We note that loyal customers contribute a sizeable 50-90% of revenues of leading retailers.
While there will be certain overlaps between loyal customers of various retailers, we also
note that: (1) usually the loyalty program is taken up by one member of the household and
not all shoppers, and (2) there will certainly be customers who are members of only one
retailer. Summing up all these customers leads us to total customer count of 47 mn. We
believe after adjusting for overlap and also the fact that there will also be customers who
shop for branded wear but are not a part of any loyalty program, we believe the total buyers
of branded apparel could be ~40-50 mn households.
Exhibit 13: ABFRL's Pantaloons and Madura brands have the largest number of loyal members
Number of members of loyalty programs of retailers as of March 31 2018
Number of members
Retailer Loyalty program (mn)
Pantaloons Loyalty program 11.8
Madura brands Loyalty program 10.2
Shoppers' Stop First Citizen 5.3
Trent Clubwest 3.5
Brand Factory Payback 2.5
Central Payback 2.2
Retailer Unique users
Myntra Unique users 11.0
xx
Proportion of revenues
Number of members contributed by loyal customers
Retailer (mn) (%)
Pantaloons 11.8 92.0
Madura brands 10.2 50.0
Shoppers' Stop 5.3 75.0
Brand Factory 3.5 70.0
Central 2.5 60.0
Assuming 50 mn urban households in FY2017 had one person buying branded apparel, our
calculation implies per person spends of US$63. We believe this spend can increase at least
in line with real GDP growth over the medium term. Coupled with a 3.5% growth in urban
households, which basically implies a similar growth in the number of buyers, we believe
men’s branded apparel industry can grow at a CAGR of 11% over FY2017-25. Our 2025
estimate of per capita spend by urban men on apparel comes to ~US$200. This is
significantly higher than the estimated per capita average Indian spend of US$66 estimated
by Technopak on apparel in FY2025 – indicating the sharp difference in consumption
patterns among various income groups.
Exhibit 15: Increase in urban population and purchasing power to drive growth in men’s apparel market
Estimation of men’s apparel market size, March fiscal year-ends
2017-25 CAGR
2017 2020 2025 (%)
Number of households (mn)
Rural 179 184 194 1.0
Urban 102 114 135 3.6
Total 281 298 329 2.0
Estimation of size of men's apparel market
Size of apparel market (US$ bn) 51 66 99 8.7
Share of menswear (%) 42 39 38
Size of men's apparel market (US$ bn) 21 26 38 7.3
Proportion branded (%) 26 30 34 3.4
Size of branded men's apparel market (US$ bn) 6 8 13 11.0
Number of urban households buying branded clothing (mn) 50 56 66 3.6
Assumed number of men buying branded wear per household (#) 1 1 1
Implied spend per person (US$) 111 138 193 7.2
Source: NSSO - 66th round, Census 2010, Kotak Institutional Equities estimates
xx
Exhibit 16: Higher proportion of affluent households can significantly drive apparel consumption
Contribution of
We acknowledge that over FY2015-17, e-commerce did negatively impact ABFRL’s business,
resulting in weak SSSGs of Pantaloons and Madura and also leading to eventual store
rationalization.
E-tailers have forced offline retailers to increase discounting, go for better targeting of
customers and stock fresher, trendier merchandise.
Lengthening of discount season. We note that over the past 3-4 years, the traditional
discount period of one month each in January and July has gradually extended to 1.5
months each over January-February and July-August. This has possibly resulted in a higher
proportion of merchandise being sold on discount. Our discussions with retailers suggest
that unless there is a definite thought process among market participants to go back to the
two-month-a-year discount season, the prolonged season is here to stay and will be used to
draw footfalls. However, we note that during the middle and end of the discount season,
retailers are stocking up on a higher proportion of fresh merchandise to improve overall
price realization.
