Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 8

GOVERNMENT, LAW, AND PUBLIC HEALTH PRACTICE

Alcohol Marketing

Multinational Alcohol Market Development and Public


Health: Diageo in India
Marissa B. Esser, PhD, MPH, and David H. Jernigan, PhD

Alcohol is a risk factor for IN INDIA, AVERAGE ADULT PER problems,16---18 there is a need to India,” “Diageo in India,” and
communicable and noncom- capita alcohol consumption in- better understand the role of the “spirits in India.” The News Alerts
municable diseases, and alco- creased by 19% from 2005 to global alcohol industry in India’s generated approximately 1500
hol consumption is rising 2010.1 In 2010, alcohol consump- changing alcohol environment. articles from various regions of the
steadily in India. The growth of tion ranked among the country’s We provide a brief history of India’s world (e.g., India, the United King-
multinational alcohol corpora-
top 10 leading risk factors for alcohol regulations to contextualize dom, and the United States), some
tions, such as Diageo, contrib-
causes of death (350 000 deaths), the current alcohol environment. of which covered similar ground.
utes to India’s changing alcohol
environment. disability-adjusted life years Diageo, the world’s largest spirits The same author also monitored
We provide a brief history of (n =14.2 million), and years of life marketer, made significant invest- alcohol industry---oriented market
India’s alcohol regulation for lost (n =11 million).2 In a popula- ments in India’s alcohol market research such as just-drinks.com.19
context and examine Diageo’s tion of 1.2 billion,3 approximately between May 2013 and July 2014, We collected additional informa-
strategies for expansion in 15% of Indians drink alcohol; and we examine its growth as a case tion from Diageo’s Web site and its
India in 2013 and 2014. Diageo however, per capita consumption study. We assess how the principal 2014 fiscal year annual report.20
is attracted to India’s younger among Indian drinkers is approxi- elements of Diageo’s “responsibility We also searched other alcohol
generation, women, and emerg- mately 1.5 times greater than the strategy” compare with evidence- industry Web sites, including the
ing middle class for growth average among drinkers worldwide.1 based public health recommenda- International Center for Alcohol
opportunities.
Alcohol consumption in tions for reducing harmful alcohol Policies (ICAP) main site21 as well
Components of Diageo’s re-
India is an immediate public health consumption. We conclude with as other ICAP sites.22,23 We drew
sponsibility strategy conflict
with evidence-based public concern, given the national burden recommendations for promoting on reviews of the alcohol policy
health recommendations for of communicable diseases and and protecting public health. research literature to identify
reducing harmful alcohol con- noncommunicable diseases (NCDs). Opportunities to obtain internal evidence-based policies to com-
sumption. Diageo’s strategies Each year, one quarter of the alcohol industry documents or pare with Diageo’s responsibility
for achieving market domi- world’s incident cases of tuberculo- firsthand accounts of its practices strategy.24---30
nance in India are at odds with sis are in India,4 and because of are rare, making it challenging to
public health evidence. We con- shifting demographic and socioeco- understand its intentions; therefore, OVERVIEW OF ALCOHOL
clude with recommendations nomic factors, NCDs now contrib- we relied on a comprehensive re- CONTROL IN INDIA
for protecting public health ute to half of the country’s deaths.5 view of sources such as media
in emerging markets. (Am
Indian studies have documented articles or annual reports over a A detailed account of India’s
J Public Health. 2015;105:
that alcohol consumption is associ- defined time period. To monitor history of alcohol consumption and
2220–2227. doi:10.2105/AJPH.
2015.302831) ated with both communicable dis- Diageo’s activities in India, the first the drinking culture has been writ-
eases and NCDs, including HIV,6---8 author read online media articles ten elsewhere.31 In brief, histori-
tuberculosis,9,10 and cancers,11 as for 18 months (July 2013--- cally, the prevalence of alcohol
well as violence12,13 and injuries.14,15 December 2014), compiled with consumption in India was relatively
With this imminent public Google News Alerts related to the low32 and there were restrictions
health crisis and links between following keywords: “alcohol in on who could drink and when
industry tactics and public health India,” “alcohol consumption in drinking was permitted.33 During

2220 | Alcohol Marketing | Peer Reviewed | Esser and Jernigan American Journal of Public Health | November 2015, Vol 105, No. 11
GOVERNMENT, LAW, AND PUBLIC HEALTH PRACTICE

