Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
2, September 2017
R 1 1 p 1
(TE TL ) p x x x ( D1 ) KQ
(41) va= xAQ L 2 Q1 L1 Q 2 LDQ D 2 +
B p B 2 J B xB xLKQ
where, TE is the electromagnetic torque, which is xL 2 D1 xL1 D 2 xLDQ ( Q1 Q 2 )
positive for motor, TL is the load torque and J is the A C cos R x AD +
moment of inertia of the rotor assembly. xB
KD FR
2.1 Mathematical equations during OC B C sin R (51)
xLKD xLFR
It is assumed that the stator winding sets abc and
xyz (having the separate neutral points n1 and n2) are which is the phase voltage during stator current ia=0.
supplied by two sets of balanced three-phase voltage For a single three-phase winding abc, phase voltages
sources vag, vbg, vcg and vxg, vyg, vzg respectively. OC satisfy the condition,
may occur at one or more supply phases of the motor
input terminals. For analyzing the performance and va + vb + vc =0 (52)
redundancy characteristic of a motor under such
conditions, mathematical equations have to be Therefore, vn1g can be written by using Equs.(43)~
determined. For mathematical modeling of motor (44) ,(52) as
during OC, two cases are considered: OC fault at 1
vn1g = (vbg vcg va ) (53)
single phase at one winding set and single phase at 2
both the three phase winding set from each input
phase of the two three- phase input terminals, as Substitution of Equ.(53) for vn1g in Equs.(43)~(44),
discussed in following sections: followed by the Park transformation of voltages va, vb
and vc yields
Case 1: single phase OC 1
vQ1 = vacosR+ (vbg vcg ) sin R (54)
3
Initially, occurrence of open conductor fault is
assumed to take place at phase a, so that its terminal 1
current is zero (i.e. ia=0). Terminal voltages, which vD1 = vasin R+ (vbg vcg ) cos R (55)
3
force the current ia to remain zero are given by:
p which is valid for all the operating conditions. During
va = a (42) normal operation, phase voltage va=vag in above Equs.,
b
whereas during the OC condition at phase a, phase
vb = vbg vn1g (43) voltage va is given by Equ.(51).
vc = vcg vn1g (44) Case 2: double phase OC
Flux and current (which is zero) expression for phase
a in the term of d and q variables can be written as It is assumed that the opening of two phases
occurs simultaneously, one from each of the two
a = Q1cosR+D1sin R (45) three- phase supply to the motor input terminals. Here,
0=iQ1cosR+iD1sin R (46) it is assumed to occur at phases a and x, such that
currents ia and ix are both zero. Mathematical
From Equs.(8) and (9), iQ1 and iD1 can be expressed as expressions can be obtained in a similar manner as the
previous case. Phase a is determined from Equs. (51),
1
iQ1= ( Q1 MQ A C ) (47) (54)~(55). Analogous to phase a, voltage expression
xL1 during OC, phase x can be determined as
1
iD1= ( D1 MD B D) (48) p xL 2 Q1 xL1 Q 2 xLDQ ( D 2 D1 )
xL1 vx= x AQ
B xB
where A = xLM (iQ1+iQ2); B = xLM (iD1+iD2); C = xLDQ iD2;
D=xLDQ iQ2. KQ
Substitution of iQ1 and iD1 from Equs.(47)~(48) into A E cos( R )
xLKQ
Equ. (46) yields
Q1cosR+D1sin R=( MQ+AC)cosR+ xL 2 D1 xL1 D 2 xLDQ ( Q1 Q 2 )
x AD
( MD +B+C)sin R (49) xB
Comparing Equs. (45) and (49), it is found
KD FR
a =( MQ+AC)cosR+( MD+B+C)sin R (50) B F sin( R ) (56)
xLKD xLFR
Above obtained flux equation can be substituted in
Equ. (42) and writing the same in terms of state where, E = xLDQ iD1; F = xLDQ iQ1
variables by substituting Equs.(33)~(34) for MQ and A general expression for winding set xyz in dq0
MD, respectively. Therefore, variables is obtained as
66 Chinese Journal of Electrical Engineering, Vol.3, No.2, September 2017
3 Simulation results
Mathematical model for operation of SPSM under
OC condition was simulated in Matlab/Simulink. For
simplicity, the occurrence of OC is considered during
steady-state operation of the motor at a particular load.
A 3.7kW motor (parameters in Appendix I) was
simulated for single and double phase OC condition as
explained in following subsections.
