Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
10.5005/jp-journals-10035-1080
Medical Audit of Documentation of Inpatient Medical Record in a Multispecialty Hospital in India
ORIGINAL article
78
JRFHHA
(Cont’d…)
Clinical audit checklist Yes No
• Follow-up instruction
• Instruction for patient
Discharge summary contains ICD number
Discharge summary contains signature of treating physician/surgeon
MLC initiated in all cases where it should initiated
LAMA patients have given their unwillingness of treatment
Lab investigation form duly filled and entered in case sheet
ICD: International Classification of Diseases; MLC: Medicolegal case; LAMA: Leaving against medical advice
International Journal of Research Foundation of Hospital & Healthcare Administration, July-December 2017;5(2):77-83 79
Madhav M Singh et al
(Cont’d…)
Gynecology
and ENT Eye Skin
Medical obstetrics Surgical ward ward Pediatric ward Psychiatry
Clinical audit checklist ward (40) ward (40) ward (40) (40) (40) ward (40) (40) ward (40)
The hospital management respects patient Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
health information as confidential
Hospital management has developed Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
and implemented policies and procedure
to prevent the loss or misuse of patient
information. Evidence of monitoring
Patient records contain a copy of the discharge Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
summary with all mandatory elements
Discharge summary is prepared at discharge Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
by a qualified individual
Patient’s referral/transfer policy, procedure, and Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
referral forms are developed in accordance
with hospital policy on patient referral
All inpatients have an initial assessment(s) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
which includes an evaluation of physical,
psychological, social, and economic factors
and all assessment must be documented
legibly
The entries in the medical record must Yes: 32 Yes: 30 Yes: 32 Yes: 34 Yes: 32 Yes: 34 Yes: 36 Yes: 34
contain numeric date (D/M/Y) No: 8 No: 10 No: 8 No: 6 No: 8 No: 6 No: 4 No: 6
• Numeric time
• Name with stamp
• Appropriate initials of care provider
(Graph 4)
Patient care record must be maintained/kept Yes: 34 Yes: 36 Yes: 36 Yes: 34 Yes: 32 Yes: 32 Yes: 34 Yes: 34
in their individual folders (Graph 5) No: 6 No: 4 No: 4 No: 6 No: 8 No: 8 No: 6 No: 6
Alteration or correction in the medical record Yes: 32 Yes: 32 Yes: 34 Yes: 34 Yes: 32 Yes: 32 Yes: 38 Yes: 34
must remain legible by using a single line No: 8 No: 8 No: 6 No: 6 No: 8 No: 8 No: 2 No: 6
to score out the information to be corrected
(Graph 6)
Medical records must not include Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
abbreviations other than those approved,
published, and made available to all staff
All the discharge summary contains details of Yes: 34 Yes: 32 Yes: 34 Yes: 36 Yes: 32 Yes: 32 Yes: 36 Yes: 34
No: 8 No: 10 No: 8 No: 6 No: 8 No: 8 No: 4 No: 6
• Summary of diseases
• Treatment given
• Follow-up instruction
• Instruction for patients (Graph 7)
Discharge summary contains ICD number Yes: 36 Yes: 34 Yes: 34 Yes: 36 Yes: 36 Yes: 38 Yes: 32 Yes: 38
(Graph 8) No: 4 No: 16 No: 6 No: 4 No: 4 No: 2 No: 8 No: 2
Discharge summary contains signature of Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
treating physician/surgeon
MLC initiated in all cases where it should be Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
initiated
LAMA patients have given their unwillingness Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
of treatment (Graph 9) No: 2 No: 4
Lab investigation form duly filled and entered Yes: 38 Yes: 32 Yes: 36 Yes: 36 Yes: 34 Yes: 38 Yes: 34 Yes: 38
in case sheet (Graph 10) No: 2 No: 8 No: 4 No: 4 No: 6 No: 2 No: 4 No: 1
ICD: International classification of diseases; MLC: Medicolegal case; LAMA: Leaving against medical advice
80
JRFHHA
Graph 2: Updated or revised plan, as appropriate, based on the reassessment of the patient by the care providers
Graph 3: Nondocumentation of food order in medical record Graph 4: Entry in medical record for date/name/sign
International Journal of Research Foundation of Hospital & Healthcare Administration, July-December 2017;5(2):77-83 81
Madhav M Singh et al
Graph 5: Patient care record not maintained/kept in their Graph 6: Alteration or correction in the medical record
individual folders
Graph 7: Completion of discharge summary Graph 8: International Classification of Diseases number not
entered in discharge summary
Graph 9: Leaving against medical advice patients have not Graph 10: Lab investigation form duly filled and entered
given their unwillingness of treatment in case sheet
CONCLUSION
• It should be the responsibility of the discharging doctor
or ward in charge to return to the inpatient records Medical records are technically valid health records
and complete the required section on “follow-up”. This which must provide an overall correct description of each
should also be signed by the respective physician.10 patient’s details of care or contact with hospital personnel.
82
JRFHHA
Medical records form a very important and critical 4. Kediegile G, Madzimbamuto FD. Obstacles faced when
document in hospital. These records are vital for legal conducting a clinical audit in Botswana. South Afr J Anaesth
Analg 2014;20(2):127-131.
purposes and for future planning of the hospital medical
5. Maegga BT, Cox J, Malley KD. Malaria in the southern
care. All possible steps should be taken to ensure that all
highlands of Tanzania: a review of hospital records. Tanzan
hospital medical records are maintained in systemic and Health Res Bull 2005 Sep;7(3):125-132.
orderly manner. The importance of the medical records 6. Omigbodun AO. Improving standards in practice through
should also be communicated to all staff. Periodic audits medical audit. Ann Ib Postgrad Med 2004 Jun;1(2):23-26.
of the medical records will help to determine the possible 7. Poscia A, Cambieri A, Tucceri C, Ricciardi W, Volpe M. Audit
deficiency in keeping records, which can be improved as a tool to assess and promote the quality of medical records
and worked upon by the hospital. and hospital appropriateness: metodology and preliminary
results. Ig Sanita Pubbl 2015 Mar-Apr;71(2):139-156.
8. Robertson AR, Fernando B, Morrison Z, Kalra D, Sheikh A.
REFERENCES Structuring and coding in health care records: a qualitative
1. Chamisa I, Zulu BM. Setting the records straight: a prospec- analysis using diabetes as a case study. J Innov Health Inform
tive audit of the quality of case notes in a surgical department. 2015 Mar;22(2):275-283.
S Afr J Surg 2007 Aug;45(3):92, 94-95. 9. Walker RW, Viney R, Green L, Mawanswila M, Maro VP,
2. Desalu I, Olanipekun O, Agbamu P. An audit of anaesthesia Gjertsen C, Godfrey H, Smailes R, Gray WK. Trends in stroke
record keeping at the Lagos University Teaching Hospital. admissions to a Tanzanian hospital over four decades: a
Afr J Anaesth Int Care 2010 Oct;10(1):1-5. retrospective audit. Trop Med Int Health 2015 Oct;20(10):
3. Dosumo EB, Dosumo OO, Lawal FB. Quality of records 1290-1296.
keeping undergraduate dental students in Ibadan, Nigéria. 10. Weed LL. Medical records that guide and teach. N Engl
Ann Ib Postgrad Med 2012 Jun;10(1):13-17. J Med 1968 Mar;278(11):593-600.
International Journal of Research Foundation of Hospital & Healthcare Administration, July-December 2017;5(2):77-83 83