the early 19th century, India be- context of a general move toward gaining prominence in the in 2003, Diageo illicitly paid more
came more industrially developed, market liberalization, India permit- recorded, or formal, alcohol mar- than US $1.7 million to hundreds of
and, like the upper class, members ted the global alcohol industry to ket.31,39 Data from a leading global Indian government officials. The
of the growing middle class enter its alcohol market.33 market research firm serving the Indian officials
abstained from alcohol to distin- Today, alcohol policies and al- alcohol industry indicate that
were responsible for purchasing
guish themselves from the lower cohol markets vary across India’s India is now among the top 10 or authorizing the sale of its bev-
classes.31 Alcohol consumption in 29 states.39 There is a national countries worldwide for alcohol erages in India, and increased sales
India became more popular during blood alcohol concentration limit sales, after experiencing consis- from these payments yielded more
than $11 million in profit for the
the British colonial period,33 and of 0.03 grams per deciliter for tent increases in the past decade company.52
1862 saw the establishment of drivers; however, the level of en- (Figure 1).48 From 1990 to 2010,
India’s first alcohol manufacturing forcement of drink-driving policies the liters of pure ethanol sold in There were also similar charges
distillery.34 Alcohol became an im- is perceived to be low.40 As of the form of spirits increased by for violations in Thailand and
portant source of revenue for the 2014, 4 states and 1 Union Ter- 147% and in the form of beer by South Korea. Diageo paid more
colonial government with the ritory had total bans on alcohol 587%. By 2011, spirits accounted than US $16 million in fines to the
implementation of the Bombay and several others had partial for nearly two thirds of the US government to settle the in-
Abkari Act of1878 and the Mhowra prohibition (e.g., bans on the pro- country’s alcohol consumption.48 vestigation.52
Act of 1892, which taxed the pro- duction or consumption—or both— International Wine and Spirits In 2010, India’s United Spirits
duction of toddy, a locally pro- of specific types of alcohol),39 al- Research data suggest that Limited (USL) sold 12.7% of the
duced alcoholic beverage, and though alcohol policies in Indian between 2009 and 2013, the world’s top 100 brands of spirits
prohibited other locally produced states change frequently over compound annual growth rate in- (by volume). Globally, Diageo
alcoholic drinks.35 time.41 Most recently, in 2014, the creased for imported alcoholic ranked second, selling 10.8%;
In 1937, several Indian states southern state of Kerala consid- beverages but decreased for do- however, Diageo was the largest
enacted policies prohibiting alcohol, ered taking steps to achieve total mestic alcoholic beverages.49 global marketer of spirits when all
although the bans were abolished alcohol prohibition but weakened spirits brands are considered.48
during World War II and alcohol the proposed policy regulations at DIAGEO AND INDIA Diageo has expanded its involve-
excise taxes became the country’s the end of the year.42 Prohibition ment in the production, marketing,
largest source of government reve- policies appear to have greater Diageo, a London-based multi- and distribution of alcoholic bev-
nue.36 Influenced by Mohandas effects on female than male con- national alcohol corporation, de- erages in India through a series of
Gandhi’s temperance movement,37 sumption,43 but precise measure- scribes itself as “the leading premium transactions to increase its share-
alcohol control was included in one ment of alcohol use in India is spirits business in the world.”50 In holding in USL, starting with
of the Directive Principles of State difficult because 44% to 50% of 2010, the company had net reve- a purchase of 10.04% of its shares
Policy under Article 47 of the alcohol consumption is unrecorded, nue of $15 billion and a ratio of in May 2013 (Table 1).20 In July
Constitution of India, giving states with even greater proportions profit to revenue of 25%.48 Diageo 2013, Diageo acquired another
control over alcohol policies.38 in rural areas.1,44,45 Unrecorded has taken numerous steps to speed 14.98%. These acquisitions of
However, the central (i.e., national) alcohol generally refers to alcohol its growth in emerging markets. An slightly more than one quarter of
Indian government formulated produced at home or informally, online industry news article stated the USL shares made Diageo the
a plan to achieve national prohibi- alcohol legally imported for per- that in 2008, emerging markets largest USL shareholder,53 at
tion by 1958, causing several states sonal use, and alcohol illicitly accounted for approximately 25% a combined cost of 52.3 billion
to temporarily reintroduce alcohol imported.46 Such beverages are of Diageo’s sales by volume; by Indian rupees (Rs) (approximately
prohibition. With economic and usually cheaper than recorded al- June 2014, that figure was roughly US $859 million).20 According to
political changes in the mid-1960s, cohol, as they evade taxes.47 65%.51 However, some of its the company’s Asia-Pacific presi-
the ruling upper class became less growth has involved illegal activi- dent, starting in October 2013,
supportive of prohibition policies; INDIA’S CHANGING ties: in July 2011, the US Securities Diageo hoped that through the
thus, by 1971, all states lifted the ALCOHOL MARKET and Exchange Commission charged USL network it would bring in
alcohol bans, except Gujarat.36 By Diageo with major violations of the 5 billion Rs (approximately US
the late 1960s, social stigma against Despite the large proportion of Foreign Corrupt Practices Act.52 $82.5 million) per year.54 With
the liquor market had largely di- unrecorded alcohol in India,44,47 According to the US government additional acquisitions of 1.35%
minished.36 In the 1990s, in the the global alcohol industry is media release, for 6 years, starting of the shares in November 2013

November 2015, Vol 105, No. 11 | American Journal of Public Health Esser and Jernigan | Peer Reviewed | Alcohol Marketing | 2221
GOVERNMENT, LAW, AND PUBLIC HEALTH PRACTICE

5000 these sachets in India, USL and


Millions of Liters Pure Ethanol

4500 Beer Wine Distilled spirits Total Diageo are now distributing their
4000 brands in mini-bottles (50---90 mL).66
Tetra-paks and mini-bottles are af-
3500
fordable and easy to conceal, and
3000
research among African university
2500
students has found that they have
2000 potential appeal to young con-
1500 sumers.67 Additionally, Diageo In-
1000 dia is introducing Smirnoff Black
500 Ice; Diageo India’s marketing
0 director, Bhavesh Somaya, says that
1990 1995 2000 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 “Ice has a much bigger footprint
Year and will focus on recruiting people
who are migrating from beer to
Source. Impact Databank.48
spirits.”68 Youths have previously
FIGURE 1—Trends in alcohol consumption, by beverage type and total consumed: India, 1990–2010. been found to be attracted to these
ready-to-drink Smirnoff alcoholic
beverages.18 Diageo is also reaching
and 2.41% of the shares in January According to Menezes, most world’s second most populous younger consumers by selling its
2014, Diageo closed the 2014 fiscal countries contribute 3% or less to country.3 Social norms regarding alcoholic beverages at community
year with 28.78% of shareholdings Diageo’s revenue, but the com- alcohol use are changing and al- events, such as music festivals. As
in USL, after investing a combined pany anticipates drawing up to cohol is becoming more culturally Diageo’s 2014 annual report states,
total of 65.7 billion Rs (nearly US 10% of its revenue from India accepted.33,59 India’s population is
Diageo India continued to deliver
$1.1 billion; Table 1).20 through USL’s 65 000 outlets relatively young, with years of
strong double digit net sales
Holding more than a quarter reaching 90% of the country.56 potential alcohol consumption growth as it benefited from having
of the USL shares, Diageo was not However, Diageo must confront ahead of them. One 2003 study its brands sold through the sales
agency agreement with USL. . . .
yet done investing in USL: in April regulatory factors in India, such as found that Indians had started
Smirnoff net sales grew high single
2014, Diageo offered approxi- taxation57 and other regulatory drinking at younger ages; the av- digit benefiting from its partnership
mately US $1.9 billion for an addi- systems that differ from state to erage age of drinking initiation with several music festivals.20(p39)
tional 26% of USL’s shares, in state, as well as a national ban on dropped from 25 years in 1988 to
Diageo also won a spot on the
hopes of becoming the majority broadcast alcohol advertising.39 20 years in 2002.44 A recent
Sahara Force India Formula 1
shareholder.55 This agreement was The managing director of Diageo study in the Indian state of Goa
racing car,69 which is likely to
finalized on July 2, 2014. In Dia- India, Abanti Sankaranarayanan, found a threefold increase in re-
increase exposure of its brands
geo’s annual report, the chief exec- acknowledges the unique regula- ported alcohol consumption during
among young fans.
utive, Ivan Menezes, stated, tory alcohol environment, but ex- adolescence among males born in
In addition to the younger gen-
plains that Diageo is “harnessing the early 1980s compared with
By acquiring an additional 26% of erations, an increasing proportion of
United Spirits Limited (USL) on 2 the opportunity that India has.”58 those born in the late 1950s.60
Indian women are consuming alco-
July 2014, taking our shareholding A growing body of global re-
hol.70 In a media interview, Somaya
to a majority holding of 54.78%, INDIA’S DEMOGRAPHIC search shows that the alcohol in-
we have taken a leadership posi- noted that the rising alcohol con-
tion in India which will provide AND SOCIOECONOMIC dustry uses strategic alcohol
sumption among women provides
a transformational platform for FACTORS marketing and packaging to attract
Diageo with growth opportunities
growth in this very attractive spirits new, young consumers,24,61---63 and
market. We will consolidate USL and said,
from the start of fiscal 2015, and India has many characteristics Diageo is no exception.18,64 In
with our combined strength, the that are appealing to multinational 2006, USL introduced the sale of That is a target segment we need
Indian market will become one of alcohol corporations such as alcohol in small sachets, or “tetra- to keep in mind and ensure that
Diageo’s largest markets next year our brands get more bilingual
and a major contributor to our Diageo. Accounting for 17% of paks,” which rapidly became pop- and speak to both sets of audi-
growth ambitions.20(p15) the world’s population, India is the ular.65 Following on the success of ences, not just be male-centric.71

2222 | Alcohol Marketing | Peer Reviewed | Esser and Jernigan American Journal of Public Health | November 2015, Vol 105, No. 11
GOVERNMENT, LAW, AND PUBLIC HEALTH PRACTICE

Diageo’s Programs to Address


TABLE 1—Diageo’s Investments in United Spirits Limited (USL): India, May 2013–June 2014 Alcohol Misuse
Cost An analysis of Diageo’s pro-
grams developed to reduce alco-
% of Shares No. of Shares Price per Share Billions of Approximate Equivalent
Date of Finalized Transaction in USL (Millions) (Indian Rupees) Indian Rupees in US $ hol misuse corroborates the exist-
ing evidence from Africa, Latin
May 13 and 27, 2013 10.04 14.59 1440 21.0 344.5 million America, and the United Kingdom,
July 4, 2013 14.98 21.77 1440 31.3 513.7 million demonstrating that industry-
November 26, 2013 1.35 1.97 2400 4.7 77.2 million funded organizations and research
January 31, 2014 2.41 3.50 2474 8.7 142.7 million undermine public health.16,78,80--82,87
Total at close of 2014 fiscal 28.78 41.83 65.7 1.1 billion Diageo’s programs fall into cate-
year (June 30, 2014) gories such as preventing exces-
Source. Diageo 2014 Annual Report.20(p102) sive drinking and reducing drink
driving, although components of
these programs seem to be at odds
with leading public health recom-
mendations (Table 2). Diageo’s
With the maturation of many DIAGEO’S Alcohol Strategy and the UN’s
NCD framework, and seek to Web site indicates
developed markets, global alco- “RESPONSIBILITY work with member states and that its approach to preventing
hol companies have shifted their STRATEGY” other stakeholders to achieve
these goals.77 excessive drinking
efforts to countries with growing
economies, where people have The alcohol industry, including ranges from funding advertising
However, in general, alcohol
increasing amounts of disposable Diageo, has in recent years created campaigns that raise awareness
industry responsibility efforts have of the risks of binge drinking, to
income.24,72 India is one of the social aspects and public relations
often focused on less effective in- supporting the medical profes-
BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, organizations and “responsibility” sion in identifying and helping
terventions to reduce harmful
China, and South Africa), programs, as they seek to build part- problem drinkers.85
drinking, shifting the focus from
a group of countries with rapidly nerships with government leaders
more solidly evidence-based public The most effective public health
growing economies. The alcohol and public health professionals—and
health approaches.75,78---82 Even policies for reducing excessive
industry recognizes the high increase their political clout.75,76
the familiar “drink responsibly” drinking1,24,88 are entirely missing
profit potential in these emerg- Diageo states that it supports public
messages funded by the alcohol from its program description.
ing markets. 24,73 In a 2014 health initiatives being undertaken
industry have been found to be Diageo’s description of its pro-
media interview, Diageo Chief by the World Health Organization
ambiguous and can serve to pro- grams to prevent excessive drink-
Executive Menezes said that In- (WHO) and the United Nations to
mote corporate interests.83,84 ing emphasizes individual-level
dia’s middle class is expected to reduce harmful drinking; on its Web
Diageo has funded 16 social interventions.85 By contrast, there
consume 42% of the total alco- site it declares,
aspect organizations in 15 different is strong consensus among public
hol consumed by 2015 and
In May 2013, the UN adopted countries,77 has developed more health researchers about the ef-
60% by 2025, making an at- a Global Monitoring Framework than 370 programs in at least 50 fectiveness of population-level
tractive market for Diageo in with a target of reducing mortal-
countries, and claims that these are strategies, such as raising the price
India. 74 Diageo’s 2014 annual ity from NCDs, including heart
disease, cancer, chronic respira- designed to address alcohol mis- of alcohol by increasing alcohol
report summarizes its vision for tory disease and diabetes, by use.85 In searching Diageo20,77,86 taxes,25,89,90 decreasing availabil-
growth in Asia: 25% by 2025, with many asso-
ciated targets, including reducing and broader alcohol industry sour- ity by regulating alcohol outlet
Our strategy focuses on the harmful alcohol consumption by ces,21---23 we found limited detailed density and reducing days and
highest growth categories and 10%. Diageo shares this goal: information on Diageo programs; hours of alcohol sales,27,28,91 and
consumer opportunities, driving every responsible drinking pro-
continued development of super gramme we support, every part- however, closer examination of the reducing exposure to alcohol
and ultra premium scotch, and nership we forge, and every information that is available on marketing.24,30,88 Developing
leveraging the emerging middle campaign we run is in service of these programs raises serious ques- countries are more vulnerable to
class opportunity through a com- this. We support the balanced
bination of organic growth and and pragmatic approach tions about their purpose and ef- accepting alcohol industry offers
selective acquisitions.20(p38) addressed by the WHO Global fectiveness. to partner in tackling harmful