3.1 Single phase OC
Before the occurrence of single phase OC, the
simulation assumes a steady state operating condition
at 50% of the motor base torque. Steady-state
pre-fault phase current of each winding set abc and
xyz are found to be 3.20A, 3.35A, 2.87A and 2.83A,
2.35A, 2.45A, respectively. Supply voltage is taken as
160V, with the variation similar to experimental
operating conditions. At time, t = 8 sec., OC is created
by opening phase a. As soon as phase current ia =0, a
sudden increase in the phase current of winding set
xyz is observed, followed by a decrease in remaining
healthy phases of winding set abc. Increase in current
of phases x, y and z is found to be 53.89% (4.35A),
106% (4.84A i.e. almost double) and 12.65% (2.76A)
respectively, indicating a larger power sharing by
winding set xyz. Decrease in the current of phase
Fig.2 Flow chart for evaluating the performance during b and c is 18.80% (2.72A) and 5.22% (2.72A)
normal and/or fault (OC and SC) condition respectively, indicating a smaller power sharing.
G. Singh et al.: Modeling and Analysis of Six-Phase Synchronous Motor under Fault Condition 67
Transient and steady state currents of healthy phases increase in current of phase b and c of 15.82%(3.88A)
of winding sets abc and xyz are depicted in Fig.3 and and 35.19% (3.88A), respectively. Increase in current
Fig.4, respectively. Motor torque is supplying the load, of phase y and z is 209.78% (7.28A) and 197.14%
accompanied by the production of torque harmonic, (7.28A), respectively. Transient as well as steady-
which varies between the peak value of 59.66N·m and state current of one healthy phase of winding sets abc
48.80N·m. This variation of instantaneous torque is and xyz are depicted in Fig.5 and Fig.6. The remaining
further noted in rotor speed and load angle, delta as healthy phases of each winding set have the same
shown in Fig.3(f)~(h). magnitude, but with a phase shift of 180 ° electrical to
satisfy the Kirchoff current law, and therefore, not
3.2 Double phase OC shown in the figure. Though the harmonics in motor
There are nine different cases of double phase torque increase in this case, the motor operates safely
OC, one phase from each winding set abc and xyz. To with its peak value varying between 26.08Nm and
examine the motor behavior, two phases, a and x were 73.21Nm. The harmonic variation in instantaneous
chosen in which OC is created at the same time, t = 8 torque is reflected in rotor speed and load angle, delta
sec., such that the currents ia =0 and ix =0. As expected, as shown in Fig.5(c)~5(e). In another case, phase a
power sharing by the healthy phases increases, with and y were chosen for double phase OC at the same
time, t = 8s, such that the currents ia =0 and iy =0. The
phase current variation was found to be similar to
previous case of phases a and x, though with a change
(a) i b in magnitude. Increase in current of phase b and c was
found to be 130.30% (7.60A) and 162.34% (7.60A),
respectively. Increase in current of phase x and y was
(b) i c found to be 34.58% (3.61A) and 50.42% (3.61A),
respectively.
(c) i x
3.3 Supply in one winding set (abc) only
Considering total supply outage for winding sets
xyz, supply in one winding set abc was simulated. The
(d) i y magnitude of current was found to be increased by
(e) i z
(f) Torque T E
(g) Speed R
(a) i b
(b) i y ,
Fig.4 Phase currents of healthy winding sets abc and Fig.6 Steady-state phase current of healthy phases after
xyz after single phase OC the occurrence of double phase OC
68 Chinese Journal of Electrical Engineering, Vol.3, No.2, September 2017
5.42A approximately, for each phase. Note that output Table 2 Pre and post fault current during OC at input
power of machine is both mechanical (to supply load motor terminals operating with different voltage levels at
torque) and electrical (voltage generation in winding 50% load neglecting supply asymmetry
set xyz), hence working simultaneously as motor and Voltage Motor phase current
level Operating modes
generator. Voltage generation for each phase in winding ia ib ic ix iy iz
set xyz due to transformer action, was found to be 160 Normal 2.29 2.29 2.29 2.29 2.29 2.29
159.94V. Waveforms of generated voltage v x and
Single phase OC 0 2.08 2.08 3.93 3.96 2.40
phase current ia are shown in Fig.7(a) and Fig.7(b),
respectively. In this mode, harmonics are decreased Double phase OC 0 5.28 5.28 0 5.46 5.46
considerably when compared to previous cases of OC. Three phase supply only 4.55 4.55 4.55 0 0 0
This is due to reduced sensitivity of the motor towards 200 Normal 1.83 1.83 1.83 1.83 1.83 1.83
supply asymmetries, working in three-phase winding Single phase OC 0 1.66 1.66 3.14 3.17 1.92
configuration. Thus, motor current inflow is increased
Double phase OC 0 4.21 4.21 0 4.35 4.35
in magnitude, but is more balanced. Analytical results
are also presented without considering the supply Three phase supply only 3.63 3.63 3.63 0 0 0
asymmetry, to have a better picture of current
distribution in pre- and post fault conditions. This set xyz. Balanced current flow can be noted in each
situation is shown at different motor loads and input winding set abc and xyz for double phase OC fault (i.e.
