Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
DISSERTATION
SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF REQUIREMENTS
FOR THE AWARD OF THE DEGREE OF
MASTER OF TECHNOLOGY
IN
CIVIL ENGINEERING
(Transportation Engineering)
BY
SACHIN DASS
(Roll No. 2062/06)
Under the Guidance of
The contents in this dissertation have not been submitted in part or in full to any
other University for the award of any Degree or Diploma.
Dated : o^.X-XoU
Place : NIT Kurukshetra
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
My thanks are also due to the faculty and the staff members of Civil Engineering
Department for their help throughout the dissertation work.
I could not have completed my thesis without the support of my friend and
colleague Mr. Vipin Chauhan. I greatly appreciate all his help that he provided
throughout my dissertation.
Thanks to my parents who have supported me from the beginning. They are truly
a blessing in my life and I would not have been here at this position without their constant
love and support.
Finally, I would like to thank my savior Jesus Christ who has blessed me and
helped me to remain faithful throughout.
ytSACHIN DASS)
Roll No. 2062/06
i ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
CERTIFICATE (i)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS (ii)
LIST OF TABLES (viii)
1. INTRODUCTION I.4
LI GENERAL 1
1.2 HEADS 1
13 MX ROAD 2
ni
CONTENTS
2.1.9 Mass-Haul Strings 7
2.3.1 Application 9
2.3.2 Industry 9
2.4.1 Application 9
2.4.2 Industry 10
3.3 ALIGNMENT 16
3.3.1 Requirements 16
' CONTENTS iv
3.3.6.2 Psychological Widening 21
3.4.1 Overview 21
3.4.2 Gradient 22
4.1 INTRODUCTION 31
4.2 HEADS 32
4.3 MX ROAD 35
5.1 INTRODUCTION 37
CONTENTS
5.3.3.1 Creating a New Project 55
5.8 EARTHWORK 64
5.9 QUANTITIES 65
5.11 ANNOTATION 70
6.1 GENERAL 74
] CONTENTS vi
6.8 CROSS SECTIONAL ANALYSIS USING MX ROAD 131
REFERENCES 153
Vll
CONTENTS
LIST OF TABLES
Vlll
CONTENTS
LIST OF FIGURES
IX
CONTENTS
5.25 New Plan Display 70
5.26 Edit Model Style Window 71-
5.27 Display Model Window 71
5.28 Edit Model Defaults Display 72
5.29 Display Plan with Style Set 72
5.30 Save Page Layout Panel 73
6.1 Alignment for the proposed road using HEADS and MX Road 77
6.2 Cross Section drawn by HEADS Software at Chainage 0.000 " 95
6.3 Cross Section drawn by HEADS Software at Chainage 30.000 96
6.4 Cross Section drawn by MX Road Software at Chainage 0.000 132
6.5 Cross Section drawn by MX Road Software at Chainage 10.000 133
I CONTENTS
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 GENERAL
Tlie development of an effective road transport system is the primary need of any
country. The upgrading of existing road network system is also essential as the traffic on
urban and rural highways touches to saturation level over a period of time.
The road development projects being highly capital intensive involve very high
degree of attention by the project authorities as well as by the consultants, engineers and
contractors. Any mistake may result in wastage of millions, which could have been
avoided. Normally the alignment and the pavement composition decide the cost of a
highway project and for this job the best experienced manpower and the best available
tools must be deployed.
1.2 HEADS
The origin of the Company goes back to 1990 when a group of research workers
began work on the software, - HEADS. This team, in 1997, set up an independent
company, Techsoft Engineering Services (I) Pvt. Ltd, which has grown annually in size
since then. With continuous development, there HEADS range of software products have
HEADS has its own CAD engine and is best appreciated for its power,
completeness, versatility, fastest processing, simplicity and exchangeability of input and
output with other commonly used road engineering software of similar kind and all
popular CAD software.
1.3 MX ROAD
This study, 'Design of Road Project using MX Road and HEADS Software'
compares two software, MX Road and HEADS. These two software have similar
purposes but deliver ftinctionality in different ways. This study discusses how MX Road
and HEADS meet the requirements of any road design project.
The study analyzes the models and the abilities of MX Road and HEADS
software designated for a computer aided road design. The analysis and the comparison of
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
these software will help to answer the questions raised by the designers regarding the
selection of the software. It will thus be helpfiil in saving user's time and money and will
be of interest to agencies involved in the business of road designing.
MX Road and HEADS software have been used to evolve various design features
of a road project. The study has been undertaken with the following main objectives:-
2. To decide road alignment using given ground data for a road project
The study for evolving various design features of a road project has been
undertaken using the software MX Road and HEADS.
MX Road version XM 2007 and HEADS 2007 have been used in the study. The
design features evolved relate to a generalized made up data of a 2 lane NH / SH road
project located in a plain terrain.
Though the study has been undertaken using above mentioned versions of the
software and for the given category of road located in plain terrain, the contents of the
study are quite general in nature and can be easily applied using other versions of the
soflAvare and for other type of roads/ terrain conditions.
The study undertaken for the thesis has been presented in seven chapters. The first
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
chapter of Introduction discusses about the thesis problem, its objectives and scope of
the study.
In the second chapter, discussion on various software present in the market and an
Overview of the software MX Road and HEADS under study is presented.
In the forth chapter of Input Data Structure, the data collection by various
modes such as total station, auto level and GPS is presented.
In the fifth chapter, Design Steps for HEADS and MX Road are presented.
In the sixth chapter of Data Analysis and Design Reports, the road project data
is analysed to prepare various design reports covering various design features.
In the seventh chapter various Conclusions based upon the study and Scope for
further research are discussed.
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
CHAPTER 2
OVERVIEW OF MX ROAD AND HEADS
There are two varieties of Software availabJe based on two basic concepts namely:
"Template" and "String" modelling. The first group of products are simple to learn and
handle but have substantial limitations in handling today's demand for road geometric
design, Whereas software using "String" modelling technique is efficient for highway
projects involving Widening of existing roads. Surface Profile Correction etc.
Different type of string are used to represent particular features, such as highway
and railway centre lines, survey stations etc.
Station strings link instrument stations. The dimensions of each station are its X,
Y and Z co-ordinates and the name of the station, so a station string is a 4D string.
Contour strings represent contours. The dimensions of each point are its X and Y
co-ordinates, so it's a 2D string. The level of the contour (the Z value) is stored at the
fi"ont of the string data because it is common to all string points.
Feature strings define linear ground features such as a ridge or the base of a hill or
design features such as a channel or back of verge. The dimensions of each point in the
string are its X, Y and Z co-ordinates, so a feature string is a 3D string.
Point strings define discrete items such as manholes and lamp columns. A point
string records the X, Y and Z co-ordinates of a set of like items, where there is no
physical continuity from item to item. MX processes these strings differently from other
strings. Point strings generally record detail in survey models.
Master strings are used to represent road or railway centrelines and other
curvilinear master design lines. These are 6D strings. The first three dimensions of each
point in the string are its X,Y and Z co-ordinates, followed by its chainage along the
string, then the whole circle bearing of the string at that point, and its radius of curvature.
Earthwork strings represent the outer limits of embankments and cuttings. These
are 5D strings. The first three dimensions of each point are X,Y and Z co-ordinates,
followed by its offset and the bearing of a line normal to the line used to generate it
(called the reference line).
Volume strings generally contain earthwork volumes. These are lOD strings, used
to store volumes computed between successive sections. The first three dimensions of
each point are its X,Y and Z co-ordinates, followed by its chainage, and finally the
volume between the sections of two specified models (usually ground and design models,
specified at the start of the run). The remaining dimensions record volumes between the
various strata, though since this information is not always available, these dimensions are
often zero.
Text strings are multi-dimensional strings that hold character information for
naming items in drawings. The first two dimensions of each point are the X and Y co-
ordinates of the start position of a string of text (in world co-ordinates, not drawing co-
ordinates). The third dimension specifies the height of the characters when plotted. The
fourth dimension is the whole circle bearing of the baseline of the characters, and
subsequent dimensions contain the characters themselves.
All strings must have a four-character alphanumeric name, but cannot include
spaces or special characters, ABCD, 1234, and XA45 are valid examples, though many
organizations will adopt a convention for names to indicate the type of the string
referenced.
Road design models are very similar in many of computer aided design software.
Design stages are practically the same in all software products. The main stages of this
model are as follows: topographical 3D data input or creation, creation of digital terrain
model, design of horizontal alignment and vertical alignment, creation of model for the
route, choose of road pavement structures, creation of the final surface model joining it to
the route, preparation of project documentation, i.e. drawings for printing, creation of
The interactive 3D objects allow the user to computerize design processes since
they have a dynamic relationship, i.e. a change to one Civil 3D object creates changes in
all the other related objects.
In this software all the project data has a dynamic relationship, i.e. a change in one
object causes an automatic renewal and representation of the other related project data.
<2.3.1 Application
2.3.2 Industry
:!.4.] Application
2.4.2 Industry
• Professional surveyors
• Geotechnical engineers
• Surveying companies
• Landscape design
• Design/build companies
GENIO
I Alignment |
|PtanwfthStyteSel I I Design |
I Modify' I
I Plan with Toots [
I Sections |
I Analysis | jy
The Geometric Design of a highway deals with the dimensions and layout of
visible features of the highway such as alignment, sight distances and intersections.
• Intersection elements
Under cross sectional elements, the considerations for width of pavement, the
surface characteristics and cross slope of pavement are included. The sight distance or
clear distance visible ahead of the driver at horizontal and vertical curves and at
intersections govern the safe movements of vehicles.
The change in the road directions are made possible by introducing horizontal
curves. Super-elevation is provided by raising the outer edge of pavement to counteract
the centrifugal force developed on a vehicle traversing a horizontal curve. In order to
introduce the centrifugal force and the super-elevation gradually, transition curves are
introduced between straight and circular curves. The gradients and vertical curves are
introduced in the vertical alignment of a highway.
12
CHAPTER 3: ROAD GEOMETRIC DESIGN
i. Design speed
ii. Topography
The design speed is the most important factor controlling the geometric design
^lements of highways. The design speed is decided taking into account the overall
tjequirements of the highway. In India different speed standards have been assigned
epending upon the importance or the class of the road such as National/State Highways,
Major/Other District Roads and Village Roads. Further the design speed standards are
nodified depending upon the terrain or topography. Similarly urban roads have a
cifferent set of design speeds.
Since there are wide variations in the speed adopted by different drivers, and by
d fferent types of vehicles, design speed should be selected such that it satisfies nearly all
drivers. At the same time, a higher design speed has cascading effect in other geometric
designs and thereby cost escalation. Therefore, an 85th percentile design speed is
normally adopted. This speed is defined as that speed which is greater than the speed of
85% of drivers. In some countries this is as high as 95 to 98 percentile speed. Table 3.1
shows the design speed on rural highways as recommended by IRC.
13
'> CHAPTER 3: ROAD GEOMETRIC DESIGN
Table 3.1 Design Speed on Rural Highways as per IRC 73:1980
(ii) Topography
The factors associated with the traffic that affect geometric design of roads are the
vehicular characteristics and human characteristics of road users. It is difficult to decide
the design vehicle or the standard traffic lane under the mixed traffic flow condition
prevalent especially on urban roads of developing countries. This is a complex problem.
The different vehicle classes such as passenger cars, buses, trucks, motor cycles, etc. have
different speed and acceleration characteristics, apart from having different dimensions
14
CHAPTER 3: ROAD GEOMETRIC DESIGN
and weights. However, it is often necessary to consider some standard vehicle as the
design vehicle. Passenger car has been universally adopted as standard vehicle. The
important human factors which affect traffic behaviour include the physical, mental and
psychological characteristics of drivers and pedestrians.
The traffic flow or volume keeps fluctuating with time, from a low value during
off-peak hours to the highest value during the peak hour. It will be uneconomical to
design the roadway facilities for the peak traffic flow or the highest hourly traffic volume.
Therefore a reasonable value of traffic volume is decided for the design and this is called
the design hourly volume. The facilities designed with capacity for 30**^ highest hourly
traffic volume in the year is found to be satisfactory fi-om both facility and economic
considerations. The 30^*^ highest hourly volume is the hourly volume that will be exceeded
only 29 times in a year and all other hourly volumes of the year will be less than this
value. Thus the 30'*' highest hourly volume is generally taken as the design hourly
volume.
The features of the cross-section of the pavement influences the life of the
pavement as well as the riding comfort and safety. Camber, kerbs, and geometry of
various cross-sectional elements are important aspects to be considered in this regard.
A typical cross section for a normal two lane two-way rural road and divided rural
road is shown in Figure 3.1.
15
CHAPTER 3: ROAD GEOMETRIC DESIGN
Carriageway
Catch Drain
'<<:>////' y\^777^^^^
Batter
Table Drain
Table Drain Batter
^ Carriageway ^ ^ Carriageway
S oulder Shoult ir
Median Traffic
\er9 I Shoulder Shoulder Lanes erg
Batter
Batter
*:^^:^3^5^^ Natural
Surface ^\^>S^/\\^
3.3 ALIGNMENT
The layout of the centre line of the highway on the ground is called alignment. The
horizontal alignment includes the straight path, the horizontal deviations and curves.
Vertical alignment covers changes in gradient and vertical curves. The alignment should
be such that it offers maximum utility, by serving maximum population/ industry per unit
length.
3.3.1 Requirements
• The alignment between two terminal stations should be short and as far as possible
be straight, but due to some practical considerations deviations may be needed.
• The alignment should be easy to construct and maintain. It should be easy for the
operation of vehicles, so to the maximum extent easy gradients and curves should be
provided.
16
CHAPTER 3: ROAD GEOMETRIC DESIGN
• It should be safe both from the construction and operating point of view especially at
slopes, embankments, and cutting. It should have safe geometric features.
• The alignment should be economical and it can be considered so only when the
initia] cost, maintenance cost, and operating cost are minimum.
It is not always possible to satisfy all the requirement for an alignment. Hence we
have to make a judicial choice considering all the factors. The various factors that control
the alignment are as follows:
• Obligatory points: These are the control points governing the highway alignment.
These points are classified into two categories. Points through which alignment
should pass and points through which it should not pass. Some of the examples are:
~ Bridge site: The bridge should be located only where the river has straight and
permanent path and also where the abutment and pier can be strongly founded.
The road approach to the bridge should not be ctirved and skew crossing should
be avoided as far as possible. Thus location of a bridge may change the highway
alignment.
These were some of the obligatory points through which the alignment should
pass. Coming to the second category that is the points through which the alignment
should not pass are:
- Religious places: These have been protected by the law from being acquired for
any purpose. Therefore, these points should be avoided while aligning a road.
17
' CHAPTER 3: ROAD GEOMETRIC DESIGN
deviated not to pass through such points.
- Lakes/ponds etc: The presence of a lake or pond on the alignment path would
also necessitate deviation of the alignment.
Traffic: The alignment should suit the traffic requirements. Based on the origin-
destination data of the area, the desire lines should be drawn. The new alignment
should be drawn keeping in view the desire lines, traffic flow pattern etc.
Geometric design: Geometric design factors such as gradient, radius of curve, sight
distance etc. also govern the alignment of the highway. All the factors are further
governed by design speed. The design standards vary with the class of road and the
terrain and accordingly the highway should be aligned.
Other considerations; Other factors that govern the alignment are drainage
considerations, political factors and monotony.
- Drainage; Though the surface water can be drained off to the side drains by
providing proper camber on the pavement surface and cross slope on
shoulders, a certain longitudinal slope is essential, to drain the water along the
side drain, depending on the surface of the drains.
18
CHAPTER 3: ROAD GEOMETRIC DESIGN
alternative from the construction costs and related benefits considerations, before
finalising an alignment. By adopting such an approach, many unfavourable features can
be avoided like long length covered by problematic soils (e.g.. Black Cotton soils), too
many cross-drainage works, high cost bridges, landslide susceptible slopes on hill roads
etc. Similarly, the ease with which the desired geometric design standards can be attained
may vary from one alternative to another alternative. Once the road is aligned and
constructed, it is not easy to change the alignment due to increase in cost of adjoining
land and construction of costly structures by the road side.
The horizontal design of a road is a plan view and usually consists of a series of
straights and circular curves. A combination of factors such as design speed, radius of
circular curves, type and length transition curves, superelevation and widening of
pavement on curves are used to assist the circular movement of a vehicle. The alignment
should enable consistent, safe and smooth movement of vehicles operating at design
speed.
While designing the various elements of the road like superelevation, we design it
for a particular vehicle called design vehicle which has some standard weight and
dimensions. But in the actual case, the road has to cater for mixed traffic. Different
vehicles with different dimensions and varying speeds ply on the road. For example, in
the case of a heavily loaded truck with high centre of gravity and low speed,
superelevation should be less, otherwise chances of toppling are more. Taking into
practical considerations of all such situations, IRC has given some guidelines about the
maximum and minimum superelevation. Depends on (a) slow moving vehicle and (b)
heavy loaded trucks with high CG. IRC specifies a maximum super-elevation of 7 percent
for plain and rolling terrain, while that of hilly terrain is 10 percent and urban road is 4
percent. The minimum super elevation is 2-4 percent for drainage purpose, especially for
large radius of the horizontal curve.
The radius of the horizontal curve is an important design aspect of the geometric
design. The maximum comfortable speed on a horizontal curve depends on the radius of
19
' CHAPTER 3: ROAD GEOMETRIC DESIGN
the curve. Although it is possible to design the curve with maximum superelevation and
coefficient of friction, it is not desirable because re-alignment would be required if the
design speed is increased in future. Therefore, a ruling minimum radius Rruiing can be
derived by assuming maximum superelevation and coefTicient of friction.
•-ruling
e = superelevation, percent
Ideally, the radius of the curve should be higher than RruUng- However, very large curves
are also not desirable. Setting out large curves in the field becomes difficult. In addition,
it also enhances driving strain.
The reasons for the mechanical widening are: When a vehicle negotiates a
horizontal curve, the rear wheels follow a path of shorter radius than the front wheels.
This phenomenon is called off -tracking, and has the effect of increasing the effective
width of a road space required by the vehicle. Therefore, to provide the same clearance
between vehicles traveling in opposite direction on curved roads as is provided on straight
sections, there must be extra width of carriageway available. This is an important factor
when high proportions of vehicles are using the road. Trailor trucks also need extra
20
CHAPTER 3: ROAD GEOMETRIC DESIGN
carriageway, depending on the type of joint. In addition speeds higher than the design
speed causes transverse skidding which requires additional width for safety purpose. If
the road has n lanes, R is the mean radius of the curve and I is the length of wheel base of
longest vehicle then the mechanical widening (Wm) of a road is given by,
^•^ 2R
Widening of pavements has to be done for some psychological reasons also. There is a
tendency for the drivers to drive close to the outer edges of the pavement on curves. Some
extra space is to be provided for more clearance for the crossing and overtaking
operations on curves. IRC proposed an empirical relation for the psychological widening
at horizontal curves Wps:
2.64VR
We = Wn,+Wps
nV V
2R 2.64VR
3.4.1 Overview
Another important feature in road design is the vertical alignment. This is the
elevation of the central line of the horizontal alignment. The vertical alignment of a road
consists of gradients (straight lines in a vertical plane) and vertical curves. The vertical
alignment is usually drawn as a profile, which is a graph with elevation as vertical axis
and the horizontal distance along the centre line of the road as the horizontal axis.
Horizontal circular curve is used to connect horizontal straight stretches of road, vertical
21
CHAPTER 3: ROAD GEOMETRIC DESIGN
curves connect two gradients. Vertical curves are either convex or concave. The former is
called a summit curve, while the latter is called a valley curve. This section covers a
discussion on gradient and summit curves.
It includes level stretches, slopes or grades and vertical curves (summit and valley
curves). Many factors influence the vertical alignment design are vehicle speed,
acceleration, deceleration, stopping distance, sight distance and comfort in vehicle
movement at high speed.
3.4.2 Gradient
Gradient is the rate of rise or fall along the length of the road with respect to the
horizontal. It is expressed as a ratio of 1 in N (1 vertical unit to N horizontal units) as
shown in Fig. 3.2. Before finalizing the gradients, the construction cost, vehicular
operation cost and the practical problems in the site also has to be considered. Usually
steep gradients are avoided as far as possible because of the difficulty to climb and
increase in the vehicle operation cost.
Table 3.3 IRC Specifications for gradients for different roads as per SP 23:1993
• Ruling gradient
22
CHAPTER 3: ROAD GEOMETRIC DESIGN
• Limiting gradient
• Exceptional gradient
• Minimum gradient
Different types of grades are discussed below and the recommended type of
gradients for each type of terrain and type of gradient is given in table 3.4.
• Ruling Gradient
The ruling gradient or the design gradient is the maximum gradient with which the
designer attempts to design the vertical profile of the road. This depends on the terrain,
length of the grade, speed, pulling power of the vehicle and the presence of the horizontal
curve. In flatter terrain, it may be possible to provide flat gradients, but in hilly terrain it is
not economical and sometimes not possible also. The ruling gradient is adopted by the
designer by considering a particular speed as the design speed and for a design vehicle with
standard dimensions. But our country has a heterogeneous traffic and hence it is not
possible to lay down precise standards for the country as a whole. Hence IRC has
•ecommended some values for ruling gradient for different types of terrain.
• Limiting Gradient
This gradient is adopted when the ruling gradient results in enormous increase in
(bost of construction. On roiling terrain and hilly terrain it may be frequently necessary to
j.dopt limiting gradient. But the length of the limiting gradient stretches should be limited
md. must be sandwiched by either straight roads or easier grades.
• Exceptional Gradient
The maximum length of the ascending gradient which a loaded truck can operate
23
CHAPTERS: ROAD GEOMETRIC DESIGN
without undue reduction in speed is called critical length of the grade for a design. The
critical length for design depends on several factors such as size, power, load and grade
ability of the truck, initial speed and final desirable minimum speed.
• Minimum Gradient
When a vehicle is negotiating a horizontal curve, if there is a gradient also, then there
will be increased resistance to traction due to both curve and the gradient. In such cases, the
total resistance should not exceed the resistance due to gradient specified. For the design, in
some cases this maximum value is limited to the ruling gradient and in some cases as
limiting gradient. So if a curve need to be introduced in a portion which has got the
maximum permissible gradient, then some compensation should be provided so as to
decrease the gradient for overcoming the tractive loss due to curve. Thus grade
compensation can be defined as the reduction in gradient at the horizontal curve because
of the additional tractive force required due to curve resistance, which is intended to
offset the extra tractive force involved at the curve. IRC gave the following specification
for the grade compensation.
1. Grade compensation is not required for grades flatter than 4% because the loss of
tractive force is negligible.
meters.
75
3. The maximum grade compensation is limited to — %•
R
3.4.3 Summit Curves
Summit curves are vertical curves with convexity upwards. They are formed when
24
I CHAPTER 3: ROAD GEOMETMC DESIGN
two gradients meet as illustrated in figure 3.3 in any of the following four ways:
1. When a positive gradient meets another flatter positive gradient (Fig. 3.3 a).
4. When a descending gradient meets another steeper descending gradient (Fig. 3.3 d).
Different types of gradients and IRC recommendations for their maximum and
gradient, grade compensation has to be provided. Due to changes in grade in the vertical
alignment of the highway, vertical curves become essential. One of the application of
summit curves that can be seen usually in the urban areas are where fly-overs come.
+ n2
/-) N = n.
n2 = 0
+ n.
+ n,
(a
/^ N = ni+n2
-fii
+ ni J
-n?
(0
-n2
Figure 3.3 Types of Summit Curves
In determining the type and length of the vertical curve, the design considerations
Among these, sight distance requirements for the safety is most important on summit
curves. The stopping sight distance or absolute minimum sight distance should be
provided on these curves and where overtaking is not prohibited, overtaking sight
distance or intermediate sight distance should be provided as far as possible. When a fast
moving vehicle travels along a summit curve, there is less discomfort to the passengers.
This is because the centrifugal force will be acting upwards while the vehicle negotiates a
summit curve which is against the gravity and hence a part of the tyre pressure is relieved.
Also if the curve is provided with adequate sight distance, the length would be sufficient
to ease the shock due to change in gradient. Circular summit curves are identical since the
radius remains same throughout and hence the sight distance. From this point of view,
transition curves are not desirable since it has varying radius and so the sight distance will
also vary. The deviation angle provided on summit curves for highways are very large,
and so the a simple parabola is almost congruent to a circular arc, between the same
tangent points. Parabolic curves is easy for computation and also it had been found out
that it provides good riding comfort to the drivers. It is also easy for field implementation.
Due to all these reasons, a simple parabolic curve is preferred as summit curve.
The important design aspect of the summit curve is the determination of the length
of the curve which is parabolic. As noted earlier, the length of the curve is guided by the
sight distance consideration. That is. a driver should be able to stop his vehicle safely if
there is an obstruction on the other side of the road. Equation of the parabola is given by y
2 ^
= ax , where a =-—, where N is the deviation angle and L is the length of the In deriving
the length of the curve, two situations can arise depending on the uphill and downhill
gradients when the length of the curve is greater than the sight distance and the length of
Let L is the length of the summit curve, S is the SSD/ISD/OSD, N is the deviation angle,
hi driver's eye height (1.2 m), and hs the height of the obstruction, then the length of the
NS'
L = 2S-
N
When stopping sight distance is considered the height of driver's eye above the
road surface (hj) is taken as 1.2 metres, and height of object above the pavement surface
(h2) is taken as 0.15 metres. If overtaking sight distance is considered, then the value of
driver's eye height (hi) and the height of the obstruction (h2) are taken equal as 1.2
metres.
The valley curve should be designed such that there is enough headlight sight
distance. Improperly designed valley curves results in extreme riding discomfort as well
as accident risks especially at nights. The length of valley curve for various cases were
also explained in the section. The concept of valley curve is used in underpasses.
This section deals with the types of valley curve and their geometrical design.
Valley curve or sag curves are vertical curves with convexity downwards. They are
formed when two gradients meet as illustrated in figure 3.4 in any of the following four
ways:
1. When a descending gradient meets another flatter descending gradient (Fig. 3.4 a).
4. When an ascending gradient meets another steep ascending gradient (Fig. 3.4 d).
HI
n2=0
(a) (b)
ni .,
N = (n2-n.)
""'•<) N = -(n,4-n2) J-
(c) <d)
There is no restriction to sight distance at valley curves during day time. But
visibility is reduced during night. In the absence or inadequacy of street light, the only
source for visibility is with the help of headlights. Hence valley curves are designed
taking into account of headlight distance. In valley curves, the centrifugal force will be
acting downwards along with the weight of the vehicle, and hence impact to the vehicle
will be more. This will result in jerking of the vehicle and cause discomfort to the
(2) availability of stopping sight distance under headlight of vehicles for night
driving.
For gradually introducing and increasing the centrifugal force acting downwards, the best
shape that could be given for a valley curve is a transition curve. Cubic parabola is
During night, imder headlight driving condition, sight distance reduces and availability of
stopping sight distance under head light is very important. The head light sight distance
should be at least equal to the stopping sight distance. There is no problem of overtaking
sight distance at night since the other vehicles with headlights could be seen from a
considerable distance.
The valley curve is made fully transitional by providing two similar transition
curves of equal length The transitional curve is set out by a cubic parabola y = bx^ where
2N
b = —Y ^^ length of the valley transition curve is designed based on two criteria:
The length of the valley curve based on the rate of change of centrifrigal
acceleration that will ensure comfort: Let L is the length of valley curve, c is the rate of
change of acceleration, R the minimum radius of the curve, v is the design speed and t is
1—1
Where, L is the total length of valley curve, N is the deviation angle in radians or
—— -^ 29
CHAPTER 3: ROAD GEOMETRIC DESIGN
tangent of the deviation angle or the algebraic difference in grades, and c is the allowable
2. Safety criteria; ensuring adequate headlight sight distance at any part of the curve
during night driving.
Length of the valley curve for headlight distance may be determined for two
conditions: (1) length of the valley curve greater than stopping sight distance and (2)
length of die vaKey curve less than the stopping sight distance.
Case 1: Length of valley curve greater than stopping sight distance (L > S)
The total length of valley curve L is greater than the stopping sight distance SSD.
The sight distance available will be minimum when the vehicle is in the lowest point in
the valley. This is because the beginning of the curve will have infinite radius and the
bottom of the curve will have minimum radius which is a property of the transition curve
2h|+2^tanflf
where N is the deviation angle in radians, hi is the height of headlight beam, a is the head
beam inclination in degrees and S is the sight distance. The inclination a is == 1 degree.
Case 2: Length of valley curve less than stopping sight distance (L < S)
The length of the curve L is less than SSD. In this case the minimum sight
distance is from the beginning of the curve. The important points are the beginning of the
curve and the bottom most part of the curve. If the vehicle is at the bottom of the curve,
then its headlight beam will reach far beyond the endpoint of the curve whereas, if the
vehicle is at the beginning of the curve, then the headlight beam will hit just outside the
curve. Therefore, the length of the curve is derived by assuming the vehicle at the
4.1 INTRODUCTION
The survey data chosen for the research work was taken from Eugene-Springfield,
Oregon. Survey was done using total station for the existing ground features in the area
under study. Survey data text file contain data as space separated (tab delimited text)
values. Each record line of data must hold "Serial-Number X Y Z Feature-Code".
In case of Survey by Total Station the points must be in proper sequence, so that when
joined will describe the shape of the feature (say a house) in the drawing.
All 2-D features are assigned a null value for elevations or 'Z' values as *-999'. In
this way we are able to register the presence of a level while ignoring its value. Null
levels are also usefiil when recording feature strings for objects such as hedges and
fences, where levels are often not required. All 3-D features will have positive or zero
values of 'Z' or elevation and must be stored in a separate text file with a file name of
maximum eight characters. This file name will be considered as the Model name holding
a set of Strings having labels obtainedfi*omthe Feature-Code written in the text file.
First GENIO file is created from the given data which can be used as one of the
common input mode for both the software and surface analysis is done on the data.
Contouring and triangulation is done to check the profile of the area and to check any
discrepancy if any in the survey data.
GENIO,DESIGN ROAD
001,Format(4F12.3)
003,ORDR,4-1,1,2,3,4
31
i CHAPTER 4: INPUT DATA STRUCTURE
080,ROAD„,7=4
00087103.01900271741.583-0000999.00000000001.000
00087228.61400271546.550-0000999.00000000002.000
00087285.75500270982.395-0000999.00000000003.000
00087115.95500270271.970-0000999.00000000004.000
00087570.62300269953.083-0000999.00000000005.000
00087739.00200269674.307-0000999.00000000006.000
00088116.26100269384.432-0000999.00000000007.000
00088410.41600269062.255-0000999.00000000008.000
00089200.12200268556.592-0000999.00000000009.000
00089419.28500267908.801-0000999.00000000010.000
00000000.00000000000.000
999
FINISH
4.2 HEADS
String based software generally starts functioning using the Detail Survey data
primarily using Total Station instrument. The GPS instrument is used to collect location
of HIPs for setting of alignment of the road on existing ground. The GPS data is more
reliable if obtained in the form of Longitude and Latitude (than in the form of East
North), the Longitude Latitude data may be converted to Easting and Northing by using
correct parameters specific to the location in the globe shown in Fig.4.1. Once the GPS
data are available in Easting and Northing, these become usable by the Total Station
instrument. The data conversion needs correct parameters and the process is also quite
cumbersome. Here comes HEADS as the complete solution for all these requirements by
the site engineers at simplest effort. Table 4.1 shows the sample data for feature LOTS
32
CHAPTER 4: INPUT DATA STRUCTURE
collected using Total Station. Table 4.2 and Table 4.3 shows the two type formats of data
collected using Auto Level accepted by HEADS.
HEADS produces detailed reports for every analysis and design and CAD
drawings for Plan & Profile, Cross sections with designed Pavement Layers, Mass Haul
diagram, Contours, Ground Models, DTM, Digital Mapping, Benched/Stepped slopes for
Cut & Fill in Embankment construction. Embankment Toes on either side. Road side
Drains, Gabion walls in Hill roads, Diagrammatic details for Horizontal & Vertical
alignments and Super Elevations, and detailed design reports required for preparation &
submissions for various Detail Project Reports.
j^rQKiiU n
ZLttrtHriCDrrwMlConePreiKtion r F^rtijCCToWeSW
SphaioMPatailfietai*
A- fB377apV,2<3
F- ijs; mamf
I.
XOffw*- [3000000
, VOffHt hoooooo
I. 'Origh - -
'LaOft«*(D,M.SJ. |i9* |l4.38ie
: UxvQFlMlD.M.S]'*!^
f StwxUrdPwalult
|RHtl(D,M.S|-
'F
;PMt2(D,M,S|-
W
ftoo—d I
33
CHAPTER 4: INPUT DATA STRUCTURE
Table 4.1 Sample Data for feature LOTS using Total Station
34
CHAPTER 4: INPUT DATA STRUCTURE
Table 4.3 Sample Data Type 2
Chainage 12000
Offset (m) -20 -5 _4 -3.52 -2.5 0 3.5 7
R L ( m ) 36.544 36.544 36.714 36.809 37.539 36.609 37.653 37.568
12010
-20 -5 -4 -3.6 -2.5 0 3.5 7
36.364 36.689 36.794 36.864 37.524 37.589 37.653 37.528
12020
-20 -5 -4 -3.36 -2.5 0 3.5 7
36.254 36.464 36.574 36.574 37.489 37.564 37.686 37.556
12030
-21 -12 -5 -4 -3.33 -2.5 0 3.5
36.239 36.324 366.524 37.574 37.449 37.474 37.541 37.446
12040
-21 -12 -5 -4 -3.72 -2.5 0 3.5
36.309 36.429 36.489 36.539 37.319 37.359 37.381 37.281
12050
-20 -5 -4 -3.52 -2.5 0 3.5 7
36.544 36.544 36.714 36.809 37.539 36.609 37.653 37.568
4.3 MX ROAD
The methods used by the two programs to access the survey data and to analyze it
are very different. HEADS accepts all sort of survey data i.e. total station data, auto level
data in its raw form and it even accepts the data entered manually in a text file. The
naming convention of strings does not cause any trouble in displaying and analyzing the
data on the other hand if the data formal does not match for MX Road naming convention
it will not accept it or shows absurd results. Unlike HEADS, the user must set up a
specified database for survey data when using MX Road. In other words, the role of
surveyor is very crucial for the design and analysis of any road project in MX. The string
naming convention must be clearly defined to Surveyor before the start of any MX Road
project.
35
' CHAPTER 4: INPUT DATA STRUCTURE
Sample data for fixed type Auto Level is shown in Table 4.4.
Sample data for variable type Auto Level is shown in Table 4.5.
36
CHAPTER 4: INPUT DATA STRUCTURE
CHAPTER 5
DESIGN STEPS
5.1 INTRODUCTION
Alignment is used to create the master string on which the rest of our design is
based; typically, this would be a highway or railway center line or equivalent.
In all three methods, design and display parameters govern the properties of the
curves and how they are displayed on the screen.
Once the horizontal design is in place, we can do the vertical design, i.e. add
elevations to the alignment and to assist us in specifying the elevations, a profile of the
ground from the survey model is displayed so we can see where to position the alignment.
When the alignment is completed, two strings are created in our design model; the
master string and its associated geometry string which describes the geometry of the
alignment.
Design a String options are used to derive additional strings from a meiSieT string;
typically, for a highway project, these would be strings such as roadway edge or hard
shoulder strings. The different options allow us to specify different information to create
the strings, for example, we can specify a horizontal and a vertical offset from the master
string, or a horizontal offset and a cross slope.
Feature sets are particulariy useful here as we can select the type of feature we
want (eg, shoulder) and the next available string name is automatically assigned.
The Earthworks Wizard is used to create earthworks strings, ie, strings which
37
\ CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
define the intersection between our design and the ground. The earthwork design rehes on
the specification of earthwork styles, together with any alternative strategies to be used
when certain criteria are met. These strategies determine the shape of the earthworks
slope in particular situations.
To make the procedure as simple as possible, the wizard has access to a library of
earthwork styles such as simple slope and slope^ench combination styles, which can be
used immediately. Additionally, we can create our own custom earthworks styles specific
to the current design or our national design rules. These custom earthwork styles can be
saved in our own library for iuture use.
Once created, the earthworks strings may be drawn with tadpole annotation or
with slope signature strings.
Section is used to create cross sections from a string, and profiles along a string or a
straight line. Both types of section are useful for checking the quality of a design, and cross
sections can also be used to calculate volumes. The sections created are displayed in a separate
viewer used by the software. In the Viewer, we can add many types of annotation and inspect
the design for any errors or weaknesses. At any time, we can create a working drawing of the
sections we are viewing.
Contour generates contours from a triangulation. The contours are categorized as either
index contours or normal contours, where index contours are used to indicate a significant
height interval, for example, an index contour can be generated for every five normal
contours.
The Area options calculate the plan or surface area of a model. We can define the part of
the model whose area is required either by boundary strings or by means of two strings limited
in extent by normals to a reference string.
38
I CHAPTER^DESIGN STEPS
Surface Analysis is a wizard which simplifies the analysis processes and displays the
results in graphical form. We can perform analyses to show elevations, slopes or aspect bands,
or show all slopes which are less than a specified grade. We can also display flat spots and flow
arrows. The wizard also handles sectioning and triangulation automatically.
Volumetric Anafysis is a Wizard for calculatii^ cut and fill areas and volumes, either
between two surfaces, or between a surface and a plane. It has many potential uses in civil
engineering,fix)mthe analysis of linear schemes such as roads and railroads, through to quarrying
and dredging works. Comparing two surfaces could be used to analyze the difference between
the existing ground and a pad for a building, or the bottom of a layer of contaminated material.
Comparing a surface with a plane could be used to model navigation channels (where the plane
could be the mean low water level), or to model retaining structures such as reservoir dams.
The analysis can then be output as a report. We can then save or print the report.
Stepl:
Select Folder "Survey Data" and select File containing survey data.
Output: Survey.DGM Select HEADS menu option "DGM_Modeling from 2D/3D or Text
DGM [GENIO]"
Click on "Proceed",
39
CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
The File is processed and HEADS model is created in files MODEL.FIL and
MODEL.LST
Step 2:
Click on "OK",
Click on "OK",
Click on "Proceed",
The File is processed and Digital Terrain Model (DTM) is created in file HDSOOl .FIL
Step 3:
Click on "RUN",
Click on "Save",
The File is processed and Contours are created in files MODEL.FIL and MODEL.LST
Step 4:
40
{ CHAPTER^: DESIGN STEPS
Select HEADS menu option "Geometrics_200 Halignment"
Click on "Proceed",
The File is processed and Horizontal Alignment is created as model DESIGN and string
MOOl in files MODEL.FIL and MODEL.LST
Step 5:
In the layer Dialog, in the top right box, click mouse and type a layer name "GROUND"
Click in the small square box, in the row "GROUND" and Column "Color",
Click on "OK" in the Color box. Click on "OK" in the layer Dialog to close.
Step 6:
41
I CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
In the layer Dialog, in the top right box, click mouse and type a layer name "CONTOUR
01"
Click in the small square box, in the row "CONTOUR 01" and Column "Color",
Click on "OK" in the Color box, Click on "CONTOUR 01" in the List in the layer
Dialog,
Click on button "Set Current", Click on "OK" in the layer Dialog to close.
Select Model Name "CONTOUR", Select String label "COOl", Click on "OK",
Click on "View_Zoom_ZoomExtends",
Step 7:
In the layer Dialog, in the top right box, click mouse and type a layer name "CONTOUR
05"
Click in the small square box, in the row "CONTOUR 05" and Column "Color",
Click on "OK" in the Color box. Click on "CONTOUR 05" in the List in the layer
Dialog,
Click on button "Set Current", Click on "OK" in the layer Dialog to close.
Select Viewer menu option "File_Draw String", Select Model Name "CONTOUR",
Click on "View_Zoom_ZoomExtends",
Step 8:
In the layer Dialog, in the top right box, click mouse and type a layer name "DSMCOO"
Click on button "New layer", TTie Layer "DSMCOO" comes in the List below.
Click in the small square box, in the row "D$ MCOO" and Column "Color",
Click on "OK" in the Color box, Click on "DSMCOO" in the List in the layer Dialog,
Click on button "Set Current", Click on "OK" in the layer Dialog to close.
Select Viewer menu option "File_Draw Stnng", Select Model Name "DESIGNS",
Click on "View_Zoom_2oomExtends",
Step 9:
In the layer Dialog, in the top right box, click mouse and type a layer name "MCOO"
Click on button "New layer", The Layer "MCOO" comes in the List below,
Click in the small square box, in the row "MCOO" and Column "Color",
Color box appears, take RED or any other Color, Click on "OK" in the Color box.
Click on "MCOO" in the List in the layer Dialog, Click on button ''Set Current,
Click on "OK" in the layer Dialog to close, Select Viewer menu option "FiIe_Draw
String",
Select Model Name "DESIGN", Select String label "MCOO", Click on "OK",
Step 10:
Step 11:
HIP and Curve details are displayed along the alignment string MCOO
Step 12:
The File name is displayed at the top, as the file Settmgout.DWG is saved.
Step 13:
Click on "Proceed",
The File is processed, Alignment string MCOO and DIM file HDSOOl.FIL and Original
Ground Levels (OGL) model & strings is created as DESIGN & EOOl in files
MODEL.FIL and MODEL.LST
Click on "Proceed",
For all messages click on "OK", finally on "Finish", The File is processed and Vertical
Alignment is created in model DESIGN and string MOOl in files MODEL.FIL and
MODEL.LST Design database file is created as VALIGN.FIL
Step 15:
In the layer Dialog, in the top right box, click mouse and type a layer name "OGL"
Click in the small square box, in the row "OGL" and Column "Color",
Click on "OK",
Click on "View_Zoom_ZoomExtends",
Click on "OK",
Click on "View_Zoom_ZoomExtends",
Step 16:
In the layer Dialog, in the top right box, click mouse and type a layer name "GRADES'
Click in the small square box, in the row "GRADES" and Column "Color",
Click on "OK",
Click on "View_Zoom_ZoomExtends",
46
JCHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
step 17:
In the layer Dialog, in the top right box, click mouse and type a layer name "PROFILE"
Click in the small square box, in the row "PROFILE" and Column "Color",
Click on "OK",
Click on "View_Zoom_ZoomExtends",
Click on "OK",
Click on "View_Zoom_ZoomExtends",
Step 18:
47
1 CHAPTER 5:^ESIGN STEPS
From same Folder "Survey Data", select File "07 Input-04_Offset_VO"
Click on "Proceed",
The File is processed and all strings for Carriageway are created in model DESIGN and
strings as
CLOl, CL02, CL03, CROl, CR02 AND CR03 in files MODEL.FIL and MODEL.LST
Step 19:
Click on "Proceed",
The File is processed and all strings for Carriageway as CLOl, CL02, CL03, CROl, CR02
AND
CR03 are combined to create road cross sections at user given interval along the
Chainages.
Step 20:
48
CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
Select HEADS menu option "Geometrics_600 Interface"
Click on "Proceed",
Step 21:
Click on "Proceed",
The File is processed and Quantities for Earthwork for Cut/Fill from road to Ground cross
sections are created at user given interval along the Chainages.
"File_Import DRG" and from the working folder select file MassHaul.DRG, For full view
use menu option, View_Zoom_ZoomExtends. May save the drawing as DWG.
Step 22:
Click on "Proceed",
The File is processed and 3 Cross Section Drawings are created as XSECl, XSEC2 &
49
|CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
XSEC3 within folder "Design Drawings".
Step 23:
Click on "Proceed",
The file may be viewed by using Viewer menu option "Filejmport DRG".
Step 24:
The file may be viewed by using Viewer menu option "File_Import DRG".
Step 25:
From same Folder "Survey Data", select File "14 Input-1 l_ProOffset"
Step 26:
The File is processed and Long Section Drawing is created as LSECl within folder
"Design Drawings". The files may be viewed by using Viewer menu option "File_Open".
Step 27:
From same Folder "Survey Data", select File "16 Drawing^l 100 PLAN"
The File is processed and Long Section Drawing is created as PLANl within folder
"Design Drawings". The files may be viewed by using Viewer menu option "File_0pen".
1^
Excel Information - — ^ -
Next >>
Excei Spreadsheet Name:
Cancel
first Ro« Containing Data; Y^
First Column Containing Data;
Data T y p c ^ —
Variable Offset ^ ' Fixed Offset Q
51
CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
Add-In tool (Fig. 5.1) which directly takes chainage-offset data from Excel Spreadsheet
i) Purpose:
This add-in allows direct import of two types of chainage-offset data into MX w.r.t a
reference string.
1) Variable Offset
2) Fixed Offset
ii) Features
1. Variable Offset
2. Fixed Offset
• Chainage, Fixed Offset in Columns, Levels for respective columns for the
chainage
iii) Requirements
1. An Excel data file for import. "N.B. this file MUST contain only one 'set' of data per
line and must be formatted in the same way throughout.
The Bonus Tool and any associated files are installed to ...\m^\exec folder and will be
JCHAPTERS^DESIGN STEPS
1. Select Import- Offset data from Add-rns>Persona( Add-Ins.
1. Click on 'Browse button' in Import Data spreadsheet option window (Fig. 5.2) and
select the "Variable sample.xls" file from the project directory.
m^QpG^ ^
; ipEKcel Information - ^-
Next >>
Excel Spreadsheet Name:
Variable sample.xls
First Row Containing Data: Cancel
i^Data Type
Variable Offset (? Fixed Offset Q
S
4. Click'Next»'
This will read the Excel data tile, identity the extents of data and take the information for
further processing. After it has processed it will display a panel to verify the processed
data.
5) This panel will display (Fig. 5.3) the loaded data; specify the data type for each
column.
r'-^JEEifJl . ^
1
. . - ^ z . ^^^__
- -
If 'Choifwff? IsJdeCLft) " " ! Offset Elevation ] Descripttori |:l*ll
) Next »
<i^mi ;L ?5 1 B,61B
Cancel
23 8591 1
. ^.5 6.511
1
! • •!
: 20 8501 b
1 185 ^ 9 1
_17 B.481
\ -H 1[iVJ
Total 2l6D5raws of data is Loaded
11
fcCLiCK ON THE CDiUVU KEADEnS TO OHfWGE THE DATA T W E -
B^vsfiwi
J.^jJ. ..Next»
Ch*»9B ^*sel Des —
Ouinage
8.E1E DMI
8591 SkJe(+H
B.S11 I Sde{HR)
8.501 Side not Avsiabi?
6) Type the new model name. Select type of string (P/L), select model containing
reference string and specify reference string name.
1. Click on 'Browse button' shown in Fig. 5.5 and select "Fixed Sample.xls "file
containing Auto level data of fixed type from project directory.
5. First Character of New strings for string name, and the model and string name of the
reference string.
Data T y p e
- F i x e d Offset
Model Name
[DESIGN
B:
, Strrg Name
Custom
3'
These strings will be imported as strings parallel to the reference string with the
levels specified. These strings will be created in the same model as reference string.
When we start MX, a startup panel is displayed. The startup panel gives us quick access
to the options on the initial File menu (Windows) or MX menu (AutoCAD and MicroStation), as
well as providing additional facilities for accessing Help and our project settings.
From either the startup panel or the File/MX menu, we can create a new project, open
an existing project, archive projects using the zip/unzip facility or access the on-line Help. Li
addition, the most recently opened projects are listed at the bottom of the menu.
55
CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
To create a new project, click the New Project button on the Startup panel or select New
Project from the MX menu bar, then specify the name of our project, its location and the location
of the design parameters to be used for this project. If the folder specify does not already exist, it
is created for the project.
An empty model file is created in the project folder when a new project is started.
However, if MX finds that there is already a model file in the folder, we can choose to keep it
rather than overwrite it with an empty one. This gives the opportunity to move an existing model
file in to place so we can continue with a design. If we are working on a project on the
network, perhaps because several people need access to the project, we can use the
network project facility to copy the project temporarily to our local disk, work on the
project, then copy it back again when we have finished. We should only have one project in
a folder.
pnnr TiJr
. - --
1 \
]
(i-
fTuh.nd U
.1
1,. ON . v . r , -^
JUUM,
Select new project for opening new project and open project for opening existing project
(Fig. 5.6).
Enter details of new project name and directory where project is to be stored in the
window opened. Select "default project setting" as "IN_metric" and tick on the non-
tangenfial alignment in the window. Then click OK to accept the data (name and
directory) supplied.
q|^li^IE]iaF^**'^-^'?^""^'Tft
t DK 1 1 Help I
The MX standard string naming convention is off. CHck OK in the pop up window as
shown in Fig. 5.7.
The survey model describes the existing ground and any other features which are
present in the area of our proposed design. It is essential that the data describing this
model is both complete and accurate, as any errors could have a serious impact on the
proposed design. It is also important that the string names in the import file conform to a
string naming convention used in a feature set and style set combination. We can either
change the names of the strings in our import file to suit an existing feature set and style
set, or we can create new ones.
The data describing the survey model can be input to MX in any of the following formats:
• MX Input
• MX GENIO
• MX Survey
• General ASCII
• MicroStation DGN
. LandXML
57
CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
ii;^i jTKixiTm m q i >i <
J l ^ File View TKF : Ds^ij] Ara'
Open Duplay^awTig..
liput.,
iDponOu^)ut'=Sft..
Cpen Jau-ialRfe..,
rtoL,.
(YrtDnpUf..
^f^OT...
UPM...
Fite MsnagBmen:
Eiplorar.,.
c o r w t to Ma>OAO E N : .,.
Irrport
BqDi-t
CtowrttiJKt
Btit
To import data in ASCII file format, select File Input (Fig. 5.8), for any of the MX
formats (e.g. GENIO). If the imported file contains drawing information, the survey model will
be created and drawn on the screen; otherwise we need to create a plan woricing display.
Now go to file and import data as ASCII File for total Station data and ASCII
import for (x,y,2) format data. Select the design modelfi-omdrop in command menu (Fig.
5.9)
t File View lools Desisi Analysis Modify D[£;^ay ft-aw Visualise Repoft Quantities Addilns £AD Help
' © i 3 @ ^1 SIJBSTRGSMX4iTUTORIA»123MG0l
"3^ S Slis:
Make sure that file type in selecfion popup window is "*.txt" (shown in Fig. 5.10).
58
CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
CJigD "MBl
Lookr: f O h o T "Zl ^ 1^ cJ- i i '
••t-iP ^MxData
MyR«»cenl 'Qstyfes
Docunenti
OetkiQp
My DocLinents
MjiCompulei
My Network
Places
Files oftype: lAutoCADDXFr.tM)
AuloCAD DXF ('.dKf)
"H Caicsl
Commands: Tools\ System Parameters\ String Naming and check the box.
^ ge gew l3ofc DftsJgn apalysis HMff. Dpptr ^ « « ysiAie Rstxit fiJHnSfiM Adcym £W tt* ; 1 ^ •(* ^ * ^ A ¥ ^ ,
Select the survey model entered (Fig. 5.11) then click on the icon next to drop in
command to view the survey data.
Select the Feature Set and Style Set in the next pop up window. Click on OK.
Select the model and set the parameters to be checked like null levels, etc as shown in
Fig. 5.12.
Then apply. Check the report if required. Click Cancel to leave the command then click
finish on next window to exit the window or rename the model to save.
59
\ CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
H
, Model Name f^e-.t
I^^^^^S" ;3 Cdnc^
JNoHsifciig
3]
Check*
r ZHoLevHs
•• L J r-Single PciniStrJnaj
I 1 | - t l ] r.HitfiPointt
. I * | - n r LowPortt
1^ I- p l r CofKidenI Pants
Save Settings
Name the model to be analyzed leave the rest of information software will pick it
up automatically and click on next. A toolbar will open (Fig. 5.13).
SgCSsaQiElB^
Next,
CorUou(s>
<Ba(^
Level 8arxls>
Cancei
Slope Bands >
Select the surface analysis required like contours, triangulation etc. by clicking on
the icons of respective analysis.
60
CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
'TjnsEife
intMval JLevobI Smooltw«]
• . Nwd>
Nottrd Conloui Intoival 1) ,|
<Ba(*
PiomnentConloulntBival IB ^ • '.
CvKcl
-ContouCotow* —
Normal Comout
• 01
Prominent Cor>lour)
J trpo^s.
For contouring click on the contour icon and enter the contour interval then click
on next (Fig. 5.14)
To save the model with contours click on finish otherwise click next.
For saving the contour model rename the model name in the popup window.
Same procedure will be adopted for all other surface analysis menus.
To check the models for contours and triangulation change the model from drop in
command and click on view.
Give the name of the model (different from previous one). Click on create model
on popup window and give the string name starting from "MC??" (Master String) and
then click next.
A menu for string editing will popup, select the ADD IP icon and make the
desired string (road) by clicking on the survey data.
We can accept the string by clicking on OK (Fig. 5.15) in the menu bar. Enter
start chainage and interval in the popup window.
61
CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
-it,--. -l-''«h
" T ^
Enter name of the model and string name (center line of the foad to be designed)
(MC??) then next.
Draw the string joining two end^_pQinjte_ and a point in center and click on join the
ends then click ok.
SteDesi^i
TraA Design
Design a String
AmendaString
EarthvrarksWizad...
Draiiage D e s i ^ . . .
/. Carriageway
Enter design model as model analyzed and design string as M??? or center line of the
road proposed.
62
i CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
Then select the road profile from the standard models or we can edit it as per
requirement by selected the desired model and then edit. Enter start chain age and end
chain age and finish to complete the design of road. Same steps are followed for rest
of the designs (super elevation, road widening, etc.).
2. Rule-based Super elevation (enter the design speed in the popup window for
super elevation)
5. Road widening
4. Shoulder Design
Enter the name of the design model (Fig. 5.17) in which road exists and string name
MC?? (center line of the road ) (Master string)
* . i»M<Jt,;.:Jittj.,. iii^Att„;\^
^
ModdDelait loFtulsl Next>
<B«:k
|MXTUT0RLAL123
J Cancel
| A P P ^ Cutrent Mastuhg
A
|TMPTR1ANGLES1
Enter the triangulation model as existing surface model and triangulation string as
TX??
63
CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
^•>,.. •,i-iH^^.i.i*-T'r,:£t.^^..tl^il^,-itJJfl.,,^. ^ ^
P^ General Repodt
Select the commands in the order it appears in the menu bar (Fig. 5.18).
• Subgrade Design
• Chainage
• General Reports
5.8 EARTHWORK
Enter triangulation model as ground model and 'TX??' string as triangulation string name
64
[ CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
^- •\v-.;;r,:^jl'-m*mniir
JS
)MXTUTDR1AL123 _-j
9f,.>.
Retaence S&tig Narne IMCOG '|
Cancel
[Road Centreline: ( M q T ]
(T(iengulatan{Kis6no [IX)
"3
^
"31
Assign earthwork style and strategy. We can assign earthwork style by selecting
style to one view and rest by simply dragging to the view from the selected one then click
on next (Fig.5.20).
.-CUttottiaHBW - — — • —
JM
'V <0SEk
C(«icd
eM
FilofrioLofl — — - I pF»lolhoRighl—• — —
|BByWXWwW_S'y'"^MFWSirtile5lQpB.rty -I | |lley\MX\m(w'JSi_5liilMWFWSinpleSlope.ity -I
AAonatfve 5tiategv> .. | ANocntfive S(7ala^ ... I
Enter start and end chain age in next window and click on finish.
5.9 QUANTITIES
Enter model name and model string name in the popup window (Fig. 5.21) and
then click next
65
CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
In the next popup window enter the name of triangulation model and triangulation string.
Select Calculate volume and then apply to get the report of cutting and filling. Save the
file in "*.txt" by clicking on "output to file" and then click next. In the next popup
window uncheck the store sections and click finish.
dSD^aftiflaa
Ecfit Section [ C a E u l ^ e ^ ^ ^ Preferences | Next>
Chalnage to <B3ck
Apply
10,000 •3 |1602.7GO 3
Cancel
Output fofiie
Section Set 1 Section Set 2
Design 31 iGround
31 f ? Apply Curvature Coriection Maximize
a) Plan
From the Final Drawing Manager select ''Add to Drawing\ Then select type of Drawing
> Plan.
Lastly, select the design model, confirm the style set used.
b) Profile
Add design model and center line of the road as 'Reference String' and then click next
66
CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
(V Rofte String Next>
FleJetence Modd
|MXTUT0R1AL123 Cancel
J
Referer^ce StfinQ jjj^ Open Set-up..
zl
d
|7 AM/Etk Sufacei
1
I -Y
1
-3
A popup window (Fig. 5.22) showing " Reference String Details" will open enter the
name of design model and master String " MC??" rest leave other information as default
and click next.
\
v?^lp7ri l¥c<M^,E"dil ion
4.
^
s/
In the popup window (Fig. 5.23) click on 'Additional Surface' menu to display 'Display
Associated String'. There are three profile types available; Surface Model, Associated
String and Offset Profile.
67
[CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
c) Surface Model
Select Additional Surface Model and select the triangulation model to the drawing as the
existing surface, then click OK. The profile of the existing ground is added to the
drawing.
d) Associated String
Select 'Display Associated String" and add the model name containing road and add the
string of carriageway edges.
e) Offset Profile
It displays a profile to the right and left of the reference string. Select 'Offset Profile' and
add contour model in 'Model to Section'.
In 'Reference Model' add design model and MC?? as design string and 6 m as offset
distance. Accept all changes then click finish.
f) Cross Sections
From the Final Drawings Manager, select Type of Drawing -> Create Sections.
The 'Create Cross Sections: Reference Details' panel is displayed (Fig. 5.24 ).
ISECTIQNS
Open Set-Up-, j
SavftSet-itt)..
Show Dc!<^^Jb
68
\ CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
Ensure that the reference model is set to design model and select the reference string as
master string.
Type the name of the model to store the cross sections. Tick Section Additional Models,
Limit or Add Section Locations and Display Cross Sections.
Click Next.
With EXISTING TIUA (TRIA) still selected in Selected Models, change the description
from Unknown to Existing Ground.
In Selected Models select DESIGN and change the description from Unknown to Design.
Click Next.
Select Method All Chainages, and click Add to add to the chainage list.
Click Finish.
The cross sections are generated and the Draw Cross Sections panel is displayed.
Tick all the Available Sections. Select the DESIGN reference model and change
the Line Colour to Red. Select the EXISTING reference model and change the Line
Colour to Green.
Select the Position tab. Check Defined by XY to manually select the insertion
location for the sections. Change the Vertical Exaggeration to 1:5. Ensure that the Gap
between Sections is set to 100. Set the Section Insertion Point Rounding Value to 1. Tick
Place Sections in an Array. Set Maximum Number of Sections in a Column to 20 and
Column Offset to 250.
Select Apply, and then fit view to see all the sections displayed in a grid layout.
—^. ^r^ ~ - ^9
I CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
5.11 ANNOTATION
Add configuration for Plan, Profile and Cross sections separately by selecting respective
*.mxtip file from the library of the MX Road in C:\ programV Bentley.
Once the Survey model file has been copied to local project directory run the
Survey INPUT files into an empty model file to view the existing ground information. In
this section following steps are discussed:
L UMMMOi
Once the survey information has been run into MX, we now
need to display this information on the screen. To do this, we need 1
to create a New Plan Display (Fig. 5.25): ^^
2. A dialog box will appear asking for the name of the new
Irt-r
plan display. Enter the new name and click OK. We are now
working in new display. We should verify this by reading the title
bar at the top of the MX window. It shows the path of your current Fig. 5.25 New Plan
Display
display or drawing.
Each model contained in the model file should be assigned a default style and
^jm
-- - — -
OK 1
J •
CaiK<ri 1
Sljrta 3 i ^ Nama
iPfwateStyfesSmdol plan coloi.pJS
Feature S H
y
|PnvaleSt}fes\mdo< plan coloi.fns ^^^
P ijMk S t ^ and Hebjn Set
OMOtnc
To set the default style and feature set at any time (Fig. 5.26):
2. Click on each model name that's listed, a style and feature set is assigned at the bottom
of the panel under the Model Defaults frame. If not, then we need to assign them. To
assign a default style and feature set, select the model in the Model Names List, and then
click on the Edit button.
D^.i^Hodei
a
1 CONTQUf^
TEMP ^
TEXT
TRAVERSE
3. Find the correct Style and Feature sets for the GROUND model by clicking on the
small buttons shown in the picture on the right.
On some occasions, users forget to assign a model's style and feature sets before
attempting to use the model in one of the MXRoad panels. A model control looks like as
shown in Fig. 5.27:
71
[CHAPTER^DESIGN STEPS
If we like to set the default feature and style sets for the current model listed in the model
control (Fig. 5.28):
Der3nMt>iH
j^v,:.:iTJ
WorkngD
flrtwKncB S»mg Narr»e
J j y Stfi-j
|AII ^ J*i(|PSi.*LJ
p Si*!cH'Ofn Masts* Stii
^'^ cut
Cooy
3. Assign the style and feature sets as outlined in step 3 of Method 1 shown above.
ffitJUnW^WBIUHI - — [ ^
- -
Mendel N B P C OK 1
j.:i^^»ii
™ ^ Aw* t
^-•roNmm ^^^^^
2l Cancel j
N..__.. izl
'•^.it
QNL.
J ^
Fig. 5.29 Display: Plan with Style Set
1. Select Display => Plan with Style Set from the menu bar (Fig. 5.29)
2. Select the model to be displayed (GROUND), and set the scale and style set if we
want to use a different one than is shown in the panel. When the information is correct,
select either OK to draw the GROUND model and dismiss the panel, or APPLY to draw
the ground model, and keep the panel open to specify another model. We can quit this
panel by clicking Cancel.
72
[ CHAPTERS: DESIGN
DESIG STEPS
5.11.5 Creating a Plan Page Layout
To create plots of the model data, MX has a pre-defined set of drawing sheets.
MX provides an interactive means to do this called Plan Page Layout. These layouts can
be saved in the project directory, and a number of different layouts can be created with
different sheet sizes, etc.
Select Draw => Working Drawings => Create New Drawing from the menu bar.
The first panel is a default panel. Browse to the correct locations for the sheets.
Click on the Private folder. This will open up the correct path for the project.
On the Page Setup Panel, Select the page description from the File Details area at
the bottom of the panel, or select one of the sheets shown graphically. New page setups
can be created from this panel, or existing page setups can be edited, and then saved as
new setups. Click Next to proceed.
Reference String Details Panel that appears, have two type layout options. The
"Along a String" choice will automatically align your selected sheet size along a specified
Master String. The "Adjacent Pages" choice doesn't orient the sheets along a specific
string; rather they are defined relative to each other.
llH^ypOitg^Wtrorfft
Ixtd
frkh 1
Pf^L-^iutFltK- m ^
|\PinVFlBn9elev'H^erialV[«data\pJflncheolcAp| - | <EsA( 1
•M-
0^-- ]
( ^ "^-re:.^ •• [i: -rtyt
I»*;D*«
Uncheck the "Produce drawings", verify that the drawing file is being saved in the
correct folder and has a descriptive name.
Select Finish.
73
CHAPTER 5: DESIGN STEPS
CHAPTER 6
6.1 GENERAL
Using made-up data for road project various reports are generated. Input and
output data as generated by two software i.e. HEADS and MX Road in respect of
Horizontal Alignment, Vertical Alignment, Cross-sectional Elements and Earthwork
Calculation have been given in the following sections. Total length of the road to be
considered for the study is 5645.372 m whereas the results given here are for the starting
one km stretch. The rest of the results being of the repetitive nature have not been shown
here for paucity of space. Giving the results of only a part of the total length of the road
considered in the project does not in any way affect the objectives of the research work.
The input data generated by the software is given in the following paragraph. The
user input data as shown below is also generated by the software using the raw data as
shown in table 4.1
The alignment using GPS Data as generated by the software is shown in Fig. 6.1.
The output data as generated by the software is shown in Element Data, Element
Summary and Alignment Details.
* * • * * • * * * * * • * * * * * * * * * * * * * • * * • * * * * * * * * * +* +* +* +* + *
HEADS R e l e a s e 12+
R e p o r t on H o r i z o n t a l A l i g n m e n t Design
Program was r u n on Sun J u l 26 0 6 : 4 8 : 0 4 2009
TechSOFT E n g i n e e r i n g S e r v i c e s (I) Pvt. Ltd.
* * * * * * * + * * * * + *****•*** + * * * * * * * * * + * * * * * * * * * * *
HEADS
200 HALIGN
201 MODEL DESIGN STRING MCOG
202 XC 0 . 0 YC 0 . 0 SC 0 IN 1 0 . 0 0 0 V 100.00 E 5.0
203 SX XI 8 7 1 0 3 . 0 1 9 0 Yl 2 7 1 7 4 1 . 5 8 3 0 X2 8 7 2 2 8 . 6 1 4 0 Y2 271546.5500
74
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
203 CRE RA 200
203 SX XI 87228.6140 Yl 271546.5500 X2 87285.7550 Y2 270982.3950
203 CRE RA 200
203 SX XI 87285.7550 Yl 270982.3950 X2 87115.9548 Y2 270271.9695
203 CLE RA 200
203 SX XI 87115.9548 Yl 270271.9695 X2 87570.6230 Y2 269953.0830
203 CRE RA 200
203 SX XI 87570.6230 Yl 269953.0830 X2 87739.0020 Y2 269674.3070
203 CLE RA 200
203 SX XI 87739.0020 Yl 269674.3070 X2 88116.2610 Y2 269384.4320
203 CRE RA 200
203 SX XI 88116.2610 Yl 269384.4320 X2 88410.4160 Y2 269062.2550
203 CLE RA 200
203 SX XI 88410.4160 Yl 269062.2550 X2 89200.1220 Y2 268556.5920
203 CRE RA 200
203 SX XI 89200.1220 Yl 268556.5920 X2 89419.2850 Y2 267908.8010
203 CRE RA 200
203 SX XI 89419.2850 Yl 267908.8010 X2 89034.8910 Y2 267257.7540
FINISH
In this analysed data 10 HIPs are used and radius of curve is fixed to 200 m.
Following are the list of notations used in the Input file that is generated by HEADS
software using the locations of HIPs collected by using GPS instrument:
200 This major option number is followed by the title HALIGN which is
for the design of Horizontal Alignment.
201 This minor option number is to be used to specify the name of the
design model and the string label.
202 This minor option number is to be used to provide four data values
related to the design of Horizontal Alignment. The data should be
given as per the.specified order.
203 This minor option number is used to provide data concerned to various
free and fixed elements. HEADS recognizes two types of elements
free and fixed. A free element must be preceded and followed by two
fixed elements. The free circular element may have free leading and
trailing transition elements before and after the circular element. The
data must be in meters. The meaning of various data labels are
explained below.
SX Fixed Straight Element, xl, yl is the start and x2, y2 is the end
co-ordinates
FINISH ^rhis is the end statement for major option '200, HALIGNMENT'
76
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
-a
o
OX)
,5
o
• • «
o
o
a.
s:
S
do
s
o
M
tH
Rt; M r- ^D ^r
M h^ CTl
t ^
en (NJ
\D CO
a\
CO
^ eg
iH
ro
t-H
m
^ liJ iH
s H R ^ EH H H tn H ^1 EH EH H H
Q:; X X X E iM U. 23 E Uj U4 X X tH
ID O u a O W W U) e) Id U O o W
tH M H H H i-:| 1-H 1-^1
o: cr; o: a;
h^
Qi
M
ff:
i j
^ M
Pi
H
Gi
U
W U3 in in o o eg
cn
^
iH
'JD
CM <M
00
CO
CO
CO in in
rH
CD
rH
CO in in
CN)
in in
O •z. t-H CTl cn r-\ ^^ CTl en i n in in in iH rH
-H in in ro ro ro ro
D::
m 2
H rH
^ rH rH
1 m CNJ CM ^£1 U3 CN CM CM eg CM CM i ^ kD
1—1
Q
(J iH rH CM CM in in ro ro CO CO
2 PJ
W a r^ ro to e» r- r~
•^ '7'
r-
CO
CTl
IT)
Oi rg
CO
eg
C^
ro
(^
ro
^
t-\
[^
iH rH
CT^
rH t-\ rH rH
• ^
rH
•ST
rH
<M
rH t-t rH rH
(J ro n CM CM iJD
\o CM eg CM
<
H w n^ rH rH rH CM CM
CM CM
in in
CM
CO ro ^
CO
W Q
r- [^ T •NT CO ro m LO <x> CO r- [— C^
-o* r~ CT\ rg CM ^J* CO
'^
rH
i ^
rH rH
CTl
r-<. rH rH
• ^
rH
OJ rsj
r-f rH
TH •-{
^ ^
(U 2, CM CO P- ro in CO CO O rH CO ro M3 O
nc en in in ro CM r~ rH CO
JJ U ^ '£' [-- CM
y3 o
1-H
in CO •=r o
1
^
ys
O
O
CO
in
CTl
yD rH r-
•3'
rH
r-
O
o in ^3" CO
O
i n
>i Q CTl rvj m •!C T-l CO rH CM rH in o ,-1 i n
CO •z
Cd m CO ro o rH en t^ o \D o iH to CO
c CO r- U3 ro CT^ CM o en ro rH e^ VD i n
en (-1 CM r~ CO ro ^£>
o o ro •c CO O) CM
in rH
^ CM CM CM eg CM CM ro
0)
Q
XJ 2 o CM CO r~ ro in CO CO O T-\ CO ro \D
rn o rsj en in rH in ro eg {~~ rH
C
< u o •^ 1,0
o
t -
en o in o CO O
1 o
^
<o o
CO
in
KD
r-
• ^
r-\ t- o in ^
^T CO
Pi o ro
l£i
^ in o rH
Cn
C to
•
o
CTl CM
^ T-\ CO t-\ CM
^
•rH 0) < o CO t » fO o •r-\ en
rg
r~ o KD o <r-\ U3
kD
t^ ro CTl o en ro CO
i-\ O EH CO VC
r- ro MS o o ro
<-< CO OO
CU - H
0) >
w t/J rH CM 00
rH rH CM CM CM •^
eg CM CM
C IM
• H 01
o r- ro
c ffi (M ^D CO \D CM ro O CM r-<
CTl
i n ^T
1X>
M H ^* CM O •<T r- vo •J3 ro CO • ^
^
c c en O ^3* UD CO o {~~ ro ro rH <T r~
in
VD i n O
w S CJD ro \r> rH
•^
y3
i n • ^
\o CM
^3*
oo m
r-\
[^
CO
CTl CM
^ T-H f^ CM rH CO ^r
5 4) ^ Q o
X <U m T in r- o (X> r- ro in -IT LO CM
6 C CTl H CO a\ CO UD >J3 ro { ^ CO T r~ CM CO
cn
eg ro ro
•rH - H
K Di o
O
w
v-\
"^ i n CM
^
C rsj H E-" P: H cc: EH CC tn a; EH CC EH Pi EH
* W \ ^; 2 x: < E < a: < 3: < X < E i< X
+ r~ O M W o t-i tj hj ej I-; U HJ o vJ (J 1-^ O
H o •• ^ 2 H D M D M D M D M D M D HH
r~
r-t
in
.-H rH
in lO
01 i£> 1^3 CvJ CN CM
£-1
CO
cn
^ H t^ E-i H H CN
u. a: a: rc a: m CO
w
h-i
o
1—1
L5
M
o (J (1
CO
H M H
Pi K K Qi p:^
fej r>i o
o o
t: p:i o
u;
n o
CO CN H
in in a\ CTl H iH r> < M M o
in in CNJ Cv] cn m
M
> o
14
fl"
pt:
D
2 2 CN
r~ t~~ CD CO cn en
ro en i-H r-( cn en
^ u
CS] CN i-H (H o O
CNJ CM UD KO iH iH
1-1 .-1 iH r-t CN CM
c>
w
(JJ
CN r-I I-H I-H CN
O O o
in CO CD CN CN I-H
to F^ 1—1 cyi
M
r-i in in c^^ cn r-\ ;^,
M
iH i-H I—i i n
TH in LO fS) nj m >;
in r^ [^
«
f^ o CO CN
OD CO en
en
m rn fH iH cn w Ul t-H
w o
r- og CN I-H .H o • ^
ro CN CN >,D 1—1 r-
i-( iH ^
'-^ I-( iH CN
f=
r- CO t-- o CO I-) Q)
in CTl
CTi CO ^•
en
^u
rsi
en
CTi
r~
TH
-P CO • ^ •=r i n (-H
o U3 r~- r- CO r^ «
> i
CO .-H
i n cn
.-H CO CO
CTi r - vD
CO o o o CTl m
cn c/5 I
o CN r-
I I-H i-D i-D CO CO
O) o in c W >^ CO
<H
c^
in
iH
CO
CN
o CO
Ol
•c
KD
cr I ^
r- in
CO
m
en
^
r-
^r
CO •H tn I
sT iH iH iH .H iH
(^ ^j' 'O'
^ in to
(U
I r- r- r- r- r~-
A: I CN CM CM CN CM
Q
o r- CO r- o CO T)
CO in
en
a^ •^ ys CO C •
H
o
in o
CO
KO
c^ CN cn
<
r- [^ CO H 1 Q
in CO
o o o cn tP • CC 1 cn -H I-H CN O
G (0 O 1 CK I i-H CM CM i n r-
CO o Cs] r~ cn o • H 0) a- I I o ^3 ii:> - ^ -a*
in I—1 in CO o CO M U W 1 O I
rvj n I-) CN CO c:^ 01 - H cr; J ) m CN CO ^
CN
m 'T
m • ^
^ "3* CD > O X o O o CO r o
C M ^ 1 I r-\ CN CN CN O
- H QJ O 1 U I r- r- r~ r~ c~
t J i CO H 1 CO CO CO CO CO
r- iH cr\ CO CO ro C CO 1
r- •y- ^T iH r- en CJ tP 1—1 W 1
CO in cn ^£> CM
in in
• ^ C c a 1
CM
o CTl iH
Ol
CO >i-H p
CN o CTi ro 10 iH L/l
'—1
H 1
S 0) S 1
(NJ in X 0) W I o
in CM c- ID tJi C 01 S 1 o M"
in -H -H •LJ 2 1 2 2 o \s> UJ O
C_3 I') o CTi
p; EH
ffi CP
C (N o "^ CD 1
M 1
H-t 1—1 o cn CM
< X < a: •K td
^ hJ- 1 x: to o o m en <v
{J (3 o * 1^ CO < 1 o r<4 C J m CO r~-
iH CN
M M H H C3 • ^ a ^ iH
79
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
03 o
in
CO • ^
^ in CO
•^
^
\D
in
r~ CM
CN in CO
CO
LT) r- O CO
• ^
^
^S> m r- m '3- o
in CO [^ OJ
OJ CO
M3 CO CO CO CO m
CN CM CO CO CO CO in
in in in 1-1 1-1 O o o
LO LT) CO CO CO
CO i n in in
0~i C71
en
.—I I—I I—I CTi en <n CTi in in in
in in in
cn cn m fn cn cn
CN MS U ) U J CM CN CM CM CN CM CM CM
CM CN CN CN in in i n i n fO
cn cn
• ^
cn m cn in in in i n CO CO CO CO r-
r^ CTi CTl c n CN CN CsJ CM •a* CM
^
r-i .H
I N CM
Pi ff; CC iX
H EH H H H
EH
w
H
H H
w EH
w w
ffl p: a: oi EH CC P^ H o:; CC
Q
H Pi
<: Q
< Q
< Q 2; < Q
< O s < Q
< o •z
rf O <: 2
2 2 2 EH H S EH Z EH 2 M
H S e u H H Ci3
s w Cd U
H S
cn [d cn W o cn w cn [i3 U cn H cn w o cn cn w cn w
in CM CM r-\ in rH
en 0^ in •^ ro OJ '^
US
m CO TH in ys}
O CM CM CM OJ T — 1 ^ I—1 iH o O o o o o o
in in in in in CO CO CO CO CM CM CM IN rH 1-1 i-t
CM l£i in KD in r- r~ r- r^ CO CO CO CO CO en ro
m ro en m ro CO CO CO ro iH 1—1 rH .H CO ro ro
r~ r^ r~ r- r- CM oo CM CM i - ( <-i r-\ 1—1 o o o
CM m Ol OJ CM OJ CM ijD in in
•r-l r-\
ro
iH rH
ro
iH iH iH r-\ .—I iH iH
in iH
!-i CM
rH t-^
I—1 OJ CM
'T > — 1 o tH in
^
kD CO
in in in
^ o ^ en CO 1^
in iH in iH rH iH CO U3 CO T •a' o in O in in en CO o~i r-
CT^ r^ [-- CO CO iH
en a\ CTlCM cn en en OJ en
ro CO CM m CO O ^ •s?- CM in
cri <T) CTi Ol m
o o CM
CTi en CTi
o
CTt CO
in in
^ ^ ^ Ol en CO CO CO OJ
CO CO CO CO r- r^ r^ r- fr~ r-
<D 'J:> in 'JD kD
CM CM CM CM OJ ^n >n in
CM OJ OJ
in in
OJ CM
kD in kD
OJ OJ CM
in in
OJ OJ
in
CM Oi •^ CM
in K£>
eg CM
ID
in r- CO r- r~- r- r- in r- CO m in in in in in in r- in rH
en CO en a\ -^ a\ .-i rH rH in 'r-\ r~ en
CM rH ^ m
rH en
in in in CO
'O'
O in rH
O o r^ CM
en m rH in CO
m o m en
og CO O CO CM CM CM O CM rH rH OJ CO o j <y\ CTl CM CN) CM -IT
O CM CO CM en en ro ^ ro <^ •a- CM CO OJ CO CO r- ^n r- CO
T-\ ^^ iy\ rH CO CO •3' m ^ rH rH CM O OJ ro ro ro in ro O
CO C O r~- CO CO CO CO CO CO en en en en en en en en en en en
CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO e» CO CO eo CO
in o O rH en ro CO CO CO cn en CsJ
T CO CO in in rH in r~ r^ ai a) r-
O rH rH in in CO CO o o o o o en en C O
rH in \D CO CO O O OJ CM r~ r^ en en O CT- in
r-t in CO o CO CO
CO in U5 in in rH in CO O • ^
CO CM CM CO CO rH <-t OJ CO e)i en UJ
CO CO Csl CO in
OJ CM CM CO CO CO CO '^ ^r ^ ^'
CC
w EH
CC
H
IX
W
H
< Q rf: U 2 < Q
< a2 tH 2 H 2
H 2w
H 2 W
t/l UJ U en W
c/D W O e/] tJ CO ti3 O e/l Cd (/I W
C) i - f W W . - ( i - ( i - ( r - f > - ( i - ( - - ( . - l t H > - ( ^ r H r - ( i - I r H t H i H t H
Ul
U] r-l'-^!-l^i-H'-li-(T-li-(T-li-(T-lrSiHT-lrHT-l7-lr-fi-)'-|
CJ s I-^r^r^I-/I-^^-(t-^^^(^I-^I-^l-lr^^^^r-^I^l-l^^I^'^
H
'^
M
rf. r <^n^r)rnfnrorviroromrorornrornrnrorTiirororn
a\ (') rHrHrHrHt—t<H>HrHrH(HrHi—(rH>—liHi-Hi-HrHTHi—li—(
w CJ
w u
m l O c o o ^ ^ l n c o o r ^ L J ^ c o o ^ o y ^ i 3 ^ 0 l ^ M ( n ^ - ^ ^ ^
c o r - > ^ ' ^ i / i " 3 ' c o r o t N ' - H O o o ^ c o r ^ r - y D i n ' ^ t H i - !
W I L n > - ^ [ ~ m a l L n t ^ r ^ f n c ^ L ^ r ^ ^ J D c ^ ] C 0 ' 3 ' O ' ^ t N C ^ a ^
I
til >i ^ H r o ^ i ^ r ~ < T V ' M ' M « T L r i r - o \ Q C M f o t n [ ^ c o o ' J 3 ' o
I ^ o - i c N ^ o o i i T i c o r - ' - O L n - ^ ' a ' r o o j t H O C T i c y i c o c o
H I
t lHl-^l-^l-lI-^r^^^t-^^-^I-^^^,-^r^t-^I-^t-ll-^l-^^-^l-^^-^
e(D
< I
I
•U
(Ti
f-i
>.
CO
Q
C
D^ Q^
-H
tfl O
Q
Q O X m a 3 m ( T l ^ o u ^ O l X l I - ^ ^ ^ c ^ J ^ ^ ^ o c O " a • O ^ L n o c M f M
o O i - Y t - i r v j r n i ^ - ^ ' ^ i n i n v p U i E ^ r - c o c o c n o o o
•a o 1—IrHi—I-—1>—IT-II—li—li—I'-Hi-Hi-HiHi—Ir-fi—1>—liMCsJCNCM
G
ooi»cocoa3co<»cx)o?cocococococococococococo
«:: H 1
Cr^ • a: 1
C CO O )
-r^ dJ CU 1
V4 O M 1
CU -H D^ 1
OJ >
C M S 1 o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o ' B ' s r
• H Q) O ( O O O O O O O O O O O O Q O O O O O O i X l U J
(31 c n H I •z O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O ' T i C T i
U] 1 M
c o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o r o r o
u tn ,—, EJ
Q
1
1 r^C M^ ^• ^ln'^D^-coo^OIHC^!^o^Lr)lX)r~•cococo
c r,
>,-H d O <H>-lrHtH<-l'-)'-HrHF-HiHi-)
fC f-' c/) H 1
S 0) 1—1
E; '
x : oj W 1
t?^ c; <n 2 1
• H -rH
H <->
D i O ^3^ s
O 11 ^ r H r H 1-t --H rH ^ U fj
t : •r^ Q
EHt--
* pj (-(
h J (1
^^
r^ CO < 1
H M
* E^ n
2 2
Cw "^ hJ 1 H 1—1 M
C/i O ^,
UJ r< 1
2 O rj
OD tw o ^ H 1
n Oi DJ
Q ^ S I o H R
O O 1 2 Ki
< !U [S] 1 CU Cd M
E-i M H 1 O I'J
W
w
H J' 1 iX I H 2 •z.
>i < M O 1 d;
X J3 U H a: 1 <
E-* H
Pi
en
82
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS ANO DESIGN REPORTS
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 > ^ > ^ > H > ^ > ^ > ^ > - ^ > ^ > - ^ > ^ > ^ > ^ > ^ > ^ > ^ >-t >H >f >H >< >^ >H >^>^ >-• >• >^
>H
O O O O O O O O O O E - ' E - I E - I E - I H E H E - ' H H E - I H H E - I H E - '
H H H H H H H H H H H H H
O O O O O O O O O O M M M H H H H H H M H H M M M M M M i-H H H M H M M M M M M
2 ; s e ; E : s i a 2 2 S S 2 Z S 2 s . _ •z.
. ._.
S ._.
S s s _ S ,2 •z._ _ 2:
IS !S „ 2„ S
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 H H H H M M H 1 - 1 1 H 1 - 1 M 1 - 1 H H H H H M H M M M M 1 - 1 H H M
O O O O O O O O O O b j P u t r j U i C w U j b j I ^ I ^ I ^ I ^ C i ^ U j h l ^ l i j I i i t j t M t i t j b j b j t j U j l j y U j ^
fMCMCNOJCNiCNjcNjcNicsicN22:^;2:Z2ZE;S2:ssS2;E:sz;ss2E:222;2;2:22
H H H M h H M H H M l - I H M H H H M M M M l - I M l - C l - I H H M M M
r~-oc^)^^^mc-J•^^-CNC^JC^lc^l^^)c^JC^Jf^lcs]c^lCNCNC^Ir^JCNCNCN^^JC^IC^3c^(c^l^^]C^Jc^
u^G^c^^Lnco•^LncoI^a^o^a^a^a^a^c^lC^l0^crl0^cno^o^o^c^l(TlC^c^<Jl<TlC^la^cTl0^o^m
Ln^T^rrocNCNiH lJ^L^LnLnlnl^lJ^lOl/^l^li^Lnl^t^LOlnLOlnu^lnLnli^u^lOl^LnL^
U30DOCN]'T'^DlXiOCs]CN)CNJC^jrslC^JCN)CNjCNC\lCs](NC\ir\l(>JCNJ(\JCNJCNir\JCNICNCNC-JC^
m - q - ^ r O O ] ^ L n > - ( r H t H r H ^ . - H ^ ^ , - l ^ , - l ^ n H T H i - l t H r H t H r H r H . - l T H T H . H . - i ^ ^ > - l r H
.Hi-l.-li-ltHiHi-lTHnHiHi-liHi-ltHiHiHr-4iH.-iiH^i-(iHiH,-(^,HiHi-li-lt-(i-lr-(tH<HrHiHtH
o^o^r-c^jOTON'^'cocNicocoo'i'^o^^ai^oinou^OLnoirioLno'^D-H'^i—(|j3i—i'jDi—IVD-—I
r-Oi^o'^iHinr-a^[^r~crioorHtHrsio^rn^<Tininij3^Dr^r^oD03cricnooiHvHC\jcsjf^
o^[^kOLn^^nc^JI^oc^)0^cy^o^[^u^ln•3•^oc^lt--^oa^co[^^Dln^^ncsl•--^oc^la^[^^Dlr^'^o^
^H^^r^I^r^IHr^t^l—liHi-ti-IiHiHtHi—ItHi-frHrHi—ft—li—It—li—li-Hi—liHi—It-It—li—li-tt—li—liHi-'i-l
rHfo^^t-ir-inr-airsfCNi(^iHCji^O'^cgmr--Lnroocoy3rniHCTit^'^cs)or-inrnoco'^'3*
t—iininocTiO'*criinLninf^^^in>^r^[^o3aiOiHrHCs]rn^^ij^'^[^coco<TiOrHi—icNf^
LOOLncylC^]'X)ODOc^J^^^fno^^ln'^^~aDc7^o^Hc^Jro^LnuJ[^o^c^lOt^fs]p^^u^>^[^coo^
Ot—^THt^r^]^^lc^J^ocn^O(^^nrno^^o^o^o^o^^^'s^^'^^>d•^'3•^rlnL/^LnLnLnLJ^u^Lnu^
C^JC^JC^IC\lr^]C^^C^JCNrg<^Jf^]C^iC^]OJC^]C^^CNCsl(N^s)<^lC^]<^JC^)C^Jr^)C^lt^lC^J^
C0O3C0C0CO<X)C0COcOCOCOCOCOCOCOCOC0C0C0CO03TOa3aJ03a)COC0COaDCOC00DCOC0CO00CO
0 0 O O 0 O 0 0 0 . - ( t H 0 O 0 O 0 O 0 O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
O O O O O O O O O O J C M O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O
O O O O O O O O O C O C O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O
o^OIH^^](^<3•Ln'^l^^^r-coa10t^^^]^o^ln^or-coc^lOr^c^]^0'3•lJ~>'JD[^coc^lOt-l(^]o^'^
O U
I I
H EH
n 0
CI4
Lli
H R
S •Z.
W W
CJ (T
s K:
< <:
H H
83
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
> ^ > H > H > - l > - l > ^ > ^ > ^ > ^ > ^ > ^ > - ^ > ^ > - ^ > ^ > ^ > ^ > ^ > ^ > ^ > ^ > - l > ^ 0 O O O O O O 0 0 > ^ > ^ > ^ > - l > ^ > ^
H E - ' H t ^ E - i E - i H H H H E - i E - ' H E H H E H E - i E - i E - i E H E - i E - ' E - ' O O o O O O O O O E - ' E H e H E - t E - i H
H H M M l - H M H H H I M M l - I H I - I H f H M M M H M M I - l O O O O O O O O O H H M M M M
H h H M M H H M l - l l - t l - I M H M M l H H H M M l - l M H H O O O O O O O O O M M M H M H
pu|J4|ijUjUj["jtij|illJj|jj|JjPulJjt4Uj|il[i|[u
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 ; ! 2 S 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 S c ^ c \ ] 0 J ( N 0 j ( N ] c \ j c N C N ] 2 2 2 ; 2 2 2
M M H M H H M M M M H H M M I - I H M H M M l - I M H M M H M H H
CNC^l^^lCNCNC-Jc^l^^]0^lcNc^]^gcNCNl^)c-J^^]c^JC^]c^lc^|{^J<^lCNl^lt^orM•^r^a1o^coo^ro
a^a^cy!(Tla^o~la^a^c^<Tl0^a^a^o^a^<Tla^ma^al(yla^c^lmco.^lncOT^<y'^^^HIHI^I^r^l^^
Cs)CNC\]CgrgCs]CNJCNirslCNCMrsIf\JCNlCNCsICN)r\)CNjr\JCNCNCNCNl[^0>OCN'!T'^03l£)^DU)>i>V£J^
1—fi—li—IrHt-Hi—IrHi-ltHtHrHrHiHiHi-Hi—l^^r^•-ll—(i—(iHi-HiH LniD'^mCNJiHCNJCNCNJCSlCNCNOJ
iHiHrH.—Ii—liHi—liHtHiHi—li—It—lrH>—lt-t.HrH.Hi—liHi—IrHi—IIHIHTH.—ITHI—liHrHrHi—liHiHi—ItH
c^o.Hc^J^o^o^Ln'-Dr~-coc^lOIHC^]CNf^^Ln>^^-cJ^^DkDO^o^ocoU).HVDa^cylo^co^Hl^}
'J^Csl^-^^J^~cN^^csI^~CN^^c-JlXl0^co^oco^oco^ocof^o^cT^[^coo^o'^o~lO^"a•cou^CNO[^
(^•^•iruOLr)i^U3r-r~cococriiTiooiHrHcsjrsiron-^oo^'^'^uoLn'-Da>^'C'rH^[^o(N
coo^cococoo^coaJCOcocococoo^o^alma^c^^cTl(yla^^£|>^c^lCna1C^a1CI^mc^lc^lOOOr^.H
^^)^HOcn(X)[^'X)^n'=3'^oc^l.HocTlCO[^vDln^To^(^]IH^HIHOCTlcor-•'^Ln^r'3•^^o^c^)IHo
0JCNicNiH(HiH.HiHtHiH(H.Hr-(OOoooooooooocnaiCT\aic^cricT.cricncricTic^a^
. H . H r H . H . H r H . H r H > H r H i H i H t H t H i H . H r H r - * . H r H i H i H i H i H i H O O O O O O O O O O O O O
^^o^[^':^c^Joa)Ln^nIHCO>^"3•.HC^^-lnc^]Ocoln^^cN^^]IHco^£)^o^^^-OTr-^lHLnoy^IH>Xl
^3"^r^nvDr--a^coo^o^HIH^^]^^<:r•^ru^u)^~o^coa^o•^'3•ocNlOco.H^cocoo^y^^.HcnlX)
cocoo^cocococococylO^O~la^c^mlTlC^<^l0^a^a~lCTlOf^f^<3^r^c^ly^^ooc^lCocol^rnokDm
o^^<^Jm^Ln^i^^~•coa^OIH(^]^o^l^>yD^-oDcJ^Of^JC^lc^]<^i^oo^f^lIHO[^[^[^Ln^n^Hco^
CNlCMC\irsi<NC\JCNlCvJCN)fN|rs)CSirNICsirNJCNCNCNCNCNlCNIOJ<NICNlCsirs)CsirNJ<NCN]CN
cococoooaD03ajo3a5aJ03coroa3a5cococococoo3coa>cococoa3cocococoo3cocococococo
O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O ^ C T i O O O O O O O C T i C n O O O O O
O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O l f i L D O O O O O O O U S ^ O C D C J O O O
o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o r o r o o o o o o o o ' ^ ' ^ o o o o o
o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o r o c n o o o o o o o o o o o o o o
ir)'x>(^a3iTiOiHCN]<^'^in'^[^coa^OrHc\im^Ln^Di^^D[^cocnotHc^jrnrnro^in'-or-co
gg ii
84
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
> H > l > - . > - . > - . > H > - . > H > H > H > H > H
B t H H H E - - H H E - t H H H H
1 — I M I — I t H l — I M M M l — I H H H
H M t H H H H H H H H H I H
|ijUj|JMUj|jj[l-ltH[i4tj[ij[ij|Jj
M H H M M H M M H M M M
COCOCOCOCOCOCOCOCOCOCOCO
cocococococooococooaooco
i-HiHrHiHt-HiHrHiMr-fiHr-JvH
CN}0]OJCMOJCNlCNCN)fN(NCN(N
tHrHi-fiHrHiHTHtHiHTHiHiH
Lncooro^DCTii—('3'i^orMLn
i-i.-irMCMCN(NrornrO'3"^^
i T i c o r ^ ' - o i n ^ m c N i H O C T i c o
c o c o o o c o c o c o c o c o c o c o r ^ i ^
CNCMCMOJCNCNCN]CMtNCM(>JCM
c M r ^ m c o n c y i ^ * C T i i n o m i - i
ojtNrgovjogojcvicNicvjcNicNJCN
ODCOCOCOCOCOCOCOCOCOCOCO
o o o o o o o o o o o o
o o o o o o o o o o o o
o o o o o o o o o o o o c
01
o o o o o o o o o o o o 6
c n o i H C N i n ^ L o u s r - o o i n o c
coc^cricri<7iaicTicrio^CTicrio tJl
•H
H
LOinLnLnLDLOininLniDLnm m
4-)
C
o
N
-H
M
O
a:
U-l
o
xs
c
85
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
6.3 VERTICAL ALIGNMENT USING HEADS
The input data generated by the software is given in the following paragraph.
The output data as generated by the software is shown in Vertical Curve Details and
Vertical Alignment Running Chainage.
1 HEADS
2 300 VALIGN
3 301 MODEL DESIGN STRING MCOO
4 302 VIP 9 SC 0.00000 EC 4900.746 IN 10.000
5 303 0.00000 20.509
6 303 560.838 28.903 120
7 303 918.980 20.509 120
8 303 1391.117 25.885 120
9 303 1837.780 20.509 120
10 303 2502.090 13.583 120
11 303 3641.658 33.797 120
12 303 4341.424 42.462 120
13 303 4900.424 24.934
14 FINISH
In this analysed data 9 VIPs are used and radius of curve is fixed to 120 m.
Various notations used in the input file generated by the software are as follows:
300 This major option number is followed by the title VALIGN, which is
for the design of vertical alignment by VIP or Vertical Intersection
Point method. The VIP data are defined in terms of Chainages in
86
[ CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
meters, Elevations in meters and VCL in meters (except at the start
and end VIP). VCL stands for the Vertical Curve Length. The option
takes input data from the user as given in the user input data file and
searches for the presence of ahgnment in the MODEL.FIL. If the
horizontal ahgnment is absent, VALIGNMENT creates NULL
horizontal ahgnment with Chainage, X, Y and Z co-ordinates, where
the values for X & Y will be - 999.9 or NULL.
302 This minor option number is to be used to provide two data values
related to the design of the Vertical Alignment. The data should be
given as per the specified order.
303 This minor option number is to be used to specify the VIP data in
terms of VIP Chainage, VIP Elevation and VCL - the Vertical Curve
Length. All the values should be in meters. The first and last 303 data
should not have the VCL value. All other intermediate 303 data will
have the VCL values. If the Vertical Curve is symmetrical there will
be only one data for VCL, but if the vertical curve is unsymmetrical
87
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
the lengths of two parts of the vertical curve are to be given.
For symmetrical curve there will be the data will be as follows:
303, VIP Chainage, VIP Elevation, VCL
and for unsymmetrical vertical curves the data will be as follows:
303, VIP Chainage, VIP Elevation, VCLl, VCL2
In case of symmetrical Vertical Curve, VCL is the total length of the
entire Vertical Curve and for unsymmetrical Vertical Curve VCLl and
VCL2 are the lengths of two parts of the vertical curve on left and
right hand side of the VIP respectively.
FINISH This is the end statement for the Major Option '300,
VALIGNMENT'.
GRADIENT = 1.4967
GRADIENT = -2.3438
GRADIENT = 1.1387
GRADIENT = -1.2036
GRADIENT = -1.0426
GRADIENT = 1.7738
GRADIENT = 1.2383
GRADIENT = -3.1356
89
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
100.000 22.006 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
110.000 22.155 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
120.000 22.305 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
130.000 22.455 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
140.000 22.604 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
150.000 22.754 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
160.000 22.904 1.497 O.QOO INFINITY
170.000 23.053 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
180.000 23.203 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
190.000 23.353 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
200.000 23.502 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
210.000 23.652 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
220.000 23.802 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
230.000 23.951 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
240.000 24.101 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
250.000 24.251 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
260.000 24.400 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
270.000 24.550 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
280.000 24.700 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
290.000 24.849 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
300.000 24.999 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
310.000 25.149 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
320.000 25.298 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
330.000 25.448 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
340.000 25.598 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
350.000 25.747 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
360.000 25.897 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
370.000 26.047 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
380.000 26.196 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
390.000 26.346 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
400.000 26.496 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
410.000 26.645 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
420.000 26.795 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
430.000 26.945 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
440.000 27.094 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
450.000 27.244 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
460.000 27.394 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
470.000 27.543 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
480.000 27.693 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
490.000 27.843 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
500.000 27.992 1.497 0.000 INFINITY
90
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
BVC- 500.838 28.005 1.497 0.000 -3124.6
510.000 28.129 1.203 -0.013 -3124.6
520.000 28.233 0.883 -0.059 -3124.6
530.000 28.305 0.563 -0.136 -3124.6
540.000 28.346 0.243 -0.245 -3124.6
550.000 28.354 -0.077 -0.387 -3124.6
560.000 28.330 -0-397 -0-560 -3124.6
570.000 28.275 -0.717 -0.414 -3124.6
580.GOD 28.187 -1.037 -0.267 -3124.6
590.000 28.067 -1.357 -0.152 -3124.6
600.000 27.916 -1.677 -0.069 -3124.6
610.000 27.732 -1.997 -0.019 -3124.6
620.000 27.516 -2.317 -0.000 -3124.6
EVC- 620.838 27.497 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
630.000 27.282 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
640.000 27.048 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
650.000 26.813 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
660.000 26.579 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
670.000 26.345 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
680.000 26.110 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
690.000 25.876 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
700.000 25.641 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
710.000 25.407 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
720.000 25.173 -2.344 O.OOD INFINITY
730.000 24.938 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
740.000 24.704 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
750.000 24.469 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
760.000 24.235 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
770.000 24.001 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
780.000 23.766 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
790.000 23.532 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
800.000 23.298 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
810.000 23.063 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
820.000 22.829 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
830.000 22.594 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
840.000 22.360 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
850.000 22.126 -2.344 0.000 INFINITY
The user input data generated for cross section analysis by the software is given in
the following paragraph.
501 This minor option number is to be used to specify the model name and
string label of the Reference String. The start and end chainages and
the interval are also to be specified here. This input will be considered
in creating the cross section data at each chainage along the control
line as the result of the analysis. The data and their order are as given
below:
502 This minor option number may be used to mention about the Offset
Sub-String to be present in the Cross Section of the proposed road.
The data is to be provided as per the specified order as given below:
LHS or RHS This is a label for either the Left Hand Side or the
Right Hand Side of the Reference / Control String
503 This minor opfion number may be used to mention about the Master
Sub-String to be present in the Cross Section of the proposed road.
The data is to given as per the specified order as given below:
LHS or RHS This is a label for either the Left Hand Side or the Right
Hand Side of the Reference / Control String
504 This minor option number may be used to mention about the existing
ground to be included in the Cross Section. The elevation of the
existing ground will be determined at the same points of the Cross
Section wherever there are elevations available on the proposed road
section i.e., at the points where a offset/master sub-string or reference
/ control string is present for this analysis. The user doesn't have to
mention about any model name or string label and the data is to be
provided as given below:
FINISH This is the end statement for the Major Option '500, XSECTIONS'.
94
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
o
o
DJD
«
C
*«
a>
I-
«
I
o
<
s
^©
'•w
U
V
C/1
M
M
o
U
\d
UJ
<
X
o
95
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
S29 61 9ZB'6l 00001^
o
o
90Z02 9020Z l9tV o
m
eseoz 99Z-0Z
oooe .S
89603 92^03
0000
909'Oa 909'OS
i.ooe-
o
Q
28zoa
S
Q
c
(/I
o
U
o
o
C3 o
CO
O _J CO
06 LU II
>
II UJ LU
_l
^>
3 al
1— Q
< Q^
O
Q Q.
96
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
-3.000 87116.370 271726.392 20.733 20.293 FILL
0.000 87113.847 271724.768 20.808 20.419 FILL
3.000 87111.325 271723.144 20.733 20.454 FILL
97
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
0.000 87140.918 271682.730 21.557 20.166 FILL
3.000 87138.396 271681.106 21.482 19.940 FILL
100
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
CHAINAGE 230.000, NO. OF C/S PTS
101
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
OFFSET X-EAST Y-NORTH PROPOSED EXISTING CUT/FILL
102
{ CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS A N D DESIGN REPORTS
OFFSET X-EAST Y-NORTH PROPOSED EXISTING CUT/FILL
OFFSET X-EAST
Y-NORTH PROPOSED EXISTING CUT/FILL
108
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
CHAINAGE 6-30.000, NO. OF C/S PTS 3
109
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
OFFSET X-EAST Y-NORTH PROPOSED EXISTING CUT/FILL
111
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
-3.000 87286.255 270989.469 23.457 26.507 CUT
0.000 87283.256 270989.490 23.532 26.414 CUT
3.000 87280.256 270989.512 23.457 26.344 CUT
112
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
-3.000 87278.583 270939.482 22.285 26.546 CUT
0.000 87275.665 270940.180 22.360 26.231 CUT
3.000 87272.747 270940.877 22.2S5 26.368 CUT
11A
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
3.000 87249.501 270843.617 20.894 25.322 CUT
11
115
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
CHAINAGE 1000.000, NO. OF C/S PTS 3
The user input data generated for Earthwork Calculations by the software is given
in the following paragraph.
*****if:^t ***********************************
116
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
HEADS This is the starting label for the Input Data.
700 This major option number is followed by the title VOLUME which is used for
the estimation of Earthwork in cut and fill.
710 This minor option number is used to specify about the job title for the
Earthwork estimation. The data in this option is EARTHWORK.
711 This minor option number is to be used to specify about the input data file
(whether HDS002.FIL or HDS003.FIL or HDS004.F1L or HDSC02.FIL) by
mentioning as either XSEC or INTERFACE or CROSSECT or COMBINED
respectively
INPUT-XSEC
Or
INPUT INTERFACE
Or
INPUT - CROSSECT
Or
INPUT = COMBINED
712 This minor option is to be used to specify about the chainage interval in
metres to give intermediate breaks in the Earthwork Computation report. The
data is to be given as described below:
SUB =1000
720 This minor option number is optional and is immediately followed by the
option title MASSHAUL, it is a single word and there is no blank space
within this. This is used to request HEADS to analyse and to create the
drawing file for MASSHAUL diagram.
117
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
721 This minor option number is used to specify about the start and end chainage
to define the length segment along the alignment for which the MASS HAUL
diagram is to be created. The data is to be given as described below:
722 This minor option number is used to specify about the horizontal and vertical
scales to draw the MASS HAUL Diagram. The horizontal scale is applied on
the chainage values and the vertical scale is applied on the accumulative
volume values. The user may check the Report File "VOLUME.REP" to get
an idea about the maximum values for the Chainage and Accumulative
volume. The Accumulative volume is the sum of positive Cut and negative
Fill values at each chainage. The values are to be divided by the scale values
(either HS or VS) to fit them within the selected paper size. The data is to be
given is described below:
VS = Vertical scale as ( 1: VS )
723 This minor option number is used to specify about the increment of chainage
in metres to be written along the horizontal axis and the accumulative volume
in cubic metres to be written along the vertical axis. The data is to be given as
described below:
724 This minor option number is used to specify about the length and width of the
drawing sheet. The data is to be given as described below:
118
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
725 This minor option number is used to specify about the margin all around the
drawing sheet. The data is to be given as described below:
726 This minor option number is used to specify about the colour number and text
size to draw the line and write the texts in the drawing. The data is to be given
as described below:
FINISH This is the end statement for the Major Option '700, VOLUME'
1 10
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
110.000 0.000 14.708 0.000 144.533 60.000
120.000 0.000 15.059 0.000 148.830 60.000
130.000 0.000 15.961 0.000 155.100 60.000
140.000 0.000 16.625 0.000 162.930 60.000
150.000 0.000 18.601 0.000 176.130 60.000
160.000 0.000 19.415 0,000 190.080 60.000
170.000 0.000 21.030 0.000 202.223 60.000
180.000 0.000 20.945 0.000 209.873 60.000
120
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
520.000 0.020 0.095 0.101 2.741 60.000
530.000 0.709 0.000 3.649 0.476 60.000
540.000 2.475 0.000 15.922 0.000 60.000
550.000 . 0.000 4.327 12.375 21.637 60.000
560.000 0.000 2.100 0.000 32.137 60.000
570.000 3.803 0.000 19.013 10.500 60.000
580.000 4.979 0.000 43.905 0.000 60.000
590.000 4.896 0.000 49.373 0.000 60.000
600.000 4.483 0.000 46.897 0.000 60.000
510.000 5.177 0.000 48.300 O.OOO 60.000
620.000 5.514 0.000 53.453 0.000 60.000
630.000 5.544 0.000 55.290 0.000 60.000
640.000 5.850 0.000 56.970 0.000 60.000
650.000 7.143 0.000 64.965 0.000 60.000
660.000 7.881 0.000 75.120 0.000 60.000
670.000 8.454 0.000 81.675 0.000 60.000
680.000 8.942 0.000 86.978 0.000 60.000
•690.000 9.213 0.000 90.773 0.000 60.000
700.000 10.008 0.000 96.105 0.000 60.000
710.000 9.341 o.ooo 96.743 0.000 60.000
720.000 9.522 0.000 94.313 0.000 60.000
730.000 14.052 0.000 117.870 0.000 60.000
740.000 13.812 0.000 139.320 0.000 60.000
750.000 15.747 0.000 147.795 0.000 60.000
760.000 15.854 0.000 158.003 0.000 • 60.000
770.000 17.121 0.000 164.873 0.000 60.000
780.000 16.944 0.000 170.325 0.000 60,000
790.000 17.552 0.000 172.478 0.000 60.000
800.000 19.401 0.000 184.763 0.000 60.000
810.000 20.328 0.000 198.645 0.000 60.000
820.000 20.303 0.000 203.152 0.000 60.000
830.000 22.064 0.000 211.830 0.000 60.000
840.000 24.129 0.000 230.963 0.000 60.000
850.000 25.515 0.000 248.220 0.000 60.000
860.000 27.228 0.000 263.715 0.000 60.000
870.000 27.738 0.000 274.830 0.000 60.000
880.000 26.516 o.ooo 271.268 0.000 6Q.000
890.000 27.982 0.000 272.490 0.000 60.000
900.000 29.472 0.000 287.272 0.000 60.000
910.000 29.948 0.000 297.097 0.000 60.000
920.000 27.416 0.000 286.815 0.000 60.000
124
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS A N D DESIGN REPORTS
Bearing 148 52 05.809
Length 245.825
Straight Start X 87592.436
Straight Start Chainage 2+090.275
Straight Start Y 269916.969
Straight End Y 269706.548
Straight End X 87719.529
Straight End Chainage 2+536.100
********Element 10 ^rc********
Intersection Point Chainage 2+373.765
Intersection Point X 87739.002
Intersection Point Y 269674.307
Radius 200.000
Arc Start Chainage 2+336.100
Arc Start X 87719.529
Arc Start Y 269706.548
Included Angle 21 19 50.296
Arc Centre X 87890.725
Arc Centre Y 269809.949
Arc End Y 269651.358
Arc End X 81168.369
Arc End Chainage 2+410.558
Arc Length 74.458
Tangent 37.665
********Element 11 Straight********
Bearing 127 32 15.514
Length 420.486
Straight Start X 87768.869
Straight Start Chainage 2+410.558
Straight Start Y 269651.358
Straight End Y 269395.163
Straight End X 88102.295
Straight End Chainage 2+831.044
********Eleitient 12 ^^c********
Intersection Point Chainage 2+848.657
Intersection Point X 88116.261
Intersection Point Y 269384.432
Radius 200.000
Arc Start Chainage 2+831.044
Arc Start X 88102.295
Arc Start Y 269395.163
125
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS A N D DESIGN REPORTS
Included Angle 10 03 56.018
Arc Centre X 87980.438
Arc Centre Y 269236.573
Arc End Y 269371.425
Arc End X 88128.137
Arc End Chainage 2+866.180
Arc Length 35.135
Tangent 17.613
********EIernent 13 Straight********
Bearing 137 36 11.531
Length 392.371
Straight Start X 88128.137
Straight Start Chainage 2+866.180
Straight Start Y 269371.425
Straight End Y 269081.662
Straight End X 88392.697
Straight End Chainage 3+258.550
* * * * * * * * £ J_gf^g[^^ ]^^ P^j-^* *******
126
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS A N D DESIGN REPORTS
straight End Chainage 4+152.069
********Eleinent 16 Straight********
Bearing 161 18 29.186
Length 613.673
Straight Start X 89222.616
Straight Start Chainage 4+287.073
Straight Start Y 268490.106
Finish on Straight Y 267908.801
Finish on Straight X 89419.285
Finish on Straight Chainage 4+900.746
The output data as generated by the software is shown in Vertical Ahgnment Report.
127
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS A N D DESIGN REPORTS
Curve Start Gradient 1.497
Curve End Gradient -2.344
********EleTnent 3 Grade********
Gradient Length 238.052
Gradient Start Chainage 0+620.838
Grade Start Level 27.-396
Gradient End Level 21.916
Gradient End Chainage 0+858.890
Gradient -2.344
********Element 4 Vertical'Curve********
IP Chainage 0+918.890
IP Level 20.509
Curve Length 120.000
Vertical Radius 3445.514
M Value 2.902
K Value 34.455
Curve Type Sag
Curve Start Chainage 0+858.890
Curve Start Level 21.916
Curve End Level 21.192
Curve End Chainage 0+978-890
Curve Start Gradient -2.344
Curve End Gradient 1.138
********Element 5 Grade********
Gradient Length 352.227
Gradient Start Chainage 0+978.890
Grade Start Level 21.192
Gradient End Level 25.202
Gradient End Chainage 1+331.117
Gradient 1.138
********Element 6 Vertical Curve********
IP Chainage 1+391.117
IP Level 25.885
Curve Length 120.000
Vertical Radius -5123.765
M Value -1.952
K Value 51.238
Curve Type Hog
Sight Distance 153.873
Curve Start Chainage 1+331.117
Curve Start Level 25.202
129
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS A N D DESIGN REPORTS
Curve Start Level 14.209
Curve End Level 14.647
Curve End Chainage 2+562.090
Curve Start Gradient -1.043
Curve End Gradient 1.774
********Eleraent 11 Grade********
Gradient Length 1019.56S
Gradient Start Chainage 2+562.090
Grade Start Level 14.647
Gradient End Level 32.733
Gradient End Chainage 3+581.658
Gradient 1.774
********Element 12 Vertical Curve********
IP Chainage 3+641.658
IP Level 33.797
Curve Length 120.000
Vertical Radius -22408.247
M Value -.446
K Value 224.082
Curve Type Hog
Sight Distance 470.543
Curve Start Chainage 3+581.658
Curve Start Level 32.733
Curve End Level 34.540
Curve End Chainage 3+701.658
Curve Start Gradient 1.774
Curve End Gradient 1.238
********Element 13 Grade********
Gradient Length 579.766
Gradient Start Chainage ' 3+701.658
Grade Start Level 34.540
Gradient End Level 41.719
Gradient End Chainage 4+281.424
Gradient 1.238
********Element 14 Vertical Curve********
IP Chainage 4+341.424
IP Level 42.462
Curve Length 120.000
Vertical Radius -2744.639
M Value -3.643
K value 27.446
130
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS A N D DESIGN REPORTS
Curve Type Hog
Sight Distance 109,.856
Curve Start Chainage 4+281,.424
Curve Start Level 41,,719
Curve End Level 40.,582
Curve End Chainage 4+401.,424
Curve Start Gradient 1.,238
Curve End Gradient -3.,134
********Element 15 Grade********
Gradient Length 499.,322
Gradient Start Chainage 4+401 .424
Grade Start Level 40 .582
Gradient End Level 24 .934
The user input data generated for cross section analysis by the software is given in
the following paragraph.
The output data as generated by the software is shown in Chainages and Offsets Report
The cross section design template of the software is used as user input and few
cross sections generated by the software are shown in Fig. 6.3 and 6.4.
Model: DESIGN
Reference String: MCOD
Offset String: CEOO
Units: Metric
Date-. l/lS/2010 \ ( J - . 2 1 ; 5 1 ?M
131
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
o
o
o
B
.s
'S
U
cs
u
a
o
OS
Q
s
*-S
V
N
03
n m
EE 0
s
rn ^ II o
o
CD ^ o
0 ct^ o
E 1-H
o\• o 3 <u
_( OJ}
II II 0
>
Qi a) *«
EE fD
_j C"* c«
Q 0 0 w
> > 4^ «
-> -1- i 1
IL U < «
•o
n
e
E >>
0
.£
KOCB- HD'E
0
0
0 N u
t-
E Q
liJ c
13 <f .2
< \I]
z N N ^ (/I
< E E 0
I \0 >J II
u
1^ VO iri
m
m ^ 01 \6
L
dd <
CJD
t^
II II
ID ™ (D
flj fl) C
L L 0
<< ^
-> -1-
::: D "D i
IL U <
133
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
Offset '3.000
Chainage 0+010.000
X 87108.433
Y 271733.175
Level 20.608
Offset String Point Number 3
Offset X 87116.370
Offset Y 271726.392
Offset Level 20.631
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+020.000
X 87113.847
y 271724.768
Level 20.706
Offset String Point Number 4
Offset X 87121.784
Offset Y 271717.985
Offset Level 20.730
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+030.000
X 87119.262
Y 271716.360
Level 20.805
Offset String Point Number 5
Offset X 87127.198
Offset Y 271709.577
Offset Level 20.829
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+040.000
X 87124.676
Y 271707.953
Level 20.904
Offset String Point Number 6
Offset X 87132.612
Offset Y 271701.170
Offset Level 20.928
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+050.000
X 87130.090
Y 271699.545
Level 21.003
Offset String Point Number 7
Offset X 87138.026
Offset Y 271692.762
Offset Level 21.026
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+060,000
X 87135.504
Y 271691.138
Level 21.101
Offset String Point Number 8
Offset X 87143.441
Offset Y 271684.355
Offset Level 21.125
Offset -3-000
Chainage 0+070.000
X 87140.918
Y 271682.730
Level 21.200
Offset String Point dumber ^
Offset X 87148.855
134
CHAPTER 6; DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
Offset Y 271675.947
Offset Level 21.224
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+080.000
^ 87146.332
Y 271674.323
Level 21.299
Offset String Point Number 10
Offset X 87154.269
Offset Y 211661.539
Offset Level 21.323
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+090.000
^ 87151.747
^ 271665.915
Level 21.398
Offset String Point Number 11
Offset X 87159.683
Offset Y 271659.132
Offset Level 21.421
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+100.000
^ 87157.161
Y 271657.508
Level 21.496
Offset String Point Number 12
Offset X 87165.097
Offset Y 271650.724
Offset Level 21.520
Offset -3.000
Chainage _ 0+110.000
X 87162.575
Y 271649.100
Level 21.595
Offset String Point Number 13
Offset X 87170.511
Offset Y 271642.317
Offset Level 21.619
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+120.000
X 87167.989
y 271640.693
Level 21.694
Offset String Point Number 14
Offset X 87175.926
Offset Y 271633.909
Offset Level 21.718
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+130.000
X 87173.403
Y 271632.285
Level 21.793
Offset String Point Number 15
Offset X 87181.340
Offset Y 271625.502
Offset Level 21.816
Offset -3.000
Chainage . 0 + 140.000
X 87178.818
Y 271623.878
Level 21.891
136
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS A N D DESIGN REPORTS
Y 271573.099
Level 22.484
Offset String Point Number 23
Offset X 87217.966
Offset Y 211565.-iSS
Offset Level 22.507
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+210.000
X 87215.254
Y 271564.170
Level 22.582
Offset String Point Number 24
Offset X 87222.076
Offset Y 271556.174
Offset Level 22.606
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+220.000
X 87219.304
Y 271555.028
Level 22.681
Offset String Point Number 25
Offset X 87225.717
Offset Y 271546.701
Offset Level 22.705
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0-^230.000
X 87222.891
Y 271545.695
Level 22.780
Offset String Point Number 26
Offset X 87228.880
Offset Y 271537.057
Offset Level 22.804
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+240.000
X 87226.007
Y 271536.194
Level 22.879
Offset String Point Number 27
Offset X 87231.557
Offset Y 271527.268
Offset Level 22.902
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+250.000
X 87228.645
Y 271526.549
Level 22.911
Offset String Point Number 28
Offset X 87233.742
Offset Y 271517.357
Offset Level 23 .001
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+260.000
X 87230.797
Y 271516.784
Level 23.076
Offset String Point Number 29
Offset X 87235.428
Offset Y 271507.349
Offset Level 23.100
Offset -3.000
138
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
Offset Level 23.692
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+330.000
X 87238.672
Y 271441.249
Level 23.767
Offset String Point Number 37
Offset X 87242.664
Offset Y 271437.602
Offset Level 23.791
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+340.000
X 87239.679
Y 271437.300
Level 23.866
Offset String Point Number 38
Offset X 87243.200
Offset Y 271432.312
Offset Level 23.844
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+345.317
X 87240.215
Y 271432.010
Level 23.919
Offset String Point Number 39
Offset X 87243.672
Offset Y 271427.653
Offset Level 23.889
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+350.000
X 87240.687
Y 271427.351
Level 23.964
Offset String Point Number 40
Offset X 87244.680
Offset Y 271417.704
Offset Level 23.984
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+360.000
X 87241.695
Y 271417.402
Level 24.059
Offset String Point Number 41
Offset X 87245.687
Offset Y 271407.755
Offset Level 24.075
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+370.000
X 87242.703
Y • 271407.453
Level 24.150
Offset String Point Number 42
Offset X 87246.695
Offset Y 271397.806
Offset Level 24.162
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+380.000
X 87243.710
Y 271397.504
Level 24.237
Offset String Point Number 43
142
CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+580.000
X 87263.864
Y 271198.522
Level 25.391
Offset String Point Number 64
Offset X 87267.857
Offset Y 271188.875
Offset Level 25.367
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+590.000
X 87264.872
Y 271188.573
Level 25.442
Offset String Point Number 65
Offset X 87268.865
Offset Y 271178.926
Offset Level 25.417
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+600.000
X 87265.880
Y 271178.623
Level 25.492
Offset String Point Number 66
Offset X 87269.872
Offset Y 271168.977
Offset Level 25.467
Offset -3.OO0
Chainage 0+610.000
X 87266.888
Y 271168.674
Level 25.542
Offset String Point Number 67
Offset X 87270.880
Offset Y 271159.028
Offset Level 25.518
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+620.000
X 87267.895
Y ' 271158.725
Level 25.593
Offset String Point Number 68
Offset X 87271.888
Offset Y 271149.078
Offset Level 25.568
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+630.000
X 87268.903
Y 271148.776
Level 25.643
Offset String Point Number 69
Offset X 87272.895
Offset Y 271139.129
Offset Level . 25.619
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+640.000
X 87269.911
Y 271138.827
Level 25.694
Offset String Point Number 70
Offset X 87273.903
144
' CHAPTER 6: DATA ANALYSIS AND DESIGN REPORTS
Offset String Point Number 77
Offset X 87280.957
Offset Y 271059.537
Offset Level 26.022
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+720.000
X 87277.972
Y 271059.234
Level 26.097
Offset String Point Number 78
Offset X 87281.965
Offset Y 271049.588
Offset Level 26.072
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+730.000
X 87278.980
Y 271049.285
Level 26.147
Offset String Point Number 79
Offset X 87282.972
Offset Y 271039.638
Offset Level 26.123
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+740.000
X 87279.988
Y ^ 271039.336
Level 26.198
Offset String Point Number 80
Offset X 87283.980
Offset Y 271029.689
Offset Level 26.173
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+750.000
X 87280.995
Y 271029.387
Level 26.248
Offset String Point Number 81
Offset X 87284.988
Offset Y 271019.740
Offset Level 26.223
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+760.000
X 87282.003
Y 271019.438
Level 26.298
Offset String Point Number 82
Offset X 87285.996
Offset Y 271009.791
Offset Level 26.274
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+770.000
X 87283.011
Y 271009.489
Level 26.349
Offset String Point Number 83
Offset X 87287.003
Offset Y 270999.842
Offset Level 26.324
Offset -3.000
Chainage 0+180,000
X 87284.018
The user input data generated for Earthwork Calculations by the software is given
in the following paragraph. The output data as generated by the software is shown in Bulk
Earthworks. Earth work in cut and fill is calculated at an interval of 50 m in the results.
BULK EARTHWORKS
Scheme : DESIGN INDIAMCll
Date : Saturday, Jul 25 2009
Time : 13:58:17
Curvature Correction ON
METRIC tJNITS
EXISTING TO . End Area End Area Volume Volume
DESIGN linage Cut (m2) Fill {m2) Cut (m3) Fill (m3)
0 0.785 0.002 0 0
Cut Factor = 1 . 0 0 50 0 6.079 5.567 139.203
Fill Factor =
1.00 100 0 12.997 0 473.735
Cut Cost = 0 . 0 0 150 0 18.766 0 779.836
Fill Cost = 0 . 0 0 200 0 23.433 0 1062.755
250 0 27.346 0 1218.965
300 0 26.625 0 1389.703
350 0 23.675 0 1290.588
400 0 25.259 0 1300.744
450 0 10.254 0 906.722
500 0 2.498 0 256.244
550 1.884 0.91 12.252 83.599
600 4.37 0 93.385 27.793
650 7.83 0 313.098 0
700 9.985 0 437.152 0
750 14.561 0 625.248 0
1 AtL
7.1 CONCLUSIONS
1. Road design models in MX Road and HEADS are very similar. They differ only
by their functions and abilities. The use of different software products makes it
possible to solve different complex design tasks.
3. The key element of a road model in both the software is road geometry which is
the basis of the structure of all design models. The more simple and accurate is the
design of geometry in CAD system the better is the computerization of the design
process, saving in user time and money.
4. Surface Checker is used to check a surface created from surveyed data once it has been
input to MX. It can be used to check any surface in applications such as landfill and
quarrying to identify incorrect or incomplete data. This includes null levels, zero levels,
single point strings, high points, low points, coincident points and intersection points.
The results may be obtained graphically or as a report. No such feature is available in
the HEADS to check the error in the survey data.
5. Both the software lack dynamic relationship of the project data, i.e. a change in
one object does not cause an automatic renewal and representation of the other
related project data. If a change or modification is to be incorporated in the design
model at any stage then the model reports need to be generated again to
incorporate the desired change in the design.
6. If a Design Engineer joins the firm in the middle of the project then it is more easy
to understand the steps in HEADS as report files are simultaneously generated
when a model is run in the default folder of the project whereas in MX no such
reports are generated.
149
^ ^ : ^ E R 7: CONCLUSIONS AND SCOPE FOR FUTURE STUDY
7. The installation of HEADS is very straightforward. Total installation time takes
approximately 15 minutes. CAD Engine along with extensions is installed at the
same time as the software itself by entering key codes that was supplied by
Softtech. A USB Key (Hardware Lock) is provided with the software, so we can
install the software in any computer and access the program by using the Key.
Although the installation of MX is somewhat different than installation of
HEADS, it is nevertheless fairly straightforward and easy to understand. Firstly,
Micro station prerequisite suite is to be installed prior to the installation of MX
Suite. Overall, installation of MX Road requires more time in comparison to
installation of HEADS and is computer specific. We can install MX in the
specified computer for which the software code is generated by Bentley. If the
system is formatted the software is to be reinstalled with new license file as the
details of the system are changed. We have to call Bentley people or send them
the details of the system required by them so that they send us new license key.
8. The amount of reference manuals and training available in case of HEADS is very
limited. The tutorial, which can be found on the HEADS website, is an outline of
the modules incorporated into the software. On the other hand Bentley offers an
abundance of manuals and training courses for MX Road software. Bentley also
offers technical support and an extensive online knowledge base for MX Road.
9. Accessing and displaying Survey Data with both the software is found to be
straightforward. Survey data can be saved in any Windows directory and accessed
directly from that location. HEADS offers different data import and export options
in most widely used formats in the market whereas in MX Road input options are
limited.
10. The MX input survey database is much more structured than that of HEADS. In
general, the MX database does not allow the user as much fi*eedom in working
with Survey data. MX forces the user to develop a specific naming convention for
features surveyed in the study area. In order to work with data outside the naming
convention or in another project, the naming convention of the database should be
altered or the data were resurveyed as per MX naming convention. Once the MX
database design concept was fully understood, import and export of data in several
different formats was rapidly conducted. Import and export of numerous data
11. In HEADS there is very few problems encountered when displaying and working
with the data downloaded for this project. However, when exporting data from
HEADS to other file formats, the resultant export files sometimes may not be read
in MX Road due to different naming convention.
12. The alignment of the road is finalized using GPS data and the two software. For
the sake of easy comparison the alignment has been kept the same in both the
software. The alignment has been shown in Fig. 6.1.
13. In MX Road the survey data of the area under study is analysed and the horizontal
and vertical intersection points are marked either by input file or by keyboard
entry and the design string is created using these intersection points all the design
parameters like speed, length of curve can be incorporated in the input data. We
can change the location of alignment in the drawing itself and the changes are
incorporated automatically in the results once the module is run again. In HEADS
Horizontal and Vertical Intersection points are entered using text file code. We
cannot change the alignment in the drawing but we can change the design by
changing the text file code for the horizontal and vertical design modules. For
alignment HEADS is easy but for the edifing in the proposed alignment MX Road
offers more comfort as it is easy to incorporate changes in the alignment in
drawing by checking various obligatory points then to edit the text code.
14. Output of horizontal design and vertical design using HEADS and MX Road are
shown in section 6.2 and 6.3 for HEADS and 6.6 and 6.7 for MX Road
respectively.
15. Few cross secfions drawn by both the software are displayed in Fig. 6.2 to Fig. 6.5
in the study for comparison of extent of detailing provided by each software.
16. The report of volume calculation is attached for the comparison in section 6.5 for
HEADS and 6.8 for MX Road.
151
! CHAPTER 7: CONCLUSIONS AND SCOPE FOR FUTURE STUDY
7.2 SCOPE FOR FUTURE STUDY
1. Only three formats of survey data are analyzed in the study i.e. total station, auto
level and GPS data. Other formats like Topo Maps, Aerial Photograph and
Satellite Imagery Remote Sensing may be considered for the future study.
2. More complex problems like interchange design, and rotary intersection etc. may
be studied to check the capabilities of software in handling complex situations.
3. Other software like Inroads, Auto Civil 3D and other road designing software
available in the market may also be incorporated in ftiture study to recommend the
most suitable software in the market.
152
CHAPTER 7: CONCLUSIONS AND SCOPE FOR FUTURE STUDY
REFERENCES
Indian Roads Congress (IRC: 73, 1980), Geometric Design Standards for Rural
Highways, New Delhi.
Indian Roads Congress (SP: 23, 1993), Vertical Curves for Highways, New Delhi.
HEADS Manual
MX Road Manual
153
REFERENCES