November 2015, Vol 105, No. 11 | American Journal of Public Health Esser and Jernigan | Peer Reviewed | Alcohol Marketing | 2223
GOVERNMENT, LAW, AND PUBLIC HEALTH PRACTICE

TABLE 2—Differences Between Diageo’s Programs in India and Public Health Recommendations

Components of Selected Diageo Programs Public Health Recommendations1,24,88

“Preventing excessive drinking: This ranges from funding Implement environmental strategies that:
advertising campaigns that raise awareness of the risks of Increase the price of alcohol25,89,90;
binge drinking, to supporting the medical profession Reduce alcohol’s availability27,28,91;
85
in identifying and helping problem drinkers.” Reduce exposure to alcohol marketing.24,30,88
“Tackling drink driving: We support many initiatives with public Implement:
and private partners to reduce drink driving through education A national drink-driving law that includes a maximum
initiatives, free rides and enforcement campaigns.”85 legal blood alcohol concentration limit (e.g., 0.05 g/dL or lower);
Sobriety checkpoints and random breath testing.29,40,92,93
“DRINKiQ: Diageo also promotes responsible drinking through the Evaluate programs for effectiveness before widely implementing them
DRINKiQ website and courses. Available in nine languages, with 22 and implement programs based on evidence of effectiveness.94,95
specific country pages, DRINKiQ.com aims to raise the ‘collective (No evaluations of DRINKiQ’s effectiveness were found in a comprehensive
drink IQ’ by increasing public awareness of the effects of alcohol. Courses search of the literature.)
aim to broaden understanding of alcohol issues and share tips for responsible Modify the alcohol environment through population-level interventions
drinking. More than 15,000 people have trained with DRINKiQ, including (as described in the first category of this column: “Implement environmental
hospitality industry trainers, students, traffic police, bus drivers, members strategies”) because education-based approaches have been found to be
of the lifestyle media and professional sports clubs.”85 less effective at changing drinking behaviors.24

alcohol consumption, as they gen- In an online news article, Managing Moreover, there is no evidence alcohol concentration above In-
erally have weak enforcement of Director Sankaranarayanan de- indicating that the distribution of dia’s legal limit of 0.03 grams per
alcohol control policies.72,96 This scribed the project in India as breath alcohol analyzers will re- deciliter.29,40,92,93
is problematic because Diageo’s including duce drink driving in a country Diageo also globally promotes
focus on individual-level behavior such as India, where there is a high its online responsible-drinking
training and capacity building of
change distracts from the imple- level of perception that corruption program titled DRINKiQ, although
enforcement agencies like the
mentation of effective public traffic police, distribution of high exists in the public sector and that the extent to which it is promoted
health policies that modify the quality breath alcohol analyzers, most of the population engages in India is unknown. As described
training drivers of commercial
alcohol environment to reduce in bribery.102 Furthermore, on its Web site, DRINKiQ “aims to
vehicles and creating awareness
harmful drinking.72 Partnering among university students.98 awareness-raising initiatives will raise the ‘collective drink IQ’ by
with leaders in developing coun- most likely be ineffective in reduc- increasing public awareness of the
tries provides Diageo with oppor- On the basis of Diageo’s de- ing drink driving unless they meet effects of alcohol” (Table 2).85
tunities to make its brands known scriptions of its drink-driving pro- several criteria (e.g., adequate au- Programs funded by the alcohol
in societies and to promote less grams,85,98 it appears that the dience exposure, implemented in industry, such as DRINKiQ, are
effective alcohol control policies programs include strategies with addition to other prevention inter- not typically evaluated.18 We
before stronger policies can be less evidence of effectiveness for ventions)26; necessary information sought information on DRINKiQ’s
implemented.96 reducing drink driving and fail to is not available to critically evaluate effectiveness by searching for
Another Diageo initiative is the include evidence-based effective Diageo’s campaigns. Diageo’s “DRINKiQ” or “Diageo” in 9 da-
implementation of drink-driving interventions (Table 2); another drink-driving programs do not tabases, including the alcohol
prevention programs in developing study that reviewed 408 alcohol seem to promote the public health industry’s own research database
countries,85 including the recent industry initiatives from around prevention strategies that have (www.drinksresearch.org), but we
launch of a 30-city program in the world reached similar conclu- strong evidence of effectiveness, were unable to find evaluative
India.97 Diageo’s Web site indicates sions.99 Studies have found limited such as countrywide sobriety studies. In public health practice, it
that its drink-driving programs in- evidence of effectiveness regarding checkpoints and random breath is recommended that programs
clude “education initiatives, free educational initiatives and testing that can result in penalties first be evaluated for effectiveness,
rides, and enforcement campaigns.”85 designated-driver programs.24,100,101 for those found to have a blood and receive wide implementation

2224 | Alcohol Marketing | Peer Reviewed | Esser and Jernigan American Journal of Public Health | November 2015, Vol 105, No. 11
GOVERNMENT, LAW, AND PUBLIC HEALTH PRACTICE