voltage levels in Table 1 and Table 2 respectively. An ia = ix =0). A slight variation in current magnitude in
unbalanced flow of stator current was found in the stator winding sets (abc and xyz) was also observed.
case of single phase OC (i.e. ia =0). Consequently, This is due to asymmetrical winding configuration on
current in remaining healthy phases of winding set abc the stator. Under OC fault, the pattern of current
decreases, whereas it increases irregularly in winding variation remained the same, when observed at
different motor load and input voltage. Change in
operating condition (motor load or input voltage) only
results in the variation of pre- and post-fault current
(a) Generated voltage v x
magnitude.
3.4 Asymmetrical SC
Occurrence of a SC at the input terminals of a
(b) current i a
motor drive system is asymmetrical in nature,
particularly in single line to ground (LG) fault.
Simulation has been carried out for line to ground (LG)
(c) Steady-state current i a
SC (most frequent case of SC), assuming it to take
place at phase a by taking phase voltage equal to
zero (va =0). It is assumed that SC prevails for a short
duration (10 cycle i.e. 0.12 sec.). SC occurs at time
(d) Torque T E t =7s. Motor current of all phases has been depicted in
Fig.8, in stationary reference frame. Asymmetrical
flow in each stator winding set can be observed. Due
to the highly inductive nature of stator windings, a
(e) Speed R change in phase current (hence, change in its magnetic
flux) is compensated by opposite and equal change in
other winding sets of corresponding phase. For
example, after the occurrence of SC in phase a at time
(f) Load angle t =7s, phase current i a increases with negative
magnitude by 266A in its first swing in Fig.8(a). In
Fig.7 Motor response with supply in winding set abc only
order to maintain constant flux, the same change in
Table 1 Pre and post fault current during OC at input current ix of phase x may be noted in Fig.8(d). Similar
motor terminals at different load with phase voltage of variation in current can be seen in other phases of
160V neglecting supply asymmetry winding sets abc and xyz. Since, motor output power
Motor phase current is assumed constant; therefore, the variation in active
Motor load Operating modes
ia ib ic ix iy iz component of current of a winding set is compensated
Normal 1.14 1.14 1.14 1.14 1.14 1.14 by the current in other winding set, as depicted in
Single phase OC 0 1.04 1.04 1.96 1.98 1.20 Fig.9. The transient offset in the phase current of
25% winding sets abc and xyz are also found to be
Double phase OC 0 2.68 2.68 0 2.70 2.70
Three phase supply only 2.27 2.27 2.27 0 0 0
pulsating at 50Hz. This transient offset reflects in
instantaneous torque, decaying with 50 Hz pulsation.
Normal 2.29 2.29 2.29 2.29 2.29 2.29
Motor electromagnetic torque becomes less than the
Single phase OC 0 2.08 2.08 3.93 3.96 2.40
50% load torque. The rotor speed decreases below
Double phase OC 0 5.28 5.28 0 5.46 5.46
synchronous speed, which increases the load angle,
Three phase supply only 4.55 4.55 4.55 0 0 0
delta. Rotor speed continues to decrease by 104.1rad/s,
G. Singh et al.: Modeling and Analysis of Six-Phase Synchronous Motor under Fault Condition 69
Table 4 Pre and post fault (OC) current data of winding sets abc and xyz at different load torque
Phase A B C X Y Z
Load Torque Op. mode Exp. Sim. Exp. Sim. Exp. Sim. Exp. Sim. Exp. Sim. Exp. Sim.
Normal 2.58 2.50 2.73 2.75 2.19 2.22 2.38 2.30 1.94 1.80 1.96 2.07
33.83% 1 phase opened 0 0 2.19 2.10 2.21 2.10 3.23 3.31 3.70 3.72 2.21 2.10
2 phases opened 0 0 2.77 2.73 2.77 2.73 0 0 4.99 5.07 4.97 5.07
Normal 2.32 2.22 2.51 2.50 1.97 1.98 1.87 1.83 1.44 1.34 1.52 1.52
1 phase opened 0 0 1.99 2.00 1.99 2.00 2.75 2.88 3.11 3.21 1.63 1.61
26.46%
2 phases opened 0 0 2.17 2.20 2.16 2.20 0 0 3.72 3.70 3.77 3.70
Table 5 Pre and post fault (OC) current data of winding sets abc and xyz at different voltage levels (phase voltage)
Phase A B C X Y Z
Voltage level Op. mode Exp. Sim. Exp. Sim. Exp. Sim. Exp. Sim. Exp. Sim. Exp. Sim.
Normal 3.55 3.50 3.74 3.77 3.11 3.17 3.27 3.31 2.89 2.80 2.83 2.80
180 1 phase opened 0 0 2.99 2.97 3.01 2.99 4.80 4.91 5.40 5.44 3.06 2.90
2 phases opened 0 0 3.58 3.55 3.59 3.55 0 0 6.59 6.61 6.60 6.61
Normal 3.87 3.86 4.24 4.28 3.61 3.68 3.82 3.82 3.32 3.25 3.24 3.20
200 1 phase opened 0 0 3.42 3.43 3.43 3.43 5.12 5.24 5.93 6.01 3.39 3.30
2 phases opened 0 0 3.83 3.90 3.82 3.90 0 0 7.02 7.08 7.04 7.08
G. Singh et al.: Modeling and Analysis of Six-Phase Synchronous Motor under Fault Condition 73
is required at zero potential. Approach for a six-phase source, is a very attractive property making it suitable
motor fed from two current-controlled inverter (for for some special applications (like power supply of air
abc and xyz winding sets) suggests that the two conditioner in electric railway etc.). A detailed
remaining healthy phase current of a particular simulation has been carried out for different cases of
winding set should be phase shifted by 30 0 electrical SC (both asymmetrical and symmetrical) occurring at
away from the faulted phase and their magnitude the motor input terminals. The provided flowchart can
should be increased by a factor of 3 . A complete be effectively used for any multi-phase machine. Two
analysis and performance evaluation of control cases of asymmetrical SC (LG and LLG) were
scheme will be reported in the near future. simulated, which prevail for 10 cycles (i.e 0.12 sec.),
resulting in an unbalanced flow of current in both the
6 Conclusion stator winding sets abc and xyz. It was found that the
motor operating under asymmetrical SC is more stable.
A unified and simplified approach was adopted
Instability is noted if it operates for more than three
for digital simulation for different cases of OC
cycles during symmetrical SC, but results in a balanced
at input terminals of SPSM using dq0 variables.
flow of stator current. In general, an excessive increase
This approach can be extended for any type of
in the magnitude of stator current was noted which
multi-phase machine, applying the OC fault at its one
was maximum during symmetrical SC. The variation
or more phases. This approach has been adopted for
in current magnitude is also reflected in the magnitude
the analysis of SPSM to explore the redundancy
of motor torque TE ripple, and found to be dependent
characteristic of motors, commonly used in higher
on input voltage level of motor terminal. A small
power applications. It includes an OC fault at one,
variation in torque ripple magnitude was noted with
two and three phases (complete outage of one set of
the change in motor load. Experimental investigation
input supply) of input terminal of the motor. It was
together with a detailed mathematical analysis of
observed that, with the increase in the number of OC
motor during SC will be reported in future work.
faults at input terminal of motor, power shared by the
remaining healthy winding set/phases increases. It Appendix I
was analytically and experimentally validated that the
motor continues to operate satisfactorily even during Parameter of 3.7 kW, 36 slots, 6-poles SPSM is given
below:
the outage of one or more input supply phases. Thus,
it can be concluded that in normal operation, fault in x MQ =3.9112 x L1 = x L2 =0.1758 r 1 =0.210
one of the two three phase winding set can be sustained x MD =6.1732 x LDQ =0 r 2 =0.210
and motor operates satisfactorily. This characteristic
is very important for the operation of motor where x LKQ =0.66097 x LM =0.001652 r KQ =2.535
reliability is of prime importance. Also, the simultaneous x LKD =1.550 r FR =0.056 r KD =140.0
operation of machine as a generator and motor, when
x LFR =0.2402
one set of stator winding is supplied by three-phase
Appendix II