Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 6

1

Microgrid Infrastructure Modeling for


Residential Microgrids
Daniel J. Cox, Senior Member, IEEE

nature of these microgrids under expected operational


Abstract-- Utility system vulnerabilities to multiple failures scenarios and extreme scenarios.
and the potential for such failures will increase as demand grows,
utility plants are forced to add units at suboptimum locations, II. BACKGROUND
and transmission capacity lags the population growth.
Microgrids have the advantage of allowing better recovery from In many ways Florida has become a leader in the
disasters as well as to boost utility system performance. By being development of planned communities to address issues of
placed close to the load, the microgrid can be switched into and urban sprawl while improving quality of life for its residents.
out of the transmission system. It can also operate independently Approaches to power distribution and load profiles can be
from the rest of the system for a period of time. This affects the used for planning an electric distribution system [1,2]. While
workflow of the disaster recovery and can also alter the economic a great deal of progress has been made in evolving community
impact to the utility and the utility’s customers. Modeling these design concepts to address the human, social, environmental
system interactions in terms of case study examples demonstrates
and overall quality of life issues, little work has been done to
the potential benefits of using microgrids to improve power
delivery and expansion of utility grids within urban areas and the address integration of energy systems into the community
methods of implementing them. design.
Before energy systems can be integrated into the
Index Terms—distributed generation, distributed control, community, modeling and analysis of the distributed
microgrids, neighborhood design. generation and distribution of energy must take place.
Detailed residential models have been used to simulate
I. INTRODUCTION distributed feeders [3] and examples of modeling distributed
generation into the electrical system have taken place [4]-[6].
U tility system vulnerabilities to multiple failures and the
potential for such failures under natural and/or man-
made threat are real exposures to power distribution
Connecting a distributed generation subsystem to the main
utility grid also requires much preparation and coordination
systems. Robust and secure community and [2],[7]-[8]. The concept of distributed generation and local
residential
transmission that encapsulates an entire local subsystem, or
neighborhood based microgrids may in the future lead to
microgrid, can operate independently or as a component of a
hardened power systems by providing significant reliability
larger electric grid.
and security benefits.
Blackouts in power delivery systems are well publicized,
and the cascading events contributing to these situations are III. MICROGRID OF ELECTRIC POWER INFRASTRUCTURE
often complex. The power distribution infrastructure Power system operation consists in producing,
vulnerabilities to disasters such as hurricanes are also transmitting, and distributing power, meanwhile minimizing
extremely highly visible in recent history. the negative effects of failures and other unexpected events.
In a utility power distribution system, the isolation of parts Power system management consists in determining which
of the system, or islanding, creates a system of microgrids. sources are to produce power, what their set points are, and
For example, the microgrids at hospitals, government which loads are to be satisfied, and maintaining all
buildings, and resources such as regional airports can also be transmission lines.
considered as support resources for islanding once excess and The US wishes to increase the robustness and efficiency of
stable sub-system capacity is achieved. the nation’s electric power infrastructure. One way to do it is
Distributed generation stations also support microgrids. to augment large power plants with small power plants, or
Advanced concepts for intelligent adaptive power microgrids microgrid resources. The impact of individual failures would
with distributed intelligence are needed as part of the be reduced and power sources would be closer to points of
infrastructure to increase robustness of the overall grid. use. This would reduce transmission losses and take pressure
Models must first be developed to understand the inherent off the transmission grid, which cannot keep pace with
growing generation and consumption.
The creation and validation of robust models of existing
This work was supported in part by the U.S. Department of Energy. power grids within a defined region provides the basis of
Daniel J. Cox is with the College of Computing, Engineering and
Construction, University of North Florida, Jacksonville, FL 32224 USA (e-mail: potential future islanding strategies to create intelligent
dcox@unf.edu). distributed microgrids within a defined region. These

1-4244-1298-6/07/$25.00 ©2007 IEEE.


