Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
SPE 49069
Copyrighl 1998, Society of Petroleum Enginwrs, Inc. reflect storage and permeabilityy characteristics but does not
ThlSpayr Wss prepar~ fw preaentafim al me 1996 SPE AnmJaI ‘rech”ical Co”ferenm a“d adequately address connectivity issues. These effects, which
EWibition bald in New Orleans, Louis!ana, Z7~–Septembar 19913,
play a key role in fractured reservoirs are generally better
This paper was seTected Tor p~esentetion by an3~rcgram Commiltaa following review OT addressed by discrete feature network (DFN) models
information cmfained in sn Astract su~ by the author(s). Cwlenta of the paper, ss
presented. have not bean reviewed by the society of Pelrdeum Enginears and are subpct to (Dershowitz and LaPointe, 1995),
mrracum by the author(s). The material. as presanted, dms not necessarily reffacf any
posltl~ of t~ *WIY of Pefrc4eum Engineers, its offimrs. w mambars, Papers presented at Despite the significant simplifications made regarding the
SPE m%ings are sub@ to pubficatiw review by Editorkl Commitfws of the Smiefy of geometry of the fracture network in equivalent porous medium
Petroleum Enginaers. Siectrmic reprtiuti~, disfr~ufi~, w storage of sny parf of this Wpar
for nmerclal purposes without M written consen! of the Society of Petroleum Engineers is DP models (Figure 1) and the recent progress made in
prtibitad, Parmissicm to r~oduce in prhf ls restricfad to an abstract of not more then s00
wards: illusfratis may not h ~ied. The abstract must cwtain cwspicuous
developing powerful DFN modeling software, DP models still
acknowledgment of Mere and by *M the pa~r was presented Write Libfarian, SPE, PO, offer advantages regarding model size, speed, accuracy of
Sox 822826, Richardsm TX 75083-~8. U-. fsx 01-972-052-94S5.
multiphase flow or EOR calculations. As a result, there is a
need to link DP and DFN models to be able to take maximum
Abstract advantage of each approach.
The discrete feature network (DFN) approach offers many key This paper presents a series of techniques, which can be
advantages over conventional dual porosity (DP) approaches, used to develop DP models that more accurately reflect the
particularly when issues of connectivity dominate recovery anisotropy, heterogeneity, and most importantly, the scale-
and reservoir stimulation in fractured and heterogeneous dependent connectivity structure of fractured reservoirs. These
reservoirs. DP models have been developed for complex techniques will allow the DP approach to take advantage of
multiphase and thermal effects, and have been implemented some of the features of the DFN approach. The approach
for basin scale modeling. However, DP models address only adopted is to derive grid cell and well parameters through
the dual porosity nature of fractured reservoirs, generally DFN models.
simplifying connectivity and scale-dependent heterogeneity The first section of this paper discusses which parameters
issues which are modeled efficiently and more accurately by can be derived for DP models from DFN models and how they
the DFN approach. are derived. The second section describes different techniques
This paper describes the development of techniques to that can be used to link DP and DFN models. At the end of the
integrate DFN and DP approaches. These techniques allow the paper two examples are given based on data from the Yates
analyst to maintain many of the advantages of the DP Field, Texas.
simulator approach without losing the realism of complex
fracture system geometry and connectivity, as captured by DP Input Parameter from DFN Modeling
DFN models, Fracture System Porosity
The techniques described are currently used within a DOE The fracture system porosity $F can be directly calculated as
funded research project for linking a DFN and a DP thermal the product of the fracture intensity expressed as fracture area
simulation model for the Yates Field, Texas. The paper per unit volume (P32) and the storage aperture of the fractures
describes some of the geological and engineering aspects of (e):
the Yates Field and gives two examples how DP parameters
for the thermal simulation can be derived using DFN modeling
techniques.
Introduction where:
Reservoir simulation can be significantly more challenging for fPF = fracture system porosity
fractured reservoirs than it is for conventional elastic v~ = fracture system volume, [L3]
reservoirs. The dual porosity (DP) approach for the simulation vce// = grid cell volume, [L3]
of fractured reservoirs adds a second interacting continuum to AF = fracture area, [L2]
e = fracture storage aperture, [L]
351
2 DERSHOWITZ ET AL. SPE 49069
The primary issue in definition of fracture porosity from Fij expresses fracture flow as a vector along the fracture’s unit
fracture intensity P32 is the selection of an appropriate normal. Assuming that fractures are impermeable in a
measure for storage aperture, e. Possible measures include: direction parallel to their unit normal, Fij must be rotated into
● aperture derived from transient hydraulic response the planes of permeability
● mechanical aperture
● aperture derived from fracture permeabilityy or
transmissivity (“cubic law”)
● aperture derived from geophysical measurements (gamma
density, matrix porosity) where:
● correlations to fracture size and orientation. kti = permeability tensor
Fu = fracture tensor
Directional Fracture System Permeability ~j = Kroenecker’s delta
The permeability of the fracture system depends on the
fracture intensity, the connectivity of the fracture network and Oda’s solution has the advantage that it can be calculated
the distribution of fracture transmissivities. Approaches for without requiring flow simulations. However, it does not take
calculation of approximate measures of grid cell effective fracture size and connectivity into account, and is therefore
directional permeability include the tensor approach of Oda limited to well-connected fracture networks.
(1984), and the use of DFN simulations with a range of The use of DFN simulations to calculate permeability
orientations for a unit gradient. tensors (Figure 2) has been addressed by a number of authors,
Oda’s (1984) method begins by considering the orientation including Dershowitz, 1984; Long, 1984; Clemo and Smith,
of fractures in a grid cell, expressed as a unit normal vector n. 1997; and Doolin and Mauldon, 1995.
Integrating the fractures over all of the unit normals N, Oda For this approach the discrete fracture objects in the DFN
obtained the mass moment of inertia of fracture normals model are discretized into a finite element mesh. Constant
distributed over a unit sphere: pressure boundary conditions are defined for two opposite
faces of a box representing the DP grid cell. The steady state
N = jninjE(n) dQ flow through the box is calculated and used to derive an
% equivalent directional permeability based on Darcy’s Law.
The biggest advantage of simulation-based approaches is
where: that they not only incorporate the fracture network
N= number of fractures in fl connectivity but also directly solve the flow at the grid cell
nl, Ilj = the components of a unit normal to the scale for the respective directions that are used in the DP
fracture n simulation.
E(n) = probability density function that describes
the number of fractures whose unit vectors n Optimum Grid Cell Size
are oriented within a small solid angle dQ. The equivalent porous medium approach assumes that a
Q= entire solid angle corresponding to the representative elemental volume (REV) exists at the size equal
surface of a unit sphere to or smaller than the grid cell size used for the simulation.
While the REV scale permeability can seldom be determined
For a specific grid cell with known fracture areas, Ak, and by field tests, DFN models provide an excellent way estimate
transmissivities, Tk, obtained from the DFN model, an the scale of REV behavior, if it exists, and to optimize the grid
empirical fracture tensor can be calculated by adding the cell size for the DP simulation.
individual fractures weighted by their area and transmissivity: The most accurate way to evaluate REV sizes is to carry
out directional flow simulations for different grid cell sizes.
This approach however, can be very time consuming.
Therefore, an alternative approach that does not require the
use of flow solutions was developed (Figure 3).
352
SPE 49069 INTEGRATION OF DISCRETE FEATURE NETWORK METHODS ... 3
353
4 DERSHOWITZ ET AL. SPE 49069
In the future, more reservoir studies will use probabilistic argillaceous units was about haIf that in the cleaner doIomitic
simulation methods (Eiben et al., 1996; Lia et al., 1997). In units.
this case, multiple realizations of the continuum model are
used to honor uncertainties in the input parameters. For those Production History
studies there are two possible ways to link the models: Since 1992 the natural fracture network within the Yates Field
c draw input parameters forthe DP model from parameter has been studied in detail (Fitzsimmons et al., 1997, Wadleigh
distribution derived with the DFN model et al., 1997). It was shown that all the wells in the field receive
● sample cell parameters directly from underlying discrete matrix fluids from conduits in the extensive natural fracture
fracture network network. By focusing on the areas where the fracture network
The ongoing research project for the Yates Field will is most developed, and by lowering well completions below
eventually use all three methodologies. The following sections the fracture water-oil contact, it was possible to take
wiII discuss some geological and engineering aspects of the advantage of the natural drainage system by maximizing
Yates Field and provide two examples for Iinking the DFN withdrawals from high rate, high efficiency wells. Between
model with a THEMK dual porosity continuum model. 1992 and 1994 almost 400 wells where shut in while keeping a
stable total daily oil production rate.
Field Case - Yates Field, Texas For the existing wells it was possible to identify those
The Yates F1eld is located in Pecos and Crockett Counties of located in highly fractured areas of the reservoir based on their
West Texas, approximately 80 miles south of Midland. It was production history. In 1993 and 1994, more than 30 new short-
discovered in 1926 and had produced nearly 1.3 billion barrels radius horizontal wells were drilled for which such data was
of oil through the beginning of 1993. The recovery at that time not available (Tank et al., 1997). A discrete fracture network
was approximately 30%” of the estimated OOIP. At the end of modeling approach was used to study the spatial distribution
1992, a total of 1100 production and 57 injection wells were of fractures in the field and to optimize location and
active. orientation of new horizontal wells.
354
SPE 49069 INTEGRATION OF DISCRETE FEATURE NETWORK METHODS ... 5
Tract 17 Discrete Fracture Network Model development. The DFN approach can also be used to derive
A DFN model was generated for the current TAGS study area model conventional parameters describing permeability and
in Tract 17 based on the available geological information anisotropy.
(Figure 7). The model contains large-scale deterministic faults
located during seismic surveys, smaller scale deterministic Acknowledgements
fractures representing features located during borehole logging The research described in this paper was supported by the US
and stochastic fractures generated with a correlation to Department of Energy through BDM-O~IPER Contract
curvature and shale content. The input parameters for this G4S51728.
model are summarized in Table 1. The authors would also like to thank Gene Wadleigh, Suzie
The model was calibrated by modeling a tracer test that Thompson and Jon Snell of the Marathon Oil Company,
was conducted in Tract 17 at the beginning of 1996. The Midland, for their support.
calibrated Tract 17 DFN model was used to derive equivalent
properties for the current 11,250 cell THERM/DK grid (Figure References
8). Clemo, T. and L. Smith, 1997. A Hierarchical Model of Solute
Transport in Fractured Media. Water Resources Research, Vol
Example 1: Vertical Permeability Field 33, No 8, pp 1763-1784.
Dershowitz, W. S., 1984. Rock Joint Systems. Ph.D. thesis,
Directional grid cell permeability simulations were carried out
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA.
by dividing the DFN model region into 11,250 cells according Dershowitz, W. and P. LaPointe, 1995. Discrete Fracture Approaches
to the THERM/DK model. At the location of each cell face a for Oil and Gas Applications, Proceedings, NARMS ’94,
constant pressure boundary was defined within the DFN Northern American Rock Mechanics Symposium, Austin, TX.
model and the steady state flow through each grid cell was Balkema, Rotterdam
calculated in each of the three grid directions. The resulting Doolin, D. and M. Mauldon, 1995. Anisotropy and Heterogeneity in
flow was then used to derive equivalent porous medium Conasauga Group Rocks Near Oak Ridge Reservation,
permeabilities for each cell. Tennessee. University of Tennessee Technical Report.
As an example of the resulting permeability fields the University of Tennessee, Knoxville.
Eiben, Th., P. LaPointe and M, Jefferies 1996. Probabilistische
vertical permeabiiit y for one THERM/DK model layer is
Lagerstattensimulation - ein neuer Weg sur Beficksichtigung
shown in Figure 9. The permeability values depicted in Figure von Unsicherheiten bei der Feldesplanung, DCiMK
9 can be used directly for the respective grid cells for one Ftihjabrstagung, Celle, Germany.
realization of a probabilistic THERM/DK simulation. Fitzsimmons, T. E., E.E. Wadleigh, B.C. Curran and T.P. Kacir, 1997.
FIowing Fracture Identification For Massive Carbonates: A Real
Example 2: Equivalent Fracture System Directional Opportunity. SPE Paper 37741.
Permeability and Porosity Distributions Kazerni, H., 1969. Pressure Transient Analysis of Naturally Fractured
The range of fracture system parameters such as eqivalent Reservoirs with Uniform Fracture Distribution. SPE Paper
permeability, equivalent porosity, etc., was calculated for the 2156A. SPE, Houston.
Lia, O., H. Ornre, H. Tjelmeland, L. Holden and Th, Egeland, 1997.
11,250 grid cells. The cumulative probability density functions
Uncertainties in Reservoir Forecasts, AAPG Bulletin 81, No. 5,
for these parameters are shown in Figures 10 and 11, pp. 775-802.
respectively. Long, J., 1984, Investigation of Equivalent Porous Media
The variability shown is for one realization of the DFN Permeability in Networks of Discontinuous Fractures. Ph.D.
model, and illustrates the spatial variability of the underlying Dissertation, University of California, Berkeley.
fracture model. which in turn is a function of the variability in Oda, M,, 1984. Permeability Tensor for Discontinuous Rock Masses.
curvature. matrix porosity and shale content. Geotechnique, Vol 35, pp 483-495.
To complete the modeling process, results from multiple Tank, W. J., B.C. Curran and E.E. Wadleigh, 1997, Efficient Oil
DFN realizations are stored as probability density functions Capture and Fracture Insights. SPE Paper 37751.
Tinker, S.W., and D.H. Mrtrk, 1995. Reservoir characterization of a
for each unique model region (domain) Depending on the
Permian giant: Yates field, west Texas, in E. Stoudt and P.M.
heterogeneity of the fracture system, a domain can be the Harris, eds., Hydrocarbon reservoir characterization, geologic
whole model. a reservoir layer, a facies or as for the Yates framework and flow-unit modeling SEPM Short Course 34,
THERM/DK model only one grid cell. The modeler can then pp.51- 128.
select mean, median or random values for each domain to Wadleigh, E. E., 1996. Process for recovering hydrocarbons by
produce input for the DP model. thermally assisted gravity segregation. United States Patent
5,503,226, April 2, 1996.
Conclusions Wadleigh, E. E., C.I. Paulson and R.P. Stoltz, 1997. Deeper Com-
The development of approaches to derive parameters for DP pletions Really Lower Water-Oil Ratios! SPE Paper 37763.
continuum models from more geologically realistic DFN
models provides an opportunity to significantly advance the
state of the art in reservoir modeling, These techniques can
improve modeling of connectivity and heterogeneity, which
are frequently the key factors in successful reservoir
355
6 DERSHOWITZ ET AL. SPE 49069
● ✍✎✍✍☛
DFN 50m
4
Pout
m= Pin. Pcut
Figure 2- Equivalent Porous Medium Permeability Calculations
using DFNModels
o~
0123456
Connecting Cells
m T357m17 w
z
.
s,
.. ... .-.
.,
- ti,nm>sw
356
SPE 49069 INTEGRATION OF DISCRETE FEATURE NETWORK METHODS ... 7
Porous Medium
Number of Intersections
............— ...
AP=Pd-Pw
w i3$7f?091b
— —.
. . ....% ~~~ Figure 6- Calculating the Productivity/in jectlvity Index
I I Fraoture Transmissivity
Fractured Reservoir
$63
1357~1S ti
357
8 DERSHOWITZ ET AL. SPE 49069
*
* 2:
“25s3
a. 243
2416
●
-
●
.
358
SPE 49069 INTEGRATION OF DISCRETE FEATURE NEWORK METHODS ,.. 9
- ---------- .
..”UW. moo”l,lp .1”,,
Discrete Features Large scale deterministic faults located during seismic surveys are
modeled deterministically.
Fractures representing features located during borehole logging are
modeled by conditional simulation with correlation to curvature and
shale content.
Orientation Distributions The deterministic fault orientation is taken from the interpretation of
the seismic survey and all faults are assumed to be vertical. The
stochastic fracture strike is correlated to curvature, and the dip is
assigned using a Fisher distribution with =8.
Size Distribution Power Law distribution D= 1,81, minimum radius= 0.3048 m,
(Stochastic Fractures) truncated between 10 m and 50 m.
Intensity Intensity of stochastic fractures P32 is 0.105 to 0.21 m2/m3, depending
(Stochastic Fractures) on shale content and porosity. This corresponds to a vertical borehole
fracture intensity of 1/30 to 1/60 m.
Transmissivity Lognormal distribution, Deterministic Faults have log mean =
-4 and log std.dev. = 1, while stochastic fracture have log mean= -4.5
and log std.dev. = 1 (all units in log m2/s)
Aperture Correlated to fracture transmissivity using the cubic law, such that a =
0.01 1P33
hlodel Dimensions and Model is 2130 m x 2130 m x 350 m deep. The top and bottom
Boundary Conditions boundaries are defined by San Adres surfaces.
359