Quicker change in trends. E-tailers have managed to bring together a plethora of brands
and also launched private labels across popular categories. In order to encourage customers
to buy more, they are changing their product offering quicker, aligning with seasons,
festivals and other events. This, we believe, is leading offline retailers to also shorten
production cycles to better adjust to quicker trend changes.
We believe competition from e-commerce has led ABFRL to devise its own strategies such as
commencement of Mission Happiness program which enables customers to provide detailed
feedback, pivot from a two-season model to a four-season model to take on fast fashion
retailers and diversification into different customer segments to cater to a larger consumer
base.
Foreign fast fashion retailers also pose a challenge to extant brand retailers
Foreign retailers such as Zara and H&M have scaled up operations rapidly in India. Zara
India’s revenues have grown at a CAGR of 21% over FY2016-18 to `12.2 bn. H&M posted
revenue of `8.8 bn in 2017 (year-ended November 2017), a growth of 94% yoy aided by
near doubling of store count from 15 to 27. These retailers sell only own branded products,
and we reckon they have taken away share from Indian retailers, although there are
indications that these companies are slowing down expansion. Competitive intensity will,
however, remain high for both the brands as well as Pantaloons.
Exhibit 17: Affordable fashion retailers have the most aggressive expansion plans
Store count and expansion plans of key large format retailers, March fiscal year-ends
The brands business will remain relatively insulated from the likes of Zara and H&M largely
due to the much larger reach – H&M and Zara, at 20-30 stores each currently, are already
expanding in a more measured way, than they have done in the past.
Madura and Pantaloons together cover a wide range of customer segments. Madura caters
to menswear across categories – luxury to mass, as well as womenswear – premium and
sub-premium. Subsequent investments in Pantaloons and Forever 21 have led to an
increased focus on womenswear, which we believe is a faster growing category.
Exhibit 18: ABFRL’s lifestyle brands cater to a fairly broad spectrum of customers
Brand-wise positioning and target customer category
Positioning Brand Category
Luxury The Collective Retailer of multiple luxury brands catering to men and women
Luxury Ted Baker Luxury menswear, womenswear and accessories
Super premium Hackett London British brand specializing in formal menswear
Super premium Simon Carter Sophisticated clothing for formal and casual occasions for men
Premium Louis Philippe Spophisticated and contemporary formal and semi-formal wear for men
Premium Van Heusen Workwear, fashion formals, party wear, casual wear for men
Premium Allen Solly Smart casual wear for men and women
Sub-premium Peter England Multi-brand format housing all of Madura's menswear brands
Premium Planet Pashion Multi-brand retailer of lifestyle brands for men
Fast Fashion Forever 21 Fast Fashion with an American sensibility for young women
Fast Fashion People Casual clothing + accessories for the youth
Notes:
(a) Number of cities includes the count of large format stores selling the brand also.
However, with consumer spends reviving post demonetization and GST implementation, we
believe Madura’s both retail and wholesale channels are coming back to normalcy. In line
with this, we believe Madura is set to add ~120-150 stores annually over the next few years
across its menswear brands. We note that only 25-30 of these new stores will be company
operated, the remainder will be franchisee operated.
2,500 EBOs (#) (LHS) New store additions (#) (RHS) 300
250
2,000 200
150
1,500
100
50
1,000
-
500 (50)
(100)
- (150)
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019E 2020E 2021E
We believe both these channels should normalize now, resulting in 10% revenue CAGR over
FY2019-21, compared to 1% revenue CAGR over FY2015-18.
15 15.8
12.1
10 10.0 9.2
7.1
5 5.9
3.7
0.8 0.4
0 (0.0)
(2.2)
(5)
(5.7)
(10)
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Barring a couple of luxury brands (Hackett, Simon Carter), ABFRL owns most other brands,
with the design process carried out in house. Further, communication from store managers
to area managers, and further to designers ensures that designers are always aware of
market trends and customer preferences.
Typically, a store is 1,000-1,500 sq. ft in size, and requires ~`2,500 sq. ft in capex on fixtures
etc. Thus, such a store does not require very high investment – `4 mn for capex and `2 mn
on inventory (~3 months of revenues). We believe stores can break-even within two years
and deliver healthy RoCE of 20-25%.
xx
Exhibit 24: Trade + LFS contributed to 34% of revenues in 2010 Exhibit 25: Trade + LFS contribution increased to 42% in 2018
Channel-wise revenues of Madura, March fiscal year-ends, 2010 (%) Channel-wise revenues of Madura, March fiscal year-ends, 2018 (%)
Others, 17
Others, 26
Retail, 40 Retail, 41
Trade +
Trade + LFS, 42
LFS, 34
Source: Company, Kotak Institutional Equities Source: Company, Kotak Institutional Equities
450
60
400
350 50
300
40
250
30
200
150 20
100
10
50
0 0
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019E 2020E 2021E
Affordable fashion retailers in India are expanding faster than mid-segment and premium
retailers. Among these, Pantaloons is one of the fastest expanding chains, targeting an
addition of 60-70 new stores annually, trailing only Reliance Trends which is targeting
adding 70-80 new stores. Besides Trent, most other mid-segment and premium fashion
retailers seem to be targeting a more measured expansion.
Exhibit 27: Pantaloons is one of the largest apparel retail chains in India
Store count and expansion plans of key large format retailers, March fiscal year-ends (#)
Exhibit 28: Price cuts in FY2018 now behind; can revive revenue growth and SSSG
Pantaloons’ revenue growth and SSSG trend, March fiscal year-ends
30 29
25 23
18 19
20 17 17
15 11 12
10 7.0 7.0
5.5 5.9 5.0
3.3
5
(1.6)
- (2.6)
(5)
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019E 2020E 2021E
Exhibit 29: Pantaloons’ price points are now comparable to other retailers in the affordable segment
Retailer-wise comparison of price points of different apparel
Men's wear
T-shirts 499-999 399-1,299 599-1,299 399-1,499
Shirts 999-1,499 499-1,499 599-1,299 899-1,699
Jeans 1,499-2,299 799-1,399 999-1,499 2,199-2,799
Notes:
(a) Based on price comparison done online and offline in June 2018 for merchandise offered on full price.
61 62
60
55
55
52
50
50
48
45
40
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Pantaloons has a mix of own and exclusive brands and popular third-party brands. As seen
below, its brands have a good mix of men’s fashion, women’s fashion and kidswear.
Exhibit 31: Portfolio of exclusive and third-party brands catering to a diversified customer base
Details of Pantaloons’ exclusive and third-party brands
Exclusive brands
Akkriti Women's ethnic and casual wear
Ajile Casual clothing for men and women
Altomoda Affordable casual clothing for men and women
Annabelle Women's western wear
Bare Denim and leisure wear
Byford Men's casual wear
Candie's New York Women's western wear and accessories
Chalk Kidswear
Chirpie Pie Kidswear and kids' accessories
Honey Women's western wear
Izabel London Women's western wear
Poppers Kidswear
Rangmanch Women's ethnic wear
Richard Parker SF Smart casual wear for men
Trishaa Women's ethnic wear
Urban Eagle Mens' and women' casual wear
Madura's brands
Allen Solly Menswear and womenswear
Allen Solly Junior Kidswear
Louis Philippe Menswear
Peter England Menswear
Van Heusen Menswear and womenswear
Third-party brands
109 F Women's western wear
AND Women's western wear
Aurelia Women's ethnic wear
Barbie Kidswear
BIBA Women's ethnic wear
Celio Mens' casual wear
Chemistry Women's western wear
Gini & Jony Kidswear
Global Desi Women's ethnic wear
Jealous 21 Women's western wear
John Miller Mens' formal and casual wear
Kraus Women's western wear
Lee Cooper Mens' and womens' casual and denim wear
Levis Mens' and womens' casual and denim wear
Spykar Mens' casual and denim wear
W Women's ethnic wear
ABFRL is aiming to bring down its losses to nil by FY2019, though we believe it might take
longer for it to break-even.
We believe expansion of this format would be gradual (6-8 stores a year), and would be
contingent on current stores breaking even.
2017 2018
Forever 21
No. of stores (#) 16 20
No. of cities present in (#) 9 14
People
No. of stores (#) 91 90
No. of cities present in (#) 50+ 50+
Fast fashion (Forever 21 + People)
Revenues (Rs mn) 3,450 3,970
EBITDA (Rs mn) (490) (540)
ABFRL: DECLINE IN DISCRETIONARY SPENDING AND HIGHER COMPETITION ARE KEY RISKS
We highlight the following risk factors for ABFRL: (1) sudden price increases by cloth vendors and garmenters,
(2) increase in mall/shop rentals thereby leading to higher costs, (3) increased competition and inability to
respond to changing customer preferences, (4) inefficient inventory management and changes in terms from
suppliers, and (5) inability to attract and retain manpower at commercially attractive terms.
ABFRL: STRONG 16% REVENUE CAGR AND 124% PBT CAGR OVER FY2018-21
We model revenue CAGR of 16% over FY2018-21 driven by steady addition to store count as well as improved
SSSG, particularly in Pantaloons. We expect ABFRL to post strong 124% PBT CAGR over FY2018-21 driven by
healthy revenue growth, steady margin improvement as well as interest cost reduction. We expect higher
profitability to drive an improvement in return ratios, though high goodwill on balance sheet will continue
to weigh on these ratios.
Expected increase in SSSG and consistent store addition to drive 16% revenue
CAGR over FY2018-21
We forecast ABFRL’s revenues to increase at a CAGR of 16% over FY2018-21. We expect
revenues of branded apparel segment (comprising lifestyle brands, fast fashion, People and
innerwear business) to grow at a CAGR of 13%, and the Pantaloons business to grow at a
CAGR of 19%.
We further note the company reports SSSG on a two year basis – a store is included in SSSG
calculation only if it has been in operation for at least 24 months. This is different from most
other apparel retailers which include stores operating for 12 months or more in their SSSG
calculation. We believe Pantaloons’ SSSG can revive as: (1) the proportion of new stores in
the overall mix increases and they get included in the SSSG calculation, and (2) the impact of
GST and price reduction normalizes.
We note that Pantaloons has aligned the prices of its private label offering to other retailers
such as Max Fashion and Reliance Trends – we thus do not expect any further major price
cuts to be undertaken. Steady SSSG of 5-7% coupled with strong store addition are the key
drivers of our assumption of 19% revenue growth drivers of Pantaloons over FY2018-21.
Exhibit 33: Revenue ramp-up from new stores to rev up revenue growth trajectory
SSSG and revenue growth profile of Pantaloons, March fiscal year-ends
30 29
25 23
18 19
20 17 17
15 11 12
10 7.0 7.0
5.5 5.9 5.0
3.3
5
(1.6)
- (2.6)
(5)
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019E 2020E 2021E
xx
450
60
400
350 50
300
40
250
30
200
150 20
100
10
50
0 0
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019E 2020E 2021E
xx
SSSG improvement and higher focus on private label to drive margin expansion
Pantaloons’ margin profile has been on an upward trajectory FY2014 onwards, as the
company focused on revamping and resizing older stores, and also increased the focus on
private label.
Private label. We note that gross margins on private labels can be 15-20 percentage points
higher than those on third-party brands, and hence a steady increase in the proportion of its
private label will drive margin improvement. We expect contribution of private label to
revenues to increase from 61% in FY2018 to 63% by FY2021, thus supporting gross
margins.
Rental expense. ABFRL’s P&L includes the impact of rent equalization over the lease period,
and we believe increase in rent expense recorded in the P&L over the next few years will
consequently be lower. Further, ABFRL has aggressively renegotiated rental expense for
Pantaloons stores. We note that for the consolidated company (Pantaloons + Madura +
other formats), rental expense as a percentage of revenues has declined from a high of 16.4%
in FY2017 to 14.5% in FY2018, and we expect it decline further to 13.3% by FY2021E.
Stable price points. A comparison of Pantaloons’ price points with other retailers across
different apparel categories indicates its prices are now aligned with those offered by other
retailers in the affordable category (such as Max Fashion and Reliance Trends), and are lower
than the relatively more premium retailers (such as Shoppers’ Stop). We believe Pantaloons’
price rationalization cycle is now over.
7
6.0
6
5.1 4.8 4.9
5
3.9
4
3
2.0
2
0
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019E 2020E 2021E
Lifestyle brands business: store additions and steady SSSG to drive revenue
growth
We expect lifestyle brands business revenues to grow at a CAGR of 10.5% over FY2018-21,
aided by 7-8% SSSG and the remainder from contribution of new stores.
Madura’s store count has remained flat over FY2016-17, though it started increasing
FY2018 onwards. With the market stabilizing post demonetization and GST and competition
from e-commerce stabilizing, we believe Madura will once again resume store addition. We
model 125-150 new stores (own+franchisee) to be added each year over FY2019-21.
While weakness in the distributor channel due to demonetization and GST impacted the
company in FY2017 and FY2018, we believe this channel is now recovering and should
enable brands business growth to revive.
15 15.8
12.1
10 10.0 9.2
7.1
5 5.9
3.7 0.8 0.4
0 (0.0)
(2.2)
(5)
(5.7)
(10)
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
xx
Exhibit 38: After tapering over FY2016-17, lifestyle brand's store additions are set to pick-up
Lifestyle brands store count and net additions, March fiscal year-ends
2,500 EBOs (#) (LHS) New store additions (#) (RHS) 300
250
2,000 200
150
1,500
100
50
1,000
-
500 (50)
(100)
- (150)
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019E 2020E 2021E
Robust revenue growth, margin expansion and lower interest expense to drive
strong 124% PBT CAGR over FY2018-21
We project ABFRL to report robust revenue growth of 16% over FY2018-21. Higher margins
in the Pantaloons segment should aid 30% EBITDA CAGR over FY2018-21. PBT CAGR of
124% over FY2018-21 is higher, given high leverage (March 2018 net debt: equity of 1.6X).
PAT CAGR is lower as ABFRL will pay tax at the rate of MAT FY2019 onwards, while it had a
deferred tax write-back in FY2018.
Exhibit 39: We expect 16% revenue CAGR over FY2018-21E Exhibit 40: We expect 30% EBITDA CAGR over FY2018-21E
Revenue profile, March fiscal year-ends EBITDA profile, March fiscal year-ends
(Rs bn) Revenue (Rs bn) (LHS) (%) (Rs bn) EBITDA, LHS (Rs bn)
(%)
120 Yoy growth (%) (RHS) 18 12 Yoy growth, RHS (%) 50
16
100 10
14 40
80 12 8
30
10
60 6
8
20
40 6 4
4 10
20 2
2
- - 0 0
2016 2017 2018 2019E 2020E 2021E 2016 2017 2018 2019E 2020E 2021E
Source: Company, Kotak Institutional Equities estimates Source: Company, Kotak Institutional Equities estimates
Exhibit 41: We expect 124% PBT CAGR over FY2018-21E Exhibit 42: We expect 54% PAT CAGR over FY2018-21E
PBT profile, March fiscal year-ends PAT profile, March fiscal year-ends
(Rs bn) PBT, LHS (Rs bn) (%) PAT, LHS (Rs bn)
(Rs bn) (%)
6 Yoy growth, RHS (%) 400
5.0 Yoy growth, RHS (%) 140
5 350
4.0 120
300
4
250 3.0 100
3 200
2.0 80
2 150
100 1.0 60
1
50
0 - 40
2016 2017 2018 2019E 2020E 2021E 0 2016 2017 2018 2019E 2020E 2021E
(1) (1.0) 20
(50)
(2) (100) (2.0) -
Source: Company, Kotak Institutional Equities estimates Source: Company, Kotak Institutional Equities estimates
Pantaloons business has clearly swung from a large EBIT loss in FY2016 to positive EBIT in
FY2018, and for reasons highlighted above, we believe this momentum will continue. This
will be a key driver for the overall improvement in return ratios of ABFRL.
(Rs mn) Net debt (Rs mn) (LHS) D/E (X) (RHS) (X)
25,000 2.5
20,000 2.0
15,000 1.5
10,000 1.0
5,000 0.5
- -
2016 2017 2018 2019E 2020E 2021E
Exhibit 46: Expect net working capital cycle to remain steady at ~21 days of sales
We believe that unlike other branded apparel businesses, Madura has lower working capital
requirements due to higher reliance on franchisees and sales to direct distributors. Further,
Pantaloons is able to manage its working capital efficiently as: (1) all third-party merchandise
for sale at its store is sold on a consignment basis, and hence the inventory is on the books
of the brand, and (2) ~61% of sales are of private label, where the company can control
inventory better.
FY2018 net working capital requirements reduced significantly as the company managed to
improve its payment cycle towards its vendors.
Madura. We forecast Madura to set up 150 new stores in FY2019 and FY2020, of which
we expect only 30 stores to be operated by ABFRL. Capex per store ranges from `3-3.5 mn,
implying new store capex of `100 mn. Maintenance capex is a larger chunk given the large
existing network of stores, and will lead to an additional capex of `76 mn in FY2019.
Including other businesses (fast fashion, innerwear business), centralized IT and other items,
total capex for Madura would be around `1.5 bn.
Pantaloons. We forecast Pantaloons to set up 65 new stores over FY2019 and FY2020 each.
Of these, nearly 20 stores would be set up by franchisees, and the remainder would be set
up by ABFRL. Capex on these stores, coupled with maintenance capex on old stores and IT
infrastructure leads to a capex forecast of `1.7 bn in FY2019 and `2.1 bn in FY2020.
Exhibit 47: SSSG revival of Madura and margin increase in Pantaloons to drive profitability
Details of key assumptions, March fiscal year-ends
xx
Exhibit 48: Consolidated income statement of ABFRL, March fiscal year-ends, 2013-21E (Rs mn)
xx
Exhibit 49: Consolidated balance sheet of ABFRL, March fiscal year-ends, 2013-21E (Rs mn)
xx
Exhibit 50: Consolidated cash flow statement of ABFRL, March fiscal year-ends, 2013-21E (Rs mn)
Ashish Dikshit is the MD of ABFRL, and was appointed to this position in January 2018 post
the exit of the then MD Pranab Barua. Prior to this role, Ashish headed the Madura Fashion
& Lifestyle division, where he has worked for more than 18 years.
Vishak Kumar is the CEO of Madura Fashion & Lifestyle. He has been with the Aditya Birla
Group for more than 23 years, and has also worked as the CEO of Aditya Birla Retail.
Sangeeta Pendurkar is the CEO of the Pantaloons business. She joined ABFRL in January
2018 and was formerly MD at Kellogg India. She has worked at several consumer facing
businesses such as food, FMCG and consumer banking. Shital Mehta had earlier headed the
Pantaloons business and resigned in January 2018.
Organization structure
ABFRL operates its business as two different segments: (1) Madura business which comprises
lifestyle brands, fast fashion (Forever 21 and People) and other businesses (innerwear), and
(2) Pantaloons. Barring corporate functions, there is little overlap between these two
businesses. Pantaloons retails Madura’s brands also on an arm’s length basis.
Shareholding pattern
Aditya Birla group has a 59.2% stake in the company – 11.3% held by Grasim Industries
and the remainder 47.9% held by promoters and promoter held entities.
Grasim Industries,
Others, 14.1 11.3
FIIs, 10.5
The Madura business was acquired in 1999 and currently comprises the lifestyle brands, fast
fashion and innerwear business. Before the restructuring in 2015, Madura was a part of
ABNL (Aditya Birla Nuvo).
ABNL had acquired Pantaloons from Future Group in FY2013, which was listed as a separate
entity.
In 2015, Aditya Birla Group carried out a restructuring to bring fashion and retail businesses
together in one listed entity (now ABFRL). Under this restructuring, Madura Fashion and
Madura Lifestyle were demerged from ABNL and merged into Pantaloons Fashion and Retail
(PFRL), a then subsidiary of ABNL. This resulted in a sharp increase in paid-up capital of PFRL
from `933 mn to `7.7 bn. Subsequently, ABNL shareholders were awarded shares in the
combined entity, which was renamed as Aditya Birla Fashion and Retail. Aditya Birla group,
directly and via Grasim Industries currently has a 59% shareholding in the company.
"I, Garima Mishra, hereby certify that all of the views expressed in this report accurately
reflect my personal views about the subject company or companies and its or their securities.
I also certify that no part of my compensation was, is or will be, directly or indirectly, related
to the specific recommendations or views expressed in this report."
60%
Percentage of companies within each category for which Kotak
Institutional Equities and or its affiliates has provided
50%
investment banking services within the previous 12 months.
300 40,000
38,000
250
36,000
200 34,000
32,000
150
30,000
100 28,000
26,000
50
24,000
- 22,000
Stock
Apr-16
Aug-16
Aug-18
Aug-15
Apr-17
Aug-17
Apr-18
Oct-15
Feb-16
Oct-16
Feb-17
Oct-17
Feb-18
Jun-16
Price
Jun-17
Jun-18
Dec-15
Dec-16
Dec-17
Index
Price
Source: Kotak Institutional Equities Research for ratings and price targets, Bloomberg for daily closing prices.
The price targets shown should be considered in the context of all prior published Kotak Institutional Equities research, which may or may
not have included price targets, as well as developments relating to the company, its industry and financial markets
Analyst coverage
Companies that the analyst mentioned in this document follow
Covering Analyst: Garima Mishra
Company name Ticker
Aditya Birla Fashion & Retail ABFRL IN
Avenue Supermarts DMART IN
Info Edge INFOE IN
InterGlobe Aviation INDIGO IN
Just Dial JUST IN
SIS SECIS IN
TeamLease Services TEAM IN
BUY. We expect this stock to deliver more than 15% returns over the next 12 months.
ADD. We expect this stock to deliver 5-15% returns over the next 12 months.
REDUCE. We expect this stock to deliver -5-+5% returns over the next 12 months.
SELL. We expect this stock to deliver <-5% returns over the next 12 months.
Other definitions
Coverage view. The coverage view represents each analyst’s overall fundamental outlook on the Sector. The coverage view will consist of one of the following designations:
Attractive, Neutral, Cautious.
Other ratings/identifiers
NR = Not Rated. The investment rating and target price, if any, have been suspended temporarily. Such suspension is in compliance with applicable regulation(s) and/or
Kotak Securities policies in circumstances when Kotak Securities or its affiliates is acting in an advisory capacity in a merger or strategic transaction involving this company
and in certain other circumstances.
RS = Rating Suspended. Kotak Securities Research has suspended the investment rating and price target, if any, for this stock, because there is not a sufficient fundamental
basis for determining an investment rating or target. The previous investment rating and price target, if any, are no longer in effect for this stock and should not be relied
upon.
NA = Not Available or Not Applicable. The information is not available for display or is not applicable.