COMMENTS FROM KHATIB & ALAMI

Strategic Reservoirs At Makkah Phase II & Taif Phase I

Designer Name METSCOO HEAVY STEEL INDUSTRIES CO. LTD.
Document 75-QP10-S-001 Rev. A Comments Originator: KHATIB & ALAMI
Reference
Document Title General Arrangement Total no of Sheets. 2
Drawing of Tank #1

Sl.no K & A Comments on General Arrangement METSCO Reply

Drawing of Tank #1 (EH-AH-D-106) Dated 18-04-2018
Dated 10-04-2018
In “drawing title” and “location” cells, it is stated Noted. The same will be revised in
1 that this general arrangement is for tank #1 in
next submission.
“Sharai” site which had been moved to the new
location in “Al Moghamass”.
The sit key plan is for the old site in “Sharai”. Noted. The same will be revised in
2
next submission.

Qiblah direction is wrong due to using wrong site Noted. The same will be revised in
3 layout. next submission.

Pump outlet nozzle is not located (as per the Noted. AICC shall provide the report
4 approved Tank Sizing Calculation Report AH-EH-D- AH-EH-D-0081 to Metscco.
0081).

Outlet and overflow nozzles level should match Noted. AICC shall provide the report
5 with approved Tank Sizing Calculation Report AH- AH-EH-D-0081 to Metscco.
EHD-0081.

Bottom slope should be changed to 1% according to Noted. The same will be revised in
6 document number (QP10-Q-5588) in tender next submission.
document instead of 1:120.

Site class B should be changed to site class D in Noted. The same will be revised in
7 earthquake data according to (SBC301 - Section next submission.
14.1 - clause 14.1.11).

Height of aluminum dome roof should be provided. Noted. The same will be provided in
8
next submission.

Width of roof walkway should be provided. Noted. The same will be revised in
9
next submission.

Detail of Periphery walkway and handrail at the top A separate detailed drawing will be
10 of tank should be provided. submitted for the same.

Shell plates that mentioned in drawing are Metscco is buying the plates directly
11 (44.1mm, 42.6mm, 36.15mm, 29.65mm, 23.2mm, from the Plate Manufacturer.
16.75mm and 10.45mm), it is recommended to

1 of 2
 COMMENTS FROM KHATIB & ALAMI
Strategic Reservoirs At Makkah Phase II & Taif Phase I
Designer Name METSCOO HEAVY STEEL INDUSTRIES CO. LTD.
Document 75-QP10-S-001 Rev. A Comments Originator: KHATIB & ALAMI
Reference
Document Title General Arrangement Total no of Sheets. 2
Drawing of Tank #1

provide plates thickness with right number in order
to avoid difficulties in finding plates with
thicknesses nearest to 0.1mm.
Please note that, when the plates to be
procured from the plates
manufacturer directly i.e from the mill
(and not from the stockiest), the plate
thicknesses shall be ordered as per
the desired designed thickness values
since the Mills are capable of
manufacturing the plates with the
thicknesses in decimal values & those
can be measured easily with
calibrated gauges/ instruments.
All our thickness calculations are in
compliance with API 650.
The thickness values cannot be
rounded to next higher value of
thickness since the plates tonnage/
weight will increase significantly.
Metscco is procuring the plates from
Plates Manufacturer i.e from a Mill.
Plates manufacturer has already
acknowledged the receipt of Metscco
Purchase Order with all the technical
compliances. Mill has further
complied to Metscco’s clause which
states that ‘Negative tolerance in the
thickness is not acceptable’.
For your reference, please find
attached Plate Manufacturers
Purchase Order Acknowledgement
with all the technical compliances.

2 of 2