Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 17

02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills


  


Home » Coaching Movements and Skills with Nick Winkelman

There are two parts to great coaching.

The first is possessing the right knowledge—what techniques to use, what exercises to
use, what drills to use and what methods to use.

The other part, which is often overlooked, is the ability to communicate and help
people apply the information in real situations.

You may know the right exercise to use, but unless you can get people to perform the
exercise correctly, they won’t be able to get the results you expect.

This is why the art and science of coaching is so important.

Questions or Comments?

Nick Winkelman is the head of athletic performance and science for the Irish Rugby
Football Union, and was formerly the Director of Training Systems and Education for
EXOS. He’s an expert when it comes to coaching, having worked with elite athletes
from many different sports over the years. He has worked with NFL athletes, rugby
players, tactical athletes, firefighters, baseball players and more.

The following article from Nick on the science of coaching will help you teach your
clients how to pick up new skills quickly. You’ll be able to help them get more out of
their training sessions, reduce frustration when practicing new skills and increase their
trust in your coaching abilities.

https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 1/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

You’ll learn a three-part framework for coaching, and how to optimize each
component—the environment, the instructions and the feedback—for maximum skill
learning and retention.

If you already have a lot of head knowledge and want to improve the results you get
simply from changing the words you use to deliver that information, you’ll find this
article very useful.



[Nick Winkelman] I’m going to show you a framework for coaching that will help your
athletes learn new skills faster, and help them transfer those new skills onto the field of

Even if you work with the general population, this framework will help you
communicate more effectively with your clients, and help them learn new
movements much more quickly.

The Theory: A Framework for Coaching

Questions or Comments?

If you look at the framework for coaching, at the bottom is the learning environment.
Independent of what you say to your athlete or client, you can design a specific
environment that optimizes learning.
https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 2/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

Changing a person’s environment can immediately start to have an impact, not only
on how an athlete practices, but also how that information is retained and, more
importantly, transferred to the field.

Would you like to receive an email when we publish new articles?

email address

Send it!

While practice is important, what you really want is for it to transfer into real situations.

From there, you want to start looking at instruction. How do you actually teach an
athlete to move? How do you give instructions to a novice, an intermediate or a highly
expert athlete? How can you optimize it just from that first exposure?

Finally, once an athlete or client moves, how can you give appropriate feedback to
refine that motor system? Are there certain bits of information that are going to help
them, or certain bits of information that can hinder them?

You want to know the information that’s going to optimize learning, and immediately
start retracting any statements that could be negative to learning.

Let’s look at each three of these components in greater detail.

1. Optimizing the learning environment

When you look at practice design and the learning environment, the first thing you
want to attain is the goal. The goal is to optimize learning and retention in an effort to
reach maximum transfer to the sporting environment.
Questions or Comments?

It’s all about how that practice transfers to the environment. Just because someone is
practicing well does not mean the information they’re learning is going to transfer to
the environment of sport or play.

Setting up practice to optimize transfer

There are two factors that influence how practice transfers to actual game situations:
practice variability and contextual interference.

Practice variability is the variety of movement and context characteristics that a

person experiences while practicing a skill.

https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 3/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

With practice variability, our goal initially is to create context.

You want people to understand why they’re doing what they’re doing. This empowers
them to make those changes by themselves. This way when they make an error, they
can look back at it and tell you what they did wrong.

On the next repetition, you don’t even need to give them information. They’ll
understand how to make the fix. This is context. The higher the level of context our
athletes have, the better it tells us how expert they are.

The goal of contextual interference is to interfere with an athlete or client’s context—

their understanding of how to do the movement, how to correct it, when they’re doing
it right or when they’re doing it wrong.

You’re probably thinking, “Why would you want to interfere with context? Why would
you want to interfere with your athletes’ understanding of what they’re doing right or
what they’re doing wrong?”

Essentially, if you do the same movement over and over again within the same
session, it almost becomes automatic. You know the predictability of the pattern
because you’re doing it over and over again. Your focus on that movement isn’t high.
When your focus on the movement isn’t high, you tend not to learn as well.

If we interfere by giving you more movements, more variations and even randomizing
the order of different movements, your cognitive system undergoes greater overload.

You can’t get complacent. You can’t predict or anticipate what’s going to happen
next. Your body constantly has to be prepared to react. Your cognitive system ends up
experiencing a greater load.
Questions or Comments?

