Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
A Project on
VIPIN SHAH
1|Page
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Introduction…………………………………..…………………………………….3
2. Labour Policy in India and Labour Legislation………..………………………….4-6
3. Relevant Provisions as regards welfare of Labour……………...…………………6-8
4. Different Plan Periods & Development of Labour Policy………………………..8-15
5. Conclusion……………………………………………………………………...…..16
2|Page
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
I. INTRODUCTION
Capital has been exploiting the labour to their own maximum benefit for they have
better economic footing and power and further stand in better position to dictate their
terms. It is generally expected that solving labour problems is the major responsibility
of the Government of any country and the Government is vested with powers to enact
and implement labour laws for solving problems not only of labours but also of
managements. The experience however has been made that labour laws themselves
cannot solve labour problems.
After the independence, the cost of living has considerably increased. The increase in
the cost of living and countrywide political up surge found its way in economic
discontent among the masses, particularly in the industries. The industrial unrest and
economic discontent led to number of strikes and labour trouble.
Workers were generally illiterate and poor and unaware about their rights. Workers
are weak in negotiating with the employer for employment and wages. The employer
dictated their own terms and conditions regarding wages and the employment. The
workers being in weaker position have no choice but to accept such terms for
employment because employment was the only means to earn their livelihood and
feed their family.
On the other hand, without considering the paying capacity of the management there
is a constant demand from labourers, for revision oi wages and allowances, even
though concern may not be in a position to fulfill workers reasonable expectations
about the wages, working conditions and welfare facilities.
Labour welfare is one of the major aspects of the national programmes towards
bettering the majority of labour and cheating a life hit and work environment of direct
comfort for the class of population. The term "welfare" is very flexible as well as
comprehensive. It includes welfare of labour as well as his family members. The
Government has made various rules, regulations and acts for the betterment of
labours life.1
1
S.P.Jain & Simmi Agrawal, Industrial & Labour Laws, [9th edn. 2002 Dhanpatrai & Company (P) Ltd].
3|Page
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
2
S C Srivastava, Industrial Relations and Labour Laws, 26 [6th edn. Vikas Publishing House Pvt. Ltd., Noida, U.P]
4|Page
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
laws which deal with employment and non- employment, wages, working conditions,
industrial relations, social security and labour welfare of industrially employed,
persons. The Government has made following Acts for the betterment of labours life:
1. The Factories Act 1948
2. The Payment of Wages Act 1936
3. The Industrial Employment Act (Standing Orders) 1946
4. The Workmen’s Compensation Act 1923
5. The Trade Union Act 1926
6. The Minimum Wages Act 1948
7. The Employees State Insurance Act 1948
8. The Employees Provident Funds Family Pension Fund and Deposit-linked
Insurance Fund Act, 1952.
Though the Government has made these Acts for the betterment of workers. The
implementation of Labour Welfare and security schemes is not satisfactory. Many
provisions and the Sections of the Act are contradictory and do not provide clear
meaning of the Act. The aims of all these Act is to provide reasonable wages and
work condition to the worker at work place and facilities like education, recreation,
medical etc. However, the implementation of this all Acts become very difficult,
some of the workers are ignorant about their rights, risk about hazardous job. In many
Acts workers rights to be away from hazardous operation remains overlooked or
unnoticed.
Employer’s expenditure on the repairs and maintenance of the machinery,
modernization, automation and computerization goes on increasing at the cost of
health and security of the workers. The workers do not get effective medicines and
proper medicare from the doctors because of improper implementation of Employees
State Insurance Scheme. (ESIS).
It is also found that the system of determination of minimum wages is not scientific
and minimum wages determined by such Act is not able to provide reasonable and
adequate wages to the workers or the wages provided by Minimum Wages Act 1948
is inadequate to serve the basic need of the employee.
Wages paid to the labour in small scale industries and labour in unorganized sector is
very low. Their wages are not sufficient to provide them food, clothes and shelter, i.e.
Roti, Kapda Aur Makan. It is very essential to revise and reformulate minimum
wages legislation after every five years. However, only committees were appointed to
review the minimum wages. These Committees took long time to review and find out
changed conditions. The Committees have right to make recommendations regarding
wages, and these recommendations are not followed by the appropriate Government.
Same time there may not be major changes in the recommendation made by the
committee and so that ultimate object or purpose is not achieved.
Some time the recommendations are opposed by 'big' managements and there is a
retreat on the part of Government to management. Strategies for revision of
allowances rather than basic wages. When Government appoints pay commission for
deciding the minimum and maximum levels of wages, different issues are considered
and it creates controversial points regarding the minimum and maximum wages.
Wages should be determined in the light of per capita national income and the wages
should be increased according to the cost of living of the workers or rate of inflation.
5|Page
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
It has been observed that instead of formulating a long term wage policy on national
basis, state or region wage policy was formulated and adhoc measures like increases
in dearness allowances, house rent allowances, increase in management contributions
are used for. In recent years, agreement between employer and employees are being
made.
III. Relevant Provisions as regards welfare of Labour:
India adopted her own Constitution and declared herself as an Independent Sovereign
Republic. The constitution established system of Government. The aim of
constitution is to provide welfare to all its citizens and ensure guarantee of their
fundamental rights. Labour being an integral part of the society found prominent
position in the constitutional provisions with regard to their protection of rights.The
constitution provides adequate safeguards for minority, backward, and tribal areas,
and depressed and other backward classes. The protection of the interest of the
Working Class was paramount in the mind of the makers of the Indian Constitution.
In a Welfare State all are assured of adequate help is case of need due to illness, old
age physical or mental incapacity, unemployment or lack of economic power. State
assistance is given as a right and not as a charity and no stigma or pauperization is
attached to those who receive it.
The Fundamental Rights incorporated in the constitution relate to the political
democracy on the citizen and the directive principles deal with social, economic and
cultural democracy. The Fundamental Rights are the basic principles on which the
democratic sovereign is founded and give direction to the state action in clear terms.
When these principles are translated into practice, it leads to the development of a
welfare state. The Directive Principles of state policy of the constitution may be
stated as below:3
Article 38 of the constitution declares that the state shall strive to promote the
welfare of the people by securing and protecting as effectively as it may a
social order in which justice - social, economic and political and shall inform
all the institution of the national life.
Article 41 states that State shall within the limits of economic capacity and
development, make provisions for securing the right to work, to education and
public assistance in case of unserved want.' (Such as unemployment, old age,
sickness and disablement)
Article 42 provides for securing just and human conditions of work and for
maternity relief. No child below 14 shall, be employed to work in Factory,
Mine or engaged in any other hazardous employment.
Article 43, imposes upon the state obligations (either by suitable legislations
or economic organization or any other way) to secure to all workers,
agricultural, industrial, or otherwise, work, a living, wage, conditions of work
ensuring a decent standard of life and full enjoyment of leisure and social and
cultural opportunities and in particular the State shall endeavor to promote
cottage industries on individual and cooperative basis in rural areas.
Article 43A states the state shall take steps by suitable legislations or in any
other way to secure the participation of workers in the management of
3
The Constitution of India, Provisions in Directive Principles for Labour Welfare
6|Page
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
7|Page
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
4
Labour Welfare Schemes in India and Labour Policy of the Government, 78.
5
S. Mathur, Labour Policy and Industrial Relations in India, 78 [Ram Prasad and Sons, Agra, 1968].
8|Page
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
9|Page
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
6
S. Mishra, Modern Labour Laws and Industrial Relations, [Deep and Deep Publications, NewDelhi, 1992].
10 | P a g e
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
11 | P a g e
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
On the other hand, fair wage was somewhere midway between the minimum
and the living wage and it would be determined with reference to the capacity
of the industry to pay the wage and the prevailing rate of wages in the same or
similar industry. Government’s policy was to link the wage-rise with the rise
in productivity. The Second Plan specifically stated: “Earnings beyond the
minimum wage should be necessarily related to results.”
Third Five Year Plan: The Government is continuing the wage policy as
enunciated by the Second Plan. The Third Plan has accepted the system of
wage boards and also proposes that the unanimous recommendations of a
wage board in an industry should be implemented fully. In the determination
of wages, the need-based minimum wage should be used.
Apart from the minimum wages, adequate incentives should be provided for
the acquisition and development- of skills and for improvements in output and
quality. The Third Plan proposed to appoint a Commission to study the
problems connected with bonus claims and to evolve guiding principles and
norms for the payment of bonus.8
ix. Working Conditions Safety and Welfare:
The Government has evolved a comprehensive code to ensure satisfactory
working conditions, safety of persons and the provision of a variety of
facilities to promote the welfare of the workers. But the implementation of the
statutory provisions has not been effective.
The Third Plan calls upon all State Governments to strengthen the
inspectorates provided for the administration of factory laws. Emphasis is
placed on the safety of persons in factories and mines and appropriate
machinery is being devised. Special Welfare funds are being constituted for
financing welfare measures for workers in coal and other mines.
The Government is interested in encouraging workers’ cooperatives in the
field of credit, housing, distribution of consumer goods, etc. The Government
feels that trade unions and voluntary organisations should take initiative and
evince interest in starting and running such cooperatives.
The Third Plan points out that despite the operation of the subsidised
Industrial Housing Scheme, for some years, housing of industrial workers has
not made much progress and in many cases it has actually deteriorated. The
Third Plan calls for a new approach to the problem of industrial housing so
that workers would have decent living conditions within a reasonable period
of time.
x. Employment and Training Schemes:
In a developing economy, the demand for skilled workers would increase
continuously and the Government has various schemes to meet such demand.
By the end of the Second Plan, there were 166 industrial training institutes
with 42,000 training seats. The Third Plan has proposed to increase the
number of these institutes to a total of 318 with an additional 58,000 training
seats.
The annual training capacity would be raised to 1 lakh. The Government has
also made adequate provisions for “in-plant training” facilities. It has also
8
http://www.economicsdiscussion.net, [Last visited on 23/10/2018]
12 | P a g e
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
13 | P a g e
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
14 | P a g e
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
15 | P a g e
ASSIGNMENT ON LABOUR AND INDUSTRIAL LAW 2018
V. CONCLUSION
In free India, the labour movement and trade unions should be in a position to assume larger
responsibilities in the context of new scenario and challenges which are coming up on the advent
of 21st century. One of the main tasks in the Five Year Plans is to evolved practical ways in
which they can make an increasing contribution to national development and national policy.
Economic progress of a country is bound up with industrial place. Industrial relations are,
therefore, not a matter between employers and employees alone, but a vital concern of the
community which may be expressed in measures for the protection of its larger interests.
16 | P a g e