2

microgrids of the future will have distributed generation periodic starting and testing, and maintain the fuel integrity.
capabilities, distributed intelligent sensing capabilities, and If routine maintenance and testing are not performed the
software infrastructure using intelligent sensing agents to emergency generator is likely not going to start when called
support islanding control strategies. upon. In contrast to the individual home generator approach,
A power system is a set of sources, loads, and consider the concept of a neighborhood microgrid.
interconnections such that any of the loads can be at least Collection of industry data to develop a residential
partially supplied by any of the sources. Breakers and microgrid model is underway to demonstrate the feasibility of
switches govern the interconnection of these elements. a residential microgrid system. Two main types of industry
Generally, power systems are often designed such that peak data are being used for the model. The first is the residential
system load can be satisfied by system sources, but these development data obtained from Centex Homes [10]. The
peaks are increasingly vulnerable as demand grows. Peak development is Cypress Trace located in southern Duval
shaving can eliminate the exposure. Unfortunately, this peak County. This Centex development is adjacent to Nocatee [11],
shaving is often needed in mid afternoon during the summer a master planned development with expected population of
and slightly after midnight on the coldest nights of the year. 35,000 over the next 20 years. A challenging unique aspect of
Additionally, if the electric power infrastructure needs access this area of Florida is that it is on the end of the transmission
to this energy for local voltage support or power quality, lines of both JEA [12] and Florida Power and Light [13].
overall control of the energy storage needs to be shared. Centex is also planning additional communities in Nocatee as
The ability to make and implement coordinated, precise are other residential developers. The second focus area for
management decisions quickly can make the difference industry data is to obtain representative data from the electric
between continued operation and going dark. If community utility, JEA in this case, regarding power distribution to the
based microgrids are to make a significant impact on the residential microgrid community and consumer usage data.
national infrastructure’s robustness, they must have sufficient Cypress Trace electricity is supplied by JEA.
generation capacity to supply loads outside of the community Cypress Trace is a modern home development consisting
itself. This is to support islanding. Islanding is the division of of approximately 250 homes averaging from 1,200 to 3,000
a power system into two separate power systems, the smaller square feet in a new planned community. The homes are
of which is the island. The power system definition implies constructed according to the latest standards, both for
that when either the source or the load of a transmission path structural integrity to withstand storms as well as a high level
does not lie within the island, the source will not be able to of energy efficiency. JEA has designed and layout of the
provide power to the load after the transition. It is possible distribution feeders, interconnection fuses and switches
that island sources will not be able to satisfy island load at during the planning stages of the development. The residential
pre-island levels [9]. microgrid system includes installation of a cost-effective,
The future of a national grid supported by community safe, reliable and dependable system. This provides the
based energy systems, requires significant and in excess homeowner a smooth, safe transition from regular service to
energy storage and generation. Proper encouraging economic emergency power in the event of an extended interruption,
incentives need to be given to developers and homeowners. even if not home. It also provides cost savings, both capital
Additionally, rules need to be allowed that will allow these and operating, over individual home generators, ensures
communities deal equitably with the corporate and municipal safety to the homeowner by not handling fuel, avoids
entities that they are connected. Overall concepts must be improper interconnection with the utility, and avoids exhaust
validated through modeling and benefits beyond the hazards from internal combustion engines. This ensures safety
boundaries of the microgrid must be quantified. to the electric utility workers to perform power restoration
duties without the danger of electric shock from improperly
IV. RESIDENTIAL MICROGRID MODELING connected emergency generators.
A residential microgrid provides reliable emergency The residential microgrid system consists of a common
backup power to the homeowners of a residential generation facility, protective relays, controls, and monitoring
development during times of extended power interruptions all to meet the utility interconnection requirements [1],[2],
resulting from storm damages or other related causes. [14]-[16]. The system is being modeled using the
Currently the main alternative to the electric utility in periods MATLAB/Simulink SimPowerSystems toolbox [17]. The
of prolonged outages such as following hurricanes is the generation facility consists of a set of four generators. It is
individual home generator. Such home generators, designed to be located on the common areas of the
particularly gasoline engine generators, are wasteful, development and interconnects with the underground
expensive, and potentially dangerous to the homeowner as distribution system of the utility. The generation facility
well as personnel of the electric utility. could actually be built by the developer, pro-rated on a “per
Currently, home developers have only the home generator lot” basis for approximately one-half the cost of individual
option to offer emergency backup power generation to the generators, and the ownership turned over to the utility in a
prospective purchaser of a new home. The cost of a generator manner similar to the other infrastructure of the development.
including a utility approved manual transfer switch, wiring, Advantages of such a neighborhood generation system include
controls and fuel tank becomes significant to homeowner. The added value to the community. The distributed microgrid
homeowner is also required to provide routine maintenance, system increases marketability of the subdivision. The set of
3

generators correctly sized to supply the subdivision instead of hot weather days. The distributed microgrid could be remotely
one unit per residence, is as low as one-half the cost of dispatched by the utility for peak shaving and load balancing.
individual home units. One strategically located central Therefore, some level of supplemental power from the
building for the generators and their controls is located away residential microgrid system can be made to the electric utility
from the individual residences. This generator building can be to be used elsewhere in the distribution system.
architecturally treated to blend in with the other structures in The present condition of power generation is done in large
the subdivision. on a macro scale. While there are safeguards to isolate parts
The system connects at the main feeder from the utility of a larger system so it can protect itself, these safeguards can
and ties into the underground distribution system to the also contribute to detrimental consequences in real systems.
individual homes in a manner approved by the utility. As the Microgrids offer benefits to the macro scale distribution by
subdivision grows additional generation of various types can enabling additional resources to be spread out to
be strategically added to accommodate phased community accommodate operating conditions out of the norm. These
expansion. In the event of a power outage, the system conditions could include catastrophes due to weather, or other
provides emergency backup power automatically to the events, or simply due to an overstressed power distribution
homeowners in a smooth, safe transition. The homeowners system on a hot summer day.
are not required to do anything but wait for the system to Current utility planning considers placing “peakers” in the
start. The homeowners’ association fees will include the cost system to provide supplemental power on high-demand
of operating and maintaining the emergency backup power occasions, but there has been no methodology developed to
service. The distributed microgrid reduces the need to vacate examine distributed generation and the effect of microgrids
the residence during the emergency. If the homeowner either connected to, or isolated from the main utility grid. The
chooses evacuation, the emergency backup system starts disadvantage of peaking systems is that they are often located
automatically, so the critical home electrical systems will be away from the load and begin to loose their ability to control
functional. The system is designed to enable the owner to voltage.
maintain current lifestyle and comfort, virtually eliminating By placing generating assets closer to the source of the
stress associated with power interruptions. load using microgrids, the overall transmission utilization
The distributed microgrid eliminates the need for the increases, and the necessity to upgrade the transmission
individual homeowner to be concerned with any aspect of system for its peak load is deferred. Microgrids are expected
owning an emergency generator. Maintenance and/or repairs to offer better VAR control and a stiffer distribution system
will be performed by professionals. There are no requirements with improved power delivery. Once they become widely
for storage of fuel or lubricants at each residence and there is used, it is expected that microgrids will offer more options for
no concern for noise or vibration or exhaust fumes at the utility system dispatching and will make available better
residences. The distributed microgrid system minimizes the power quality while maintaining the same, if not improved
environmental impact. Fewer, larger generators are more reliability.
efficient than hundreds of smaller units, therefore emitting Microgrids have the advantage of allowing better recovery
fewer pollutants. from a disaster. By being placed close to the load, if the main
Although the residential microgrid concept poses some transmission lines are disabled, the microgrid can be switched
technical, legal, and regulatory issues that will require out of the main power distribution system and operate
understanding and collaboration among the developer, independently for a period of time. This is one of the key
homeowners, and the electric utility, there are distinct benefits of microgrids, however, the level of sophistication in
advantages of the microgrid system to the utility. The the control strategy needed is well beyond current utility grid
possibility of inadvertently energizing the utility’s distribution operation capabilities.
network is eliminated. Because criticality of power restoration Compared to generation resources, transmission and
is reduced, the microgrid enables the utility to safely restore distribution systems are not as well utilized. For example,
power at a lower priority; this potentially eliminates the need generation assets are typically used at 70% of capacity or
for line crews to perform repairs during periods of dangerous more at least 50% of the time. A typical distribution feeder,
storm conditions. The utility will be able to remotely monitor by contrast, is used at 70% of capacity or above less than 10%
the status of the system through the utility control and of the time. Another comparison is the amount of time the
monitoring system. assets are used at high capacity. Overall generation assets
There are currently two main scenarios being considered usually never fall below 50% utilization. However, a typical
for the residential microgrid model to demonstrate the distribution feeder is utilized at 50% capacity less than 40%
feasibility and benefits of the residential microgrid system of the time.
using the modeling and simulation efforts. The first and This points out the potential value of distributed generation
primary scenario is the outage due to catastrophic event such as a means of leveling the peak demands not only of the
as a hurricane. The second is the use of the system to generation assets of a utility, but more significantly, the peak
supplement the power distribution of the utility. As mentioned demands of the transmission and distribution system. By
above, the subdivision under investigation is on the placement of small generation capacity at key locations in the
distribution end of the utility transmission feeder lines. An utility system grid, the peaks can be leveled and the existing
additional resource would likely benefit the utility on extreme transmission capacity can be more effectively utilized.
4

The distributed generation assets also become a key backup will be more difficult to evacuate from hurricanes. Newer
feature in the event of a disaster such as a hurricane or other home construction encourages homeowners to “ride out” all
disaster. The utilization of distributed generation can alleviate but the worst storms. New homes, particularly those in south
reliability concerns and help a utility recover in a more Florida include the use of multiple construction enhancements
responsive, cost efficient and safe manner when used with such as high impact windows, poured concrete construction,
islanding control strategies. steel truss system, and metal roofs. As confident as builders
The telemetry and current data capabilities for a utility are that construction techniques will withstand major
system vary widely across the industry. Although, there hurricanes, the type of lifestyle that they are envisioning and
typically is a fair amount of data, the type and periodicity of promoting for prospective homeowners will be dramatically
the data is insufficient for sophisticated real-time control impacted if there is a loss of power.
strategies. Nevertheless, much insight is gained by the data Even though many homeowners are not home at the time
available and logged on present-day grids, in order to examine of a storm, they do not want the power to be lost for extended
sensing requirements for microgrids of the future. periods because of food spoilage, mold, security issues, and
A key element in a control strategy such as an islanding preservation of the home’s contents. More people work at
control strategy of a larger grid to create microgrids, is a real- home than ever before. It has been learned that the worst
time sensing capability. With an agent-based approach using impact is generally not only from the storm damage, but also
islanding agents in an islanding control strategy, intelligent from the millions of dollars in lost business due to the
sensing agents for the intelligent distributed microgrid are extended power outages following the storm. More
necessary. Intelligent sensing agents use strategically placed homebuyers are requesting and purchasing individual home
sensors within the designated microgrids and communicate generators as part of their new Florida home.
real-time information to control systems of intelligent Added value to the community, the distributed micro-
distributed microgrids. The types and modalities of intelligent grid system will increase marketability of the subdivision,
sensing agents require further research and development. The lower cost, 3 or 4 generators correctly sized to supply the
aim is that residential microgrid modeling can also help in this subdivision instead of one unit per residence, as low as one-
effort. half the cost of individual home units. One strategically
located central building for the generators and their controls,
V. REQUIREMENTS OF RESIDENTIAL MICROGRID MODEL located away from the individual residences.
Even though different types of generating units can be used Generator building can be architecturally treated to blend
to makeup a microgrid, the underlying characteristics of a in with the other structures in the subdivision. The system will
microgrid are still the same. All microgrids provide power connect at the main feeder from the utility and tie into the
generation independent of the main utility grid. They have the underground distribution system to the individual homes in a
ability to connect and disconnect from the main power lines manner approved by the utility. Adaptable to future expansion
and provide emergency back-up power service when needed. as the subdivision grows additional generation can be
They distribute power in close proximity to their consumption strategically added to accommodate phased community
loads and are capable of improving power quality to the main expansion. In the event of a power outage, the system
grid. Microgrids also incorporate similar functions as the provides emergency backup power automatically to the
utility grid including wired and wireless communications, load homeowners in a smooth, safe transition. The homeowners
control, integrated control system, protective relaying, are not required to do anything but wait for the system to
programmable logic control, substation logistics, and remote start. The homeowners’ association fees will include the cost
dispatch capability. Microgrids control both supply and of operating and maintaining the emergency backup power
demand side functions to optimally meet the power supply service.
and distribution needs of the community served. The residential neighborhood used as a basis for the
The main use of the microgrid is to provide power in an residential Microgrid model is Cypress Trace [10]. There are
emergency to the residential community. However in times of two types of residences in Cypress Trace, multi-family
need, the model will examine the potential of using this power residences consisting of town home condominiums and single
supply to supplement the main grid in times of peak usage. In family homes. Cypress Trace is a modern residential
addition to dispatchable capacity, the incumbent utility is development with many energy saving features standard in the
interested in VAR support to help manage stability in the residential units. All units are frame construction using wood
affected power grid. studs and truss system with hurricane tie downs. Deluxe R-30
The requirements of the model are developed from the ceiling insulation is used, R-11 is used in the interior walls,
pattern of a basic new start up community located in the the water heaters are 40-50 gallons, the A/C units are 10
Northeastern Florida area. The community would likely SEER, insulated fiberglass entry doors, and dual-glazed
distribute the cost of the microgrid equitably to a minimum thermo pane windows are used.
number of residential homes and multifamily dwellings to There are a total of 51 single family homes comprised of
support a defendable business case. A primary benefit and six models of floor plans. The smallest plan 2063 sq. ft. uses a
attractiveness to the homeowner of the backup generation of 200 amp electrical source. The remaining models ranging
the microgrid is to minimize the effect of hurricane power from 2543 sq. ft. to 3547 sq. ft. use a 300 amp source. The
outage. As Florida becomes increasingly more populated it town home condominiums (multi-family homes) are grouped
5

in arrangements of four living units and six living units. There VI. CONCLUSION AND FUTURE WORK
are 3 different floor plans comprising the units. Utility system vulnerabilities to multiple failures and the
There are 4-unit complexes and 6-unit complexes. The potential for such failures under natural and/or man-made
total number of 4-unit complexes is eight. The square footage threat have been discussed. Florida is an excellent target
on the units in the 4-unit complexes is 3765 sq. ft. on the main market for near term exploitation of distributed generation in
floor and 3674 sq. ft. on the upper floor. The total building microgrids. As communities are developed and evolve they
demand load of 81,351 VA uses a 339 amp source. There are need to be monitored and analyzed to assure the continued
31 6-unit complexes with 5,508 sq. ft. on the main floor and appeal of their future development. Models of the residential
5114 sq. ft. on the upper floor. The total building demand load communities are being developed using industry data to
is 114,778 VA with a 478 amp source. The individual units understand the capabilities for expected backup usage and for
range from 1067 sq. ft. to 1468 sq. ft. potential support of the main utility grid.
Other objectives of the modeling include analysis of
General loads are modeled for normal use. These include
advanced concepts for integration of distributed energy
general lighting load, air handler fans, seasonal electric
resources and microgrids within a defined regional electric
heat/heat pump/air conditioning and appliances. Appliances
distribution system to establish islanding control strategies.
include laundry machines, electric range/oven, dishwasher,
Advanced concepts for intelligent adaptive power grids with
disposal, microwave, entertainment and other small
distributed intelligence is a longer term objective to increase
appliances. The approach is to model these into a residential
robustness of the overall grids of the future. Another benefit
power consumption model for each of the residences. The
gained from modeling effort for sensing within the defined
seasonal effects are also being considered, in the summer
grid to determined real-time requirements for intelligent
time, cooling loads are modeled, and in the winter heating
sensing agents used in intelligent control of microgrids of the
loads are modeled. These loads correspond to the types of
future.
HVAC units in the residences.
The neighborhood infrastructure consists of a community
VII. REFERENCES
center, pump station, street lights, and the existing
neighborhood electrical distribution system. The pump station [1] Willis, H.L., Power Distribution Planning Reference Book, Marcel
Dekker, Inc, 1997.
consists of two 60 hp pumps that are 3 phase, 460 volts, and [2] Short, T. A., Electric Power Distribution Handbook, CRC Press, 2003.
250 amp units. The existing grid tie-in to the power utility grid [3] Guttromson, R.T., Chassin, D. P., and Wildergren, S.E., “Residential
is interconnection single point of an existing grid tie–in to 26 Energy Resource Models for Distribution Feeder Simulation,” Proceedings
KV on the main grid. A grid radial feed of 4160 volts IEEE/PES Summer Conference, 2003, pp. 108-113.
[4] Delfino, B., “Modeling of the Integration of Distributed Generation into
disperses to transformers throughout the neighborhood. the Electrical System,” Proceedings IEEE/PES Summer Conference, 2002,
There are two likely candidates for neighborhood pp. 170-175.
generation. These would supply 4160 volts. Either diesel [5] Slootweg, J.G., “Representing Distributed Resources in Power System
generators, or gas turbine generators are to be considered. Dynamics Simulation,” Proceedings IEEE/PES Summer Conference, 2002,
pp. 176-178.
Models of the power plants [18] must be integrated into the [6] Chao, X.H., “System Impact Studies for DG Projects under Development
residential microgrid model. The distributed generation is in the US,” Proceedings IEEE/PES Summer Conference, 2001, pp. 772-
then modeled with the existing neighborhood electrical 774.
distribution system. These small units can be incrementally [7] Funabashi, T., “Study on Protection and Control of Dispersed Generators,”
Proceedings IEEE/PES Summer Conference, 2001, pp. 775-776.
initiated in the microgrid. In the scenarios of supplying excess [8] Papathanassiou, S.A.., “Technical Requirements for Connection of
capacity to the main grid, the 4160 volts is stepped up to 26 Dispersed Generation to the Grid,” Proceedings IEEE/PES Conference,
KV. Synchronization to the main grid would need to occur. 2001, pp. 749-754.
Further functional and operational constraints are also [9] Phillips, L.R., Cartes, D., Liu, W., Cox, D., Davis, T., Simmons, S.,
Edwards, D., Wilde, N., “Agents and Islands: Managing a Power System
included in the modeling effort. This is somewhat limited by Before, During, and After Transition to the Islanded State,” 2006
the tools used but consists of startup, transient behavior, IEEE/SMC International Conference on System of Systems Engineering,
limited control of the individual units, synchronization, and pp. 161-166.
considerations for communication and safety. [10] http://www.centexhomes.com/
[11] http://www.nocatee.com/
Two scenarios are for using the model are under [12] http://www.jea.com/
development for use within the residential microgrid model. [13] http://www.fpl.com/
The first scenario is the primary scenario of insuring power to [14] G. Johnson editor, “Onsite Power Generation: A Reference Book,”
the residential neighborhood in the event of a natural disaster Electrical Generating Systems Association, 1993.
[15] “Power Distribution Planning,” IEEE Course 92 EHO 361-6-PWR.
such as a hurricane. The second is a hot weather scenario in [16] “Protection of Synchronous Generators.” IEEE Course 95 TP 102.
which excess capacity from the distributed generation of the [17] http://www.mathworks.com/
residential microgrid may introduce excess capacity to the [18] Lesseter, R., “Dynamic Models for Micro-Turbines and Fuel Cells,”
larger electric utility main grid. The amount and available Proceedings IEEE/PES Summer Conference, 2001, pp. 761-766.
excess is found using the base model to assess the
neighborhood requirements and using the excess for the main
grid.
6

VIII. BIOGRAPHY
Daniel Cox was born in Gainesville, Florida, on
April 10, 1957. He graduated with both the
BSME with Honors and Master of Science in
Mechanical Engineering from the University of
Florida. He received his Ph.D. from the
University of Texas at Austin in Mechanical
Engineering. He worked for 16 years with the
IBM Corporation, 3 years as a Research Scientist
at UT Austin and is currently on the faculty at the
University of North Florida.

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi