Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
71
— P A P E R 2 C —
High-Pressure Zirconium
Urea Stripper
®
C O R R O S I O N S O L U T I O N S C O N F E R E N C E 2 0 0 9 — P R O C E E D I N G S
29409-CSC09 Pro_INT_100427 4/28/10 4:25 PM Page 72
this urea stripper. This paper will also Figure 1. Aerial view of the Profertil fertilizer complex.
review the operating experience and
success achieved after nearly three
years in service.
KEYWORDS
• zirconium
• urea production
• urea stripper
• Omegabond ®
• Zircadyne ®
• stainless steel
• organic acids
• mineral acids
• ammonia
• heat exchanger
• chemical process industry
• UNS S31050 INITIAL CORROSION In all the aforementioned corrosion
PROBLEMS events with the 310MoLN stainless
INTRODUCTION When the original commissioned steel, no deleterious effects were
The high-pressure urea stripper (2001) urea stripper design was observed to the zirconium material.
exists in one of the most severe specified, the preferred wetted One example of the extreme
process conditions in the urea plant. internal materials of construction corrosion issue seen in the
The urea stripper is a vertical heat were zirconium lined / SS 310MoLN stainless steel weld
exchanger (falling film evaporator) (310MoLN) bimetallic tubing and overlay between exchanger tubing
which operates under high stainless steel overlay (310MoLN is seen in Figure 2. Such corrosion
temperatures and pressures. equivalent) on the channels. During caused leakage of process media
Historically, a number of material the initial operation of the urea to the lower pressure side of the
solutions have been applied to the plant, Profertil’s urea stripper exchanger and severe damage to
Snamprogetti (Saipem SpA) urea experienced a number of corrosion the carbon steel tube sheets.
stripper design. Because of the issues, largely confined to the In order to maintain production,
severe corrosion experiences with bottom (outlet) channel section. Profertil was required to undergo a
urea strippers, several generations These corrosion problems included number of repairs to the original
of designs were developed including the following: commissioned unit. The severe
the following: corrosion problems led Profertil to
• Corrosion in the 310MoLN repair and eventually plug over 500
• Titanium explosive-clad steel stainless steel tubesheet weld of the 3600 tubes in the urea
equipment and solid Ti-3 overlay. stripper. Initially auxiliary passivation
tubes. • Corrosion in the 310MoLN air was not added to the lower
• Various combinations of 25- stainless steel weld overlay channel area to mitigate the
22-2 (Cr-Ni-Mo) stainless steel applied to the lower channel corrosion effects noted above.
(310MoLN) wetted internals stainless steel lining. However, when auxiliary passivation
with zirconium lined / SS • Corrosion in the exposed air was added in 2002, the
(310MoLN) bimetallic tubes, 310MoLN stainless steel bi- corrosion attack continued. Efforts
and with and without auxiliary metallic tube ends and the to limit the lower channel operating
passivation air to protect the tube-to-tubesheet strength temperature to 204°C (~400°F)
(310MoLN) components. welds. were only partially successful in
• Zircadyne ® explosive-clad • Corrosion in the 310MoLN lessening the corrosion attack in the
steel equipment and solid Zr tubes under the zirconium 310MoLN stainless steel.
702 tubes. tube (inner liner) caused by a After input from other producers
• OmegaBond ® tubes and stagnant zone due to poor operating facilities with a urea
titanium-clad steel equipment. bonding. stripper design similar to Profertil’s,
®
Zircadyne and OmegaBond are registered trademarks of ATI Properties, Inc.
®
C O R R O S I O N S O L U T I O N S C O N F E R E N C E 2 0 0 9 — P R O C E E D I N G S
29409-CSC09 Pro_INT_100427 4/28/10 4:25 PM Page 73
and who in turn were suffering similar practices. It has been reported a even at 204°C (400°F). This
corrosion behavior, the consensus number of times that strippers in the operating temperature limit is
was Profertil had suffered some of same environment, manufactured exacerbated by slightly altered
the worst corrosion effects based on by different vendors, exhibit very material chemistry and properties
limited operating time. Additionally, different behavior and performance. resulting from fabrication practices.
the view was that the 310MoLN Thus small variations in the process
stainless steel was near its operating conditions, such as the NH 3 /CO 2
temperature limits within the urea MATERIAL SOLUTIONS ratio (even for a short time of a few
stripper environment. Due to the on CONSIDERED hours), or an increased operating
going corrosion problems Initially, a number of options were temperature may lead to severe
experienced, Profertil began their investigated, but one option corrosion of the materials. This high
review of alternative materials of discounted very quickly was to sensitivity to the process conditions
construction. fabricate another unit with the bi- reduces the plant’s flexibility and
metallic tube design. The three increases the safety concerns for
options considered were the operations. Even with adding the
MATERIAL EVALUATION & titanium design, the Safurex® duplex passivation air it was thought that
SELECTION stainless steel design and the solid the stainless steel was close to its
Because of the extreme corrosive Zircadyne ® zirconium tube design. limit in regards to the corrosion
conditions in the urea stripper, a According to Proferil’s plant resistance.
number of considerations had to be experience, the 310MoLN stainless The titanium design with the
taken into account to ensure that the steel bimetallic design may have clad liner plates and solid titanium
optimum material was selected. In been used if the passive corrosion tubes was discounted as many urea
these severe conditions, the state could be achieved but, as producers reported issues with
corrosion resistance of the current experienced, slight changes in the erosion / corrosion of the titanium
materials used was shown to be process conditions caused the SS tubes in the upper section of the
dependent and very sensitive to to revert to an active corrosion heat exchanger. The corrosion /
chemical variables of the process state. It was understood that even erosion issue in the upper portion
conditions. Furthermore, it is well- with passivation air addition into the of the heat exchanger resulted in
known that the corrosion resistance bottom of the stripper, the titanium urea stripper units to be
behavior of these materials depends 310MoLN stainless steel was very designed for rotation 180°C (356°F)
strongly on using proper fabrication near its operating temperature limit, after approximately 8–10 years to
produce a cost effective production
usage.
Figure 2. Extreme corrosion seen in the 310MoLN weld overlay at the bottom tube
sheet between exchanger tubing. Safurex ® had been considered
by Profertil but due to an exclusive
agreement between Sandvik and
Stamicarbon, the use of Safurex ® in
the Snamprogetti process was not
an option. Even though the Safurex®
duplex stainless steel had proven
corrosion resistance over that of the
310MoLN stainless steels in the
Stamicarbon urea operations, the
corrosion resistance was less than
that expected for zirconium.
Following a one year
investigation, Profertil selected the
option of fabricating the urea
stripper using zirconium lined steel
equipment with solid zirconium
tubes. The zirconium mill products
were obtained from ATI Wah Chang
and the fabrication of the vessel was
performed by Officine Luigi Resta,
SpA of Scanzorosciate, Italy [1] .
®
C O R R O S I O N S O L U T I O N S C O N F E R E N C E 2 0 0 9 — P R O C E E D I N G S
29409-CSC09 Pro_INT_100427 4/28/10 4:25 PM Page 74
®
C O R R O S I O N S O L U T I O N S C O N F E R E N C E 2 0 0 9 — P R O C E E D I N G S
29409-CSC09 Pro_INT_100427 4/28/10 4:25 PM Page 75
zirconium alloys. Zr 702 has lower Figure 3. The completed vessel arriving at the Profertil fertilizer complex in Bahia
strength and generally better Blanca, Argentina.
corrosion resistance than Zr 705. The
Zr 705 alloy, with 2–3% niobium, has
higher strength and better formability
than that of the Zr 702 grade. The Zr
700 grade is used for explosion-
cladding applications.
Zirconium is less dense than
stainless steel and has much better
thermal conductivity. Zirconium also
has a much higher melting point and
a very low thermal expansion as
compared to other materials used
in urea production facilities. Table 3
shows a comparison of properties
of materials used in urea production.
CORROSION RESISTANCE
OF ZIRCONIUM
Zirconium has had a long history of
excellent corrosion-resistant
properties in many applications. equipment. Because zirconium is titanium clad channels and heads
There are a large number of ductile, it can be explosively-clad to were used. It was found during the
applications where zirconium has stainless or mild steel and fabricated fabrication of this zirconium urea
been placed in extremely corrosive in clad vessels using the batten stripper that the “conventional”
environments for many years strap technique. The earliest reactive metals batten strap clad
without experiencing any corrosion zirconium vessel fabricated using construction methods were not
attack. In particular, zirconium explosive-cladded material was in sufficient for this vessel [3] . After a
reactors and heat exchangers were the early 1970s. Since that time, number of batten strap weld failures
used in the urea services for over over 30 explosive clad pressure during the construction process, it
25 years without showing signs of vessels have been manufactured was found that the new generation
corrosion attack. The primary use with zirconium. Although zirconium of urea stripper would require
of zirconium in the chemical is a reactive metal, it can be readily unique design and fabrication
processing industry (CPI) has been welded using equipment and similar techniques different from that used
in organic acids (e.g., acetic acid processes that are being used for in conventional construction
and formic acid) but also in mineral stainless steel equipment. Zirconium methods. Determining the proper
acids such as nitric, sulfuric, and is however, much more reactive design required many weld tests
hydrochloric acids. than stainless steel so greater and stress analyses.
attention to cleanliness and Officine Luigi Resta developed
shielding is needed. a new technique based upon many
ZIRCONIUM FABRICABILITY investigations and studies carried
Zirconium has good fabricability. It out after hydrotest failures of the
can be formed, machined, and ZIRCONIUM UREA STRIPPER original designed zirconium material
fabricated using conventional FABRICATION liners. The result is a new design of
techniques and equipment currently Although zirconium had been used the filler and cover straps based
applied to other more common in many heat exchanger designs upon a double filler strap and a
materials of construction. Zirconium during the past 40 years, zirconium reduced thickness cover strap. With
Grade 702 and Grade 705 are had never been previously applied this design, operating stress level is
currently approved for use in the as a solid tube material in a high- lowered and peak stresses in the
ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel pressure urea stripper. Officine Luigi area of the filler straps were
Code. It is commonly fabricated into Resta had significant experience in eliminated.
solid and explosive-clad vessels for fabrication of previous urea strippers The incorporation of zirconium
use in chemical processing where solid titanium tubing and as the corrosion-resistant material
®
C O R R O S I O N S O L U T I O N S C O N F E R E N C E 2 0 0 9 — P R O C E E D I N G S
29409-CSC09 Pro_INT_100427 4/28/10 4:25 PM Page 76
Figure 4. The completed urea stripper awaiting installation at the Profertil fertilizer Figure 5. The completed urea stripper
complex in Bahia Blanca, Argentina. installation at Profertil, Bahia Blanca,
Argentina.
Figure 6. A thin crack located in the J-area during a routine internal inspection in
December 2008.
®
C O R R O S I O N S O L U T I O N S C O N F E R E N C E 2 0 0 9 — P R O C E E D I N G S
29409-CSC09 Pro_INT_100427 4/28/10 4:25 PM Page 77
®
C O R R O S I O N S O L U T I O N S C O N F E R E N C E 2 0 0 9 — P R O C E E D I N G S