Just like the body, when you overload a certain area of the system, the system will
adapt by learning and being able to deal with these higher interference factors.

Think about a time when you’ve driven home. You’ve driven home thousands of times
on the same road. I’m sure there have been times where you didn’t even realize how
you got home.

You covered that 30 minutes, but in your mind you’ve been going through what you
did that day, what you’re going to do that night, and what you’re going to do
tomorrow because your body has the auto-pilot, this autonomy.

https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 4/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

Essentially, this same thing can happen in practice when it’s a blocked practice. Your
body just knows what’s going to happen. Thus, you do it over and over again. The
learning effect isn’t as high.

This is why if we interfere with contextual interference through a random-type

practice, it has been shown to drive up learning effects in transfer skills and actually
transferring to the sport.

Yes, your athletes may make more errors with contextual interference. But you will see
higher retention rates from practice sessions, meaning your athletes will master new
skills in a shorter amount of time.

2. Optimizing instructions
Priming the motor system with proper task instruction is important whether you’re
working with athletes or the general population.

You can instruct in one of two ways—using either verbal information or visual

Visual information
With visual information you have two options. You can show someone learning the
movement for the first time, mistakes and all. Or you can show someone performing it

You should try to instruct using the latter—showing someone performing the task
perfectly, though there may actually be some benefit from observing a novice and
learning from that.
Questions or Comments?

Verbal information
With verbal instruction, you want to provide one or two focus cues to build awareness.
Within this, you want to limit unnecessary information to avoid over-coaching. The
more information we give, the more of their attentional capacity we take. The more of
their attentional capacity we take, the less attention they have to actually focus on
the movement they’re doing.

A perfect example is this: Have you ever had someone do a movement and then while
doing the movement, you say, “Great job. Keep that up.”

All of a sudden the person messes up.

https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 5/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

The reason is we’ve diverted the attention from what the person was doing and put
the attention toward you, now exposing the movement as having a dysfunction.

In all reality, the movement was fine. It was your interference or the attentional focus
that drove the movement to go haywire.

With verbal information, you can either give it an internal focus or an external focus.

Internally focused cues draw attention to muscles and body parts. For example,
extending a knee, firing a quad or squeezing a glute.

Externally focused cues, on the other hand, draw attention to the environment
around the body. For example, pushing the ground away or driving the body off the

When we cue, we want to cue with an external focus, and diminish any kind of cueing
that drives up an internal focus.

This is probably the most important concept for both instruction and feedback.

Dr. Gabriele Wulf’s work has shown that focusing someone externally improves
performance and efficiency, as opposed to focusing someone internally, which
decreases performance and decreases efficiency.

External focus also improves transfer and retention.

Every time you give information, you’re affecting the attention of the person. If you
focus the attention externally, it takes up less demand. If it takes up less attentional
demand, it allows more attentional resources toward the movement.
Questions or Comments?

This is exactly what we want.

What to always start and finish instructions with

You want to always start and finish instruction with what you want versus what you
don’t want.

If you tell people not to do something or you identify an error, there are 1,000 other
things they can do. You’re not focusing their attention.

https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 6/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

You want to tell them what we want them to do correctly. Give them one option—one
focus point. It decreases their attentional demand, allowing the focus and move to be

3. Feedback to refine learning

Feedback is given during practice to refine the motor system. You’ll still use verbal
information and external cues as previously outlined.

There are two different categories of feedback—task-intrinsic feedback and

augmented feedback.

Task-intrinsic feedback is very simple. It’s essentially the natural feedback that comes
from doing a movement. It can be visual, auditory, tactile or proprioceptively

Taking the example of people in archery. If they pull back and shoot, they can use
visual feedback to understand exactly where they hit on the target. You don’t need to
tell them they missed the bull’s eye.

Other tasks give less feedback naturally and require an additional input of
information. For example, it’s hard for sprinters to tell how much extension they have
or how much knee drive they have.

This is where augmented feedback comes in.

You can give two types of augmented feedback—knowledge of results or knowledge

of performance. Questions or Comments?

Knowledge of results is essentially information about the outcome of a skill or the

goals achieved. It’s the numbers. For example, how fast a person runs.

Knowledge of performance is information about the movement characteristics that

led to the outcome. These are more qualitative.

In the example of running a 40, knowledge of results would be that you ran the 40 in
4.56 seconds.

Knowledge of performance would be driving the knees during the first five yards.

https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 7/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

If you want to be highly external, draw a black dot on the end of the knee and say,
“Drive that black dot more during the first five yards” to drive in even more external

As athletes improve ability and have the context on how to correct themselves, we
tend to give them more knowledge of results.

How much feedback does a person need?

New coaches tend to think that more is always better. They coach every single
repetition. They’re talking the entire time because they value themselves as coaches.

But is this ideal?

Let’s look at one of the most powerful studies ever done on instruction and feedback, a
study from Dr. Gabriele Wulf done in 2002.

Fifty-two participants took part in a passing accuracy task. Feedback frequency and
internal versus external focus was examined. They had four different groups.

They had one group who received 100% feedback, and there was an internal cue. The
second group received 100% feedback, and there was an external cue. The third group
received 33% feedback, with an internal cue. Finally, the fourth group received 33%,
with an external cue.

As a whole, both in practice as well as a couple of days later in retention, an external

focus was found to be superior to internal focus. Performance, accuracy and all of the
variables improved not only in practice, but in retention as well.

They also found that 33% feedback—giving information every third repetition—was
Questions or Comments?

superior to 100% feedback for all internal focus conditions. Internal focus messes up
athletes, so giving them less of that feedback is better.

Now, here’s the interesting fact: In terms of the external focus, 33% and 100% feedback
were equally as effective. If you’re working with novice athletes or they’re learning a
novel task, you might want to communicate with them a bit more. That’s fine as long
as the feedback is externally oriented.

As a whole, though, less feedback is better than more. That 33% to 50% feedback
amount is what you see in the literature.

https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 8/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

And external is better than internal.

Identifying what feedback to give

You have to understand how the movements biomechanically and physiologically
are supposed to be performed so you can focus your attention.

You want to understand the major technical components of the movement and
understand that multiple errors will oftentimes be seen, especially when you’re looking
at running, linear and multi-directional movement.

You then want to prioritize the multiple errors.

You want to direct your feedback at the true weakest link—cause versus symptom.
This means if you see five things going wrong, four of them are probably symptoms,
but one of them is actually a cause.

The better you understand movement, the better you can understand the causes of
movement dysfunction and which are just symptoms

When giving feedback, you can give prescriptive or descriptive feedback.

Prescriptive is better for the beginner or intermediate athlete. You want to say exactly
what you want them to do right to fix the problem. Even if what they’re doing is wrong,
focus on what you want them to do. Keep it positive.

Descriptive means telling the athletes what they did wrong. If they have high levels of
autonomy and you tell them what they did wrong, high-level autonomist athletes can
handle that because they know how to fix it. They don’t need you to tell them how to fix
Questions or Comments?

A final reminder
Don’t just be proud of practice, but look at how practice and training actually transfers

to the field.

If you’re making baseball players faster, does it actually result in more stolen bases? If
you’re making golf players stronger, can they actually drive the ball farther and more
accurately when they’re on the golf course?

Look for transfer.

https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 9/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills



Nick Winkelman is the head of athletic performance & science for the Irish Rugby
Football Union. Prior to working for Irish Rugby, Nick was the director of education for
EXOS (formerly Athletes’ Performance), located in Phoenix, AZ. As a performance
coach, Nick oversaw the speed and assessment component of the EXOS NFL Combine
Development Program. Nick has also supported many athletes in the NFL, MLB, NBA,
National Sport Organizations and Military. Nick is an internationally recognized speaker
on human performance and coaching science, and has multiple publications through
the UKSCA, NSCA and IDEA Health and Fitness. The best way to connect with Nick is via
facebook or twitter .

If you liked this article and want to learn more from Nick about effective coaching,
here are a few resources you may find helpful.

Nick Winkelman: Science of Coaching—Theory


Questions or Comments?

This article was extracted from Nick’s lecture, Science of Coaching: Theory Applied. In
the complete lecture, Nick goes through other important coaching points, including:

Three different ways you can practice: which you should use with beginners, and which you
should use with highly skilled individuals.
Factoring in regulatory and non-regulatory conditions when designing practice sessions.
These affect motor skill characteristics and must be considered if you want practice to
transfer into competition.
The difference between closed and open skills, and which you should use in practice
depending on the situation
Do your athletes want to jump higher? A simple cue from one of Gabriele Wulf’s studies that
got people jumping significantly higher
Types of feedback that allow you to optimize the quality of feedback you give to people
https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 10/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

Where the current research in motor learning falls short, and what coaches need to factor in
when reading the research
A type of feedback to try with advanced athletes that can empower them and tell you more
about how they want to receive information

Click here to get Nick Winkelman’s full lecture, Science of Coaching: Theory Applied.

Gabriele Wulf: Attention and Motor Skill Learning

This is the book Nick refers to in his lecture.

In Attention and Motor Skill Learning, Gabriele Wulf looks at the the difference between
internal and external focus, and its impact on motor skill learning. She delves into the
research and draws practical applications for different groups and situations.

This is a great resource if you’re interested in the science behind teaching and
coaching a motor skill. This is a textbook and a fairly heavy read. Questions or Comments?

Click here to get Gabriele Wulf’s Attention and Motor Skill Learning on Amazon.

Want to become a better coach or trainer?

https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 11/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

In Essentials of Coaching and Training Functional Continuums, Gray Cook and Dan
John provide plenty of practical tips you can start applying immediately.

They cover—

When to correct and when to coach

Minimum standards to progress, hold or regress
The difference between an exercise continuum and a training progression
How to evaluate movement health, competency, capacity and complexity
Postures and patterns, and drills to develop both
Exercise choices for power, work capacity and metabolic load

… and much more.

You can use what you learn, together with what you learned in Nick’s commentary on
the science of coaching to get better results for your clients.

To find out more about Essentials of Coaching and Training Functional Continuums,
click here.

Tap into the Brains of Some of the World’s Leading

Performance Experts

FREE Access to the OTP Vault

Questions or Comments?

Inside the OTP Vault, you’ll find over 20 articles and videos from leading strength
coaches, trainers and physical therapists such as Dan John, Gray Cook, Michael Boyle,
Stuart McGill and Sue Falsone.

https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 12/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

Click here to get FREE access to the On Target Publications vault and receive the
latest relevant content to help you and your clients move and perform better.

coaching Nick Winkelman

Latest Favorites Featured

Dan John: Si x Decades Of Comp e t i t i o n

Dan John: W andering Weights, I ssue # 16 3

Gray Cook: Don’t Rush The Move me nt Le a rni ng Pro c e ss

Dan John: W andering Weights, I ssue # 16 2

Chuc k W ol f: I nsights Into The Foo t

Chris Hol der : Qigong For Recove ry And H e a l t h

Lorimer M osel ey: Learning From Pha nt o m Pa i n

Dan John: W andering Weights, I ssue # 16 1

Stac y Bar r ows: Foam Roller Histo ry And Pra c t i c a l U se

Gray Cook: W hat Are Progressions?

Questions or Comments?


Dan John Wandering Weights Gray Cook Functional Movement Screen FMS

strength training coaching exercise program design corrective exercise assessments

designing training programs Mark Cheng olympic lifts weightlifting mobility

personal training anatomy Sue Falsone stability kettlebell


https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 13/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

Subscribe and we'll send great artic les t o your email box. Inc lu des FREE
access to our OTP Vault of mater ial fr om ex per ts in t he f ield.

Your Name

Your Email



On Target is home to some of the leading minds in the fitness, strength & conditioning and
medical worlds. Working with them, we develop fresh continuing educational materials that
meet the needs of fitness professionals, strength coaches, physical therapists and other

  



Dan John: Six Decades of Competition


Dan John: Wandering Weights, Issue # 163

Questions or Comments?

Gray Cook: Don’t Rush the Movement Learning Process


aging functional training coaching physical therapy workout programming

functional movement screen pain and injury chiropractic FMS performance training

movement screening corrective exercise strength coaching rehabilitation personal training


https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 14/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

May we send our new articles direct to your email box? Subscription includes free access to
our OTP Vault of material from experts in the field.

Your Name

Your Email

Subs cribe !




Questions or Comments?

https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 15/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 16/17
02/01/2018 Nick Winkelman Coaching Movement Skills

https://www.otpbooks.com/coaching-movements-and-skills-with-nick-winkelman/ 17/17