only if there is evidence of leading the public health agenda 21205 (e-mail: messer1@jhu.edu). Reprints southern India but high in alcohol venues:
can be ordered at http://www.ajph.org by results from 2 probability surveys. J
effectiveness.94,95 around the world.
clicking the “Reprints” link. Acquir Immune Defic Syndr. 2007;46
First, as others have advo- This article was accepted July 2, 2015. (4):491---497.
Plan W cated,75,78 researchers should 8. Silverman JG, Raj A, Cheng DM, et al.
Given Diageo’s stated hope of monitor and document the alcohol Contributors Sex trafficking and initiation-related vio-
lence, alcohol use, and HIV risk among
promoting greater alcohol con- industry’s efforts to involve itself M. B. Esser conceptualized the study,
monitored online media articles, and HIV-infected female sex workers in
sumption among women,71 and in public health. Cumulatively, the Mumbai, India. J Infect Dis. 2011;204
wrote the first draft of the article. D. H.
global evidence that as income research community can enhance Jernigan drafted sections of the article (suppl 5):S1229---S1234.
rises, alcohol consumption in- awareness of the conflicted nature and made substantial intellectual contri- 9. Pednekar MS, Sansone G, Gupta PC.
butions in revising and editing. Both Association of alcohol, alcohol and tobacco
creases,103 it is also of interest that of industry-funded programs and
authors take responsibility for the content with mortality: findings from a prospective
in 2012, Diageo launched Plan W, research. Second, public health in the article and approved the final cohort study in Mumbai (Bombay), India.
“a community investment pro- professionals should advocate for version for publication. Alcohol. 2012;46(2):139---146.
gramme that aims to empower health policies based on unbiased 10. Rajeswari R, Chandrasekaran V,
Acknowledgments Suhadev M, Sivasubramaniam S, Sudha
women through learning.”104 As of evidence of effectiveness and en-
M. B. Esser received funding from the G, Renu G. Factors associated with patient
March 2014, Diageo had 32 ini- courage government leaders to be and health system delays in the diagnosis
Department of Health, Behavior and So-
tiatives in a dozen markets in the wary of industry-funded initia- ciety at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg of tuberculosis in south India. Int J Tuberc
Lung Dis. 2002;6(9):789---795.
Asia Pacific region,104 and by June tives. Third, the WHO and other School of Public Health.
11. Gajalakshmi V, Hung RJ, Mathew A,
2014, its Plan W initiatives had international organizations should
Varghese C, Brennan P, Boffetta P. Tobacco
reached more than 57 000 women endorse conflict-of-interest stan- Human Participant Protection smoking and chewing, alcohol drinking and
Protocol approval was not necessary
and 19 500 men.86 The corpo- dards for alcohol companies simi- lung cancer risk among men in southern
because the study did not involve human India. Int J Cancer. 2003;107(3):441---447.
ration implemented 2 Plan W lar to those recommended for the research participants.
12. Babu BV, Kar SK. Domestic violence
pilot programs in India in 2014, tobacco industry106 and provide
in eastern India: factors associated with
one in Bangalore and the other in capacity development training References victimization and perpetration. Public
New Delhi, to train women in to countries to guide them in 1. Global Status Report on Alcohol and Health. 2010;124(3):136---148.
Health. Geneva, Switzerland: World
technical and life skills.105 By deflecting overtures of partnership 13. Nayak MB, Patel V, Bond JC,
Health Organization; 2014. Greenfield TK. Partner alcohol use, vio-
2017, Diageo aims to “empower” with the industry, thereby de-
2. Institute for Health Metrics and lence and women’s mental health:
2 million women in the Asia creasing their vulnerability to the Evaluation. GBD arrow diagram. 2013. population-based survey in India. Br J
Pacific.105 public health threats associated Available at: http://www.healthdata.org/ Psychiatry. 2010;196(3):192---199.
data-visualization/gbd-arrow-diagram.
with industry-sponsored assis- 14. Das A, Gjerde H, Gopalan SS,
Accessed September 26, 2014. Normann PT. Alcohol, drugs, and road
PROMOTING PUBLIC tance; however, this is indisput-
3. Government of India. Census Info traffic crashes in India: a systematic review.
HEALTH ably challenging unless more re- India 2011. Available at: http://www. Traffic Inj Prev. 2012;13(6):544---553.
sources are made available. censusindia.gov.in/2011census/ 15. Benegal V. Alcohol and injuries:
censusinfodashboard/index.html.
This case study provides insight Additional research on the glob- India. In: Cherpitel C, Giesbrecht N,
Accessed September 15, 2014. Hungerford D, et al., eds. Alcohol and
into the global alcohol industry’s alization of the alcohol industry
4. TB India 2014: Annual Status Report. Injuries: Emergency Department Studies in
strategies for growth in emerging and the intersection with public New Delhi: Central TB Division, Indian an International Perspective. Geneva,
markets through the documenta- health is critical for preventing Ministry of Health and Family Welfare; Switzerland: World Health Organization;
tion of Diageo’s recent activities in a rising tide of health and social 2014. Available at: www.tbcindia.nic.in/ 2009:251---258.
pdfs/TB%20INDIA%202014.pdf. 16. Babor TF, Robaina K, Jernigan D.
India; however, it does not provide problems resulting from harmful Accessed September 18, 2014. The influence of industry actions on the
causal evidence that Diageo India’s alcohol consumption. j 5. Srinath Reddy K, Shah B, Varghese C, availability of alcoholic beverages in the
practices will lead to increases in Ramadoss A. Responding to the threat African region. Addiction. 2015;110
alcohol consumption. Nonetheless, of chronic diseases in India. Lancet. 2005; (4):561---571.
About the Authors 366(9498):1744---1749.
this case study increases awareness At the time of the study, Marissa B. Esser 17. Jahiel RI, Babor TF. Industrial epi-
and David H. Jernigan were with the De- 6. Dandona L, Dandona R, Kumar GA, demics, public health advocacy and the
of the potential discordance be- et al. Risk factors associated with HIV in a alcohol industry: lessons from other fields.
partment of Health, Behavior and Society,
tween industry practices and public Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public population-based study in Andhra Pra- Addiction. 2007;102(9):1335---1339.
health evidence and priorities, and Health, Baltimore, MD. desh state of India. Int J Epidemiol. 18. Mosher JF. Joe Camel in a bottle:
Correspondence should be sent to Marissa 2008;37(6):1274---1286. Diageo, the Smirnoff brand, and the
sheds light on ways that public
Esser, PhD, MPH, Bloomberg School of 7. Go VF, Solomon S, Srikrishnan AK, transformation of the youth alcohol mar-
health professionals can help to Public Health, Johns Hopkins University, et al. HIV rates and risk behaviors are low ket. Am J Public Health. 2012;102(1):
prevent the alcohol industry from 624 N Broadway St, 2nd Fl, Baltimore, MD in the general population of men in 56---63.

November 2015, Vol 105, No. 11 | American Journal of Public Health Esser and Jernigan | Peer Reviewed | Alcohol Marketing | 2225
GOVERNMENT, LAW, AND PUBLIC HEALTH PRACTICE

19. Just-Drinks. Aroq Ltd, 2014. Avail- 32. Room R, Janca A, Bennett LA, Available at: http://www.nimhans.kar. http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2014/04/
able at: http://www.just-drinks.com. Schmidt L, Sartorius N. WHO cross‐ nic.in/cam/html/publications.html. 15/diageo-makes-new-bid-for-
Accessed October 21, 2014. cultural applicability research on diagnosis Accessed September 15, 2014. controlling-stake-in-united-spirits-of-
20. Diageo. Diageo Annual Report and assessment of substance use disorders: 45. Chakrabarti A, Rai TK, Sharma B, india/?_php=true&_type=blogs&_r=0.
2014. 2014. Available at: http://www. an overview of methods and selected re- Rai BB. Culturally prevalent unrecorded Accessed September 11, 2014.
diageo.com/en-row/newsmedia/Pages/ sults. Addiction. 1996;91(2):199---220. alcohol consumption in Sikkim, North East 56. Badrinath R, Madonna A. Diageo
reports.aspx. Accessed September 11, 33. Saxena S. Country profile on alcohol India: cross-sectional situation assessment. aims for 10% revenue from India. Busi-
2014. in India. In: Riley L, Marshall M, eds. J Subst Use. 2015;20(3):162---167. ness Standard. 2014. Available at: http://
21. International Center for Alcohol Alcohol and Public Health in 8 Developing 46. International Guide for Monitoring www.business-standard.com/article/
Policies (ICAP). Welcome to ICAP. 2014. Countries. Geneva, Switzerland: World Alcohol Consumption and Related Harm. companies/diageo-aims-for-10-revenue-
Available at: http://www.icap.org. Health Organization; 1999:37---60. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Or- from-india-114032400997_1.html.
ganization; 2000. Accessed September 15, 2014.
Accessed October 14, 2014. 34. Desai N, Nawamongkolwattana B,
Ranaweera S, Man Shrestha D, Sobhan 47. Rehm J, Kailasapillai S, Larsen E, et al. 57. Why Indian alcohol market is not in
22. International Center for Alcohol
MA. Get High on Life Without Alcohol. A systematic review of the epidemiology of high spirits. Business World. 2015. Avail-
Policies. Beer, wine and spirits producers’
New Delhi, India: World Health Organi- unrecorded alcohol consumption and the able at: http://cdn.bwbusinessworld.com/
commitments to reduce harmful drinking.
zation; 2003. chemical composition of unrecorded alco- co-report/why-indian-alcohol-market-not-
2014. Available at: http://www.
hol. Addiction. 2014;109(6):880---893. high-spirits#sthash.zWUB6HkU.dpbs.
producerscommitments.org/default.aspx. 35. Saldanha IM. On drinking and
Accessed July 14, 2015.
Accessed May 19, 2015. “drunkenness”: history of liquor in co- 48. Impact Databank. The Global Drinks
lonial India. Econ Polit Wkly. 1995;30 Market: Impact Databank Review and 58. Agarwal S. About 40% of our luxury
23. International Center for Alcohol Pol-
(37):2323---2331. Forecast, 2011 Edition. New York, NY: M. growth comes from non-metros: Diageo
icies. Global actions on harmful drinking:
Shanken Communications; 2012. India MD. Live Mint. 2014. Available at:
India. 2014. Available at: http://www. 36. Reddy DN, Patnaik A. Anti-arrack
http://www.livemint.com/Companies/
global-actions.org/Countries/India/ agitation of women in Andhra Pradesh. 49. Mitra S. Indians High on Imported
DWjkzNvk3pN9jix11JY36N/About-40-
Overview/tabid/346/Default.aspx. Econ Polit Wkly. 1993;28(21):1059--- Spirits. New Delhi, India: Business Stan-
of-our-luxury-growth-comes-from-nonmetros-
Accessed October 14, 2014. 1066. dard; 2014. Available at: http://www.
Diageo.html. Accessed June 9, 2015.
24. Babor TF, Caetano R, Casswell S, et al. 37. Blocker JS, Fahey DM, Tyrrell IR. business-standard.com/article/companies/
indians-high-on-imported-spirits- 59. Prasad R. Alcohol use on the rise in
Alcohol: No Ordinary Commodity. 2nd ed. New Alcohol and Temperance in Modern His-
114081300885_1.html. Accessed Sep- India. Lancet. 2009;373(9657):17---18.
York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2010. tory: A Global Encyclopedia. Santa Bar-
bara, CA: ABC-CLIO Inc; 2003. tember 15, 2014. 60. Pillai A, Nayak M, Greenfield T,
25. Elder RW, Lawrence B, Ferguson A,
50. Diageo. Spirits. 2014. Available at: Bond JC, Hasin DS, Patel V. Adolescent
et al. The effectiveness of tax policy in- 38. Constitution of India: Seventh Schedule.
http://www.diageo.com/en-row/ourbrands/ drinking onset and its adult consequences
terventions for reducing excessive alcohol New Delhi: Government of India; 1996.
categories/spirits/Pages/default.aspx. among men: a population based study
consumption and related harms. Am J 39. Alcohol Marketing and Regulatory Accessed September 11, 2014. from India. J Epidemiol Community Health.
Prev Med. 2010;38(2):217---229. Policy Environment in India. New Delhi, 2014;68(10):922---927.
26. Elder RW, Shults RA, Sleet DA, et al. India: Public Health Foundation of India; 51. Hopkins A. USL takeover gives Dia-
geo “unassailable” position. The Spirits 61. Hastings G. “They’ll Drink Bucket
Effectiveness of mass media campaigns 2013.
Business, 2014. Available at: http://www. Loads of the Stuff”: An Analysis of Internal
for reducing drinking and driving and 40. Global Status Report on Road Safety, thespiritsbusiness.com/2014/06/usl- Alcohol Industry Advertising Documents.
alcohol-involved crashes: a systematic re- 2013: Supporting a Decade of Action. takeover-gives-diageo-unassailable- Stirling, UK: Alcohol Education and Re-
view. Am J Prev Med. 2004;27(1):57---65. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Or- position. Accessed September 11, 2014. search Council; 2009.
27. Hahn RA, Kuzara JL, Elder R, et al. ganization; 2013.
52. US Securities and Exchange Commis- 62. Ross C, Ostroff J, Jernigan D. Evidence
Effectiveness of policies restricting hours 41. Rahman L. Alcohol Prohibition and sion. SEC charges liquor giant Diageo with of underage targeting of alcohol advertising
of alcohol sales in preventing excessive Addictive Consumption in India. London, FCPA violations. 2011. Available at: http:// on television in the United States: lessons
alcohol consumption and related harms. UK: London School of Economics; 2003. www.sec.gov/news/press/2011/2011- from the Lockyer v. Reynolds decisions.
Am J Prev Med. 2010;39(6):590---604.
42. India’s Kerala state dilutes alcohol 158.htm. Accessed September 19, 2014. J Public Health Policy. 2014;35(1):105---118.
28. Middleton JC, Hahn RA, Kuzara JL, ban. BBC News. 2014. Available at: 53. Wehring O. INDIA/UK: Diageo 63. Ross CS, Ostroff J, Siegel MB, DeJong
et al. Effectiveness of policies maintaining or http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia- takes control of United Spirits with further W, Naimi TS, Jernigan DH. Youth alcohol
restricting days of alcohol sales on excessive india-30544717. Accessed January 9, stake buy. Aroq Ltd. 2013. Available at: brand consumption and exposure to
alcohol consumption and related harms. 2015. http://www.just-drinks.com/news/ brand advertising in magazines. J Stud
Am J Prev Med. 2010;39(6):575---589.
43. Subramanian SV, Nandy S, Irving M, diageo-takes-control-of-united-spirits- Alcohol Drugs. 2014;75(4):615---622.
29. Shults RA, Elder RW, Sleet DA, et al. Gordon D, Davey Smith G. Role of so- with-further-stake-buy_id110806.aspx. 64. Nicholls J. Everyday, everywhere:
Reviews of evidence regarding interven- cioeconomic markers and state prohibi- Accessed September 11, 2014. alcohol marketing and social media—
tions to reduce alcohol-impaired driving. tion policy in predicting alcohol con- current trends. Alcohol Alcohol. 2012;47
54. Madonna A. Diageo charts roll-out
Am J Prev Med. 2001;21(4 suppl):66---88. sumption among men and women in (4):486---493.
plans with United Spirits. Business Stan-
30. Anderson P, de Bruijn A, Angus K, India: a multilevel statistical analysis. Bull dard. 2013. Available at: http://www. 65. Dalal M. Tetra Pak emerging as
Gordon R, Hastings G. Impact of alcohol World Health Organ. 2005;83(11): business-standard.com/article/ preferred packing for alcohol in Karna-
advertising and media exposure on ado- 829---836. companies/diageo-charts-roll-out-plans- taka. Live Mint. 2013. Available at:
lescent alcohol use: a systematic review of 44. Benegal V, Gururaj G, Murthy P. with-united-spirits-113092400857_1. http://www.livemint.com/Industry/
longitudinal studies. Alcohol Alcohol. WHO Collaborative Project on Unrecorded html. Accessed September 15, 2014. D2HAiol3V8A57JoquKUzwJ/Tetra-Pak-
2009;44(3):229---243. Consumption of Alcohol: Karnataka, India. 55. Bray C. Diageo makes new bid for emerging-as-preferred-packing-for-
31. Benegal V. India: alcohol and public Bangalore, India: National Institute of controlling stake in United Spirits of India. alcohol-in-Karna.html. Accessed October
health. Addiction. 2005;100(8):1051-- 1056. Mental Health and Neuro Sciences; 2003. New York Times. 2014. Available at: 14, 2014.

2226 | Alcohol Marketing | Peer Reviewed | Esser and Jernigan American Journal of Public Health | November 2015, Vol 105, No. 11
GOVERNMENT, LAW, AND PUBLIC HEALTH PRACTICE

66. Dhamija A, Sarkar J. Now, booze research and policy. Alcohol industry 88. Anderson P, Chisholm D, Fuhr DC. 99. Babor TF, Robaina K. Public health,
comes in affordable packs. Times of India. use of social aspect public relations orga- Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of academic medicine, and the alcohol
2013. Available at: http://timesofindia. nizations against preventative health policies and programmes to reduce the industry’s corporate social responsibility
indiatimes.com/business/india-business/ measures. Addiction. 2011;106(9): harm caused by alcohol. Lancet. activities. Am J Public Health. 2013;103
Now-booze-comes-in-affordable-packs/ 1560---1567. 2009;373(9682):2234---2246. (2):206---214.
articleshow/27324427.cms. Accessed 77. Diageo. Alcohol policy. 2014. 89. Wagenaar AC, Salois MJ, Komro KA. 100. Rivara FP, Relyea-Chew A, Wang J,
September 15, 2014. Available at: http://www.diageo.com/en- Effects of beverage alcohol price and tax Riley S, Boisvert D, Gomez T. Drinking
67. Mwele JK. Perceived impact of row/csr/alcoholinsociety/Pages/alcohol- levels on drinking: a meta-analysis of behaviors in young adults: the potential
packaging on alcohol consumption: a case policy.aspx. Accessed September 11, 2014. 1003 estimates from 112 studies. Ad- role of designated driver and safe ride
of the University of Nairobi students. 78. Jernigan DH. Global alcohol pro- diction. 2009;104(2):179---190. home programs. Inj Prev. 2007;13
University of Nairobi. 2009. Available at: ducers, science, and policy: the case of the (3):168---172.
90. Wagenaar AC, Tobler AL, Komro
http://erepository.uonbi.ac.ke/handle/ International Center for Alcohol Policies. KA. Effects of alcohol tax and price policies 101. Ditter SM, Elder RW, Shults RA,
11295/13267. Accessed October 21, Am J Public Health. 2012;102(1):80---89. on morbidity and mortality: a systematic et al. Effectiveness of designated driver
2014. review. Am J Public Health. 2010;100 programs for reducing alcohol-impaired
79. Caetano R. About smoke and mir-
68. Dhamija A. Diageo breezes into RTD rors: the alcohol industry and the pro- (11):2270---2278. driving: a systematic review. Am J Prev
battle. Times of India. 2014. Available at: motion of science. Addiction. 2008;103 Med. 2005;28(5 suppl):280---287.
91. Babor TF, Caetano R. Evidence-
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/ (2):175---178. based alcohol policy in the Americas: 102. Transparency International. Cor-
Business/India-Business/Diageo-breezes- strengths, weaknesses, and future chal- ruption perceptions index 2013. Avail-
80. Babor TF. Alcohol research and the
into-RTD-battle/articleshow/44904642. lenges. Rev Panam Salud Publica. able at: http://cpi.transparency.org/
alcoholic beverage industry: issues, con-
cms. Accessed October 23, 2014. 2005;18(4---5):327---337. cpi2013/results. Accessed December 22,
cerns and conflicts of interest. Addiction.
69. Wehring O. INDIA: Smirnoff joins 2009;104(suppl 1):34---47. 2013.
92. Peden M, Scurfield R, Sleet D, et al.,
Johnnie Walker on Diageo’s Formula One eds. World Report on Road Traffic Injury 103. Room R, Jernigan D, Carlini Cotrim
81. McCambridge J, Hawkins B, Holden
podium. Aroq Ltd. 2014. Available at: Prevention. Geneva, Switzerland: World B, et al. Alcohol in Developing Societies: A
C. Industry use of evidence to influence
http://www.just-drinks.com/news/ Health Organization; 2004. Public Health Approach. Helsinki, Finland:
alcohol policy: a case study of submissions
smirnoff-joins-johnnie-walker-on-diageos- Finnish Foundation for Alcohol Studies
to the 2008 Scottish government consul- 93. Elder RW, Shults RA, Sleet DA,
formula-one-podium_id113573.aspx. and World Health Organization; 2002.
tation. PLoS Med. 2013;10(4):e1001431. Nichols JL, Zaza S, Thompson RS. Effec-
Accessed September 15, 2014.
82. Hawkins B, McCambridge J. Industry tiveness of sobriety checkpoints for re- 104. Diageo. Diageo empowers 40,000
70. Benegal V, Nayak M, Murthy P, ducing alcohol-involved crashes. Traffic women under Asia Pacific Plan W Pro-
actors, think tanks, and alcohol policy in
Chandra P, Gururaj G. Women and Inj Prev. 2002;3(4):266---274. gramme. 2014. Available at: http://www.
the United Kingdom. Am J Public Health.
alcohol in India. In: Obot IS, Room R, diageo.com/en-row/newsmedia/Pages/
2014;104(8):1363---1369. 94. Glasgow RE, Vogt TM, Boles SM.
eds. Alcohol, Gender and Drinking Prob- resource.aspx?resourceid=2176.
lems: Perspectives From Low and Middle 83. Smith SW, Atkin CK, Roznowski J. Evaluating the public health impact of
Accessed September 11, 2014.
Income Countries. Geneva, Switzerland: Are “drink responsibly” alcohol cam- health promotion interventions: the
RE-AIM framework. Am J Public Health. 105. Diageo. Empowering urban women
World Health Organization; 2005: paigns strategically ambiguous? Health
1999;89(9):1322---1327. in India—Plan W 2014. Available at:
89---124. Commun. 2006;20(1):1---11.
http://www.diageo.com/en-row/csr/
71. Dutta S. Sipping success. IMPACT. 84. Smith KC, Cukier S, Jernigan DH. 95. Rychetnik L, Frommer M, Hawe P,
casestudies/Pages/empowering-urban-
2014. Available at: http://www. Defining strategies for promoting product Shiell A. Criteria for evaluating evidence
women-in-india-plan-w.aspx. Accessed
impactonnet.com/Sipping-success. through “drink responsibly” messages in on public health interventions. J Epidemiol
September 11, 2014.
Accessed September 15, 2014. magazine ads for beer, spirits and alco- Community Health. 2002;56(2):119---127.
106. World Health Organization. Guide-
pops. Drug Alcohol Depend. 2014;142: 96. Casswell S. Vested interests in ad-
72. Caetano R, Laranjeira R. A “perfect lines for implementation of Article 5.3 of
168---173. diction research and policy. Why do we
storm” in developing countries: economic the WHO Framework Convention on
growth and the alcohol industry. Addiction. 85. Diageo. Programmes to address al- not see the corporate interests of the Tobacco Control. 2008. Available at:
2006;101(2):149---152. cohol misuse. 2014. Available at: http:// alcohol industry as clearly as we see those www.WHO.int/fctc/guidelines/article_
www.diageo.com/en-row/csr/ of the tobacco industry? Addiction. 5_3.pdf. Accessed June 15, 2015.
73. Jernigan DH. The global alcohol 2013;108(4):680---685.
alcoholinsociety/Pages/programmes-to-
industry: an overview. Addiction. 2009;104
address-alcohol-misuse.aspx. Accessed 97. TNN. Karisma Kapoor launched
(suppl 1):6---12.
September 11, 2014. Diageo Road to Safety campaign in
74. Dhamija A, Kurian B. New middle Mumbai. Times of India. 2014. Available
86. Diageo. Sustainability & responsibil-
class will form 60% of business: Diageo at: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/
ity performance addendum 2014. 2014.
CEO. Times of India. 2014. Available at: entertainment/events/mumbai/Karisma-
Available at: http://www.diageo.com/en-
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/ row/NewsMedia/Pages/resource.aspx? Kapoor-launched-Diageo-Road-to-Safety-
Business/India-Business/New-middle- resourceid=2316. Accessed September campaign-in-Mumbai/articleshow/
class-will-form-60-of-business-Diageo-CEO/ 11, 2014. 44772700.cms. Accessed October 14, 2014.
articleshow/40862744.cms. Accessed
September 15, 2014. 87. Truen S, Ramkolowan Y, Corrigall J, 98. ET Bureau. Diageo launches road
Matzopoulos R. Baseline study of the safety programme in India. Economic
75. Anderson P. The beverage alcohol liquor industry: including the impact of Times. 2014. Available at: http://articles.
industry’s social aspects organizations: the National Liquor Act 59 of 2003. DNA economictimes.indiatimes.com/2014-09-
a public health warning. Addiction. Economics. 2011. Available at: http:// 01/news/53441986_1_traffic-police-
2004;99(11):1376---1377. www.thedti.gov.za/business_regulation/ international-road-federation-road-safety-
76. Miller PG, de Groot F, McKenzie S, docs/nla/other_pdfs/dna_economics_ programme. Accessed September 15,
Droste N. Vested interests in addiction nla_act.pdf. Accessed June 8, 2015. 2014.

November 2015, Vol 105, No. 11 | American Journal of Public Health Esser and Jernigan | Peer Reviewed | Alcohol Marketing | 2227

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi