Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 10

Pathophysiology 17 (2010) 19–28

Myofascial syndrome and pain: A neurophysiological approach


Juhani V. Partanen a,∗ , Tuula A. Ojala b , Jari P.A. Arokoski c
a University and University Hospital of Helsinki, Department of Clinical Neurophysiology, Jorvi Hospital, P.O. Box 800, FIN-00029 HUS, Finland
b University Hospital of Kuopio, Department of Clinical Neurophysiology, FIN-70200 Kuopio, Finland
c University Hospital of Kuopio, Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, FIN-70200 Kuopio, Finland

Received 7 December 2008; received in revised form 26 March 2009; accepted 7 May 2009

Abstract
It has been debated whether muscle spindles have a role in myofascial pain or not. We present a number of arguments for the former
hypothesis. It was hypothesized that firing of intrafusal muscle fibres, i.e. fusimotor activity can be observed as “end plate spikes” (EPSs)
in electromyography (EMG). The EPSs may be found in local active spots of muscle, often associated with miniature end plate potentials
(MEPPs). Insertion of EMG needle electrodes into an active spot is painful, indicating nociception in the muscle spindle. Myofascial syndrome
patients have taut bands with active trigger points (TrPs) in painful muscles.
End plate activity (EPSs and MEPPs) is a significantly more common finding in TrPs of myofascial pain than in control points of the muscle,
indicating the presence of muscle spindles. However, some control sites may show EPSs of normal muscle spindles. Increased amount of
inflammatory metabolites have been observed in active TrPs.
Muscle spindle is a capsulated gel-filled container, where inflammatory and contraction metabolites may be heavily concentrated during
sustained fusimotor activation. Thus the intrafusal chemosensitive pain mediating III- and IV-afferents are sensitized and activated. Intrafusal
inflammation causes further reflex activation of the fusimotor and skeletofusimotor systems via sensitized III- and IV-afferents. The taut band
itself may be a contracture (rigor) of local skeletofusimotor (beta) units caused by sustained reflex drive by the given muscle spindles. In
EMG this may be seen as complex repetitive discharges. We conclude that TrPs of myofascial pain are related to painful muscle spindles in
taut bands.
© 2009 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Myofascial syndrome; Gamma and beta motor units; Muscle spindle; Muscle III- and IV-afferent; Electromyography

1. Introduction muscle involved. The latent TrP is a focal area of tenderness


and tightness in a muscle that does not result in spontaneous
Myofascial syndrome is a muscular pain syndrome [1] pain [6]. The main characteristic criteria of the myofascial
with regional symptoms [2]. It is common with a prevalence syndrome are as follows: 1. regional pain complaint, 2. pain
rate of 30% in the internal medicine practice [3] and cause or paraesthesia in the typical distribution of the TrP, 3. a taut
much disability and inability to work [4]. Typical clinical band in the muscle, 4. exquisite tenderness found in that taut
findings in symptomatic muscles are taut bands with active band, 5. a local twitch response within the band of muscle
trigger points (TrPs) of myofascial pain [2]. Latent TrPs are on plucking palpation across the fibres, and 6. a restricted
common even in non-symptomatic individuals. They have range of motion in the affected muscle [2,7–11]. There are
been detected in the shoulder girdle musculature in nearly maps describing the typical locations of TrPs and referred
half of a group of young, asymptomatic military personnel pain areas [12]. Mapping of the infraspinatus muscle showed
[5]. that most, but not all active TrPs are at midfiber region in the
The active TrP is defined to cause spontaneous pain at rest, painful side [13]. Functional complaints include decreased
with an increase in pain on contraction or stretching of the work tolerance, fatigue, and weakness [14]. Myofascial syn-
drome may be activated by recent muscle injury or chronic
∗ Corresponding author. overload (repetitive strain) of muscles [6]. Works which need
E-mail address: juhani.v.partanen@hus.fi (J.V. Partanen). repetitive movements demanding precision or repetitive light

0928-4680/$ – see front matter © 2009 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.pathophys.2009.05.001
20 J.V. Partanen et al. / Pathophysiology 17 (2010) 19–28

lifting may cause myofascial pain especially in the shoulder End plate activity arises in two forms: 1. end plate noise or
and neck region [4]. It has also been suggested that anx- miniature end plate potentials (MEPPs) [28–31] and 2. end
iety, muscle wasting by malignant disease or neurological plate spikes (EPSs), which have a characteristic irregular fir-
disorders, muscle ischemia, visceral disease, radiculopathic ing pattern [29,32,33]. MEPPs and several sequences of EPSs
compression of motor nerves or climatic causes may be pos- are usually activated together [34]. The firing pattern [35–39]
sible reasons for myofascial pain [2]. and wave form [38] of EPSs is distinctly different from other
potentials in electromyography (EMG). If a concentric nee-
dle electrode is inserted through an active spot, the cannula
2. Hypotheses on the origin of myofascial pain potentials representing EPSs are seen as sputtering positive
potentials in EMG. These potentials are converted to EPSs
Kellgren [15] was the first to study human muscular pain as the electrode is withdrawn [40].
experimentally by injecting hypertonic saline into muscles, In needle EMG the insertion of needle through skin and
and he also turned his attention to patients with muscle pain. fascia is felt as sharp transient pain, but further advancement
The reason for muscular pain syndromes has, however, been is painless [41]. However, there are local spots in the muscle
a matter of debate for a longer time. Muscular strain is one which often are exquisitely painful when inserted with an
of the reasons for myofascial syndrome [2]. There are sur- EMG needle. The hallmark of these spots is end plate activity
prisingly sparse histological alterations either in the muscle in EMG [29,32,34,41] (Fig. 1). Occasionally a brief twitch
or in the TrPs, although mitochondrial changes have been of a strip of a muscle is seen as the recording needle enters an
described [16]. Thus muscle trauma or lesion does not seem active area [28], i.e. a local myotatic response may be seen
to be the primary cause [1]. There may be an increase of in the active spot.
reticular or elastic fibres which are absent in normal muscle MEPPs are considered to be local postsynaptic non-
[17]. Local muscle pain might be related to local, temporary propagated potentials caused by spontaneous vesicular
hypoxia causing a limited energy crisis within the muscle exocytosis of acetylcholine from the nerve terminal mem-
fibres [16,18]. Reduced blood flow was observed in Trapez- brane into the neuromuscular synaptic cleft [31]. The
ius myalgia and it correlated with the intensity of pain [16]. initiating factor in EPS generation is believed to be the needle
Muscle biopsies of tender points show that there were abnor- electrode “irritating” mechanically the terminal motor nerve
malities in high energy phosphate metabolites, but there or endplate connected to a muscle fibre. The EPSs are then
were no abnormalities in the non-tender muscle [19]. An recorded postsynaptically with the same needle electrode
“integrated hypothesis” was presented; muscular ischaemia, [30,42,43].
energy crisis, and increased leakage of acetylcholine into However, there is some concern with the prevailing
neuromuscular junction cause TrPs in taut bands [12]. hypothesis of the origin of EPSs. Experienced neurophys-
There is a sustained electrically silent contracture (rigor) iologists have not observed prolonged injury discharges in
of muscle fibres in taut bands [20]. A role of fusimotor nerve fibres. If a peripheral nerve is cut across, the muscle
reflexes evoked by muscular III- and IV-afferent activation is seen to twitch but contraction does not continue. This is
in the evolution of muscle pain and stiffness has also been evidence that large myelinated motor axons generate nerve
suggested [21–23]. However, no electrophysiological signs impulses on section, but the discharge is brief [44]. Insertion
of spasticity in these patients have been confirmed [9,24]. of microelectrode into nerve fascicles may cause spontaneous
The muscle contraction of a local twitch response following activity, brief bursts of two to five spikes. Short-term damage
a direct mechanical stimulation of a myofascial TrP appears to the nerve fibre may result in the generation of spontaneous
to occur only within the taut band with latency consistent repetitive discharges. They appear mainly as rhythmic single
with a polysynaptic reflex [25]. Recently, using the micro- potentials or rhythmic bursts, “crazy units” [45], i.e. with fir-
dialysis method an increase of a number of inflammatory and ing patterns different from that of EPSs [38]. Spontaneously
algesic metabolites and decrease of pH has been observed in active units could not be influenced by mechanical stimu-
active myofascial TrPs with local twitch response, compared lation within the fascicular innervation territory, nor could
to normal muscle [26,27]. This explains pain and pressure units recorded from motor fascicles be influenced by volun-
sensitivity by inflammation in TrPs. tary effort [45], contrary to the behaviour of EPSs [33,34,38].
Ectopic potentials of peripheral branches of motor axons
spread to both directions from the site of origin, causing motor
3. Nociception of a muscle is mainly in “active spots” unit potentials or fasciculations, not EPSs. There is no exper-
with end plate activity imental data pointing out that mechanical manipulation of
a nerve terminal might cause sustained postsynaptic action
3.1. Hypothesis for the origins of end plate activity potentials in the muscle fibre, even if increased concentration
of potassium ions accelerates the MEPP frequency [46].
Every electromyographer sometimes observes end plate Another theory was presented for EPSs: they are action
activity in the muscle studied. These minuscule sites are potentials of intrafusal nuclear chain and nuclear bag muscle
called “active spots” or “active areas” of the muscle [28]. fibres [34]. This theory was based on observed EPS reactions
J.V. Partanen et al. / Pathophysiology 17 (2010) 19–28 21

Fig. 1. Typical end plate spikes (EPSs) as seen in needle electromyography in an active spot of a relaxed gastrocnemius muscle. Note the occurrence of EPSs
with a negative onset (upwards) and others with a positive onset (downwards) as well (arrows, inset). There is end plate noise (MEPPs) in the background.

to a number of gamma efferent activating and non-activating from intrafusal neuromuscular junctions together with action
procedures. Due to arguments against this theory [47], new potentials of the intrafusal muscle fibres under fusimotor
needle EMG recordings with several electrodes in active spots drive. MEPPs are the hallmark of neuromuscular junction
(with EPSs) and parallel silent sites (non-active areas) of the in alpha motor unit [28]. However, intrafusal MEPPs (“spon-
given muscle were performed [38]. The results were in accor- taneous miniature potentials”) have also been observed in
dance with the local intrafusal origin of EPSs. Thus it seems microelectrode recording of intrafusal muscle fibre close to
to be possible to record EMG activity (MEPPs and EPSs) of motor terminals [48]. Most EPSs are local but there are
intrafusal muscle fibres with needle EMG [38], as well as with also irregularly firing EPSs which propagate for a greater
microelectrodes [48]. Indeed, intrafusal muscle fibres are not length than a muscle spindle, resembling a motor unit terri-
very small in diameter (mean 16.7 ␮m for bag and 8.4 ␮m for tory, and these are probably derived from skeletofusimotor
chain fibres), compared to the diameter of extrafusal muscle (beta) units [38]. Irregular firing and frequent short interpo-
fibres and in the extracapsular C region the diameter of a tential intervals in sequences of EPSs [38] could be caused by
bag fibre may resemble that of small extrafusal fibre [49]. lack or rarity of recurrent inhibition of gamma-motoneurones
The topographical localization of motor endplates of a mus- [52]. The lack of recurrent inhibition is surprising since
cle is usually restricted and confined to the midfibre region gamma-motoneurones are smaller than even the smallest
(endplate zone) [50]. The MEPPs and EPSs may be recorded alpha-motoneurones which have widespread and powerful
both inside and outside of the endplate zone for example in recurrent inhibition via Renshaw cells [53] and thus long
the brachial biceps muscle [38,41,51]. Muscle spindles are interpotential intervals and a relatively regular firing pattern.
concentrated in the region of nerve entry and around the sub- Nociceptors of the muscle seem in EMG to be concen-
divisions of the intramuscular nerves, preferentially among trated in active spots which thus have the EMG characteristics
extrafusal fibres with a high proportion of oxidative and fast of muscle spindles [38]. There are several descriptions of
oxidative-glykolytic types [49,52]. This corresponds to the spontaneous EMG activity either in active spots [32–34] or
observation of MEPPs and EPSs both in motor point and TrPs of muscular pain syndromes [12,24,54–57]. Recently is
non-motor point sites (83% in motor point sites and 34% in has been established that EMG activity in myofascial TrPs
non-motor point sites) [41]. indeed is typical end plate activity [58,59]. Thus TrPs also
have the EMG characteristics of muscle spindles. However,
3.2. End plate spikes and intrafusal nociceptors myofascial TrP spindles do not represent all muscle spin-
dles of a painful muscle and thus it is conceivable that end
According to the present hypothesis only MEPPs, not plate activity with spikes (of normal muscle spindles) can also
EPSs could be recorded from the extrafusal neuromuscu- be observed in control points outside the TrP, or in control
lar junctions, whereas MEPPs and EPSs together derive muscles, although with a lower incidence. Another, distinctly
22 J.V. Partanen et al. / Pathophysiology 17 (2010) 19–28

different form of spontaneous activity in myofascial TrPs is nent of the action potential of the muscle fibre, correlated
the complex repetitive discharge, which is not as common to the distance of the recording site from the neuromuscular
finding as EPSs [24]. Spontaneous end plate activity may junction [76]. However, the action potential propagation is
eventually become a gold standard against which the bed- confined to the polar region and does not happen over the
side diagnostic criteria for myofascial pain syndrome can be equatorial region of muscle spindle, where the Ia-afferent
validated [60]. receptors are situated [49]. Thus the fusimotor innervation
of the polar regions of a muscle fibre takes place selectively.
The great majority of fusimotor axons produce activity at one
4. Afferent and efferent systems of the muscle and spindle pole only [73]. One third of the responses to stimu-
muscle spindle lation of static fusimotor axons are action potentials and the
rest are junction potentials [75]. The figures are in concert
Muscle spindle consists of static and dynamic intra- with EPSs having a short initial positive deflection (sign of a
fusal motor units which adjust the sensitivity of Ia and II propagated potential, 36%) and EPSs having a negative onset
mechanoreceptors to change and rate of change of the mus- (local response, 64%) in EMG [38]. There may be some spon-
cle length. These mechanoreceptors are situated in the nuclear taneous fusimotor activity in relaxed muscle but spontaneous
chain and nuclear bag intrafusal muscle fibres; Ia receptors skeletofusimotor activity is lacking [53,77].
in the equatorial region and II receptors close to Ia receptors
between the equatorial and polar regions of the spindle [48].
The reflex effects of these receptors differ. Ia-afferents acti- 5. Effects of sustained muscle contraction on III- and
vate alpha motor neurons and cause increase of the muscle IV-afferents
tension. II-afferents have only weak monosynaptic excitation
of homonymous alpha motor neurons. II-afferents activate Sustained muscle contraction and fatigue cause gradual
mainly gamma motor neurons, affecting the sensitivity of decrease of the firing rate of motor units but excitation of
the muscle spindle [61,62]. A part of muscle spindles receive group III and IV muscle afferents [78], most of which have
also autonomic axons that are in non-selective neuroeffective high threshold of firing [79]. This excitation may be medi-
association with the intrafusal muscle fibres [63,64]. ated by ischemic contraction, lactic acid (acidosis), and also
There are also thin somatic sensory nerve fibres in the by algesic metabolites, such as bradykinin, serotonin, and
muscle [64]. These afferents may be either mechanosen- arachidonic acid [23,69,80–82], which may be concentrated
sitive or chemosensitive. There is evidence that thinly in exhausted muscle [23]. Excitation of group III- and IV-
myelinated III-afferents are sensitive to pressure and other afferents evokes reflex activation of gamma-efferent system
group III receptors respond to chemical changes within the in the same and also neighbouring muscles [72,80,83], but
muscle [66]. Unmyelinated IV-afferents are high-threshold it may inhibit alpha motor neurones [68,84]. The gamma
mechanoreceptors, and also sensitive to pain-producing sub- and beta efferent axons show both convergence (4–5 dif-
stances [67–69]. III- and IV-afferents are structurally A␦ and ferent axons innervate the poles of a muscle spindle) [73]
C nerve fibres. However, the finding that the (extrafusal) and divergence (each gamma or beta axon innervates several
muscle fibres proper are not supplied with neuropeptide- spindles, but in a selective manner) [49], which explains the
containing free nerve endings may relate to the clinical spread of evoked gamma and beta activation within a mus-
experience that muscle cell death – even on a large scale, cle. If the muscle overload continues for a long time, there
such as may occur during muscular dystrophy, polymyositis, may even be neurogenic inflammation and sensitization of
or dermatomyositis – usually is not painful [70,71]. The evi- III- and IV-afferent receptors [85], and even afferents which
dence so far available suggests that receptors with group III under normal conditions have a high threshold for excitation
and IV axons play a particular role in nociception and also [79].
subserve a wide range of sensory modalities [1,66–68,72].
The efferent system on muscle spindle consists of static
and dynamic gamma efferents [53]. Dynamic gamma effer- 6. Hypothesis: intrafusal III- and IV-afferents and
ents innervate intrafusal nuclear bag I muscle fibres and their activation in the muscle spindle play a part in
static gamma efferents innervate intrafusal nuclear bag II and myofascial pain
nuclear chain fibres [49]. There are also some non-selective
fusimotor axons [73]. Activated nuclear bag fibres have junc- The single largest group of sensory fibres leaving skele-
tion potentials (“local responses”) which do not propagate tal muscles are small myelinated or unmyelinated (groups III
from the end plate area of the muscle fibre. Junction potentials and IV) fibres [68]. Successively smaller nerve fibres are pro-
spread electrotonically, i.e. are seen as synchronous negative- duced by branching. Eventually they leave the nerve trunks
onset waves in electrodes along a minute distance of the to end freely in the muscle. Free nerve endings are present
nuclear bag fibre [74,75]. Nuclear chain fibres have prop- in virtually every tissue of the muscle with the exception
agated action potentials [74,75]. Propagation is seen in the of capillaries. Free nerve endings are found in the blood
form of positive component before the main spike compo- vessels, connective tissue adjacent ligaments, between extra-
J.V. Partanen et al. / Pathophysiology 17 (2010) 19–28 23

cle. A blood/nervous system barrier therefore, obtains in both


endoneurial and intrafusal periaxial spaces [93,94]. There are
few or no capillaries in the periaxial space [95]. This cap-
sular barrier and vascular arrangement may predispose the
accumulation of lactic acid, potassium ions, algogenic and
inflammatory agents (“inflammatory soup”) in the periaxial
space over the intrafusal sensory terminals during sustained
fusimotor or skeletofusimotor activation. Muscle spindle is
a container with thick membrane and tight sleeves. The
periaxial space is full of highly viscous gel containing gly-
cosaminoglycan hyaluronate [96]. Thus the accumulation
of “inflammatory soup” may be stronger intrafusally than
Fig. 2. A schema illustrating the sensory innervation of the muscle spindle. extrafusally. Those facts also slow down the evacuation of
In addition to the Ia and II afferents the presence of III- and IV-afferents with “inflammatory soup” from the intrafusal periaxial space,
free nerve endings was observed. compared to the well perfused extrafusal muscle tissue.
Algesic substances like bradykinin, 5-HT, histamine,
fusal and intrafusal muscle fibres, and in the adventitia of TNF␣, interleukin 8, potassium, or hypertonic sodium
arterioles and venules [23,65,68,86]. Considering the mus- chloride stimulate chemosensitive III- and IV-afferents
cle spindle, muscle spindle capsule has free nerve endings [27,66,67,97]. The activation of III- and IV-afferents cause
[87] and unmyelinated somatic C-nerve fibre (IV-afferent) fusimotor reflex activation which may readily reach other
was observed inside the muscle spindle (which are the first spindles of the same and even neighbour muscles [22]. It is
to degenerate after section of the somatic nerve) [88]. A few more difficult to distinguish a local intrafusal inflammation
group III axons serve spindle secondary endings, other are than a widespread inflammation in extrafusal muscle tissue.
widely distributed in skeletal muscle [66]. The presence of Sensitization of intrafusal III- and IV-afferents may lead to
one or two very small-diameter (less than 0.5 ␮m) unmyeli- spontaneous firing and neuropathic pain, intensified by local
nated nerve fibres in the human muscle spindle without any pressure. Chronic nociceptor firing is reflected for instance
endings were observed and considered sympathetic [89]. in elevated substance P levels in the cerebrospinal fluid. Sub-
They show varicosities [63,90]. Somatic unmyelinated IV- stance P is a peptide involved in the neurotransmission of pain
afferents may also exist as thin varicose nerve fibres [91] from the periphery to the central nervous system [98]. The
(Fig. 2). Stacey [65] describes the difficulty to observe C- development of central hyperexitability may ensue [6,99].
fibres with light microscope; electron microscope reveals a Reflex effects of intrafusal III- and IV-afferent activa-
four-fold increase of non-myelinated fibres present in the tion may cause also activation of extrafusal muscle fibres
muscle nerve over that seen with the light microscope. It of the skeletofusimotor (beta) motor units. There is histo-
is not possible to determine the nature of thin axon ter- chemical evidence for the existence of beta innervation in
minals in silver preparations [63]. Autonomic fibres were the primate [100]. There is histological and electrophysio-
observed by the subsequent use of fluorescence microscopy logical evidence for beta motor units in man [38,101,102].
[63]. Neurogenic inflammation is caused by release of neu- There is evidence that sustained isometric muscle contrac-
ropeptides, for example substance P from the terminals of tion in man causes muscle spindle excitation on hard-wired
primary nociceptive neurons [92] via an axon reflex. Thus basis via static skeletofusimotor (beta) units [102]. A large
there are varicosities and exocytosis also in these nocicep- number of intrafusal P1 plates are observed in feline hind-
tive afferent neurons. Novel studies of somatic C-fibres of limb muscles and also in man. P1 plates are the probable
the muscle spindle, especially neuropeptide-containing ones, sign of beta innervation. Extrafusal beta fibres are widely
are evidently needed with the modern immunohistochemical distributed within a muscle fascicle. There are both dynamic
staining and electron microscopic methods. and static beta axons. The high density of beta innervation
The capsulated part of muscle spindle is isolated from suggests that the beta system may be as important in con-
the extrafusal tissue. Tight junctions between capsular sheet trolling muscle spindle sensitivity as the separate fusimotor
cells act as barrier to the diffusion of substances into the system [103].
periaxial space. There is some leakage in the poles through During postural stresses, precision work or sustained over-
the open end of each capsular sleeve. There is a transcapsular load of the muscle there is an increase in the fusimotor and
potential of −15 mV due in part to a relatively high K+ in the skeletofusimotor drive, which causes accumulation of inflam-
periaxial fluid, especially after sustained fusimotor activity matory and algesic agents into the capsular region (periaxial
[49,53]. This may contribute to the increased excitability of space) of the muscle spindle. These agents cause activation
the sensory endings [49]. and sensitization of intrafusal III- and IV-afferents, which
Extrafusal and intrafusal capillaries are different. The further increase gamma and beta efferent drive via reflex
spindle capillaries, as capillaries supplying intramuscular pathway (a positive feedback loop). Reflex activation of beta
nerves do not leak as capillaries supplying extrafusal mus- motor units associated with a given muscle spindle may cause
24 J.V. Partanen et al. / Pathophysiology 17 (2010) 19–28

Fig. 3. A complex repetitive discharge (40 Hz) recorded from a painful trigger point in the levator scapulae muscle of a patient with myofascial syndrome.
There were no signs of peripheral neuropathy in this patient.

fatigue, energy crisis and finally silent contracture of the involved (Fig. 3). There is also a spread of the fusimotor drive
extrafusal muscle fibres of these beta motor units, observed to less active muscle spindles [22,104], and thus a taut band
clinically as a palpable taut band. Complex repetitive dis- may even be formed by a number of neighbour beta units
charges [24] may represent this short-living EMG pattern of (Fig. 4). It should again be emphasized that there is no EMG
the ongoing development of a taut band, which finally leads to evidence of general increase of the muscle tension (alpha
exhaustion and silent contracture (rigor) of the muscle fibres motor unit activity) in these patients [24].

Fig. 4. A schema illustrating the taut band. Striped muscle fibres are extrafusal beta muscle fibres in silent contracture. The inflamed muscle spindles are red.
The divergent beta innervation (illustrated from the right side of the figure) to several muscle spindles as well as to extrafusal beta fibres forms the pathway for
concomitant III- and IV-afferent reflex drive (positive feedback loop) to both of them. Light grey muscle fibres are innervated by alpha motor neurons at the
end plate zone (not illustrated) and they are capable to produce the local twitch response of the taut band when Ia afferents are stimulated.
J.V. Partanen et al. / Pathophysiology 17 (2010) 19–28 25

6.1. The nature of the vicious cycle in myofascial massage and stretching may mechanically improve perfu-
syndrome sion of the muscle spindles and empty the “inflammatory
soup” from the periaxial space via open sleeves of the spindle
Considering the intrafusal localization of sensitized III- capsule and thus relieve neurogenic inflammation. Condition-
and IV-afferents to activate the gamma and beta efferent ing programme may also facilitate increased aerobic capacity
system it is not surprising, that small intramuscular injec- and increased muscle strength may alleviate the symptoms
tions of hypertonic saline do not cause increased fusimotor [10,112].
drive [105]. The explanation is that a small extrafusal bolus Anti-inflammatory agents have been used to inhibit
of hypertonic saline does not penetrate to the well capsu- prostaglandin E2 accumulation [69]. TrP injections by preci-
lated muscle spindles. A longer infusion caused the stretch sion needling and local anaesthetic and anti-inflammatory
reflex response to increase. However, the H-reflex did not agents reduce pain [6]. The technique involves mechani-
change and thus the excitability of the alpha motoneurone cal disruption of the TrP and by the present hypothesis the
pool was unchanged [106] and thus the extrafusally orig- effect is due to disruption of the spindle capsules, which
inated vicious cycle model [21] was not supported. If the empties the intrafusal “inflammatory soup” to the well per-
intramuscular injection of hypertonic saline is very large fused extrafusal muscle tissue, from which it is soon carried
compared to the volume of the muscle studied, the muscle away. Dry needling may do the same. Due to the possible
spindles are affected and the afferent effects of injections are excessive release of acetylcholine from the dysfunctional
significant [107]. It is hypothetized that an intrafusal vicious motor endplates in myofascial pain [113,114], it could be
cycle exists but it originates from the sensitized III- and IV- considered rational to use therapeutic agents, which target
afferents of the inflamed muscle spindles. It activates the this undesirable neurotransmitter release. Because botulinum
gamma and beta efferent system of the same and neighbour toxin acts to prevent the presynaptic release of acetylcholine
muscle spindles via the spinal reflex pathway. The reflection from cholinergic nerve terminals, it could be considered that
of this kind of vicious cycle could be the complex repeti- injections of botulinum toxin may be used to treat myofas-
tive discharges in EMG, as observed in myofascial syndrome cial pain. Although botulinum toxin was beneficial in some
patients [24]. Complex repetitive discharges were observed patients [115], the current evidence does not support the
in partially denervated muscles [108] but also in some healthy use of botulinum toxin injection for TrPs in myofascial pain
muscles [109]. Thus the activation of a reflex loop (intrafusal [116,117].
III- or IV-afferent to beta efferent) is possible in myofascial
syndrome.
8. Conclusion

7. Therapy A number of hypotheses has been presented in this review,


not always in concert with the prevailing ones. However,
Numerous therapy methods have been employed in every consideration is based on published data. The main
myofascial pain. Prevention of muscle overload with effi- points for the neurophysiological hypothesis for myofascial
cient work ergonomy has been recommended, although there syndrome are the following:
is little scientific data to support this [14]. Fusimotor drive is 1. The motor end plates are confined to a strip in the
largely dependent on subject’s internal attitude toward partic- midfibre area of a muscle, the endplate area. 2. However,
ular tasks and contexts [77,110], and thus short pauses during the muscular distribution of “active spots” with EPSs in
precision work may decrease intrafusal overload and help to EMG, TrPs of myofascial syndrome, and muscle spindles
restore the homeostasis. The same holds true for tasks caus- are not confined to the endplate area. 3. MEPPs and EPSs
ing fatigue, which activates muscle III- and IV-afferents and in “active spot” in EMG are supposed to derive from intra-
gamma efferent activity [111]. There are relatively few spin- fusal end plates and muscle fibres under fusimotor drive.
dles in the shoulder-girdle muscles [49]. This may increase 4. The exquisite pain caused by EMG needle electrode in
the proprioceptive burden of muscle spindles in these mus- “active spots” of muscle and exquisite pain of TrPs in myofas-
cles, especially during precision work, leading to myofascial cial syndrome, which also often show end plate spikes,
syndrome and TrPs. reflect the nociceptive role of muscle spindles. 5. A taut
Stretching exercise is considered to be one of the basic band in myofascial syndrome is caused by inflammation
treatments of myofascial pain because the muscles involved of muscle spindles and consequent III- and IV-afferent-
in this syndrome are shortened [6,14]. There are several dif- driven skeletofusimotor activity and contracture of extrafusal
ferent stretching techniques such as reciprocal inhibition and muscle fibres of beta units. The active stage is reflected
post-isometric relaxation techniques. It has been suggested as complex repetitive discharges in EMG. 6. The local
that focal muscle contractions result in prolonged ATP con- twitch response of a taut band is caused by activation of
sumption and that the restoration of a muscle to its full stretch local Ia afferents and consequent reflex response of alpha
length breaks the link between the energy crisis and contrac- motor neurones (a local myotatic reflex) and it indicates the
tion of sarcomeric unit [6]. It can also be speculated that presence of muscle spindles. We hope that these hypothe-
26 J.V. Partanen et al. / Pathophysiology 17 (2010) 19–28

ses give impetus for further studies of EPSs and muscle muscle pain syndromes, Am. J. Ind. Med. (Suppl. 1) (1999)
pain. 104–106.
[24] T.A. Ojala, J.P.A. Arokoski, J.V. Partanen, Needle-electromyography
findings of trigger points in neck-shoulder area before and after injec-
tion treatment, J. Muskuloskel. Pain 14 (2006) 5–14.
References [25] C.Z. Hong, D.G. Simons, Pathophysiologic and electrophysiologic
mechanisms of myofascial trigger points, Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil.
[1] P. Marchettini, Muscle pain: animal and human experimental and 79 (1998) 863–872.
clinical studies, Muscle Nerve 16 (1993) 1033–1039. [26] J.P. Shah, T.M. Phillips, J.V. Danoff, L.H. Gerber, An in vivo micro-
[2] M. Cummings, P. Baldry, Regional myofascial pain: diagnosis and analytical technique for measuring the local biochemical milieu of
management, Best Pract. Res. Clin. Rheumatol. 21 (2007) 367–387. human skeletal muscle, J. Appl. Physiol. 99 (2005) 1977–1984.
[3] S.A. Skootsky, B. Jaeger, R.K. Oye, Prevalence of myofascial pain in [27] J.P. Shah, J.V. Danoff, M.J. Desai, S. Parikh, L.Y. Nakamura, T.M.
general internal medicine practice, West J. Med. 151 (1989) 157–160. Phillips, L.H. Gerber, Biochemicals associated with pain and inflam-
[4] K.G. Henriksson, E. Bäckman, C. Henriksson, J.H. de Laval, Chronic mation are elevated in sites near to and remote from active myofascial
regional muscular pain in women with precise manipulation work, trigger points, Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 89 (2008) 16–23.
Scand. J. Rheumatol. 25 (1996) 213–223. [28] W.C. Wiederholt, End-plate noise in electromyography, Neurology
[5] A.E. Sola, M.L. Rodenberger, P.P. Gettys, Incidence of hypersensi- (Minneap.) 20 (1970) 214–224.
tive areas in posterior shoulder muscles, Am. J. Phys. Med. 3 (1955) [29] R.V. Jones, E.H. Lambert, G.P. Sayre, Source of a type of insertion
585–590. activity in electromyography with evaluation of a histological method
[6] R. Bennett, Myofascial pain syndromes and their evaluation, Best of localization, Arch. Phys. Med. 36 (1955) 301–310.
Pract. Res. Clin. Rheumatol. 21 (2007) 427–445. [30] F. Buchthal, P. Rosenfalck, Spontaneous electrical activity of human
[7] J. Travell, S. Rinzler, M. Herman, Pain and disability of the shoul- muscle, Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 20 (1966) 321–336.
der and arm, treatment by intramuscular infiltration with procaine [31] B. Katz, Electrical exploration of acetylcholine receptors, Postgrad.
hydrochloride, JAMA 120 (1942) 417–422. Med. J. 57 (Suppl. 1) (1981) 84–88.
[8] J. Travell, Identification of myofascial trigger points syndromes: a [32] H. Jasper, G. Ballem, Unipolar electromyograms of normal and den-
case of atypical facial neuralgia, Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 62 (1981) ervated human muscle, J. Neurophysiol. 12 (1949) 231–244.
100–106. [33] E. Kugelberg, I. Petersen, Insertion activity in electromyography, J.
[9] D.G. Simons, J.G. Travell, Myofascial origin of low back pain. 1. Prin- Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry 12 (1949) 268–273.
ciples of diagnosis and treatment, Postgrad. Med. 73 (1983) 66–70. [34] J.V. Partanen, U. Nousiainen, End-plate spikes in electromyogra-
[10] J.R. Fricton, Myofascial pain, Bailliére’s Clin. Rheumatol. 8 (1994) phy are fusimotor unit potentials, Neurology (Cleveland) 33 (1983)
857–880. 1039–1043.
[11] E. Tunks, J. Crook, Regional soft tissue pains: alias myofascial pain? [35] M. Stöhr, Benign fibrillation potentials in normal muscle and their
Bailliére’s Clin. Rheumatol. 13 (1999) 345–370. correlation with endplate and denervation potentials, J. Neurol. Neu-
[12] D.G. Simons, J.G. Travell, L.S. Simons, Myofascial Pain and Dys- rosurg. Psychiatry 40 (1977) 765–768.
function: The Trigger Point Manual, vol. 1 Upper Half of Body, [36] J.V. Partanen, R. Danner, Fibrillation potentials after muscle injury in
Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, 1999. humans, Muscle Nerve 5 (1982) S70–S73.
[13] H.-Y. Ge, C. Fernández-de-las-Peñas, P. Madeleine, L. Arendt- [37] R. Heckmann, H.P. Ludin, Differentiation of spontaneous activity
Nielsen, Topographical mapping and mechanical pain sensitivity of from normal and denervated skeletal muscle, J. Neurol. Neurosurg.
myofascial trigger points in the infraspinatus muscle, Eur. J. Pain 12 Psychiatry 45 (1982) 331–336.
(2008) 859–865. [38] J. Partanen, End plate spikes in the human electromyogram. Revision
[14] J. Borg-Stein, D.G. Simons, Myofascial pain, Arch. Phys. Med. Reha- of the fusimotor theory, J. Physiol. (Paris) 93 (1999) 155–166.
bil. Suppl. 83 (2002) S40–47. [39] W.J. Schulte-Mattler, D. Georgiadis, S. Zierz, Discharge patterns
[15] J.H. Kellgren, A preliminary account of referred pains arising from of spontaneous activity and motor units on concentric needle elec-
muscle, Br. Med. J. 1 (1938) 325–327. tromyography, Muscle Nerve 24 (2001) 123–126.
[16] S.E. Larsson, L. Bodegard, K.G. Henriksson, P.A. Oberg, Chronic [40] J.B. Pickett, W.J. Schmidley, Sputtering positive potentials in the
Trapezius myalgia. Morphology and blood flow studied in 17 patients, EMG: an artefact resembling positive waves, Neurology 30 (1980)
Acta Orthop. Scand. 61 (1990) 394–398. 215–218.
[17] E.M. Bartels, B. Danneskiold-Samsoe, Histological abnormalities in [41] E. Qerama, A. Fuglsang-Frederiksen, H. Kasch, F.W. Bach, T.S.
muscle from patients with certain types of fibrositis, Lancet 8484 Jensen, Evoked pain in the motor endplate region of the brachial
(1986) 755–757. biceps muscle: an experimental study, Muscle Nerve 29 (2004)
[18] F. Kadi, K. Waling, C. Ahlgren, G. Sundelin, S. Holmner, G.S. 393–400.
Butler-Browne, L.E. Thornell, Pathological mechanisms implicated [42] W.F. Brown, G.P. Varkey, The origin of spontaneous electrical activity
in localized female Trapezius myalgia, Pain 78 (1998) 191–196. at the end-plate zone, Ann. Neurol. 10 (1981) 557–560.
[19] M. Bengtsson, K. Henriksson, J. Larsson, Reduced high-energy [43] D. Dumitru, Electrodiagnostic Medicine, Hanley and Belfus Inc.,
phosphate levels in the painful muscles of patients with primary Philadelphia, 1995, pp. 29–64, 218–221.
fibromyalgia, Arthritis Rheumatol. 29 (1986) 817–821. [44] P.D. Wall, S. Waxman, A.I. Basbaum, Ongoing activity in peripheral
[20] D.G. Simons, S. Mense, Understanding and measurement of muscle nerve: injury discharge, Exp. Neurol. 45 (1974) 576–589.
tone as related to clinical muscle pain, Pain 75 (1998) 1–17. [45] W.G. Macefield, Spontaneous and evoked ectopic discharges recorded
[21] H. Johansson, P. Sojka, Pathophysiological mechanisms involved in from single human axons, Muscle Nerve 21 (1998) 461–468.
genesis and spread of muscular tension in occupational muscle pain [46] S. Thesleff, J. Molgó, A new type of transmitter release at the neuro-
and in chronic musculoskeletal pain syndromes. A hypothesis, Med. muscular junction, Neuroscience 9 (1983) 1–8.
Hypotheses 35 (1991) 196–203. [47] W.F. Brown, The Physiological and Technical Basis of Electromyo-
[22] H. Johansson, M. Djupsjöbacka, P. Sjölander, Influences of the graphy, Butterworth Publishers, Boston, 1984, pp. 339–343.
gamma-muscle spindle system from muscle afferents stimulated by [48] D. Barker, P. Bessou, E. Jankowska, B. Pagès, M.J. Stacey, Identifica-
KCl and lactic acid, Neurosci. Res. 16 (1993) 49–57. tion of intrafusal muscle fibres activated by single fusimotor axons and
[23] H. Johansson, P. Sjölander, M. Djupsjöbacka, M. Bergenheim, injected with fluorescent dye in cat tenuissimus spindles, J. Physiol.
J. Pedersen, Pathophysiological mechanisms behind work-related 275 (1978) 149–165.
J.V. Partanen et al. / Pathophysiology 17 (2010) 19–28 27

[49] R.W. Banks, D. Barker, The muscle spindle, in: A.G. Engel, C. [73] I.A. Boyd, J. Ward, Motor control of nuclear bag and nuclear chain
Franzini-Armstrong (Eds.), Myology, 3rd edition, McGraw-Hill, intrafusal fibres in isolated living muscle spindles from the cat, J.
Medical Publishing Division, New York, 2004, pp. 489–509. Physiol. 244 (1975) 83–112.
[50] C. Coërs, A.L. Woolf, The Innervation of Muscle: A Biopsy Study, [74] I.A. Boyd, Internal working of muscle spindles. Review, in: I.A. Boyd,
Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford, 1959. M.H. Gladden (Eds.), The Muscle Spindle, The Macmillan Press Ltd.,
[51] S.-M. Aquilonius, H. Askmark, P.-G. Gillberg, S. Nandedkar, Y. Houndmills, UK, 1985, pp. 129–150.
Olsson, E. Stålberg, Topographical localization of motor endplates [75] P. Bessou, B. Pages, Intracellular potentials from intrafusal muscle
in cryosections of whole human muscles, Muscle Nerve 7 (1984) fibres evoked by stimulation of static and dynamic fusimotor axons
287–293. in the cat, J. Physiol. 227 (1972) 709–727.
[52] V.H. Voss, Zahl und Anordnung der Muskelspindeln in den oberen [76] D. Dumitru, Physiologic basis of potentials recorded in electromyo-
Zungenbeinmuskeln, in M. Trapezius und M. Latissimus Dorsi, Anat graphy, Muscle Nerve 23 (2000) 1667–1685.
Anzeiger 103 (1956) 443–446. [77] E. Ribot, J.-P. Roll, J.-P. Vedel, Efferent discharges recorded from sin-
[53] M. Hulliger, The mammalian muscle spindle and its central control, gle skeletomotor and fusimotor fibres in man, J. Physiol. 375 (1986)
Rev. Physiol. Biochem. Pharmacol. 101 (1984) 1–110. 251–268.
[54] J. Travell, Symposium on the mechanisms and management of [78] U. Windhorst, D. Kirmayer, F. Soibelman, A. Misri, R. Rose,
pain syndromes, Proc. Rudolf Virchow Med. Soc. 16 (1957) Effects of neurochemically excited group III–IV muscle affer-
128–136. ents on motoneuron afterhyperpolarization, Neuroscience 76 (1997)
[55] D.R. Hubbard, G.M. Berkoff, Myofascial trigger points show spon- 915–929.
taneous needle EMG activity, Spine 18 (1993) 1803–1807. [79] S. Mense, Slowly conducting afferent fibres from deep tissues: neuro-
[56] W.H. McNulty, R.N. Gevirtz, D.R. Hubbard, G.M. Berkoff, Needle biological properties and central nervous actions, Prog. Sens. Physiol.
electromyographic evaluation of trigger point response to a psycho- 6 (1986) 139–219.
logical stressor, Psychophysiology 31 (1994) 313–316. [80] K. Jovanovic, R. Anastasivejic, J. Vuco, Reflex effects on gamma
[57] D.G. Simons, C.-Z. Hong, L.S. Simons, Endplate potentials are com- fusimotor neurones of chemically induced discharges in small-
mon to midfiber myofascial trigger points, Am. J. Phys. Med. Rehabil. diameter muscle afferents in decerebrate cats, Brain Res. 521 (1990)
81 (2002) 212–222. 89–94.
[58] A. Fuglsang-Fredriksen, The utility of interference pattern analysis, [81] M.J. Joyner, Muscle chemoreflexes and exercise in humans, Clin.
Muscle Nerve 23 (2000) 18–36. Auton. Res. 2 (1992) 201–208.
[59] C. Couppé, A. Midttun, J. Hilden, U. Jorgensen, P. Oxholm, A. [82] M. Djupsjöbacka, H. Johansson, M. Bergenheim, B.I. Wenngren,
Fuglsang-Fredriksen, Spontaneous needle electromyographic activ- Influences of the gamma-muscle spindle system from muscle afferents
ity in myofascial trigger points in the infraspinatus muscle: a blinded stimulated by increased intramuscular concentrations of bradykinin
assessment, J. Muskuloskel. Pain 9 (2001) 7–17. and 5-HT, Neurosci. Res. 22 (1995) 325–333.
[60] R.N. Harden, S.P. Bruehl, S. Gass, C. Niemiec, B. Barbick, Signs and [83] M. Ljubisavljevic, K. Jovanovic, R. Anastasijevic, Changes in dis-
symptoms of the myofascial pain syndrome: a national survey of pain charge rate of cat hamstring fusimotor neurones during fatiguing
management providers, Clin. J. Pain 16 (2000) 64–72. contractions of triceps surae muscles, Brain Res. 579 (1992) 246–252.
[61] M.H. Gladden, H. Matsuzaki, Static gamma-motoneurones couple [84] V.E. Pettorossi, G. Della Torre, R. Bortolami, O. Brunetti, The role
group Ia and II afferents of single muscle spindles in anaesthetized of capsaicin-sensitive muscle afferents in fatigue-induced modulation
and decerebrate cats, J. Physiol. 543 (2002) 273–288. on the monosynaptic reflex in the rat, J. Physiol. 515 (1999) 599–607.
[62] U. Windhorst, Muscle proprioceptive feedback and spinal networks, [85] A. Ekblom, M. Rydh-Rinder, Pain mechanisms: anatomy and phys-
Brain Res. Bull. 73 (2007) 155–202. iology, in: N. Rawal (Ed.), Management of Acute and Chronic Pain,
[63] D. Barker, M. Saito, Autonomic innervation of receptors and muscle BMJ Books, London, 1998, pp. 1–22.
fibres in cat skeletal muscle, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B. Biol. Sci. 212 [86] P. Haouzi, J.M. Hill, B.K. Lewis, M.P. Kaufman, Responses of group
(1981) 317–332. III and IV muscle afferents to distension of the peripheral vascular
[64] M. Passatore, M. Filippi, G. Grassi, Cervical sympathetic nerve stim- bed, J. Appl. Physiol. 87 (1999) 545–553.
ulation can induce an intrafusal muscle fibre contraction in the rabbit, [87] D. Barker, Morphology of muscle receptors, in: C.C. Hunt (Ed.),
in: I. Boyd, M. Gladden (Eds.), The Muscle Spindle, Macmillan, Muscle Receptors, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1974, p. 77.
London, 1985, pp. 221–226. [88] R. Schober, Y. Yamamura, On the fine structure of intrafusal and
[65] M.J. Stacey, Free nerve endings in skeletal muscle of the cat, J. Anat. extrafusal nerve segments of the rat muscle spindle after sciatic
105 (1969) 231–254. nerve transcetion (in German), Acta Neuropathol. (Berlin) 59 (1983)
[66] A.S. Paintal, Functional analysis of group III afferent fibres of mam- 246–254.
malian muscles, J. Physiol. (London) 152 (1960) 250–270. [89] W.R. Kennedy, Innervation of normal human muscle spindles, Neu-
[67] S. Mense, Nervous outflow from skeletal muscle following chemical rology 20 (1970) 463–475.
noxious stimulation, J. Physiol. 267 (1977) 75–88. [90] D. Barker, R.W. Banks, The muscle spindle, in: A.G. Engel, C.
[68] V.C. Abrahams, Group III and IV receptors of skeletal muscle, Can. Franzini-Armstrong (Eds.), Myology, McGraw-Hill Inc., New York,
J. Physiol. Pharmacol. 64 (1986) 509–514. 1994, pp. 333–359.
[69] D.M. Rotto, H.D. Schultz, J.C. Longhurst, M.P. Kaufman, Sensitiza- [91] T. Müller, Characteristic intraepidermal nerve fiber endings of the
tion of group III muscle afferents to static contraction by arachidonic intervibrissal fur in the mystacial pad of the rat: morphological details
acid, J. Appl. Physiol. 68 (1990) 861–867. revealed by intravital methylene blue staining and the zinc iodide-
[70] S. Mense, P. Skeppar, Discharge behaviour of feline gamma- osmium tetroxide technique, J. Anat. 195 (1999) 147–152.
motoneurones following induction of an artificial myositis, Pain 46 [92] J.C. Foreman, C.C. Jordan, Neurogenic inflammation, TIPS March
(1991) 201–210. (1984) 116–119.
[71] A. Reinert, A. Kaske, S. Mense, Inflammation induced increase in the [93] W.R. Kennedy, K.S. Yoon, Permeability of muscle spindle capillaries
density of neuropeptide-immunoreactive nerve endings in rat skeletal and capsule, Muscle Nerve 2 (1979) 101–106.
muscle, Exp. Brain Res. 121 (1998) 174–180. [94] T. Miyoshi, W.R. Kennedy, K.S. Yoon, Morphometric comparison of
[72] J. Pedersen, P. Sjolander, B.I. Wenngren, H. Johansson, Increased capillaries in muscle spindles, nerve and muscle, Arch. Neurol. 36
intramuscular concentration of bradykinin increases the static fusimo- (1979) 547–552.
tor drive to muscle spindles in neck muscles of the cat, Pain 70 (1997) [95] A. Maier, The blood supply of muscle spindles in some mammals and
83–91. the pigeon, J. Morphol. 161 (1979) 323–336.
28 J.V. Partanen et al. / Pathophysiology 17 (2010) 19–28

[96] Y. Fukami, Studies of capsule and capsular space of cat muscle spin- [107] J. Thunberg, M. Ljubisavljevic, M. Djupsjöbacka, H. Johansson,
dles, J. Physiol. 376 (1986) 281–297. Effects on the fusimotor-muscle spindle system induced by intramus-
[97] L.S. Sorkin, C.M. Doom, Epineural application of TNF elicits an acute cular injections of hypertonic saline, Exp. Brain. Res. 142 (2002)
hyperalgesia in awake rat, J. Peripher. Nerv. Syst. 5 (2000) 96–100. 319–326.
[98] B. Evengard, C.G. Nilsson, G. Lindh, L. Lindquist, P. Eneroth, S. [108] G. Roth, Repetitive discharge due to self-ephaptic excitation of
Fredrikson, L. Terenius, K.G. Henriksson, Chronic fatigue syndrome a motor unit, Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 93 (1994)
differs from fibromyalgia. No evidence for elevated substance P levels 1–6.
in cerebrospinal fluid of patients with chronic fatigue syndrome, Pain [109] J.R. Daube, D.I. Rubin, Needle electromyography, Muscle Nerve 39
78 (1978) 153–155. (2009) 244–270.
[99] L. Arendt-Nielsen, T. Graven-Nielsen, Muscle pain: sensory impli- [110] V. Hospod, J.-M. Aimonetti, J.-P. Roll, E. Ribot-Ciscar, Changes in
cations and interaction with motor control, Clin. J. Pain 24 (2008) human muscle spindle sensitivity during a proprioceptive attention
291–298. task, J. Neurosci. 27 (2007) 5172–5178.
[100] K.S.K. Murthy, W.D. Letbetter, E. Eidelberg, W.E. Cameron, J. Petit, [111] J. Pedersen, M. Ljubisavljevic, M. Bergenheim, H. Johansson, Alter-
Histochemical evidence for the existence of skeletofusimotor (␤) ations in information transmission in ensembles of primary muscle
innervation in the primate, Exp Brain Res. 46 (1982) 186–190. spindle afferents after muscle fatigue in heteronymous muscle, Neu-
[101] S. Cooper, P.M. Daniel, Muscle spindles in man: their morphology roscience 84 (1998) 953–959.
in the lumbricals and the deep muscles of the neck, Brain 86 (1963) [112] J.R. Fricton, R. Kroening, D. Haley, R. Siegert, Myofascial pain
563–586. syndrome of the head and neck: a review of clinical characteris-
[102] N. Kakuda, T. Miwa, M. Nagaoka, Coupling between single mus- tics of 164 patients, Oral Surg. Oral Med. Oral Pathol. 60 (1985)
cle spindle afferents and EMG in the human wrist extensor muscles: 615–623.
physiological evidence of skeletofusimotor (beta) innervation, Elec- [113] P.E. Baldry, Myofascial Pain and Fibromyalgia Syndromes. A Clin-
troencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 109 (1998) 360–363. ical Guide to Diagnosis and Management, Churchill Livingstone,
[103] Y. Laporte, F. Emonet-Dénant, L. Jami, The skeletofusimotor or beta- Edinburgh, 2000, pp. 57–79, 103–118.
innervation of mammalian muscle spindles, Trends Neurosci. (1981) [114] D.G. Simons, Diagnostic criteria of myofascial pain caused by trigger
97–99, April. points, J. Musculoskel. Pain 7 (1999) 111–120.
[104] M. Bergenheim, H. Johansson, J. Pedersen, The role of the gamma- [115] W.P. Cheshire, S.W. Abashian, J.D. Mann, Botulinum toxin in the
system for improving information transmission in populations of Ia- treatment of myofascial pain syndrome, Pain 59 (1994) 65–69.
afferents, Neurosci. Res. 23 (1995) 207–215. [116] T. Ojala, J.P.A. Arokoski, J. Partanen, The effect of small doses of
[105] I. Birznieks, A.R. Burton, V.G. Macefield, The effects of experimental Botulinum Toxin A on neck-shoulder myofascial pain syndrome: a
muscle and skin pain on the static stretch sensitivity of human muscle double-blind, randomized and controlled crossover trial, Clin. J. Pain
spindles in relaxed leg muscles, J. Physiol. 586 (2008) 2713–2723. 22 (2006) 90–96.
[106] D.A. Matre, T. Sinkjaer, P. Svensson, L. Arend-Nielsen, Experimen- [117] K.Y. Ho, K.H. Tan, Botulinum toxin A for myofascial trigger point
tal muscle pain increases the human stretch reflex, Pain 75 (1998) injection: a qualitative systematic review, Eur. J. Pain 11 (2007)
331–339. 519–527.

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi